The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
2. Smt. Sarmistha Laskar (Das), 34, Azad Hind Road, Dhaleswar, Agartala, P.O. Dhaleswar, PS-East Agartala, Sub-DivisionSadar, District-West Tripura. [The Next-of-kin, Legal Heir and W/o Late Nalini Ranjan Das, ExOfficer of Tripura Police Service]. By Advocate : Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Adv. Mr. P. Chakraborty, Adv. Date of hearing & delivery of Judgment & order : 2nd July, 2024. Whether fit for reporting : √ …………Proforma Respondent HON‟BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL) Heard Mr. S. Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the writ petitionerappellant in WA No.30 of 2023 and for the respondent in WA No.53 of 2023. Also heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the State-respondents in WA No.30 of 2023 and for the State appellants in WA No.53 of 2023. [2] Both the appeals having arisen out of a judgment dated 20.02.2023 passed in WP(C) No. 426 of 2021, have been heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment. [3] The short question falls for consideration in both the appeals is whether grant of two different pay scales to two different employees working in the same postone appointed by direct recruitment and another by way of promotion is permissible at law especially when the senior is getting lower pay scale than his junior. [4] The writ petitioner namely, Pinaki Samanta was directly app…
11. The Office Memorandum dated 4.11.1993, Government of India, Department of Personnel & Training, has set out the various instances where stepping of pay cannot be done. It gives, inter alia, the following instances which have come to the notice of the Department with a request for stepping up of pay. There are: „(a) Where a senior proceeds on Extraordinary Leave which results in postponement of date of next increment in the lower post, consequently he starts drawing less pay than his junior in the lower grade itself. He, therefore, cannot claim pay parity on promotion even though he may be promoted earlier to the higher grade: (b) If a senior foregoes/refuses promotion leading to his junior being promoted/appointed to the higher post earlier, the junior draws higher pay than the senior. The senior may be on deputation while the junior avails of the ad hoc promotion in the cadre. The increased pay drawn by a junior either due to ad hoc officiating/regular service rendered in the higher posts for periods earlier than the senior, cannot, therefore, be an anomaly in strict sense of the term. (c) If a senior joins the higher post later than the junior for whatsoever reasons, whereby he draws less pay than the junior, in such cases the senior cannot claim stepping up of pay on a par with the junior." (d) ***‟ There are also other instances cited in the Memorandum. The Memorandum makes…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A. No.30 of 2023
W.A. No.53 of 2023
In W.A. No.30 of 2023
Sri Pinaki Samanta,
son of Sri Jogendra Chandra Samanta, Tripura
Police Service, resident of Ramkrishna Ashram
Road, Town Bordawali, PO-Agartala, PS-West
Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-700001;
……… Appellant
By Advocate :
Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary & Commissioner,
Department of Finance, Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New
Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Sadar, DistrictWest Tripura.
2.
The Deputy Secretary,
Department of Finance (Establishment Branch),
Government of Tripura, having his office at New
Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.OKunjaban, P.S-New Capital Complex, SubDivision-Sadar, District-West Tripura.
3.
The Commissioner & Secretary,
GA (P&T) Department, Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New
Capital Complex, Sub- Division-Sadar, DistrictWest Tripura.
4.
Smt. Sarmistha Laskar (Das),
34, Azad Hind Road, Dhaleswar, Agartala, P.O.
Dhaleswar, PS-East Agartala, Sub-DivisionSadar, District- West Tripura. [The Next-of-kin,
Legal Heir and W/o Late Nalini Ranjan Das,
[Ex-Officer of Tripura Police Service];
By Advocate :
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. GA
……. Official Respondents
…………Proforma Respondent
In W.A. No.53 of 2023
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary & Commissioner,
Department of Finance, Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New
Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Sadar, DistrictWest Tripura.
2.
The Deputy Secretary,
Department of Finance (Establishment Branch),
Government of Tripura, having his office at New
Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala, POKunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, SubDivision-Sadar, District-West Tripura.
3.
The Commissioner & Secretary,
GA (P&T) Department, Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New
Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Sadar, DistrictWest Tripura.
……… Appellants
By Advocate :
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. GA
–Versus–
1. Sri Pinaki Samanta,
son of Sri Jogendra Chandra Samanta, Tripura
Police Service, resident of Ramkrishna Ashram
Road, Town Bordawali, P.O-Agartala, P.S-West
Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-700001;
…………Respondent
2. Smt. Sarmistha Laskar (Das),
34, Azad Hind Road, Dhaleswar, Agartala, P.O.
Dhaleswar, PS-East Agartala, Sub-DivisionSadar, District-West Tripura. [The Next-of-kin,
Legal Heir and W/o Late Nalini Ranjan Das, ExOfficer of Tripura Police Service].
By Advocate :
Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of hearing & delivery
of Judgment & order
:
2nd July, 2024.
YES
Whether fit for reporting
:
√
NO
…………Proforma Respondent
HON‟BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. S. Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the writ petitionerappellant in WA No.30 of 2023 and for the respondent in WA No.53 of 2023. Also
heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the State-respondents in WA
No.30 of 2023 and for the State appellants in WA No.53 of 2023.
[2]
Both the appeals having arisen out of a judgment dated 20.02.2023 passed
in WP(C) No. 426 of 2021, have been heard together and are being disposed of by this
common judgment.
[3]
The short question falls for consideration in both the appeals is whether
grant of two different pay scales to two different employees working in the same postone appointed by direct recruitment and another by way of promotion is permissible at
law especially when the senior is getting lower pay scale than his junior.
[4]
The writ petitioner namely, Pinaki Samanta was directly appointed to the
post of Tripura Police Service (Grade-II), [TPS Grade II in short], by way of direct
recruitment on 31.10.1998 in pre-revised pay scale of Rs.2100-3000-5000/-, as was
admissible under Tripura Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 1988. Thereafter, Tripura
State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 1999 (for short, ROP Rules, 1999) came into
force with retrospective effect from 01.01.1996. As per ROP Rules 1999, the pay scale
admissible to direct recruitee in the said grade was revised to Rs.7800-15100/- and
accordingly, the pay of the writ petitioner was fixed in the said scale.
[5]
Subsequently, on 28-03-2000, one Nalini Ranjan Das (now deceased), the
husband of the proforma-respondent was promoted to said post of TPS (Grade-II) from
the feeder post of Inspector of Police.
[6]
The ROP Rules, 1999 provided a higher pay scale of Rs. 10,000-15,000/-
at the initial entry for the promotee TPS (Grade-II) officers and accordingly, pay of said
Nalini Ranjan Das was fixed in that scale. According to writ petitioner, he was not aware
of such higher fixation of pay of his junior and at a much later stage, when he came to
know about said difference in pay that his junior officer was getting higher pay than him,
he submitted the representation on 08.05.2020 and again on 23.06.2020 to the Finance
Department for stepping up of his pay which was ultimately turned down and thereafter,
he filed WP(C) No.426 of 2021 and the learned Writ Court allowed the said petition in
the following terms:
“5.2 In the light of the above analysis on facts and legal issues involved in
the instant writ petition and for the foregoing reasons, the State-respondents
are directed to re-fix the scale of pay of the petitioner by way of steppingup/up-grading his pay scale to Rs.10,000-15,100/- w.e.f. 28.03.2000, i.e. the
date when the said pay scale was given to the proforma-respondent, Sri
Nalini Ranjan Das. Needless to say, all financial benefits, the petitioner is
entitled to under the ROP Rules ,1999 and subsequent revision of Pay Rules,
should be fixed notionally till the date prior to 1 (one) year of the date of
filing of the writ petition. To re-iterate, the relief relating to payment of
arrears is restricted to only 1(two) year before the date of filing of the writ
petition and such payment would not carry interest.”
[7]
Being aggrieved by the said decision only with regard to limiting the
payment of arrear only for 1 (one) year before filing the writ petition, the writ petitioner
preferred W.A. No.30 of 2023 claiming arrear at least for 3 (three) years prior to filing of
the writ petition. Simultaneously, the State respondents have preferred the writ appeal
bearing WA No.53 of 2023 challenging the said decision mainly on the ground that
when the ROP Rules, 1999 created difference between the pay scale of a promotee
officer and a direct recruitee, the petitioner could not claim the pay fixation at par with
the said promotee officer. According to them, as per ROP Rules, 1999, a direct recruitee
was entitled to move to CAS-1 after completion of 4 (four) years of service which was
duly granted to the writ petitioner.
[8]
During hearing, Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl. GA submits that both rules
9A and 9B of ROP Rules, 1999 were not applicable in case of the present writ petitioner
and moreso, FR 22(I)(a)(1) was also not applicable in his case inasmuch as he was a
direct recruitee and said ROP Rules of 1999 prescribes different pay scales for direct
recruitee and a promotee.
[9]
According to Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl. GA both the sources of holding
the said post of TPS (Grade-II) by the petitioner as well as said Late Nalini Ranjan Das
were different and therefore, they cannot be treated equally at par so far as their pay
fixation is concerned and above all, the matter of pay fixation is an expertise subject
dealt with by a pay commission and therefore, the court normally should not interfere in
the matter.
[10]
He also relies on a decision of Apex Court in Union of India & Ors. vs.
Shri C.R. Madhava Murthy & Anr. [Civil Appeal Nos. 2087-2088 of 2022] decided
on 06.04.2022 wherein the persons who were placed lower in the upgradation list than
the writ petitioner were drawing higher pay due to upgradation granted to them under
ACP scheme. The writ petitioners submitted representation to the Department for
stepping up of their pay at par with the juniors. Finally Apex Court held that High Court
was justified directing the appellants to step up the pay of the writ petitioners keeping in
view of pay scale which has been granted to the juniors from the date they have started
drawing lesser pay than their juniors.
[11]
Mr. Debbarma also relies on another decision of Apex Court in the case of
Union of India v. R. Swaminathan, (1997) 7 SCC 690. In this case, the benefit of
stepping up was not allowed for the following reasons :
“9. We are, however, in the present case, concerned basically with
Fundamental Rule 22(I)(a)(1) and the proviso to Fundamental Rule 22
because, in all these appeals, the junior employees who have got higher
pay on promotion than their seniors, had officiated in the promotional
post for different periods on account of local ad hoc promotions granted
to them. This is because the Department of Telecommunications is
divided into a number of circles within the country. The regular
promotions from the junior posts in question to the higher posts are on
the basis of all-India seniority. The Heads of Circles have, however,
been delegated powers for making local officiating arrangements based
on Circle seniority to the higher posts in question against short-term
vacancies up to 120 days in the event of the regular panelled officers not
being available in that Circle. This period of 120 days was subsequently
revised to 180 days. Under this provision for local officiation, the
seniormost official in the Circle is allowed to hold the charge of the
higher post for a limited duration. This is purely out of administrative
considerations and is resorted to in order to tide over the exigencies of
work. This practice, we are informed, has been followed in all Circles in
the Department of Telecommunications since 1970. This is because, at
times it is not possible to fill up all the vacancies in a particular Circle
for various reasons such as non-joining by a particular person, chain
promotions or short-term vacancies arising on account of leave etc. It is
submitted before us by the Department that it is not always possible to
convene meetings of the departmental promotion committee for filling
up all the posts which are only available for short periods on all-India
basis because of administrative problems. To fill up this gap, the
Government has issued instructions from time to time to allow local
officiating arrangements in the interest of work. The Department has
also pointed out that all the aggrieved employees in these appeals have
availed of such officiating promotions as and when such occasion arose
in their Circle and they were eligible. The juniors, therefore, in each of
these cases who have received a higher pay on their regular promotion
than the seniors, have received this higher pay on account of the
application of the proviso to Fundamental Rule 22.
…….
…….
…….
11. The Office Memorandum dated 4.11.1993, Government of India,
Department of Personnel & Training, has set out the various instances
where stepping of pay cannot be done. It gives, inter alia, the following
instances which have come to the notice of the Department with a
request for stepping up of pay. There are:
„(a) Where a senior proceeds on Extraordinary Leave which
results in postponement of date of next increment in the lower
post, consequently he starts drawing less pay than his junior in
the lower grade itself. He, therefore, cannot claim pay parity on
promotion even though he may be promoted earlier to the
higher grade:
(b) If a senior foregoes/refuses promotion leading to his junior
being promoted/appointed to the higher post earlier, the junior
draws higher pay than the senior. The senior may be on
deputation while the junior avails of the ad hoc promotion in the
cadre. The increased pay drawn by a junior either due to ad hoc
officiating/regular service rendered in the higher posts for periods
earlier than the senior, cannot, therefore, be an anomaly in strict
sense of the term.
(c) If a senior joins the higher post later than the junior for
whatsoever reasons, whereby he draws less pay than the junior,
in such cases the senior cannot claim stepping up of pay on a par
with the junior."
(d) ***‟
There are also other instances cited in the Memorandum. The
Memorandum makes it clear that in such instances a junior drawing
more pay than his senior will not constitute an anomaly and, therefore,
stepping up of pay will not be admissible. The increased pay drawn by a
junior because of ad hoc officiating or regular service rendered by him
in the higher post for periods earlier than the senior is not an anomaly
because pay does not depend on seniority alone nor is seniority alone a
criterion for stepping up of pay.”
The decision in this case was rendered in a different perspective
distinguishable with facts of the present appeals.
[12]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel for the writ petitioner, on the other hand,
argues that the learned Writ Court was completely justified directing the respondents to
fix the pay scale of the writ petitioner by way of stepping up but, according to him,
normally the arrear is allowed for at least 3 (three) years retrospectively prior to the date
of filing of writ petition, but here, the learned Writ Court without justifiable cause has
confined the monetary relief only for 1 (one) year.
[13]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel relies on the decision of Kamlakar &
Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors., (1999) 4 SSC 756 wherein it was observed that once
all the related persons came to one cadre, the distinction between direct recruits and
promotees disappears at any rate so far as equal treatment in the same cadre for payment
of pay scale given is concerned. It was also observed by the Apex Court that the
birthmarks have no relevance in this connection. Learned Writ Court also relied on this
judgment while coming to its conclusion.
[14]
In Union of India & Ors. vs. Atul Shukla & Ors., (2014) 10 SSC 432, as
relied on by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel, the followings were held by the Apex
Court:
“24. …..Classification of employees based on the method of their
recruitment has long since been declared impermissible by this Court. There
can be no differential treatment between an employee directly recuirted visà-vis another who is promoted. So long as the two employees are a part of
the same cadre, they cannot be treated differently either for purposes of pay
and allowances or other conditions of service, including the age of
superannuation…...”
[15]
Regarding continuous cause of action, Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel
also relied on another decision in the case of State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors vs.
Yogendra Shrivastava, (2010) 12 SCC 538 wherein at Para 18, the followings were
observed :
“18………………..Where the issue relates to payment or fixation of salary
or any allowance, the challenge is not barred by limitation or the doctrine of
laches, as the denial of benefit occurs every month when the salary is paid,
thereby giving rise to a fresh cause of action, based on continuing wrong.
Though the lesser payment may be a consequence of the error that was
committed at the time of appointment, the claim for a higher allowance in
accordance with the Rules (prospectively from the date of application)
cannot be rejected merely because it arises from a wrong fixation made
several years prior to the claim for correct payment. But in respect of grant
of consequential relief of recovery of arrears for the past period, the principle
relating to recurring and successive wrongs would apply. Therefore the
consequential relief of payment of arrears will have to be restricted to a
period of three years prior to the date of the original application. [See:
M.R. Gupta v. Union of India – (1995) 5 SCC 628, and Union of India v.
Tarsem Singh (2008) 8 SCC 648]”
[16]
ROP Rule, 1999 was published on 6.2.1999 giving its effect
retrospectively from 1.1.1996. Rule 9A of said ROP Rules mainly deals with the issue
where the pay of an employee was meanwhile stepped up on or after said date 1.1.1996
and in such cases it was envisaged that, validity of such stepping up would depend on
the actual necessity while fixing up the pay in revised scale of both the senior and junior
employees in the same cadre. It further stipulated that if the revised pay of senior
employee (without stepping up) in such cases was same or more as that of junior
employee in the revised scale, the benefit of stepping up would not be admissible.
However, if the revised pay of senior (without stepping up) was lower than that of junior
employee, the pay of senior employee would be stepped up to an amount equal to the
pay fixed for junior employee in the revised scale of pay from the date the stepping up
was permitted in the existing scale with the approval of the Finance Department or by
the Department as per existing orders of the Government.
[17]
Anyway, in Kamlakar‟s case it has been categorically observed by the
Apex Court that the birthmarks have no relevance in connection with fixation of pay. In
Atul Shukla‟s case also similar view was taken by the Apex Court that there can be no
differential treatment between an employee directly recruited vis-a-vis another who is
promoted, so long as the two employees are a part of the same cadre.
[18]
In view of the above, we are of the view that the present writ petitioner is
entitled to certain pay protection without refixing the pay of the writ petitioner by way of
stepping up of his pay to which the pay of said Nalini Ranjan Das was fixed. Further
keeping in view of the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Yogendra Shrivastava‟s
case we are also of the view that the actual benefits of such pay protection should be
limited up to 3(three) years.
For the foregoing reasons, both the appeals are partly allowed and are
disposed of in the following terms:
The State-respondents are directed to give similar financial
benefits to the writ petitioner equal to the gross salary of said Nalini Ranjan
Das with effect from the date when said Nalini Ranjan Das was promoted to
the post of TPS(Grade-II) i.e. from 28.03.2000 for 03 (three) years next and
the difference of the gross salary of Nalini Ranjan Das and the writ
petitioner, Sri Pinaki Samanta as was during that period should be paid by
way of arrear to the writ petitioner without changing or upgrading his pay
scale by way of stepping up. Such arrear should be paid by the Staterespondents within 3(three) months from the date of receipt of the copy of
the order.
The impugned judgment is accordingly interfered with and both appeals are
disposed of with the above said directions.
Interim application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA, J)
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2024.07.29 17:49:56 +05'30'
Sujay
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review