The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. The learned Writ Court, however, fell in error in treating the vacant post of ST hearing category as available for being considered for appointment of a person like the petitioner who suffered from locomotor disability in the unreserved category. As such, the impugned judgment and order dated 06.03.2020 passed in WP(C) No.1106 of 2016 by the learned Writ Court cannot be sustained in the eye of law. It is accordingly set aside.
11. With the aforesaid observations, the writ appeal is allowed and stands disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. (S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ Pulak 2023.12.15 PULAK BANIK Date: 18:00:20 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A. No.451/2020
1. The State of Tripura, Represented by the Chief Secretary to the Government
of Tripura, New Civil Secretariat Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala-799010.
2. The State of Tripura, Represented by the Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, Department of Education (Social Welfare and Social Education),
Agartala, Tripura.
3. The Director of Education (Social Welfare and Social Education),
Government of Tripura, Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Tripura.
4. The Deputy Director of Education (Social Welfare and Social Education),
Government of Tripura, Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Tripura.
………Appellant(s).
VERSUS
Md. Suruk Ali, S/O. Md. Mahmad Ali, R/O. Jubarajnagar, Baburbazar, P.S.
Kailasahar, District-Unakoti, Tripura.
………Respondent(s).
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. R. Paul, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Date of hearing and judgment: 11th December, 2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Dipankar Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the appellants-State and Mr. R. Paul, learned counsel appearing
for the writ petitioner/respondent.
2.
The State of Tripura being aggrieved by the judgment and order
dated 06.03.2020 passed in WP(C) No.1106 of 2016 by the learned Writ Court
is in appeal. By the impugned judgment, the learned Writ Court has, inter alia,
held as under:
"6.
It is clear that 24 numbers of Group-C posts are still lying vacant
and these posts are roster verified. The reasons as assigned by the
respondents are that suitable candidates were not found from Schedule
Tribe/hearing category.
7.
From the said statement made in the counter affidavit, it is
revealed that some posts are reserved for the persons having hearing
disability. According to me, it amounts to reservation within
reservation. Physically handicapped persons themselves form a different
class and total 119 numbers of posts are kept reserved for this class of
person and all posts are roster verified. Reservation for a particular class
i.e., for hearing category persons is not permissible in law. The
advertisement as issued by the State-respondents only classified the
physically disabled persons as eligible for being appointed to those
posts. It was further clarified in the advertisement that the total number
of posts may vary for any category. It is also to be kept in mind that the
respondents while issuing advertisement did not specify the number of
posts to be reserved for persons having any particular type of disability.
Having found no such stipulation in the advertisement, in my opinion,
the petitioner deserves to be considered for appointment against the
vacant posts, otherwise, it would offend Article 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. In the context of the case, and having considered
the fact that 24 numbers of roster verified posts under Group-C category
are still lying vacant, I direct the State-respondents to consider the case
of the petitioner sympathetically, and appoint him in any Group-C posts
within the said 24 posts, keeping in mind the above observations made
by this Court.
8.
With the aforesaid observation and direction, the present writ
petition stands disposed. The entire exercise shall be completed within
4(four) months from the date the petitioner shall furnish a copy of this
order to the respondent No.3."
3.
The appellants contend that writ petitioner who was an unreserved
candidate with locomotor disability under the advertisement dated 24.06.2015
issued by the Education (Social Welfare and Social Education) Department,
Government of Tripura cannot be accommodated against the vacancy available
for the Scheduled Tribe candidate suffering from hearing disability.
4.
The respondents/appellants herein in their additional counter
affidavit made the following categorical statement:
"4.
That I humbly submit that total 119 nos. vacant posts have been
received for Group-C as per verified roster. Because Social Welfare &
Social Education Department did not receive clearly category wise &
cast wise verified posts from few Departments. However, it was clearly
mentioned in the newspaper on 30th June 2015 that the total number of
posts may vary for any category.
(A copy of the verified roster is annexed as Annexure RR/1 and
copy of the newspaper dated 30-06-2015 is annexed as Annexure RR/2)
5.
That I humbly submit that out of 119 nos. roster verified posts
under Group-C, initially Department has distributed/recommended
89(eighty nine) nos. posts to various Departments and 6 nos. posts for
Group-C have been kept in abeyance as 6(six) nos. eligible candidates
had submitted different date in regard to their date of birth in different
documents along with their application. And thus, 6 nos. posts for
Group-C have been retained for the said candidates till the finalization
of necessary verification from concerned certificate issuing authority.
Accordingly, after completion of necessary verification, these 6(six)
nos. posts have been distributed to the Departments. Therefore, total 95
(ninety five) nos. posts have been distributed/recommended to the
various Departments.
(A Copy of the Note-02 Dated 13-05-2016 is appended herewith
as Annexure RR/3).
6.
That I humbly submit that further, 24 (twenty four) nos. roster
verified posts under Group-C could not be distributed by the SW & SE
Department due to non availability of eligible candidates under
ST/Hearing category."
5.
Mr.
Dipankar Sarma, learned
Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the appellants-State, submits that since out of notified 119 posts,
95 were already filled up and distributed amongst different departments, the
remaining 24 roster verified posts could not be distributed due to nonavailability of eligible candidates under ST hearing category.
6.
As per the notification dated 24.05.2016 which is the list of
successful candidates, 89 were recommended for appointment to the post under
Group-C, out of which 43 belonged to the category of Visual disability, 26 to
the category of Locomotor disability and 20 to the category of Speech and
hearing disability. Petitioner's name did not figure in the category of Locomotor
disability. Therefore, he approached the Writ Court. The appellants further
contend that 6(six) no. of Group-C posts were kept in abeyance as these eligible
candidates had submitted different dates of their birth in different documents
with their application forms. These posts had been retained for the said
candidates till finalization of the necessary verification from the concerned
certificate issuing authority. After necessary verification, six number of posts
were distributed to the department. Therefore, total 95 number of posts have
been distributed/recommended to the various departments and only 24 number
roster verified posts of eligible ST hearing candidates in Group-C remained
vacant. Petitioner stood at Sl. No.65 in the merit list and as such, his claim for
being accommodated against the remaining 24 vacancies meant for ST hearing
category would be in teeth of the provisions of Section 33 of the Persons with
Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation)
Act, 1995 since the advertisement was issued during the prevalence of the 1995
Act. As per the said Act, 1% each was to be reserved for persons suffering from
(i) blindness or low vision; (ii) hearing impairment; and (iii) locomotor
disability or cerebral palsy in the post identified for each disability.
7.
Learned Addl. Government Advocate for the appellants has also
drawn the attention of this Court to the relevant provisions of the Tripura
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991. Paragraph-14
of the Schedule earmarks the reservation for physically handicapped categories
and the operation of the roster. It is submitted that in view of the ratio rendered
by the Apex Court in the case of Union of India and another vrs. National
Federation of the Blind and others reported in (2013) 10 SCC 772
(paragraphs-41 and 42), these vacancies are not interchangeable. In substance,
it is the case of the appellants that petitioner cannot seek appointment against a
vacancy available for ST hearing category as he was a candidate for the
vacancy available against locomotor disability in the unreserved category.
Therefore, the direction of the learned Writ Court requires interference,
otherwise it would amount to breaching the statutory mandate of the Act of
1995 and the Act of 1991 in a case of horizontal reservation and not vertical
reservation.
8.
Mr. R. Paul, learned counsel for the writ petitioner/respondent, has
taken the Court through the pleadings of the writ petition. The first plea raised
by him is to the effect that after the advertisement of 2012 bearing No.Tripura/
SW & SE/01/2012 did not lead to any appointment, these vacancies of
physically disabled category were carried forward under the 2015
advertisement and the distinction between the 3(three) physically disabled
category disappeared. However, on two counts such plea is untenable in law.
Firstly, the advertisement of 2012 did not lead to a recruitment process as the
advertisement was cancelled. As such, the vacancies were never carried
forward. It was a fresh recruitment exercise for the available vacancies of
physically disabled category. Secondly, learned counsel for the petitioner has
not been able to show any rule which provides for disappearance of the
earmarked vacancy of each of the physically disabled category in case they are
carried forward to a subsequent exercise on remaining unfilled. Since the first
advertisement of 2012 was cancelled and did not lead to any recruitment
exercise, the second ground becomes totally untenable on facts also.
9.
Learned counsel for the writ petitioner has then sought to raise a
point of fact which remains undisputed during course of writ proceedings. As
per the stand of the respondents in the additional counter affidavit extracted
above, after filling up of 95 of the 119 posts notified under the advertisement of
2015, the remaining 24 posts belonged to the hearing disability in ST category.
Indisputably, petitioner belongs to the unreserved category and suffered from
locomotor disability. The horizontal reservation guaranteed under the Act of
1995 provides for 1% each of the vacancies to persons suffering from the
following physical disability:
(i)
blindness or low vision;
(ii)
hearing impairment;
(iii)
locomotor disability or cerebral palsy.
The position in law as regards the allocation of posts as 1% for
each of the three physically disabled category stands settled by virtue of the
decision rendered by the Apex Court in the case of National Federation of the
Blind (supra).
10.
The learned Writ Court, however, fell in error in treating the
vacant post of ST hearing category as available for being considered for
appointment of a person like the petitioner who suffered from locomotor
disability in the unreserved category. As such, the impugned judgment and
order dated 06.03.2020 passed in WP(C) No.1106 of 2016 by the learned Writ
Court cannot be sustained in the eye of law. It is accordingly set aside.
11.
With the aforesaid observations, the writ appeal is allowed and
stands disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
2023.12.15
PULAK BANIK Date:
18:00:20 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review