Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.A.4 of 2025
The State of Tripura
Represented by the Secretary,
Home Department, Government of Tripura
---Appellant (s)
Versus
1. Abul Hashem,
S/o Late Ali Miah resident of Kulubari,
Ward No.4, PS: Sonamura, District: Sepahijala Tripura
2. Kurban Ali,
S/o Jurul Haque resident of Aralia,
PS: Sonamura, District: Sepahijala Tripura
---Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of hearing and date of
judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. Raju Datta, PP.
Mr. Tapash Datta Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Kingshuk Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. Dalit Kalai, Advocate.
Mr. Samar Das, Advocate.
Mr. Keneth L. Debbarma, Advocate.
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate.
30.07.2025
Yes.
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Dr. T.Amarnath Goud, J
[1]
This is an application under Section 378(1)(b) Cr.P.C
corresponding to 419(1)(b) of BNSS against the Judgement/Order dated
28.08.2024 passed by the Ld. Special Judge (NDPS), Sepahijala Tripura,
Sonamura in case No. Special (NDPS) 66 of 2022 whereby the respondentaccused person has been acquitted from charge under Section 22(C) of
NDPS Act.
[2]
It is the case of the appellant that on 06.07.2022, one suo moto
written complaint was filed by I/C Inspector Manash Paul before the O/C
Sonamura PS stating interalia that on 06.07.2022 at about 2016 hours he
received an information from his reliable sources that a huge quantity of
Yaba tablets are kept inside the vehicle bearing Registration No.TR- 01-
BM-0526 Hyundai Venue, White colour which proceeded from
Thakurmura. On receipt of the information, he immediately conveyed the
matter to O/C PS and recorded the information in writing vide Sonamura
PS GDE No.33 dated 06.07.2022. Thereafter O/C PS conveyed the matter
to SDPO Sonamura and SP C/S Sepahijala for authorization vide Sonamura
PS GD Entry No.34 dated 06.07.2022. Accordingly, SDPO Sonamura
authorized O/C PS and the complainant to conduct raid and search inside
the vehicle bearing Registration No.TR-01-BM- 0526. The complainant
along with police personnels reached the spot and identified the vehicle, one
person namely Kurban Ali managed to escape from the vehicle, however
the driver of the vehicle Abul Hashem was unable to escape and he was
detained. Thereafter, the complainant along with staff conducted search and
recovered 2200 red colour YABA tablets from the vehicle bearing
Registration No.TR-01-BM-0526 which was wrapped by grey colour
adhesive tape, which were seized and handed over to O/C Sonamura PS. On
the basis of said information, a specific case was registered vide No.
Sonamura PS case No.078 of 2022 under Section 22(C)/8/25/29 of NDPS
Act against the respondents herein. After investigation, IO submitted
Charge Sheet under Sections 22(C),8,25 and Section 29 of NDPS Act and
the Ld. Trial Court framed charge against the respondent under Section
22(C) of NDPS Act but without affording reasonable opportunity to the
prosecution to produce their witnesses, only after examining 2(two)
prosecution witnesses closed the chapter of prosecution evidence and the
Ld. Special Judge (NDPS), Sonamura, Sepahijala acquitted the respondents
from the charge framed under Section 22(C) of NDPS Act. Hence, this
Appeal.
[3]
It is contended by Mr. Raju Datta, learned PP for the state-
appellant that Ld. Court below did not consider that offence under NDPS
Act is a grave offense against the society and huge quantity of contraband
were recovered from the dwelling house of the accused and Investigation
Officer also submitted charge sheet against the accused person under the
provisions of Cr.P.C but without giving an opportunity to the prosecution to
produce their prosecution witnesses No.1, 3, 5, 6 & 7 the Ld. Trial Court
erroneously acquitted the accused Respondents. There was no necessity to
close the case of 2022 in 2024 hurriedly. Similarly around 145 NDPS cases
were acquitted by the learned trial court in a short span.
[4]
It is further contended that Ld. Trial Court did not consider the
settled principle of law that no accused can be acquitted from a criminal
liability without facing proper trial and giving reasonable opportunity to the
prosecution agency to prove their case.
[5]
To support his case, on the point of issuing summons to the
investigating officer, learned PP has relied upon Para no.9 of a judgment of
the apex court in Shailendra Kumar vs. State of Bihar and Others reported
in (2002) 1 SCC 655 where the apex court has observed as follows:
9. In our view, in a murder trial it is sordid and repulsive matter that
without informing the police station officer-in-charge, the matters are
proceeded by the Court and by the APP and tried to be disposed of as if
the prosecution has not led any evidence. From the facts stated above, it
appears that accused wants to frustrate the prosecution by unjustified
means and it appears that by one way or the other the Addl. Sessions
Judge as well as the APP have not taken any interest in discharge of
their duties. It was the duty of the Sessions Judge to issue summons to
the investigating officer if he failed to remain present at the time of trial
of the case. The presence of investigating officer at the time of trial is
must. It is his duty to keep the witnesses present. If there is failure on
part of any witness to remain present, it is the duty of the Court to take
appropriate action including issuance of bailable/non-bailable warrants
as the case may be. It should be well understood that prosecution
cannot be frustrated by such methods and victims of the crime cannot be
left in lurch.
[6]
On the point of prescribing an outer limit for conclusion of all
criminal proceedings, learned PP has relied upon Para no.29 of a judgment
of the apex court in P. Ramachandra Rao vs State of Karnataka reported
in (2002) 4 SCC 578 where the apex court has observed as follows:
29. For all the foregoing reasons, we are of the opinion that in
Common Cause case (I) (as modified in Common Cause (II) ) and
Raj Deo Sharma (I) and (II), the Court could not have prescribed
periods of limitation beyond which the trial of a criminal case or
a criminal proceeding cannot continue and must mandatorily be
closed followed by an order acquitting or discharging the
accused. In conclusion we hold:(1) The dictum in A.R. Antulay's case is correct and still holds the
field.
(2) The propositions emerging from Article 21 of the Constitution
and expounding the right to speedy trial laid down as guidelines
in A.R. Antulay's case, adequately take care of right to speedy
trial. We uphold and re-affirm the said propositions.
(3) The guidelines laid down in A.R. Antulay's case are not
exhaustive but only illustrative. They are not intended to operate
as hard and fast rules or to be applied like a strait-jacket formula.
Their applicability would depend on the fact-situation of each
case. It is difficult to foresee all situations and no generalization
can be made.
(4) It is neither advisable, nor feasible, nor judicially permissible
to draw or prescribe an outer limit for conclusion of all criminal
proceedings. The time-limits or bars of limitation prescribed in
the several directions made in Common Cause (I), Raj Deo
Sharma (I) and Raj Deo Sharma (II) could not have been so
prescribed or drawn and are not good law. The criminal courts
are not obliged to terminate trial or criminal proceedings merely
on account of lapse of time, as prescribed by the directions made
in Common Cause Case (I), Raj Deo Sharma case (I) and (II). At
the most the periods of time prescribed in those decisions can be
taken by the courts seized of the trial or proceedings to act as
reminders when they may be persuaded to apply their judicial
mind to the facts and circumstances of the case before them and
determine by taking into consideration the several relevant
factors as pointed out in A.R. Antulay's case and decide whether
the trial or proceedings have become so inordinately delayed as
to be called oppressive and unwarranted. Such time-limits cannot
and will not by themselves be treated by any Court as a bar to
further continuance of the trial or proceedings and as
mandatorily obliging the court to terminate the same and acquit
or discharge the accused.
(5) The Criminal Courts should exercise their available powers,
such as those under Sections 309, 311 and 258 of Code of
Criminal Procedure to effectuate the right to speedy trial. A
watchful and diligent trial judge can prove to be better protector
of such right than any guidelines. In appropriate cases
jurisdiction of High Court under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. and
Articles 226 and 227 of Constitution can be invoked seeking
appropriate relief or suitable directions.
(6) This is an appropriate occasion to remind the Union of India
and the State Governments of their constitutional obligation to
strengthen the judiciary-quantitatively and qualitatively by
providing requisite funds, manpower and infrastructure. We hope
and trust that the Governments shall act.
We answer the questions posed in the orders of reference dated
September 19, 2000 and April 26, 2001 in the abovesaid terms.
[7]
On the point of responsibility of the court, learned PP has
relied upon Para no.19 of a judgment of the apex court in Mina Lalita
Baruwa vs State of Orissa and Others reported in (2013) 16 SCC 173
where the apex court has observed as follows:
19. In criminal jurisprudence, while the offence is against the
society, it is the unfortunate victim who is the actual sufferer and
therefore, it is imperative for the State and the prosecution to
ensure that no stone is left unturned. It is also the equal, if not
more, the duty and responsibility of the Court to be alive and alert
in the course of trial of a criminal case and ensure that the
evidence recorded in accordance with law reflect every bit of vital
information placed before it. It can also be said that in that
process the Court should be conscious of its responsibility and at
times when the prosecution either deliberately or inadvertently
omit to bring forth a notable piece of evidence or a conspicuous
statement of any witness with a view to either support or prejudice
the case of any party, should not hesitate to interject and prompt
the prosecution side to clarify the position or act on its own and
get the record of proceedings straight. Neither the prosecution
nor the Court should remain a silent spectator in such situations.
Like in the present case where there is a wrong statement made by
a witness contrary to his own record and the prosecution failed to
note the situation at that moment or later when it was brought to
light and whereafter also the prosecution remained silent, the
Court should have acted promptly and taken necessary steps to
rectify the situation appropriately. The whole scheme of the Code
of Criminal Procedure envisages foolproof system in dealing with
a crime alleged against the accused and thereby ensure that the
guilty does not escape and innocent is not punished. It is with the
above background, we feel that the present issue involved in the
case on hand should be dealt with.
[8]
On the point applicability of Section 87 of the Cr.PC, learned
PP has relied upon Para no.4 of a judgment of Calcutta High Court in
Prodyut Kumar Baidya vs Smt. Chaya Rani Baidya and Anr. reported in
1995 SCC OnLine Cal 3 where the apex court has observed as follows:
4. Heard the submissions of the ld. Advocates appearing for the
parties. Considered the materials on record. From the impugned
order it appears that the Sub-Postmaster, Katihar Post Office and
Head of Post-Office were served with the summons and they
received the same. In spite of receipt of the summons, the SubPostmaster, Katihar Post Office failed and neglected to appear
before the Court in answer to the summons. The ld. Magistrate
sought to have taken steps according to law for securing the
presence' of the witnesses before him. Instead of doing the same,
he simply avoided it saying that the matter is a quasi-civil in
nature and it is duty of the person who cited them as witnesses to
secure his presence before the Court. The part that is to be
performed by the party who cites a witness is to deposit the
requisite and if on his prayer the summons are issued then it
becomes the duty of the court to secure the presence of that
witnesses if the summons are served upon that witness as the fiat
of the court has not been complied with. In the instant case, upon
the prayer of the party summons were issued and served upon the
witnesses but they ignored the summons and failed to appear
before the court. In such circumstances, the court is to take steps
for securing their presence before the court as contemplated
under the Cr. P.C. The ld. Magistrate is, accordingly, directed to
take appropriate steps to secure the presence of the said witnesses
before the court and for that he may consider the exercise of his
power under Section 87 of the Cr. P.C. 1973.
[9]
In the course of his argument, the learned Public Prosecutor
drew the attention of this Court to the fact that as many as 145 cases exist in
which the accused persons were acquitted without providing a proper
opportunity to the prosecution. It was also brought to the notice of this
Court that in many of these cases, the public prosecutors assigned to them
were reported to have resigned following such acquittals. He finally prayed
before this court to allow his appeal by setting aside the impugned judgment
of the learned court below.
[10]
On the other hand Mr. T.D Majumder, learned senior counsel
for the accused-respondents has contended before this court that impugned
order as challenged by the state-appellant is just and proper and needs no
interference from this court. By way of filing an objection petition against
the special leave petition being Crl.L.P 01 of 2025 preferred by the stateappellant, Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel has drawn the attention of
this court to the Para no.4 and 5 of the accompanying affidavit which read
as under:
4. That the Ld. Special Judge, after due consideration of the
prosecution's evidence, rightly concluded that there was no
evidence to substantiate the charges against the respondents. The
prosecution examined only two witnesses out of the seven cited,
and their testimonies, as recorded in Annexures 1 and 2, failed to
establish any incriminating facts against the respondents. PW-1
(Dy.SP Manik Debnath) merely confirmed procedural aspects of
registering the case, while PW-2 (Bikash Bhowmik) explicitly
stated he knew nothing about the case. Such evidence is wholly
insufficient to sustain a conviction under the stringent provisions
of the NDPS Act.
5. That the appellant's contention that the Ld. Special Judge
illegally closed the prosecution evidence is misconceived. The
case records (Annexures 5, 6, 7, and 8) clearly show that the
prosecution was granted multiple opportunities to produce its
witnesses on 10.04.2024, 20.07.2024, 22.07.2024, and
29.07.2024. Despite these opportunities, the prosecution failed to
ensure the presence of key witnesses, including the complainant
(CSPW No. 1) and other cited witnesses (CSPWs No. 3, 5, 6, and
7). The Ld. Special Judge's decision to close the prosecution
evidence on 29.07.2024 was in accordance with law, as the
prosecution's repeated failure to produce witnesses cannot be
attributed to the court or the respondents.
[11]
Finally, it is contended by the counsel for the respondents that
the decision of the learned Special Judge to close the prosecution evidence
on July 29, 2024, was not arbitrary but was a just and lawful exercise of
judicial discretion in response to the prosecution's repeated and persistent
failure to produce its witnesses. Such inaction on the part of the prosecution
cannot, and should not, be attributed to the court or to the respondents. The
learned Trial Court, by closing the evidence, merely ensured that the trial
progressed in a timely manner, preventing unwarranted delays caused solely
by the prosecution's lethargy.
[12]
He further stated that the learned Special Judge's judgment of
acquittal is a reflection of the prosecution's failure to adduce any credible or
incriminating evidence, coupled with its repeated inability to produce its
witnesses despite numerous opportunities. The impugned judgment is sound
in law and fact, and therefore, this Court is humbly urged to dismiss the
appeal and uphold the acquittal of the respondents.
[13]
Heard and perused the record.
[14]
The trial court took cognizance of the matter and framed
charges against the accused-appellant on 20.09.2023. The prosecution
presented its case by examining two witnesses. The first, PW-1 Deputy
Superintendent of Police Manik Debnath, and the second, PW-2 Bikash
Bhowmik, an independent witness, both provided testimony which was
duly recorded. For ready reference, the court proceedings dated 20.09.2023
is extracted herein below:
“The accused persons namely Abul Hossain and Kurban Ali on
bail are present along with their engaged Ld. Counsel.
Ld. Special P.P is present.
Heard Ld. Counsels of both sides on the framing of charge.
Upon hearing of both sides, this Court finds there is prima facie
case for framing of charge under Section 22(C) of NDPS Act
against accused person namely Abul Hossain and Kurban Ali.
Accordingly, charge has been framed under Section 22(C) of
NDPS Act against accused person namely Akter Hossain and
Kurban Ali and the contents of the same is read over and
explained to them to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to
be tried.
Office is directed to issue summons upon the complainant and RO
of this case.
After examination of complainant and RO the complete calendar
shall be fixed.
Fix 10.04.2024 for Pws(CSW No.1 & 4).”
[15]
However, after reviewing the evidence presented, the trial
court found it to be insufficient. Consequently, in its order dated
28.08.2024, the trial court acquitted the accused, Abul Hashem and Kurban
Ali, of the charges under Section 22(C) of the IPC, concluding that there
was no evidence on which a conviction could be based. For ready reference,
the court proceedings dated 20.07.2004, 22.07.2024, 29.2024 and
28.08.2024 are extracted herein below:
20.07.2024
The accused person namely Abul Hossain and Kurban Ali on bail
are present along with their respective engaged Ld. Counsels.
Ld. Special P.P is present with one witness namely Bikash
Bhowmik, he is examined, cross-examined as PW-02 and
discharged.
No other witness is present.
No service report received.
To-date-fixed (22.07.2024) for Pws.
22.07.2024
The accused person namely Abul Hossain and Kurban Ali on bail
are present along with their respective engaged Ld. Counsels.
Ld. Special P.P is present.
Today the case record is listed for Pws.
No witness is present.
No service report returned regarding the witnesses.
On perusal of the case record the last two occasions order dated
10.04.2024 prosecution was given last chance to produce the
remaining witnesses but he he failed to produce the witnesses and
he also admitted failed to produce the witnesses.
Ld. P.P. verbally prays for short adjournment for deposition of
the witnesses.
Heard and considered.
Prayer is allowed for the last opportunity failing which the
prosecution evidence will be closed as it is a long pending case.
Inform.
Fix 29.07.2024 for Pws (1, 3,5,6 & 7).
29.07.2024
Today the case record is listed for Pws.
The accused person namely Abul Hossain and Kurban Ali on bail
are present along with their respective engaged Ld. Counsels.
Ld. Special PP is present.
No witness is present today.
Prosecution was given last chance for producing the witnesses
today with direction that if he fails to produce the witnesses the
evidence of prosecution witnesses will be closed.
As prosecution has failed to produce the witnesses, on verbal
submission of Ld. Special PP the evidence of prosecution
witnesses is hereby closed.
Accused is directed to remain present on the next date and furnish
bail bond in compliance of Section 437A of Cr.P.C on the next
date without fail.
Fix 13.08.2024 for examination of accused person u/s 313 of
Cr.P.C/execution of bail bond.
28.08.2024
Bailed out accused persons namely Abul Hassem and Kurban Ali
are present along with their Ld. defence counsels.
Ld. PP Mr. M. Sen is present for the state.
Today the date was fixed for examination of the accused person
under section 313 of Cr.PC/ furnishing of bail bond under section
437A of Cr.PC.
Bail bond submitted on behalf of the accused person Kurban Ali
in compliance of section 437A of Cr.PC which is checked, found
correct and accepted.
From the record, I find that, it is a case of no evidence.
Hence, I proceed to conclude this case in exercising power under
section 232 of Cr.PC to make an order of acquittal.
In this case charges were framed against the accused persons on
20.09.2023 under sections 22(C) of IPC.
In course examined 2 witnesses.
PW.1 Dy.SP Manik Debnath in his evidence deposed that on
07.07.2022 at about 1.48. hours he received one written
complaint of one Sri Manash Paul, Inspector of police and
registered the same as SNM PS case No.78/2022 under section
22(C)/08/25/29 of NDPS Act and witness identified the received
endorsement on the body of the written ejahar and also identified
the Printed FIR form along with signature which are marked and
exhibit. PW.1 also identified his signature in the seizure list and in
the presearch memo which is marked and exhibit. PW.2 Bikash
Bhowmik is an independent witness and and nothing made out
from their evidences in support of prosecution case.
In the aforesaid circumstances, there cannot and should not be
any doubt that it is a case of no evidence at all for which all the
accused persons desires to be acquitted from the instant
prosecution.
In the result, the accused persons namely, Abul Hassem and
Kurban Ali are hereby acquitted from the charges under sections
22(C) of IPC.
Seized alamats, if any be destroyed / released after expiry of
appeal period.
The case is disposed of on contest.
Make necessary entry in the relevant TR and CIS
Pronounced in the open court.
[16]
To deal with the case, this court thinks it apposite to extract
herein below Sections 67, 87, 230 and 242 of Cr.PC.
67. Service of summons outside local limits: When a Court desires
that a summons issued by it shall be served at any place outside
its local jurisdiction, it shall ordinarily send summons in
duplicate to a Magistrate within whose local jurisdiction the
person summoned resides, or is, to be there served.
87. Issue of warrant in lieu of, or in addition to, summons.
- A Court may, in any case in which it is empowered by this Code
to issue a summons for the appearance of any person, issue, after
recording its reasons in writing, a warrant for his arrest (a) if either before the issue of such summons, or after the issue of
the same but before the time fixed for his appearance, the Court
has reason to believe that he has absconded or will not obey the
summons;
(b) if at such time he fails to appear and the summons is proved to
have been duly served in time to admit of his appearing in
accordance therewith and no reasonable excuse is offered for
such failure.
230. Date for prosecution evidence.
- If the accused refuses to plead, or does not plead, or claims to
be tried or is not convicted under Section 229, the Judge shall fix
a date for the examination of witnesses, and may, on the
application of the prosecution, issue any process for compelling
the attendance of any witness or the production of any document
or other thing.
242. Evidence for prosecution
(1)If the accused refuses to plead or does not plead, or claims to
be tried or the Magistrate does not convict the accused under
section 241 the Magistrate shall fix a date for the examination of
witnesses.
(2)The Magistrate may, on the application of the prosecution,
issue a summons to any of its witnesses directing him to attend or
to produce any document or other thing,
(3)On the date so fixed, the Magistrate shall proceed to take all
such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution;
Provided that the Magistrate may permit the cross-examination of
any witness to be deferred until any other witness or witnesses
have been examined or recall any witness for further crossexamination.
[17]
The learned Public Prosecutor's submission regarding the
alarming number of 145 acquittals in NDPS cases without proper
opportunity to the prosecution and the subsequent resignations of public
prosecutors further underscores the systemic issues at play, which warrant
immediate rectification to uphold the integrity of the judicial process. The
cases pertaining to 2022 were disposed of in 2024 in a hurried manner,
which was not warranted.
[18]
In light of the fundamental principle that a fair trial is
paramount to ensuring justice, this Court notes with concern the Trial
Court's premature closure of the prosecution's evidence. The Apex Court's
pronouncements are unequivocal Shailendra Kumar (supra) mandates the
trial court's imperative duty to secure the presence of the Investigating
Officer and other crucial witnesses, even resorting to coercive measures like
warrants, to prevent the frustration of justice. This critical responsibility
was evidently not discharged in the present case, as the prosecution was
denied the opportunity to present its full evidence. For ready reference, the
same is extracted herein below:
9. In our view, in a murder trial it is sordid and repulsive matter that
without informing the police station officer-in-charge, the matters are
proceeded by the Court and by the APP and tried to be disposed of as if
the prosecution has not led any evidence. From the facts stated above, it
appears that accused wants to frustrate the prosecution by unjustified
means and it appears that by one way or the other the Addl. Sessions
Judge as well as the APP have not taken any interest in discharge of
their duties. It was the duty of the Sessions Judge to issue summons to
the investigating officer if he failed to remain present at the time of trial
of the case. The presence of investigating officer at the time of trial is
must. It is his duty to keep the witnesses present. If there is failure on
part of any witness to remain present, it is the duty of the Court to take
appropriate action including issuance of bailable/non-bailable warrants
as the case may be. It should be well understood that prosecution
cannot be frustrated by such methods and victims of the crime cannot be
left in lurch.
[19]
Further, the decision to terminate the trial due to the mere lapse
of time stands contrary to the dictum in P. Ramachandra Rao (supra),
which firmly establishes that no rigid outer limit can be prescribed for the
conclusion of criminal proceedings, particularly if such termination stifles
the prosecution's ability to prove its case. The Trial Court's role, as clarified
in Mina Lalita Baruwa (supra), is not that of a silent spectator; rather, it
has an active duty to ensure all relevant evidence is brought forth and to
intervene when necessary. This inherent judicial responsibility was not
upheld. For ready reference, the same is extracted herein below:
19. In criminal jurisprudence, while the offence is against the
society, it is the unfortunate victim who is the actual sufferer and
therefore, it is imperative for the State and the prosecution to
ensure that no stone is left unturned. It is also the equal, if not
more, the duty and responsibility of the Court to be alive and alert
in the course of trial of a criminal case and ensure that the
evidence recorded in accordance with law reflect every bit of vital
information placed before it. It can also be said that in that
process the Court should be conscious of its responsibility and at
times when the prosecution either deliberately or inadvertently
omit to bring forth a notable piece of evidence or a conspicuous
statement of any witness with a view to either support or prejudice
the case of any party, should not hesitate to interject and prompt
the prosecution side to clarify the position or act on its own and
get the record of proceedings straight. Neither the prosecution
nor the Court should remain a silent spectator in such situations.
Like in the present case where there is a wrong statement made by
a witness contrary to his own record and the prosecution failed to
note the situation at that moment or later when it was brought to
light and whereafter also the prosecution remained silent, the
Court should have acted promptly and taken necessary steps to
rectify the situation appropriately. The whole scheme of the Code
of Criminal Procedure envisages foolproof system in dealing with
a crime alleged against the accused and thereby ensure that the
guilty does not escape and innocent is not punished. It is with the
above background, we feel that the present issue involved in the
case on hand should be dealt with.
[20]
Moreover, the principle from Prodyut Kumar Baidya (supra)
reinforces the court's obligation to secure witness presence once summons
are served. For ready reference, the same extracted herein below:
4. Heard the submissions of the ld. Advocates appearing for the
parties. Considered the materials on record. From the impugned
order it appears that the Sub-Postmaster, Katihar Post Office and
Head of Post-Office were served with the summons and they
received the same. In spite of receipt of the summons, the SubPostmaster, Katihar Post Office failed and neglected to appear
before the Court in answer to the summons. The ld. Magistrate
sought to have taken steps according to law for securing the
presence' of the witnesses before him. Instead of doing the same,
he simply avoided it saying that the matter is a quasi-civil in
nature and it is duty of the person who cited them as witnesses to
secure his presence before the Court. The part that is to be
performed by the party who cites a witness is to deposit the
requisite and if on his prayer the summons are issued then it
becomes the duty of the court to secure the presence of that
witnesses if the summons are served upon that witness as the fiat
of the court has not been complied with. In the instant case, upon
the prayer of the party summons were issued and served upon the
witnesses but they ignored the summons and failed to appear
before the court. In such circumstances, the court is to take steps
for securing their presence before the court as contemplated
under the Cr. P.C. The ld. Magistrate is, accordingly, directed to
take appropriate steps to secure the presence of the said witnesses
before the court and for that he may consider the exercise of his
power under Section 87 of the Cr. P.C. 1973.
[21]
The cumulative effect of these judicial pronouncements leads
this Court to conclude that the Trial Court's actions constitute a clear
deviation from established norms, resulting in a miscarriage of justice that
warrants the setting aside of the impugned judgment.
[22]
This Court must remind the trial court of its powers and duties
under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, as well as the Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. Section 67 of the NDPS Act deals
with the power to call for information, which is often a critical piece of
evidence. The trial court's duty to secure the presence of the witnesses who
can testify to such information is thus integral to the prosecution's case.
Under Section 242 of the Cr.P.C., the court is to proceed to hear the
prosecution and take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the
prosecution. This is the stage where the prosecution is to be given a fair and
complete opportunity. Furthermore, Section 230 of the Cr.P.C. expressly
mandates the judge to fix a date for the examination of witnesses and to
issue process for compelling their attendance upon the prosecution's
application. Finally, Section 87 of the Cr.P.C. provides the necessary legal
mechanism, allowing the court to issue a warrant for a person's arrest in
addition to, or in lieu of, a summons, if there is reason to believe the person
has absconded or will not obey the summons, or fails to appear despite due
service. The trial court's inaction in utilizing these statutory powers to
ensure a full and fair trial for the State led to a miscarriage of justice that
cannot be sustained.
[23]
In light of the foregoing, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the learned Trial Court gravely erred in acquitting the
respondents without providing a fair and reasonable opportunity to the
prosecution to lead its evidence. The impugned judgment has resulted in a
miscarriage of justice and cannot be sustained.
[24]
Therefore, the Judgment/Order dated 28.08.2024 passed by the
Ld. Special Judge (NDPS), Sepahijala Tripura, Sonamura in case No.
Special (NDPS) 66 of 2022 is hereby set aside.
[25]
The matter is remanded back to the learned Special Judge
(NDPS), Sonamura, Sepahijala, with a direction to conduct a fresh trial by
calling upon all the witnesses of the prosecution. However, it is made clear
that if the parties want to rely upon the earlier evidence on record, in that
case, the learned Special Judge may examine the rest unexamined witnesses
and deliver a fresh judgment in accordance with law by affording all
opportunities to the parties. The same trial shall also be completed as
expeditiously as possible.
[26]
The appeal is accordingly allowed. As a sequel, stay, if any,
stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any, also stands closed.
[27]
The respondents are hereby directed to surrender before the
concerned Trial Court on or before 20.08.2025. Upon their surrender, the
Trial Court may consider bail application filed by them in accordance with
law.
[28]
It is needless to observe that, in the event the accused persons
are on bail pending trial, the benefit shall be extended to them.
B.Palit, J
Dipak
DIPAK DAS
DIPAK DAS
Date: 2025.08.07
16:34:43 +05'30'
Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review