The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. In view of the above finding and reasons, this Court is also of the opinion that appellant herein is also a similarly situated person like that of the respondent of WA No.228 of 2021 and order dated 04.02.2022 passed by the learned Single Judge is liable to be set aside and accordingly, the same is set aside. Hence in the light of the observation given in the earlier W.A No.228 of 2021, the present Writ Appeal is allowed.
15. As a sequel, stay if any is vacated, pending application(s), if any, also stands closed. suhanjit CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA NO.122 OF 2022
The State of Tripura
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
Sri Munna Das
……. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 04.04.2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
This
appellant-State
present
against
appeal
the
has
been
filed
Judgment
and
Order
by
the
dated
04.02.2022 passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.684
of 2021 allowing the writ petition.
2.
Brief fact of this present case is that the father of
the writ appellant namely Dip Kumar Das passed away on
25.12.2018 while working as the Sweeping and Cleaning
Assistant borne in the regular establishment. At the time of
death, he was posted in the office of the Information and
Cultural Affairs situated in Santirbazar, South Tripura. After
death of the father of the petitioner, the petitioner applied for
the
compassionate
appointment
under
the
Die-in-Harness
scheme. It may be noted that the appellant has been working as
Casual Worker under the Directorate of Information and Cultural
Affairs, Government of Tripura but he is not in the regular
establishment. The surviving members of the family left by the
deceased employee have executed a no-objection certificate
relinquishing their individual claims and laying their no objection
in respect of appointment of the petitioner under Die-in-Harness
Scheme. The petitioner filed his application for compassionate
appointment on 26.03.2019 within one year from the day of
death of his father. It has been asserted by the petitioner that
except him, none of his family members is eligible for the
Government employment. As the respondents did not take any
decision on the prayer for compassionate appointment, the
petitioner served a notice on 16.03.2020 for his appointment
under Die-in-Harness scheme. Thereafter, he filed a writ petition
being WP(C) No.852 of 2020 in this Court and the said writ
petition had been disposed of vide by order dated 13.01.2021 in
following terms:-
“let the respondents decide the application of the petitioner
for compassionate appointment within 4(four) weeks from today
and communicate the decision to the petitioner. If the decision is
adverse to the petitioner, the competent authority shall state brief
reasons for arriving at such conclusions upon which it would be
open for the petitioner to seek further remedy in law”.
3.
It transpires that pursuant to the order dated
13.01.2021, the Director, Information and Cultural Affairs,
Government of Tripura, by the order dated 06.01.2021 has
dismissed the prayer for the compassionate appointment.
4.
Thereafter, the appellant herein filed WP(C) No.684
of 2021 agitating his grievance. The respondents by filling the
reply has reiterated their stand as espoused in the reply. The
date of relevance would be the date of consideration. As the
family will be getting the pension, it can be stated that the
family left by the deceased employee will not suffer any form of
destitution. On the foundation of the policy, the impugned
decision has been taken by the respondents. When a scheme is
abolished, any pending application seeking appointment under
the scheme will also cease to exist unless its operation for a
purpose is saved. The mere fact that an application was made
when the scheme was in force, will not by itself create a right in
favour of the petitioner.
5.
After hearing the parties, the Hon’ble Single Judge,
allowed the said WP(C) No.684 of 2021 in the following terms:-
“Having observed thus, the respondents are directed to
consider the case of the petitioner for compassionate appointment on the
day of death of the deceased employee i.e. on 25.12.2018 under the Diein-Harness Scheme circulated by the notification dated 26.12.2015. Such
exercise shall be completed within a period of two months from the day
when a copy of this order will be furnished to the respondents by the
petitioner.
6.
Aggrieved
thereby,
the
appellant-State
has
preferred this present appeal seeking the following reliefs:“ A) Admit appeal & call for records.
B) Pass order setting aside the judgment & order
dated 04.02.2022 passed by the Hon’ble Single Judge in WP(C)
No.684 of 2021.
C) Pass order staying the operation of the
Judgment & order dated 04.02.2022 passed by the Hon’ble Single
Judge in WP(C) No.684 of 2021.
D) Pass any other order or Orders as deem fit &
proper having regard to the facts & circumstances of the case.”
7.
Heard Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing
for the appellant-State and as well as Mr. P. Roy Barman,
learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr.S. Bhattacharjee, learned
counsel appearing for the respondent.
8.
Mr. D.
Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. submits that
learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate that the norms
prevailing on the date of consideration of the application, should
be the basis for consideration of claim for compassionate
appointment. A dependant of the government employee, in the
absence of any vested right accruing on the death of the
government
his/her
employee, can only demand consideration of
application.
He
is
however,
disentitled
to
seek
consideration in accordance with the norms as applicable, on the
day of death of the Government employee. Learned Addl. G.A.
further submits that the claim for compassionate appointment is
traceable only to the scheme framed by the employer for such
employment and there is no right whatsoever beyond such
scheme. An appointment under the scheme can be made only if
the scheme is in force. When a scheme is abolished, any
pending application seeking appointment under the scheme will
also cease to exist, unless saved. The mere fact that an
application was made when the scheme was in force, will not by
itself create a right in favour of the applicant.
9.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned Sr. counsel appearing
for the respondent submits that judgment and order as passed
by the learned Single Judge is just and proper and touches all
the legal aspects. Learned Sr. counsel referred to several
paragraphs of the impugned Judgment passed by the learned
Single Judge and submitted that in view of the same, the
learned Single Judge has rightly considered the date of the
death of the deceased employee as the considering factor. Here
the deceased employee died on 25.12.2018 and on that day, the
scheme under 26.12.2015 was in force and the new scheme has
come into force is in 2019. So, the new scheme cannot take
away the right of the appellant herein. Though compassionate
appointment might not be a vested right but right to be
considered cannot be taken away by the new scheme and
learned Single Judge has rightly allowed the writ petition.
10.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record.
11.
Learned Division Bench of this Court in Judgment
and order dated 16th March, 2022 passed in WA No.228 of 2021
along with WP(C) No.686 of 2020 delivered in similar kind of
issues which are as follows:-
“ (i) Whether right to compassionate appointment
under die-in-harness policy is a vested right.
(ii) Whether the revised notification dated
02.03.2019 susperseding the die-in-harness scheme of 2015 with
retrospective operation from 21.11.2018 is valid.
(iii) Whether the norms prevailing on the date of
death of the deceased employee or the norms prevailing on the
date of consideration of the application would apply for
considering a claim under die-in-harness policy.”
12.
While giving finding to the said issues, the learned
Division Bench observed thus:-
“[27] The next question which arose for our
consideration was whether the application would be considered under
the norms prevailing on the date of death or under the norms prevailing
at the time of consideration of the application. Such issue was dealt with
a larger bench of the Apex Court in N.C. Santosh vs. State of
Karnataka & Ors. (Supra) wherein the Apex Court held that norms
prevailing on the date of consideration of claim for compassionate
appointment. Observation. Observation of the Apex Court is as under:
“19. Applying the law governed compassionate
appointment culling out from the above cited judgments, our opinion on
the point at issue is that the norms prevailing on the date of
consideration of claim for compassionate appointment, A dependant of a
government employee, in the absence of any vested right accruing on
the death of the government employee, can only demand consideration
of his/her application. He is however, disentitled to seek consideration in
accordance with the norms as applicable, on the day of death of the
government employee.”
[28]
In the given context, as noted, the petitioner’s father in
WP(C)No.502 of 2020 died on 18.01.2019, petitioner Kamalabati Gour
filed her application seeking compassionate appointment on 21.09.2019.
The revised policy was notified on prior date on 02.03.2019 with
retrospective effect from 21.11.2018. Similarly, in WP(C) No.686 of
2020, petitioner’s father died on 17.01.2019 and application for
compassionate appointment was filed by the petitioner on 02.06.2020.
The revised scheme, as sated above, was notified on a prior dated on
02.03.2019 with retrospective effect from 21.11.2018. It is thus obvious
that in both the cases, the petitions were field and considered after the
revised scheme came into operation. Situated thus, the respondent in
WA No.228 of 2021 as well as the petitioner in WP(C) No.686 of 2020
are not entitled to be considered for compassionate appointment under
the old scheme. Both of them are entitled to be considered for the
benefits available to them under the revised scheme date 02.03.2019.
[29]
For the forgoing reasons the judgment of the
learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.502 of 2020 is set aside and
resultantly WA No.228 of 2021 stands allowed and the reference made
by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.686 of 2020 is answered
accordingly in view of the our decision rendered in WA No.228 of 2021.”
13.
Similarly, the father of the appellant here passed
way on 25.12.2018 and the revised policy was notified on prior
date on 02.03.2019, with retrospective effect from 21.11.2018.
Thus, it is obvious that the petition was filed and considered
after the revised scheme came into operation. So, the appellant
herein is not entitled to be considered for compassionate
appointment under the old scheme and he is entitled to be
considered for the benefits available to them under the revised
scheme dated 02.03.2019.
14.
In view of the above finding and reasons, this
Court is also of the opinion that appellant herein is also a
similarly situated person like that of the respondent of WA
No.228 of 2021 and order dated 04.02.2022 passed by the
learned Single Judge is liable to be set aside and accordingly,
the same is set aside. Hence in the light of the observation
given in the earlier W.A No.228 of 2021, the present Writ Appeal
is allowed.
15.
As a sequel, stay if any is vacated, pending
application(s), if any, also stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review