Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100021 OF 2015 (A)
BETWEEN:
THE STATE,
BY THE POLICE INSPECTOR,
KARNATKA LOKAYUKTA POLICE STATION,
BELGAUM.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. SRINIVAS B. NAIK, ADVOCATE)
AND:
SHRI. SANGAPPA AND SANGAMESH
S/O. GOURAVVA KAMBLE,
AGE: 58 YRS,
OCC: ASST.DIRECTOR OF DISTRICT.
INDUSTRIAL CENTRE, BELGAUM,
R/O. HIPPARAGI, TALUKA: JAMKHANDI,
DIST: BAGALKOT.
…RESPONDENT
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
(BY SRI. VIJAY K. NAIK, ADVOCATE)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECION 378(1) AND
(3) OF CR.P.C. PRAYING TO GRANT LEAVE TO THE APPELLANT TO
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
Date: 2026.02.02
17:04:18 +0530
APPEAL AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF ACQUITTED DATED
20.10.2014 PASSED IN SPL. CASE NO.14/2012 ON THE FILE OF THE
IV-ADDL. DIST. & SESSIONS & SPL JUDGE (PCA), BELGAUM AND
ALLOW THE APPEAL AND ETC.,
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA)
1.
Heard Sri Srinivas B. Naik, learned counsel for
the appellant and Sri Vijay K.Naik learned counsel for the
respondent.
2.
Lokayuktha,
Belagavi,
is
the
appellant
challenging the acquittal of the respondent in Special Case
No.14/2012 dated 20.10.2014 on the file of the IV
Additional District and Sessions Judge and Spl Judge (PCA),
Belagavi.
3.
Facts of the case in brief which are utmost
necessary for disposal of the present appeal are as under:
Complainant, a resident of Airforce Station quarters,
Belagavi, filed an application with the office of the accused
on 03.01.2011 for issue of temporary registration certificate
in order to start the Primes Dairy before the District
Industrial Centre, Belagavi.
Accused being the Assistant
Director in District Industrial Centre, Belagavi, was required
to process the application filed by the complainant.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
4.
Complainant approached the accused who was
working in the said District Industrial Centre, on 04.01.2011
for issue of provisional registration certificate. It is the case
of the complainant that accused demanded Rs.1,300/- as
illegal gratification to process the said application. As the
complainant was not willing to pay the illegal gratification,
he approached the Lokayukta Office, Belagavi.
5.
The Inspector of Lokayukta, Belagavi, secured
two independent Government servants as panch witnesses
for the proposed trap and explained to them the contents of
the complaint. Thereafter, the Inspector demonstrated the
chemical reaction of phenolphthalein powder with sodium
carbonate solution. The tainted currency notes amounting
to
Rs.1,300/-
were
taken
from
the
custody
of
the
complainant, smeared with phenolphthalein powder, and an
entrustment (experimental) mahazar was drawn.
6.
Thereafter, the raid party proceeded to the office
of the accused and conducted the trap. At about 1:20 p.m.
on 07.01.2011, the raid was conducted, the colour test
yielded positive results, and the accused was arrested.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
7.
Subsequently,
a
thorough
investigation
was
carried out, and a charge sheet came to be filed against the
accused.
8.
The presence of the accused was secured by the
learned Special Judge and the trial was conducted.
9.
In order to prove the case of the prosecution, the
complainant was examined as PW-1. He deposed in line
with the averments made in the complaint and supported
the prosecution case during his examination-in-chief with
regard to the pre-trap and trap proceedings.
10.
During his cross-examination, PW-1 admitted
that in Ex.P-13, at page No.14, there is an acknowledgment
for having received the application. He further admitted that
on 03.01.2011 he had submitted the application for
temporary registration and that no document was written
by the accused on 07.01.2011. He also admitted that the
records
disclose
that
on
04.01.2011
there
is
an
acknowledgment of his application.
11.
that
on
PW-1 further admitted that the records reveal
04.01.2011
itself
the
application
had
been
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
processed. However, he denied the suggestion that the
entire work relating to the application was completed on
04.01.2011.
12.
He also admitted that when he visited the office
of the accused on 07.01.2011, the accused was not found in
his chamber, but stated that the accused was standing
outside and smoking.
13.
He further admitted that there is no conversation
regarding the demand of money recorded in the voice
recorder. He also admitted that the alleged demand was not
recorded
as
the
accused
had
made
a
hand
signal
demanding payment of the illegal gratification.
14.
PW-4 is the shadow witness. He deposed in
consonance with the averments made in the complaint and
supported the prosecution case with regard to the pre-trap
proceedings, experimental mahazar, and trap mahazar
during his examination-in-chief. He specifically deposed that
the experimental mahazar was conducted in his presence,
that a sum of Rs.1,300/- was recovered from the accused,
and that the colour test yielded positive results.
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
15.
During cross-examination, PW-4 admitted that
he had signed Ex.P-13, which was seized by the Inspector
on 07.01.2011. He further admitted that Ex.P-13 contains
an endorsement acknowledging receipt of the application
submitted by the complainant. He also admitted that Exs.P13 and P-14 are the original and copy respectively, and that
they were seized from the complainant and the accused.
16.
PW-4 further admitted that the complainant did
not produce any document at the time of drawing the
entrustment (experimental) mahazar, except the voice
recording. He admitted that the voice recording was not
clearly audible and that there was no specific conversation
in the recording to indicate a demand for Rs.1,300/-.
17.
The learned Trial Judge, upon appreciation of the
evidence on record, held that mere handling of the tainted
currency by the accused on the day of the trap is not
sufficient to prove the prosecution case in the absence of
specific evidence regarding demand and acceptance of
illegal gratification.
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
18.
The Trial Court further noted that the work
relating to the complainant’s application, insofar as the
accused was concerned, had already been completed on
04.01.2011. Accordingly, the Trial Court recorded an order
of acquittal.
19.
Being
aggrieved
by
the
said
judgment
of
acquittal, the State has preferred the present appeal on the
following grounds:
The order of acquittal of he accused/respondent passed
by the Special Court below is opposed to law, facts and
probabilities of the case.
Though the PW-2 & 4 have supported the prosecution
case the trial Court acquitted the accused/respondent
without any proper reasons and not in accordance with
law;
the
court
below
has
otherwise
ignored
the
acceptable and trustworthy evidence placed on record
by the prosecution, which has resulted in miscarriage of
justice.
It is submitted that, as per the evidence placed on record
when the complainant/PW-2 who had no ill will against
the accused/respondent gave evidence regarding the
demand
by
accused
and
lodging
of complaint
to
Lokayukta police, for trap of accused; the learned trial
judge
ought
to
have
accepted
the
complainant's
testimony ivoted of giving undue importance to certain
minor discrepancies.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
It
is submitted that independently of the recorded
conversation there was evidence regarding demand by
the accused as spoken by the PW.2 & 4.
The learned trial Judge failed to consider that PW.2 & 4
had stood the test of cross examination and the
circumstantial evidence in the case least support to their
testimonies.
The learned trail Judge failed to draw the presumption
U/Sec. 20 of P.C Act, has resulted in miscarriage of
justice.
Learned
trial judge ought to have appreciated the
evidence in an objective manner and with an intention
of ascertaining the facts.
The learned trial Judge failed to consider that lapses if
any in the part of I.O could not affect prosecution case.
It is submitted that the pre-trap conversation between
the accused and P.W,2 had been recorded in the voice
recorder by P.W.2 and the voice of the accused therein
was identified by PW.8 Sudha Jnaneshwar Pawar and
PW-7 Shivabasappa Basappa Tigadi before court and the
said conversation is sufficiently established the demand
by the accused. PW-8 & PW-7 are the official of District
Industrial Centre, Belgaum who have identified the voice
of accused in the conversation recorded in the voice
recorder.
The entire judgment lacks the reason for recording
finding and deserve to be set aside.
There is no objective assessment of the evidence of
prosecution witnesses by the learned trial judge.
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
It is submitted that, the learned trial Judge not look into
the presumption under Sec. 20 of P.C. Act. 1988.
It is submitted that the Investigation Officer who was
examined as PW.11 fully supported the prosecution
case.
It is submitted that there is corroboration between the
evidence of the pancha witnesses and complainant
witnesses.
The trial court relying on some minor omissions and
contradictions and has given benefit of doubt by
acquitting the respondent/accused, which is totally
illegal in the eye of law.
The entire approach of the court below and the reasons
assigned for acquitting the accused was contrary to law,
evidence and material on record.
20.
Sri Srinivas B. Naik,
learned counsel for the
appellant–State, reiterating the grounds urged in the
memorandum of appeal, vehemently contended that the
approach of the Trial Court is erroneous in acquitting the
accused.
21.
He submitted that the material evidence on
record clearly establishes the demand of illegal gratification,
inasmuch as the complainant has specifically deposed that
the accused made a hand signal demanding payment of
illegal
gratification.
He
therefore
contended
that
the
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
absence of an oral demand would not dilute the prosecution
case and sought for allowing the appeal.
22.
He
further
contended
that
Ex.P-13
only
evidences acknowledgment of the application and that the
work was not completed, contrary to the observation of the
learned Trial Judge. According to him, there is a clear
misreading of material evidence on record, resulting in
miscarriage of justice, and hence interference by this Court
is warranted.
23.
Per contra, Sri Vijay K. Naik, learned counsel for
the respondent–accused, supported the impugned judgment
and contended that the prosecution has failed to establish,
beyond reasonable doubt, the essential ingredients of
demand
and
acceptance
of
illegal
gratification.
He
submitted that mere handling of the tainted currency is not
sufficient to convict the accused and sought dismissal of the
appeal.
24.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for
both sides, the following points arise for consideration:
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
i.
Whether
the
prosecution
was
successful
in
establishing all the ingredients necessary to attract
the offences punishable under Sections 7, 13(1)(d)
red with Section
13(2) of the
Prevention of
Corruption Act?
ii.
Whether the impugned judgment suffers from any
legal infirmity or perversity warranting interference
by this Court?
iii.
If points Nos.1
and 2
are
answered in the
affirmative, what sentence?
iv.
25.
What order?
Regarding point Nos.1 and 2: In the case on
hand, the fact that the complainant filed an application for
temporary licence with the concerned District Office on
03.01.2011 is not in dispute. As per Ex.P-13, the said
application was acknowledged. The material documents
placed on record also reveal that the application was
processed insofar as the present respondent–accused was
concerned, subject to affixing of his final signature after
necessary processing.
26.
cogent
The material on record does not disclose any
evidence
to
establish
the
demand
of
illegal
gratification of Rs.1,500/-, which was allegedly negotiated
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
and reduced to Rs.1,300/-. The conversation recorded at
the pre-complaint stage is admittedly not properly audible,
as conceded by PW-4.
27.
In fact, when the said recording was played in
open Court during the cross-examination of PW-4, he
categorically stated that he was unable to identify the voice
or establish any specific demand of illegal gratification.
Though he volunteered to state that, if heard closely, there
appeared to be some conversation indicating demand, the
same was not clear or definite.
28.
Trial
Court
has
also
heard
the
said
voice
recording along with PW-4, and the Trial Court has rightly
observed that the conversation is not audible and does not
establish any specific demand at the pre-complaint stage.
29.
Admittedly, there is no voice recording on the
date of the trap evidencing demand. The shadow witness
has not supported the case of demand. It is only the
complainant who has stated that the demand was made by
way of a hand signal.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
30.
It is also an admitted fact that the alleged hand
signal was not made inside the cabin of the accused. The
complainant has specifically stated that when he and the
shadow
witness
visited
the
accused’s
chamber
on
07.01.2011, the accused was not present therein. He
volunteered to state that the accused was standing outside
the office and smoking a cigarette.
31.
The said place is not shown in the sketch
appended to the charge sheet. If, in fact, the alleged
demand had taken place outside the office premises, the
same ought to have been reflected in the sketch and a
panchanama should have been drawn. Thus, in the absence
of clear proof of demand, mere handling of the tainted
currency alone would not be sufficient to conclude that the
prosecution has established all the ingredients of the
offence.
32.
Moreover, the incident pertains to a period prior
to the amendment of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
Therefore, mere recovery or handling of tainted currency
cannot, by itself, constitute an offence under Section 7 of
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
Prevention of Corruption Act, following the dictum of the
Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Neeraj Dutta Vs. State
(Govt. of N.C.T. of Delhi)1.
33.
Further, the admissions of the complainant and
the shadow witness, coupled with the documents marked at
Exs.P-13
and
P-14,
clearly
establish
that
there
was
acknowledgment of the application and that the role of the
present accused, insofar as processing of the application
was concerned, stood completed on 04.01.2011. Though
the complainant denied the suggestion that the entire work
was completed on that date, the documentary evidence on
record supports the defence.
34.
Under these circumstances, there was no scope
for the accused to demand illegal gratification. The learned
Trial Judge has taken a view favourable to the accused,
which is permissible in criminal jurisprudence. It is well
settled that when two views are possible, the view
favourable to the accused must be adopted.
2022 INSC 1280
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
35.
distance
The prosecution is required to traverse the
between
mere
suspicion
and
proof
beyond
reasonable doubt. It is also a well-established principle that
an accused is presumed innocent and an order of acquittal
further strengthens such presumption.
36.
Applying these settled principles to the facts of
the present case, this Court finds that the judgment of
acquittal passed by the learned Special Judge does not
warrant interference, as there is proper appreciation of the
evidence on record.
37.
Accordingly, Point
No.1
is answered in the
negative and Point No.2 in the affirmative.
38.
Regarding Point No.3: In view of the findings
on Point Nos.1 and 2, this point does not arise for
consideration.
39.
Regarding Point No.4: In view of the findings
recorded on Point Nos.1 to 3, the following order is passed:
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1228
CRL.A No. 100021 of 2015
HC-KAR
ORDER
i. The appeal is devoid of merit and is hereby
dismissed.
ii. The bail bond, if any, stands discharged.
Sd/(V.SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
KCM,AC, CT:CMU
list no.: 1 sl no.: 15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review