Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:THC:544-DB
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A. No.101 of 2025
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Secretary, Social Welfare and
Social Education, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital
Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799010.
2. The Secretary, Department of Social Welfare and Social Education Govt. of
Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
3. The Secretary, Department of Finance, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
4. The Director, Social Welfare and Social Education, Malancha, Ujan
Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura.
5. Child Development Project Officer, Damcherra ICDS Project, North
Tripura.
……… Appellant(s).
VERSUS
1. Smt. Dhayarung Reang alias Daya Bati Reang, W/O. Shri Lalbeiseia Reang,
R/O. Kheracherra, VTC-Monacherra, Dist- North Tripura.
2. Smt. Phorbati Reang alias Fharbati Reang, W/O. Shri Debsnghi Reang,
R/O. Khedacherra, Monacherra, Dist-North Tripura.
3. Smt. Pusaiti Reang alias Pusairung Reang, W/O. Bidhayaham Reang, R/O.
Kacharicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
4. Smt. Sabitri Reang, W/O. Nanda Kumar Reang, R/O. Shantipur ICDS
center, Kacharicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
5. Smt. Purenti Reang, W/O. Shri Birdhiram Reang, R/O. Shantipur ICDS
center, Kacharicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
6. Smt. Jalirung Reang, W/O. Shri Pradip Molsom, R/O. 48 Uricherra,
Santipur, Kachiacherra, Dist-North Tripura.
7. Smt. Salukrung Reang alias Salukti Reang, W/O. Shri Aingyak Rai Reang,
R/O. Shantipurpara, Kacharicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
8. Smt. Gahanbati Reang, W/O. Botan Pranjoy Reang, R/O. Khedacherra,
Monacherra, Dist-North Tripura.
9. Smt. Gomaiti Reang alias Gumoti Reang, W/O. Lalnunzira Reang, R/O.
Khedacherra, Monaicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
10. The Union of India, to be represented by the Secretary, Ministry of
Women and Child Development, Govt. of India, Shastriya Bhawan, New
Delhi.
………Respondent(s).
2026:THC:544-DB
W.A. No.114 of 2025
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Secretary, Social Welfare and
Social Education, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital
Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799010.
2. The Secretary, Department of Social Welfare and Social Education Govt. of
Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
3. The Secretary, Department of Finance, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
4. The Director, Social Welfare and Social Education, Malancha, Ujan
Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura.
5. Child Development Project Officer, Damcherra ICDS Project, North
Tripura.
……… Appellant(s).
VERSUS
1. Smt. Ruati Reang, W/O. Shri Aichu Rai Reang, R/O. Kancharichhara,
Dist-North Tripura, Aged-50 years.
2. The Union of India, to be represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Women
and Child Development, Govt. of India, Shastriya Bhawan, New Delhi.
………Respondent(s).
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. S.M. Chakraborti, Advocate General,
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mrs. Aradhita Debbarma, Advocate.
W.A. No.16 of 2026
1. Smt. Dhayarung Reang alias Daya Bati Reang, W/O. Shri Lalbeiseia Reang,
R/O. Kheracherra, VTC-Monacherra, Dist- North Tripura.
2. Smt. Phorbati Reang alias Fharbati Reang, W/O. Shri Debsnghi Reang,
R/O. Khedacherra, Monacherra, Dist-North Tripura.
3. Smt. Pusaiti Reang alias Pusairung Reang, W/O. Bidhayaham Reang, R/O.
Kacharicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
4. Smt. Sabitri Reang, W/O. Nanda Kumar Reang, R/O. Shantipur ICDS
center, Kacharicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
5. Smt. Purenti Reang, W/O. Shri Birdhiram Reang, R/O. Shantipur ICDS
center, Kacharicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
6. Smt. Jalirung Reang, W/O. Shri Pradip Molsom, R/O. 48 Uricherra,
Santipur, Kachiacherra, Dist-North Tripura.
2026:THC:544-DB
7. Smt. Salukrung Reang alias Salukti Reang, W/O. Shri Aingyak Rai Reang,
R/O. Shantipurpara, Kacharicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
8. Smt. Gahanbati Reang, W/O. Botan Pranjoy Reang, R/O. Khedacherra,
Monacherra, Dist-North Tripura.
9. Smt. Gomaiti Reang alias Gumoti Reang, W/O. Lalnunzira Reang, R/O.
Khedacherra, Monaicherra, Dist-North Tripura.
……… Appellant(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Secretary, Department of
Social Welfare and Social Education, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
2. The Secretary, Department of Finance, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
3. The Director, Social Welfare and Social Education, Malancha, Ujan
Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799005.
4. The Child Development Project Officer, Damcherra ICDS Project, North
Tripura, Pin-799256.
………Respondent(s).
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mrs. Aradhita Debbarma, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. S.M. Chakraborti, Advocate General,
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Date of hearing
: 30.03.2026.
Date of judgment
: 29.04.2026.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(M.S. Ramachandra Rao, C.J.)
1)
Heard Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, counsel appearing for the appellants/
2026:THC:544-DB
petitioners and Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Additional Government Advocate
appearing for the State respondents.
2)
Writ Appeal No.16 of 2026 and Writ Appeal No.101 of 2025
arise out of the same judgment dt.24.07.2025 of the learned Single Judge in
WP(C) No.550 of 2024.
3)
Writ Appeal No.114 of 2025 arises out of the judgment
dt.10.09.2025 of the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.518 of 2025, where
the learned Single Judge had followed the judgment dt.24.07.2025 in WP(C)
No.550 of 2024 and granted relief partly to the petitioners in the WP(C)
No.518 of 2025/ respondents in the said appeal.
4)
The appellants in W.A. No.101 of 2025 and W.A. No.114 of
2025 are the State of Tripura and its officers. They shall be referred to in this
judgment as "State".
5)
The respondents in those Writ Appeals as well as the appellants
in W.A. No.16 of 2026 will be referred to henceforth as "petitioners".
6)
Petitioners 1, 2, 4, 6 & 8 were engaged as Anganwadi Workers
and petitioners 3, 5, 7 & 9 in WP(C) No.550 of 2024 were engaged as
Anganwadi Helper in different Anganwadi centres under the Damcherra ICDS
Project . The sole petitioner in WP(C) No.518 of 2025 was engaged as
Anganwadi Helper in one of the Anganwadi centres under the Damcherra
ICDS Project. They had been discharging their duties in their respective
Anganwadi centres ever since their respective dates of appointment between
2007 and 2010 to the full satisfaction of the competent authority.
7)
Meanwhile, the Child Development Project Officer of Damcherra
ICDS Project issued one memorandum dt.28.12.2022 mentioning that 5
2026:THC:544-DB
Anganwadi centres situated at Khakchang Para Nos.1 to 5, where the
petitioners were working as Anganwadi Workers and Anganwadi Helpers,
were shifted from Khakchang Para to Khahamthai Para without his consent,
that all Anganwadi centres of Khakchang Para were closed (locked) with all
equipments and utensils, and all the Bru people were also shifted from
Khakchang Para Bru camp to Khahamthai Para Bru camp in the last week of
November, 2022. The said memo also states that a report was submitted by the
CDPO, Damcherra ICDS Project to the Director, Social Welfare and Social
Education Department, Government of Tripura and the honorarium of all the
petitioners was to be stopped from the month of December, 2022 until further
orders.
8)
However, no subsequent decision was taken as regards the fate of
the petitioners and they were deprived of the honorarium, and the
engagements of the petitioners, though not specifically cancelled, were kept in
limbo.
9)
This prompted the petitioners to approach this Court by filing the
respective Writ Petitions contending that as per the Rules framed by the State
Government, the retiring age of Anganwadi Workers and Helpers was 60
years and so before such date, their engagement also cannot be terminated.
10)
Petitioners contend that shifting of an Anganwadi centre from
one place to another place merely results in change of location of such centre,
but does not change the status of its employees; and that their honorarium
cannot also be withheld on that ground as has been done from the month of
December, 2022 onwards, because they were not at fault, and they were not
being allowed by the State to work in the said Anganwadi centres.
11)
2026:THC:544-DB
The State, however, contended that the Bru Camp wherein the
Bru people were rehabilitated got shifted from Khakchang Para Bru camp to
Khahamthai Para Bru camp. So there was no further necessity of keeping
these Anganwadi centres operational in Khakchang Para. It contended that
department had started processing of engagement of Anganwadi Workers and
Helpers to newly established Anganwadi centre at Khahamthai Para. The State
opposed the prayer of the petitioners for honorarium on the ground that they
did not work during the period after December, 2022.
Judgment of the learned Single Judge:
12)
After considering the respective contentions of the parties and
taking note of the contents of the memorandum dt.28.12.2022 referred to
above, learned Single Judge held that withholding of honorarium of the
petitioners by delaying the decision making process as regards their fate, is not
proper, as no material was produced before him as to what decision was taken
on the report of the CDPO.
13)
Learned Single Judge also noted that no blame can be attached to
any of the petitioners as they were prevented from discharging their duties, but
since they did not discharge their duties, they cannot claim full honorarium.
14)
He, however, disposed of the Writ Petitions on 24.07.2025 and
10.09.2025 respectively with a direction to the Director, Social Welfare and
Social Education (respondent No.4) to take a conscious decision within 15
(fifteen) days of receipt of copy of the judgment on the reports submitted by
the CDPO, Damcherra ICDS Project to him. Simultaneously, he also directed
both of them to release 50% of the monthly honorarium to all the petitioners
2026:THC:544-DB
from December, 2022 till the period their honorarium is kept withheld and to
make the said payments up to July, 2025 within 4(four) weeks.
15)
Challenging the same, the State preferred W.A. No.101 of 2025
and W.A. No.114 of 2025. Petitioners in WP(C) No.550 of 2024 filed W.A.
No.16 of 2026.
The contentions of counsel for the State Government:
16)
Counsel for the State raised the following contentions in Writ
Appeals:
(i)
The petitioners had no cause of action and the Writ
Petitions should have been dismissed.
(ii)
According to him, the learned Single Judge had erred in
allowing 50% of the monthly honorarium, though the petitioners
had not rendered any service and that this was contrary to
established jurisprudence that honorarium is payable only for the
period of actual work done;
(iii)
According to him, no statutory right of the petitioners was
violated and that the learned Single Judge incorrectly applied the
doctrine of "Implied Continuity of Service", because there was no
mutual conduct indicating continuity of service during the
petitioners' non-operational period.
He placed reliance on the engagement orders of the
petitioners which mentioned that each candidate selected for the
Reang Migrant Camps may work as long as the Reang Migrants
stay;
(iv)
2026:THC:544-DB
According to him, there is no necessity existing to continue
to engage the services of petitioners because there is no person in
the Bru Camps/Anganwadi centres in which they were engaged,
after November, 2022 and they had all been shifted to another
location of the Bru Camp.
Contentions of petitioners:
17)
The counsel for the private parties/Writ Petitioners in W.P.(C)
No.518 of 2025 and W.P.(C) No.550 of 2024 out of which these Writ Appeals
arise (for short ‘petitioners’) refuted the said contentions and relied on the
judgment of this Court in State of Tripura and others v. Smt Bina Rani Paul
and Ors1 (‘Bina Rani Paul’ case) and the judgment of the Supreme Court in
Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya v. Distt. Development Officer, Dahod2 (for
short ‘Maniben’s case’).
18)
They contended that the learned Single Judge, in the impugned
judgments erred in giving only limited relief to petitioners and should have
directed the State to pay full honorarium and to allow the petitioners to resume
their duty as AWHs or AWWs instead of remitting the matter to the State
Officials.
19)
They contended that mere shifting of Anganwadi centers from
Khakchang Para to Khahamthai Para Bru Camp cannot be made an excuse for
depriving the petitioners of their entitlement to be in the service till they attain
the age of superannuation.
Judgment of DB of the Tripura High Court in W.A.No.83 of 2024 and batch dt.1.4.2026
(2022) 16 SCC 343
2026:THC:544-DB
The consideration by the Court:
20)
The important issues to be considered in this case are:
(i)
What is the nature of engagement of petitioners as AWWs
and AWHs?
(ii)
Whether their employment can be termed ‘contingent’ at
all?
(iii)
Whether the policy “No work, No pay/wages/Honorarium”
adopted by the State is valid?
(iv)
Whether financial constraints can be pleaded by the State
to deny petitioners any relief?
21)
We shall first consider the nature of engagement of petitioners as
AWWs and AWHs.
22)
In the judgment in Maniben’s case, the Supreme Court was
considering the question whether the AWWs and AWHs engaged in the State
of Gujarat were entitled to ‘gratuity’ under the Payment of Gratuity Act,1972.
It held that they were entitled to the said benefit.
23)
It relied mainly on the provisions of the National Food Security
Act, 2013 and has taken a view that one of the objectives of the said statute
was to improve the nutritional status of women and children and the said Act
intended to bring about a shift in addressing the issue of food security and
altered the previous ‘welfare’ approach to a ‘rights based’ approach.
24)
The Supreme Court also referred to para-7 of the Statement of
Objects and Reasons of the said statute and concluded that Anganwadi
Centres have been statutorily recognized under the 2013 Act and they had
2026:THC:544-DB
been entrusted with wide vital and significant role in implementing Sections 4
to 6 of the Act.
25)
It recorded that the said provisions lay down entitlements of
pregnant women, lactating mothers, and children in the age group of 6 months
to 6 years and provided also that children who suffered due to malnutrition are
entitled to the benefit of free meals through Anganwadi Centres.
26)
The Supreme Court held that these entitlements confer
corresponding rights on the said beneficiaries and that the benefits referred to
in the said Sections are provided through Anganwadi Centres as set out in the
Supplementary Nutrition (Under the Integrated Child Development Services
Scheme) Rules, 2017.
27)
It held that Anganwadi Centres perform a pivotal role in
discharging the statutory obligation of the State to provide nutritional support
to pregnant women, lactating mothers, and children in the age group of 6
months to 6 years, that these AWWs and AWHs constitute the backbone of
the Anganwadi Centres, and therefore, this onerous responsibility of extending
benefits under the National Food Security Act, 2013 to the beneficiaries is on
them.
28)
It declared:
“24. In view of the provisions of the 2013 Act and Section 11 of
the RTE Act, Anganwadi centres also perform statutory duties.
Therefore, even AWWs and AWHs perform statutory duties under
the said enactments. The Anganwadi centres have, thus, become
an extended arm of the Government in view of the enactment of
the 2013 Act and the Rules framed by the Government of
Gujarat. The Anganwadi centres have been established to give
effect to the obligations of the State defined under Article 47 of
2026:THC:544-DB
the Constitution. It can be safely said that the posts of AWWs and
AWHs are statutory posts.”
25. As far as the State of Gujarat is concerned, the
appointments of AWWs and AWHs are governed by the said
Rules. In view of the 2013 Act, AWWs and AWHs are no longer a
part of any temporary scheme of ICDS. It cannot be said that the
employment of AWWs and AWHs has temporary status.”
29)
The Supreme Court in Maniben’s case had thus held that
Anganwadi Centres and Mini Anganwadi Centres are part of the anganwadi
establishment of the State Government. (see also Para 36 of the judgment in
Maniben’s case).
30)
It also held in Maniben’s case that AWWs and AWHs are
‘employees’ and hold ‘statutory posts’, and also that what is paid to them
though called ‘honorarium’, it is in fact a ‘wage’, it is not open to the
appellants to again canvass the contrary propositions to deny the private
respondents the benefit of ‘gratuity’ under the Payment of Gratuity Act,1972.
31)
The above decision was applied by this Court in ‘Bina Rani
Paul’ case where the AWWS and AWHs of State of Tripura made a claim for
gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act,1972 and allowed their claims for
the said benefit.
32)
In ‘Bina Rani Paul’ case, this Court had noted that the
Government of Tripura had also issued a Notification No.F:1(1-21)ICDS/SWE/2018/5271(100) dated 17.01.2019 laying down the guidelines for
engagement of AWWs and AWHs under the ICDS Scheme in Tripura.
33)
These guidelines lay down the selection procedure of AWWs and
AWHs in the State of Tripura in the following terms:
2026:THC:544-DB
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
SOCIAL WELFARE AND SOCIAL EDUCATION
DEPARTMENT
**************
GUIDELINES FOR ENGAGEMENT OF ANGANWADI
WORKERS (AWWs)/ ANGANWADI HELPERS (AWHs) ON
HONORARY BASIS UNDER UMBRELLA ICDS SCHEME
IMPLEMENTED BY SOCIAL WELFARE & SOCIAL
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, GOVT. OF TRIPURA.
Selection Procedure:1. Advertisement of Vacancies:
a) The vacancies of Anganwadi Workers/Anganwadi Helpers
shall not be notified through the Employment Exchange.
b) The Child Development Project Officer wil call applications
for engagement of Anganwadi Workers/Anganwadi Helpers by
formally advertising the vacancies through News Papers.
c) Publicity of vacancies shall also be made through Block
Development Officers/ CEO of Urban Local Bodies/ICDS
Supervisors/Panchyat Secretaries.
d) Notice of vacancy shall also be notified in writing on the
notice board of Block Development Office/Gram Panchayat
Office/Ward Office/Child Development Project Office/concerned
Anganwadi centers.
e) Procedure for appointment with other relevant details would
also be published in the same letter/notice.
2. Eligibility Criteria:
Only such female married / widow candidates are eligible to
apply for the post of Anganwadi Worker/Anganwadi Helper who
are:
a) Normal residents of the village (in case of Rural Area) /ward
(in case of Urban Area) where Anganwadi Centre is located and
belongs to the feeder villages/wards of the Anganwadi area.
b) Freezing of the list of families being covered in the feeder area
of the AWC will be ensured before starting the selection process
and advertising of vacancies with due publicity. Only the
residents of the areas as above will be entitled to apply. If the
candidates are not available within the feeder area, applications
2026:THC:544-DB
can be invited from the desirous candidates residing within the
area of the concerned Gram Panchayat/Ward.
c) For Anganwadi Worker minimum qualification shall be
Matriculate and for Anganwadi Helper minimum qualification
shall be Class -VIII passed.
d) Age between 18-45 years, 5 years relaxation for SC/ ST/
Divyangjan (Differently able) candidates.
3. Application:
a) The desirous candidates will have to apply in prescribed
format to the Child Development Project Officer concerned with
requisite documents.
b) Receipts will be given to all the applicants by the Office of the
CDPO.
c) The applicants will be required to submit the testimonials/
certificates viz address proof, age proof (eligible documents),
educational qualification, citizenship, ration card, disability
certificate (if applicable), caste certificate (if applicable) along
with the application, which will be screened/scrutinized by the
Office of the CDPO.
d) After screening / scrutinizing, database of eligible applicants
will be prepared by the Office of the CDPO. Ineligible
candidates would be informed in writing by the CDPO with
proper receipt.
4. Interview Board-cum-Selection Committee:
Walk-interview for selection of candidate Anganwadi Workers
and Helpers shall be made by the following Board:i. Block Development Officer (in case of Rural area)
Executive Officer of AMC area/NP areas
- Chairman
ii. Medical Officer (Block area/AMC area/NP area) - Member
iii. Inspector of School (Block area/AMC area/NP area) Member
iv. Child Development Project Officer (concerned project) Member Secretary
2026:THC:544-DB
The Interview Board cum Selection Committee shall award
interview marks and prepare the merit list.
6. Panel of Selected Candidates:
For every selected/engaged candidate, two candidates who are
next in merit will be kept in waiting. This waiting list will be
valid for 6 months after the selection process is over.
7. Finalization & Declaration of result:
The result will be declared by the Interview Board cum Selection
Committee after taking approval from the Social Welfare and
Social Education Department, within 3 days of receipt of
approval from the department.
8. Offer of Appointment:
On the basis of results, the concerned Child Development Project
Officer will issue offer of appointment within 7 days of
declaration of results.
9. Appeal against selection:
1st and final appeal by any aggrieved candidate can be made to
the concerned District Magistrate & Collector who will decide
the same within 15 days from the date of filing appeal.”
34)
This Court in Bina Rani Paul’s case, noted the above uniform
procedure laid down by the State for recruitment in all Anganwadi Centres of
AWWs and AWHs and held that the selection is being made by a Selection
Board consisting of the Block Development Officer (in case of rural area) or
Executive Officer of AMC area/NP areas as Chairman, Medical Officer,
Inspector of School as the Members, and the Child Development Project
Officer as the Member Secretary. It therefore held that each Anganwadi
Centre is not a separate and distinct establishment as all of them, function as
components under the umbrella ICDS Scheme in Tripura which has now been
statutorily recognized under the National Food Security Act, 2013.
35)
2026:THC:544-DB
It also referred to the fact that the State Government had issued
the Memorandum dt.15.04.1992 (filed as an exhibit in Bina Rani Paul’s
case’), through the Directorate of Social Welfare and Social Education
engaging many AWHs for several Anganwadi Centres by a single order; and
through another notification dated 01.08.2015 (also filed as an exhibit in Bina
Rani Paul’s case’), the Government of Tripura had issued a common order for
all AWWs and AWHs with regard to payment of monthly pension/one time
financial benefit on their retirement or death treating them as a single class or
group.
36)
It rejected in the said case, the plea of the State that there are only
2 AWWs or AWHs in each Anganwadi center and so the Act cannot apply to
them because it requires 10 persons, and concluded that the Anganwadi
Centres and Mini Anganwadi Centres are part of the anganwadi establishment
of the State Government and it is not open to count their members centre wise
and treat them as distinct and separate.
37)
It also rejected the argument about the possible financial liability
which would be imposed on the State Government if the private respondents
in Bina Rani Paul’s case were to be granted gratuity under the Act and held
that, if the private respondents are entitled to the same on account of the
proper interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions of the Act, such as
Section 1(3)(b) thereof by the Supreme Court, the State cannot avoid the same
by taking such a plea. They cannot contend that this a matter of policy and the
Court should not enter into it.
38)
In view of the above settled legal position, after the enactment of
the National Food Security Act, 2013 and the above guidelines issued
2026:THC:544-DB
regarding uniform method of recruitment of AWWs and AWHs, there is no
manner of doubt that AWWs and AWHs in the Anganwadi centres hold
statutory posts and that the Anganwadi centres are part of the Anganwadi
establishment of the State Government. They therefore cannot be termed by
the State as ‘contingent employees’ or ‘temporary employees” without any
protection of service who can be terminated by the State before they attain the
age of superannuation.
39)
What is paid to them though called "honorarium", is in fact a
"wage" and it is not open to the State Government to treat each Anganwadi
centre as a separate and distinct establishment, because all of them functioning
in the State are components under the umbrella ICDS Scheme in Tripura,
which has now been statutorily recognized under the National Food Security
Act, 2013. Therefore, the State cannot contend that their engagement is centrewise and each centre is distinct and separate.
40)
Consequently, the employment of each of the petitioners cannot
be termed as "contingent" at all. Questions (i) and (ii) are answered
accordingly.
41)
Also a Full bench of the Allahabad High Court in Sheela Devi v.
State of U.P3. held that the Anganwadi workers, though appointed under a
scheme of the government, notwithstanding that they are not holders of civil
posts, are entitle to invoke the writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution against the order terminating their services passed by the CDPO,
a government functionary on grounds permissible for judicial review.
2010 SCC OnLine All 1142 : 2010 Lab IC (NOC 1051) 276 : (2010) 82 ALR 8 : (2010) 4
All LJ 485
42)
2026:THC:544-DB
The Clause in the letters issued to them when they were first
engaged as AWWs and AWHs treating them as having been engaged on
purely temporary basis and rendering such appointment liable to be cancelled
at any time without assigning any reason, cannot, therefore, be accepted as
valid after the passing of the National Food Security Act,2013. Such a clause,
when the petitioners and respondents have no equal bargaining power like in
this case, has been held arbitrary and contrary to public policy in Central
Inland Water Transport Corpn. v. Brojo Nath Ganguly4 where it was held
that such a clause was unconscionable and cannot be enforced. It had held in
the said case:
“89. … The principle deducible from the above discussions on
this part of the case is in consonance with right and reason,
intended to secure social and economic justice and conforms to
the mandate of the great equality clause in Article 14. This
principle is that the courts will not enforce and will, when called
upon to do so, strike down an unfair and unreasonable contract,
or an unfair and unreasonable clause in a contract, entered into
between parties who are not equal in bargaining power. It is
difficult to give an exhaustive list of all bargains of this type. No
court can visualize the different situations which can arise in the
affairs of men. One can only attempt to give some illustrations.
For instance, the above principle will apply where the inequality
of bargaining power is the result of the great disparity in the
economic strength of the contracting parties. It will apply where
the inequality is the result of circumstances, whether of the
creation of the parties or not. It will apply to situations in which
the weaker party is in a position in which he can obtain goods or
services or means of livelihood only upon the terms imposed by
the stronger party or go without them. It will also apply where a
(1986) 3 SCC 156 : 1986 SCC (L&S) 429, at page 215
2026:THC:544-DB
man has no choice, or rather no meaningful choice, but to give
his assent to a contract or to sign on the dotted line in a
prescribed or standard form or to accept a set of rules as part of
the contract, however unfair, unreasonable and unconscionable
a clause in that contract or form or rules may be. ..”
43)
The other Clause in their engagement letters which states that
their selection is for the Reang Migrant Camps and they would work only as
long as the Reang Migrants stay and it could not confer any right upon them
for appointment in Government Service or engagement in future also cannot
be countenanced for the same aforesaid reason after the coming into force of
the National Food Security Act,2013.
44)
Once they are statutory employees rendering the duties under the
ICDS Scheme framed under the National Food Security Act, 2013, in view of
the judgment of the Supreme Court in Maniben’s case and the judgment of
this Court in Bina Rani Paul’s case, merely because one Bru Camp where
they were working, is closed and shifted to another place, their employment
cannot be determined on that ground.
45)
Also admittedly, the shifting of the Bru Camp to the new place is
also under the same Damcherra ICDS Project and instead of employing new
persons replacing the petitioners, it was incumbent on the State to re-engage
the services of the petitioners at the new place as well.
46)
Whatever was the legal status of their appointment before the
coming into force of the National Food Security Act, 2013, once the said
statute had come into operation in the country and the AWWs and AWHs
have secured statutory recognition under that statute, the State Government
cannot continue to rely on the terms of their engagement orders and act
2026:THC:544-DB
arbitrarily and disengage them after they have been engaged for more than 15
to 18 years.
47)
This would be patently arbitrary, illegal and violative of Article
14 of the Constitution of India.
48)
Admittedly, the State Government itself has framed a Scheme
providing for superannuation of AWWs and AWHs on attaining of 60 years of
age; and in the absence of any misconduct on their part justifying their
disengagement, the State cannot simply disengage them on the pretext of
closure of the Anganwadi centres where they were working when they can be
re-engaged in the new place as well.
49)
The plea of the State that the principle of "No work, no pay" is
attracted, is equally not tenable for the reason that it is not the petitioners who
voluntarily stopped working, but it was the State which prevented them from
work and in such a situation, the above principle has no application.
50)
Paying a paltry honorarium as wage to these petitioners for
services they would have rendered had they been continued, cannot be said to
be imposing grave financial liability on the State, because the State cannot be
permitted to take advantage of their own wrong in disengaging their services
in an arbitrary manner and then pleading that the petitioners cannot be paid
anything after December, 2022.
51)
Accordingly, W.A. No.16 of 2026 is allowed; W.A. No.101 of
2025 and W.A. No.114 of 2025 are dismissed and the order of the learned
Single Judge in WP(C) No.550 of 2024 and WP(C) No.518 of 2025 is
modified as under:
(i)
2026:THC:544-DB
The State shall re-engage the petitioners in Khahamthai
Para Bru Camp or any other Anganwadi centre in the ICDS,
Damcherra Project within 4(four) weeks;
(ii)
The State shall pay full honorarium to the petitioners from
December, 2022 till their re-engagement within 8(eight) weeks.
No costs.
52.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(BISWAJIT PALIT, J)
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
Pulak
PULAK BANIK
Date: 2026.04.29 14:34:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review