Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.197 of 2021
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Secretary,
Department of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura,
New Civil Secretariat Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, West
Tripura, PIN- 799006.
2. The Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Secondary
Education Department, Civil Secretariat Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN-799006.
3. The
Secretary to the
Government of
Tripura,
Department of Elementary Education, Civil Secretariat
Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN799006.
4. The Director of Elementary Education, Government of
Tripura, Old Secretariat Building, Akhaura Road, Agartala,
PIN-799001.
5. The Director of Secondary Education, Government of
Tripura, Old Secretariat Building, Akhaura Road, Agartala,
PIN-799001.
6. The Addl. Secretary, Government of Tripura, Office of the
Director of Secondary Education, Secretarial Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN- 799006.
7. The Principal-in-Charge, DIET, Abhoynagar, Agartala,
P.O. Abhoynagar, District: West Tripura, PIN- 799005.
……Appellants
(Respondents No.1 to 7 in writ petition)
Versus
Smt. Susmita Bhattacharjee @ Susmita Bhattacharya,
daughter of late Jagadindra Bhattacharjee, wife of Sanjib
Bhattacharjee, resident Krishnanagar, Pragati Road, P.O.
Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN799001.
.......Respondent
(Petitioner in writ petition No.1190 of 2019)
WA No.199 of 2021
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Secretary,
Department of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura,
New Civil Secretariat Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, West
Tripura, PIN- 799006.
2. The Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Secondary
Education Department, Civil Secretariat Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN-799006.
3. The
Secretary to the
Government of
Tripura,
Department of Elementary Education, Civil Secretariat
Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN799006.
4. The Director of Elementary Education, Government of
Tripura, Old Secretariat Building, Akhaura Road, Agartala,
PIN-799001.
5. The Director of Secondary Education, Government of
Tripura, Old Secretariat Building, Akhaura Road, Agartala,
PIN-799001.
6. The Addl. Secretary, Government of Tripura, Office of the
Director of Secondary Education, Secretarial Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN- 799006.
7. The Principal-in-Charge, DIET, Abhoynagar, Agartala,
P.O. Abhoynagar, District: West Tripura, PIN- 799005.
……Appellants
(Respondents No.1 to 7 in writ petition)
Versus
Sri Prasenjit Roy, son of late Sudarshan Chandra Roy,
resident of East Shibnagar, P.O. Agartala College, District:
West Tripura, PIN- 799004.
.......Respondent
(Petitioner in writ petition No.1189 of 2019)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate.
Date of hearing
: 12.03.2024.
Date of pronouncement
of Judgment & Order
: 18.03.2024.
Whether fit for reporting : Yes
______
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Heard Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. and
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. for the State- appellants. Also
heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P.
Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The present writ appeals filed by the appellants arise out
of common cause of action challenging the same impugned
judgment and order of the learned Single Judge dated 09.04.2021
[in a common judgment in WP(C) No.706 of 2019, W.P(C) No.1189
of 2019 and W.P(C) 1190 of 2019] and the reliefs sought for in
these appeals are also similar in nature. Accordingly, the present
writ appeals are taken together for consideration and disposal of the
same in a common judgment.
[3]
The brief fact of this case is that the petitioners in the
writ petitions (respondents herein) are teachers (PGT/AT) in
Government Schools. In 2003, vide applications from the interested
teachers of Government Secondary and Higher Secondary Schools,
the petitioners had been invited for service utilization on deputation
at District Institution of Education and Training [DIET, for short.] In
2004, it was decided for appointment to the post of Lecturer, DIET
on contract for 37 posts (Newly created 20 + available vacancies
17). Accordingly, 22 candidates were appointed to the post of
Lecturer, DIET on a contractual basis in December 2004. Eight of
them continued to perform as Lecturer DIET on a contractual basis
and finally, they were appointed to the post of Lecturer, DIET on
regular basis. The three petitioners earlier filed writ petitions WP(C)
No.06/2014, WP(C) No.722/2018 and WP(C) No.214 of 2018 for
their absorption as lecturers in DIET as the appointment of those
8(eight) numbers of lecturers.
[4]
The
State
categorically
denied
and
disputed
the
contentions of the petitioner through its counter affidavit stating
inter alia that the petitioner holds the post of Post Graduate Teacher
and their services were placed under F.R. 11 at the disposal of the
Principal, DIET, Agartala with the scale of pay and post held by
them i.e. Post Graduate Teacher moreover, their placement is
subject
to
the
condition
of
the
Memorandum
No.F.3.(1-99)
DSE/2000 dated 17.07.2003 with specific term and conditions and
that the petitioners may be withdrawn from DIET at any time, when
their services are not required in DIET. According to the appellants
State, the petitioners are bound by the foregoing terms and
conditions mentioned in the said memorandum.
[5]
It is contended on behalf of the appellant- State that the
said eight persons have been offered to the post of Lecturer, DIETs
on contract basis under F.R. 11 on the recommendation of the
Selection Committee against the Advertisement (ICAT-C-1940)
dated, 06.02.2004. The petitioners did not apply for the post of
Lecturer of DIET on contract basis as like the eight Lecturers of
DIET engaged on contractual basis as the petitioners were enjoying
the higher pay package of the scale of Post Graduate Teacher.
[6]
Learned Single Judge, upon hearing the arguments made
by the parties, disposed of the case of the petitioners (respondents
herein) in a common judgment and order dated 09.04.2021 in a
common judgment in WP(C) No.706 of 2019, W.P(C) No.1189 of
2019 and W.P(C) 1190 of 2019 with the following observation and
direction:
“.........[26]
In my considered view, when the Director SCERT
had recommended the names of the petitioners for their absorption
under DIET, non-forwarding of the same for approval of the Council
of Ministers while the names of contractual candidates were
forwarded, definitely violates the doctrine of equality and thus
offends Article-14 of the Constitution of India. In furtherance
thereof, in the recommendation letter, the Director, SCERT clearly
has stated that the petitioners were eligible in all respects to be
absorbed in the regular posts of Lecturers under DIET. In the
instant case, it is established from the records that eight candidates
who were appointed on contract basis initially, they were absorbed
against the regular vacant posts of Lecturers under the DIET on the
basis of their repeated representations without following the
established procedure of public employment. I was inclined to
quash the appointments of these eight Lecturers who were
appointed in total violation of the established rule of public
employment. But, the petitioners have not made such prayer before
this Court.
However, it is apparent from the face of the records that
the petitioners were utterly discriminated due to arbitrary decision
taken by the authorities concerned. The reason assigned while
rejecting the representations of the petitioners particularly, Smt.
Nandini Bhattacharjee, that she had no required qualification, is
absolutely unfounded and factually incorrect. The authority
concerned even did not think it necessary to examine her records,
though, according to the learned senior counsel, her qualification
has also been recorded in her service book. As such, in my
considered view, the petitioners also are entitled to get similar
treatment as those of eight Lecturers who were absorbed under the
DIET. The State-respondents are directed to send the names of the
petitioners to the Council of Ministers and this Court hopes and
trust that the Council of Ministers shall consider the case of the
petitioners herein in the line of those eight contractual Lecturers
exploring all possibilities, keeping in mind the DIET needs the
service of all the petitioners, and vacant posts still exist under DIET.
Furthermore, the petitioners have all the essential qualifications for
being absorbed/appointed as Lecturer under respondent No.7.
It has been made clear that till such consideration by the
Council of ministers and a fresh decision is taken by the competent
authority, the services of the petitioners namely, Sri Prasenjit Roy
and Smt. Susmita Bhattacahrjee @ Susmita Bhattacharya, who
have been serving under DIET till today, shall not be disturbed by
way of repatriation to their parent department. It is further made
clear that repatriation of Smti. Nandini Bhattacharjee, the petitioner
in WP(C) No.706 of 2019 shall not come in the way of her
absorption under DIET as Lecturer.
[27]
With the above observations and directions, the
present petitions stands disposed. Pending application(s), if any,
also stands disposed.”
Aggrieved by the above quoted order of the learned Single
Judge dated 09.04.2021, the present writ appeals have been
preferred by the State respondents (appellants herein) for setting
aside the said order.
[7]
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the
State appellants submits that learned Single Judge has committed
serious error in passing the judgment in favour of the petitioners
(respondents herein) by not considering that the appointment of
those 8(eight) lecturers were made through an interview and later
on, they were brought under regular appointment granting only age
relaxation and relaxation in the mode of direct recruitment as
approved by the council of ministers, while the writ petitioners have
never subjected themselves to any such interview or the selection
process for the post of Lecturer, DIET whatsoever for recruitment
substantively to the post. He, therefore, urges before this Court that
the impugned judgment and order passed by the learned Single
Judge is liable to be set aside.
[8]
the
It is further contended on behalf of the State that as per
memorandum
dated
15th
May,
the
petitioners
(respondents herein) applied for deputation in the DIET and
subsequently, they were placed at the disposal of the Principal,
District Institute of Education, Agartala as per the memo dated
17.7.2003 issued by the Director of School Education, Tripura. The
clause-3 of memorandum dated 15th May, 2003 issued by the
Director of School Education more particularly clause „3C‟ clearly
indicates that the school teachers selected for deputation to the
institutions of teacher education shall not be entitled to any extra
financial benefits during the period of their deputation in the
teacher training institutions. Neither will they be entitled to claim
absorption, higher scale of pay, promotion, etc, for working in the
above teacher training institutions on deputation. They will continue
to get pay and allowances in their respective scales of pay they
used to get in their respective schools as school teachers before
deputation. Now, in the present situation, they cannot claim that
their cases should be treated at par with the 8(eight) lecturers
those who were appointed through an interview and later on, they
were brought under regular appointment in the mode of direct
recruitment. For the purpose of reference, Clause-3 of the said
memorandum dated 15th May, 2003 issued by the Director of School
Education is quoted hereunder:
“…3. The following terms and conditions are laid down for the
school teachers who will opt for working in the teacher education
institutions under this Project.
A.
The persons selected for the assignment shall have to
perform duties assigned by the Heads of the Institutions.
B.
Their deputation shall be only for one academic session.
However, their deputation period may be extended further
depending upon the performances shown in the report of the
concerned Heads of the training institutions.
C.
The school teachers selected for deputation to the above
institutions *illegible not be entitled to any extra financial benefits
during the period of the deputation in the teacher training
institutions. Neither will they be entitled to claim absorption,
higher scale of pay, promotion, etc. for working in the above
teacher training institutions on deputation. They will continue to
get pay and allowances in their respective scales of pay they used
to get in their respective schools as school teachers before
deputation.
D.
As they shall be working in the institutions of teacher
education, their services may be needed even beyond normal
office schedules as such, they should be ready to serve extra time
without any extra benefits.
E.
If not found suitable, the deputed school teachers may be
sent back to their respective schools
even during the academic
session and the decision of the Education Department in this
regard shall be final…..”
[9]
On the other hand, Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior
counsel assisted by Mr. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents opposes the submission made by the Addl. G.A.
contending that the petitioners in the writ petition are severing at
the D.I.E.T for a long period and for the interest of justice, they
must be absorbed as Lecturer. To support his submission, learned
senior counsel has placed reliance on the following judgments of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court, the contents of the said judgments as
referred by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel is quoted herein-below:
(i) Nehru Yuva Kendra Sangathan v. Rajesh Mohan Shukla
and others reported in (2007) 6 SCC 9:
"9. Now, these appeals have come up for hearing. We find that
the nature of duties being discharged by the Youth
Coordinators who have come on deputation and have been
absorbed as such and those who were directly recruited on
fixed term are discharging the same duties. The only difference
is their source of recruitment. Once the deputationists are
discharging the same duties and are being paid salary and
other allowances then there is no reason to deny the same
benefits who are discharging the same duties and functions.
Those deputationists now absorbed obtained the order from
this Court but the direct recruits did not approach this Court,
they were treated as a class apart because of their source of
recruitment. Once these persons are already working for more
than two decades discharging the same functions and duties
then we see no reason why the same benefit should not be
given to the respondents. Looking to the nature and duties of
these respondents we are of opinion that there is no reason to
treat them differently. However, at the time of admission this
Court on 1-5-2000 confined the relief from the date of filing of
the writ petition before the High Court. In fact, these directly
recruited Youth Coordinators approached the Court in earlier
point of time but they were advised to approach the
Government and they did approach the Government but the
Government denied them the same relief as was given to the
deputationists. Therefore, there is no reason not to grant them
the same scale pay and as such this Court at the time of
admission has confined the relief that why it should not be
granted from the date of the filing of the writ petition in the
High Court. Accordingly, we dispose of these civil appeals with
a direction that the same benefits as were being given to the
Youth Coordinators who were initially on deputation and were
absorbed, should be given to the respondents from the date of
filing of the writ petition in the High Court of Allahabad. Hence,
the order of the High Court of Allahabad is affirmed with minor
modification as indicated above. There would be no order as to
costs.”
(ii) Food Corporation of India and others v. Ashis Kumar
Ganguly and others reported in (2009) 7 SCC 734:
"17. The learned Additional Solicitor General drew our
attention to the statements made in the rejoinder affidavit to
show as to how the Central Government employees were
different from that of the State Government employees. Only
because, according to the Corporation, they were treated
differently, in our opinion, by itself cannot be a ground not to
apply the rules applicable to the employees of Food
Corporation of India on their absorption in the services of Food
Corporation of India only because they have been taken from
the different sources. Different treatments meted out to the
respondents vis-a-vis the Central Government employees
although drawn from separate cadre, for the purpose of grant
of benefit to one class only, would, in our opinion, amount to
discrimination.
************************
30. It is contended that the deputationists who were the
Central Government employees were transferred in terms of
Section 12-A of the Act. We may notice sub-section (3) threof,
which reads as under:
"12-A.(3) An officer or other employee transferred by an
order made under sub-section (1) shall, on and from the date
of transfer, cease to be an employee of the Central
Government and become an employee of the Corporation with
such designation as the Corporation may determine and shall
subject to the provisions of sub-sections (4), (4A), (4B), (4C),
(5) and (6) to be governed by the regulations made by the
Corporation under this Act as respects remuneration and other
conditions of service including pension, leave and provident
fund, and shall continue to be an officer or employee of the
Corporation unless and until his employment is terminated by
the Corporation."
As in terms of the aforementioned provision, the employees so
transferred would be deemed to be the employees of the
Corporation upon cessation of the relationship of employer and
employee between the Central Government and themselves
and they would be subject to the provisions of the same
regulations.
31. Incidentally, we may notice that even in the Circular Letter
dated 19-3-1984, it was categorically stated:
"The absorption of the employees will be subject to the
following conditions:
(i) The State Government employees who opt for
permanent absorption in the service of the Corporation will be
treated as direct recruit and will be subject to the terms and
conditions as prescribed in FCI (Staff) Regulations, 1971."
25. If respondents, thus, were to be treated as direct recruits
subject to the terms and conditions and as prescribed in FCI
Staff Regulations, 1971, in law they were also required to be
treated alike as having entered the services of the Corporation
for the first time. Even their seniority in the post in which they
were absorbed was to be accounted from the date of
absorption in the Corporation.
32. Thus, for all intent and purport, the past services of the
Central Government employees and the State Government
employee whether appointed in the service of the Corporation
by way of transfer or by way of absorption would result in
cessation of relationship of employer and employee between
the Central Government or the State Government as the case
may be and the employees concerned. In other words, until
their absorption, the respondents were the employees of the
State Government and they become the employees of the
Corporation only upon their absorptions. Furthermore in the
cases of both the Central Government employees as also the
State Government employees, common regulation would bind
them since their absorption in the service of the Corporation
either in terms of sub-section (3) of Section 2A of the Act or in
terms of the order of absorption passed in respect of each of
the respondents.
33. Submission of the learned Additional Solicitor General that
the employees transferred from the Central Government and
those deputationists who have been absorbed fall in different
classes cannot be accepted.
34. The learned Additional Solicitor General pointed out the
following purported differences between the two groups of
employees:
"a. The services of the food transferees from Central
Government were transferred to FCI on compulsory/permanent
basis after Central Government Gazette Notification, in
accordance with Section 12A of the Food Corporations Act,
1964. Whereas the West Bengal Deputationists were sent on
deputation to FCI as per agreement with the Government of
West Bengal and FCI.
b. The Food transferees from Central Government had no
option for joining or otherwise in the FCI on transfer from RDF.
It was compulsory for them. Whereas there was no compulsion
for West Bengal Deputationists for their absorption in FCI.
They had an option either to be repatriated to their parent
department. Govt. of West Bengal or to be inducted in FCI as
per FCI, HQ circular No.21 of 19.3.1984.
c. After the transfer of the services of the Food transferees
from Central Government to FCI, their parent department was
wound up except for existence of power with 1 or 2 officers to
settle their pension cases. Whereas existence of the parent
department of West Bengal Deputationists i.e. Food & Supplies
Department, Government of West Bengal with manpower
was/is all along there.
d. The Food transferees from Central Government did not have
to tender any resignation with their parent department for
transfer of their services to FCI. Whereas the deputationists
emplopyees had to resign from the Department of Food &
Supplies of West Bengal before their absorption in FCI.
e. The Food transferees from Central Government enjoyed
continuity of their services. They were the food "Transferees".
Whereas by virtue of the option exercised with FCI by the
Deputationists Employees, their status is of a direct recruit
w.e.f. 01.07.1984.
f. On joining FCI, the Food transferees from Central
Government did not get any gratuity from their parent
department in respect of their services rendered with the
Government of India. Whereas the Deputationists Employees
had received their gratuity and pro-rata pension from their
parent department for the services they rendered with the
Government of West Bengal.
g. The Food Corporation of India (Staff) Regulations, 1971
were not in existence at the initial stage of the transfer of the
RDR Employees in FCI. Whereas at the time of the absorption
of the Deputationist Employees in FCI, the Food Corporation of
India (Staff) Regulations, 1971 were in existence."
35. We would deal with them in seriatum:
a. The conditions of service of employees from two different
sources can not be different only because they were recruited
from different sources. In view of the fact that both the set of
employees were governed by the same set of regulations, it
would not be correct to contend that the transferees from the
Central Government had no option.
b. It was for the Central Government to issue an appropriate
notification in terms of Section 12A(1) of the Act. Only when
such an order was issued, sub-section (3) thereof would come
into play. Applicability of a rule would not depend upon the
question as to whether the respondents had an option either to
be repatriated to their parent department or not inasmuch as
the rule became applicable only on their absorption and not
prior thereto.
c. No additional fact has been placed before us in support of
the statement that the entire Food Department was wound up.
Even if that be so, in absence of any such regulation governing
their cases, they could have been given the benefit of an
additional increment to which other employees were also
entitled to.
d. For the aforementioned reasons, in our opinion, it is wholly
immaterial as to whether cessation of relationship of employer
and employee took place by reason of resignation or by
transfer.
e. In view of the terms and conditions of transfer so far as the
Central Government employees are concerned and the option
exercised by the deputationists as well the effect of Regulation
81, there is no force in the aforementioned contention.
f. As in the case of the employees of the Central Government,
the continuity of service had been maintained only because the
deputationists had received their gratuity and pro-rata pension
from their parent department, in our opinion would not make
any difference as the sole question was as to whether the
proviso appended to Rule 81 was applicable in their case or
not.
g. We have noticed hereinbefore that even before coming into
force of the FCI Staff Regulations, 1971, there existed a similar
provision by way of paragraph 4.68 of the Mannual. Thus,
whereas in the case of the Central Government employees, the
earlier provisions were applied, in the case of the State
Government employees, the regulations are to be made
applicable.
36. Submission of the learned Additional Solicitor General that
Article 14 of the Constitution of India postulates a valid
classification cannot be said to have any application in the
instant case. The High Court, in our opinion, has rightly found
that in the matter of grant of benefits under proviso appended
to Regulation 81, all the employees were similarly situated.
37. In a case of this nature, legal right of the respondents
emanated from violation of the equality clause contained in
Article 14. If they were otherwise similarly situated, there was
absolutely no reason why having regard to the provisions
contained in Article 39A of the Constitution of India, the
respondents should be treated differently. It is, therefore, not
a case where persons differently situated are being treated
differently as was submitted by Mr. Saran.
**********************************
40. In Haryana State Minor Irrigation Tubewells Corportion &
Ors. v. G.S. Uppal & Ors. [(2008) 7 SCC 375]
"19. In S.B. Vohra case this Court dealing with the fixation
of pay scales of officers of the High Court of Delhi (Assistant
Registrars) held that the fixation of pay scales is within the
exclusive domain of the Chief Justice, subject to approval of
President/Governor of the State and the matter should either
be examined by an expert body or in its absence by the Chief
Justice and the Central or State Government should attend to
the suggestions of the Chief Justice with reasonable
promptitude so as to satisfy the test of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. Further, it was observed that financial
implications vis-`-vis effect of grant of a particular scale of pay
may not always be a sufficient reason and differences should
be mutually discussed and tried to be solved.
20. In State of Haryana case this Court held that the High
Court was in error in allowing the parity in pay scale to State
Civil Secretariat PAs with Central Secretariat PAs merely
because the designation was same, without comparing the
nature of their duties and responsibilities and qualifications for
recruitment and without considering the relevant rules,
regulations and executive instructions issued by the employer
and governing the cadre concerned.
21. There is no dispute nor can there be any to the
principle as settled in the abovecited decisions of this Court
that fixation of pay and determination of parity in duties is the
function of the executive and the scope of judicial review of
administrative decision in this regard is very limited. However,
it is also equally well settled that the courts should interfere
with the administrative decisions pertaining to pay fixation and
pay parity when they find such a decision to be unreasonable,
unjust and prejudicial to a section of employees and taken in
ignorance of material and relevant factors. (See K.T. Veerappa
v. State of Karnataka)"
Such a question does not arise in this case as it has been
found that the action on the part of the appellant is grossly
arbitrary.
41. It was furthermore contended by Mr. Saran that in the
event a finding is arrived at that the Central Government
employees had been given, an advance increment wrongly,
similar benefit may not be granted to the respondents on the
premise that no equality can be claimed in illegality. Such a
case has never been made out by the appellants. Even
otherwise, we are of the opinion, the Central Government
employees have rightly been given the benefit of one
additional increment in terms of the proviso appended to
Regulation 81 of the Regulations.......”
It is contended on behalf of the State that the case
[10]
of the petitioners (respondents herein) cannot be treated for on
deputation and they cannot seek any shelter comparing them be on
par with any other employees and they cannot seek a relief of
absorption as petitioners continued their services in Education
Department only as a teacher and they did not go on deputation to
any other department or State/local body. Thus they are not
entitled to claim relief of absorption and consequential benefits or
reliefs and prayed to dismiss the writ petitions.
[11]
Heard the submissions made at the Bar. Perused the
record.
[12]
On perusal of record, it is a clear case that the
petitioners have opted for service and their services were obtained
as teacher. The above-quoted clause-3 of the memorandum dated
15th May, 2003 issued by the Director of School Education clearly
indicates that there cannot be any benefit accruing out of this
deputation.
[13]
The petitioners joined D.I.E.T. in the year 2003 in terms
of memorandum dated 17.07.2003 issued by the Director of School
Education, Tripura. The same is extracted below for the purpose of
reference:
“NO.F.3(1-99) DSE/2000
Government of Tripura
Directorate of School Education
Estt. Training Section
Dated, Agartala, the 17.7.2003
MEMO
Subject:- Placement of services of Post Graduate Teacher to District Institute of Education,
(DIET) Abhoynagar, Agartala.
The services of the following Post Graduate Teachers are hereby placed at the
disposal of the Principal, District Institute of Education, Agartala to teach 6 months abridge
course teachers trainees for the period of 1(one) year from the date of joining at District
Institute of Education, Abhoynagar, Agartala or till recruitment of regular teachers for
DIET, Abhoynagar, Agartala whichever is earlier with the following terms and conditions:
2.
i)
ii)
Terms and Conditions
While serving in the DIET, Abhoynagar, Agartala the teacher concerned will not be
allowed any extra remuneration or deputation allowance during the period of
deputation.
The concerned teacher also will not be allowed to claim higher scale on the plea
that they are serving in the DIET, Abhoynagar, Agartala.
3.
The deputation of the concerned teachers will finally be accepted by the Principal,
DIET, Abhoynagar, Agartala subject to the production of written undertaking to the effect
that the concerned teacher will abide by the terms and conditions laid down in the forgoing
para.
4.
The principal, DIET, Abhoynagar, Agartala is directed to obtain a written
undertaking from the teacher concerned in the time of joining and the same copy of
written undertaking should be forwarded to the Directorate of School Education, Estt.
Training Section and other copy of the same will be sent to the Director, SCERT,
Abhoynagar.
5.
The concerned teacher are directed to report to the Principal, DIET, Abhoynagar,
Agartala on 26th July, 2003 positively.
6.
The concerned Head of Office shall release the concerned teachers immediately.
SL.
NO
1.
Name and Present place of posting.
Subject.
Shri Manoj Kumar Deb, A/T
Chebri Govt. H.S. School, Khowai.
Bengali.
2.
Shri Subash Ch Shil, A/T
Tuichindraibari H.S. School, Teliamura.
Bengali.
3.
Shri Brajendra Kishore Singha, A/T
Halhali H.S. School, Kamalpur.
English.
4.
Smti Nandini Bhattacharjee, A/T
Taltala H.S. School, Bamutia.
English.
5.
Smti Sumita Banerjee, A/T
B.K. Girls H.S. School.
Life
Science.
6.
Smti Susmita Bhattacharjee, PGT,
Chandrapur H.S. School, Udaipur.
Life
Science.
7.
Shri Chayan Paul, PGT,
Navagram H.S. School, Sadar,
Math.
8.
Shri Prasanjit Roy, A/T
Bishrambari S.B. School I/S Jirania.
Math.
6.
7.
[14]
NO TA/DA will be admissible for this purpose.
Pay and allowances will be drawn by the concerning Head of Office after receiving
the working report from the Principal, DIET, Agartala in every months.
Sd/(M.S. Bhattacharjee)
Director of School
Education.
Tripura.”
It is also seen from record that the service of Smt.
Susmita bhattacharje @ Susmita Bhattacharya, respondent in WA
No.197 of 2021 was extended in D.I.E.T until further order as per
the memo dated 25.6.2005 issued by the Director of School
Education, Tripura. For the purpose of reference, the same is
extracted as under:
“No.F.1(7-1)-SE-E(NG)/2005
Government of Tripura
Directorate of School Education
Estt. (NG) Section
Dated, Agartala, the 25.6.2005
M E M O
Following 3(three) Assistant Teachers who are working at DIET, Agartala as per
memos No.F.3(67)-DSE/04 dated 15.6.2004 and No.F.3(1-99)-DSE/2002 dated 15.7.2004
are hereby allowed to continue at DIET, Agartala until further order.
1. Smt. Rajkumari Kanchanprava Sinha, A/T, Banividyapith Girls H.S.
School, Agartala.
2. Smt. Nandini Bhattacharjee, A/T, Taltala H.S. School, Bamutia.
3. Smt. Susmita Bhattacharjee, PGT, Chandrapur H.S. School, Udaipur.
Other terms and condition shall remain unchanged.
Sd/(Santanu Das)
Director of School Education
Tripura”
[15]
Insofar as, the appointments made in terms of selection
procedure for recruiting Lecturer by notification dated 17th June,
2004 is concerned, the same is extracted as under:
“No F2A(10-40) DSE/2001
Government of Tripura
Education (School) Department
Dated, Agartala 17th June, 2004
NOTIFICATION
In continuation of this Department Memorandum of even number dated
28.05.2004 and on recommendation of the Tripura Public Service Commission, the
Governor of Tripura is pleased to appoint the following persons to the post of Lecturer,
District Institute of Education and Training (D.I.E.T) in the Scale of pay of Rs.7,450-225 –
11,500-250-13,000/- plus admissible allowances purely on temporary basis and posted to
the places as noted below in Col.No.3:Sl.
No.
1.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Name of the officers.
2.
Smt. Manidipa Gan Choudhuri, (U.R.)
A/T(HS), Charipara HS School, Bishalgarh
Smt. Chandana Bandyopadhyay, (U.R.)
C/O: Sri Mukundalala Bandyopadhyay,
Banamalipur, A.A. Road, Agartala- 799001
Smt. Paushali Das, (U.R.)
A/T(HS), Shishu Bihar HS School, Agartala
Sri Ashesh Datta, (U.R.)
A/T (HS), Chandrapur HS School, Udaipur
Smt. Sumita Datta, (U.R.)
AT (HS), Mirza HS School, Udaipur.
Smt. Mallika Das, (U.R.)
A/T (HS), Birendranagar HS School, Sadar
Sri Mihir Datta, (U.R.)
A/T (HS), Amarpur HS School, Amarpur
Smt. Maya Mukherjee (Bhowmik), (U.R.)
A/T (HS), Udaipur English Medium HS
Udaipur.
Posted to.
3.
D.I.E.T., Agartala
D.I.E.T., Kailashahar
D.I.E.T., Kakraban
D.I.E.T., Kakraban
D.I.E.T., Kamalpur
D.I.E.T., Agartala
D.I.E.T., Agartala
D.I.E.T., Kakraban
School,
2.
Sl. No(s) 1, 3, 4 & 6 to 8 will join in the respective D.I.E.Ts and Sl.No.2 and 5 will
report to the Deputy Director of Education, North Dist, Kailashahar and District Education
Officer, Dhalai Dist., Ambassa respectively on 30th June, 2004 positively by submitting
one-sided charge report under G.F.R.-33-A failing which his/her appointment shall
automatically be cancelled.
3.
They will remain on probation for a period of 2(two) years from the date of their
joining in the post.
4.
Their pay etc. will be fixed as per normal rules except under Sl.No.2.
5.
The above appointments are subject to police verification reports in case anyone is
found unsuitable for Government job as per police verification reports, his/her
appointment shall be terminated *illegible.
6.
They are entertained against 8 of 30 temporary posts of Lecturer, D.I.E.T. cleared
vide No.F.36(10)-SCERT/97/5379-125 dated 11.06.98. The expenditure on this account
shall be debitable to the Head of Account:- 2202- General Education, 02- Secondary
Education, 004- Research and Training (SCERT) (Non-Plan)
By order of the Governor,
Sd/(Ms. S. Deb)
Under Secretary to the
Government of Tripura.”
A fair reading of the above quoted Notification
[16]
dated 17th June, 2004 clearly indicates that the selection procedure
which
is
referred
above
is
different
and
it
requires
the
recommendations from the TPSC. Insofar as, the selection of the
petitioners is concerned, it was done as per the selection procedure
of the year 2003 as discussed earlier and the petitioners now
cannot be entitled for any additional benefits including absorption.
The petitioner-respondents cannot compare themselves on par with
the other candidates who were selected subsequent to their
selection in the year 2004 by a different selection procedure in
terms of the Clause-3 of the Memorandum dated 15th May, 2003
issued by the Director of School Education. The said arguments
made on behalf of the petitioners cannot be appreciated and the
same is devoid of merit. The judgments cited on behalf of the
petitioners is of no relevant to the facts of the case as the
petitioners continued their services in the Education Department
only as a teacher and did not go on deputation to any other
department or State/local body. We find force in the argument
made on behalf of the appellant-State.
In view of the above observation, we are of the opinion that
the order passed by the learned Single Judge on 09.04.2021 is
liable to be set aside and accordingly, the same is set aside.
Resultantly, the present writ appeals filed by the State stand
allowed and the same are disposed of.
As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s) pending, if any, shall
also stand closed.
B. PALIT, J
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
SABYASACHI GHOSH
Date: 2024.03.20 16:16:38
+05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review