The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. 09.2021 it is clear that on agreement of learned counsel of both sides the writ petition was disposed of. Counsel also contends that the impugned order was passed way back on 10.09.2021 and the review petition has been filed after a long delay in 2023. Accordingly, he submits that the review petition is not maintainable on the ground of delay and prays for dismissal of the same. [19] In view of above discussion, this Court feels it apposite to discuss Order-47 Rule-1 of the CPC which reads thus: “3. Order 47 deals with the procedure with respect to the disposal of such applications for review. Rule 1 of this Order, however, mentions in Sub-rule (1) not only the grounds on which an application for review of judgment can be filed, but also the decree or orders against which such an application can be filed by a person considering himself aggrieved by the decree or order. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 1 of this Order mentions the special circumstances in which a person who has not appealed may apply for review of judgment even after an appeal has been filed by any other party. Its proper place should have been in Section 114. Rule 1 mentions the decrees and orders against which a review application can be filed, presumably on account of its being a reproduction of Section 623 of the earlier Code of Civil Procedure, Act 14[xiv] of 1882.” [20] In a case of Behari Lal And Anr. v. M.M. Gobardh…
9. Section 114, Clause (a) does not say directly that a review application must be filed before the filing of the appeal but allows a person to file an application for review of judgment if a person feels aggrieved by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed by this Code, but from which no appeal has been preferred. The section really does not lay down a condition precedent to the filing of a review application but enunciates the circumstances in which an applicant may ask for review, the circumstances being mentioned in Clauses (a), (b) and (c). In this view of the matter, it would follow very clearly that once an appeal is filed, there is no right in the applicant to seek review of the judgment in appeal and there is no jurisdiction in the Court to deal with the review application which has become incompetent. After the filing of the appeal, it cannot be said that the applicant is aggrieved by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed by this Code, but from which no appeal has been preferred.” [21] The review petition is a petition in which it is prayed before the Court of law to review its order or judgment which it has already pronounced. The Court may accept a review petition when a glaring omission or patent mistake or like grave error has crept in earlier by judicial fallibility. When a review takes place, the Court will not take fresh stock of the case but…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Review Pet. No.15/2023
The State of Tripura and others
----Petitioner(s)
Versus
Smt. Ratna Rani Debnath and others
-----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. B. Majumder, CGC
Mr. D. Sarkar, Advocate.
Along with
Cont.Cas(C) No.98/2022
Smt. Ratna Rani Debnath and another
----Petitioner(s)
Versus
Chandni Chandran, IAS
-----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. D. Sarkar, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
Whether fit for report
: Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
: YES
Final order dated 4th April, 2023
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
The present review petition and the contempt case are taken up
together since they arise in common background and would be disposed of
by this common judgment.
[2]
Heard Mr. Mangal Debbarma, learned Addl. Government
Advocate appearing for the review petitioners. Also heard Mr. Somik Deb,
learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents No.1 to 3-petitioners and Mr. Biswanath Majumder,
learned CGC appearing for the respondent No.4-Union of India.
[3]
This review petition is filed by the review petitioners under
Order XLVII Rule 1 read with Section 114 of the Code of Civil Procedure
and Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking review of the order
dated 10.09.2021 passed by this Court in WP(C) No.1548 of 2017.
[4]
The brief facts of the case is that the respondent-writ petitioners
are the part-time teachers of Kasturba Gandhi Balika Vidyalaya (KGBV, for
short) under SSA and they have completed 7 to 9 years of service without
any regularization. They claimed that since the teachers under the SSA were
given regularization by the directions of this Court, they being similarly
situated to those SSA teachers are also entitled for regularization. This Court
vide order dated 10.09.2021 passed order in their favour being covered by
the decision of Division Bench of this Court dated 23.02.2021 in case of
Shri Sajal Deb vrs. The State of Tripura and others in WP(C) No.329 of
2015 and connected petition. But the review petitioners claimed that the writ
petitioners were not similarly situated as that of the SSA teachers.
Accordingly, they preferred this review petition.
[5]
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the review petitioners, contends that in the Sajal Deb case
(supra), the SSA teachers were contract teachers but in the present case the
writ petitioners are part-time teachers. Referring to a memorandum dated
28.04.2010 issued by the Addl. State Project Director, SSA Rajya Mission,
learned counsel has also pointed out the difference between the fulltime
teachers and part-time teachers contending that the fulltime teachers of
KGBVs will have to take classes in schools whereas the part-time teachers
shall take classes in the hostel, not in schools. Accordingly, he prays for
review of the order dated 10.09.2021 passed by this Court in WP(C)
No.1548 of 2017.
[6]
He has further submitted that a group of contract teaches
appointed under SSA have filed writ petitions seeking regularization of their
service and accordingly, writ petitions have been allowed by this Court with
certain directions to the State Government. For the purpose of reference, the
operative portion of the judgment and order dated 23.02.2021 passed in
WP(C) No.329 of 2015 may be reproduced hereunder:
“53. We are, therefore, of the view that the petitioners must receive the
remuneration in regular scale of pay assigned to the primary/upper primary
Government teachers. The State Government also has a policy of initial
appointment of a teacher on fixed pay basis for a period of 5 years. The same
rule can be applied in the present case also. In case of all the petitioners thus
from the date of the petitions or upon completion of 5 years of service
whichever is later, they shall be placed in regular corresponding scales of pay
for the Government teachers. However, this pay fixation would be for a
notional purpose from the appropriate date till the date of this judgment, of
course with notional release of increments as per the rules. Actual difference
in salary would be paid effective from the date of this judgment.
54. The petitioners would have a right to be regularised after 10 years of
continuous and uninterrupted engagement from initial appointment. It would
be up to the Government to consider them for regularisation either in existing
vacant posts of Government teachers or to sanction new posts as SSA
teachers by creating such cadre if so advised. It would be open for the
Government to frame a scheme providing for further terms and conditions on
which such regularisation shall be done. However, any such scheme shall
contain a clause that the service upon completion of 5 years from initial
engagement or the date of filing the petition whichever is later, (when as per
this judgment the petitioners would notionally start receiving pay in regular
scales) till date of regularisation, the services rendered by the petitioners shall
count towards their pensionary benefits.
55. We are conscious of the legal issues concerning regular teachers in the
Government schools which is a fall out of the Division Bench judgment of
this Court in case of Tanmoy Nath and others vrs. State of Tripura and others
reported in (2014) 2 TLR 731, whereas per further orders passed by the
Supreme Court, all those teachers who were terminated on account of the
judgment of the High Court, would have a right to compete for fresh
selections with age relaxation granted to them up to 31.03.2023. We have,
therefore, left for the Government to regularize these petitioners either against
the existing posts or on new posts which may be sanctioned.
56. These directions shall be carried out within a period of six months from
today.
57. As noted in WP(C) No.329 of 2015 petitioners espouse the cause of the
class of teachers through the association. In any case, the nature of disputes
and our consideration are for the entire cadre. This judgment, therefore, shall
act as a judgment in rem and will apply to all similarly situated SSA teachers
without any of them having to approach the Court separately.
58. Writ petitions are disposed of accordingly. Pending application(s), if any,
also stands disposed of.”
[7]
A group of part time teachers who were engaged on contractual
basis for KGBV hostels under a separate component of SSA in different
years have filed writ petition for regularization of their service in view of
the judgment of Shri Sajal Deb (supra) and allowed the petition on the
ground that the substantive issues raised in the writ petition are squarely
covered by the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court dated
23.02.2021.
[8]
After passing the said order dated 10.09.2021 in WP(C)
No.1548 of 2017by this Court which is under review, while scrutinized in
department some new facts have been detected which were not placed by
the respondents before the Court at the time of adjudication of the case and
these facts are necessary to be discussed.
[9]
Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the State-
respondents has submitted that after passing the order in Sajal Deb case
(supra), and in compliance of the verdict, the State Government had
formulated a new scheme vide notification dated 30 th September, 2021
whereby the Government has categorized three categories of teachers for
regularization of the SSA teachers in the following manner:
“i. Category-I: Those SSA Teacher who have been qualified in the T-TET and
have not joined as regular teacher till 23.02.2021;
i. Category-II: Who appointed on or after 03.09.2001 but prior to 23.08.2010,
with minimum qualifications in accordance with NCTE (determination of
minimum qualifications for recruitment of teachers in schools) regulation,
2001, as amended from time to time at the time of recruitment; and
iii. Category-III : SSA Contract teachers who will not be covered under the
Category-I & II, i.e. Category –III (A)-SSA Contract teachers who as on date
possess the requisite academic and professional qualification (D.EI.Ed/B.Ed)
but have not clared T-TET , category6-III (B)-SSA contract teachers who as
on date have not acquired the professional qualification (D.EI.Ed/B.Ed) and
neither have cleared T-TET and category –III (C)-SSA contract teachers who
have not yet acquired the requisite academic qualification (i.e. Class-XII
passed with 50% marks for getting admission in professional qualification
course (D.EI.Ed/B.Ed.) and neither have cleared T-TET. All the original
petitioners are not covered under this new scheme formulated by the
Government.”
[10]
The State Government had also segregated the job nature of
both the posts appointed under SSA and part time teacher engaged for
DGBV hostels with the following differences are given below:
Indicator
Eligibility criteria
as
Recruitment Notification
Terms
&
engagement
Conditions
Existing rate of remuneration
per
of
Upper primary contract teacher
As per a Recruitment notification
issued for filling up posts of
Upper
Primary
Contract
Teachers under SSA, the
minimum
educational
qualification mandated for the
post is observed to be Graduation
(BA/B.Sc)
1) The engagement shall be of
only 1 (one) year on a fixed
monthly honorarium as given
above (as per rate given in the
engagement letter).
2) The person so engaged shall
be
terminated
from
the
engagement automatically on
expiry of 1(one) year from the
date of engagement.
3)
Continuation
of
the
engagement for another year
shall be subject to satisfactory
performance of the person in the
1st year of engagement.
KGBV Part Time Teacher
As per a Recruitment notification
given for filling up posts of Part
Time Teachers for KGBV under
SSA, the minimum educational
qualification mandated for the
post is observed to be Graduation
(BA/B.Sc/B.Com).
@.27,711/- (completed 5 years)
Rs.10,000/- vide Memo dated
1) The engagement shall be of
only 1 (one) year on a fixed
monthly honorarium as given
above (as per rate given in the
engagement letter).
2) The person so engaged shall
be
terminated
from
the
engagement automatically on
expiry of 1(one) year from the
date of engagement.
3)
Continuation
of
the
engagement for another year
shall be subject to satisfactory
performance of the person.
Leave Provision
Job Description
Salary Head
[11]
vide Memo dated 08.01.2018
1. Special Leave-10 days in a
completed calendar year vide
Notification dated 22.05.2012.
2. Maternity leave-180 days vide
notification dated 20.06.2012.
3. Medical Leave-5 days in a
calendar year vide notification
dated 19.07.2011.
4. Paternity leave-7 days vide
notification dated 24.06.2013.
5. Quarantine Leave-21 days (30
days
under
exceptional
circumstances) vide notification
dated 08.10.2015.
6. Casual Leave-12 days in a
calendar year vide Memo dated
19.07.2011.
They impart teaching at par with
departmental teachers in schools.
Expenditure
towards
remuneration is incurred from
Salary Head of SSA Contract
Teacher (Upper Primary).
16.11.2019.
12 days casual leave in a
calendar vide Memo dated
16.07.2015.
As per Memo dated 17.08.2015,
they are required to take classes
in the hostel twice daily i.e. in
the morning (6.30 am to 8.30 am)
and evening (5.30pm to 7.30pm)
and also take extra co-curricular
activities like sports, cultural
activities, gardening etc. twice a
week.
Expenditure
towards
remuneration is incurred from
Salary
Head of Part-Time
Teacher
under
KGBV
component of Samagra Shiksha.
The case of the petitioners is not squarely covered with the case
of the Sri Sajal Deb (supra) and would not apply in rem in the case of the
petitioners because of the fact that all part time teachers of KGBV hostel
were engaged only for fulfilling the interim measures under a component
scheme of SSA on the basis of Walk-in-Interviews without following the
basic recruitment rules for public employment and reservation policy of
State, even there is not accorded sanctioned posts of KGBV teachers for
hostels in the State as like as Teachers under SSA.
[12]
The policy of the State government in the matter of
regularization after a period of five years is followed in different context,
wherein, who appointed in Group-C and Group-D posts on fixed pay basis
by keeping abeyance the concerned regular pay scale posts, in that event,
after completion of five years they will be regularized. But, in the case of
the petitioners, there is no regular posts created by the State in the name of
Teacher for KGBV hostels.
[13]
Their salaries and other minor facilities were provided through
a fund under a component scheme of SSA. Though, the government has
decided to implement the verdict of this Court in the matter of the teachers
appointed under SSA. However, it would not be possible on the part of the
State Government that such extra huge financial burden should bear by the
government alone as the scheme was launched by the Union Government of
India and therefore, the Union government should fix financial liabilities in
the matter of regularization of those employees who were engaged under
different schemes of the Central Government.
[14]
Job nature of the contract teachers under SSA (now Samagra
Shiksha) and Part-Time Teacher for KGBV Hostels are quite different.
Contract teachers engaged under SSA are rendering teaching duties in
schools likewise other Government teachers and part time teachers engaged
for KGBV are rendering part time teaching duties in KGBV hostels only.
leave provisions and job descriptions of the part time teacher engaged in
KGBV hostels are also different from the engaged of Contract Teacher
under SSA and fund is placed for KGBV as a separate component under
SSA.
[15]
He has further contended that the scheme i.e. Kasturba Gandhi
Balika Vidyalay (KGBV) is being implemented in educationally backward
blocks (EBBs) of the country where the female rural literacy is below the
national average and gender gap in literacy is above the national average.
The scheme was launched by the government of India in August, 2004 for
setting up residential schools at upper primary level for girls belonging
predominantly to the SC, ST, OBC and minorities in difficult areas.
[16]
The KGBV has been merged with the SSA programme as a
separate component of that programme during the XIth Five Year Plan since
1st April, 2007 under RTE-SSA Annual Work Plan & Budget which is a
Central Government Scheme run under MHRD, Government of India and
the fund sharing pattern for the scheme between central and States is at
present in the ratio of 90:10. The job of teaching in KGBVs is done by the
teachers who are temporary or hired on temporary/contractual basis. The
scheme provides options for establishment of residential schools or the
addition of a girl’s hostel facility to an existing upper primary school. Three
different models with separate unit costs based or the number of girls has
been provided. Model-I new school + residential facility for 100 girls,
Model-II new school + residential facility for 50 girls, Model -III addition of
hostel facility to an existing upper primary school for 50 girls.
[17]
It is to be mentioned herein, that Model-III has been adopted by
the State of Tripura wherein as many as 32 part time teachers were engaged
as of now throughout the State and the petitioners were engaged under
Model-III norms of the component of SSA wherein addition of hostel
facility to an existing upper primary school for 50 girls is required in the
school. The Governing Council of SSA, Rajya Mission, Tripura has also
been revised with enhanced remuneration of various categories of staffs
under KGBV, vide notification dated 22.08.2022 including the service of
the petitioners.
[18]
On the other hand, Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
No.1 to 3-writ petitioners, contends that from the impugned order dated
10.09.2021 it is clear that on agreement of learned counsel of both sides the
writ petition was disposed of. Counsel also contends that the impugned
order was passed way back on 10.09.2021 and the review petition has been
filed after a long delay in 2023. Accordingly, he submits that the review
petition is not maintainable on the ground of delay and prays for dismissal
of the same.
[19]
In view of above discussion, this Court feels it apposite to
discuss Order-47 Rule-1 of the CPC which reads thus:
“3. Order 47 deals with the procedure with respect to the disposal of such
applications for review. Rule 1 of this Order, however, mentions in Sub-rule
(1) not only the grounds on which an application for review of judgment can
be filed, but also the decree or orders against which such an application can
be filed by a person considering himself aggrieved by the decree or order.
Sub-rule (2) of Rule 1 of this Order mentions the special circumstances in
which a person who has not appealed may apply for review of judgment even
after an appeal has been filed by any other party. Its proper place should have
been in Section 114. Rule 1 mentions the decrees and orders against which a
review application can be filed, presumably on account of its being a
reproduction of Section 623 of the earlier Code of Civil Procedure, Act
14[xiv] of 1882.”
[20]
In a case of Behari Lal And Anr. v. M.M. Gobardhan Lal And
Ors, reported in AIR 1948 All 353, the Court has held thus:
“8. It is clear from the provisions of Section 114 that an application for review
of a judgment is allowed against an appealable decree or order only when no
appeal has been preferred against it, and that applications for a review have
been allowed in two other cases in which there is no right of appeal, the cases
being decrees or orders from which no appeal is allowed by the Code or a
decision on a reference from a Court of Small Causes. It authorises the Court
to make such orders on the application for review as it thinks fit. I am inclined
to the view that the Court's powers to pass such orders are also subject to the
condition that upto the time the Court's orders are passed no appeal has been
preferred against a decree or order from which an appeal was allowed. This
would be consistent with the view that once an appeal is filed the appellate
Court has full jurisdiction over the matter, and that, therefore, the special
power of review is exercisable only upto the time that an appeal is preferred
against the order or decree sought to be reviewed.”
9. Section 114, Clause (a) does not say directly that a review application must
be filed before the filing of the appeal but allows a person to file an
application for review of judgment if a person feels aggrieved by a decree or
order from which an appeal is allowed by this Code, but from which no
appeal has been preferred. The section really does not lay down a condition
precedent to the filing of a review application but enunciates the
circumstances in which an applicant may ask for review, the circumstances
being mentioned in Clauses (a), (b) and (c). In this view of the matter, it
would follow very clearly that once an appeal is filed, there is no right in the
applicant to seek review of the judgment in appeal and there is no jurisdiction
in the Court to deal with the review application which has become
incompetent. After the filing of the appeal, it cannot be said that the applicant
is aggrieved by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed by this
Code, but from which no appeal has been preferred.”
[21]
The review petition is a petition in which it is prayed before the
Court of law to review its order or judgment which it has already
pronounced. The Court may accept a review petition when a glaring
omission or patent mistake or like grave error has crept in earlier by judicial
fallibility. When a review takes place, the Court will not take fresh stock of
the case but just correct grave errors that have resulted in the miscarriage of
justice. Also, judicial review can only correct a “patent error” and not
“minor mistakes of inconsequential import. The court does not entertain
every review petition filed. It exercises its discretion to allow a review
petition.
[22]
The Hon’ble Apex Court laid down three grounds for seeking a
review of a verdict viz. (i) the discovery of new and important matter or
evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within the
knowledge of the petitioner or could not be produced by him (ii) mistake or
error apparent on the face of the record and (iii) any sufficient reason that is
analogous to the other two grounds. The grounds of review may be the
discovery of new and important matter or evidence, some apparent mistake
or error on the face of the record or any other sufficient reason.
[23]
In the present learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondents
has submitted that after passing the said order dated 10.09.2021 in WP(C)
No.1548 of 2017, while scrutinized in department, some new facts have
been detected which were not placed by the respondents before the Court at
the time of adjudication of the case. The State Government had formulated a
new scheme vide notification dated 30th September, 2021 whereby the
Government has categorized three categories of teachers for regularization
of the SSA teachers, which have already been reproduced hereinabove.
[24]
The case of the petitioners is not squarely covered with the case
of the Sri Sajal Deb (supra) and would not apply in rem in the case of the
petitioners because of the fact that all part time teachers of KGBV hostel
were engaged only for fulfilling the interim measures under a component
scheme of SSA on the basis of Walk-in-Interviews. The policy of the State
government in the matter of regularization after a period of five years is
followed in different context, wherein, who appointed in Group-C and
Group-D posts on fixed pay basis by keeping abeyance the concerned
regular pay scale posts, in that event, after completion of five years they will
be regularized.
[25]
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel of both sides,
this Court is of the considered view that it is the case of the respondent-writ
petitioners that a consent order has been passed and now the respondents/
review petitioners cannot take back their version by filing this review
petition.
[26]
In the event the respondents/review petitioners are willing to
pass any order indicating that the writ petitioners are not entitled for the
reliefs sought for in the writ petition holding that the petitioners are the parttime employees, they are free to do so, to which the counsel appearing for
the petitioners pleads that direction may be given to the respondents for
passing such orders since the matter was decided by this Court in batch of
writ petitions in WP(C) No.329 of 2015 and another connected matter way
back on 23.02.2021.
[27]
This Court is of the opinion that “A person cannot take the
advantage of an order to which he is not entitled to”. In view of the same,
this Court finds that the review petition needs to be reconsidered and
accordingly, the same is considered and it is disposed of giving liberty to the
respondents/review petitioners to consider the case of the writ petitioners in
accordance with law, more particularly, in the light of the memorandum
dated 28.04.2010 deciding whether the petitioners are part-time employees
or full-time under a contract basis and extend all benefits towards category
of their employment. This exercise shall be completed within a period of
one month from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
[28]
In terms of above, the review petition is allowed and
accordingly disposed of. Consequently, the contempt petition [Cont.Cas(C)
No.98 of 2022] also stands closed. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications
pending, if any, shall stand closed.
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review