The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Therefore, keeping in view the facts and circumstances of the case, we feel that the interest of justice will be served if punishment of compulsory retirement is imposed upon the petitioner instead of punishment of dismissal from service. The impugned orders are modified accordingly. The petitioner shall be deemed to have been compulsorily retired from the date of his dismissal from service.
13. All the retiral and other pensionary benefits of the petitioner shall be released to him within 6 (six) months from today, failing which the petitioner shall be entitled to interest @ 12% per annum on the entire amounts w.e.f. 01.5.2016……………….” [16] The writ petitioner is a TSR personnel who has served his department for about 20 years and the allegation against him is that he violated Rule 21 of the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988 contracting a second marriage while his first spouse was living. In this regard, this Court is in complete agreement with the observations made in the judgment passed by the learned Division Bench of this Court in Ghulam Nabi Shergujri (supra) to the fact that this is not a criminal offence of bigamy because the personal law of the writ petitioner permits such conduct. We are, therefore, of the opinion that though the misconduct of the writ petitioner is serious mandating his discontinuation in service but it is not so serious as to warrant forfeiture of his all service benefits. The act of second marriage without seeking permission of the Government is misconduct but it cannot be said that the misconduct is so severe in nature that he should be dismissed from service disentitling him from pensionary or other service benefits. Therefore, this Court is of view that the punishment imposed upon the writ petitioner is grossly unreasonable to…
01. 04.2026. With such observation and direction, the writ appeal is disposed of. Miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall also stand closed. S. Datta Purkayastha, J. Rudradeep RUDRADEEP BANERJEE Digitally Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No. 81 of 2025
1.
The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Principal Secretary, Department of Home, New
Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Agartala West Tripura.
2.
The Director General of Police, Tripura,
Agartala, Revisional Authority.
3.
The Deputy Inspector General of Police, AP (OPS-I),
Tripura, Agartala, Appellate Authority.
4.
The Commandant, 13th Bn, TSR (IR-IX),
Subhash Nagar, Kanchanpur, North Tripura, Disciplinary Authority.
5.
The AC, 13Bn TSR (IR-IX),
Enquiry Authority.
6.
The Inspector General of Police, AP (OPS) Tripura,
Agartala, Revisional Authority.
…….Appellant(s)
Versus
Sri Kabir Uddin of „F‟ COY, No.20005122 RFN (GD)
13 Battalion, Tripura State Rifles, (IR-IX),
S/o. Mobaswar Ali, presently residing at Vill & PO Kalachara, PS Kadamtala, Dist
North Tripura.
……..Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
For Respondent(s)
: Ms. Rajasree Purkayastha, Advocate
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
: 17.03.2026.
Whether fit for reporting
: No.
HON‟BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
[Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J.]
[1]
When the case is called, Mr. Karnajit De, learned Addl. G.A. appears
for the appellants (respondents of the writ petition) and Ms. Rajasree Purkayastha,
learned counsel appears on behalf of the respondent-writ petitioner (hereinafter
referred to as the writ petitioner).
[2]
The present appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated
16.05.2025 passed in WP(C) No.64 of 2024 whereby the learned Single Judge
allowed the petition filed by the writ petitioner.
[3]
The appellant-State has filed this appeal seeking the following reliefs:
“(i) Admit the appeal;
(ii) Call for the records of the Judgment & Order dated 16.05.2025 passed in WP(C)
64/2024 by the learned Single Judge;
(iii) Issue Notice;
(iv) After hearing the parties pleased to set aside the impugned Judgment and Order dated
16.05.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge and be pleased to allow the instant Writ
Appeal;
(v) Pass such other order or orders as seems fit and proper having regard to the
circumstances of the case.
AND
In the mean time the operative portion of the Judgment and order dated 16.05.2025 passed
by the learned Single Judge may be stayed till disposal of the writ appeal……..”
[4]
Factual context of the case is as under:
The writ petitioner was a TSR personnel bearing enrolment
No.20005122RFN(GD) of „F‟-COY,13th BN. TSR (IR-IX) and posted at Subhas
Nagar, Kanchanpur North Tripura under the kind, control and command of the
appellants herein. Since his appointment on 28.03.2000, the writ petitioner was
serving his duties with sincerity, honesty, diligence with utmost satisfaction of the
authorities without any blemish and stigma at any point of time. He is a married man
having his wife namely, Hazira Begam who is 39 years old and three daughters
namely, Yesmin Sultana (19 years), Sahanaj Aktar (17 years) and Nasrim Aktar (12
years). He is also the sole bread earner in his family and his service was the only
source of his family‟s livelihood. On 27.05.2019, one Smt. Khelan Bibi lodged a
complaint to the appellant No.4 herein alleging that the writ petitioner had
contracted marriage with her but he was not taking any care of her. On the basis of
said complaint, appellant No.4 initiated departmental proceeding against the writ
petitioner under Memorandum No. 8492/F.DP-NO./2019/K.U/TSR-13/ESTT/2019
as per Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal)
Rules, 1965 read with Rule 40 of the Tripura State Rifles (Discipline, Control,
Service Conditions, etc.), Rules 1986 for the alleged offence punishable under
Section 12(1) of Tripura State Rifles Act, 1983 framing article of charge against him
which are extracted hereunder:
“Article of Charge-I
That the said No.20005122 Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin of
'F'-Coy, 13th Bn TSR (IR-IX) got married one Smt. Khelan
Bibi D/O Khalek Miah of Vill: Thakcherra, PO.
Mahamillan, Amarpur, Gomati Tripura without any
consent and intimation to his first wife Smt. Hazira Begam
on 28.01.2016 at Thakcherra. This kind of act is prejudicial
to good order and discipline of the Rifles and punishable
U/S 12 (1) of TSR Act, 1983.
Article of Charge-II
That the said No. 20005122 Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin of
'F'-Coy, 13th Bn TSR (IR-IX) got married one Smt. Khelan
Bibi D/O Khalek Miah of Vill: Thakcherra, PO:
Mahamillan, Amarpur, Gomati Tripura without any prior
permission from the authority while his first wife is still
living. This kind of Act is prejudicial to good order and
discipline of the Rifles and punishable U/S 12(1) of TSR Act,
1983.”
[5]
Subsequently, a statement of imputation of misconduct or misbehavior
on which the article of charges were framed together with a list of documents and
witnesses by which the article of charges proposed to be sustained were issued
against the writ petitioner. Prior to that, according to the writ petitioner, a
preliminary enquiry was conducted by the authority behind the back of the writ
petitioner without affording any opportunity to him.
[6]
Shri R.L. Darlong, Asstt. Commandant, 13th Bn TSR (IR-IX) was
appointed as 'Inquiring Authority' to inquire into the charges framed against the writ
petitioner who after thorough inquiry submitted inquiry report (Annexure 4 to the
writ petition) wherein the article of charges framed were proved against the writ
petitioner. It is alleged by the writ petitioner that during the course of the inquiry, no
official formalities were observed and no opportunity was given to the writ
petitioner to defend his case properly and finally on the basis of the inquiry report,
the appellant No.4 came to the finding that the alleged charges under Article of
Charges I and II were proved against the writ petitioner. Thereafter, a provisional
punishment order was passed on 23.08.2021 in DP No.11/2019 (Annexure 5 to the
writ petition) against the writ petitioner tendering provisional major punishment of
"removal from service” which shall not be a disqualification for future employment
under the Government. Thereafter, the writ petitioner was given an opportunity to
make written representation against the report of provisional order of punishment to
which the he submitted his representation to the appellant No.4 on 09.09.2021. The
appellant No.4 passed final order on 02.10.2021 reducing the major punishment of
"removal from service” to “compulsory retirement” from service upon charged
official. Thereafter, against the final order, the writ petitioner filed appeal before the
appellate authority and the appellate authority rejected the appeal vide order dated
28.11.2021 on the ground of 30 days delay in filing such appeal from the date of
receipt of said final punishment order. Being aggrieved by the said order, the writ
petitioner approached before this Court by filing WP(C) No.14 of 2022 and this
Court vide order dated 18.01.2022 directed the appellate authority to reconsider his
appeal. Subsequently, appellant No.3 mechanically reconsidered the appeal and by
order dated 30.03.2022 (Annexure 8 to the writ petition) dismissed the same
upholding the findings of appellant No.4. Thereafter, the writ petitioner preferred
revision petition before the appellant No.6 which was also rejected vide order dated
21.05.2022 (Annexure 10 to the writ petition).
[7]
Being aggrieved, the writ petitioner again approached this Court
preferring WP(C) No.695 of 2022 and this Court vide order dated 28.06.2023
(Annexure 11 to the writ petition) quashed and set aside the order dated 21.05.2022.
Pursuant to the judgment passed by this Court in WP(C) No.695 of 2022, the
appellant No.2 again passed a revisional order dated 11.09.2023 (Annexure 12 to the
writ petition) rejecting said revisional order whereby most illegally the appellant
No.2 upheld the impugned appellate order dated 30.03.2022 passed by appellant
No.3. According to the writ petitioner, the entire proceeding was illegal as all the
orders were passed without providing any proper legal opportunity to him and
therefore, he filed WP(C) No.64 of 2024 for setting aside all the above mentioned
orders passed by the concerned authorities. On consideration of the arguments
placed and the documents relied upon by both sides, learned Single Judge allowed
the writ petition observing as under:
“12. In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner is allowed.
All the orders passed by the disciplinary authority, appellate
authority and revisional authority are accordingly stands set aside.
The matter is remanded back to the respondent No.4 i.e. the
appointing authority of the petitioner to reconsider the matter of
imposition of punishment upon the petitioner and thereafter to issue
a fresh order of punishment to the petitioner, if necessary by calling
the interested parties of the proceeding.
The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of
4(four) months from the date of passing of this judgment and order.
With this observation, the instant writ petition stands disposed
of.”
[8]
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment dated
16.05.2025, the appellants herein preferred the instant writ appeal by seeking the
reliefs as quoted above.
[9]
Mr. Karnajit De, learned Addl. G.A. for the appellants-State submits
that with respect to contracting a second marriage is concerned, a government
employee is governed by Rule 21 of the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules,
1988 which is applicable to the TSR personnel also and said Rule prohibits
government employees from entering into a new marriage if a spouse is already
living, or marrying someone who already has a living spouse and in case of
exceptions Government permission is required, granted only if permissible under
personal law and for valid grounds. Said Rule 21 is extracted hereunder:
“Rule - 21. Restriction regarding marriage
(1)
No Government employee shall enter into, or contract,
marriage with a person having a spouse living; and
(2)
No Government employee having a spouse living, shall enter
into, or contract, a marriage with any person;
Provided that the Government may permit a Government
employee to enter into, or contract, any such marriage as is referred
to in clause (1) or Clause (2) if it is satisfied that(a)
such marriage is permissible under the personal law
applicable to such Government employee and the other party to the
marriage; and
(b)
there are other grounds for, so doing;
(3)
A Government employee who has married or [marries] a
person other than of Indian nationality shall forthwith intimate the
fact to the Government.”
[10]
Mr. De, learned Addl. G.A. further submits that the writ petitioner, who
has a spouse living, has not approached before the Government or his authority
before contracting another marriage which was in violation of Rule 21 of the Tripura
Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988. Learned Addl. G.A. has relied on a decision
of the Division Bench of this High Court rendered in the case of Ghulam Nabi
Shergujri vs. the United of India and another reported in 2016 SCC OnLine Tri
259 at Paragraph No.8 of the judgment the followings were observed:
“8. The main argument raised on behalf of the petitioner is that since
second marriage is permissible under the Muslim Personal Law and
furthermore, since the Government has the power to grant such
permission, the conduct of the petitioner could not be treated to be
misconduct and, therefore, the services could not be terminated. We
are not in agreement with this submission. In case of any
Government employee who has a spouse living and such person
wants to enter into a second marriage which is permitted under his
personal law, he must approach the Central Government or the
authorities concerned with a prayer in which it should be clearly
spelt out that as per his personal law he is entitled to enter into a
second marriage and secondly, that such second marriage is
necessary for certain reasons. It is for the Government to decide
whether permission should be granted or not. It is not for the
employee to decide himself without approaching the Government
that he is entitled to get married a second time. This by itself is
misconduct and contracting a second marriage without the
permission of the Central Government, even if permissible under the
personal law, clearly amounts to misconduct and, therefore, the BSF
was entitled to take disciplinary action in terms of Rule 22 of the BSF
Rules.”
[11]
It is argued by Mr. De, learned Addl. G.A. that the article of charges
framed against the writ petitioner was proved during the course of DP enquiry based
on credible documentary evidence on record and even after lapse of two years from
the date of issue of Memorandum and issue of final order of punishment, the writ
petitioner failed to submit any kind of proof, evidence or witness to disprove those
article of charges proved against him. Another point of argument advanced by
learned Addl. G.A. is that the writ petitioner was asked to nominate defence assistant
but he declined to nominate defence assistant despite several opportunities given to
him during the enquiry. Learned Addl. G.A. further submits that the writ petitioner
had participated in the hearing of the DP enquiry from the beginning till the end of
such enquiry and as such he was given reasonable opportunities of being heard, and
therefore, principle of natural justice was duly served in each stages of the enquiry.
It is further argued by learned Addl. G.A. that in the present case the punishment of
“dismissal from service” had been converted to “compulsory retirement” of the writ
petitioner and the instant case is also squarely covered by the case of Ghulam Nabi
Shergujri (supra). Mr. De, learned Addl. G.A. finally submits that the learned
Single Judge erred in both fact and law in passing the impugned judgment and
prayed for setting aside the impugned judgment passed by the learned Single Judge.
[12]
On the other hand, Ms. Rajasree Purkayastha, learned counsel for the
respondent submits that the quantum of punishment awarded to the writ petitioner
was harsh in nature and urged before this Court for taking lenient view while doing
so, as he is the sole bread earner in his family and he has three minor daughters and
it would be difficult for him to maintain his family if he is not reinstated in service.
In this regard, Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel has referred to a decision of High
Court of Madhya Pradesh in case of Hem Singh vs. Union of India; WP(C)
No.1723 of 2007 decided on 21.06.2018 wherein the High Court of Madhya Pradesh
has held as under:
“Not only this, in another case decided by Manipur High
Court in the case of Union of India & three others v/s Mohammad
Jakir Hussain 2015 SCC Online Mani 67, a similar view has been
taken in respect of Constable of CRPF and the punishment of
dismissal has been set aside.
Not only this, in the case of Rameshwar Kumbhakar v/s
State of M.P. & Another passed in W.P. No.3816/2006 decided on
24.03.2015, again in case of second marriage during the life time
of the first wife, a similar view has been taken by this Court and
the punishment of dismissal from the services has been substituted
to that of withholding of one increment with cumulative effect.
Resultantly, the present writ petition also stands allowed.
The punishment of dismissal is substituted to that of withholding
of one increment with cumulative effect. The Constable/petitioner
will not be entitled for backwages, however, he will be entitled for
continuity in the services and for all other consequential benefits.
The respondents are also directed to reinstate the petitioner
within thirty days from the date of receipt of certified copy of this
order in case he has not attained the age of superannuation.”
[13]
We have carefully considered the submissions of the learned counsel
appearing for the parties and also meticulously gone through the records.
[14]
It appears to this Court from the final order passed by appellant No.4,
order of the appellate authority and order of the revisional authority that the writ
petitioner during hearing of the DP was given ample opportunities of being heard.
He was also given the facilities to inspect the documents in the DP file and also to
keep notes of the same. The writ petitioner did not give any requisition for additional
documents or defense witnesses in spite of the opportunities given to him. He was
also asked to nominate defence assistant but he declined to nominate defence
assistant despite several opportunities given to him during the enquiry.
[15]
It is also evident that writ petitioner neither informed nor obtained any
permission from his department before contracting second marriage which is in
violation of Rule 21 of the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988. In the case
of Ghulam Nabi Shergujri (supra) as relied on by learned Addl. G.A., in an
identically placed situation, followings were observed by the Division Bench of this
Court:
“9. Having held so, we are clearly of the view that the punishment
imposed upon the petitioner is grossly disproportionate to the
misconduct committed by him. We must keep in mind the fact
that the petitioner had already rendered 18 years of service before
he contracted into the second marriage. He was terminated after
he had completed almost 20 years of service. In the reply, there is
no allegation that there was any other complaint against the
petitioner. No doubt, his act of marrying a second time without
seeking permission of the Government is misconduct but can it be
said that this misconduct is so severe that he should be dismissed
from service which would mean that he would virtually be entitled
to no pensionary or other benefits.
10. The petitioner has pleaded that he was not aware of the
provisions of Rule 21 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules. Ignorance of
law is no excuse but at the same time, we cannot ourselves ignore
the hard truth that a large number of employees are not aware of
the details of the rules. Whatever be the case, the petitioner is a
person who served the BSF for about 20 years and the allegation
against him is that he misconducted himself by contracting a
second marriage while his first spouse was living. This is not a
criminal offence of bigamy because the personal law permits such
conduct. Misconduct is the technical misconduct in not seeking
permission of the authorities concerned. We are, therefore, of the
opinion that though the misconduct of the petitioner is serious
enough to warrant his non-continuation in service but it is not so
serious as to warrant forfeiture of all his service benefits.
11. It is true that normally the writ Court does not interfere in
matters of punishment and does not impose a punishment by itself
but we are clearly of the view that this is one of those glaring cases
where the punishment is totally disproportionate to the
misconduct.
12. Therefore, keeping in view the facts and circumstances of the
case, we feel that the interest of justice will be served if
punishment of compulsory retirement is imposed upon the
petitioner instead of punishment of dismissal from service. The
impugned orders are modified accordingly. The petitioner shall be
deemed to have been compulsorily retired from the date of his
dismissal from service.
13. All the retiral and other pensionary benefits of the petitioner
shall be released to him within 6 (six) months from today, failing
which the petitioner shall be entitled to interest @ 12% per
annum on the entire amounts w.e.f. 01.5.2016……………….”
[16]
The writ petitioner is a TSR personnel who has served his department
for about 20 years and the allegation against him is that he violated Rule 21 of the
Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988 contracting a second marriage while
his first spouse was living. In this regard, this Court is in complete agreement with
the observations made in the judgment passed by the learned Division Bench of this
Court in Ghulam Nabi Shergujri (supra) to the fact that this is not a criminal
offence of bigamy because the personal law of the writ petitioner permits such
conduct. We are, therefore, of the opinion that though the misconduct of the writ
petitioner is serious mandating his discontinuation in service but it is not so serious
as to warrant forfeiture of his all service benefits. The act of second marriage
without seeking permission of the Government is misconduct but it cannot be said
that the misconduct is so severe in nature that he should be dismissed from service
disentitling him from pensionary or other service benefits. Therefore, this Court is of
view that the punishment imposed upon the writ petitioner is grossly unreasonable to
the misconduct committed by him.
[17]
In view of the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the
considered opinion that interest of justice will be served if instead of punishment of
dismissal from service, punishment of compulsory retirement is imposed upon the
writ petitioner. Resultantly, the impugned judgment passed by the learned Single
Judge is set aside.
[18]
As the present case is in identically placed situation to the case of
Ghulam Nabi Shergujri (supra), the direction given by the Division Bench of this
Court in that judgment with regard to entitlement of pensionary and other service
benefits needs to be applied in this case also. Therefore, this Court opines that the
writ petitioner will be deemed to have been compulsorily retired from the date of his
dismissal from service.
[19]
The retiral and other pensionary benefits of the writ petitioner shall be
released to him within 6(six) months from today, failing which the writ petitioner
shall be entitled to interest @ 12% per annum on the entire amount w.e.f.
01.04.2026.
With such observation and direction, the writ appeal is disposed of.
Miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall also stand closed.
S. Datta Purkayastha, J.
Rudradeep
signed by RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE Digitally
Date: 2026.03.23 13:32:41 +05'30'
Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review