The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
29. 01.2026. Meanwhile, the present petition for cancellation of bail has been filed by the prosecution. [3] Before entering into merit of the matter, the Court is constrained to observe that the way learned Addl. Sessions Judge is repeatedly allowing him to remain on interim bail without giving any decision on his prayer for regular bail, is not proper at all. When in Bail Application No.20 of 2025, the petitioner prayed for bail under Section 483 of BNSS at pre-commitment stage, learned Addl. Sessions Judge ought to have decided the matter on merit whether he should be granted regular bail or not, and even thereafter also, on several occasions, learned Addl. Sessions Judge has been extending the period of interim bail as indicated above. The last order passed by the learned Addl. Sessions Judge which is challenged by the prosecution in this application is the order dated 27.10.2025 but thereafter also several orders have been passed by said learned Court granting him interim bail but those orders are not challenged in this petition. [4] The wife of the deceased Ashish Ranjan Das namely, Smt. Ranubala Das lodged one ejahar at Kamalpur P.S. on 20.06.2025 alleging, inter alia, that on 16.06.2025 in the evening getting a phone call from one person, the deceased went to the brick kiln of the present respondent with some pieces of cucumber but ultimately, he did not return on that nigh…
18. 06.2025, he seized empty mineral water bottle, used empty green coloured bottle (brand Campa), three nos. of used plastic disposable glass along with fingerprints available therein, from said brick kiln which indicates that prior to lodging of FIR on 20.06.2025 already these items were seized by the police. [9] Mr. Raju Datta, learned P.P. submits that without considering prayer for custody trial of the accused persons, learned Addl. Sessions Judge has granted bail to the present respondent. Referring to the materials as came out during investigation, Mr. Datta, learned P.P. contends that despite having sufficient materials against the present accused person in the case diary, erroneously learned Addl. Sessions Judge has granted bail ignoring those materials. Learned P.P. also submits that the accused person has a history of absconding and he went to Guwahati just after the incident to evade arrest. Learned P.P. also contends that learned Addl. Sessions Judge has committed error by ignoring the settled principle of law that a regular bail cannot be granted for a limited period in the nature of interim bail. Learned P.P. continues to submit that it was a pre-planned murder which has shaken the conscience of the people of that locality and moreover, the respondent is very influential and rich person and therefore, there is every possibility that he will influence the witnesses. […
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.113 of 2025
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Home
Department, Agartala.
……… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
Sri Souvik Das,
S/o Sri Sajal Kanti Das, resident of Kamalpur, P.S. Kamalpur, District Dhalai
Tripura.
……..Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
12th February, 2026.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
26th March, 2026.
YES
Whether fit for reporting :
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The prosecution by challenging the orders dated 08.09.2025,
23.09.2025 and 27.10.2025 passed by learned Addl. Sessions Judge,
Kamalpur has sought for cancellation of bail of the present respondent Souvik
Das.
[2]
By order dated 08.09.2025, learned Addl. Sessions Judge initially
granted interim bail to the respondent till 18.09.2025 in connection with
Kamalpur
PS
case
No.43
of
registered
under
Sections
103(1)/238(a)/61(2)/318(2)/351(3) of BNS, 2023. Said order was passed in
connection with Bail Application No.20 of 2025 filed under Section 483 of
BNSS, 2023. Thereafter, the respondent on 18.09.2025, surrendered before
the Court of learned SDJM, Kamalpur and on that day, his interim bail was
further extended by learned SDJM directing him to appear before the Court of
learned Addl. Sessions Judge on 23.09.2025 on commitment of the case. On
23.09.2025, when the present respondent appeared before learned Addl.
Sessions Judge, again the respondent applied for regular bail but learned
Addl. Sessions Judge granted him interim bail till 27.10.2025. On 27.10.2025,
also he was further released on interim bail till 29.11.2025. On 29.11.2025,
when the respondent surrendered, his interim bail was extended till
04.01.2026 but on the previous day i.e. on 03.01.2026, the respondent has
been again allowed to remain on previous bond till 16.01.2026. On his
surrender on 16.01.2026, he was further released on interim bail till
29.01.2026. Meanwhile, the present petition for cancellation of bail has been
filed by the prosecution.
[3]
Before entering into merit of the matter, the Court is constrained to
observe that the way learned Addl. Sessions Judge is repeatedly allowing him
to remain on interim bail without giving any decision on his prayer for regular
bail, is not proper at all. When in Bail Application No.20 of 2025, the petitioner
prayed for bail under Section 483 of BNSS at pre-commitment stage, learned
Addl. Sessions Judge ought to have decided the matter on merit whether he
should be granted regular bail or not, and even thereafter also, on several
occasions, learned Addl. Sessions Judge has been extending the period of
interim bail as indicated above. The last order passed by the learned Addl.
Sessions Judge which is challenged by the prosecution in this application is
the order dated 27.10.2025 but thereafter also several orders have been
passed by said learned Court granting him interim bail but those orders are not
challenged in this petition.
[4]
The wife of the deceased Ashish Ranjan Das namely, Smt.
Ranubala Das lodged one ejahar at Kamalpur P.S. on 20.06.2025 alleging,
inter alia, that on 16.06.2025 in the evening getting a phone call from one
person, the deceased went to the brick kiln of the present respondent with
some pieces of cucumber but ultimately, he did not return on that night. On the
following day, when after search her husband could not be traced out, they
lodged one missing entry in the police station and on 18.06.2025, the dead
body of her husband was recovered from a riverlet called Lutmachara in
floating condition. On the following day, i.e. on 19.06.2026, she identified the
dead body to be of her husband and on the next day she lodged the FIR
against the present respondent and others. She also stated that there was
dispute between her husband and father-in-law with the respondent as the
respondent had cheated her father-in-law by taking some of his land on lease
for ten years though it was verbally agreed between the parties that the lease
deed would be for five years only but in the deed, the respondent got the
period of lease mentioned as ten years by deceiving her father-in-law.
[5]
Police after registration of the case as Kamalpur PS case No.43 of
2025 investigated the same and ultimately, laid the charge-sheet against the
present respondent, the manager of his brick kiln namely Prasanta Das and
others under Sections 103(1)/61(2)/238/238(a)/318(3)/351(3) of BNS praying
for custody trial of all the accused persons. According to investigating officer,
there is possibility of tampering of evidences by the accused persons and
moreso, it was a cold blooded and pre-planned murder and it has shaken the
conscience of the local people. It is also stated that the respondent being a
brick field owner is having substantial financial power and influence and he
may either directly or through his associates tamper with evidence, intimidate
or cause harm to the victim’s family and important witnesses.
[6]
The result of the investigation as projected in the charge-sheet
shows that it is a case of circumstantial evidence, having no eye witness of the
occurrence. According to the investigating officer, the respondent was the
principal conspirator of the offence as he had previous land dispute with the
deceased’s father concerning execution of a lease deed and less payment of
the rent and therefore, he conspired with Prasanta Das, his manager to kill the
deceased and therefore, he was brought to the brick kiln on the pretext of
consuming liquor with accused Manoranjan Goon and another accused
namely, Pranesh Banik, both of whom are hired killers. According to the
prosecution, a part payment for the murder was also made by the respondent
thereafter on 16.06.2025. On the fateful day, they arranged a liquor party in
the brick kiln where other accused persons also joined but the respondent was
not personally present there. His manger Prasanta Das also left the place after
a point of time. Both Manoranjan Goon and Pranesh Banik came by an Alto
vehicle in the scene of occurrence and remained present in the said liquor
party. After Prasanta Das left the place, the driver and other labourer of the
brick kiln (accused herein) also left the same. Then Manoranjan Goon mixed
some sleeping pills in the glass of the deceased which were brought by
Pranesh Banik and thereafter, both Pranesh Banik and Manoranjan Goon
killed him by throttling and thereafter, they left the dead body in Lutmachara by
said alto vehicle.
[7]
The investigating officer mainly based on the confessional
statements made by the accused persons to the police during their
interrogation and also the CDR and SDR of the telephone numbers of the
accused persons to establish that the accused persons (except the present
respondent) and the deceased were present in RKBI brick field on the night of
incident and there were previous communications between them more
frequently. According to the investigating officer, bank statement of respondent
showed that on 17.06.2025, he transferred Rs.40,000/- to his manager,
Prasanta Das which was used for making payment to hired killer.
[8]
The investigating officer on 17.06.2025 also seized one pair of
slipper, two pieces of cucumber from a bamboo made hut of said brick kiln and
two pieces of glass, one bottle neck of foreign liquor, blood stain collected in
two nos. of gauge cloth from the old office corridor of said brick kiln. On
18.06.2025, he seized empty mineral water bottle, used empty green coloured
bottle (brand Campa), three nos. of used plastic disposable glass along with
fingerprints available therein, from said brick kiln which indicates that prior to
lodging of FIR on 20.06.2025 already these items were seized by the police.
[9]
Mr. Raju Datta, learned P.P. submits that without considering
prayer for custody trial of the accused persons, learned Addl. Sessions Judge
has granted bail to the present respondent. Referring to the materials as came
out during investigation, Mr. Datta, learned P.P. contends that despite having
sufficient materials against the present accused person in the case diary,
erroneously learned Addl. Sessions Judge has granted bail ignoring those
materials. Learned P.P. also submits that the accused person has a history of
absconding and he went to Guwahati just after the incident to evade arrest.
Learned P.P. also contends that learned Addl. Sessions Judge has committed
error by ignoring the settled principle of law that a regular bail cannot be
granted for a limited period in the nature of interim bail. Learned P.P.
continues to submit that it was a pre-planned murder which has shaken the
conscience of the people of that locality and moreover, the respondent is very
influential and rich person and therefore, there is every possibility that he will
influence the witnesses.
[10]
Finally, Mr. Datta, learned P.P. relies on a decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in case of State of Karnataka vs. Sri Darshan Etc., 2025
SCC OnLine SC 1702 wherein at Paragraph No.22.1, it was observed by the
Apex Court that the seriousness and heinous nature of the alleged offence is a
significant factor for consideration, while evaluating a plea for cancellation of
bail. At paragraph No.22.4.5, it was further observed that in offences
punishable with life imprisonment or death, the bail court must be especially
cautious and in serious offences, the gravity of the offence and its impact on
society must weigh heavily with the court, and such cases must be considered
with greater care and circumspection.
[11]
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel, on the other hand, argues that the
provision of Section 483 (3), BNSS under which the present bail application is
filed is quite different from the provision of Section 528, BNSS and therefore,
State cannot challenge the bail order passed by the learned Addl. Sessions
Judge or by Magistrate in this forum. In support of his contention, he also
relies on two decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court in cases of Bharatbhai
Bhimabhai Bharwad vs. State of Gujarat and others, (2020) 18 SCC 693
and Ashok Dhankad vs. State of NCT of Delhi and another, 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 1690. In Bharatbhai Bhimabhai Bharwad (supra), at Paragraph
No.9 it is observed that the consideration applicable for cancellation of bail and
consideration for challenging the order granting of bail on the ground of
arbitrary exercise of discretion are different. While considering the application
for cancellation of bail, the Court ordinarily looks for some supervening
circumstances like; tampering of evidence either during investigation or during
trial, threatening of witness, likelihood of abscondence of the accused and
delayed trial on that ground etc.; whereas, in an order challenging the grant of
bail on the ground that it was granted illegally, the consideration is whether
there was improper or arbitrary exercise of discretion in grant of bail. In Ashok
Dhankad (supra), at Paragraph No.19, it was also observed that an appeal
against grant of bail cannot be considered to be on the same footing as an
application for cancellation of bail and the Court concerned must not venture
into a threadbare analysis of the evidence adduced by prosecution. The merits
of such evidence must not be adjudicated at the stage of bail. It was also
observed that an order granting bail must reflect application of mind and
assessment of the relevant factors for grant of bail that was elucidated by this
Court and an appeal against grant of bail may be entertained by a superior
Court on grounds such as perversity; illegality; inconsistency with law and
relevant factors not been taken into consideration including gravity of the
offence and impact of the crime. However, the Court may not take the conduct
of an accused subsequent to the grant of bail into consideration while
considering an appeal against the grant of such bail. Such grounds must be
taken in an application for cancellation of bail.
[12]
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel also submits that there is no prima
facie materials that the death of the deceased was a homicidal death and
therefore, it does not justify submission of charge-sheet under Section 103,
BNS and moreover, there was no material collected against the present
respondent to implicate him with such a grievous allegation. According to Mr.
Lodh, learned counsel, said Prasanta Das, being the manager of the
respondent, it was very usual for him to frequently talk with the respondent
over phone and no exception can be taken for the same. Mr. Lodh, learned
counsel, finally, contends that any confession made by an accused person
before any Executive Magistrate or before the police officer has no evidential
value. On these grounds, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel prays for rejecting the
prayer of the prosecution.
[13]
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Darshan’s case has referred to
another decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in case of Prahlad Singh Bhati
vs. NCT of Delhi, (2001) 4 SCC 280 wherein the broad principle while dealing
with the application for seeking bail was discussed, that while granting bail the
Court is required to keep in mind the nature of accusations, the nature of
evidence in support thereof, the severity of the punishment which conviction
would entail, the character, behaviour, means and standing of the accused,
circumstances which are peculiar to the accused, reasonable possibility of
securing the presence of the accused during trial, the reasonable
apprehension of tampering with the witnesses and the larger interests of the
public or State and similar other considerations. Hon’ble Supreme Court, in
this case also deals with the issue of annulment of the bail order and refers to
some earlier decisions of the Apex Court wherein it was held that a bail order
can be set aside even in the absence of post-bail misconduct if it is found to be
unjustified, illegal, or perverse or that bail order was passed taking into
consideration of irrelevant materials or it was granted mechanically and
without application of mind to the material factors such as the gravity of the
offence or antecedents of the accused.
[14]
In the case in hand, one of the major factor is that no positive
opinion was given by the autopsy surgeon regarding homicidal death of the
accused person and though, the possibility of post mortem drowning could not
be ruled out but the doctor could not specifically determine with certainty that it
was not a case of anti mortem drowning. Benzodiazepine group of drug was
found in the stomach and liver of the deceased and over dose of the same
also, according to the Medical Officer, can cause death of a person. The
investigating officer collected fingerprints from different items seized from the
said brick kiln and got it compared with the specimen fingerprints of the
accused persons but the forensic authority could not also come to any definite
finding to connect the accused persons with those materials. The blood stain
found in the said brick kiln also could not be matched with the blood group of
the deceased. By way of soil test also matching could not be done between
the soil collected from the said brick kiln and the soil seized from railing of
Baralutma RCC bridge and back of the deceased. Though it is alleged that the
respondent absconded after the incident but as it appears he was arrested on
20.06.2025 which means for one day he along with manager Prasanta went to
Guwahati after the alleged incident and thereafter he duly returned to
Kamalpur. Having taking into consideration of the totality of materials available
in the record, it appears that learned Addl. Sessions Judge has committed no
error in granting bail to the respondent though for interim periods.
[15]
Nothing is placed in the record by the investigating officer that the
respondent has any previous criminal record. He has his permanent residence
within the jurisdiction of the learned Trial Court. Considering all these aspects,
this Court does not find any infirmity in the order of the learned Court below in
granting bail to the respondent.
[16]
In view of above discussions, no cogent ground is found to
interfere with the order of the learned Addl. Sessions Judge and accordingly,
the present bail application is rejected.
It is however clarified that whatever are observed hereinabove
regarding materials placed by the investigating officer, are made only for
limited purpose to examine the merit of the instant application and any such
observation made hereinabove will have no bearing in the trial of the case.
Return the case diary to learned P.P.
Re-consign the Trial Court record with copy of this order.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Rudradeep
signed by RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE Digitally
Date: 2026.03.26 17:21:22 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review