Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
BA No.37 of 2025
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary to the
Government of Tripura, Home Department,
Agartala.
---Applicant
-VsSri Saikat Talapatra,
S/o Late Ranjit Talapatra
Resident of AD Nagar Road No.6,
P.O. & P.S. – A.D Nagar, District- West Tripura
(Under custody at Kendriya Sansodhanagarh, Bishalgarh)
---Respondent
For Applicant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
None.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
02/07/2025
Heard Learned P.P., Mr. Raju Datta appearing on behalf of
the State-applicant.
We have already received the record from the Learned Trial
Court. But l today also no step has been taken by the private
respondent-accused inspite of service of notice.
At the time of hearing, Learned P.P. appearing on behalf of
the State-applicant drawn the attention of the Court the contents
of the FIR and referring the same, Learned P.P. submitted that on
the basis of FIR Killa P.S. Case No.027 of 2023 under Section
153A/153B/504/505/506/509 of IPC read with Section 67 of IT
Act and also under Section 3(1)(r)/3(1)(s)/3(1)(u)/3(2)(va) of SC
and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 was registered against
the
respondent-accused
and
the
I/O
after
completion
of
investigation laid chargesheet against the respondent-accused
before the Court.
Learned P.P. thereafter submitted that the I/O in the
chargesheet prayed by holding custody trial of the said accused
but the Learned Trial Court below by order dated 02.05.2025 in
connection with Case No. Special 01 of 2025 granted bail to the
said accused which was violative of the provision of Section 15A of
SC and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 specifically the subsections 3 and 5 of the said Act. For the sake of convenience, I
would like to refer herein below the relevant provisions of subsection 3 and 5 of Section 15 A of the aforesaid Act which are as
follows:“15A. Rights of victims and witnesses. –
(3) A victim or his dependent shall have the right to reasonable,
accurate, and timely notice of any Court proceeding including any bail
proceeding and the Special Public Prosecutor or the State Government
shall inform the victim about any proceedings under this Act.
(5) A victim or his dependent shall be entitled to be heard at any
proceeding under this Act in respect of bail, discharge, release,
parole, conviction or sentence of an accused or any connected
proceedings or arguments and file written submission on conviction,
acquittal or sentencing.”
Thereafter, Learned P.P. further drawn the attention of the
Court referring one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
reported in 2021 SCC OnLine SC 1010 in Hariram Bhambhi
Vs. Satyanarayan and Another wherein in Para Nos.6, 13, 14
and 17 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:“6. The appellant moved the High Court under Section 439(2) of CrPC
for cancellation of bail [S.B. Criminal Bail Cancellation Application
No.21/2020]. In the meantime, another Single Judge of the High
Court, by an order dated 29 January 2021 rejected the application for
bail filed by three co-accused - Kalu Ram, Kishan Lal and Chaman Lal.
The application for cancellation of bail before the High Court was
moved principally on the ground that no notice was issued to the
appellant under sub-section (3) of Section 15A of the SC/ST Act,
resultingly no opportunity to be heard was provided under subsection (5) of Section 15A. The Single Judge who had admitted the
first respondent to bail on 7th November 2019 rejected the
application on the ground that since the appellant was being heard in
the application for cancelling bail, the requirements of sub-sections
(3) and (5) of Section 15A were complied with. The High Court
observed:
"So far as compliance of Section 15A(3)(5) of SC/ST is
concerned, this Court today heard counsel for the
complainant-petitioner
again
on
merits,
therefore,
requirement of issuing notice to the complainantpetitioner (victim) as provided under Section 15A(3)(5) of
the SC/ST Act is being complied with.
The order dated 07.11.2019 was passed by this Court after
considering the statement of PW-2, Smt. Aaram Devi, wife
of the deceased, therefore, I see no reason for recalling of
the order dated 07.11.2019. As such, this criminal
miscellaneous bail cancellation application is hereby
dismissed."
13. Section 15A of the SC/ST Act contains important provisions that
safeguard the rights of the victims of caste-based atrocities and
witnesses. Sub-sections (3) and (5) of Section 15A specifically make
the victim or their dependent an active stakeholder in the criminal
proceedings. These provisions enable a member of the marginalized
caste to effectively pursue a case and counteract the effects of
defective investigations. Sub-sections (1) to (5) of Section 15A are
extracted below:
"15A(1) It shall be the duty and responsibility of the State
to make arrangements for the protection of victims, their
dependents,
and
witnesses
against
any
kind
of
intimidation or coercion or inducement or violence or
threats of violence.
(2) A victim shall be treated with fairness, respect
and dignity and with due regard to any special need that
arises because of the victim's age or gender or
educational disadvantage or poverty.
(3) A victim or his dependent shall have the right to
reasonable, accurate, and timely notice of any Court
proceeding including any bail proceeding and the Special
Public Prosecutor or the State Government shall inform
the victim about any proceedings under this Act.
(4) A victim or his dependent shall have the right to
apply to the Special Court or the Exclusive Special Court,
as the case may be, to summon parties for production of
any documents or material, witnesses or examine the
persons present.
(5) A victim or his dependent shall be entitled to be
heard at any proceeding under this Act in respect of bail,
discharge, release, parole, conviction or sentence of an
accused or any connected proceedings or arguments and
file written submission on conviction, acquittal or
sentencing.”
(emphasis added)
14. Sub-section (3) of Section 15A confers a statutory right on the
victim or their dependents to reasonable, accurate, and timely notice
of any court proceeding including a bail proceeding. In addition, subsection (3) requires a Special Public Prosecutor or the State
Government to inform the victim about any proceeding under the Act.
Sub-section (3) confers a right to a prior notice, this being evident
from the use of the expression "reasonable, accurate, and timely
notice of any court proceeding including any bail proceeding". Subsection (5) provides for a right to be heard to the victim or to a
dependent. The expression "dependent" is defined in Section 2(bb)
thus:
"2(bb) "dependent" means the spouse, children,
parents, brother and sister of the victim, who are
dependent wholly or mainly on such victim for his support
and maintenance;"
17. The Gujarat High Court in Hemal Ashwin Jain v.
Union of India, R/Special Civil Application No.6369 of
(Gujarat
High
Court),
available
at
https://www.livelaw.in/pdf
upload/pdf
upload380514.pdf (last accessed on 27 October 2021) observed
that:
"37. The victims, even today, have no semblance of
rights at the investigation stage and a feeble position at
the trial stage of a criminal prosecution.
…..
53. We are also not impressed by the argument of Mr.
Popat that Section 15A(3) of the Amendment Act should
be construed as directory and not mandatory. As is
evident from a plain reading of the section quoted above,
the victim must be served with notice of the bail
application and must be provided an opportunity to be
heard and advance argument. When a statute specifically
provides a right to the victim/dependent to be heard at
any proceedings in respect of bail, and if the court fails to
provide such opportunity, then there is an inherent failure
of justice. This procedure, in our opinion, cannot be
bypassed. The non-compliance of the provision of Section
15A(3) of the Amendment Act would render an order null
and void. If Section 15A(3) of the Amendment Act is to be
construed as directory, then the very object and purpose
with which such provision is enacted would got
frustrated.”
61. In such circumstances referred to above, we hold
that Section 15A(3) of the Amendment Act is mandatory
and not directory”
(emphasis supplied).
Learned P.P., thereafter submitted another citation of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported in (2024) 10 SCC 768
in Ajwar Vs. Waseem and Another wherein in Para Nos.26 and
27 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:“26. While considering as to whether bail ought to be granted in
a matter involving a serious criminal offence, the Court must consider
relevant factors like the nature of the accusations made against the
accused, the manner in which the crime is alleged to have been
committed, the gravity of the offence, the role attributed to the
accused, the criminal antecedents of the accused, the probability of
tampering of the witnesses and repeating the offence, if the accused
are released on bail, the likelihood of the accused being unavailable in
the event bail is granted, the possibility of obstructing the
proceedings and evading the courts of justice and the overall
desirability of releasing the accused on bail. [Refer: Chaman Lal v.
State of U.P., (2004) 7 SCC 525; Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh
Ranjan, (2004) 7 SCC 528; Masroor v. State of U.P., (2009) 14 SCC
286, Prasanta Kumar Sarkar v. Ashis Chatterjee, (2010) 14 SCC 496,
Neeru Yadav v. State of U.P.(2014) 16 SCC 508; Anil Kumar Yadav v.
State (NCT of Delhi), (2018) 12 SCC 129; Mahipal v. Rajesh Kumar,
(2020) 2 SCC 118]
27. It is equally well settled that bail once granted, ought not to
be cancelled in a mechanical manner. However, an unreasoned or
perverse order of bail is always open to interference by the superior
court. If there are serious allegations against the accused, even if he
has not misused the bail granted to him, such an order can be
cancelled by the same Court that has granted the bail. Bail can also be
revoked by a superior court if it transpires that the courts below have
ignored the relevant material available on record or not looked into
the gravity of the offence or the impact on the society resulting in
such an order. In P v. State of M.P., (2022) 15 SCC 211 decided by a
three-Judge Bench of this Court [authored by one of us (Hima Kohli,
J.)] has spelt out the considerations that must weigh with the Court
for interfering in an order granting bail to an accused under Section
439(1) CrPC in the following words: (SCC p. 224, para 24)
"24. As can be discerned from the above decisions, for
cancelling bail once granted, the court must consider
whether any supervening circumstances have arisen or
the conduct of the accused post grant of bail demonstrates
that it is no longer conducive to a fair trial to permit him to
retain his freedom by enjoying the concession of bail
during trial [Dolat Ram v. State of Haryana, (1995) 1 SCC
349]. To put it differently, in ordinary circumstances, this
Court would be loathe to interfere with an order passed by
the court below granting bail but if such an order is found
to be illegal or perverse or premised on material that is
irrelevant, then such an order is susceptible to scrutiny
and interference by the appellate court."”
Referring those citations, Learned P.P. submitted that in the
instant case, Learned Special Judge at the time of considering bail
application did not follow the provisions of sub-sections 3 and 5 of
Section 15A of the Act and also in view of the aforesaid citations
of law of the Hon’ble Apex Court of India, granted bail to the
respondent-accused which needs to be interfered with and be set
aside.
Considered.
In this case, the prosecution was set into motion on the
basis of an FIR laid by the informant Smt. Ati Jamatia on
14.11.2023 to O/C, Killa Police Station which are mentioned
herein below:To
The Officer in Charge
Killa Police Station
Gomati District
Subject:- Complaint against Saikat Talapatra for registration of
criminal case under appropriate penal section of IPC, IT Act & SC/ST
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act.
Sir,
I am deeply pained to bring to your knowledge about a
outrageous comments made by one Saikat Talapatra, S/o Lt
Ranjit Talapatra, of Road No-06, A.D Nagar, PO- AD Nagar, PSA.D. Nagar, West Tripura through social media on his Facebook
page “Independent” and YouTube Page “News Independent
Tripura”. I am a proud citizen of this country and also a member
of women wing of Tipra Motha party known as Tipra Women
Federation (TWF). On 15.06.2023, Saikat Talapatra uploaded
video on his Facebook page named Independent whose URL is
https://www.facebook.com/watch?v=tdTGwsOxPIQ which was
titled “Chinese Aunty Bhoy Payeni Independent. In the
aforementioned video I can be seen with my other members of
TWF wherein we have been referred as Chinese Aunty which is
deeply insulting and humiliating to us and our entire tribal
community. In the same video, he also uploaded a video of our
agitation in which a large number of tribal community. In the
same video, he also uploaded a video of our agitation in which a
large number of tribal men and women can be seen. He has also
used the words “Matal”, “Junglee” and “Ugrapanthi”while
addressing us and while referring to our entire tribal community
people. We are extremely humiliated, and insulted by such racial
attack on us and our entire ST community of Tripura. Such
provocative statements/video has outraged the tribal sentiments
throughout the State. As they have shown the video in a public
platform calling us Chinese Aunties besides referring to us by
other derogatory and demeaning words, not only me but my
entire family and tribal society have been affected and insulted
by such racial slurs. After the video went viral, about 107
thousand viewers on Facebook and about 14 thousand viewers
on YouTube have viewed his post already and this video has
caused huge resentment and grudge among tribal people and
has
created
an
environment
of
ethnic
tension
and
misunderstanding between tribal and non tribal population of
the State.
I could not lodge complaint against him earlier as I was
fearing that, if any complaint is lodged against him, he would
publish further derogatory and insulting post against me. Now,
since he has been arrested by the police, I could muster courage
to lodge complaint with request to take stringent legal action
against him.
Thus I humbly pray to take appropriate legal action under
the provisions of IPC, IT Act and SC/ST (Prevention of
Atrocities) Act against Mr. Saikat Talapatra as per law.
Enclo:1)One pen drive containing the aforementioned video.
Yours’ Sincerely
Sd/Smt. Ati Jamatia(50)
W/o Shri Bikan Jamatia
Of Jalema, P.S. Killa,
Gomati Tripura.
On the basis of that, the aforesaid Killa P.S. case was
registered and the I/O after completion of investigation laid
chargesheet against the respondent-accused. The accused was
arrested on 18.01.2025 in this case and thereafter by order dated
02.05.2025, he was granted bail by the Court of Learned Special
Judge, Court No.2, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur. I have
perused the said order. It appears that Learned Court below came
to the observation that since the investigation was completed and
I/O filed chargesheet and considering the period of imprisonment
of this case, he has considered to grant bail to the respondentaccused in connection with this case.
Probably at the time of hearing, Learned Special P.P. failed
draw the attention of the Court referring the aforesaid provisions
of Section 15A of the SC and ST of (Prevention of Atrocities) Act,
1989 and Court also did not refer the said provisions of law at the
time of passing of order. On bare perusal of the aforesaid
provisions it is crystal clear that at the time of disposing of bail
application, the victim or his dependent shall be entitled to be
heard in any proceeding under the said act in respect of bail,
discharge, release, parole, conviction or sentence of an accused or
any connected proceeding or arguments or to file written
submission on conviction, acquittal or sentencing etc. Situated
thus, it appears that without giving any opportunity to the victim
or the informant, no order could have been passed by the Learned
Special Judge. It is also on record that more 12/13 cases are
pending against the said accused.
So, considering the nature of allegation and also the
aforesaid provisions of law as referred by Learned P.P. and after
going through the citations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
it appears that, the order was passed without application of proper
mind and as such, the order dated 02.05.2025 passed by the
Learned Special Judge, Court No.2, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur cannot be sustained in the eye of law. Accordingly, the
same stands cancelled.
Learned Special Judge, Court No.2, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur shall rehear the matter after giving opportunities to the
victim of the case in the event of filing afresh bail application by
the accused and shall pass appropriate order in accordance with
the aforesaid provisions of law. As the respondent-accused
remained absent at the time of hearing of this case, so Learned
Trial Court shall also apprise the order of this Court during the
next time of hearing of this case. It is not known to the Court as
to whether the bail bond has been executed by the respondentaccused or not. However, if his bail bond is accepted by the
Learned Trial Court, in that case, the same shall be cancelled and
the accused shall be taken into custody again till disposal of fresh
bail application, if filed by the accused and also after hearing the
victim of this case for fair ends of justice.
With this observation, this present bail application stands
disposed of.
Send down the record of the Learned Trial Court along with a
copy of this order.
Send down the CD, if any, to the I/O through Learned P.P.
along with a copy of this order.
Accordingly, the application filed by the prosecution under
Section 439(3) of Cr.P.C. corresponding to Section 483(3) of
BNSS, 2023 for cancellation of bail of the order dated 02.05.2025
in connection with Case No.Special 01 of 2025 stands allowed.
Further it appears that, the case is pending for recording
evidence of the witnesses of the prosecution. So, Learned Trial
Judge shall take all endeavour to dispose of the case giving top
priority keeping it in mind that the accused is lodging in custody.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Amrita
AMRITA
DEB
AMRITA DEB
Date: 2025.07.04
17:31:50 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review