Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 102 of 2021
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Forest, Govt. of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN: 799010
2. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forest, Tripura,
Govt. of Tripura (PCCF), Aranya Bhavan, P.N. Complex, Gorkhabasti,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN: 799006
3. The DFO Khowai,
South Tripura, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, Gomati District,
Govt. of Tripura, Notices to be served through the office of the PCCF,
Aranya Bhavan, P.N. Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN: 799006
4. The SDFO Teliamura,
Mandai, Sabroom, Karbook, Kanchanpur, Dharmanagar, Govt. of Tripura,
(Notices to be served through the office of the PCCF, Aranya Bhavan, PN
Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN: 799006)
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Sujit Roy, S/o – Sri Sushil Roy, Vill-Netaji Nagar, PO-Teliamura, SubDivision- Teliamura, District- Khowai Tripura, PIN: 799205
2. Bijoy Krishna Dey, S/0: Sri Nitai Chandra Dey, Vill: Rajnagar, No-4, PO
& PS: Teliamura, Disrtrict- Khowai Tripura, PIN: 799205
3. Sri Angshuman Datta, S/o- Lt. Swadesh Rn. Datta, Vill: Joynagar, PO &
PS: Teliamura,, District: Khowai Tripura, PIN: 799205
4. Sri Rupak Deb, S/o: Lt. Nripendra Deb, Vill: Joynagar, PO: & PS:
Teliamura, District: Khowai Tripura, PIN: 799205
5. Sri Biplab Roy, S/0; Lt. Naresh Ch. Roy, Vill: Maiganga, PO: Maiganga,
Sub-Division: & PS: Teliamura, District: Khowai Tripura, PIN: 799205
6. Sri Mangal Hari Jamatia, S/o: Rati Mohan Jamatia, Vill: Sinabil, PO:
Ghilatali, PS: Kalyanpur,
Tripura, PIN: 799205
Sub-Division:
Teliamura,
District:
Khowai
7. Sri Prodyut Chowdhury, S/o: Subrata Chowdhury, Village & PO:
Harina, PS: Manu Bazar, Sub-Division: Sabroom, District: South Tripura,
PIN: 799145
8. Sri Shyam Saha, S/o- Dipak Saha, Vill: Silachari, PO & PS: Silachari,
Sub Division: Karbook, District: Gomati Tripura
9. Sri Bappa Paul, S/o: Bijan Kanti Paul, Village- Uttar Krishnapur, PO:
Krishnapur, PS: Dharmanagar, PIN: 799270
10. Sri Koushik Ch. Paul, S/o- Kriparnoy Paul, Village: Uttar Krishnapur,
PO: Krishnapur, PS: Dharmanagar, PIN: 799253
---Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. GA.
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Date of hearing & date of
delivery of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
: 19.07.2023
: No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment Order (Oral)
This is an appeal under Rule 2 of Chapter VA of Gauhati High
Court Rules Read with Article 226 of the Constitution of India, against the
impugned judgment and order dated 07.01.2021 passed by the Hon’ble
Single Bench in WP(C) 623 of 2020.
[2]
The reliefs sought for in WP(C) No.623 of 2020 may be
reproduced here-in-below:
(i) Issue Rule upon the respondents to show cause as to why Writ in the nature
of mandamus and/or Order or direction of lie nature shall not be issued
whereby directing the Respondents to absorb the petitioners as Permanant
Labourers in terms of Rule 4 & 5 of the Tripura Government, Sepahijala
Biological Complex/ any other complex, Institution Permanent Labourers
(Recruitment and Condition of Service) Rules, 1990.
(ii) Pass an interim order, directing the respondents to allow the petitioners to
resume their duty as Casual Workers and to continue as such till their
absorption as Permanent Labouorer.
(iii) Make the rule absolute.
(iv) Pass any other Oral Orders as may be considered fit and proper by the
Hon’ble High Court.
(v) Award cost incidental to the writ petition.
[3]
After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, the learned
Single Judge has observed in the following manner while allowing the
petition of the petitioner:
“The respondents have not raised any serious dispute about the
factual data provided by the petitioners particularly with respect to
their initial date of engagement, their qualification and the fact
that all of them had put in more than 240 days of actual work in
each of the 3(three) years under consideration. The dispute about
the petitioners being engaged against the project has already been
examined in the previous litigation in case of Gopesh Malakar and
cannot be reopened now. The sole surviving objection pressed by
the Additional Government Advocate was that the said Rules were
later on repealed in 2020. The rights of the petitioners flow from
events much prior to the repeal of the Rules, Such existing rights
cannot be taken away by subsequent repeal.
In the result, petitions are allowed, the respondents shall absorb
the petitioners as permanent labourers in the Forest Department
w.e.f. 11.01.2018.”
[4]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned
judgment and order, the respondents in WP(C) 623 of2020 have
preferred the present writ appeal before this court.
[5]
The case of the petitioners as narrated in earlier writ
petitions that the petitioners have prayed for the directions to the
respondents to absorb them as permanent labourers in terms of Rules 4 &
5 of Tripura Government Sepahijala Biological Complex/any other
Complex/Institution Permanent Labourers (Recruitment and Condition of
Services) Rules, 1990 (hereinafter to be referred as the said Rules). The
petitioners placed heavy reliance on a judgment of this Court in case of
Gopesh Malakar and others versus State of Tripura and others in
WP(C)NO.450 of 2019 which was decided in favour of the petitioners. The
respondents had challenged the said judgment of this court of Gopesh
Malakar in Writ Appeal No.192 of 2020 which has been dismissed by a
judgment dated 22.12.2020.
[6]
The respondents (the appellants herein) filed their reply and
clearly contended that the Rules namely “Tripura Sepahijala Biological
Complex/any
other
Complex/Institution
Permanent
Labourers
(Recruitment and conditions of Service) Rules, 1990” has already been
repealed
vide
No.F.2(350)/For/Estt-2017/Part/6448-520
dated
28/05/2020 before filling of the Writ petition. As the Rules was repealed
already, thus the question of absorption as permanent labourers as per
term and conditions in reference to the said Rules does not stand at all.
The workers those who are engaged under any scheme/project could not
claim for absorbing them as Permanent Labourer in the Government
Department as per Rules. These was no scope to absorb the petitioners as
Permanent Labourers & there is no vacancies of Permanent Labourers,
which was approved for 363 permanent labourers against specific names.
After hearing the Hon’ble single Judge allowed the writ petition. Hence
this writ appeal.
[7]
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
[8]
Mr.
D.
Sharma,
learned
Addl.
GA
appearing
for
the
appellants has submitted before this court that the petitioners in WP(C)
623 of 2020 have never been engaged and worked as Casual Workers in
the Forest Department. All these petitioners have been engaged as
contractual workers and performed as Documentation Assistant under
JICA Project. The JICA project is an extremely aided time bound project
which was substantially funded by external agencies. The said project was
sanctioned for a period w.e.f. 2007 to 2018. There were around 500 nos.
contractual workers worked in the JICA project earlier. All of them have
been discontinued immediately after closure of the project.
[9]
It is further contended by the learned Addl. GA for the
appellants that all the petitioners in WP(C) 623 of 2020 were engaged
under JICA Project so the “Tripura Government Sepahijala Biological
Complex/any
other
Complex/Institution
Permanent
Labourers
(Recruitment and Condition of Service) Rules, 1990” shall never be
applied to those contractual workers.
[10]
In course of his submission, learned Addl. GA has also
contended that learned Single Judge while issuing the order dated
07.01.2021 neither scrutinize required documents etc nor
passed any
order to the Forest authority to scrutinize all required documents of the
petitioners. The Forest authorities did not recommend their name at any
time by any selection committee like similarly situated other cases. In any
Government establishment there is a mandatory process of scrutinizing
the documents to be submitted by the petitioners at the very initial state
of selection of candidate. After scrutiny at the local level the eligible
candidate would be recommended for absorption in the department which
is not done here in the instant case.
[11]
Mr. D. Sharma, learned counsel Addl.GA appearing for the
appellants has relied on a judgment of the apex court in The State of
Gujarat and Others vs. R.J. Pathan and Others reported in 2022
LiveLaw(SC) 313 which has been passed in the light of the “Umadevi”
case. Reliance has been placed on the following paragraphs which is
extracted herein under:
8. Now, so far as the reliance placed upon the decision of this
Court in the case of Umadevi (supra) and the subsequent decision
of this Court in the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari (supra), relied
upon by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondents is concerned, none of the aforesaid decisions shall be
applicable to the facts of the case on hand. The purpose and intent
of the decision in Umadevi (supra) was, (1) to prevent irregular or
illegal appointments in the future, and (2) to confer a benefit on
those who had been irregularly appointed in the past and who
have continued for a very long time. The decision of Umadevi
(supra) may be applicable in a case where the appointments are
irregular on the sanctioned posts in regular establishment. The
same does not apply to temporary appointments made in a
project/programme.
9. Even otherwise, it is to be noted that though not required, the
State, instead of putting an end to the services of the respondents,
graciously placed the respondents in the Indian Red Cross Society.
No duty was cast upon the State to transfer them to another
establishment in a case where it is found that the employees are
appointed in a temporary unit and on a temporary contractual
basis and on a fixed term salary and on closure of the temporary
unit, their services are not required. However, the State
Government was gracious enough to place the respondents in the
Indian Red Cross Society, which the respondents did not accept.
10. From the impugned order passed by the Division Bench of the
High Court it appears that the High Court has observed
hereinabove that in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
case, it is directed that the order of absorption and regularization
and if necessary, by creating supernumerary posts, will not be
treated as a precedent in other cases. Even such a direction could
not have been passed by the Division Bench of the High Court as
there were no peculiar facts and circumstances which warranted
the above observation. No such order of absorption and/or
regularization even if required for creating supernumerary posts
and not to treat the same as precedent could have been passed by
the High Court in exercise of powers under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
[12]
On the contrary, Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents herein has submitted before this court that their solitary
cause for approaching this court to absorb the petitioners in WP(C) 623 of
2020 as permanent labourers. According to learned senior counsel, the
appellants herein have not only denied to the legitimate rights of the
respondents herein but also the benefit of absorption as permanent
labourer. The appellants herein have rather taken away their means of
livelihood by not allowing them to continue as casual workers w.e.f
18.03.2018.
[13]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has also pointed
out that there are recommendation in favour of the petitioners in WP(C)
623 of 2020 indicating that petitioners are entitled for absorption as the
permanent labour since they have sufficient qualification for absorption as
the casual worker.
[14]
In view of the above discussion, we are of the opinion that
the order of the learned single judge is liable to be set aside. Accordingly,
the order dated 07.01.2021 of the learned single judge is set aside.
However, it is further seen from the record that except one petitioner, no
other petitioners have approached the respondents seeking relief for
absorption by the respondents. Admittedly, there is no impugned order
which is under challenge. This court is very conscious with regard to its
jurisdiction and it cannot fit into the shoes of the administrative authority
nor as the appellate capacity.
[15]
Without expressing any opinion on merit of the case, this
writ appeal is disposed of giving liberty to the petitioners in WP(C) 623 of
2020 to approach the respondents by way of making their representations
along with all relevant documents in support of their claim, if so advised.
On receipt of such representations, the respondents shall consider their
case in accordance with law within a period of three months from the date
of receipt of such representations.
[16]
In view of the above, the instant writ appeal stands allowed
and thus disposed of. As a sequel, stay, if any, stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
JUDGE
Dipak
DAS
DIPAK DAS DIPAK
Date: 2023.07.26
17:33:35 +05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review