Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.112 of 2022
1. The State of Tripura,
to be represented by Principal Secretary, Food,
Civil Supplies and Consumer Affairs Department,
Govt. of Tripura, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Dist.- West Tripura.
2. The Director of Food, Civil Supplies and Consumer
Affairs Department, Government of Tripura,
Khadya Bhawan, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
District-West Tripura, PIN: 799005.
3. The Principal Secretary, Finance Department,
Government of Tripura, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New
Capital Complex, District: West Tripura, PIN: 799006.
4. The Sub Divisional Magistrate,
Kumarghat, P.O. & P.S.- Kumarghat,
District-Unokoti, PIN: 799264.
….Appellant(s)
Versus
Smt. Suprava Debnath,
W/o Lt. Niranjan Debnath, R/o- Kumarghat,
Sukanta Nagar, P.O. & P.S.-Kumarghat,
Dist.- Unakoti, PIN: 799264.
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of hearing
:
Date of delivery of judgment & order :
….Respondent(s)
Mr. K. De, Addl. GA
Mr. A. Bhaumik, Advocate
Mr. S. Dey, Advocate
29.08.2023
16.10.2023
[
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Arindam Lodh, J.)
This intra-court appeal preferred by the appellants-State is
directed against the judgment and order dated 20.06.2022 passed by a
learned Single Judge of this Court in WP(C) No.867 of 2021, whereby and
whereunder the learned Single Judge directed the State-appellants to
regularize the service of the respondent-writ petitioner in terms of
Memorandum dated 21.01.2009 along with all service benefits including
financial benefits.
2.
The facts, as projected by the respondent-writ petitioner in the
writ petition, are as under:
2.1.
The respondent-writ petitioner(here-in-after referred to as the
„writ petitioner‟) was engaged as a Contingent Worker in the office of the
SDC, Food, Kumarghat in the year 1993. Since her engagement, she had
been rendering full-time duty for 8(eight) hours in a day.
2.2.
On 03.11.2003, the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kailashahar
issued a Radiogram Message wherein it was stated that the writ petitioner
had been engaged in the office of the SDC, Food at Kumarghat against
monthly wage of Rs.950/- which was being paid from the contingency
fund.
2.3.
Later on in the year 2007, the Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Kailashahar by issuing another letter dated 10.02.2007 informed that the
writ petitioner had been engaged as Contingent Worker on 15.05.1990
wherein financial approval was shown given in the year 1993.
2.4.
At a later stage in the year 2017, vide letter dated 03.03.2017,
the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kumarghat, Unakoti Tripura informed the
Director, FCS&CA, Agartala that the writ petitioner had been engaged as a
Contingent Worker and in the said communication the year of her
engagement was shown as 1993.
2.5.
It was stated that her engagement was made in the year 1993
which is also evident from the statement/chart issued by one Sri Apurba
Roy, the then Under Secretary to the Government of Tripura.
2.6.
On the basis of the above communications and the
chart/statement, it was contended by the writ petitioner that she had been
engaged as a Contingent Worker in the year 1993 and she had been
discharging Full-Time duty i.e. 8(eight) hours in a day. So she was entitled
to be regularized as Group-D in terms of Memorandum dated 21.01.2009
on the date of her completion of ten years service as Full-Time Contingent
Worker. But, the Addl. Secretary & Director, FCS&CA, Government of
Tripura vide Memorandum dated 14.09.2017 arbitrarily engaged the writ
petitioner as Daily Rated Worker(Group-D) from Part Time Worker(PTW)
on her completion of ten years of service as PTW as on 30.11.2012.
3.
Being aggrieved by the Memorandum dated 14.09.2017 issued
by the appellants the petitioner filed a writ petition before this Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India for setting aside the impugned
Memorandum dated 14.09.2017 and also for issuing direction upon the
State-appellants to regularize the service of the writ petitioner on the date of
her completion of ten years of service as Full Time Contingent Worker in
terms of Memorandum dated 21.01.2009 issued by the Government of
Tripura and to grant all service benefits including the arrears of pay.
4.
Learned Single Judge after hearing the learned counsel
appearing for the parties and having gone through the records, vide
judgment and order dated 20.06.2022 allowed the writ petition directing the
appellants-State to regularize the service of the writ petitioner along with all
consequential service benefits including arrears of pay within a period of
3(three) months.
5.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned
judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge, the appellants
preferred the present appeal praying for the following relief(s):
“(i) Admit the appeal;
(ii) Call for the records of the Judgment & Order dated 20/06/2022 passed
in WP(C) 867/2-21 by the learned Single Judge;
(iii) Issue Notice;
(iv) After hearing the parties pleased to set aside the impugned Judgment
and Order dated 20/06/2022 passed by the learned Single Judge and be
pleased to discuss the writ petition;
(v) Pass such other order or orders as seems fit and proper having regard to
the circumstances of the case.”
6.
On the aforementioned background facts and circumstances,
we have heard Mr. K. De, learned Addl. GA appearing for the appellants as
well as Mr. A. Bhaumik and Mr. S. Dey, learned counsel appearing for the
writ petitioner.
7.
Mr. De, learned Addl. GA for the appellants, at the outset has
submitted that the communications dated 05.06.2014(Annexure/R1 to the
writ petition) and 21.03.2015(Annexure/R2 to the writ petition) issued by
the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kumarghat would clearly show that the writ
petitioner was engaged as Part Time Worker(Wages) without concurrence
of the Finance Department. He has further argued with vehemence that the
writ petitioner failed to produce any document to show that she had been
rendering „Full-Time‟ duty for 8(eight) hours in a day, which is one of the
main conditions for regularization in terms of Memorandum dated
21.01.2009.
7.1.
It is also submitted by learned Addl. GA that the radiogram
message dated 03.11.2003 issued by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Kailashahar clearly indicates that the writ petitioner was engaged for the
purpose of office sweeping/cleaning and water carrying, etc. work and for
such engagement she was being paid monthly wage from contingency fund
and there was no approval of the Finance Department for such engagement.
Her engagement also clearly affirms that the service of the writ petitioner
was required for a particular time of a working day in the office where she
was attached and not on „Full-Time‟ basis as claimed by the writ petitioner.
Even she was not engaged in a regular vacant post following the established
procedure of employment.
7.2.
Referring to Memorandum dated 21.01.2009 issued by the
Finance Department, Government of Tripura, Mr. De, learned Addl. G.A.
has further argued that regularization of the writ petitioner is not covered by
the said Memo. dated 21.01.2009 firstly, on the ground that she was not
engaged on „Full-Time‟ basis as contemplated in the said Memo. for
regularization, secondly, her service of ten years will be completed on
13.09.2027 as she was engaged by the appellants after obtaining
concurrence of the Finance Department as DRW(Group-D) w.e.f.
14.09.2017, and thirdly, the said Memorandum dated 21.01.2009 on which
the writ petitioner relied upon had already been repealed by a subsequent
Memorandum dated 31.07.2018 issued by the Government of Tripura.
Learned Addl. G.A. therefore prayed for quashing the
impugned order of the learned Single Judge.
8.
Refuting the submissions advanced by the learned Addl. G.A.
for the appellants, Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel for the writ petitioner has
submitted that the writ petitioner was engaged as “Full-Time” contingent
worker in the year 1993 and since after her engagement she had been
rendering service for eight hours a day in that capacity. She had completed
ten years of continuous service in the year 2003 as “Full-Time” contingent
worker.
8.1.
It has been further contended by Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel
that though she was entitled to be regularized in the year 2003 on her
completion of ten years of continuous service as Contingent Worker, but
the appellants most illegally deprived her right of regularization in the
service. Thereafter, when the Memorandum dated 21.01.2009 came into in
existence, which was a policy decision of the Government to regularize the
services of DRWs/Casual/Contingent Workers from the next date of
completion of ten years of service, then also the appellants, most arbitrarily
deprived her from the benefit of that policy. Thereafter, all on a sudden in
the year 2017, the appellants vide Memo. dated 14.09.2017 engaged her as
Daily Rated Worker(Group-D) instead of regularizing her service as GroupD, which was grossly erroneous and violative of the right of the writ
petitioner.
Learned counsel therefore prayed for upholding the judgment
and order passed by the learned Single Judge.
9.
We have considered the rival submissions of the learned
counsel appearing for the parties and also have gone through the records.
Keeping in view the rival contentions of the parties and having gone
through the materials available on record, we feel the main questions which
broadly fall for consideration before us are:
(i) Whether the writ petitioner was engaged as „Full-Time‟
Contingent Worker having duty hours of eight hours per day
since her engagement?
(ii) Whether the claim for regularization of the writ petitioner
comes within the ambit of the Memorandum dated 21.01.2009
issued by the Finance Department, Government of Tripura?
(iii) Whether the engagement of the writ petitioner was
“irregular” or “illegal”?
(iv) Whether the learned Single Judge had committed error
directing the appellants to regularize the service of the writ
petitioner?
10.
Before we delve into the questions as formulated above, it
would be apposite to reproduce here-under the Memorandum dated
21.01.2009, extract of which reads thus:
“No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)/2008(Part)
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
Dated, Agartala, the 21st January, 2009
MEMORANDUM
Subject: Regularization of services of DRWs/Casual/Contingent Workers
on the next date of completion of 10 years of service.
The undersigned is directed to inform that the Government has
taken
a
policy
decision
to
regularize
services
of
full-time
DRWs/Casual/Contingent Workers from the next date of completion of
10 years of service and fulfill the following criterion as per Departmentwise names and particulars attached herewith:
(i) DRW/Casual/Contingent workers who were engaged on a full time
basis in different Departments with or without concurrence of Finance
Department other than Permanent Labourers, Part-time workers,
Anganwadi Workers and Helpers, Home Guards, Teachers and Workers
engaged under SSA and other Schemes/programmes, may be considered
for regularization as per names attached.
(ii) Requirement of age as per Recruitment Rules will be deemed to be
relaxed for the purpose of this regularization.
(iii) Requirement of educational qualification as per Recruitment Rules
will be deemed as relaxed for regularization under Group-D only. In case
of DRW/and Contingent Workers who were appointed under Group-C
category, educational qualification as required under concerned R.R.
must be ensured while entertaining their cases for regularization.
(iv) Except age and educational qualification mentioned in point (ii) &
(iii) all other criterion as per relevant Recruitment Rules including
reservation roster will have to be followed strictly for this process of
regularization.
(v) Subject to fulfillment of above conditions, the eligible workers will be
provided pay scale in the relevant post on the following day of
completion of 10 years of service(without any break) from the date of
joining. In the event of revision of pay scales the revised structure will be
followed as per Govt.‟s decision.
2. To facilitate quick action for implementation of the above decisions,
appropriate authorities of the concerned Administrative Department of
the State Government are authorized to take following actions:
xxx xxx
xxx xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
3. There shall be a complete ban on engagement of DRW/Casual/
Contingent etc. workers after 31.3.2003 without concurrence from
Finance Department. Responsibility shall be fixed on the official found
responsible for any irregular engagement henceforth. Such irregular
engagement shall have to be instantly terminated. The wages, if paid
any, shall be recovered from the official concerned.
4.
The undersigned is directed to request all concerned to ensure
strict implementation of the above decisions.”
(emphasis supplied)
10.1.
A bare perusal of the aforesaid Memo. it comes to fore that the
Finance Department, Government of Tripura had taken a policy decision to
regularize the services of those DRWs/Casual/Contingent Workers who had
rendered service continuously for ten years on “Full-Time” basis with
certain conditions as mentioned at sub-clauses (i), (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of
the first para of the said Memo.
10.2.
At this stage, we must note that on perusal of the entire records
we find no engagement letter, issued in favour of the writ petitioner either
as „Part-Time’ or „Full-Time’ at any point of time, except the impugned
order of engagement of the writ petitioner dated 14.09.2017 as
DRW(Group-D). However, what we find is that there are some mentions in
the communications(as annexed by the writ petitioner) issued by the
appellants stating that she had been engaged as „contingent worker‟, „parttime worker‟, etc., but in absence of an order of engagement/appointment
issued by a competent authority specifying that she was engaged as “FullTime” contingent worker, it would be difficult for us to arrive at a definite
finding that she was engaged as “Full-Time” contingent worker for which
she was entitled to get the benefit of the policy decision of the Government
under Memo. dated 21.01.2009.
10.3.
It is the contention of the learned counsel for the writ
petitioner that she was engaged as „contingent worker‟ in the year 1993. In
support of his contention he has referred to a chart/statement of contingent
workers, marked as Annexure-1 to the writ petition. The content of the
chart/statement is reproduced hereunder, in extenso:
Sl.
No.
CATE
GOR
Y OF
WOR
K
NAME
OF
WORK
ERS
PLACE
OF
POSTING
DDO
YEAR
OF
ENGA
GEME
NT
EXISTIN
G RATE
OF
WAGES
PER
MONTH/
DAY
NAME
OF
TREASU
RY/SUBTREASU
RY
SDM, KAILASHAHAR
CONT SUPRA
INGE VA
NT
DEBNA
TH
CONT SAXMI
INGE NAMA
NT
SUDRA
KUMAR
GHAT
GODOW
N
KUMAR
GHAT
KAILAS
HAHAR
SDM,
KAILAS
HAHAR
900 PM
KAILAS
HAHAR
SDM,
KAILAS
HAHAR
900 PM
KAILAS
HAHAR
(APURBA ROY )
Under Secretary
Govt. of Tripura”
On going through the afore-mentioned statement/chart it
appears that the writ petitioner was shown engaged in the year 1993 under
the category of “contingent” worker in the office of the Kumarghat Food
Go-down at a monthly wage of Rs.900/-. In the chart/statement, we
however find nothing to ascertain on which date and from which
department the chart was issued. However, we are of the view that the said
chart/statement fails to prove that she was engaged as „Full-Time‟
contingent worker in the year 1993.
10.4.
We have next perused the radiogram message dated
03.11.2003(Annexure-2 to the writ petition) issued by the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, Kailashahar on the basis of which the writ petitioner contended
that she was engaged in the year 1993 as „Full-Time‟ Contingent Worker.
The radiogram message clearly stipulates that-“THERE IS NO PART TIME
CONTINGENT/CASUAL/D.R.W. ETC WORKERS ENGAGED.” The
message also clarifies that for the purpose of office sweeping/cleaning and
water carrying, the writ petitioner was being paid monthly wage of Rs.950/from contingency for which there was no approval of Finance Department.
The above statement therefore does not convince us to conclude that she
was engaged as „Full-Time‟ Contingent worker.
10.5.
Thereafter, we have perused letter dated 10.02.2007(Annexure-
3 to the writ petition) issued by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kailashahar,
wherein the name of the writ petitioner had been shown under the category
of „Contingent Worker‟ and her engagement date had been shown as
15.05.1990 having financial approval of the year 1993. So, the letter dated
10.02.2007 also does not convince us to hold that the respondent-petitioner
was engaged as „Full-Time‟ Contingent worker. Different dates of her
engagement as mentioned in the writ petition and discussed here-in-above
indubitably justifies that the writ petitioner herself is not sure about the
actual date of her engagement vis-à-vis the nature of her engagement.
10.6.
However,
we
have
also
gone
through
letter
dated
05.06.2014(Annexure-R/1 to the writ petition, annexed by the appellants in
their counter affidavit) issued by the SDM, Kumarghat. Clauses (1), (4), (5)
& (6) of the said letter read thus:
“1. Category of Worker
4. Working since(Date)
: Part-Time Worker(Wages)
:1988. The then she was under Kailashahar SubDivision up to Feb, 2012 and thereafter she has
transferred to the office of the SDM(Food Section)
Kumarghat after bifurcation of Kailashahar SubDivision w.e.f. March, 2012 and working in this
establishment till date.
5. Details of concurrence
of Finance Dept.
:This office has no record regarding concurrence
of the Finance Department but as per the LPC
issued by the SDM, Kailashahar she is getting her
salary under head of Account 2408-01-001-98-2122-Wages(Non-Plan) Demand No.21@Rs.3055/per month.
6. If No concurrence was
Obtained, Authority who
Approved the engagement:
This office has no record regarding concurrence of
the Finance Department but as per the LPC issued
by the SDM, Kailashahar she is getting her salary
under head of account 2408--01-001-98-21-22Wages(Non-Plan) Demand No.21@Rs.3055/- per
month.”
The statements made in the aforementioned clauses would
show that the writ petitioner was engaged as „Part-Time Worker(Wages)‟ in
the year 1988 without concurrence of the Finance Department. So, the
claim of the writ petitioner regarding her engagement as „Full-Time‟
Contingent Worker does not support the statements made in the
aforementioned clauses.
10.7.
Annexure-R/2 to the writ petition annexed by the appellants is
another letter of communication dated 21.03.2015 containing five vouchers
and three bills, wherefrom it is revealed that the writ petitioner was
discharging duty as „Part-Time‟ worker on payment of wages for carrying
water and sweeping/cleaning of rooms of the Food Office at Kumarghat.
10.8.
The letter of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kumarghat dated
03.03.2017(Annexure-4 to the writ petition) stipulates that the writ
petitioner was working in the office of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Kumarghat on her transfer after bifurcation of Kailashahar Sub-Division
w.e.f. March, 2012 and she was getting monthly wage @Rs.3940/-. The
letter of SDM, Kumarghat, however, clarifies in the manner that no
document was available with them with regard to her engagement and
concurrence of the Finance Department, except a statement/chart of one Sri
Apurba Roy, Under Secretary showing her as a „Contingent Worker‟
against Sl. No.316 and recording her engagement as 1993.
10.9.
Finally, on going through the impugned Memo. dated
14.09.2017 we find the respondent-petitioner was engaged as DRW(GroupD). Extract of the Memo. dated 14.09.2017 reads thus:
“Pursuant to concurrence of the Finance Department vide letter
No.F.34(2)-Fin(G)/2016 dated 01-09-2017, the following 6(six) numbers
of Part Time Workers(PTW) who have been engaged for 2(Two) hours
job prior to 31-03-2003 and have completed 10(Ten) years of service as
on 30-11-2012 are hereby engaged as Daily Rated Worker(DRW),
Group-D with prospective effect under Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer
Affairs Department.
Sl.
Finance
Department ID
……………..”
11.
Name of Worker
Cate
gory
Smt.
Suprava UR
Debnath
Group
D
Name of Head
Of Office
SDM Kumarghat
The upshot of the aforesaid discussions is that the writ
petitioner, though claimed that she had been engaged in the year 1993 as
„Full-Time’ contingent worker basing on the chart/statement(Annexure-1),
the radiogram message of SDM, Kailashahar dated 03.11.2003(Annexure2), subsequent letter of SDM, Kailashahar dated 10.02.2007(Annexure-3)
and the letter of SDM, Kumarghat dated 03.03.2017(Annexure-4), but she
failed to produce any engagement letter issued in her favour and also failed
to justify her claim that she had been engaged as „Full-Time’ contingent
worker to get the benefit of the policy decision of the Government under
the Memo. dated 21.01.2009. Moreover, we find no documentary evidence
on record to come to a conclusion that her appointment was done after
following due procedure of selection or to say the least that she was
engaged against any regular vacant post.
11.1.
The observation of learned Single Judge that the petitioner was
working as „Full-Time‟ basis since her engagement is, in our opinion, not at
all acceptable as we find not a single document from where we can arrive at
a decision that the writ petitioner had been rendering duty on „Full-Time‟
basis as contingent worker, rather what we find is that the service of the
writ petitioner was required for a particular time of a working day and not
on „Full-Time‟ basis in the office where she was attached to. In any case,
the fact remains that the writ petitioner had been serving as „part-time‟
worker and she was being paid from contingent fund. Another aspect
necessary to be dealt with herein in respect of the fact that the post in which
the writ petitioner was engaged/held is not created and sanctioned by any
authority of law and therefore, the directions issued by learned Single Judge
by the impugned judgment and order, in our opinion, cannot be sustained.
11.2.
Furthermore, the right of the writ petitioner, if any to claim
regularization arose during the life of the afore-discussed Memo./Scheme
and within the realm of the scheme, but she had approached before the
court for the first time in the year 2021 to enforce her claims, that too,
under the repealed scheme. Such claim, according to us, by now has
become stale, and thus, is absolutely barred by the doctrine of delay and
laches. On this count only, the instant appeal is liable to be allowed. It is reiterated that the scheme made for the purpose of regularization, was existed
for more than 10 (ten) years.
11.3.
Needless to mention, regularization or absorption is not a
matter of right. It is a right to be considered by the employer and subject to
availability of sanctioned vacant posts, etc. As we discussed earlier, there is
no material before us that the writ petitioner had been working against any
regular sanctioned post. Any appointment/engagement made not against
duly sanctioned post must not to be treated as “irregular appointments” but
would be treated as “illegal appointments”.
11.4.
It is clear that she was not engaged against any regular
sanctioned post. That apart, neither in the pleadings nor any submission is
made that at present any vacant sanctioned post exists. It is established
proposition of law that the courts cannot direct the Government to create
posts. According to us, creation of post is a matter of policy, which is
absolutely within the domain of the Government itself.
11.5.
In the context of the instant case, we may gainfully refer the
Constitution Bench judgment rendered in Secretary, State of Karnataka
and others vs. Uma Devi (3) and others, (2006) 4 SCC 1, where-under it
was held that orders for absorption, regularization or permanent
continuance of such employees are passed apparently in exercise of the
wide powers under Article 226 of the Constitution. The wide powers under
Article 226 are not intended to be used for a purpose certain to defeat the
concept of social justice and equal opportunity for all, subject to
affirmative action in the matter of public employment as recognized by our
Constitution. It is time that the courts desist from issuing orders preventing
regular selection or recruitment at the instance of such persons and from
issuing directions for continuance of those who have not secured regular
appointments as per procedure established. The passing of orders for
continuance tends to defeat the very constitutional scheme of public
employment. It has to be emphasized that this is not the role envisaged for
the High Courts in the scheme of things and their wide powers under
Article 226 are not intended to be used for the purpose of perpetuating
illegalities, irregularities or improprieties or for scuttling the whole scheme
of public employment. Its role as the sentinel and as the guardian of equal
rights protection should not be forgotten. [SCC p.18 para 4]
It was further held that this bypassing of the constitutional
scheme cannot be perpetuated by the passing of orders without dealing with
and deciding the constitutional validity of the interim and final orders of
the Supreme Court and High Courts which have issued directions for
regularization, permanent continuation or absorption without referring to
the legal position obtaining thereby, and which have been relied on by the
respondent employees to claim the same relief. While approaching the
questions falling for decision before this Constitution Bench, it is necessary
to bear this in mind and to bring about certainty in the matter of public
employment. The claim to a parity of treatment based on such orders also
highlights the need for the Supreme Court to formally lay down the law on
the question and ensure certainty in dealings relating to public
employment. The very divergence in approach in the Supreme Court, the
so-called equitable approach made in some, as against those decisions
which have insisted on the rules being followed, also justifies a firm
decision by the Supreme Court one way or the other. It is necessary to put
an end to uncertainty and clarify the legal position emerging from the
constitutional scheme, leaving the High Courts to follow necessarily, the
law thus laid down. This Constitution Bench has to lay down the law. It has
to approach the question as a constitutional court should . [SCC pp.20, 2324, paras 10 & 14]
In para 53 of Uma Devi (3)(supra), it has been held that-
“53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be cases where
irregular appointments (not illegal appointments) as explained in State of
Mysore vs. S.V. Narayanappa, reported in (1967) 1 SCR 128, R.N.
Nanjundappa vs. T. Thimmiah, reported in (1972) 1 SCC 409, B.N.
Nagarajan vs. State of Karnataka, reported in (1979) 4 SCC 507, and
referred to in paragraph 15 above, of duly qualified persons in duly
sanctioned vacant posts might have been made and the employees have
continued to work for ten years or more but without the intervention of
orders of courts or of tribunals. The question of regularization of the
services of such employees may have to be considered on merits in the light
of the principles settled by this Court in the cases above referred to and in
the light of this judgment. In that context, the Union of India, the State
Governments and their instrumentalities should take steps to regularize as a
one time measure, the services of such irregularly appointed, who have
worked for ten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but not under cover
of orders of courts or of tribunals and should further ensure that regular
recruitments are undertaken to fill those vacant sanctioned posts that
require to be filled up, in cases where temporary employees or daily wagers
are being now employed. The process must be set in motion within six
months from this date. We also clarify that regularization, if any already
made, but not subjudice, need not be reopened based on this judgment, but
there should be no further by-passing of the constitutional requirement and
regularizing or making permanent, those not duly appointed as per the
constitutional scheme.”
11.6.
In the instant case, there is no averment that the writ petitioner
has been working in duly sanctioned vacant post under the appellants. One
of the pre-conditions as laid down by the Constitution Bench in Uma Devi
(3)(supra), is that the employees concerned apart from due qualification,
should have worked for 10 (ten) years or more in a “duly sanctioned
vacant post” without the benefit or protection of any interim order from
any court or tribunal.
11.7.
Further, the Constitution
Bench
directed
the Central
Government, State Governments and their instrumentalities to take steps to
regularize the services of irregularly appointed temporary employees or
daily wagers as “one-time measure”. In the line of the directions, the State
of Tripura had formulated schemes as stated supra to regularize the services
of the Full-Time DRWs, Casual/Contingent Workers and the same was
continued for long 10(ten) years. During the said period, the
employees/workers who had completed 10(ten) years of service were
regularized either by the Government or by the order of this Court within
the realms of the policy. As stated above, the Government also decided to
regularize those classes of irregularly appointed employees who were
engaged on or after the cut-off date(31.03.2003) with or without the
concurrence of the Finance Department. The scheme was existed for more
than 10(ten) years till the same was repealed vide Memorandum dated
31.07.2018.
11.8.
In Uma Devi (3)(supra), Hon‟ble Supreme Court had extended
the benefit of regularization as “one-time measure” to the employees who
were appointed irregularly, but, not illegally against duly sanctioned posts.
In State of Karnataka vs. M.L. Kesari, reported in (2010) 9 SCC 247, the
distinction between the illegal appointment and irregular appointment was
made in the manner as under:
“7. It is evident from the above that there is an exception to the general
principle against regularization enunciated in Uma Devi (3) 1, if the
following conditions are fulfilled:
(i) The employee concerned should have worked for 10 years or more in a
duly sanctioned post without the benefit or protection of the interim order of
any court or tribunal. In other words, the State Government or its
instrumentality should have employed the employee and continued him in
service voluntarily and continuously for more than ten years.
(ii) The appointment should not be illegal, even if irregular. Where the
appointments are not made or continued against sanctioned posts or where
the person appointed do not possess the prescribed minimum qualifications,
the appointments will be considered illegal. But where the person possessed
the prescribed qualifications and was working against sanctioned posts, but
had been selected without undergoing the process of open competitive
selection, such appointments are considered to be irregular.
8. Umadevi (3) casts a duty upon the Government or instrumentality
concerned to take steps to regularize the services of those irregularly
appointed employees who had served for more than ten years without the
benefit or protection of interim orders of courts or tribunals, as a one timemeasures, Umadevi (3) directed that such one time-measure must be set in
motion within six months from the date of its decision.
9. The term „one time-measure‟ has to be understood in its proper
perspective. This would normally mean that after the decision in Umadevi
(3), each department or instrumentality should undertake a one-time
exercise and prepare a list of all casual, daily wage or ad-hoc employees
who have been working for more than ten years without the intervention of
courts and tribunals and subject them to a process verification as to whether
they are working against vacant posts and possess the requisite qualification
for the post and if so, regularize their service.”
11.9.
We noted in the preceding paragraphs that there is no material
before us that the writ petitioner was engaged against duly sanctioned
regular post and the said post was vacant at the time of her engagement or
is still lying vacant. That apart, since the engagement of the writ petitioner
was not made in duly sanctioned post, her appointment/engagement cannot
be said to be irregular appointment/engagement, but, as per Uma Devi
(3)(supra) and M.L. Kesari(supra), her appointment/engagement was
illegal appointment/engagement.
12.
Another interesting feature surfaced in the present appeal is
that the writ petitioner has not been able to produce any document that she
was appointed/engaged as „Full-Time” Contingent Worker under any order
of the competent authority of the appellants. Only she had annexed some
communications, as referred to above from which it can hardly be
ascertained that she had been appointed/engaged as “Full-Time” contingent
worker as required under the Memo. dated 21.01.2009. So, on this score
also, the appointment/engagement of the writ petitioner under the
appellants was/is per se illegal.
13.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan & Ors. vs.
Daya Lal & Ors. reported in (2011) 2 SCC 429, while dealing a case in
respect of regularization or absorption of some of the temporarily appointed
employees under the State of Rajasthan, had recast the well-settled
principles relating to regularization, which is as under: [SCC pp. 435, 436,
para 12]
“12. We may at the outset refer to the following well settled principles
relating to regularization and parity in pay, relevant in the context of these
appeals:
(i) The High Courts, in exercising power under Article 226 of the
Constitution will not issue directions for regularization, absorption or
permanent continuance, unless the employees claiming regularization had
been appointed in pursuance of a regular recruitment in accordance with
relevant rules in an open competitive process, against sanctioned vacant
posts. The equality clause contained in Articles 14 and 16 should be
scrupulously followed and courts should not issue a direction for
regularization of services of an employee which would be violative of
constitutional scheme. While something that is irregular for want of
compliance with one of the elements in the process of selection which does
not go to the root of the process, can be regularized, back door entries,
appointments contrary to the constitutional scheme and/or appointment of
ineligible candidates cannot be regularized.
(ii) Mere continuation of service by an temporary or ad hoc or daily-wage
employee, under cover of some interim orders of the court, would not confer
upon him any right to be absorbed into service, as such service would be
`litigious employment'. Even temporary, ad hoc or daily- wage service for a
long number of years, let alone service for one or two years, will not entitle
such employee to claim regularization, if he is not working against a
sanctioned post. Sympathy and sentiment cannot be grounds for passing any
order of regularization in the absence of a legal right.
(iii) Even where a scheme is formulated for regularization with a cut-off
date (that is a scheme providing that persons who had put in a specified
number of years of service and continuing in employment as on the cut-off
date), it is not possible to others who were appointed subsequent to the cutoff date, to claim or contend that the scheme should be applied to them by
extending the cut-off date or seek a direction for framing of fresh schemes
providing for successive cut off dates.
(iv) Part-time employees are not entitled to seek regularization as they are
not working against any sanctioned posts. There cannot be a direction for
absorption, regularization or permanent continuance of part time temporary
employees.
(v) Part time temporary employees in government run institutions cannot
claim parity in salary with regular employees of the government on the
principle of equal pay for equal work. Nor can employees in private
employment, even if serving full time, seek parity in salary with government
employees. The right to claim a particular salary against the State must
arise under a contract or under a statute.
(See : Secretary, State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi - 2006 (4) SCC 1, M.
Raja vs. CEERI Educational Society, Pilani - 2006 (12) SCC 636, S.C.
Chandra vs. State of Jharkhand - 2007 (8) SCC 279, Kurukshetra Central
Co-operative Bank Ltd vs. Mehar Chand - 2007 (15) SCC 680, and Official
Liquidator vs. Dayanand - 2008 (10 SCC 1)”
13.1.
What emerges in Daya lal (supra) is that the appointments
even if irregular must be against sanctioned posts. Sympathy and sentiment
cannot be a ground for passing any order of regularization in the absence of
a legal right. Further, where the scheme is formulated for regularization
with cut-off date(i.e. a scheme providing that persons who have put in a
specified number of years and continuing in employment as on cut-off
date), it is not possible for others who were appointed subsequent to the
cut-off date, to claim or contend that the scheme should be applied to
them by extending the cut-off date.
(Emphasis supplied)
As we have already discussed that in the instant appeal, the writ
petitioner had failed to assert, or in other words, could not substantiate that
she was engaged against “sanctioned vacant posts” in terms of the
recruitment rules applicable to the concerned department. Moreover, in
terms of communication dated 14.09.2017 her term of continuous ten years
will be completed on 13.09.2027.
14.
However, we are not unoblivious of the decisions and
directions of the two-Judge Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Narendra Kumar Tiwari & Ors. vs. State of Jharkhand & Ors. reported in
(2018) 8 SCC 238, where the Hon‟ble Supreme Court directed the State of
Jharkhand to take necessary steps for regularization of the irregularly
appointed employees in the spirit of the decisions of the Constitution Bench
in Uma Devi (3)(supra). In the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari(supra), the
Hon‟ble supreme Court had referred and discussed the cases of Uma Devi
(3)(supra) and M.L. Keshari(supra). To evaluate the distinguishing features
of the case at hand, with that of the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari
(supra), it is necessary to extract the relevant paragraphs of the case of
Narendra
Kumar
Tiwari(supra):-[SCC
pp.240,241,
242,
paras
5,6,7,8,9,10,11 & 12]
“5. The decision in Umadevi (3) was intended to put a full stop to the
somewhat pernicious practice of irregularly or illegally appointing daily
wage workers and continuing with them indefinitely. In fact, in paragraph
49 of the Report, it was pointed out that the rule of law requires
appointments to be made in a constitutional manner and the State cannot be
permitted to perpetuate an irregularity in the matter of public employment
which would adversely affect those who could be employed in terms of the
constitutional scheme. It is for this reason that the concept of a one-time
measure and a cut-off date was introduced in the hope and expectation that
the State would cease and desist from making irregular or illegal
appointments and instead make appointments on a regular basis.
6. The concept of a one-time measure was further explained in Kesari in
paragraphs 9, 10 and 11 of the Report which read as follows: (SCC pp.25051, paras 9-11)
“9. The term “one-time measure” has to be understood in its proper
perspective. This would normally mean that after the decision in Umadevi
(3), each department or each instrumentality should undertake a one-time
exercise and prepare a list of all casual, daily-wage or ad hoc employees
who have been working for more than ten years without the intervention of
courts and tribunals and subject them to a process verification as to whether
they are working against vacant posts and possess the requisite qualification
for the post and if so, regularise their services.
10. At the end of six months from the date of decision in Umadevi (3), cases
of several daily-wage/ad hoc/casual employees were still pending before
courts. Consequently, several departments and instrumentalities did not
commence the one-time regularisation process. On the other hand, some
government departments or instrumentalities undertook the one- time
exercise excluding several employees from consideration either on the
ground that their cases were pending in courts or due to sheer oversight. In
such circumstances, the employees who were entitled to be considered in
terms of para 53 of the decision in Umadevi (3), will not lose their right to
be considered for regularisation, merely because the one-time exercise was
completed without considering their cases, or because the six- month period
mentioned in para 53 of Umadevi (3) has expired. The one-time exercise
should consider all daily-wage/ad hoc/casual employees who had put in 10
years of continuous service as on 10-4-2006 without availing the protection
of any interim orders of courts or tribunals. If any employer had held the
one-time exercise in terms of para 53 of Umadevi (3), but did not consider
the cases of some employees who were entitled to the benefit of para 53 of
Umadevi (3), the employer concerned should consider their cases also, as a
continuation of the one-time exercise. The one-time exercise will be
concluded only when all the employees who are entitled to be considered in
terms of para 53 of Umadevi (3), are so considered.
11. The object behind the said direction in para 53 of Umadevi (3) is
twofold. First is to ensure that those who have put in more than ten years of
continuous service without the protection of any interim orders of courts or
tribunals, before the date of decision in Umadevi (3) was rendered, are
considered for regularisation in view of their long service. Second is to
ensure that the departments/instrumentalities do not perpetuate the practice
of employing persons on daily-wage/ad hoc/casual basis for long periods
and then periodically regularise them on the ground that they have served
for more than ten years, thereby defeating the constitutional or statutory
provisions relating to recruitment and appointment. The true effect of the
direction is that all persons who have worked for more than ten years as on
10-4-2006 [the date of decision in Umadevi (3)] without the protection of
any interim order of any court or tribunal, in vacant posts, possessing the
requisite qualification, are entitled to be considered for regularisation. The
fact that the employer has not undertaken such exercise of regularisation
within six months of the decision in Umadevi (3) or that such exercise was
undertaken only in regard to a limited few, will not disentitle such
employees, the right to be considered for regularisation in terms of the
above directions in Umadevi (3) as a one-time measure.”
7. The purpose and intent of the decision in Umadevi (3) was therefore twofold, namely, to prevent irregular or illegal appointments in the future and
secondly, to confer a benefit on those who had been irregularly appointed in
the past. The fact that the State of Jharkhand continued with the irregular
appointments for almost a decade after the decision in Umadevi (3) is a
clear indication that it believes that it was all right to continue with
irregular appointments, and whenever required, terminate the services of
the irregularly appointed employees on the ground that they were
irregularly appointed. This is nothing but a form of exploitation of the
employees by not giving them the benefits of regularisation and by placing
the sword of Damocles over their head. This is precisely what Umadevi (3)
and Kesari sought to avoid.
8. If a strict and literal interpretation, forgetting the spirit of the decision of
the Constitution Bench in Umadevi (3), is to be taken into consideration then
no irregularly appointed employee of the State of Jharkhand could ever be
regularised since that State came into existence only on 15th November,
2000 and the cut-off date was fixed as 10 th April, 2006. In other words, in
this manner the pernicious practice of indefinitely continuing irregularly
appointed employees would be perpetuated contrary to the intent of the
Constitution Bench.
9. The High Court as well as the State of Jharkhand ought to have
considered the entire issue in a contextual perspective and not only from the
point of view of the interest of the State, financial or otherwise – the interest
of the employees is also required to be kept in mind. What has eventually
been achieved by the State of Jharkhand is to short circuit the process of
regular appointments and instead make appointments on an irregular basis.
This is hardly good governance.
10. Under the circumstances, we are of the view that the Regularisation
Rules must be given a pragmatic interpretation and the appellants, if they
have completed 10 years of service on the date of promulgation of the
Regularisation Rules, ought to be given the benefit of the service rendered
by them. If they have completed 10 years of service they should be
regularised unless there is some valid objection to their regularisation like
misconduct etc.
11. The impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is set aside
in view of our conclusions. The State should take a decision within four
months from today on regularisation of the status of the appellants.
12. We may add that that it would be worthwhile for the State of Jharkhand
to henceforth consider making regular appointments only and dropping the
idea of making irregular appointments so as to short circuit the process of
regular appointments.”
14.1.
On meticulous reading of the above paragraphs, it is clear that
the two-Judge Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Narendra Kumar
Tiwari(supra) had approved the interpretation of the term “one-time
measure” as explained in M.L. Keshari (supra) that the State or its
instrumentalities had to undertake one-time exercise for regularization of all
casual, daily wagers or ad-hoc employees who had been working for more
than ten years without the intervention of the courts or tribunals and subject
to a process of verification as to whether such employees were working
against sanctioned vacant posts, and possess requisite qualification for the
post they were holding. In the process of such regularization, if any
employer had held the „one-time exercise‟ in terms of para 53 of Uma Devi
(3)(supra), but did not consider the cases of some employees who were
entitled to the benefit of para 53 of Uma Devi (3)(supra), the employer
concern was to consider their cases also as a continuation of „one-time
exercise‟. Furthermore, the said „one-time exercise‟ would be concluded
only when all the employees who were entitled to be considered in terms of
para 53 of Uma Devi (3)(supra) were considered.
15.
In our opinion, the object behind the directions passed by the
Constitution Bench in Uma Devi (3)(supra) was to save all daily-wagers,
ad-hoc, casual employees from exploitations by the State and their
instrumentalities and to bind the States and their instrumentalities to stop
irregular appointments ignoring the established norms of employment as
enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. There are
conditionalities. Firstly, the employees must have completed at least ten
years of continuous service as on 10.04.2006 [the date of decision in Uma
Devi (3) (supra)] without the protection of any interim orders of courts or
tribunals; Secondly, those engagement/appointments, though irregular, but
not illegal; Thirdly, the engagements/appointments must be against
sanctioned vacant posts; and, Fourthly, they must possess requisite
qualification commensurate the posts they held.
16.
In the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari(supra), the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court had observed that the State of Jharkhand continued with the
irregular appointments for almost a decade after the decision of Uma Devi
(3)(supra). It was further observed that the State of Jharkhand had taken it
granted that it is all right to continue with irregular appointments, and
whenever required, could terminate the services of the irregularly appointed
employees on the ground that they were irregularly appointed, and in that
context, it was held that the said process was nothing but a form of
exploitation of the employees by not giving them the benefits of
regularization and by placing the sword of Damocles over their head,
contrary to the object the Hon‟ble Supreme Court wanted to achieve in the
case of Uma Devi (3)(supra) and M.L. Keshari(supra).
17.
The
facts
and
circumstances
in
Narendra
Kumar
Tiwari(supra) was completely different. Noticeably, unlike the Government
of Jharkhand, the Government of Tripura, being a policy maker, vide
Memorandum dated 21.01.2009 had declared a complete ban on
engagement of DRWs/Casual/Contingent workers after 31.03.2003 without
concurrence from the Finance Department. Even it was declared that the
responsibilities would be fixed on the officials found responsible for any
irregular employments henceforth, and such irregular engagement would
have to be instantly terminated. It was further decided that the wages, if
paid, would be recovered from the official concerned (Clause 3 of the
Memorandum dated 21.01.2009).
18.
In the instant case, according to the writ petitioner, she was
engaged in the year 1993 and there is no material or evidence that she was
engaged with concurrence from the Finance Department, Government of
Tripura. The Government of Tripura had undertaken exercise to regularize
the services of the DRWs/Casual/ Contingent etc. workers having noticed
that in some departments such workers were engaged without prior
approval of the Finance Department on Full Time basis after 31.03.2003,
and some of them by that time had completed 10 (ten) years of continuous
service, and in this regard, a policy decision was taken by the Government
of Tripura directing the Heads of all the Departments to send the names of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent workers to Finance Department who were
engaged after 31.03.2003 with or without prior approval of the Finance
Department, in prescribed format within 10th January, 2014.
19.
On reading of the policy decision under Memorandum dated
21.01.2009, we find two factors for the purpose of regularization of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent workers. Firstly, the Government of Tripura had
declared complete ban on engagement of such workers after 31.03.2003
without concurrence from the Finance Department and responsibility was
also fixed on the erring officials. Secondly, the then existing policy being
reviewed, the Government of Tripura found that in some departments the
DRWs/Casual/Contingent workers were engaged without prior approval of
the Finance Department with Full Time basis after 31.03.2003 and some of
them by that time had completed 10(ten) years of continuous services.
20.
As a matter of further exercise, the Government had decided to
regularize the services of such workers and the Heads of the Department
were directed to submit the list of the workers who fulfilled the above
criteria within a stipulated date, i.e., within 10th January, 2014 in a
prescribed format. On perusal of the appeal and having heard learned
counsel appearing for the parties, we find no evidence that competent
authority of the concerned department had ever considered to send the
name of the writ petitioner to the Government of Tripura for the purpose of
her regularization as Group-D, though the process continued for a
considerable period.
21.
Thereafter, the Government of Tripura had come up with a
Memorandum dated 31.07.2018 whereunder all the policy decisions
formulated for regularization of DRWs/Casual/Contingent workers had
been repealed. We have an opportunity to go through the Memorandum
dated 31.07.2018(though it was not annexed by either parties) issued by the
Finance Department, Government of Tripura by which all the existing
schemes for regularization have been repealed. We deem it fit to reproduce
here-under the said Memorandum, for the sake of convenience, in extenso:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
Dated:- The 31st July, 2018
MEMORANDUM
Subject: Policy decision of regularization of service of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent/PTW etc. Workers in Government
Establishment and State PSUs and Autonomous bodies including
AMC/NPS Finance Department has issued instructions from time to
time as given for regularization of service of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent/PTW etc. workers on the date completion
of 17 years/15 years/10 years of services. The memorandums are as
follows:
Sl.No.
Memo No.
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/05,
Dated 04.03.2006
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/05,
Dated 22.02.2007
No.F.10(2)Fin(G)/08(part),
Dated 01.09.2008
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/
08(part),
Dated 21.01.2009
No.F.34(3)Fin(G)/2012,
Dated 04.09.2012
No.F.10(12)Fin(G)/7(part-1),
Issues
Regularization of DRWs/Contingent
etc. workers on completion of 17 years
of service as on 31.03.2005 allowing
effect from 01.02.2006
Regularization
of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc. workers
on completion of 15 years of service as
on 31.03.2006 allowing effect from
01.01.2007
Regularization
of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc. workers
on completion of 10 years of service as
on 31.03.2008 allowing effect from
01.07.2008
Regularization
of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc. workers
from the next date of completion of 10
years of service
Regularization
of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc. workers
working in State PSUs and Autonomous
bodies
including
AMC/NPs
on
completion of 10 years of service
Engagement of PTWs etc. as DRWs
(Group-D) working in different
Dated 07.11.2012
Departments of the Government for
2/3/4 hours who were engaged on or
prior to 31.03.2003 and have completed
10 years of service w.e.f. 01.12.2012
2. Recently, the matter has been further reviewed it has been observed that
there are some shortcoming in these instructions for regularization of the
service of DRWs/Casual/contingent staff affecting institutional efficiency
and individual productivity due to different reasons.
3. With a view to ensure transparent public employment policy for
engagement of staff for such services, all the memorandums as mentioned
above is repealed.
4. All the concerned are required to ensure the implementation of above
decision with immediate effect.
Under Secretary to
Government of Tripura
Finance Department”
22.
Now, reverting to the facts of the case of Narendra Kumar
Tiwari (supra), it comes to fore that the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had
noticed that the exercise undertaken by the State of Jharkhand for
regularization of irregularly appointed employees suffers from doctrine of
impossibility. The State of Jharkhand came into existence only on
15.11.2000, but the cut-off date for the purpose of regularization of the
irregularly appointed employees under the State of Jharkhand was fixed as
10.04.2006. It was noticed that the State of Jharkhand preferred to continue
with irregular appointments. In that context, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
had held that when the State of Jharkhand came into existence only on
15.11.2000 it was impossible for any of the employees to complete 10 (ten)
years of continuous service as on 10.04.2006, further holding that, such
pernicious practice of indefinitely continuing irregularly appointed
employees would be perpetuated contrary to the spirit and intent of the
decision of the Constitution Bench in Uma Devi (3)(supra) and directed the
State of Jharkhand to take a decision within four months from the date of
the judgment (decided on August, 1, 2018) for regularization of the services
of the irregularly appointed employees who have completed 10 (ten) years
of service.
23.
In our opinion, any direction for regularization dehors the
directions passed by the Constitution Bench in Uma Devi (3)(supra), will
tentamount to show disrespect to the Constitution as well as the directions
passed in Uma Devi(3)(supra) that the Central Government, the States and
their instrumentalities should desist from appointing any person
inconsistent to the constitutional schemes as enshrined under Articles 14
and 16 of the Constitution of India. According to us, the Constitution Bench
judgment in Uma Devi (3)(supra) is ratio decidendi upon all the courts.
24.
We have also taken note of the decision of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in Nihal Singh & Ors. vs. State of Punjab & Ors., reported
in (2013)14 SCC 65, where the State of Punjab was directed to regularize
the services of the Special Police Officers by creating necessary posts
within a certain period. After perusal of the said judgment, in our opinion,
in the said case, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had directed the Government
of Punjab to regularize the services of the SPOs on consideration of the fact
that requisition for engagement of SPOs was given by the bank authorities
to guard and protect the banks operating in the State and expenditures
including their salaries would be borne by those banks only, and not by the
State Government. So, it was a direction passed merely on facts.
Added to it, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Nihal
Singh(supra) categorically held that “the creation of posts necessarily
means additional financial burden on the exchequer of the State.
Depending upon the priorities of the State, the allocation of the finances is
no doubt exclusively within the domain of the legislature. However in the
instant case creation of new posts would not create any additional financial
burden to the State as the various banks at whose disposal the services of
each of the appellants is made available have agreed to bear the
burden.”[SCC p.80, para 36].
25.
More importantly, in Divisional Manager, Aravali Golf Club
& Anr. Vs. Chander Hass & Anr., reported in (2008) 1 SCC 683, the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court has settled the proposition that the courts cannot
direct the creation of posts. Creation and sanction of posts is a prerogative
act of the legislatures and executives. The Apex Court held thus:
“5. The court cannot direct the creation of posts. Creation and
sanction of posts is a prerogative of the executive or legislative authorities
and the court cannot arrogate to itself this purely executive or legislative
function, and direct creation of posts in any organisation. This Court has
time and again pointed out that the creation of a post is an executive or
legislative function and it involves economic factors. Hence the courts
cannot take upon themselves the power of creation of a post. Therefore, the
directions given by the High Court and the first appellate court to create the
posts of tractor driver and regularize the services of the respondents against
the said posts cannot be sustained and are hereby set aside.”
26.
In a later case, in Maharashtra State Road Transport
Corporation & Anr. vs. Casteribe Rajya Parivahan Karmchari
Sanghatana reported in (2009)8 SCC 556, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held
thus:
“41. Thus, there is no doubt that creation of posts is not within the
domain of judicial functions which obviously pertains to the executive. It is
also true that the status of permanency cannot be granted by the Court
where no such posts exist and that executive functions and powers with
regard to the creation of posts cannot be arrogated by the courts.”
27.
We have also kept in mind the case of Amarkant Rai vs. State
of Bihar & Ors., reported in (2015) 8 SCC 265, where the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court directed the Government of Bihar to regularize the services
of the petitioner, Amarkant Rai. In the said decision the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court had found that the petitioner/appellant Amarkant fell in exception
carved out in Umadevi(3)(supra). A two-Judge Bench of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in Amarkant (supra) had considered the fact that the
engagement of Amarkant was irregular but not illegal. He served for 29
years. There were two sanctioned vacant posts of Class IV employees in the
concerned college and Amarkant was appointed against the same. It was
found that the Human Resources Development, Department of Bihar
Government, vide its Letter dated 11.7.1989 intimated to the Registrar of
all the Colleges that as per the settlement dated 26.4.1989 held between
Bihar State University and College Employees' Federation and the
Government, it was agreed that the services of the employees working in
the educational institutions on the basis of prescribed staffing pattern are to
be regularized. Besides, in terms of Resolution No. 989 dated 10.5.1991
issued by the Human Resources Development Department, employees
working upto 10.5.1986 had to be adjusted against the vacancies arising in
future. It was noticed that the petitioner was appointed in 1983 temporarily.
In the context of the said case, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that though
the initial engagement of the appellant was not against a sanctioned post,
but, he was entitled to regularization pursuant to said resolution in one of
the sanctioned posts subsequently fell vacant.[SCC p. 269, para 9].
In the instant case, the writ petitioner could not make out a
case that she falls within the exception carved out in Uma Devi(3)(supra).
As we said earlier, the writ petitioner has neither pleaded nor the learned
counsel appearing on her behalf, has submitted that any sanctioned vacant
post exists at present.
28.
In State of M.P. & Ors. vs Yogesh Chandra Dubey & Ors.,
reported in (2006) 8 SCC 67, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court while dealing
with a claim of regularization and minimum of pay scale has held that the
State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India, while
offering public employment, must comply with the constitutional as also
statutory requirements. Appointments to the posts must be made in terms of
the existing Rules. A person, who had been appointed by State upon
following the Recruitment Rules, enjoys a status. A post must be created
and/or sanctioned before filling it up. As the respondents did not hold any
post, they are not entitled to any scale of pay. It has further been held that
regularization is not a mode of appointment. If any recruitment is made by
way of regularization, the same would mean a back door appointment,
which does not have any legal sanction [Ref. paras 9, 11 and 14].
29.
In M.P. State Coop. Bank Ltd. Bhopal vs Nanuram Yadav &
Ors. reported in (2007) 8 SCC 264, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court delineated
the principles of regularization as under: [SCC pp. 274, 275, Para 24]
“24) It is clear that in the matter of public appointments, the following
principles are to be followed:
1) The appointments made without following the appropriate procedure
under the Rules/Government Circulars and without advertisement or
inviting applications from the open market would amount to breach of Arts.
14 & 16 of the Constitution of India.
2) Regularisation cannot be a mode of appointment.
3) An appointment made in violation of the mandatory provisions of the
statute and in particular, ignoring the minimum educational qualification
and other essential qualification would be wholly illegal. Such illegality
cannot be cured by taking recourse to regularization.
4) Those who come by back door should go through that door.
5) No regularization is permissible in exercise of the statutory power
conferred under Art. 162 of the Constitution of India if the appointments
have been made in contravention of the statutory Rules.
6) The Court should not exercise its jurisdiction on misplaced sympathy.
7) If the mischief played so widespread and all pervasive, affecting the
result, so as to make it difficult to pick out the persons who have been
unlawfully benefited or wrongfully deprived of their selection, it will neither
be possible nor necessary to issue individual show-cause notice to each
selectee. The only way out would be to cancel the whole selection.
8) When the entire selection is stinking, conceived in fraud and delivered in
deceit, individual innocence has no place and the entire selection has to be
set aside.”
30.
Again, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Vibhuti Shankar
Pandey vs. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors., reported in (2023)3 SCC 639
had set aside the order of learned Single Judge of Madhya Pradesh High
Court directing the State to regularize the service of the petitioner who was
appointed on daily rated basis under a project and not against any
sanctioned post as it was noticed that the initial appointment of the
petitioner/appellant was not made by the competent authority and the
appointment was not made against a sanctioned post. The Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in Vibhuti Shankar Pandey(supra) has reiterated the
principle laid down in Umadevi (supra). [SCC p 640 para 4]. As we
discussed earlier, in the case in hand, the initial engagement/appointment of
the writ petitioner was not made by the competent authority of the
appellants and there is no evidence that she was engaged/appointed against
any sanctioned vacant post.
(emphasis supplied)
31.
In a recent decision, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Government of Tamil Nadu & Anr. vs. Tamil Nadu Makkal Nala
Paniyalargal & Ors., 2023 SCC Online SC 393, relying upon the
judgments of the Supreme Court in Chander Hass(supra) and
Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation(supra) reiterated the
principles that the creation of posts is not within the domain of judicial
functions and it pertains to the executive or legislature. In the case of
Government of Tamil Nadu(supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has
categorically held that in absence of sanctioned posts, the State cannot be
compelled to create the post and absorb the persons who are continuing in
service of the State.
32.
We have also taken into consideration the decision of the
Hon‟ble Supreme court in Raman Kumar & Ors. vs. Union of India &
Ors. [decided on July 03, 2023 in SLP(C) No.7898/2020], wherein the
Supreme Court has directed the regularization of 35 Group-D employees
considering the fact that the Chief Commissioner of Income Tax had found
that 65 persons were entitled to be regularized, but, the act of regularizing
the services of only 35 employees and not regularizing the services of other
employees including the petitioners was blatantly discriminatory or
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India on the ground that some
of the Group-D posts had been abolished. This case is clearly
distinguishable from the facts of the instant case.
33.
Nihal
The present case is clearly distinguishable from the cases of
Singh(supra),
Amarkant
Rai(supra),
Narendra
Kumar
Tiwari(supra) and Raman Kumar(supra) as regards the factual aspects are
concerned.
34.
On analysis of the above narrations of facts and the law
enunciated in the decisions cited above, the following ratios have emerged
out in matters related to regularization.
(i)
The engagement/appointment must be made by a
competent authority;
(ii)
The appointment must be against duly sanctioned vacant
post;
(iii)
Regularization, if any, has to be made within the realm
of the Government Rules/Circulars;
(iv)
The appointment should be irregular, but not illegal, to
justify his/her claim that he/she falls within the exception carved
out in para 53 of Uma Devi (3) (supra);
(v)
The court cannot direct the State or its instrumentalities
in regard to creation of post/s;
(vi)
Such irregularly appointed employees must have
requisite qualification for the posts they hold;
(vii)
The Courts should not be swayed with emotion and
sympathy;
(viii)
Budgetary provision and sanction thereto against the
post/s must be taken into consideration before passing any
direction for regularization;
(ix)
If there is any cut-off date, such date cannot be
elongated or extended;
35.
In the instant case, the writ petitioner was neither appointed
by the competent authority nor was she able to justify that she was engaged
against any duly sanctioned vacant post. Even the writ petitioner failed to
justify that she had requisite qualification to hold any post under the
respondents.
(emphasis supplied)
36.
There is yet another aspect. After perusal of the scheme dated
21.01.2009, it appears that sub-clause (iv) of the said scheme mandates that
except age and educational qualification mentioned in point (ii) & (iii) all
other criterion as per relevant Recruitment Rules including reservation
roster will have to be followed strictly for this process of regularization. In
the instant case, the writ petitioner has not come out with a case that at the
time of her appointment, reservation roster as embodied in Tripura
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991 and the
Rules thereto was followed or not. It is reiterated that to claim
regularization, all the parameters mentioned in the regularization scheme
have to be strictly followed and the appointment has to be made within the
realm of the scheme. On this score also, the claim of regularization made by
the writ petitioner in the present appeal cannot be entertained.
36.1.
Undoubtedly, we have noticed that there had been a divergent
opinion formed by different Benches of this Court in the matter of
regularization of DRWs/Contingent/Casual Workers, etc. In this situation,
in the opinion of this Court, there is no concept of negative equality under
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. In a case, where a person has a right
he has to be treated equally but where right is not available, a person cannot
claim as a matter of right to be treated equally as the right does not exist,
i.e. when the right does not exist, negative equality cannot be claimed.
We may gainfully refer the case of Basawaraj & Anr. vs.
Special Land Acquisition Officer, reported in (2013) 14 SCC 81 wherein
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held as under:
“8. It is a settled legal proposition that Article 14 of the Constitution is
not meant to perpetuate illegality or fraud, even by extending the wrong
decisions made in other cases. The said provision does not envisage
negative equality but has only a positive aspect. Thus, if some other
similarly situated persons have been granted some relief/benefit
inadvertently or by mistake, such an order does not confer any legal right on
others to get the same relief as well. If a wrong is committed in an earlier
case, it cannot be perpetuated. Equality is a trite, which cannot be claimed
in illegality and therefore, cannot be enforced by a citizen or court in a
negative manner. If an illegality and irregularity has been committed in
favour of an individual or a group of individuals or a wrong order has been
passed by a judicial forum, others cannot invoke the jurisdiction of the
higher or superior court for repeating or multiplying the same irregularity
or illegality or for passing a similarly wrong order. A wrong order/decision
in favour of any particular party does not entitle any other party to claim
benefits on the basis of the wrong decision. Even otherwise, Article 14
cannot be stretched too far for otherwise it would make functioning of
administration impossible. (Vide Chandigarh Admn. v. Jagjit Singh [(1995)
1 SCC 74 5: AIR 1995 SC 705],
Anand Buttons Ltd. v. State of
Haryana [(2005) 9 SCC 164 : AIR 2005 SC 565] , K.K. Bhalla v. State of
M.P. [(2006) 3 SCC 581 : AIR 2006 SC 898] and Fuljit Kaur v. State of
Punjab [(2010) 11 SCC 455 : AIR 2010 SC 1937] .)”
36.2.
Again, in the case of Chaman Lal vs. State of Punjab & Ors.
reported in (2014) 15 SCC 715, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had observed
thus:
“16. More so, it is also settled legal proposition that Article 14 does
not envisage for negative equality. In case a wrong benefit has been
conferred upon someone inadvertently or otherwise, it may not be a ground
to grant similar relief to others. This Court in Basawaraj v. Land
Acquisition Officer, (2013) 14 SCC 81 considered this issue and held as
under : (SCC p. 85, para 8)
“8. XXX
XXX
XXX”
36.3.
In the case of Fuljit Kaur vs. State of Punjab & Ors. reported
in (2010) 11 SCC 455, it was held by the Apex Court thus:
“11 The respondent cannot claim parity with D.S. Laungia [AIR 1993
P&H 54] in view of the settled legal proposition that Article 14 of the
Constitution of India does not envisage negative equality. Article 14 is
not meant to perpetuate illegality or fraud. Article 14 of the Constitution
has a positive concept. Equality is a trite, which cannot be claimed in
illegality and therefore, cannot be enforced by a citizen or court in a
negative manner. If an illegality and irregularity has been committed in
favour of an individual or a group of individuals or a wrong order has
been passed by a judicial forum, others cannot invoke the jurisdiction of
the higher or superior court for repeating or multiplying the same
irregularity or illegality or for passing a wrong order. A wrong
order/decision in favour of any particular party does not entitle any other
party to claim the benefits on the basis of the wrong decision. Even
otherwise Article 14 cannot be stretched too far otherwise it would make
function of the administration impossible. (Vide Coromandel Fertilizers
Ltd. v. Union of India [1984 Supp SCC 457 : 1984 SCC (Tax) 225 : AIR
1984 SC 1772] , Panchi Devi v. State of Rajasthan [(2009) 2 SCC 589 :
(2009) 1 SCC (L&S) 408] and Shanti Sports Club v. Union of
India [(2009) 15 SCC 705] .)”
36.4.
It would be apposite to refer the decision rendered in
Kulwinder Pal Singh & Anr. vs. State of Punjab & Ors. reported in (2010)
11 SCC 455, wherein the Apex Court while relying upon the case of State
of U.P. vs. Rajkumar Sharma reported in (2006) 3 SCC 330 had observed
as under:
“16. The learned counsel for the appellants contended that when
the other candidates were appointed in the post against dereserved
category, the same benefit should also be extended to the appellants.
Article 14 of the Constitution of India is not to perpetuate illegality and it
does not envisage negative equalities. In State of U.P. v. Rajkumar
Sharma, (2006) 3 SCC 330 it was held as under : (SCC p. 337, para 15)
“15. Even if in some cases appointments have been made by
mistake or wrongly, that does not confer any right on another
person. Article 14of the Constitution does not envisage negative
equality, and if the State committed the mistake it cannot be
forced to perpetuate the same mistake. (See Sneh Prabha v. State
of U.P. [Sneh Prabha v. State of U.P., (1996) 7 SCC 426]
; Jaipur Development Authority v. Daulat Mal Jain [Jaipur
Development Authority v. Daulat Mal Jain, (1997) 1 SCC 35]
; State
of
Haryana v. Ram
Kumar
Mann [State
of
Haryana v. Ram Kumar Mann, (1997) 3 SCC 321 : 1997 SCC
(L&S) 801]
; Faridabad CT Scan Centre v. DG, Health
Services [Faridabad CT Scan Centre v. DG, Health Services,
(1997) 7 SCC 752] ; Jalandhar Improvement Trust v. Sampuran
Singh [Jalandhar Improvement Trust v. Sampuran Singh, (1999)
3 SCC 494] ; State of Punjab v. Rajeev Sarwal [State of
Punjab v. Rajeev Sarwal, (1999) 9 SCC 240 : 1999 SCC (L&S)
1171]
; Yogesh
Kumar v. Govt.
(NCT
of
Delhi) [Yogesh
Kumar v. Govt. (NCT of Delhi), (2003) 3 SCC 548 : 2003 SCC
(L&S) 346] ; Union of India v. International Trading Co. [Union
of India v. International Trading Co., (2003) 5 SCC 437]
and Kastha
Niwarak
Grahnirman
Maryadit v. Indore Development
Sahakari
Sanstha
Authority [Kastha
Niwarak
Grahnirman Sahakari Sanstha Maryadit v. Indore Development
Authority, (2006) 2 SCC 604] .)”
Merely because some persons have been granted benefit illegally or by
mistake, it does not confer right upon the appellants to claim equality.”
36.5.
In Arup Das & Ors. vs. State of Assam & Ors., reported in
(2012) 5 SCC 559, the ratio was followed by the Apex Court thus:
“19. In a recent decision rendered by this Court in State of
U.P. v. Rajkumar Sharma [(2006) 3 SCC 330 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 565]
this Court once again had to consider the question of filling up of
vacancies over and above the number of vacancies advertised. Referring
to the various decisions rendered on this issue, this Court held that filling
up of vacancies over and above the number of vacancies advertised
would be violative of the fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution and that selectees could not claim
appointments as a matter of right. It was reiterated that mere inclusion of
candidates in the select list does not confer any right to be selected, even
if some of the vacancies remained unfilled. This Court went on to observe
further that even if in some cases appointments had been made by
mistake or wrongly, that did not confer any right of appointment to
another person, as Article 14 of the Constitution does not envisage
negative equality and if the State had committed a mistake, it cannot be
forced to perpetuate the said mistake.”
36.6.
In the case of State of Orissa & Anr. vs. Mamata Mohanty,
reported in (2011) 3 SCC 436, it was observed by Hon‟ble Supreme Court
thus:
“56. It is a settled legal proposition that Article 14 is not meant to
perpetuate illegality and it does not envisage negative equality. Thus,
even if some other similarly situated persons have been granted some
benefit inadvertently or by mistake, such order does not confer any legal
right on the petitioner to get the same relief. (Vide Chandigarh
Admn. v. Jagjit Singh [(1995) 1 SCC 745 : AIR 1995 SC 705] , Yogesh
Kumar v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi [(2003) 3 SCC 548 : 2003 SCC (L&S)
346 : AIR 2003 SC 1241]
, Anand Buttons Ltd. v. State of
Haryana [(2005) 9 SCC 164 : AIR 2005 SC 565] , K.K. Bhalla v. State of
M.P. [(2006) 3 SCC 581 : AIR 2006 SC 898] , Krishan Bhatt v. State of
J&K [(2008) 9 SCC 24 : (2008) 2 SCC (L&S) 783] , Upendra Narayan
Singh [(2009) 5 SCC 65 : (2009) 1 SCC (L&S) 1019] and Union of
India v. Kartick Chandra Mondal [(2010) 2 SCC 422 : (2010) 1 SCC
(L&S) 385 : AIR 2010 SC 3455] .)
37.
In view of the aforesaid exposition of law, it is abundantly
clear that in case of undue benefit conferred on someone inadvertently or
by ignoring the provision laid down in law, others similarly situated
persons cannot claim granting of similar benefit as a matter of right. Apart
from what we have discussed in the preceding paragraphs on the subject in
issue we are of the firm opinion that if a wrong committed in an earlier
case or cases, the same cannot be perpetuated by treating the same as
precedent.
(emphasis supplied)
38.
Before concluding, we must deal with the arguments advanced
by learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioner that since she was
engaged in the year 1993 her right to claim regularization was ripened in
the year 2003 or at least 2009 when the scheme for regularization was
existed before its repeal in the year 2018. We have considered the
submission of learned counsel. As we discussed earlier, the writ petitioner
herein has filed the writ petition on 29.11.2021. The scheme for
regularization has been repealed on 31.07.2018. In the opinion of this court,
the argument advanced by learned counsel for the writ petitioner would
have some force if the writ petitioner would have approached the court
during the existence of the scheme because regularization must be made
within the realm of the scheme.
39.
In our opinion, a person who enters into service in an irregular
manner at the whims of certain officers, and the Government made
provision to regularize the services of such irregularly appointed employee
under certain Schemes, then, he/she undoubtedly acquire right for
consideration of regularization of his/her services. However, in case of nonconsideration or discrimination, he/she must agitate their right and claim
the benefit of regularization before such scheme is repealed. The delayed
approach and lackadaisical attitude should not be given a liberal view. As is
well-known- “vigilantibus non dormientibus jura subveniunt”- equity helps
the vigilant and not the indolent i.e. equity comes to the rescue of those
who approach the court for their rights within time and not to the rescue of
those who slumber over their rights. In the instant case, according to the
writ petitioner, her right ought to have been considered in the year 2003 or
at least in the year 2009 after completion of 10(ten) years of services as per
the regularization schemes. But she has not agitated her rights till the
schemes are repealed in the year 2018. Repealing the schemes was a policy
decision of the Government and it is absolutely within their domain because
they know the ground realities as regards the requirements and continuation
of the scheme, which the courts do not have. Even she approached the
court, as we said earlier, in the year 2021 to get the benefit of the repealed
scheme, which according to this court, cannot be entertained at all.
40.
The persons appointed irregularly or illegally at the behest of
some officers depriving large number of eligible and competent job
aspirants are none but the offenders of committing wrongs against societal
as well as constitutional ethos, which, according to us, should not be
allowed to be perpetuated for an indefinite period, and after long ten years
of continuation of such schemes, thousands of job aspirants must expect to
see it‟s end in line with the constitutional mandates as enshrined under
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India in the matter of public
employment. Here, it is noticed that the Government of Tripura had
declared total ban on engagement of DRWs/ Casual/Contingent, etc.
workers under the Policy dated 21.01.2009 supra in the line of the
Constitutional scheme for employment and following the directives in Uma
Devi(3)(supra), the schemes for regularization of irregularly appointees
have been repealed under Notification dated 31st July, 2018.
41.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, we allow
the instant appeal preferred by the State. Consequently, we set aside the
impugned judgment and order dated 20.06.2022 passed by the learned
Single Judge in WP(C) No.867 of 2021.
(ARINDAM LODH, J)
Nihar/Snigdha
signed by
SANJAY Digitally
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2023.10.17
GHOSH 16:59:21 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review