The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. 11.2024 after noting down the listed vacation period from 09.10.2024 till 03.11.2024. While this court considered the prayer for custodial trial, the grounds for consideration were the possibility of hampering/tampering, of absconsion and the conduct of the accused as several other cases were filed based on similar acts. It is important to mention that the stage was inquiry and the stage of the case record now, is trial. The custodial trial prayer was allowed by providing an opportunity to the prosecution to conclude the trial within a considerable period of time and once the trial commenced, the grounds for deciding bail prayer U/S 437(6) of Cr.P.C. override and are more weighty than the grounds considered by the court while deciding prayer for custodial trial. At this juncture, reliance is placed on the judgment passed by the Apex Court in Subhelal @Sushil Sahu v. State of Chattisgarh Criminal Appeal No.818/2025 wherein the Apex Court elaborated essential factors to be considered to be relevant while deciding bail prayer U/S 437(6) of Cr.P.C. and the court also explained further that if answer to any of the factors is in the affirmative, then that would work as a fetter on the right that accrues to the accused under first part of sub-section (6) of Section 437 of Cr.P.C.” From the aforesaid observation of the Learned Trial Court, it appears that considering the materials on r…
07. Thus, the order dated 24.04.2025 passed by the Learned Trial Court stands cancelled and set aside. From the record of the Learned Trial Court, it appears that in this case I.O. has cited 31 nos. of witnesses in the charge-sheet. So, all endeavour should be made by the Learned Trial Court to dispose of the case giving top priority at an earliest on the ground that the accused is languishing in jail. However, it will be always open for the respondent-accused to move for bail to the appropriate forum in-accordance-with law, if he so advised. With this observation, this present bail application stands disposed of. Send down the record to the Learned Trial Court along with a copy of this order. Return back the Case Diary, if any, to IO through Learned P.P. along with a copy of this order. Also, send a copy of this order to Learned J.M. 1st Class, West Tripura, Agartala, Court No.6 for information and compliance. Purnita +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.30 of 2025
The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary
to the Government of Tripura,
Home Department, Agartala.
---- Applicant (s)
Versus
Sri Saikat Talapatra,
S/o Late Ranjit Talapatra
resident of AD Nagar Road No.6,
P.O. & P.S.- A.D. Nagar,
District-West Tripura (under custody
At Kendriya Sansodhanagarh, Bishalgarh)
----Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr.
Adv,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
07.11.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
14.11.2025
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This application under Section 439(3) of Cr.P.C.
corresponding to Section 483(3) of BNSS is filed by the
prosecution
for
cancellation
of
the
order
of
bail
dated
24.04.2025 passed by Learned J.M. 1st Class, Court No.6,
Agartala, in connection with case No. PRC (WP) 58 of 2024. By
the said order Learned Trial Court has granted bail to the
respondent-accused.
02.
Heard Learned P.P., Mr. Raju Datta appearing on
behalf of the State-appellant also heard Learned Senior
Counsel, Mr. P. Roy Barman assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr.
Kawsik Nath appearing on behalf of the respondent-accused.
03.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned P.P. first of all
drawn the attention of the Court that on the basis of an FIR
laid by one Puja Roy, this present case was registered against
the respondent-accused by O/C, West Agartala Women P.S.
and after that by order dated 29.11.2023 the accused was
shown arrested in connection with this case.
It was further submitted by Learned P.P. that
against this present accused some other cases were pending
across the State and almost in all the cases he was languishing
in jail and after completion of investigation, the I.O. laid
charge-sheet
against
the
accused,
Saikat
Talapatra
and
another under Sections 120(B)/354(A)/384/386/500/506/509
of IPC and under Section 67(A) of IT Act and accordingly,
Learned
CJM,
West
Tripura,
Agartala
by
order
dated
29.01.2024 took cognizance of offence and the case was
transferred to the Court of Learned J.M. 1st Class, Court No.6
for disposal as per law. Before the Learned Trial Court a prayer
was submitted by the prosecution for holding custody trial of
the accused on 07.03.2024 and the Learned Trial Court after
hearing both the sides by order dated 01.05.2024 passed an
order for holding custody trial of the accused. Thereafter, on so
many occasions bail prayer was filed on behalf of the accusedin-custody but that was rejected by the Learned Trial Court
time to time but later on, on 24.04.2025 Learned Trial Court
granted bail invoking the provision of Section 437(6) of Cr.P.C.
which was not permissible in the eye of law and challenging
that order, the prosecution has moved this application before
this Court for cancellation of the order of bail granted to the
accused.
Learned P.P. further submitted that there was no
power on the part of the Learned Trial Court to review or
modify the earlier order of custody trial and Section 362 of
Cr.P.C. does not empower the Court to alter or review the
judgment or final order except to correct clerical or arithmetical
error.
In this regard, Learned P.P. relied upon one citation
of the Hon’ble Apex Court of India In Vikram Bakshi & Ors.
vs. R.P. Khosla & Anr. reported in (2025) SCC OnLine SC
1783, wherein in para Nos.27, 28 and 34, Hon’ble the Apex
Court observed as under:
“27. The law relating to power of a criminal court to
review or alter its own judgment or order is governed
by the provisions of Section 362 of CrPC (equivalent to
Section 403 of Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita,
2023). The Provision explicitly provides that except for
clerical and arithmetical error, no court shall alter or
review its judgment. It is appropriate to refer to the
bare provision of Section 362 of CrPC which reads as
follows:
“362. Court not to alter judgment.— Save as
otherwise provided by this Code or by any
other law for the time being in force, no
Court, when it has signed its judgment or final
order disposing of a case, shall alter or review
the same except to correct a clerical or
arithmetical error.”
27A. The comparison of the power of review of a
civil court visa-vis power of criminal court to review
or recall its own judgment or order arising out of
criminal proceedings has been put to rest by
numerous decisions of this Court. It would be
appropriate at this juncture to discuss the relevant
decisions of this court pertaining to review or recall
power of criminal courts to ascertain the correct
position of law before proceeding to refer and deal
with the factual matrix of the present case.
28. The scope of Section 362 of CrPC has been
discussed and elaborated by a three-judge bench
decision of this Court in State of Kerala v. M.M.
Manikantan Nair4, wherein it held that CrPC does not
authorize High Court to review its judgment or order
passed either in exercise of its appellate, revisional or
original jurisdiction. Section 362 explicitly prohibits
the court after it has signed its judgment or final order
disposing of case from altering or reviewing the said
judgment or order except to correct a clerical or
arithmetical error. This prohibition is complete and no
criminal court can review its own judgment or order
after it is signed.
34. A careful consideration of the statutory provisions
and the aforesaid decisions of this Court clarify the
now-well-settled position of jurisprudence of Section
362 of CrPC which when summarize would be that the
criminal courts, as envisaged under the CrPC, are
barred from altering or review their own judgments
except for the exceptions which are explicitly provided
by the statute, namely, correction of a clerical or an
arithmetical error that might have been committed or
the said power is provided under any other law for the
time being in force. As the courts become functus
officio the very moment a judgment or an order is
signed, the bar of Section 362 CrPC becomes
applicable, this, despite the powers provided under
Section 482 CrPC which, this veil cannot allow the
courts to step beyond or circumvent an explicit bar. It
also stands clarified that it is only in situations
wherein an application for recall of an order or
judgment seeking a “procedural review” that the bar
would not apply and not a substantive review” where
the bar as contained in Section “362 CrPC is attracted.
Numerous decisions of this Court have also elaborated
that the bar under said provision is to be applied
stricto sensu.”
Relying upon the same, Learned P.P. drawn the
attention of the Court that by the subsequent order of bail
dated 24.04.2025 delivered by Learned Trial Court, the Trial
Court has reviewed its earlier order dated 01.05.2024 which
the law does not permit. As such in view of the principle of law
laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforenoted case,
Learned P.P. urged for setting aside/cancel the order dated
24.04.2025 passed by Learned Trial Court and to direct the
Trial Court to dispose of the case in-accordance-with law.
04.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. P.
Roy Barman assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. Kawsik Nath
appearing on behalf of the accused person drawn the attention
of the Court that this is one of the high profile cases and this
accused has been falsely implicated in so many cases across
the State and in this case also the accused is languishing in jail
for a considerable period of time and he has been shown
arrested in connection with this case w.e.f. 19.11.2023 and
even according to Learned Senior Counsel, if the accused is
found guilty in this case after conclusion of trial also, it will be
found that he has served the maximum period of imprisonment
in custody and more so, the Learned Trial Court passed the
order during pendency of trial of this case and the prayer for
custody trial was allowed before trial. So, according to Learned
Senior Counsel there was no infirmity in the order passed by
Learned Trial Court and in support of his contention Learned
Senior Counsel relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Apex
Court reported in AIR (2025) SC 1483 [titled as Subhelal
alias Sushil Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh] wherein in para
Nos.9, 13 and 17, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“9. Sub-section (2) of Section 437 of the Code can be
divided in two parts. The first part would indicate that
it is mandatory, but in the next breath, the legislature
has given discretion to the Magistrate not to grant bail
by assigning reasons. In that situation, although the
first part can momentarily said to be mandatory, it
cannot be interpreted to give an indefeasible right to
the accused of being released on bail, since that right
is controlled/regulated by the later part of the subsection. If legislature had stopped at the end of the
first part, making it mandatory for the Magistrate to
release the accused on bail if the trial is not over
within 60 days from the first date of taking evidence,
the provision would have been somewhat akin to subsection (2) of Section 167 of the Code. But, with the
second part being in its place, the two provisions
cannot be equated. The provision of sub-section (6) of
Section 437 can certainly be said to have been
inserted with an intention to speed up the trial without
unnecessarily detaining a person as an under-trial
prisoner for a prolonged time. Contrary to that,
Section 167(2) leaves no room for any discretion with
the Court so far as release of an accused on bail is
concerned in the given set of circumstances. Under
this provision of the Code no reason is good to deny
bail to the accused.
13. In our view, following factors would be relevant:
1. Whether the reasons for being unable to
conclude trial within sixty days from the first date
fixed of taking evidence, are attributable to the
accused?
2. Whether there are any chances of the accused
tampering with evidence or causing prejudice to
the case of the prosecution in any other manner?
3. Whether there are any chances of abscondence
of the accused on being bailed out?
4. Whether accused was not in custody during the
whole of the said period?
If the answer to any one of the above referred fact
situations or similar fact situations is in
affirmative then that would work as a fetter on the
right that accrues to the accused under first part
of sub-section (6) of Section 437 of the Code.
17. This Court is of a considered view that applications
under Section 437 (6) have to be given a liberal
approach and it would be a sound and judicious
exercise of discretion in favour of the accused by the
Court concerned more particularly where there is no
chance of tampering of evidence e.g. where the case
depends on documentary evidence which is already
collected; where there is no fault on part of the
accused in causing of delay; where there are no
chances of any abscondence by the accused; where
there is little scope for conclusion of trial in near
future; where the period for which accused has been
in jail is substantial in comparison to the sentence
prescribed for the offence for which he is tried. Normal
parameters for deciding bail application would also be
relevant while deciding application under Section
437(6) of the Code, but not with that rigour as they
might have been at the time of application for regular
bail.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel drawn
the attention of the Court that there was no infirmity in the
order passed by Learned Trial Court and urged for dismissal of
the application filed by the prosecution.
05.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused
the record of the Learned Trial Court. In this case as already
stated the case was registered on the basis of an FIR laid by
one Puja Roy against this present accused and another and on
conclusion of investigation, the I.O. laid charge-sheet against
both of them. After hearing both the sides, it appears that the
impugned order was passed by Learned Trial Court under
Section 437(6) of Cr.P.C.
Now for the sake of convenience, I would like to
reproduce herein below the relevant provision of Section
437(6) of Cr.P.C. which provides as follows:
“437(6). If, in any case triable by a Magistrate, the
trial of a person accused of any non-bailable offence is
not concluded within a period of sixty days from the
first date fixed for taking evidence in the case, such
person shall, if he is in custody during the whole of the
said period, be released on bail, to the satisfaction of
the Magistrate, unless for reasons to be recorded in
writing, the Magistrate otherwise directs.”
From the aforesaid provision, it appears that the
first part would indicate that it is mandatory but in the next
part, the legislature has given discretion to the magistrate not
to grant bail by assigning reasons.
06.
But here in the case at hand Learned Trial Court
once allowed the prayer of prosecution for holding custody trial
by order dated 01.05.2024 but later on by another order dated
24.04.2025 granted bail to the accused with the following
assertions:
“………It is true that on 01.05.2024, after considering
the
entire
case
record
along
with
the
materials/evidences placed, that this court allowed
the prayer for custodial trial and, thereafter, on
07.10.2024, charges were framed against the accused
persons, and the trial commenced. The case record
was then fixed for examination of CSPW No.1 on
25.11.2024 after noting down the listed vacation
period from 09.10.2024 till 03.11.2024. While this
court considered the prayer for custodial trial, the
grounds for consideration were the possibility of
hampering/tampering, of absconsion and the conduct
of the accused as several other cases were filed based
on similar acts. It is important to mention that the
stage was inquiry and the stage of the case record
now, is trial. The custodial trial prayer was allowed by
providing an opportunity to the prosecution to
conclude the trial within a considerable period of time
and once the trial commenced, the grounds for
deciding bail prayer U/S 437(6) of Cr.P.C. override and
are more weighty than the grounds considered by the
court while deciding prayer for custodial trial. At this
juncture, reliance is placed on the judgment passed by
the Apex Court in Subhelal @Sushil Sahu v. State of
Chattisgarh Criminal Appeal No.818/2025 wherein the
Apex Court elaborated essential factors to be
considered to be relevant while deciding bail prayer
U/S 437(6) of Cr.P.C. and the court also explained
further that if answer to any of the factors is in the
affirmative, then that would work as a fetter on the
right that accrues to the accused under first part of
sub-section (6) of Section 437 of Cr.P.C.”
From the aforesaid observation of the Learned Trial
Court, it appears that considering the materials on record the
Learned
Trial
Court
initially
allowed
the
prayer
of
the
prosecution on the ground of possibility of hampering and
tampering of evidence, chance of absconsion and also on the
ground of having some other cases against him with further
expectation that the prosecution can take step to control the
trial but as no effective step was taken by the prosecution, so,
bail was granted, which in my considered opinion was not
proper on the part of the Learned Trial Court. Because once the
Trial Court passes an order for holding custody trial and that
order still stands good and until and unless that order remain
unchallenged
or
without
recording
evidence
of
material
witnesses, in my considered view it was not proper on the part
of the Learned Trial Court to grant bail to the accused, since in
view of Section 362 of Cr.P.C., there is no scope to review or
modify its own order and thus, clearly bars the Learned Court
trial to review its earlier order by the subsequent order passed.
The citation referred by prosecution in this regard is
very much applicable for decision of this matter. So, the order
dated 24.04.2025 passed by Learned Trial Court appears to be
passed
without
jurisdiction,
incorrect
and
also
not
in-
accordance-with the established procedure of law.
07.
Thus, the order dated 24.04.2025 passed by the
Learned Trial Court stands cancelled and set aside. From the
record of the Learned Trial Court, it appears that in this case
I.O. has cited 31 nos. of witnesses in the charge-sheet. So, all
endeavour should be made by the Learned Trial Court to
dispose of the case giving top priority at an earliest on the
ground that the accused is languishing in jail. However, it will
be always open for the respondent-accused to move for bail to
the appropriate forum in-accordance-with law, if he so advised.
With this observation, this present bail application
stands disposed of.
Send down the record to the Learned Trial Court
along with a copy of this order.
Return back the Case Diary, if any, to IO through
Learned P.P. along with a copy of this order.
Also, send a copy of this order to Learned J.M. 1st
Class, West Tripura, Agartala, Court No.6 for information and
compliance.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.11.14 17:57:18
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review