Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J (2)
In The High Court at Calcutta
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Debangsu Basak
And
The Hon’ble Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi
M.A.T. 1975 of 2025
IA NO: CAN/1/2025
CAN/2/2025
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
vs.
Abhishek Kumar Singh & Anr.
with
M.A.T. 2011 of 2025
IA NO: CAN/1/2025
CAN/2/2025
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
vs.
Abhishek Kumar Singh
For the Appellants
:
Mr. Dibasish Basu, Ld. A.G.P.
Ms. Sneha Dutta, Advocate
Mr. Purnendu Das, Advocate
For the Respondent
:
Mr. Sattwik Bhattacharyya, Advocate
Mr. Aashutosh Bhattacharyya, Advocate
Mr. Titas Niyogi, Advocate
Mr. Aritra Roy, Advocate
MAT 1975 of 2025 with MAT 2011 of 2025
Heard on
:
07.07.2026
Judgment on
:
07.072026
DEANGSU BASAK, J.:1.
CAN/2/2025 is an application for condonation of delay.
2.
For the ends of justice, causes shown in the application for condonation
of delay are accepted as sufficient.
3.
CAN/2/2025 is allowed.
4.
Two appeals are taken up for analogous hearing as issues involved are
same. Parties are also same.
5.
Writ petitioner applied for grant of Stage Carriage Permit on the interstate
route Howrah and Ranchi (B-94). Such application is yet to be finally
decided.
6.
Learned advocate appearing for the appellants submits that, State
Transport Authority considered the existing vacancy in terms of the
interstate agreement. He submits that, initially, a private operator was
granted Stage Carriage Permit for such route. Such grant was set aside by
the order dated March 3, 2025 passed in WPA 28780 of 2024. He submits
that the appeal being MAT 1975 of 2025 is directed against such order of
the learned Single Judge.
MAT 1975 of 2025 with MAT 2011 of 2025
7.
So far as MAT 2011 of 2025 is concerned, learned advocate appearing for
the appellants submits that, the authorities considered the application of
the writ petitioner afresh. Authorities passed an order dated July 18,
2025. Such order was challenged by way of a writ petition being WPA
14037 of 2025. Such order is under challenge in the appeal being MAT
2011 of 2025.
8.
Learned advocate appearing for the appellants submits that, the
authorities took decisions based on the materials made available on
record. He submits that, such decisions being plausible the Writ Court
erred in interfering with the same.
9.
Learned advocate appearing for the writ petitioner submits that, there
exists Inter-State Reciprocal Transport agreement between the State of
West Bengal and Jharkhand. B-94 is one of the routes governed by such
agreement. Such route is between Howrah and Ranchi. He submits that,
there is one vacancy in such route. Writ petitioner applied for grant of
Stage Carriage Permit in respect of such route. He draws the attention of
the Court to the application for grant of such permit. He submits that,
such application was made on October 9, 2023. Subsequently, another
application was made on September 3, 2024.
10. Learned advocate appearing for the writ petitioner submits that first
application was rejected on the ground of no vacancy. There was vacancy
MAT 1975 of 2025 with MAT 2011 of 2025
when the second application was made. There is no dispute that, there
exists a vacancy in such route. He submits that, the second application
was not appropriately considered resulting the writ petitioner filing the
first writ petition being WPA 28780 of 2024. He submits that, the learned
Judge allowed such writ petition by an order dated March 3, 2025 by
directing the authorities to process the issuance of fresh permit
considering the respective merits of their application. He submits that,
subsequent to the order dated March 3, 2025, the authorities passed an
order dated May 20, 2025. He draws the attention of the Court to such
order. He submits that, the authorities did not consider the application for
grant of Stage Carriage Permit. Rather, the authorities directed fresh
online application after declaration.
11. Learned advocate for the writ petition submits that, being aggrieved by the
decision dated May 20, 2025, the writ petitioner filed a second writ
petition being WPA 14037 of 2025. Such writ petition was allowed by the
order dated July 18, 2025 setting aside the decision dated May 20, 2025.
The Board of State Transport Authority was directed to consider the
application pending before it strictly in accordance with the order dated
March 3, 2025 passed in WPA 28780 of 2024. He submits that, the
authorities are yet to comply with the direction contained in the order
dated July 18, 2025.
MAT 1975 of 2025 with MAT 2011 of 2025
12. Learned advocate appearing for the writ petitioner relies upon 2026 INSC
175 (Mahendra Prasad Agarwal vs. Arvind Kumar Singh & Ors.) and
submits that, when repeated applications remains unresolved at the
behest of the authorities the Court can direct grant of the relief of the writ
petitioner. He submits that, in the facts and circumstances of the present
case, application for grant of Stage Carriage Permit be allowed by the
Court instead of requiring the State Transport Authority to consider the
second application once more.
13. Learned advocate for the writ petitioner submits that, the resolution dated
May 20, 2025 which was set aside by the order dated July 18, 2025
records that there were four applicants. He submits that apart from the
writ petitioner no other applicants turned up or fulfils the criteria.
14. We are concerned with the application for grant of Stage Carriage Permit
in the two appeals. Petitioner applied for State Carriage Permit for the B94 in the Howrah-Ranchi in terms of the Inter-State Reciprocal Transport
agreement between the State of West Bengal and Jharkhand.
15. First application of the writ petitioner dated October 9, 2023 was rejected
on the ground of no vacancy. Apparently, that is the accepted position as
on the date of such decision.
16. Vacancy for the concerned route was declared on August 27, 2024. The
writ petitioner applied for grant of Stage Carriage Permit for the concerned
MAT 1975 of 2025 with MAT 2011 of 2025
route on September 3, 2024. The second application was considered by
the State Transport Authority when they purported to apply “First In and
First Out” policy. On such principle, the application of the writ petitioner
was rejected by the State Transport Authority West Bengal on September
20, 2024. This decision of the State Transport Authority dated September
20, 2024 was assailed by the writ petitioner in WPA 28780 of 2024. The
decision dated September 20, 2024 passed by the State Transport
Authority was set aside by the order dated March 3, 2025 passed in WPA
28780 of 2024.
17. By the order dated March 3, 2025, the learned Judge, directed the
authorities to start the process of issuance of permitting considering the
respective merits of their applications on the basis of the relevant
materials submitted by the respective incumbents and also other ancillary
factors.
18. Purporting to act on the basis of such order dated March 3, 2025 passed
in WPA 28780 of 2024, State Transport Authority by a resolution dated
May 20, 2025 held that, the offer letter issued in favour of the Shyamal
Mukherjee was no-longer valid. It decided to permit all applicants to apply
afresh after declaration of vacancy in the route.
19. Vacancy already declared on August 27, 2024 continues to remain.
Question of declaration of fresh vacancy does not arise and at best there
MAT 1975 of 2025 with MAT 2011 of 2025
may be other vacancies. The vacancy declared on August 27, 2024 is
governed by the order dated March 3, 2025.
20. So far as the vacancy declared on August 27, 2024 is concerned, such
vacancy required to be filled up as filling up of such vacancy is in public
interest. Route is from Howrah to Ranchi. It is not the case of any of the
parties before us that, there are no passengers in such route.
21. We do not find any infirmity in the order dated March 3, 2025 passed in
WPA 28780 of 2024. Such order required State Transport Authority to
assess and evaluate the applicants on the basis of merits taking into all
factors into consideration and in accordance with law.
22. Therefore, we do not find any merit in the appeal being MAT 1975 of 2025
filed by the appellants directed against the order dated March 3, 2025.
Moreover, the appellants themselves acted in terms of the order dated
March 3, 2025 and passed a subsequent resolution dated May 20, 2025.
23. In the second round of litigation being WPA 14037 of 2025, learned Single
Judge set aside the resolution dated May 20, 2025 and required the State
Transport Authority to act strictly in terms of the order dated March 3,
2025.
24. Again, on the parity of the reasoning as noted above, we do not find any
ground to interfere with the order dated July 18, 2025.
MAT 1975 of 2025 with MAT 2011 of 2025
25. The resolution dated May 20, 2025 which was set aside by the order dated
July 18, 2025 recorded that, the initial allottee, did not act in terms of
such allotment and that, the allotment elapsed by efflux of time. The
resolution dated May 20, 2025 however, notes that, there were four
applicants. One applicant is noted above did not fulfill the conditions of
the initial allotment and therefore, the allotment in his favour was held to
be elapsed by efflux of time. Apart from writ petitioner there are two other
applicants.
26. The contention that, the other two applicants apart from writ petitioner
noted in the resolution dated May 20, 2025 did not fulfill the requirements
is required to be evaluated on the basis of the materials as placed before
us in the two appeals. We are not in a position to arrive at a finding that,
it is the writ petitioner only who fulfills all criteria for the Stage Carriage
Permit. We hasten to add we are not pronouncing on the fulfillment of the
criteria of any of the applicants including the writ petitioner for grant of
Stage Carriage Permit. Such issue is kept open to be decided by State
Transport Authority.
27. In view of the such finding, we are not minded to apply the ratio of
Mahendra Prasad Agarwal (supra) where noting the repeated infractions
of the authorities direction was issued for compliance.
MAT 1975 of 2025 with MAT 2011 of 2025
28. In such circumstances, we dispose of the two appeals by directing the
State Transport Authority to consider the application for grant of Stage
Carriage Permit of the writ petitioner dated September 3, 2025 in
accordance with law in the ensuing Board meeting of the State Transport
Authority without fail. The State Transport Authority will afford a
reasonable opportunity of hearing to the writ petitioner. It will pass a
reasoned order which it will communicate to the writ petitioner forthwith
thereafter.
29. MAT 1975 of 2025, MAT 2011 of 2025 along with connected
applications are disposed of.
(Debangsu Basak, J.)
30. I agree.
(Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J.)
CHC
signed by CHINMOY CHAKRABORTY
CHINMOY CHAKRABORTY Digitally
Date: 2026.07.08 15:33:39 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review