The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. 02.2021, for the posts of Group-C, [Lower Division Clerk (LDC), Agriculture Assistant (Except TAFS Grade-III), Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade-III), Junior Operator (Pump) & Junior Multi-Tasking Operator (Uncommon)], after including the name of the petitioner therein, as the petitioner's name has been excluded even after securing 102 marks, whereas the last candidate, whose name was recommended for the post of Junior Multi Tasking Operator (Uncommon), secured 86 marks and the last candidate whose name was recommended for the post of Junior Operator (Pump) secured 88 marks. [4] The respondents by filing the reply has reiterated their stand as espoused in the reply. As per criteria regarding age relaxation contained in Clause (c) of the relevant portion of Advt. dated 12/02/2021 which stipulates that "As regards to the candidates who had participated in the cancelled recruitment process by the Deptt. of Agriculture, they will be given one time age relaxation in the upper age limit subject to providing documentary evidence of their participation in the earlier recruitment processes for the same post(s)", the petitioner has submitted a document issued by the Director of Agriculture, wherein it is mentioned that the petitioner had appeared before the interview board as per notice of the Deptt. vide No.F.2(803)-Agri(Estt)/2015-16/2488-92 dated 01/06/2017 for the post of Junior Fitt…
04. 09.2018 following the notification dated 20.08.2018 issued by the GA (P&T) Department. In the cancelled advertisement, the Agriculture Department had advertised 11 Nos. of vacancies for the post of Jr. Fitter. [10] It is further contended that in the advertisement notification the JRBT dated 12.02.2021, the vacancies of 209 Posts of Jr. Multi Tasking Operators (Un-common) and 236 posts of Jr. Operator (Pump) were included along with certain other Posts. There is no documentary evidence nor any Government requisition made to the JRBT for recommending candidates for the post of Jr. Fitter to be appointed in the Agricultural Department. There is also no evidence that the 209 posts of Jr. Multi Tasking Operators (Un-common) and 236 posts of Jr. Operator (Pump) advertised by JRBT included the 11 Nos. of vacancies or more for the post of Jr. Fitter for which the Agricultural Department had advertised in 2017 and later which was cancelled in 2018. [11] It is further contended that the learned Single Judge failed to consider that there is difference between the eligibility for the Jr. Operator (Pump) posts and Jr. MultiTasking Operator (Un-Common) post as advertised by the JRBT and the Jr. Fitter posts that was advertised in the cancelled advertisement by the Agriculture Department. As per advertisement vide No. F.2(803)-Agri(Estt.)/2015-16/14561-70 dated 03.01.2017 issued by Departmen…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 56 of 2025
The State of Tripura
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
Subrata Dey
---Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. GA.
Mr. Sujata Das (Gupta), Advocate.
Ms. Rumpa Dey, Advocate.
Date of hearing and date of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
24.06.2025.
Yes.
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Dr. T.Amarnath Goud, J
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
[2]
This is an appeal under Chapter VIII, Rule B(A) of the High Court
of Tripura Rules, 2023 preferred against the judgment and order dated 27.02.2025
passed by the Single Judge in WP(C) 46 of 2024.
[3]
The contention of the writ petitioner in the writ petition is that the
petitioner has prayed for necessary directions from the this Court to republish the
Merit List, dated 13.09.2023, in c/w Advt. No. 01/2020 and Notification, dated
12.02.2021, for the posts of Group-C, [Lower Division Clerk (LDC), Agriculture
Assistant (Except TAFS Grade-III), Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade-III),
Junior Operator (Pump) & Junior Multi-Tasking Operator (Uncommon)], after
including the name of the petitioner therein, as the petitioner's name has been
excluded even after securing 102 marks, whereas the last candidate, whose name
was recommended for the post of Junior Multi Tasking Operator (Uncommon),
secured 86 marks and the last candidate whose name was recommended for the
post of Junior Operator (Pump) secured 88 marks.
[4]
The respondents by filing the reply has reiterated their stand as
espoused in the reply. As per criteria regarding age relaxation contained in Clause
(c) of the relevant portion of Advt. dated 12/02/2021 which stipulates that "As
regards to the candidates who had participated in the cancelled recruitment
process by the Deptt. of Agriculture, they will be given one time age relaxation in
the upper age limit subject to providing documentary evidence of their
participation in the earlier recruitment processes for the same post(s)", the
petitioner has submitted a document issued by the Director of Agriculture,
wherein it is mentioned that the petitioner had appeared before the interview
board as per notice of the Deptt. vide No.F.2(803)-Agri(Estt)/2015-16/2488-92
dated 01/06/2017 for the post of Junior Fitter under post code-6 held on
05/07/2017 against token No.4, which is not the 'same post' as per the
advertisement issued by the JRBT vide No. F.10(28)/DESMP/ESTT/2020/140
dated 12.02.2021 as no such requisition for the post of Junior Fitter was made by
the Agriculture Department. More particularly, no Advertisement was made for
the post of "Junior Fitter" by the JRBT.
[5]
The 209 posts of Jr.Multi Tasking Operator (Uncommon) and 236
posts of Jr. Operator (Pump) were requisitioned by the PWD(DWS) and
PWD(WR)
under
Public
Work
Department
vide
letter
No.F.8(17)-
CE/DWS/UC/2016/1055758 dated 07/01/2021 No.F.1(328)CE/PWD/WR/UC/15/
6694-95 and dated 13.01.2021 respectively and recommendation was made on
selection by JRBT according to that Department only. Since the petitioner was
not found eligible for any post due to over agei.e. the age of the petitioner was 41
Years 08 month 24 days as on the last date of submission of application i.e. on
12/03/2021 as per Advt. dated 12/02/2021and as such his candidature was
cancelled after compilation of the all verified documents and thus, not
recommended in the final merit list. Besides, Arpan Sarkar & Debabrata Debnath
of UR category, at Sl. No.1965 & Sl. No.1963 were recommended in the final
merit list for the post of Junior Multi Tasking Operator (Un-common) and Junior
Operator (Pump) having secured 86 marks & 88 marks respectively considering
their National Council for Vocational Training certificate as required vide Advt.
dated 12.02.2021.
[6]
The petitioner though submitted a document issued by the Director
of Agriculture, wherein it is mentioned that the petitioner had appeared before the
interview board as per notice of the Deptt. vide No.F.2(803)-Agri(Estt)/201516/2488-92 dated 01/06/2017 for the post of Junior Fitter under post code-6 held
on 05/07/2017 against token No.4, which is not 'same post(s)' for which
advertisement was issued by the JRBT and as such, the petitioner was not
considered for age relaxation. Due to non- fulfillment of the age relaxation
criteria of the said Advisement, JRBT could not recommend the petitioner,
against the posts of Junior Operator (Pump) / Junior Multi Tasking Operator (Uncommon) or any other post and as such the name of the petitioner is not included
in the final merit list.
[7]
After hearing the learned Single Judge, High Court of Tripura
allowed the writ petition. Hence, the writ appeal is submitted before the Division
Bench.
[8]
It is contended by learned Addl. GA for the state that the learned
Single Judge should have considered that 11(eleven) posts of Jr. Fitter of
Agriculture Department advertised earlier or more number of such post of that
Department were not included in the selection made by the JRBT as there was no
such requisition made by the Agriculture Department. The 209 Posts of Multi
Tasking Operators (Un-common) and 236 posts of Jr. Operator (Pump) were
requisitioned by Public Work Department and recommendation was made on
selection by JRBT accordingly to that Department only. So, the same posts of Jr.
Fitter of Agriculture Department for which recruitment process was cancelled
earlier, were not included in the advertisement by JRBT for selection. As such the
petitioner could not be entitled to age relaxation for the posts of Multi Tasking
Operators (Un- common) on the basis of advertisement criteria for age, on the
ground of cancellation of earlier selection process of the Agriculture Department,
in the selection made by the JRBT.
[9]
It is further contended that learned Single Judge failed to consider
that the petitioner had participated in the recruitment process for the post of Jr.
Fitter advertised by the notification dated 03.01.2017 of the Agriculture
Department, which was cancelled later on by the Department notice dated
04.09.2018 following the notification dated 20.08.2018 issued by the GA (P&T)
Department. In the cancelled advertisement, the Agriculture Department had
advertised 11 Nos. of vacancies for the post of Jr. Fitter.
[10]
It is further contended that in the advertisement notification the
JRBT dated 12.02.2021, the vacancies of 209 Posts of Jr. Multi Tasking
Operators (Un-common) and 236 posts of Jr. Operator (Pump) were included
along with certain other Posts. There is no documentary evidence nor any
Government requisition made to the JRBT for recommending candidates for the
post of Jr. Fitter to be appointed in the Agricultural Department. There is also no
evidence that the 209 posts of Jr. Multi Tasking Operators (Un-common) and 236
posts of Jr. Operator (Pump) advertised by
JRBT included the 11 Nos. of
vacancies or more for the post of Jr. Fitter for which the Agricultural Department
had advertised in 2017 and later which was cancelled in 2018.
[11]
It is further
contended that the learned Single Judge failed to
consider that there is difference between the eligibility for the Jr. Operator
(Pump) posts and Jr. MultiTasking Operator (Un-Common) post as advertised by
the JRBT and the Jr. Fitter posts that was advertised in the cancelled
advertisement by the Agriculture Department. As per advertisement vide No.
F.2(803)-Agri(Estt.)/2015-16/14561-70 dated 03.01.2017 issued by Department
of Agriculture, the essential educational qualification and technical/ professional
qualification required for the post of Jr. Fitter and Advertisement Notification
vide No.10(28)/DESMP/ESTT/2020/140 dated 12.02.2021 issued by the JRBT
essential qualification for the post of Junior Operator (Pump) posts under
PWD(WR)and Junior Multi Tasking Operator (Un-common) under PWD(DWS)
is furnished below in a tabular form:
Name of Post
Jr. Fitter under Agriculture Department
Junior
Operator
(Pump)
posts/Junior
Multi
Tasking
Operator (Un- common) under
PWD
Educational & essential qualification: Educational &
other
qualification:
Class-VIII passed with I.T.I. passed in
Fitter trade with three years experience
or 5 (five)years experience as Fitter in
any recognized workshop particularly in
repair and maintenance in implements,
workshop practices and minor repair of
different types of Agri. Implements and
machineries. Age: 18 to 40 years. Upper
age limit is relaxable by 5 (five) years in
case of ST/SC/ and in- service
candidates.
[12]
other
essential
a) Madhyamik equivalent or
examination passed from any
recognized Board/Institution.
And
(b) National Trade Certificate
(NTC) issued by Council National
for Vocational Training (NCVT) in
any of the following trade (i)
Welder (Gas & Electric), (ii)
Plumber, (iii) Turner, (iv) Fitter, (v)
Mechanic Diesel, (vi) Pump
Operator cum Mechanic, (vii)
Wireman, (viii) Electrician
Therefore, what it appears that the Junior Operator (Pump)/ Junior
Multi Tasking Operator (Un- common)post of Public Work Departmentand "Jr.
Fitter"of Agriculture Department are different post andcannot be called as "same
post".
[13]
On the contrary, learned counsel for the respondent-petitioner has
submitted before this court that the impugned judgment of the learned Single
Judge is just and proper and needs no interference from this Court. It is further
contended that the petitioner was ineligible due to being overage as per the upper
age limit prescribed in Advt. No. 01/2020 dated 12.02.2021. The age relaxation
clause applies only to those who had participated in recruitment for the same
post(s). However, the petitioner’s claim is based on his prior appearance for the
post of Junior Fitter, which is not identical to any of the posts now advertised. No
requisition was made by the concerned department for that post under the present
notification. Hence, the petitioner was rightly excluded from the merit list, and no
illegality was committed by the respondents. She further prayed to dismiss the
appeal by confirming the impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge.
[14]
Having considered the submissions of the learned counsel for both
the parties, the pleadings on record, and the relevant clauses of the Advertisement
dated 12.02.2021, particularly Clause (c) concerning age relaxation, we are of the
considered view that the learned Single Judge committed an error in directing
inclusion of the petitioner’s name in the republished merit list.
[15]
It is not in dispute that the petitioner, on the date of submission of
the application i.e. 12.02.2021, had crossed the prescribed upper age limit. The
petitioner sought to claim the benefit of age relaxation under Clause (c), which
explicitly provides for a one-time age relaxation only for those candidates who
had participated in the cancelled recruitment process for the same post(s) under
the Department of Agriculture.
[16]
The record reveals that the petitioner had earlier appeared for the
post of Junior Fitter, whereas the present recruitment was for posts such as Junior
Multi Tasking Operator (Uncommon) and Junior Operator (Pump). These posts
were requisitioned by the Public Works Department (DWS & WR) and not by the
Department of Agriculture. Moreover, the post of Junior Fitter was never
requisitioned by the JRBT under the said advertisement. As such, the claim of
participation in a previous recruitment process for the “same post” is not tenable.
[17]
The term “same post(s)” used in Clause (c) cannot be interpreted
loosely or broadly to include other posts with possibly similar nature of work.
Recruitment is a statutory process governed by specific criteria. Relaxation
clauses must be strictly construed in accordance with the express terms of the
advertisement. Extending the benefit of age relaxation beyond the scope of the
clause would be contrary to the terms of the recruitment process and would
amount to rewriting the eligibility criteria.
[18]
Furthermore, the petitioner’s candidature was validly rejected
during document verification for non-fulfilment of age eligibility. Candidates
securing lower marks were recommended based on meeting all eligibility
conditions, including age and possession of required vocational certificates.
[19]
In light of the above, we find sufficient merit in the writ appeal. The
order passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No.46 of 2024 is accordingly
set aside. The writ appeal stands allowed, and the direction to republish the merit
list including the name of the writ petitioner is quashed. As a sequel, stay, if any,
stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any, also stands closed.
B.Palit, J
Dipak
DIPAK DAS
DIPAK DAS
Date: 2025.06.27
10:52:37 +05'30'
Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review