Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Review Petn. 13 of 2024
The Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Sadar Sub-Division, Agartala
P.O- Agartala, P.S- West Agartala,
District-West Tripura.
Petitioner(S)
Versus
1. Smt. Babita Saha,
W/o Late Subal Saha.
2. Smt. Pinky Saha,
Daughter of Late Subal Saha.
3. Shri Mithun Saha,
S/o Late Subal Saha.
4. Smt.Simran Saha,
Daughter of Late Subal Saha
All are the residents of Pratapgarh, near Ekta Club,
Agartala, P.O, Agartala, P.S East Agartala, District
West Tripura
5. Waris Finance International Ltd.
Having its local offices at Waris Bhaban, L.N Bari Road, P.O. Agartala,
P.S East Agartala, District- West Tripura, represented by its Chairmancum-Managing Director, Present Address-22 Camac Street, Block-A (1St
Floor), Kolkata-700016, West Bengal.
6.
North Eastern Development Finance Corporation Ltd. (NEDFi),
NEDFi House, G.S. Road, Dispur, Guwahati-781006, Assam.
Respondent(s)
Along with
Review Petn. 14 of 2024
The State of Tripura,
Through Secretary, Department of Revenue, Government of Tripura,
P.O – Agartala Secretariat, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.Hotel Simran Pvt. Ltd,
Represented by its Managing Director, Smt. Babita Saha, W/o Late
Subal Saha, L. N Bari Road, Agartala, P.S East Agartala, District- West
Tripura.
2. Smt. Babita Saha,
W/o Late Subal Saha.
3.Smt. Pinky Saha,
Daughter of Late Subal Saha.
4.Shri Mithun Saha,
S/o Late Subal Saha
5.Smt. Simran Saha
Daughter of Late Subal Saha
All are residents of Pratapgarh, near Ekta Club, Agartala
P.O- Agartala, P.S East Agartala, District- West Tripura.
6. Waris Finance International Ltd.
Having its local offices at Waris Bhaban, L.N Bari Road, P.O. Agartala,
P.S East Agartala, District- West Tripura, represented by its Chairmancum-Managing Director, Present Address-22 Camac Street, Block-A (1St
Floor), Kolkata-700016, West Bengal.
7.North Eastern Development Finance Corporation Ltd. (NEDFi),
NEDFi House, G.S. Road, Dispur, Guwahati-781006, Assam.
Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
For the Respondent(s) :
Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General.
Mr. R.Datta, Advocate.
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. R.R. Datta,Advocate.
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
07.08.2024
Whether fit for reporting
YES.
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
Heard Mr. S.S Dey, learned Advocate General, assisted by
Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the review petitioners. Also
heard Mr. S.M Chakraborty, learned Sr.Counsel assisted by Mr. R. R.
Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 in
Review Petition 13 of 2024 and respondent Nos. 1 to 5 in Review Petition
14 of 2024.
[2]
Since both these review petitions have been filed under
Article 215 of the Constitution of India read with Order 47 Rule 1 of the
Code of Civil Procedure for review of the common Judgment and Order
(oral) dated 01.02.2024 passed by this Hon’ble Court in CRP 95 of 2022
and CRP 76 of 2021 respectively, the same are also taken together for
disposal in a common Judgment and Order.
[3]
The review petition 13 of 2024 is filed for reviewing the
impugned order passed in CRP 95 of 2022 wherein this Court has allowed
the said CRP. The brief facts of the case in CRP 95 of 2022 were that the
predecessor-in- interest of the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 in Review Petition
13 of 2024 took loan from NEDFi, a financial institution, but he could not
repay the loan and ultimately NEDFi initiated a proceeding in Debt
Recovery Tribunal (DRT for short) against him and after his demise, it
continued against his legal heirs. The matter was settled between the
legal heirs and NEDFi and the amounts so settled was deposited by them
and consequent upon NEDFi
issued a clearance certificate
dated
06.04.2011 in favour of them. It is contended by them that the auction
process initiated by DRT also closed following the clearance of dues but
respondent No.5 i.e. Waris Finance International Ltd. managed to get
mutation for the said property by showing a purported sale certificate for
the immovable property, namely Hotel Simran Pvt. Ltd. The Revenue
Authority granted mutation in favour of them without serving any notice
upon the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 herein. When they came to know about
the said mutation, they filed a Review petition before the Collector to
review the order of mutation, but the authority concerned rejected the
prayer.
[4]
Authority
Thereafter, a Revision was filed before the Revisional
and
that
revision
was
also
dismissed
by
taking
into
consideration the purported sale certificate, issued in the name of
respondent No.5 herein. Challenging that order of Revisional Authority
(Revenue Secretary), the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 herein filed a CRP
before this Court numbered as CRP 76 of 2021 which was taken for
disposal along with this CRP 95 of 2022.
[5]
The State Government, at one point of time closed the Chit
Fund Depositors, finance business in Tripura and started taking action
against them, including the respondent No.5 herein and to refund the
deposit to the depositors, the properties of the Chit Funds were attached
in which the property of the respondent Nos.1 to 4 herein namely, Hotel
Simran Pvt. Ltd. was also attached, as the mutation was in the name of
respondent No.5 that too without any notice to the respondent Nos. 1 to
4 herein.
[6]
The Petitioner herein, Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sub-
Division- Sadar, Agartala filed a petition in the Court of learned District
Judge, West Tripura, Agartala seeking permission to sell the property in
auction, which was registered as Civil Misc (TPID) 09 of 2016, but in the
said proceedings, the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 were not made parties.
When they came to know about that judgment, they filed a Review
Petition in that Court, but the said learned Court rejected the Review
petition by taking into consideration the sale certificate ignoring the final
order of the DRT dated 25.11.2011 and the clearance certificate dated
06.04.2011 issued by NEDFi in favour of them. This Court upon hearing
the submission of the learned counsel appearing for both the parties and
on perusal of record allowed the said CRP 95 of 2022 along with CRP 76
of 2021 in a common judgment and order dated 01.02.2024.
[7]
Challenging the aforesaid order passed in CRP 95 of 2022
the review petitioner has preferred
the present review petition being
numbered as 13 of 2024. According to the review petitioner the
respondent Nos. 1 to 4 with malafide intention filed the Revision Petition
CRP 95 of 2022 before this Court and suppressed the material fact that
the attached property i.e. Hotel Simran was sold by the creditors
with
the permission of Debt Recovery Tribunal, Guwahati to the Waris Finance
International Pvt. Limited and accordingly, a sale certificate was issued in
their favour on the basis of which, record of right was created in favour of
Waris Finance International Pvt. Limited. Subsequently, when the
properties of Waris Finance International Pvt. Limited were attached by
the Government of
Tripura, the property situated at LN Bari Road,
Agartala i.e. Hotel Simran was rightly attached by the State which was
made absolute by the Learned Designated Court, West Tripura.
[8]
The review petition 14 of 2024 is filed for reviewing the
impugned order passed in CRP 76 of 2021 wherein this Court allowed the
said CRP. The case in brief is that the respondent No.1
is a private
limited company and the respondent no.2 is the Managing Director of the
said company. The predecessor-in-interest of the respondent Nos. 1 to 5
took a loan from the respondent No.7 herein, but could not liquidate it
during his lifetime. Ultimately, one proceeding was initiated by the DRT,
in which a One Time Settlement (OTS) was made and the entire settled
amount was paid by them and thereafter, the recovery proceeding was
withdrawn and a Loan Liquidation Certificate (LLC) was issued by the
respondent No.7 herein in favour of them. It was contended by the
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 that the Collector, West Tripura created a Khatian
in the name of the respondent No.6 with reference to a purported sale
certificate, which was invalid, void and nullity in all respects. After getting
information of such creation of the Khatian, when the respondent Nos. 1
to 5 filed review petition before the Collector, it was rejected. Thereafter,
a revision petition was filed to the Revenue Secretary, Government of
Tripura, but that also has been rejected without appreciating the fact
properly and without exercising his jurisdiction in accordance with law.
This Court upon hearing the submission of the learned counsel appearing
for both the parties and on perusal of record allowed the said CRP 95 of
2022 along with CRP 76 of 2021 in a common judgment and order dated
01.02.2024.
[9]
Challenging the aforesaid order passed in CRP 76 of 2021
the review petitioner has preferred
the present review petition being
numbered as 14 of 2024. According to the review petitioner the
respondent Nos. 1 to 5 with malafide intention filed the Revision Petition
CRP 76 of 2021 before this Court and suppressed the material fact that
the attached property i.e. Hotel Simran was sold by the creditors
with
the permission of DRT, Guwahati to the Waris Finance International Pvt.
Limited and accordingly, a sale certificate was issued in their favour on
the basis of which, record of right was created in favour of Waris Finance
International Pvt. Limited. Subsequently, when the properties of Waris
Finance International Pvt. Limited were attached by the Government of
Tripura, the property situated at LN Bari Road, Agartala i.e. Hotel Simran
was rightly attached by the State which was made absolute by the
Learned
Designated Court, West
Tripura. Hence, both these review
petitions.
[10]
Mr. S. S Dey, learned Advocate General appearing for the
petitioners submits that the revision petitioners i.e. Respondents (1 to 4
in Rev. Petn. 13 of 2024 and 1 to 5 in Rev. Petn. 14 of 2024 ) herein are
guilty of suppression of material facts that recovery
proceedings was
closed by the Debt Recovery Tribunal on the basis of an application vide
No. MA 24 of 2011 in OA 22 of 2005 filed by the respondent- NEDFi to
withdraw the Certificate of recovery vide No. 653 dated 01.05.2007 which
was issued
in favour
the respondent-NEDFi, as
the respondent i.e.
NEDFi had come to an amicable settlement with the credit debtors i.e. the
respondents 1 to 4 in Rev. Petn. 13 of 2024 and Respondent Nos. 1 to 5
in Rev. Petn. 14 of 2024 herein for an amount of Rs. 2,05,00,000/- only
by writing off the balance principal amount of Rs. 14,00,000/- and also
balance accrued interest, penal interest and other charges totaling to Rs.
5,32,06,615/- was waived.
[11]
Consequently the Ld. Debts Recovery Tribunal, Guwahati
allowed the petition for withdrawal of Certificate and closed the recovery
proceedings and as such it can be safely concluded that on the basis of
amicable settlement due to writing of the balance amount the recovery
proceedings was closed but the Sale certificate dated 19.01.2011 issued
in favour of Waris Finance International Private Limited was not affected
due to closure of said recovery proceedings as the settled amount of Rs.
2,05,00,000/- was paid by the creditors by settling Hotel Simran to the
Waris Finance International Private Limited as per the direction of Debts
Recovery Tribunal, Guwahati, thus the respondents 1 to 4 in Rev. Petn.
13 of 2024 and respondent Nos. 1 to 5 in Rev. Petn. 14 of 2024
herein
had no title over the property in question and had no locus to wither
challenge the mutation or taking over of property by the state.
[12]
He
further
contended
that
the
respondents
herein
(petitioners in both the CRPs) have played fraud on this Court by
suppressing facts and obtained orders and same needs to be reviewed by
dismissing their cases.
The extract of the Order passed in MA 24 of 2011 (OA 22
of 2005) dated 25.11.2011 is quoted hereunder:“I have heard the learned counsel for the misc. applicant. It has been
revealed from the above facts and circumstances of the case that the
certificate amount was to be recovered by the sale of the primary
security of Hotel Simran and other properties of the deceased gurantors.
The gurantors were also promoters and Managing Directors of the
certificate debtor company who have expired and legal heirs have been
substituted accordingly in case. The Certificate was issued on 1/5/07
and as such, this proceedings were started but no recovery could be
made till 24/4/09 and as such, a petition was filed by the certificate
debtor No.6 for permission to sell the mortgaged property but it was
rejected and thereafter another petition was filed by the same petitioner
on 5/10/09 to sell the attached property not below the reserve price of
Rs.2,03,87,000/- and Rs. 50.00 lakhs was deposited simultaneously
with a prayer to allow time to deposit the remaining amount of Rs. 1.55
lakhs which was allowed by the learned Recovery Officer and the auction
sale was not given effect to. The certificate debtor No.6 had accordingly,
deposited and amount of Rs. 2,05,00,000/- and the learned Recovery
Officer vide ordered 6/4/09 allowed her to sell the attached property this
order of the Recovery Officer has not been challned by the certificate
holder institution. That the certificate creditor had settled the account
amicably for the said amount of Rs. 2,05,00,000/- after adopting certain
rules and procedures of their institution reportedly framed as per RBI
guidelines which means that the settlement was arrived in accordance
with the conformity with the RBI guidelines as stated by the General
Maneger of the Corporation on Oath. Since the settlement was arrived
at between the parties for an amount of Rs. 2,05,00,000/- as per final
debtors and No Due Certificate has been issued by the Corporation they
prayed that the certificate be withdrawn and the recovery proceeding be
closed.
In view of the above facts and circumstances narrated by the certificate
holder institution on oath that the settlement has been arrived at in
conformity with the RBI guidelines there appears no hesitation to allow
the petition for withdrawal of the Certificate and to close the recovery
proceedings with the Recovery Officer. Accordingly, I Pass the following
order
ORDER
The Misc. Application No. 24/2011 is allowed relating to O.A No. 22/05.
The Certificate being No. DRPC No. 653 dated 1/5/07 is accordingly
withdrawn and the recovery proceeding is closed and as such, Misc.
Application No. 24/11 and also O.A No. 22/05 is disposed of finally.
Copy of this order be sent to the Recovery Officer for information and
compliance.
Copy of this order be also provided to the misc. applicant.
Consign the record to the Record Room.
Presiding Officer”.
[13]
On the contrary Mr. S.M Chakraborty, learned Sr. counsel
appearing for the respondents-Hotel Simran denied the allegation of fraud
and submits before this Court that the as per petitioners counsel
submission the amount was paid by them to DRT for settlement of the
amount and the amount so given was obtained from Waris Financial
International Ltd. if it is accepting for a while than it is a case of the
advancement of amount and if somebody advance loan to someone
he/she cannot claim the owner of the property unless it is sold. He further
submitted that whether the state has filed any sale deed because as a
private person one cannot sell property by executing a sale certificate.
Only when the auction sale is made under Sarfaesi Act, the State Financial
Corporation Act or The Financial Institution Act, the court can issue the
sale certificate. A private person cannot sell his property by issuing a sale
certificate. He also submitted that if Mrs. Babita Saha- respondent herein
sold the property to Waris Financial International Ltd. than under section
17 of the Registration Act it must be a registered sale deed but the same
is not brought by them. Thus, he prayed to dismiss the Review Petitions.
[14]
Heard the submission made at the Bar. Perused the
evidence on record.
[15]
On perusal of record, it is seen that the Learned Debt
Recovery Tribunal, Guwahati by a Judgment dated 23.02.2007 allowed the
application filed by the respondent No.7 herein whereby he has been
entitled to receive from Hotel Simran Pvt. Ltd the loan and interest
amounting to Rs.3,64,86,728/- along with @6% p. a simple interest from
08.07.2005 till realization of the entire sum due and recoverable with cost.
A certificate of recovery was also ordered to be prepared and the same
was prepared accordingly. vide No. 01.05.2007 was issued in favour of the
respondent No.7 to recover the certificate amount. For better appreciation
of the facts the relevant contents of the said judgment is extracted herein
below:
“ORDER
Hence, the Application of the Applicant is, hereby accepted and allowed
with cost ex-parte against the defendant No.1 Company and it is
hereby ordered that the Applicant is entitled to receive from defendant
No.1 the loan and interest amounting to Rs. 3,64,86,728/- (Three
Crores sixty four lakhs eighty six thousand seven hundred twenty
eight) along with interest @ 6 % p.a. simple from 8/7/2005 till the
realization of the entire sum due and recoverable with cost. The liability
of defendant No.2 to 9 are limited only to the extent, the properties
and assets of deceased two guarantors are laying in their hands.
Let a certificate of recovery be prepared in terms of provision contained
in Section 19(22) of Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial
Institutions Act, 1993. Put up for seal and signature on 27-3-2007.
Judgment pronounced in the open court on this the 23rd day of
February, 2007.”
[16]
On issuance of the certificate of recovery vide
No. 653
dated 01.05.2007 by the learned Debt Recovery Tribunal, Guwahati the
Recovery Officer of the Debt Recovery Tribunal at Guwahati proceeded for
recovery of certificate amount and by an order dated 07.05.2008 issued
attachment of the property of Hotel Simran. The respondent- Mrs.Babita
Saha herein filed an application before the Recovery Officer of the Debts
Recovery Tribunal at Guwahati for allowing her to sell Hotel Simran but the
Recovery Officer by an Order dated 06.07.2009 rejected the prayer of the
respondent-Mrs. Babita Saha for sale of Hotel Simran and by an order
dated 13.08.2009 directed for auction sale of Hotel Simran on 07.10.2009.
[17]
The Recovery Officer obtained valuation for sale of Hotel
Simran which was assessed by the valuer at Rs. 2.05 Crores and on
05.10.2009 the respondent- Mrs. Babita Saha again filed an application
before the Recovery Officer of Debt Recovery Tribunal at Guwahati for
staying
auction of the attached property and to allow her to sell the
attached
property i.e. Hotel Simran not below the reserve price of
Rs.
2.05 Crores and the respondent- Mrs. Saha deposited Rs.50,00,000/- with
the Recovery Officer and undertook to make payment of remaining 1.55
Crores within a month and accordingly, the Recovery Officer stayed the
auction sale of Hotel Simran. Thereafter, as per the order passed by DRT at
Guwahati, the respondent- Mrs. Saha on 06.04.2010, deposited the
remaining amount before the DRT, Guwahati confirmed by an order dated
06.04.2010, which is extracted herein below:“06-04-10
The case record is put up today, Certificate Debtor Smti Babita Saha is
present and deposited an amount of Rs 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs)
only vide Demand Draft No. 000459 dtd 5-4-10 (for Rs. 30 lakhs) in
favour of the Recovery Account of this Tribunal.
Applicant corporation is also present by authorized representative Shri A
Buragohain who is well aware of the fact of this case
Perused the records. As per order dated 05-10-09 of the undersigned, the
Certificate Debtor prayed for allowing her to sell the attached property
not below the reserve price as per the valuation report in order to
liquidate the amount of loan taken by her husband form the applicant
corporation
Accordingly, Smti Babita Saha has made complete payment in the
following manner.
Date
Amount deposited
05-10-09
Rs.50,00,000/22-01-12
Rs. 30,00,000/16-02-10
Rs.15,00,000/08-03-10
Rs.25,00,000/31-03-10
Rs.25,00,000/06-04-10
Rs.2,05,00,000/Contd…
[18]
It is brought to the notice
of this Court that the
respondent-M/s Waris Finance International Ltd. submitted an application
before the DRT, Guwahati and prayed for a description
of the attached
property which was purchased by them that was not reflected in the
aforesaid
order dated 06.04.2010 passed by the Recovery Officer DRT,
Guwahati. Accordingly, the learned DRT, Guwahati by an order dated
05.08.2010 mentioned the detailed description of the property purchased
by
the
respondent-M/s
Waris
Finance
International
Ltd.
from
the
respondent- Hotel Simran.
It is necessary to extract the relevant contents of the
order dated 05.08.2010 for examining the instant review petitions filed by
the petitioner:“Case record is put up today in view of Petition No.109/2010 filed
Petitioner M/S Waris Finance International Ltd. and earlier order dated
06/04/10 passed by the undersigned.
The Petitioner has prayed for a description of the attached property
which was purchased by them that was inadvertently not reflected in
order dated 06/04/10 of the undersigned.
Perused the records. It appears that Petitioner M/S Waris Finance
Internatioal Ltd. had purchased the attached property of Certificate
Debtors for an amount of Rs. 2,05,00,000/- (Rupees two crores five
lakhs) only as per order dated 06/04/10 of the undersigned.
The description of the property so purchased is as follows :
DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY AS PER VALUATION REPORT SUBMITTED
BY APPLICANT CORPORATION
A four storied RCC structural building covering an area of 0.122 acres
i.e. 5270.40 sq ft., situated at L. N Bari Road, Banamalipur, Agartala,
West Tripura, under Khatian No.4386; Sale/Gift Deed No. 1-10588
dated 21-12-2000, Mouja- Agartala Sheet No. 14, Tahasil- Sadar East
Agartala; PS- East Agartala; Dag No.- 11768/70619, 11768/70621,
11768P, Revenue Holding No. 6233;District-West Tripura,
and
bounded by:
North: H/o Smt. Ranjana Barua;
South: L. N. Bari Road;
East : H/o Dr. Prasenjti Saha
West : Gali Road.”
[19]
The aforesaid orders dated 06.04.2010 and 05.08.2010 of
the DRT Guwahati, have been brought to the notice of this Court by the
learned Advocate General. From the aforesaid orders it is seen that the
property in question i.e. Hotel Simran was sold to M/s Waris Finance
international Ltd. and the facts which have been reflected in the
aforesaid orders were suppressed by the respondents herein. Thus, this
court draws an adverse inference against the respondents and holds the
respondents herein have played fraud and obtained orders from this
Court.
[20]
Mr. S.S Dey, learned Advocate General contends that the
respondents herein committed fraud in suppressing the facts in CRPs
and as such these review petitions are maintainable. To support his
contention, learned Advocate General has placed reliance on S.P.
Chengal Varaya Naidu (Dead) By LRS Versus Jagannath (Dead)
By LRS and Others. (1994) 1 Supreme Court Cases 1) passed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The relevant paragraphs of the said
judgments as referred by the learned Advocate General are quoted
herein below:4. The High Court reversed the findings of the trial court on the
following reasonings:
"Let us assume for the purpose of argument that this document, Ex. B15, was of the latter category and the plaintiff, the benamidar,
had completely divested himself of all rights of every description. Even
so, it cannot be held that his failure to disclose the execution of Ex. B-15
would amount to collateral or extrinsic fraud. The utmost that can be
said in favour of the defendants is that a plaintiff who had no title (at
the time when the suit was filed) to the properties, has falsely asserted
title and one of the questions that would arise either expressly or by
necessary implication is whether the plaintiff had a subsisting title to the
properties. It was up to the defendants, to plead and establish by
gathering all the necessary materials, oral and documentary, that the
plaintiff had no title to the suit properties. It is their duty to obtain an
encumbrance certificate and find out whether the plaintiff had still a
subsisting title at the time of the suit. The plaintiff did not prevent the
defendants, did not use any contrivance, nor any trick nor any deceit by
which the defendants were prevented from raising proper pleas and
adducing the necessary evidence. The parties were fighting at arm's
length and it is the duty of each to traverse or question the allegations
made by the other and to adduce all available evidence regarding the
basis of the plaintiff's claim or the defence of the defendants and the
truth or falsehood concerning the same. A party litigant cannot be
indifferent, and negligent in his duty to place the materials in support of
his contention and afterwards seek to show that the case of his
opponent was false. The position would be entirely different if a party
litigant could establish that in a prior litigation his opponent prevented
him by an independent, collateral wrongful act such as keeping his
witnesses in wrongful or secret confinement, stealing his documents to
prevent him from adducing any evidence, conducting his case by tricks
and misrepresentation resulting in his misleading of the Court. Here,
nothing of the kind had happened and the contesting defendants could
have easily produced a certified registration copy of Ex. B-15 and nonsuited the plaintiff; and, it is absurd for them to take advantage of or
make a point of their own acts of omission or negligence or carelessness
in the conduct of their own defence."
The High Court further held as under:
"From this decision it follows that except proceedings for probate and
other proceedings where a duty is cast upon a party litigant to disclose
all the facts, in all other cases, there is no legal duty cast upon the
plaintiff to come to Court with a true case and prove it by true evidence.
It would cut at the root of the fundamental principle of law of finality of
litigation enunciated in the maxim 'interest reipublicae ut sit finis litium'
if it should be held that a judgment obtained by a plaintiff in a false
case, false to his knowledge, could be set aside on the ground of fraud,
in a subsequent litigation."
Finally, the High Court held as under:
"The principle of this decision governs the instant case. At the worst the
plaintiff is guilty of fraud in having falsely alleged, at the time when he
filed the suit for partition, he had subsisting interest in the property
though he had already executed Ex. B-15. Even so, that would not
amount to extrinsic fraud because that is a matter which could well have
been traversed and established to be false by the appellant by adducing
the necessary evidence. The preliminary decree in the partition suit
necessarily involves an adjudication though impliedly that the plaintiff
has a subsisting interest in the property."
5. The High Court, in our view, fell into patent error. The short question
before the High Court was whether in the facts and circumstances of this
case, Jagannath obtained the preliminary decree by playing fraud on the
court. The High Court, however, went haywire and made observations
which are wholly perverse. We do not agree with the High Court that
"there is no legal duty cast upon the plaintiff to come to court with a
true case and prove it by true evidence". The principle of "finality of
litigation" cannot be pressed to the extent of such an absurdity that it
becomes an engine of fraud in the hands of dishonest litigants. The
courts of law are meant for imparting justice between the parties. One
who comes to the court, must come with clean hands. We are
constrained to say that more often than not, process of the court is
being abused. Property-grabbers, tax-evaders, bank-loan-dodgers and
other unscrupulous persons from all walks of life find the court-process
a convenient lever to retain the illegal-gains indefinitely. We have no
hesitation to say that a person, who's case is based on falsehood, has
no right to approach the court. He can be summarily thrown out at any
stage of the litigation.”
[21]
On the question of suppression of facts Mr. S. S Dey,
learned Advocate General further placed reliance on a judgment of
Hon’ble Supreme Court in A. V. Papayya Sastry and Others vs.
Govt. of A.P. and Others (2007) 4 Supreme Court Cases 221, the
relevant paragraphs of this Judgment is quoted herein below :
“7.The State Authorities, thereafter, filed recall- applications on June 1306-2001. In the recall applications, it was stated inter alia that fraud
was committed by the land-owners and material facts were suppressed
by them. It was alleged that possession of land was never handed over
to Port Trust Authorities, nor Port Trust Authorities received such
possession of land and yet it was asserted by the owners that
possession of land was given to Port Trust Authorities in 1972 which was
not correct. It was only in December, 1985 that the correct fact came to
the knowledge of the State Authorities from a letter by the Chief
Engineer of Port Trust. Hence, the order was taken in suo motu revision
under Section 34 of the Ceiling Act. It was further stated that even if the
Port Trust Authorities would be deemed to be in possession of land on
the day the Ceiling Act came into force, Land Acquisition Proceedings
were not concluded and no award was passed. The Port Trust
Authorities, in the circumstances, would be in possession of the land for
and on behalf of the land-owners and the land was required to be
declared surplus and vacant under the Ceiling Act.
21. Now, it is well settled principle of law that if any judgment or order
is obtained by fraud, it cannot be said to be a judgment or order in law.
Before three centuries, Chief Justice Edward Coke proclaimed;
"Fraud
temporal".
avoids
all
judicial
acts,
ecclesiastical
or
22. It is thus settled proposition of law that a judgment, decree or order
obtained by playing fraud on the Court, Tribunal or Authority is a nullity
and non est in the eye of law. Such a judgment, decree or order by
the first Court or by the final Court
has to be treated as nullity by
every Court, superior or inferior. It can be challenged in any Court, at
any time, in appeal, revision, writ or even in collateral proceedings.
23. In the leading case of Lazarus Estates Ltd. v. Beasley, Lord Denning
observed: (AII ER p.345 C )
"No judgment of a court, no order of a Minister, can be
allowed to stand, if it has been obtained by fraud."
24. In Duchess of Kingstone, Smith's Leading Cases, 13th Edn., p.644,
explaining the nature of fraud, de Grey, C.J. stated that though a
judgment would be res judicata and not impeachable from within, it
might be impeachable from without. In other words, though it is not
permissible to show that the court was “mistaken”, it might be shown
that it was “misled”. There is an essential distinction between mistake
and trickery. The clear implication of the distinction is that an action to
set aside a judgment cannot be brought on the ground that it has been
decided wrongly, namely, that on the merits, the decision was one
which should not have been rendered, but it can be set aside, if the
court was imposed upon or tricked into giving the judgment.
25. It has been said; Fraud and justice never dwell together (fraus et
jus nunquam cohabitant); or fraud and deceit ought to benefit none
(fraus et dolus nemini patrocinari debent).
26. Fraud may be defined as an act of deliberate deception with the
design of securing some unfair or undeserved benefit by taking undue
advantage of another. In fraud one gains at the loss of another. Even
most solemn proceedings stand vitiated if they are actuated by fraud.
Fraud is thus an extrinsic collateral act which vitiates all judicial acts,
whether in rem or in personam. The principle of “finality of litigation”
cannot be stretched to the extent of an absurdity that it can be utilized
as an engine of oppression by dishonest and fraudulent litigants.”
[22]
On the other hand, Mr. SM Chakraborty, learned Sr.
counsel on the point of review also placed reliance on two judgments
i.e. (2023) 2 Tripura Law Reports 130, Indian Oil Corporation
Ltd. Vs. Tripur India (P) Ltd. and another i.e. (2008) 8 SCC 612,
State of West Bengal and Others. Vs. Kamal Sengupta and
Another, the relevant portion of this Judgment is quoted hereunder:“22. The term “mistake or error apparent” by its very
connotation signifies an error which is evident per se from the record of
the case and does not require detailed examination, scrutiny and
elucidation either of the facts or the legal position. If an error is not selfevident and detection thereof requires long debate and process of
reasoning, it cannot be treated as an error apparent on the face of the
record for the purpose of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC or Section 22(3)(f) of the
Act. To put it differently an order or decision or judgment cannot be
corrected merely because it is erroneous in law or on the ground that a
different view could have been taken by the Court/Tribunal on a point of
fact or law. In any case, while exercising the power of review, the
Court/Tribunal
concerned
cannot
sit
in
appeal
over
its
judgment/decision.
[23]
In view of the above discussion, this court finds force in
the argument made by the learned Advocate General and also confirms
that the respondents herein have played fraud on this Court and also
have not approached this Court with clean hands. In view of their act,
this Court feels that it is not open for the respondents to argue on
technicalities and maintainability. Therefore, the arguments of the
respondents is rejected. The respondents- i.e. (1 to 4 in Rev. Petn. 13
of 2024 and 1 to 5 in Rev. Petn. 14 of 2024 ) suppressed the facts
before this Court while arguing the CRPs.
[24]
Hence, this court is of the opinion that the order dated
01.02.2024 passed in CRPs i.e. CRP No. 95 of 2022 and CRP. No. 76 of
2021 be reviewed and the same is hereby dismissed.
Resultantly, the present review petitions stand allowed.
As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s) pending if any,
shall stand closed.
JUDGE
Paritosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review