Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 463/2020
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner & Secretary to
the Government of Tripura, Education (Higher) Department, Civil
Secretariat Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. East Agartala,
District- West Tripura, PIN- 799006;
2. The Director of Higher Education, Government of Tripura, old
Secretariat Complex, P.O. Agartala, District- West Tripura;
3. The Principal, Women’s Polytechnic Hapania, P.O. Amtali via
Sekherkote, PIN- 799130, West Tripura.
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
Sri Debasish Majumder, son of late Anil Kanti Majumder, resident of
Ramnagar Road No.5 (End), P.O. Ramnagar, Agartala, Tripura, P.S.
West Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN- 799002.
………….. Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Ms. S. Deb (Gupta), Advocate.
Date of hearing and
delivery of judgment
and order
: 22nd July, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
: NO
_B_E_F_O_R_E_
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. LODH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
Judgment & Order(Oral)
(S.G. Chattopadhyay, J)
The present writ appeal came to be filed against the judgment and
order dated 26.09.2019 passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.217 of
2019.
[2]
Heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate appearing
for the State-appellants as well as Ms. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel appearing
for the respondent.
[3]
The factual context of the case is as under:(i)
Respondent, Debasish Majumder was initially appointed as an
Accountant on 19.02.2004 on contractual basis under the District
Rural Development Agency (DRDA), North Tripura at Kailashahar,
as it was then. His tenure was later extended till 06.03.2006.
(ii)
Thereafter, in 2005, an advertisement inviting applications for
filling up various posts on deputation by employees holding
analogous posts in Government departments/PSUs/Stenographers’
Service came to be issued on 21.12.2005 under Advertisement
No.2/2005 by Women’s Polytechnic run by the Society for Women’s
Polytechnic, Agartala which was a society registered under the
Societies Registration Act, 1860.
(iii)
The respondent who is the original writ petitioner applied for
the post of Accountant in response to the said advertisement and he
was selected for the said post. By Order No.F.1(22) W.POLY.
SOCIETY/PPIU/2005/1819-30 dated 02.01.2006, he was engaged as
an Accountant on deputation under the Society for Women’s
Polytechnic, Agartala in the scale of pay of Rs.5,000–10,300/-.
Pursuant to his engagement as an Accountant in the Society for
Women’s Polytechnic, the Project Director, DRDA by his order dated
17.01.2006 (Annexure R/1 to the writ petition) released him from
DRDA, North Tripura in order to enable him to join his new posting
in the Women’s Polytechnic. Accordingly, the writ petitioner
(respondent herein) joined his new assignment in the Women’s
Polytechnic on 20.01.2006 by submitting his joining report
(Annexure-4 to the writ petition).
(iv)
Thereafter,
by
a
Notification
under
No.F.2(374)-
DHE/GTCA/07(L)/3945(16) dated 24.03.2010, the Government of
Tripura, Department of Education (Higher) had taken over Women’s
Polytechnic, Hapania with all its assets and liabilities with effect from
01.04.2010 and conferred upon the Women’s Polytechnic, Hapania
the status of a State Government technical institute under the
Education (Higher) Department. As a fall out of the said notification,
the registered society for Women’s Polytechnic was dissolved with
immediate effect.
(v)
Pursuant to the said notification dated 24.03.2010 (Annexure-6
to the writ petition), writ petitioner’s service was migrated and
continued in the capacity of Accountant under Education (Higher)
Department. Since he was not regularized in the post, the writ
petitioner (respondent herein) after rendering service over a
considerable period of time, submitted several representations to the
Director, Higher Education, Government of Tripura urging to
regularize him in the post of Accountant. But, instead of regularizing
him in service, the State Government in the Department of Higher
Education by issuing Memorandum No. F.7(235)-DHE/NG/2006(L-
2)/1131(4) dated 25.08.2014, engaged him as an Accountant afresh on
contractual basis for a period of one year on a consolidated pay of
Rs.24,256/- with effect from 01.04.2014 and he was posted in
Women’s Polytechnic, Agartala. By a subsequent memorandum dated
01.07.2015, he was re-engaged as an Accountant on contract basis for
a further period of 11 months. Aggrieved thereby, he approached this
Court by seeking remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India in WP(C) No.349/2015 claiming absorption in the post of
Accountant in regular scale of pay.
[4]
The learned Single Judge by a judgment and order dated 04.03.2016
passed in WP(C) 349/2015 (Annexue-10 to the writ petition) directed the State
Authority to consider for absorption of the petitioner in the post of Accountant in
regular scale of pay without delay. The order of the learned Single Judge in
paragraph 14 of the judgment reads as under:“14. Having regard to all these material facts, this court is of the
considered opinion that the respondents shall consider the petitioner for
absorption in the post of the Accountant in the regular scale of pay without
delay. The respondents are directed to complete the said exercise within a
period of 3(three) months from today. Till the petitioner is absorbed he
shall be allowed to continue as the Accountant on contractual basis.”
[5]
Pursuant to the said direction of this Court, the writ petitioner was
absorbed to the post of Accountant under the Directorate of Higher Education with
retrospective effect in regular scale of pay in Pay Band-2 of Rs.5,700-24,000/with Grade Pay of Rs.4,200/- under Memorandum No.F.5(381)-DHE/PLG/16
dated 05.12.2016 (Annexure-11) on condition that he would complete necessary
accounts training within 2 years from the date of absorption. The petitioner joined
the said post on 12.12.2016.
[6]
The petitioner had, after his regularization, approached this Court by
filling miscellaneous application bearing IA No.01/2018 (in WP(C) No. 349/2015)
for treating him as absorbed retrospectively from the date of deputation on
contractual engagement as Accountant in the Women’s Polytechnic.
[7]
Learned Single Judge instead of issuing any direction, reverted the
matter to the State-respondents for consideration whether the absorption of the
petitioner could be allowed retrospectively from the date of his contractual
engagement as an Accountant on deputation. By issuing memorandum under No.
F.7(235)-DHE/NG/2018(L)/2624(2) dated 07.12.2018 (Annexure 15 to the writ
petition), the Director of Higher Education, [Appellant No.2], rejected such prayer
holding that the absorption will have its effect from 13.12.2016.
[8]
Being aggrieved by the decision of the State-appellants declining to
absorb him in the regular scale of pay with retrospective effect from the date of his
engagement on deputation as an Accountant in Women’s Polytechnic, the
respondent approached this Court by filing WP(C) No.217 of 2019 seeking the
following reliefs:
(i)
To set aside the memorandum dated 07.12.2016, Annexure 15 to the
writ petition and to direct the State-respondents to treat petitioner’s
absorption w.e.f. 20.01.2006 for the purpose of calculating the qualifying
service for grant of his pension and other retiral benefits; and
(ii)
To count his past service w.e.f. 20.01.2006 with all financial benefits
which may accrue due to absorption w.e.f. 20.01.2006.
[9]
In the course of arguments before the learned Single Judge, Ms. S. Deb
(Gupta), learned counsel representing the present respondent (original writ
petitioner) relied on the following Memorandum dated 25.02.2010 of the Finance
Department, Government of Tripura regarding counting of past services of
Contingent Workers/DRWs/ Casual Workers towards calculation of their pension:
“NO.F.8(3)-FIN (G)/78
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
(General Section)
February 25, 2010
MEMORANDUM
Subject: Counting of service of Contingent Workers/DRWs/Casual
Workers towards pension etc.
References have been received from different Departments seeking
clarification about continuation of applicability of memo No.F.8(3)FIN(G)/78, dated 16.08.1978 and memo of even number dated 19.07.1982
regarding counting of half the period of continuous service rendered by
Contingent Workers/Copyist/Typist/Extra Mohafars etc who were paid
from „wages‟ on full time basis, towards pension and in respect of
DRWs/Contingent Workers/Monthly Rated Workers/Casual Workers
working on full time basis and subsequently regularized as per
Government decision.
[2]
After careful consideration of the matter, the Governor has been
pleased to decide that the benefit of counting of half of the period of
continuous service rendered by the DRWs/Contingent Workers/Monthly
Rated Workers/Casual Workers who were engaged on full time basis and
paid from „Wages‟ would be counted towards pension following their
regularization with the approval of the Finance Department. The benefit
provided under this circular will not have any relevance in declaration of
employees as quasi permanent/ permanent/counting of seniority/counting
of period for the purpose of determining eligibility for extending benefit of
CAS/ACP.
(N. Darlong)
Sd/.Illegible
Joint Secretary to the
Government of Tripura”
[10]
Ms. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel contended before the learned Single
Judge that relying on the said memorandum, relief was given to the petitioner in
the case of Smt. Mamata Rani Roy (Saha) vs. State of Tripura (judgment dated
08.10.2015 delivered in WP(C) No.77/2015). It would be pertinent to reproduce
hereunder the relevant extract of the said judgment rendered in the case of Smt.
Mamata Rani Roy (Saha) (supra) which is as under:
“11.
It would also be pertinent to mention that the Central
Government and the Government of Tripura have taken a decision that even
half of the services rendered by an employee on daily wages shall be counted
towards qualifying service. The person appointed on fixed pay basis is on a
much better footing than a person appointed on daily wages and if half of
the service rendered by a daily wages employee can be counted for
determining his/her qualifying service, I see no reason why the full service
rendered by a fixed pay employee should not be counted towards her
qualifying service if this uninterrupted service is followed by regular service.
12.
In view of the above discussion, the writ petition is allowed with
costs assessed at Rs.5,000/- (rupees five thousand) and it is directed that the
service rendered by the petitioner from the date of her joining as School
Mother on fixed pay basis pursuant to the letter of appointment dated 19-071990 till her regularisation shall be added to her regular service from 01-102007 till her superannuation on 03-11-2007 for calculating her pension and
other retiral benefits. The State shall ensure that the pension is accordingly
fixed and all retiral benefits be released in favour of the petitioner latest by
31st January, 2016 along with interest @ 9% per annum from the date of
retirement of the petitioner, i.e. 30-06-2013 till payment/deposit of this
amount.”
[11]
Counsel of the writ petitioner (respondent herein) argued before the
learned Single Judge that case of the present respondent was fully covered by the
judgment rendered in the case of Smt. Mamata Rani Roy (Saha) (supra) and
therefore, learned counsel urged before the learned Single Judge for providing
same relief to the respondent (original writ petitioner).
[12]
Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. on the other hand, argued before
the learned Single Judge that in his earlier writ petition, the present respondent
(original writ petitioner) never claimed counting of his past service as an
Accountant on deputation on contractual basis in terms of Finance Department’s
Memorandum dated 25.02.2010. Therefore, his claim in the subsequent writ
petition was barred by the principle of res judicata. The State-counsel also argued
before the learned Single Judge that petitioner was purely on contractual
employment for a particular period which was extended from time to time by
issuing fresh letters of engagement until he was absorbed in service with regular
scale of pay in terms of the judgment of this Court rendered in WP(C) 349/2015.
Therefore, he was not entitled to claim absorption in regular scale of pay with
retrospective effect.
[13]
Having appreciated the submissions of the counsel representing the
parties, the learned Single Judge was of the view that the writ petitioner
(respondent herein) was entitled to the benefit of past services in terms of Finance
Department’s Memorandum dated 25.02.2010 read with the law espoused by this
Court in the case of Smt. Mamata Rani Roy (Saha) (supra) and accordingly, the
learned Single Judge directed the State authority (appellants) to absorb the
petitioner in regular scale of pay with effect from 01.04.2010. Learned Single
Judge made the following observation in the impugned judgment:
“13.
Having appreciated the submission of the learned counsel for the
parties as well as the policy as espoused by the state government in the
memorandum dated 25.02.2010, and the decision of this court in Mamata
Rani Ray (Saha) (supra), this court is of the view that the petitioner shall
be entitled to the benefit of his past services, in terms of the memorandum
dated 25.02.2010 read with the law decided by this Court in Mamata Rani
Ray (Saha) (supra), from the date when the Institution was taken over by
the State by virtue of the notification No. F.2(374)DHE/GTCA/07(L)/3945(16) dated 24.03.2010 (Annexure 6 to the writ
petition) meaning from 01.04.2010.
14.
The full period starting from 01.04.2010 be added in terms of the
memorandum dated 25.02.2010 for pension and other retrial benefits and
not for any other purpose.
15.
Needless to say, that the order dated 07.12.2018 had been passed
in a completely different perspective and as such there is no reason to
interfere with the said order.
In terms of the above direction, this writ petition is partly allowed,
and the other reliefs, as indicated above, stand dismissed.”
[14]
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. appearing for the State-appellants
have raised the same points which were argued by the State-counsel before the
learned Single Judge. It is contended by Mr. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. that the
petitioner was engaged purely on contractual basis and his engagement was
regulated by the terms and conditions of the contractual appointment. His
engagements were renewed from time to time under fresh engagement letters and
moreover, the contractual appointment do not come within the purview of the
Finance
Department’s
Memorandum
dated
25.02.2010
since
the
said
memorandum has clearly catalogued the class of workers who are entitled to the
benefit provided under the said memorandum. According to learned G.A.
contractual engagement does not come within the purview of the said
memorandum. The State-counsel has therefore argued before us that the impugned
decision of the learned Single Judge based on Memorandum dated 25.02.2010 is
erroneous which calls for interference in appeal.
[15]
Ms. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel of the respondent while opposing
the contention of the State-counsel has vehemently argued that in similar
circumstances Smt. Mamata Rani Roy (Saha) (supra) in WP(C) No.77/2015 was
given the benefit of absorption with retrospective effect in terms of Finance
Department’s memorandum dated 25.02.2010. The decision in Smt. Mamata Rani
Roy (Saha) (supra) was never challenged by the State Government. Therefore, the
law laid down by this Court in the case of Smt. Mamata Rani Roy (Saha) (supra)
holds the field. Counsel has therefore argued that there is no ground to interfere
with the judgment of the learned Single Judge.
[16]
We have considered the submissions made by learned counsel of the
parties before us. We have also perused the entire materials placed before us.
[17]
Admittedly, the respondent (original writ petitioner) has been
rendering service as an Accountant since his initial contractual appointment on
19.02.2004 in DRDA, North Tripura at Kailashahar. Term of his contractual
appointment was then extended till 06.03.2006. Before the term came to end, he
applied for the post of Accountant on deputation in Women’s Polytechnic run by
the Society for Women’s Polytechnic in response to Advertisement No.2/2005
dated 21.12.2005 and in due course, he was selected for the post and by order No.
F.1(22) W.POLY.SOCIETY/PPIU/2005/1819-30 dated 02.01.2006, he was
engaged as an Accountant on deputation under the Society for Women’s
Polytechnic, Agartala in the scale of pay of Rs.5,000-10,300/-. Since he was at that
time engaged as an Accountant in DRDA, North Tripura, he was officially
released from DRDA to join his new assignment. Accordingly, he joined
Women’s Polytechnic on 20.01.2006.
[18]
By a Notification dated 24.03.2010, the State Government had taken
over Women’s Polytechnic with all its assets and liabilities with effect from
01.04.2010 from the registered society which was running the said Women’s
Polytechnic and conferred the status of a State Government technical institute
under the Education (Higher) Department on the said Women’s Polytechnic. Since
the State Government was reluctant to regularize the respondent (original writ
petitioner) despite his migration to the Department of Higher Education,
Government of Tripura, he approached the High Court and pursuant to the
judgment of the learned Single Judge in WP(C) 349/2015, he was absorbed in
regular scale of pay as an Accountant by the State Government under the
Department of Higher Education, Government of Tripura with effect from
05.12.2016. Petitioner further approached this Court by filing a review petition
before the learned Single Judge seeking direction for his absorption with
retrospective effect. The learned Single Judge reverted the matter to present
appellant No.2 for consideration. The State-appellant after reconsideration of the
matter, rejected the claim of the respondent (original writ petitioner). Then the
respondent approached this Court seeking absorption with effect from 20.01.2006
i.e. date on which he joined Women’s Polytechnic on deputation after being
selected through a regular selection process pursuant to Advertisement No.2/2005
dated 21.12.2005.
[19]
Notification dated 25.02.2010 of the Finance Department clearly
contemplates that half of the period of continuous service rendered by
DRWs/Contingent Workers/ Monthly Rated Workers/Casual Workers who were
engaged on full-time basis and paid from ‘wages’ would be counted towards
pension following their regularization with the approval of the Finance
Department. In the case of Smt. Mamata Rani Roy (Saha) (supra), petitioner was
a fixed-pay employee. While appreciating the Finance Department’s memo dated
25.02.2010, in the case of Smt. Mamata Rani Roy (Saha) (supra), it was held by
this Court that even though there was no specific mention of fixed –pay employees
in the said memorandum, the person appointed on fixed-pay basis is on a much
better footing than a person appointed on daily wages and if half of the service
rendered by a daily wager can be counted for determination of his/her qualifying
service for pension, there was no reason for not counting the full service rendered
by a fixed-pay employee towards his/her qualifying service if the uninterrupted
service was followed by a regular service. In the present case, the respondent (the
original writ petitioner) has been rendering service as an Accountant in the
Women’s Polytechnic since 20.01.2006 without any break in service. Admittedly,
he was selected for the post through a proper selection procedure against an
advertisement issued on 21.12.2005. There is no dispute that he is working on fulltime basis and he is being paid from ‘wages’. Obviously, his uninterrupted service
was followed by a regular service.
[20]
In these circumstances, we find no embargo in applying Finance
Department’s Memorandum dated 25.02.2010 to the case of the respondent
(original writ petitioner). Moreover, his case is squarely covered by the decision of
this Court rendered in Smt. Mamata Rani Roy (Saha) vs. State of Tripura
(supra).
[21]
For the reasons stated above, we are not persuaded to interfere with
the judgment of the learned Single Judge. Resultantly, the appeal stands dismissed.
Appellants are directed to comply with the directions of the learned Single Judge
within 3(three) months from today.
In terms of the above, the writ appeal stands disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi G.
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review