The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. In view of the above, according to me, merely the Standing Review Committee held its meeting before expiry of 90 days would not subserve the purpose of amending provisions under sub-rules (6) and (7) of Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
17. In light of above analysis on law coupled with the facts of the case, I find no merit in the review petition presented by the petitioner before this court since review order extending the period of suspension after expiry of ninety days giving its effect from a retrospective date is not at all permissible and would be deemed to be invalid being contrary to sub-rules (6) and (7) of Rule 10 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. Accordingly, the Review petition stands dismissed. Interim application(s), if any, also stands disposed. Saikat
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Review Petn. 66/2022
The State of Tripura & ors.
-vsSri Soumitra Chakma
… Review Petitioners
… Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA
Mr. K. Dey, Addl. GA
Ms. R. Purkayastha, Advocate
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
01.12.2022
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment and Order (ORAL)
01/12/2022
Heard Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA assisted by Mr. K. Dey, learned
Additional GA appearing for the review petitioner. Also heard Ms. R.
Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for the respondent, the original writ
petitioner in WP(C) 917 of 2022.
2.
The State of Tripura has filed the present review petition to review the
judgment and order dated 14.11.2022 passed in WP(C) 917 of 2022 wherein
this court had set-aside and quashed the review order dated 03.10.2022
extending the suspension period of the respondent, who was the original writ
petitioner.
3.
Facts of the case, in brief, are that, the petitioner (the respondent
herein) was put on suspension on 30.06.2021. The suspension order was
reviewed time to time upto 22.09.2022. The court while disposing of the writ
petition found the last order dated 03.10.2022 extending the suspension
period of the writ petitioner, who is the respondent in this review petition,
was bad in law being made in contravention to sub-rules (6) and (7) of Rule
10 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, as inserted vide notification dated
23.12.2003 w.e.f. 02.06.2004.
4.
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing for the review petitioner
i.e. State of Tripura has filed the present review petition stating inter alia
that review committee was formed before the expiry of 90 days and, thus, it
conforms the provisions laid down in sub-rules (6) and (7) of Rule 10 of the
CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
5.
On the other hand, Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for
the respondent herein has opposed the contention so raised on behalf of the
review petitioner with all vehemence. Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel
submits that the amended provisions of sub-rule (6) and (7) of Rule 10 of the
CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 clearly lay down that review order extending the
suspension order must be made before expiry of 90 days. Learned counsel
has placed reliance on a decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of
India vs. Dipak Mali, reported in (2010) 2 SCC 222, paras 10 and 11.
6.
In view of the aforesaid submissions advanced by learned counsel
appearing for the parties, it will be useful to reproduce the provisions laid
down in sub-rule (6) and (7) of Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965,
which are as under:
“(6) An order of suspension made or deemed to have been made under this rule
shall be reviewed by the authority which is competent to modify or revoke the
suspension,[before expiry of ninety days from the effective date of suspension] on
the recommendation of the Review Committee constituted for the purpose and pass
orders either extending or revoking the suspension. Subsequent reviews shall be
made before expiry of the extended period of suspension. Extension of suspension
shall not be for a period exceeding one hundred and eighty days at a time.
(7) An order of suspension made or deemed to have been made under sub-rule (1)
or (2) of this rule shall not be valid after a period of ninety days unless it is extended
after review, for a further period before the expiry of ninety days :
Provided that no such review of suspension shall be necessary in the case of deemed
suspension under sub-rule (2), if the Government servant continues to be under
suspension at the time of completion of ninety days of suspension and the ninety
days period in such case will count from the date the Government servant detained
in custody is released from detention or the date on which the fact of his release
from detention is intimated to his appointing authority, whichever is later.”
7.
A minute reading of sub-rules (6) and (7) of Rule 10 makes it
manifest that the provisions are mandatory. A bare perusal of the aforesaid
provisions crystallizes that review order extending suspension period must
be made before expiry of 90 days. Sub-rule (7) of Rule 10 makes it aptly
clear that an order of suspension made or deemed to have been made under
sub-rule (1) or (2) of Rule 10 shall not be valid after a period of 90 days
unless it is extended after review, for a further period, before the expiry of
90 days.
8.
In my opinion, the language of the provisions itself suggests this. Sub-
rule (6) suggests that every order of suspension must be reviewed by the
authority competent to modify or revoke the suspension. For this purpose, a
review committee has to be constituted which will recommend such
modification or revocation on the basis of which the competent authority
shall pass order. The language incorporated by way of amendment in this
Sub-rule (6) postulates that the competent authority shall pass the order of
modification or revocation before expiry of ninety days from the effective
date of suspension. The rule-makers while legislating Sub-rule (6) further
went on to clarify that “subsequent reviews shall be made before expiry of
the extended period of suspension.”
9.
Again, in Sub-rule (7), it is stipulated that an order of suspension
made or deemed to have been made under Sub-rule (1) or (2) of Rule 10
shall not be valid after a period of ninety days unless it is extended after
review, for a further period before expiry of ninety days. The phrase used by
the legislatures that “unless it is extended after review” is quite indicative
that exercise of review has to be completed before the order is passed for
further extension of suspension period which is further fortified by
encryption of the words in the end part of Sub-rule (7) “before the expiry of
ninety days”.
10.
Here, I may gainfully extract the relevant paragraphs of the case of
Dipak Mali (supra), which are as under:
“10. Having carefully considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties and
having also considered the relevant dates relating to suspension of the Respondent
and when the Petitioners’ case came up for review on 20-10-2004, we are inclined to
agree with the views expressed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, as confirmed
by the High Court, that having regard to the amended provisions of Sub- rules (6) and
(7) of Rule 10, the review for modification or revocation of the order of suspension
was required to be done before the expiry of 90 days from the date of order
of suspension and as categorically provided under Sub- rule (7), the order of
suspension made or deemed would not be valid after a period of 90 days unless it was
extended after review for a further period of 90 days.
11. The case sought to be made out on behalf of the petitioner, Union of India as to
the cause of delay in reviewing the Respondent's case, is not very convincing. Section
19(4) of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, speaks of abatement of proceedings
once an original application under the said Act was admitted. In this case, what is
important is that by operation of Sub-rule (6) of Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules, the order
of suspension would not survive after the period of 90 days unless it was extended
after review. Since admittedly the review had not been conducted within 90 days
from the date of suspension, it became invalid after 90 days, since neither was there
any review nor extension within the said period of 90 days. Subsequent review and
extension, in our view, could not revive the order which had already become invalid
after the expiry of 90 days from the date of suspension.”
11.
Learned GA has tried to interpret the provisions as laid down in sub-
rule (7) of Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, that if Standing Review
Committee holds its meeting before expiry of 90 days that would be deemed
to be in compliance of sub-rule (7) of Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules,
1965.
12.
In the case in hand, the last review order extending the suspension
period has ended on 22.09.2022 and next order of extension of suspension
period of the writ petitioner was made on 03.10.2022, which is apparent on
the face of the review petition filed by the State of Tripura having given its
effect retrospectively from 23.09.2022.
13.
The aforesaid principles laid down by the Hon’ble apex court as well
as the provisions of sub-rule (6) and (7) of Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules,
1065 makes it abundantly clear that any order extending the suspension
period, if not made before expiry of 90 days, that would be held to be
invalid.
14.
I am not in agreement with the interpretation made by learned GA as
regards sub-rule (6) and (7) of Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The
language and words used in sub-rule (6) and (7) of Rule 10 of the CCS
(CCA) Rules, 1965, are clear, plain and unambiguous. Rule of
“interpretation” suggests that, if the words of the statute are in themselves
precise and unambiguous, then, no more can be necessary than to expound
those words in their natural and ordinary sense. The words themselves do
alone in such cases best declare the intent of the lawgiver.
[Emphasis supplied]
15.
Another interesting feature in both the sub-rules is that the law-makers
has repeatedly used the word “shall”. This repetition of the word “shall”
explicitly manifests the intention of the legislature that any departure of
these sub-rules shall defeat the very object for which the rule-makers
had carried out amendment in sub-rule (6) and incorporated “before
expiry of 90 days from the effective date of suspension” and also
inserted sub-rule (7) vide notification no. 11012/4/2003-Estt.(A), dated,
6th June, 2007 and published as GSR-105 in the gazette of India dated
16th June, 2007. Besides sub-rule (6), sub-rule (7) mandates the
competent authority to pass review order of extension before the expiry
of 90 days and an order extending the suspension period shall not be
valid after a period of 90 days. In the opinion of this court, any
departure from this rule shall definitely defeat the legislative
intendment.
[Emphasis supplied]
16.
In view of the above, according to me, merely the Standing Review
Committee held its meeting before expiry of 90 days would not subserve the
purpose of amending provisions under sub-rules (6) and (7) of Rule 10 of
the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
17.
In light of above analysis on law coupled with the facts of the case, I
find no merit in the review petition presented by the petitioner before this
court since review order extending the period of suspension after expiry of
ninety days giving its effect from a retrospective date is not at all permissible
and would be deemed to be invalid being contrary to sub-rules (6) and (7) of
Rule 10 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. Accordingly, the Review petition
stands dismissed.
Interim application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Saikat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review