Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
WA.No.82 of 2016
1.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Principal Secretary,
Finance Department, Government of Tripura, Civil Secretariat, P.O.
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura.
….. Respondent-appellant.
-V E R S U S-
1.
Tripura Government Employees Federation, having its Head Office
at Post Office Chowmuhani, P.S. West Agartala, P.O. Agartala,
West Tripura, represented by Sri Shishirendra Saha, Secretary
General.
..... Petitioner-respondent
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE [ACTING]
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
Mr. S. S. Dey, Advocate General.
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
None.
YES
Judgment and order dated 15th March, 2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER
When the case is called, Mr. S. S. Dey, learned Advocate
General assisted by Ms. A. Chakraborty, learned counsel entered
appearance on behalf of the appellant and submitted that despite issuance
of notices, there is no representation for the respondents and the matter
pertains to 2016. In view of above, today the matter has been taken for
final disposal as the matter was listed in the caption of final hearing.
[2]
This appeal has been filed against the judgment and order passed
by this Court in WP(C) No.268 of 2011 dated 28.04.2016. This judgment is
passed answering a writ petition filed by “Tripura Government Employees
Federation” represented by its General Secretary inter alia praying for
mandamus or similar direction be issued to the respondent State to fulfill its
commitments and maintain the mandamus issued by this Court in CR. No.525
of 1995 by clearing the arrears of 36% (12+24) to reach the central rate and
then to continue the parity.
[3]
The grievance as canvassed in this writ appeal by the appellant is
that the Tripura Government Employees Federation an association of
Government Employees filed the present writ petition for issuance of an
appropriate mandamus to the state respondents to pay Dearness Allowance to
reach the Central Rate of DA and then to continue the parity. According to the
writ petitioner there is a mandamus in earlier writ petition being C.R. No.525
of 1995 dated 07.02.1996. At the time of filing the writ petition there was a gap
of 32% DA to reach the central rate. The State respondents contested the writ
petition and contended that there was no mandamus to pay the DA at a central
rate in all time to come.
[4]
There was no policy of payment of DA at a central rate.
However, the State Government issued a clarificatory memorandum to the
effect that DA would be paid at the rate declared by the State Government
from time to time. This Court passed judgment directing the State respondents
to calculate DA at the rate of the central Government till 27-08-2011 and
released the arrear DA by three installments, one each on expiry of every six
month commencing from 01.07.2016. The State Government may, for purpose
of overcoming difficulty credit a part only of the arrear of DA in the GPF of
the concerned employee declaring moratorium for a maximum period of three
years.
[5]
Learned Single Judge, after hearing the parties and perusal of the
material evidence on record, has observed as under:
“But when by operation of the policy, entitlement of DA becomes due, it
becomes debt in nature and it has been held by the apex court in State of
Madhya Pradesh versus G. C. Mandawar that unlike England, in our
country such „debt‟ due to be discharged by the Government could be
attached. When the State cannot be compelled by mandamus to grant
DA/DR but when entitlement accrues by way of the policy and the same
is not paid, mandamus can be issued. While issuing such mandamus the
court may take a pragmatic approach. For certainty of the rate, entitlement
of the State Government employees cannot be denied by the respondent.
Even there cannot be any amount of debate that this financial relief
[DA/DR] is granted to the employees or the pensioners to adjust the
inflationary effects or to preserve actual wage value. Its impounding for
uncertain and unlimited period cannot be terms as fair labour practice.
With this observation and direction this writ petition is allowed to the
extent as indicated above. There shall be no order as to the costs.”
[6]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the observation made
above by the learned Single Judge, the appellant has preferred this present
appeal before this Court.
[7]
Mr. S. S. Deb, learned Advocate General assisted by Ms. A.
Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that the
learned Single Judge wrongly reached the conclusion that before 27.08.2011
the State government was under an obligation to release the DA/DR at the
central rate in the same manner as it has been recommended by the PRC for
release of 16% arrear DA on the basis of central rate. In fact the PRC
recommended to the State government to consider whether 16% arrear DA
could be released in favour of the State government employees as a one-time
measure, nothing more. The learned Single Judge held that as a policy matter
the State government was under an obligation to release DA/DR at the central
rate prior to memorandum dated 27.08.2011.
[8]
It has further been held by the learned Single Judge that the State
government employees were entitled to DA at the central rate till an
appropriate method was adopted by the State government since there has been
no policy change before memorandum dated 27.08.2011. The learned Single
Judge should have considered that by memorandum dated 05.05.2009 it was
declared that DA as admissible to the State government employees would be
released w.e.f. 01.01.2009 and it was further declared that accordingly,
Governor was pleased to decide 16% DA shall be released to the employees
appointed in regular scale of pay to services and posts in connection with the
State w.e.f. 1st January, 2009. Drawal and disbursement of the released DA
shall be regulated under Rule-16(2) of the TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009.
[9]
Mr. Dey, learned A.G. has further contended that the petitioner
association failed to indicate any enforceable legal right in favour of the State
government employees to claim DA at the same rate and periodicity as it made
available by the central government in favour of its employees from time to
time except an unfounded assertion based on an erroneous assumption that the
earlier judgment dated 07.02.1996 delivered in Civil Rule-525 of 1995
mandates the respondents in perpetuity to continue the parity of the rate of the
DA with the central government and such perpetual mandamus having been
found non-existent the writ petition squarely deserved to be dismissed for want
of any lawful cause of action.
[10]
Though the learned Single Judge was convinced that by the
earlier judgment dated 07.02.1996 no mandamus in perpetuity had been issued
for maintaining the parity of the central rate of DA or its periodicity and hence
on that ground no relief can be granted in favour of the writ petitioner. The
learned Single Judge went beyond the pleadings and the case made out by the
writ petitioner to come to an unsustainable conclusion to the effect that the
State government‟s policy of releasing DA for its employees remained unchanged though the earlier policy decision taken in the year 1988 was found to
be merely confined to the recommendation of the 3rd Tripura Pay Commission.
[11]
He has submitted that the learned Single Judge has arrived at a
glaringly erroneous finding that no records had been placed before this Court
that the policy of releasing DA at the rate of central government employees has
been changed earlier before the memorandum dated 27.08.2011 or there had
been any policy decision to change the policy as declared by the Council of
Ministers by the decision taken on 26.12.1996, since as by way of annexure
R/9 annexed to the counter affidavit the decision of the State government taken
on 26.12.1998 at the time of implementation of the recommendation of the 4th
Tripura Pay Commission was formally brought on records of this Court by
which it was clearly notified that the DA may be released on pattern of the
government of India depending on availability of fund.
[12]
It was pointed out to the learned Single Judge on behalf of the
State respondents that not only the petitioner association had not challenged
the new policy about grant of DA in favour of its employees depending upon
the availability of its financial resources, but the petitioner association was
guilty of deliberate suppression of this material fact in its writ petition while
claiming equal rate of DA compared with that available to the central
government employees on the basis of the mandamus issued earlier.
[13]
Mr. Dey, learned AG has averred that the learned Single Judge
ought to have been conscious about the limitations of any judicial forum to
interfere by any judicial interdict to compel the executive government to
disburse its finances in a way departing from its financial policy which has no
legally binding requirements. In the context of the changed policy decision
taken in 1998 by the State government immediately after the period covered by
the 3rd Tripura Pay Commission there could be no question of any promissory
estoppels, expressed or implied, against the State government to go on
releasing the DA for its employees at the same rate as available to the central
government employees till 27.08.2011 when merely a notification was issued
in clarification of the previous decision of the State government that the
government has been and will continue to release DA/DR at a rate and on such
periodicity, which will be specified by the State government from time to time
depending on the resource position of the State.
[14]
The learned Single Judge observed that the decision of the
Council of Ministers quoted in paragraph-9 of the petition had not been straight
away admitted by the respondent but they have stated that the said decision has
been extracted from an unsigned confidential memorandum placed before the
Council of Ministers and that no records have been placed before this Court to
show that that the policy of releasing DA at the rate of central government
employees has been changed earlier before the memorandum dated 27.08.2011
or there had been any policy decision to change the policy as declared by the
Council of Ministers by their decision taken on 26.12.1996. Having observed
thus, the Single Judge was pleased to quote a decision taken in the meeting of
the Council of Ministers on 03.09.2011 as pleaded in the counter affidavit of
the state as may be reproduced hereinbelow:
“While the rates declared by the Central Government have always been
kept in view, the Government has been and will continue to release
DA/DR at a rate and on such periodicity, which will be specified by the
State Government from time to time depending on the resource position of
the State. This policy decision is in clarification of the previous decision
in this regard.”
[15]
The conclusion and decision recorded by the learned Single
Judge is wholly erroneous and factually without any basis inasmuch as, there
had been any decision taken by the State government that it is following the
central rate of DA. To buttress this point, learned Advocate General has drawn
attention of this Court to the decision of the Cabinet dated 26.12.1998 in
respect of implementation of recommendation of the Tripura 4th Pay
Commission, the following has been noted as under:
“8. Dearness Allowance
The Dearness Allowance may be released on the pattern of the
Government of India depending on availability of fund.
At present DA of 8% on the revised scale may be released w.e.f. 1-10-98
and transferred to GPF along with pay and other allowances for all
category of employees. The additional DA of 5% may be released w.e.f.
1-1-99 and may be transferred to GPF. At the same time the D.A. already
impounded may be permitted to be drawn with effect from 1-2-99.”
Consequent policy notification the government of Tripura, Finance
Department dated 27.08.2011, produced by the State has been also quoted
which clearly depicts the government stand and for the purpose of
reference it may be read as follows “the government has been and will
continue to release DA/DR at a rate and on such periodicity, which will be
specified b y the State Government from time to time depending on the
resource position of the state. This policy decision is in clarification of the
previous decision in this regard.”
[16]
The government had never taken any policy decision to release
DA/DR at the central rate. What was decided was that DA would be released
on the pattern of government of India depending on availability of fund and the
rate and periodicity will be specified by the government from time to time
depending on the resource position. In the counter affidavit it has been clearly
stated that the committee recommends that the State Government may consider
releasing the entire 16% DA to the employees while implementing revision
structure of pay structure.
[17]
Therefore, the committee recommended to State government to
only consider releasing the entire 16% DA to the employees while
implementing revision of pay structure. The PRC (Pay Review Committee) did
not give any recommendation on future payment of DA. The recommended
rate of 16% was released with effect from 01.01.2009. The state government
could not follow central rate even after the PRC will be clear from the fact that
when 16% of DA was released w.e.f. 01.01.2009, the central rate had already
changed to 22% w.e.f. 01.01.2009. Since then, DA is being released at a rate
decided by the State government from time to time on the pattern of the central
government depending on the resource position as seen from Annexure-R/10.
[18]
In order to clear any confusion arising out of the alleged decision
of the Council of Ministers upon the recommendation of Pay Review
Committee 2009, wherein, it has been observed that the government has been
and will continue to release DA/DR at a rate and on such periodicity, which
will be specified by the State government from time to time depending on the
resource position of the State. The policy decision is in clarification of the
previous decision in this regard.
[19]
It is thus apparent on the face of the pleadings that not only the
answering State respondents had denied the veracity of the statements made in
the judgment of the learned Single Judge, rather had fortified the government
stand by producing relevant uncontroverted documents at Annexures-R/10,
R/11, R/12, R/13, R/14 and R/15 as well quoting from the same in the pleading
to prima facie show that the State government had never ever taken any
decision to pay DA to State government employees at central government rate.
The consistent policy had been to pay DA/DR on the pattern of central
government depending on resource position of the State and also to release
DA/DR at a rate and on such periodicity which will be specified by the State
government from time to time depending on the resource position of the State.
[20]
The learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate that after the
release of the 3rd instalment of 11% of the DA in favour of the State
government employees by the memorandum dated 29.01.1997, by which the
mandamus issued in Civil Rule No.525 of 1995 was fully complied with,
though the State government went on releasing DA in favour its employees at
much lower rates and different periodicity from those made available to the
central government employees from time to time there was no formal objection
made b y the petitioner association or anybody else in accepting such DA for
years together till the representation was made to the Chief Secretary of the
State Government as late as 10.10.2010 before moving the writ petition.
[21]
In support of his contention, learned Advocate General has
placed his reliance upon a decision of the Apex Court in the State of Madhya
Pradesh v. G.C. Mandawar, reported in AIR 1954 493, wherein the Court held
thus:
“3. In the petition it was alleged that "the State Government should have
uniformly adopted the Government of India rates for all its servants and
the discrimination in making the two-fold slab and accepting the
Government of India rates for one slab, i.e., for servants receiving salary
over Rs. 400, and not accepting them in respect of the other slab, i.e., of
servants drawing below Rs. 400, is highly discriminatory.”
That "the State Government servant has a right to be treated equally with
the Central Government servant similarly situated,"
and that "every servant has these fundamental and natural rights and the
petitioner and the members of the Ministerial Services Associations have
a right to demand from the respondent the Dearness Allowance at the
Government of India rates."
The petitioner then prayed:
"That declaring that all ministerial servants are entitled to the Government
of India rates of Dearness Allowance or in any case adequate Dearness
Allowance, the State Government should be directed by a writ of
mandamus or by any other suitable writ or direction to cancel the
discriminatory rules of Dearness Allowance and adopt the Government of
India rates to all servants without discrimination or in any case, to provide
with adequate rates of Dearness Allowance sufficient to provide
reasonable subsistence for them.
The Government contested the petition on the grounds, firstly, that the
claim for dearness allowance was not justiciable, and secondly, that the
difference in the scales of dearness allowance adopted by the Commission
and by the Committee did not violate article 14. The learned Judges
(Sinha C.J. and Bhutt J.) held that under the rules dearness allowance was
placed on the same footing as pay, and that the claim relating thereto was
therefore justiciable; and that the differentiation made between the
employees of the Central Government and of the State Government in the
matter of the grant of dearness allowance rested on "no intelligible and
reasonable basis," and that the Resolution dated 16th September, 1948,
was therefore bad. They accordingly issued a direction to the State
Government that they do reconsider the question of dearness allowance
payable to the employees concerned. It is against this judgment that the
present appeal has been preferred by the State Government on a certificate
granted under article 132(1) of the Constitution.
5. On the first question, Rule 44 of the Fundamental Rules runs as follow:
Subject to any restrictions which the Secretary of State in Council may by
order impose upon the powers of the Governor-General in Council or the
Governor in Council, as the case may be, and to the general rule that the
amount of a compensatory allowance should be so regulated that the
allowance is not on the whole a source of profit to the recipient, a Local
Government may grant such allowance to any Government servant under
its control and may make rules prescribing their amounts and the
conditions under which they may be drawn.
Under this provision, it is a matter of discretion with the local
Government whether it will grant dearness allowance and if so, how
much. That being so, the prayer for mandamus is clearly misconceived, as
that could be granted only when there is in the applicant a right to compel
the performance of some duty cast on the opponent. Rule 44 of the
Fundamental Rules confers no right on the Government servants to the
grant of dearness allowance; it imposes no duty on the State to grant it. It
merely confers a power on the State to grant compassionate allowance at
its own discretion, and no mandamus can issue to compel the exercise of
such a power. Nor, indeed, could any other writ or direction be issued in
respect of it, as there is no right in the applicant which is capable of being
protected or enforced.”
[22]
In view of above discussion and the principle laid down by the
Apex Court, we are of the considered opinion that the conclusion and decision
as arrived at by the learned Single Judge in the judgment and order is contrary
to records and prima facie without any basis whatsoever. There being no
decision of the Government to pay DA at central rate beyond the period dealt
with by the earlier decision in Civil Rule-525 of 1995, i.e. the 3rd Pay
Commission, no mandate as has been directed in the order of the learned
Single Judge which can be sustained in the eye of law.
[23]
It is well settled proposition of law that there is no right per se
vested on any employee to claim DA as a right. DA is extended to service
employees to remedy malady of inflation. There is a distinction between DA
and Dearness Pay and the two concepts cannot be confused with each other. It
is not any more res integra that no employee has a right to claim DA.
Consequently, no writ can lie far less a mandamus can be prayed for
commanding the government to pay DA at any particular rate. [(2013) 2 SCC
772 Kallakkurichi Taluk Retired, Officials Association, Tamil Nadu and
Others v. State of Tamil Nadu].
[24]
While rejecting the contention of the petitioner to the effect that
on mandamus in perpetuity can flow from the earlier judgment dated
07.02.1996 passed in Civil Rule 525 of 1995, the learned Single Judge did not
have any material basis to proceed any further and h old contrary to records
that the State Government was still following the central rate of DA. The entire
case of the writ petitioner has been developed absolutely without any substance
on record and rather contrary to the materials apparent on the face of the
records.
[25]
Far from there being any policy in operation there is not even any
primary material to show that State government had ever decided to pay DA to
its employees at central rate. The decision dated 26.12.1998 espoused by the
petitioner, as quoted in paragraph 5 of the judgment and order speaks of release
of DA on the pattern of government of India and this word pattern has been
interpolated by the petitioner to be rate as is seen in paragraph-6 of the
judgment and order and later on accepted by the learned Single Judge in his
observation and conclusion recorded which is absolutely untenable in law.
[26]
The State government has been repeatedly deciding right from
26.12.1998 that DA may be released on the pattern of government of India
depending on the availability of fund and that DA of 8% of revised scale may
be released with effect from 01.01.1998 to be reiterated and clarified again on
06.09.2011 in no uncertain terms that the policy of the State government in
1998 was that DA would be released on pattern of Government of India
depending upon the availability of fund and that the government has been and
will continue to release DA/DR at a rate on such periodicity which will
specified by the State government from time to time depending on the resource
position of the State. The policy decision is in clarification of the previous
decision in this regard. This clarification is obviously intended and meant to
take effect on and from the period intended to be regulated by the Cabinet
decision dated 26.12.1998 i.e. post 3rd Pay Commission w.e.f. the period
covered by Tripura 4th Pay Commission.
[27]
Locus of the writ petitioner to file the writ petition even at this
appellate stage as the same germane to the jurisdictional issue of the entire
proceeding. The writ petition has been filed in the name of the Tripura
Government Employees Federation but, nowhere it is pleaded as to under
which legal provision, if at all the said federation is registered. An unregistered
organization merely on recognition given by any executive authority for the
limited purpose of participation in collective bargaining process do not assume
the status of a de jure person so as to maintain a writ petition in its name,
admittedly it is no one‟s case that Tripura Government Employees Federation
is a de facto person. So there is a question regarding maintainability of the writ
petition.
[28]
Regarding writ of mandamus on the issue of DA by the State
Government to its employee has clearly been dealt with FR-44 wherein, it has
observed that mandamus can be granted only when there is in the applicant a
right to compel the performance of some duty cast on the opponent. Rule-44 of
the Fundamental Rules confers no right on the Government servants to the
grant of dearness allowance, if imposes no duty on the State to grant it. It
merely confers a power on the State to grant compassionate allowance at its
own discretion. No mandamus can, therefore, issue to compel the exercise of
such a power. Nor, indeed, could any other writ or direction be issued in
respect of it, as there is no right in the applicant which is capable of being
protected or enforced.
[29]
As per decision, the DA was to be on pattern of and not at par
with central government. Following the central pattern did not mean that at all
points of time, DA released by the State had to be equal to the central rate.
Only the pattern of government of India was to be followed not the rate at any
given point time. In fact, the chart of DA of central and state government in
Annexure-R/10 will clearly indicate that the state‟s rate was always lagging
behind central rate since first release of DA on revised pay after 4th Pay
Commission report i.e. 01.10.1998.
[30]
The basic foundation of the judgment underwent change after
1998 when new policy decision was taken based on report of next pay
commission. Therefore, the practice followed by the centre cannot be applied
in case of employees under the State. The existing policy followed by the State
government was to release of DA at a rate and at such periodicity which is
decided by the government from time to time depending on its financial
resources which is not at par with the rates of the central government. This can
be proved from a comparison of DA rates released by centre and state over the
years, which clearly shows that the state has been following its own policy
different from the centre.
[31]
It reveals from the report of PRC, 2008 that the committee
recommended to State government to only consider releasing the entire 16%
DA to the employees while implementing revision of pay structure. The PRC
did not give any recommendation on future payment of the DA. The
recommended rate of 16% was released with effect from 01.01.2009. The state
government could not follow central rate even after the PRC will be clear from
the fact that when 16% of DA was released w.e.f. 01.01.2009, the central rate
had already changed to 22% w.e.f. 01.01.2009 and since then, DA is being
released at a rate decided by the State government from time to time on the
pattern of the central government depending on the resource position.
[32]
After the acceptance of the PRC recommendation on DA the
government issued memo No. F.5 (4)-FIN(G)/09 dated 5th May, 2009 releasing
16% DA in the revised pay structure to the State government employees w.e.f.
01.01.2009. Therefore, it cannot be said that the government decided to release
central rate of DA because from the very first release, state rate of the DA was
different from the central rate. The central rate w.e.f. 01.01.2009 was 22%
whereas; in the State DA was released @16% w.e.f. 01.01.2009.
[33]
The government of Tripura during the year 2011 has issued a
notification and placed reliance to the policy in issuing DA and that has been
issued basing upon the 1994 pay revision of the Government of India and
accordingly, DA has been fixed and the State Government is issued a
clarification to that effect. For the purpose of reference the notification dated
27th August, 2011 may be reproduced hereunder:
“No.F.6(1)-FIN(PC)/2008 (Part-1)
Government of Tripura.
Finance Department.
Dated, Agartala, the 27th August, 2011.
NOTIFICATION
Subject: Regarding State Policy on release of DA/DR
The State Government has been reviewing the financial difficulty arising
out of highly unfavourable grant awarded by 13th Finance Commission
which has seriously under assessed the state‟s requirement for salary,
pension and other committed liabilities.
The Policy of the State Government in 1998 was that DA would be
released on the pattern of Government of India depending upon
availability of fund. In other words, only the pattern of Government of
India was intended to be followed by the State Government subject to
availability of funds.
In such circumstances, the Governor is pleased to take a policy decision
on DA/DR as follows:
“The government has been and will continue to release DA/DR at a rate
and on such periodicity, which will be specified by the State Government
from time to time depending on the resource position of the State. This
policy decision is in clarification of the previous decision in this regard.
By the order of the Governor.
Commissioner & Secretary
Government of Tripura.”
[34]
In view of above discussions and after thorough analysis of the
material evidence on record, we are of the opinion that the present appeal
needs to be allowed by setting aside the judgment and order passed by the
learned Single Judge. Accordingly, the same is ordered on the basis of the
below mentioned reasons viz:
i. The petitioners are not recognized persons under the statute to approach
before the Court under Article-226 of the Constitution of India seeking
mandamus.
ii. There is no cause of action and there is no impugned order.
iii. The prayer which is sought for in the writ petition referring to the
decision taken by the Gauhati High Court in a particular case cannot be
made binding over this Court for issuance of mandamus.
iv. With regard to issuance of DA since it is varies from year to year, there
cannot be fixed amount that can be directed to be issued.
v. Issuance of DA is a policy decision and since there is no express policy
decision with regard to issuance of the DA as relied by the learned Single
Judge is ex-facie, incorrect on factual and legal aspects.
vi. The government of Tripura during the year 2011 has issued a
notification and placed reliance to the policy in issuing DA and that has
been issued basing upon the 1994 Pay Revision of the Government of
India and accordingly, DA has been fixed and the State Government has
issued a clarification to that effect. The said notification holds good and
the same is not challenged.
vii. The DA as a matter of statutory right cannot be claimed as decided by
the Apex Court in way back in 1954 in G.C. Mandawar, reported in AIR
1954 493 [supra] wherein, the Apex Court has expressed its concerned
with regard to the DA that it is not a fundamental right as indicated in the
Fundamental Rule-44, wherein, it has been stated as follows:
“Mandamus can be granted only when there is in the applicant a right to
compel the performance of some duty cast on the opponent. Rule-44 of the
Fundamental Rules confers no right on the Government servants to the
grant of dearness allowance, if imposes no duty on the State to grant it. It
merely confers a power on the State to grant compassionate allowance at
its own discretion. No mandamus can, therefore, issue to compel the
exercise of such a power. Nor, indeed, could any other writ or direction
be issued in respect of it, as there is no right in the applicant which is
capable of being protected or enforced.”
[35]
But, when by operation of the policy, entitlement of DA becomes
due, it becomes debt in nature and it has been held by the Apex Court in State
of Madhya Pradesh v. G.C. Mandawar that unlike England, in our country
such debt due to be discharged by the Government could be attached and when
the State cannot be compelled by mandamus to grant DA/DR but when
entitlement accrues by way of the policy and the same is not paid, mandamus
can be issued. While issuing such mandamus the Court may take a pragmatic
approach. For certainty of the rate, entitlement of the State Government
employees cannot be denied by the respondent. Even there cannot be any
amount of debate that this financial relief [DA/DR] is granted to the employees
or the pensioners to adjust the inflationary effects or to preserve actual wage
value. Its impounding for uncertain and unlimited period cannot be terms as
fair labour practice.
[36]
For the reasons indicated above and more particularly, no such
policy is enumerated from the records and for lack of other cogent reasons as
indicated above, the respondents have no right to claim for any DA as per
central rate. There is no substantive right of anyone to claim DA in the absence
of any statutory formula, design or mandate. DA is solely governed by FR-44
and it is the sole discretion of the employer. There are also no promissory
estoppels that government had made for certain rate of Dearness allowance. In
this case there is no decision by the government that any point of time, as has
been sought to be made out by the respondents.
[37]
When the Council of Ministers approved the implementation of
the recommendation of the Fourth Tripura Pay Commission, in its meeting
held on 26.12.1998 stating that “the dearness allowance will be released on the
pattern of the government of India depending on availability of fund” and as
per this decision, the dearness allowance to be on pattern of and not at par with
central government. Following central pattern did not mean that at all points of
time; the dearness allowance released by the State had to be equal to the central
rate. Only the pattern of government of India was to be followed not the rate at
any given point of time.
[38]
In view of above observations and reasons, the present appeal
preferred by the appellant-State, stands allowed setting aside the judgment
dated 28.04.2016 passed in WP(C) No.268 of 2011, as devoid of merits and the
WP(C) No.268 of 2011 is not maintainable and thus, the same stands
dismissed.
[39]
The writ appeal stands allowed and disposed of. As a sequel,
miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
CHIEF JUSTICE [ACTING]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review