The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. In view of the law laid down by the Hon,blc Apex Court, the ingredients of Section 31 I of Cr.p.C. and the essentiality evidence of the witness to be examined, along with marking of FIR as an Exhibit through him, indeecl are vital for a just decision in the case and relief as prayed must have gralted keeping in mind the gravity of charges. I just decision in a case is the touchstone which i i , : i I I decision making for a Court to recall, examine of been he need for a must guide the and re examine, h Y .J,TK, J ..\r 73ss 2025 if evidence is essential to achieve a just decisio r this crucial aspect cannot be ignored.
13. In the circumstances narrated above, this '- rurt is of the considered opinion that the order dated ) t . )4 .2025 in Crl.M.P.No.87 of 2025 in S.C. No.128 of 2() t passed by lear:red I Additional Sessions Judge, Hanumakc t c.a, need s to bc set asidc and is accordingly set aside. L4. The Court of learned I Additional Ser;, ions Judgc, Hanumakonda, is directed to recall PW 2 I for further ex:rmination, get thc FIR marked as an Exhib jt. Ncedlcss to state, an opportunity shall be given to the othe- l;idc to ra,rise objcction(s), for a fair and just decision.
15. For rcasons aforesaid, this Criminal Petitior L ir; allowed Miscellaneous applications pending, if an shall stand " closed. } )/- L VIJAYA LAXMI S I iTANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY// \ S;ECTION OFFICER To,
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA // AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY SEVENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR JUKANTI
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 73 55 0F 2025
Between:
The State of Telangana, through Station House Officer, Kazipet p.S., Rep by
The Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State of Telangana, Hyderabad.
... Petitioner/Com plaina nt
AND
1, Sunchu Ashrsh, S/o Srinrvas, Age 19 years, Occ. Student, R/o. H.No 25-4-
/753/4, Somidi, Kazipet
2. Sunchu Srinrvas, S/o Yellaiah, Age 45 years, Occ. Hire with RTC Driver, R/o.
H No.25-4-753lA, Somidi, Kazipet.
3. Sunchu Ramesh, Sio Yellaiah, Age 50 years, Occ. RTC Driver, R/o.H.No.254 -7 53/4, Somidi, Kazrpet
4. Sunchu Thirupathi, Sio. Yellaiah, Age 40 years, Occ. Rarlway Contract
Employee, R/o. H. No 25 -4-7 5318, Somidi, Kazipet.
... Res po ndents/Acc used
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances
stated in the [\rlemorandum of Grounds of Criminal petition, the High Court may
be pleased to allow this crimrnal petition by setting aside the order dt. 24t4l2o25
passed in Crl.lt/l P.No.87 of 2025 in S.C.No.'128 of 2019 on the file of the
Additional Sessions Judge, Hanamkonda and consequently recall pw-21 for
further examination in chief for marking of FIR in the interest of justice.
I
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the lvlemorandum of
Grounds of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of lVr SUREpALLI
PRASHANATH, Assistant PUBLTC PROSECUTOR, for the petitioner and none
appeared for the Respo n d en ts/Accu sed No.1 to 4,
The Court made the following: ORDER
d
THE HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR
J J AANTI
CRIMINAL PETITIO N No. 7355 0F 2 \its
o RDER:
'lhis Criminal Petitior-r is hled uncler Secti -- I 528 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita' 2023
(for ;.rort. 'BNSS')
by State seeking t.o set asidc the Orde r datcd '
Cri.M.P.No.87 of 2025 in S C'No l28 of 2Ol9
1 04 '2025 in
pas'' :1 by learned
I Additional Sessiotts Judge, I{anumakonda'
Ileard Mr. Surepalli Prashanth' learnecl A; i stant
2,
l\blic
r appears for
Prosecutor appear-ing lor petitioner- S t ate ' Nor
Nos' 1 to 4. The ( r ltnsel name
respondents / accuscd
Sri A. Prabhakar Rao is reflected in the cause
there is no representation on behalf of the couns
st. However,
e
On the basis of a complaint given by ';
.re Sonaboina
Saraiah, an Express FIR bcaring No01/2O1f
came to be
registered for offences under Sections 302 anc
201 read with
3.
Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 186O
(i r short 'lPC').
Charge sheet came to be hled on 17 'O7 '2O
following Persons as accused:
I
.
Sunchu Ashish
3 naming the
JAK, J
c.lp 7355 2025
Sunchu Srinivas
lr 1.
Sunchu Ramesh
tv.
Sunchu Thirupathi
(a)l are residents of Kazipet)
4.
It is alleged that grudges cleveloped
in
distribu tion be tween D I
propcrty
, D2 (who are the decea secl) and
respondents / accu secl Nos. I to
4. It is further alleged that on
01.01.2O18 in betneen 21:00 hours
to 2l:2O hours at Housc
No.25-4 783, Somicli, Kazipet, responclen
2 attacked Dl and D2_ Respondent/
ts/accused Nos.1 and
accused No.1 attacked D2
with knife, cut the throat of D2, stabbed
her on back on
different parts of the body, later respondents/
and 2 entered into bed room of D1
accused Nos.1
and respondent/ accusecl
No.2 caught hold of D I and respondent/accused
No.1 stabbed
him incliscriminately for about ten to twenty
causecl instantaneous death. The
respondents/accused Nos.3 and
times and
allegation
agalnst
4 is that they have concealed
evidence related to both deaths,
thereby causing the
disappearance of evidence.
A petition i.e., Crl.M.p.No.87 of 2O2S
2O 19 came
in S.C.No.128 of
to be hled under Section 3 1 i ol_ the
Cocle of
.IAK..I
c.lp 7355 2025
I
Criminal Procedure (for short 'Cr.P.C.) by the Sta -, represerlted
by the Station House Officcr, Kazipet Pr I t:e Station.
S.C.No. 128 of 2019 was posted on 16.12.'2O2t. i'lvidence of
Investigat.ing Ofhcer (Ch.Ajay) rvas recorded , r PW 2 1 on
01.O5.2O24 and further cross examination was h' c al-rd closcd
on 13.06.2024. tt is the case of the proscct 1 on that lhe
prosecution did not mark the I"lR due to ovcr-siglr luring chief
examination and case was coming for reply arguD.r ltt.s.
6.
On hling a petition undcr Section 311 of (l .P.C., it \\ras
requested to the Court to recall PW-21 for furthe :'<amination-
in-chief arrd mark the FIR as trxhibit in 'P' seric s rnd Lhus to
allow the petition. It was prayed that- if the C c ;rt does uot
recall PW-21, it would amount to unfair trial arr lrecalling of
PW-21 would not prejuclice the case of respon,l nts/accused
Nos.l to 4 ald in fact it wouid lead to just:c :. Lean'red I
Additional Sessions Judge, Hanumakonda, b1 order dated
24.O4.2025, held as follows:
POINT: Having considered the submi ; ions on both
sides and having perused the record, the p', sent petition
is frled after submitting argumcnts by the 1> csecution as
well as by the defence Counsel and wht r the mntter
adjourned for judgment. Since this petition s hled at the
fag end of the case and further when the ', i-ness/PW2 1
"5.
JAK, J
crlp 7355_2025
was examined by the prosecution, the prosecution did not
tirke arry measures to get the FIR exhibited through him
and PW2 1 was also subjected to cross_examination.
6.
At this stage, after completion of cross examination
of PW2l ancl after hearing the arguments ald when the
matter posted for reply arguments, the present petition is
filed. Ilence, this Court is of the opinion that the present
petition cannot bc allowed and if the petition is allowecl it
may cause prejudice to the respondents/A 1 to .{4. This
point is answered accordingly.,,
7.
Learned Assistant public prosecutor appearing for
petitioner/ State i.e., complainant submitted that learned I
Additional Sessions Judge, Hanumakoncla, erred in not
considering the legal position correctly. It is further submitted
that it is a case ol brutal murder and the respondents are
accused Nos. 1 to 4. it is submitted that the power under
Section 311 of Cr.P.C. is very wide anrl the powers are to be
exercised for the justice is the criteria and the power cal be
exercised at any stage of inquiry, trial or any other proceedings
under Cr.P.C. It is further submitted that the ambit of Section
311 of Cr.P.C. allows the Courts to exercise the power at any
stage.
8.
Learned Assistant Public prosecutor placed reliance on
the Hon'ble Apex Court judgment io Varsha Ga.rg u. State of
JAK, J
ctlp-7355 2025
-t
Mad.hga Pradesh and. othersl and invited atttrt lion of this
Court to paragraph Nos.31, 36,40,41, 48 and 5o
9.
Section 31 1 of Cr.P.C. rcads as follows
"3 1 1. Power to summon material witnes s , or
examine person Present.
- Any Court mav, at any stage of any inquiry, tr-ial
or other proceeding under this Code, summo irtl.1'
person as witncss, or examine any pcrs'r I in
attendance, though not summoned as a rvi I t'ss,
or recall anci re-examine any persoll :r r I ldt'
examinerl; and the Court shall sr-lmmor ltlld
examine or recall and re-examille any such P < :sot-t
if his evidence appears to it to bc essential .( thc
just decision of the case."
10. On perusal of the order daLed 24 'O4 '2O ) i passed by
'it is
leaned I Additional Sessions Judge, I Ianum r onda,
apparent that the Court fell into error in not c
>
r
sidering the
aspect of lust decision". The trial Court holI rrg that the
petition is filed at fag end of the case and that r" t:ress/PW-21
was cxamined by the prosecution and the prosec ,rtion did not
take any measures to get the FIR exhibited thr:) ,rgh him and
PW-21 was also subjected to cross examination t rrd that after
completion of cross examination and after hearing the
' lzoza; ro scc o16
JAK, J
crlp-7355 2025
arguments and when the matter was posted
for reply
arguments, Crl.M.p.No.B7 ot 2025 in S.C.No t28
of 2O19 is
filed and declining to grant relief is not the right
approach.
11. Power under Section 3l l of Cr.p,C. is governed by the
requirement of justice. The Hon'ble Apex court
helcr that the
statutory provision (i.e., Section 31 1 Cr.p.C.) emphasise(s)
that
the Court is not a hapless bystander in the derailment
justice. It further held that the Court has
of
a vital role to
discharge in ensuring that thc cause of cliscovering
truth as an
aid in the realization of justice is manifest. .t.he apparent
misconception of trial Court o[ the law is not only
powers under Section 31 I of Cr.p.C. were not
fatal, but the
exercised in a
pJoper manner.
12. In view of the law laid down by the Hon,blc Apex Court,
the ingredients of Section 31 I of Cr.p.C. and the essentiality
evidence of the witness to be examined, along with
marking of
FIR as an Exhibit through him, indeecl are vital for
a just
decision in the case and relief as prayed must have
gralted keeping in mind the gravity of charges. I
just decision in a case is the touchstone which
i
i
,
:
i
I
I
decision making for a Court to recall, examine
of
been
he need for a
must guide the
and re examine,
h
Y
.J,TK, J
..\r 73ss 2025
if evidence is essential to achieve a just decisio r this crucial
aspect cannot be ignored.
13. In the circumstances narrated above, this '- rurt is of the
considered opinion that the order dated ) t . )4 .2025 in
Crl.M.P.No.87 of 2025 in S.C. No.128 of 2() t passed by
lear:red I Additional Sessions Judge, Hanumakc t c.a, need s to
bc set asidc and is accordingly set aside.
L4. The Court of learned I Additional Ser;, ions Judgc,
Hanumakonda, is directed to recall PW 2 I
for further
ex:rmination, get thc FIR marked as an Exhib jt. Ncedlcss to
state, an opportunity shall be given to the othe- l;idc to ra,rise
objcction(s), for a fair and just decision.
15. For rcasons aforesaid, this Criminal Petitior L ir; allowed
Miscellaneous applications pending, if an shall stand
"
closed.
} )/- L VIJAYA LAXMI
S I iTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
\
S;ECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The lV Additional First Class Magistrate at Warangal.
2. I Additional Sessions Judge, Hanamkonda.
3. The Station House Officer, Kazipet police Station, Wara I 1,:l Dist.
4 Two ccs to the Public Prosecutor, High court for the r; rte of rerangana, at
C,
Hyderabad [OU1l
5, One CC to Mr. A PRABHAKAR RAO Advocate
Two CD Copies
[OPUC]
t
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2710112026
(
IiE S
I
-t
rr B 202fi
*
ORDER
S:ATC
:
==-----=:--
*
CRLP.No.7355 of 2025
Accordingly, this Criminal Petition is l, Iowed.
)4
z
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review