Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WA .No.123 of 2024
The State of Tripura & Others
…..Appellants
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
Sri Ratan Kumar Das
…..Respondent
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
20.08.2025
YES
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
_F_I_N_A_L_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
[Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Heard.
[2]
The present writ appeal has been filed under Chapter-VIII, Rule-B
(A) of the High Court of Tripura Rules, 2023 against the impugned judgment and
order dated 03.07.2024 passed in WP(C) No.745 of 2023 by the learned Single
Judge.
[3]
The facts in brief are that the matter relates to extension of benefits
under TSCS (First Amendment) Rules, 2018 to the petitioner-respondent herein,
who is a retired employee of DRDA agency which was ran under central scheme,
now
discontinued
the
scheme
by
the
Government
of
India.
The
petitioner/respondent herein claims for benefits of revised pay scale, gratuity, leave
encashment etc. to him by way of adopting the TSCS (First Amendment) Rules,
2018 by the respondents, the appellant herein. The respondent State denied his
claim as the petitioner was employed under a centrally ran scheme DRDA who was
not an employee under the State Government and the revision of pay as adopted by
the State for its employees which do not applied automatically upon the employees
under DRDA like the petitioner, without adopting the State revised pay by the
DRDA authority. But the learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition and
directed to re-determine the pay scale of the petitioner in terms of the TSCS (First
Amendment) Rules, 2018 and to pay consequential benefits.
[4]
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and gone
through the material evidence on records, the learned Single Judge has observed as
under:
“[21] In the result, the writ petition is allowed and disposed of in the following
terms:
The respondents shall re-determine the post retirement benefits of the petitioner
i.e the Leave Encashment and Gratuity after fixation of his basic pay in terms
of Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) (1st Amendment) Rules, 2018 in
the light of the discussions made in Para-11 above. The Gratuity payable to the
petitioner will be computed after taking into consideration the revised ceiling
limit of Rs.20,00,000/- as notified by the Government of India vide notification
dated 29.03.2018 and payment of arrears will be made accordingly. The
respondents will also pay interest @7% per annum on the rest amount of Leave
Encashment and Gratuity, computing from the date after the expiry of one
month of the date of retirement of the petitioner till payment is made.
The respondents will also ensure payment of benefits under the GSLI Scheme
to the petitioner as indicated above accordingly at the earliest after taking up
the matter with LICI, if the same is not already paid. All the above said
exercises should be done within 4[four] months from the receipt of the copy of
this Judgment and order.”
[5]
Being aggrieved, the State-respondents, the appellants herein, have
filed this intra court appeal.
[6]
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the appellants
has submitted that the learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate the fact that the
petitioner-respondent herein, was an employee under the DRDA agency which is a
centrally sponsored scheme ran under the Central Government and the State share
is only 10%. Further, the scheme has been discontinued by the central government
across the country with effect from 01.04.2022 and thereafter, no funds has been
released by the central government and also since then there is no new engagement
in the agency. In 2022, Ministry of RD and Panchayatiraj, Govt. of India has been
requested by the State Government to provide fund at least to release one time
granting fund for DRDA staffs as there are as many as 72 DRDA staffs working in
8 districts, out of which 47 regular staffs (Group-A-15, Group-C-21, Group-D-11)
and 25 DRW/PTW/Contractual workers as on February, 2022. But the central
government informed about their inability to release one time grant of fund for
DRDA staffs and thereby, the DRDA agency could not be adopted the revised pay
as per the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) (1st Amendment) Rules,
2018.
[7]
Further, since after discontinuation of DRDA Administration Scheme
w.e.f. 1st April, 2022, in spite of financial crisis of the State, all DRDA staffs have
been deputed to Tripura Rural Livelihood Mission (TRLM) by the State and
extended their service in time to time with certain terms and conditions. The State
is facing lots of financial hardship in managing their monthly pay and salaries and
therefore, the State is not in a position to bear extra financial burden unless the
central government is not extending their financial support in this particular matter.
[8]
It has been further contended that the learned Single Judge has also
failed to segregate the status of the service of the petitioner. The service of the
petitioner is under the control of the DRDA agency, not with the State Department.
The service status of the petitioner is not at par status of the employees under State
Government. DRDA staffs like the petitioner has no right to claim service benefits
directly from the State Government until and unless DRDA agency has absorbed or
adopted the State policy including the revision of pay scales announced in time to
time by the State Government. Time to time decision of the State Government for
revision of pay and other benefits for the State employees could not be applied
automatically to the employees working under the DRDA agency. The State
revised pay may be applied if the DRDA agency adopted the revised pay scales and
other benefits subject to their available of funds. But in the instant case, DRDA
agency has not adopted the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) (1st
Amendment) Rules, 2018 due to non-available of funds and therefore, there is no
question arises for applying the benefits under the Tripura State Civil Services
(Revised Pay) (1st Amendment) Rules, 2018 to the staffs under DRDA agency.
[9]
Admittedly, the State Finance Department has agreed initially with
the proposal of the State RD Department towards implementation of the TSCE
(Revised Pay) (1st Amendment) Rules, 2018 with giving effect from 01.10.2018
notionally and actual benefits to be given w.e.f. 01.04.2020 subject to flow of fund
vide communication letter dated 05.03.2020. But in spite of increasing flow of fund
from the central government, the scheme itself is discontinued by the central
government. Having been such situation neither the State RD Department nor the
DRDA agency has in any position to continue the decision taken earlier to give
benefits under TSCE (Revised Pay) (1st Amendment) Rules, 2018 and thereby,
there has no option except to stop earlier decision for adoption of TSCE (Revised
Pay) 1st Amendment Rules, 2018 by the appellant‟s side. However, the petitioner
has been paid gratuity, leave encashment as per Revised Pension Rules of 2017.
[10]
The learned Single Judge has also failed to appreciate that once an
employee taken the benefits of pay scales under the TSCS (RP) Rules, 2017, i.e.,
the State pay rules as adopted and/or its First Amendment Rules, 2018, as the case
may be, he, on retirement, must not receive the pension and other retiral benefits as
per Rules or Act other than the State Pension Rules i.e., TSCS (Revised Pension)
Rules, 2017 or its First Amendment Rules, 2018 if so adopted. But he cannot claim
to receive the amount of gratuity under different rules or Payment of Gratuity Act,
1972.
[11]
The
petitioner
was
not
on
monthly
wages
during
his
service/employment. He was getting pay and salary. The provision of Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972 was not applicable to the employees of DRDA in Tripura. In
fact, no other employee of DRDA has also been given such benefit under the
payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
[12]
The learned Single Judge has also failed to appreciate that the State
Government in exercise of power under Article-309 of the Constitution framed its
own pay and pension rules from time to time in partial modification of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972 as adopted in the State, for its own employees. Even the
State Government employees at present are paid gratuity amount subject to
maximum ceiling limit of Rs.10 lakhs. Such revised pay scales, pension rules are
adopted by different Organizations/Boards/Agency /Corporations etc.
[13]
It has been further contended that the petitioner-respondent was not
eligible for revision of pay as per Revised Pay-1st Amendment Rules of 2018, in as
much as, the direction of the Finance Department was to calculate the benefit
notionally from 01.10.2018 and the actual benefit was to be given from 01.04.2020
subject to availability of fund and before the said date, the petitioner went on
superannuation. According to them, the amount of gratuity was paid to the
petitioner within 30 days from the date of his retirement as per Tripura Civil
Services ROP, 2018.
[14]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.
Bhattacharhee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has drawn attention of
this Court to the letter dated 05.03.2020 of the Director (Projects) and submitted
that as per the said letter itself, the petitioner was entitled to the benefits under said
Revised Pay-1st Amendment Rules of 2018 which was illegally denied to the
petitioner. To substantiate the claims, learned senior counsel further referred
another notification dated 06.11.2018 of the Finance Department containing
Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) (1st Amendment) Rules, 2018 whereby
old Rule-15 was substituted with the following words:
“Notwithstanding anything contained elsewhere in these Rules, or in any other
Rules for the time being in force, the benefit of revision of pay for the month of
October, 2018 payable in November 2018 and onwards shall be provided in
cash. The Government employees, who had died/retired/ superannuated on or
after the 1st day of October, 2018 and before publication of these Rules in the
Official Gazette, shall be paid arrear pay and allowances for the period from
the
1st
day
of
October,
upto the
date
of
his
death/retirement/superannuation in cash.”
[15]
According to learned counsel, gratuity should be paid taking into
consideration the upper ceiling limit as determined by Central Government in terms
of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. It has been contended that the petitionerrespondent retired from service w.e.f. 31.12.2019 as such he is governed by the
notification dated 29.03.2018, whereby, the amount of gratuity payable to an
employee has been enhanced from Rs.10,00,000/- to 20,00,000/-. Since the
petitioner has retired in the year 2019, he is governed by the notification dated
29.03.2018 published in the Gazette of India, instead of the notification dated
11.07.2017.
[16]
The Govt. of India by Notification, dated, 29.03.2018, published in
the Gazette of India, dated, 29.03.2018, notified, that, the amount of Gratuity
payable to an employee under the Act shall not exceed Rs 20,00,000/-.But the
respondents, the appellants herein, in calculating the amount of Gratuity which
became payable to of the petitioner on his retirement from service did not take into
account the enhanced ceiling limit of Rs 20,00,000/- which came in force w.e.f.
29.03.2018, instead of that, the respondents have calculated the Gratuity as per
ceiling limit of Rs. 10,00,000/- which was earlier to the amendment of Sec 14(3) of
the Act.
[17]
In terms of the amendment of the Payment of Gratuity Act raising the
ceiling limit to Rs 20 Lakhs w.e.f. 29.03.2018, the petitioner became entitled to
gratuity at the enhanced rate i.e., beyond the earlier ceiling limit of Rs 10,00,000/-.
But the respondents have caused payment of Gratuity to the petitioner in terms of
the ceiling limit which was prior to amendment of the Payment of Gratuity Act
vide the Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 2018, w.e.f., 29.03.2018. Only
partial payment of gratuity has been caused to the petitioner. After retirement from
service the petitioner became entitled to full and final payment of gratuity within
30 days in terms of section 7(3) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The
Payment of Gratuity Act is applicable to the petitioner and other employees of the
DRDA.
[18]
Vide letter, dated, 25.08.2021, issued by the Director (Projects),
SLMC, RD, Govt. of Tripura, it has been informed to the Project Director, District
Rural Development Agency, Gomati, Udaipur, that, RD Department has issued an
Order for revision of pay under Tripura State pay Matrix-2018 for employees and
workers of DRDA, in which the revision may be considered notionally and actual
benefit may be given from 01.04.2020 subject to availability of fund. Stating so,
the claim of the petitioner for any financial benefit has been rejected on the ground
that, he has retired from service on 31.12.2019, and as such he is not entitled to
such financial benefit.
[19]
By notification, dated, 06.11.2018, issued by the Secretary to the
Govt. of Tripura, Department of Finance, pay of an existing employee under
Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) (1st Amendment) Rules, 2018, has been
re-fixed and the same shall be calculated by dividing the existing basic pay by 2.25
and then multiplying the resultant value by applicable multiplication factor at the
particular level under Tripura State Pay Matrix 2018 and the figure so arrived at
will be located in that appropriate level of the Pay Matrix and if such figure
corresponds to any identical value in any Cell in the applicable level of the pay
matrix, the same shall be the pay, and if no such Cell is available in the applicable
level, the pay shall be fixed at the immediate next higher Cell in that applicable
level of the pay matrix.
[20]
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has further argued that the
respondents have failed to take into consideration the revised pay fixation as per
Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) (1st mendment) Rules, 2018 and
thereafter, the petitioners' gratuity and other pensionary benefits ought to have been
calculated as per the revised pay rules. The respondents, the appellants herein have
failed to cause full and final payment of gratuity to the petitioner within the
stipulated period. The respondents are liable to pay interest @9% per annum on the
balance amount of gratuity. The petitioner is entitled to gratuity at the enhanced
rate i.e. Rs.20,00,000/- upper limit.
[21]
In this regard the petitioner submitted representation, dated,
18.04.2022, to the respondents, for fixation of initial pay as per RoP- 2018. In the
said representation, the petitioner have prayed for benefit of RoP-2018 like other
employees of DRDA, but the prayer of the petitioner has been rejected on the
ground that he has retired from service w.e.f. 31.12.2019. The petitioner has further
submitted, that, there will be an enhancement in his gratuity and leave salary and
thus the petitioner has requested to issue order to prepare fixation of pay as per
RoP-2018. It has been also submitted that DRDA(South) has considered the
fixation of pay as per RoP-2018 with full arrear pay w.e.f. 01.10.2018 in respect of
their employees and thus similar procedure may be adopted for the employees of
DRDA. Pursuant to the retirement of the petitioner, he is entitled to get full and
final payment of gratuity and Leave Encashment as per RoP-2018 along with
interest.
[22]
It is seen from the observation made by the learned Single Judge that
Tripura State Revised Pay Rules, 2017 was brought into force w.e.f. 01.04.2017
and the said First Amendment thereof was made effective from 01.10.2018. It is
evident from the letter dated 05.03.2020 of the Director (Projects), State Level
Monitoring Cell of SGSY, Rural Development Department that the Finance
Department concurred with the proposal of the department towards implementation
of revised pay scale in terms of said Revised Pay – 1st Amendment Rules of 2018
in respect of staff and workers under DRDA subject to the condition that revision
may be considered w.e.f. 01.10.2018 notionally and actual benefits may be given
from 01.04.2020. The arrears may be paid if fund is found sufficient.
[23]
Therefore, there is no doubt that the employees of the DRDA were
entitled to get revised pay scale in terms of said Revised Pay-1st Amendment Rules
of 2018. Only a condition was imposed that the actual benefit would be paid from
01.04.2020 but fixation of pay should notionally be done w.e.f. 01.10.2018. The
said decision does not cover the situation where an employee goes on
superannuation before 01.04.2020. Such imposition of condition of giving actual
financial benefits from 01.04.2020 on its plain reading creates the impression that it
was meant for the employee who are in service on said date 01.04.2020. But said
decision of Finance Department nowhere creates any bar in computing the post
retirement benefits of an employee based on said Revised Pay-1st Amendment
Rules of 2018, who went on retirement in between the period 01.10.2018 to
01.04.2020. At best, fixation of pay of the concerned employee may be done w.e.f.
01.10.2018 notionally till the date of his retirement based on which his post
retirement benefits may be computed and paid to him. Therefore, the decision of
the respondents for not giving the benefits of aid 1st Amendment Rules of 2018 to
the petitioner on his retirement was arbitrary and illegal. His pay could be fixed
notionally w.e.f. 01.10.2018 and his post retirement benefits, as admissible, ought
to have been provided as per the said Amendment Rules of 2018 with effect from
the date of his retirement. The letter dated 11.12.2020 of Project Director, DRDA,
Gomati District, Udaipur shows that the Gratuity and the Leave Encashment
benefits were released in favour of the petitioner as per Tripura Pay Matrix, 2017,
which was, therefore, not in accordance with the said rules.
[24]
Furthermore, the said issue was also decided by a Division Bench of
this Court (comprising of S. Talapatra, J and S.G. Chattopadhyay, J in an intraCourt appeal in W.A. No.185 of 2020) and held that all the corporations and other
establishments under the State Government shall come within the purview of
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 as amended time to time by the Central
Government. The relevant part of the said judgment may be reproduced hereinbelow:
“Admittedly, the writ petitioner is not an employee of the Central Government
or State Government but of a local body. As such the said exception as curved
out while defining „employee‟ cannot authorise Agartala Municipal
Corporation (the appellant) to make their own rules which is in contrast to the
provisions of Central Statute namely the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972
inasmuch as the Central Government has notified that local bodies having
employees more than ten would be covered by the provisions of Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972.”
[25]
In that view of the matter, this Court having observed that similarly
placed employees are extended benefit and there cannot be discrimination. For
ready reference, the observations made by the learned Single Judge was that :
“the respondents shall re-determine the post retirement benefits of the
petitioner i.e the Leave Encashment and Gratuity after fixation of his basic pay
in terms of Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) (1st Amendment) Rules,
2018 in the light of the discussions made in Para-11 above. The Gratuity
payable to the petitioner will be computed after taking into consideration the
revised ceiling limit of Rs.20,00,000/- as notified by the Government of India
vide notification dated 29.03.2018 and payment of arrears will be made
accordingly. The respondents will also pay interest @7% per annum on the
rest amount of Leave Encashment and Gratuity, computing from the date after
the expiry of one month of the date of retirement of the petitioner till payment is
made. The respondents will also ensure payment of benefits under the GSLI
Scheme to the petitioner as indicated above accordingly at the earliest after
taking up the matter with LICI, if the same is not already paid. All the above
said exercises should be done within 4[four] months from the receipt of the
copy of this Judgment and order.”
[26]
Thus, the findings arrived at by the learned Single Judge which is
directory in nature and the respondents need to take a decision in terms of the order
and the said order passed needs no interference. Thus, the present writ appeal is
liable to be dismissed and the same is accordingly dismissed.
[27]
As a sequel, miscellaneous application, pending if any, shall stand
closed
B. PALIT, J
A. Ghosh
signed by ANJAN GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.08.27 17:16:55 +05'30'
dr. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review