Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
BA No.75 of 2024
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary
to the Government of Tripura,
Home Department, Agartala
-----Petitioner
-VsSmt. Payel Biswas,
Wife of Sri Shantanu Biswas,
Resident of Milan Chakra,
P.O. & P.S. A.D. Nagar,
District: West Tripura
---Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Mr. P. Saha, Adv.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. K. Nath, Adv.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
24/01/2025
This bail application under Section 439(2) read with Section
482 of Cr.P.C. is filed by the State of Tripura for cancellation of
the order dated 28.03.2024 delivered by Learned Sessions Judge,
West Tripura, Agartala in connection with Bail Application No.45 of
2024 under Section 120(B)/406/468/417/420 of IPC, granting
anticipatory bail to the respondent-accused Smt. Payel Biswas.
Heard Learned P.P. Mr. Raju Datta appearing on behalf of
the state-appellant and also heard Learned counsel Mr. P. Saha
appearing
on
behalf
of
the
de-facto-complainant
i.e.
bank
authority and further heard Learned Senior counsel Mr. P. Roy
Barman assisted by Mr. K. Nath, Learned counsel appearing for
the respondent-accused.
Taking part in the hearing Learned P.P. Mr. Raju Datta first
of all drawn the attention of the court that the initially the FIR was
laid by the respondent-accused herself and submitted that on the
basis of the FIR laid by the respondent-accused West Agartala, PS
Case No.161 of 2023 under Section 120-B/406/468/471/420 was
registered against 69 loanees with the allegation that those
persons obtained loan using fraud and fake documents and also
showing fake unit before TGB, DC, Bazar Branch and thus a sum
of Rs.2,99,15,000/- was disbursed and after registration of the
case according to Learned P.P. the respondent-accused first of all
approached for granting anticipatory bail before the court of
Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala and accordingly
the same was registered as Bail Application No.41 of 2024 and by
order dated 21.03.2024 according to Learned P.P. Learned
Sessions Judge was pleased to reject the bail application of the
petitioner on the ground that no material was available in the CD
regarding apprehension of the petitioner that she may be arrested
on bail. But thereafter the respondent-accused according to
Learned P.P. again approached for granting anticipatory bail which
was registered as Case No. Bail Application 45 of 2024 and
Learned Sessions Judge by order dated 28.03.2024 allowed the
bail application on the ground that on that relevant point of time
the respondent-accused was the Manager of Tripura Gramin Bank,
Durga Chowmuhani Branch when there was no allegation against
her. Learned P.P. further drawn the attention of this court that a
preliminary inquiry was conducted by the bank authority and after
that another FIR was laid by the Regional Manager, TGB, Durga
Chowmuhani Bazar Branch to OC Agartala PS on 31.01.2024
wherein it was mentioned that the respondent-accused being the
Manager of the Branch giving the undue privilege to the most of
the loanee to submit fake documents show fake unit and based on
which huge amount of loan of Rs.2,99,15000/- was disbursed
illegally, fraudulently and dishonestly and as per report of the I.O.
the said second FIR was tagged with the record. But Learned
Sessions Judge at the time of considering of bail application on
28.03.2024
which
was
available
with
the
record
failed
to
appreciate the said subsequent FIR laid by the bank authority
against the respondent-accused and other materials on record.
Learned
P.P.
further
submitted
that
since
there
was
misappropriation of huge public money, so for the sake of
investigation custody interrogation of the accused is required. So
Learned P.P. in summing up of his argument urged for cancellation
of the order of bail granted by Learned Sessions Judge to the
respondent-accused on 28.03.2024.
Learned counsel Mr. P. Saha appearing on behalf of the defacto-complainant submitted that he has submitted one written
note wherein in para No.1 the de-facto-complainant mentioned
that on preliminary investigation it was found that the respondentaccused assisted the loanee to sanction loan by using fake
documents and furthermore the loan amount was directly credited
to the account of the respective account holders inspite of
releasing
the
same
to
the
respective
vendors.
Thus
misappropriated of the huge public money and due to the official
procedure of the bank initially no FIR could be laid against the
respondent-accused. He also relied upon Annexure-D-1 i.e. the
second FIR dated 31.01.2024 and the letter dated 05.06.2024 to
OC, West Agartala PS to Regional Manager, Tripura Gramin Bank,
Annexure-D-2 wherein the OC, West Agartala P.S. informed the
bank authority stating that the subsequent complaint was tagged
with the original case record as the matter was same and finally
Learned counsel for the defacto-complainant with the consent of
Learned P.P. submitted that there is sufficient materials showing
implication of the respondent-accused with the alleged crime, so
Learned Counsel urged for cancellation of the order of bail granted
by Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala on 28.03.2024
in connection with BA No.45 of 2024.
Per contra, Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman
assisted by Mr. K. Nath, Learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the respondent-accused first of all submitted that this present
petition is not maintainable as it does not disclose any cause of
action. Secondly referring the order dated 28.03.2024 i.e. the
operative portion Learned Senior Counsel drawn the attention of
the court that on perusal of the case diary Learned Sessions Judge
allowed anticipatory bail to the respondent-accused with certain
conditions and accordingly the respondent-accused appeared
before I.O. to assist the investigation, but there is no such
allegation on record from the side of the prosecution that the
respondent-accused
has
misused
the
bail
or
violated
the
conditions of the bail. As such, in view of the provision provided
under Section 439(2) of Cr.P.C. there is no scope to interfere with
the order passed by Learned Sessions Judge at this stage. Learned
Senior Counsel further submitted that the accused being a
responsible Officer of the bank and at the time of releasing of loan
amount to a person so many procedures are adopted and based
on the report of other officers of the bank the loan is disbursed so
the respondent-accused cannot be held liable for that and since
she is cooperating with the investigating agency and there is no
chance of her absconsion, so at this stage there is no scope to
cancel the order of bail. Learned Senior Counsel further drawn the
attention of the court referring para No.8 of the objection of the
respondent-accused wherein it is stated that the respondent
cannot grant sanction loan to any beneficiaries. Signature of
Assistant Manager (Processing Officer) is required who after
verifying documents and personally visiting the site, process the
loan proposal after signing it and thereafter Bank Manager
approves and sanctions the loan proposal and the present
respondent acted in bonafide. Verification of documents and
visiting of cites in connection with the sanction of loans was not
carried out by the present respondent and till date the Assistant
Managers (Processing Officers) have not been interrogated by the
investigating officer. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted
that there cannot be any second FIR on the same subject matter
so the submission of Learned counsel for the de-facto complainant
cannot be accepted at this stage and finally Learned Senior
Counsel submitted that since there was no violation of the order of
bail granted by the Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura,
Agartala to the respondent-accused. So this present petition for
cancellation of bail may be rejected henceforth and in summing up
Learned Senior Counsel relied upon one citation of Supreme Court
of India in Myakala Dharmarajam and Others vs. State of
Telengana and Another reported in AIR 2020 SC 317 wherein
in para No.7 Hon’ble the Supreme Court observed as under:
“7. In Raghubir Singh v. State of Bihar2 this Court held
that bail can be cancelled where (i) the accused misuses
his liberty by indulging in similar criminal activity, (ii)
interferes with the course of investigation, (iii) attempts
to tamper with evidence or witnesses, (iv) threatens
witnesses or indulges in similar activities which would
hamper smooth investigation, (v) there is likelihood of his
fleeing to another country, (vi) attempts to make himself
scarce by going underground or becoming unavailable to
the investigating agency, (vii) attempts to place himself
beyond the reach of his surety, etc. The above grounds are
illustrative and not exhaustive. It must also be
remembered that rejection of bail stands on one footing
but cancellation of bail is a harsh order because it
interferes with the liberty of the individual and hence it
must not be lightly resorted to.”
Referring the same Learned Senior Counsel submitted that
since there was no violation of the bail granted to the respondentaccused, now this present application filed by the prosecution is
not maintainable and it is nothing but to harass the respondentaccused and urged for rejection of the application of the
prosecution.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides and gone
through the case diary and other relevant prosecution papers and
the records of the Learned Court below. Admittedly in this case
initially the prosecution was set into motion on the basis of an FIR
laid by the respondent herself to the OC, West Agartala, PS on
30.08.2023 wherein there was allegation against 69 borrowers
that at the time of obtaining loan they used some false and
fabricated documents and showed fake unit before TGB D.C. Bazar
Branch
and
during
investigation
the
Bank
Authority
after
preliminary inquiry also laid another FIR on 31.01.2024 wherein
the bank authority stated that the respondent-accused during her
tenure had given undue privilege to most of the loanees to submit
fake documents and show fake units and based on which those
loans were sanctioned and disbursed on the part of the said
Officer illegally, dishonestly and fraudulently. It was further
submitted that at the instance of the respondent-accused it was
arranged to disburse the amount directly to the savings bank
account of the respective loanees instead of disbursing the same
to the vendors’ account without any reasonable cause. Resultantly
instead of proper utilization of loan amount on the part of the 69
loanees the same was misappropriated and according to the bank
authority the respondent-accused was responsible officer of the
bank severely failed to ascertain the end use of the fund. Further,
from the communication of OC, West Agartala, PS to Regional
Manager, TGB dated 05.06.2024 it appears that the subsequent
FIR was tagged with the original case record.
I have perused the petition filed by the prosecution and also
the objection submitted by the respondent-accused and also the
written note by the de-facto complainant through their engaged
Learned Counsel and also perused the statements of witnesses so
far collected by I.O. up to the stage of investigation. It is on
record that after registration of the case initially the respondent
accused moved on bail application to the Learned Sessions Judge
which was numbered as BA No.41 of 2024 and by order dated
21.03.2024
the
Learned
Sessions
Judge
rejected
the
bail
application to the accused on the ground that there was no reason
for apprehension of the petitioner and by subsequent bail
application which was registered as BA No.45 of 2024 dated
28.03.2024 Learned Sessions Judge on perusal of the CD came to
the observation that in the FIR there was no allegation against the
respondent-accused. So Learned Sessions Judge by the said order
dated
28.03.2024
respondent-accused
granted
with
anticipatory
some
bail
conditions.
to
But
the
said
surprisingly
although the second complaint which was tagged with the record
after inquiry which was submitted by the bank to the OC, West
Agartala PS, the same was not brought to the notice of Learned
Sessions Judge at the time of hearing or the same might have lost
sight of the Learned Sessions Court at the time of consideration of
the
bail
application
of
the
respondent-accused.
From
the
statements of the witnesses collected by I.O. up to the stage of
investigation it appears that the allegation against the respondentaccused is no doubt serious and heinous one also. She misused
her chair being a responsible Public Officer in disbursing loan
amount to the different loanees. So prima facie there is no scope
to presume the respondent-accused to be innocent at this stage
and to unearth the truth this court is of the considered opinion
that her custodial interrogation will be required for proper
investigation of this case. The citation as referred by Learned
Senior Counsel in course of hearing of arguments in Myakala
Dharmarajam and Others (supra) is no doubt relevant but the
same principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court cannot
be applied in this case at this stage because in the said citation in
para No.8 Hon’ble the Apex Court further observed as under:
“8. It is trite law that cancellation of bail can be done in
cases where the order granting bail suffers from serious
infirmities resulting in miscarriage of justice. If the court
granting bail ignores relevant material indicating prima
facie involvement of the accused or takes into account
irrelevant material, which has no relevance to the question
of grant of bail to the accused, the High Court or the
Sessions Court would be justified in cancelling the bail:
AIR 2013 SC 296.”
Learned P.P. in course of hearing of argument also relied
upon another citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Ajwar vs. Waseem and Another reported in (2024) 10 SCC
768 wherein in para No.27 the Apex Court observed as under:
“27. It is equally well settled that bail once granted, ought
not to be cancelled in a mechanical manner. However, an
unreasoned or perverse order of bail is always open to
interference by the superior Court. If there are serious
allegations against the accused, even if he has not
misused the bail granted to him, such an order can be
cancelled by the same Court that has granted the bail. Bail
can also be revoked by a superior Court if it transpires that
the courts below have ignored the relevant material
available on record or not looked into the gravity of the
offence or the impact on the society resulting in such an
order. In P v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Another(supra)
decided by a three judges bench of this Court [authored by
one of us (Hima Kohli, J)] has spelt out the considerations
that must weigh with the Court for interfering in an order
granting bail to an accused under Section 439(1) of the
CrPC in the following words:
"24. As can be discerned from the above decisions,
for cancelling bail once granted, the court must
consider whether any supervening circumstances
have arisen or the conduct of the accused post grant
of bail demonstrates that it is no longer conducive to
a fair trial to permit him to retain his freedom by
enjoying the concession of bail during trial [Dolat
Ram v. State of Haryana, (1995) 1 SCC 349: 1995
SCC (Cri) 237]. To put it differently, in ordinary
circumstances, this Court would be loathe to
interfere with an order passed by the court below
granting bail but if such an order is found to be
illegal or perverse or premised on material that is
irrelevant, then such an order is susceptible to
scrutiny and interference by the appellate court."
From the aforesaid citation it appears that if there is/are
serious allegations against the accused and if the accused also
does not misused the bail granted to her in that case such as
order can be cancelled by the same court that has been granted
bail to the accused and even bail can also be revoked by a
Superior Court if it transpires that the courts below have ignored
the relevant material available on record and not looked into the
gravity of the offence or the impact on the society resulting in
such an order.
Here in the given case after considering the materials on
record it appears that there is serious allegation against the
respondent-accused showing her involvement with the alleged
crime because without her indulgence and assistance such a huge
amount of loan could not be released/disbursed in favour of the 69
loanees who have obtained loan on the basis of fake documents
and showing fake units i.e. business place.
I have also seen the relevant datas collected by the I.O.
during investigation at the time of releasing loan amount to the
different loanees it appears that without verifying the norms i.e.
without obtaining the proper application format, without appraisal
recommendation sheet the disbursement of the loan was made
directly to the account of the loanees and it could not have been
possible without the active connivance of the respondent-accused
in this case. So considering all, at this stage, it appears to this
court that the order dated 28.03.2024 delivered by Learned
Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with Bail
Application No.45/2024 was not proper because the Learned
Sessions Judge at the time of granting anticipatory bail did not
consider the gravity of the offence and also did not consider the
relevant materials available on record which shows implication of
accused with the alleged crime. So in view of the principle laid
down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the said case I am of the
considered view that the order dated 28.03.2024 delivered by
Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with
Bail Application No.45/2024 needs to be cancelled. Accordingly the
order dated 28.03.2024 delivered by Learned Sessions Judge,
West Tripura, Agartala in connection with BA No.45 of 2024 stands
cancelled. The respondent-accused is directed to surrender before
the Learned Jurisdictional Magistrate with a period of seven days
from the date of passing of this order failing which case will
proceed in accordance with law against her.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this order to the
Learned Jurisdictional Magistrate and also send down the records
of BA No.45 of 2024 and the records of BA No.41 of 2024 to the
court of Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala along
with a copy of this order. Further send down the Case Diary along
with a copy of this order to the I.O. through Learned P.P.
Thus the application filed by the Prosecution praying for
cancellation
of
bail
granted
to
the
respondent-accused
accordingly hereby allowed.
The application is thus disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.01.26
22:51:25 +05'30'
is
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review