Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3488 I
lN THE HIGH COURT FOR T-H-E STATE OF TEITANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent prefened against the order dated
28t1Ot2O25 in W.P.No.32351 of 2025 on the file of the High court.
Between
U?.:#:^?fdI:'F1351?03,?ltil'ff"J5"tt,:Illi8;11.ffi ::"'li,%,1'o,Tl
2. The Collector (CS), Kumuram Bheem Asifabad District, Asifabad'
3. The Deputy Tahsildar (CS), Dahegaon Mandal, Kumuram Bheem Asifabad
District.
...APPELLANTS/RESPONDE NTS
AND
Sri Vasavi Rice
1. Sandeep Sura, S/o.Madhu\?.t, Ag". 45 Years, O-cc Business.
Asifabad
Bheem
frlif i Fio6r- tor;' D;h;gion Vittdge-and Manciai. Kumuram
District.
of the
Village,
2. Gulbam Rakesh, S/o.Gulbam
Vehicle Bearing No. TS19T
Kannepally Mandal, Mancherial
........ RESPONDENTS/WRIT PETITIONERS
3. The Station House Officer,
Police Station. Kumuram Bheem
Asifabad District.
(Responden[ No-g is Proforma Party to thisAppdal)...RESPON DENT'RESPON DE NT
lA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pteased suspend
the order daled. 28-10-2025 passed in W.P.No .32351 of 2O25, pending disposal of
the Writ Appeal.
Counsel for the Appellants: SRI N.S.ARJUN KUMAR,
GP FOR GP FOR CIVIL SUPPLTES
Counsel forthe Respondents No 1 &2: SRI K. VENUMADHAV
counselforthe Respondent No 3: sRt J. MAJESH RAJU, cp FoR HOME
The Court rnade the following: JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH COT'RT FOR THE STATE OF TELIINGAI{A
AT IIYDERABAD
THE HONtsLE THE CHIEF JUSUCE SRI APARESH KI'ITIAR SINGH
AI{D
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHII'DDIN
IVRIT APPEAL No. 1O7 OF 2o.26
DATEI 29.OL.2O26
Between:
The State of Telang€Lna, represented by its
Principal Secretary to the Consumer Affairs,
Food and Civil Supplied, Secretariat
Buildings, Hyderabad and 2 others.
....Appellants
AND
Sandeep Sura and 2 others.
....Respondents
JUDGMENT
This Writ Appeal assails the order dated 28.10.2025 passed
by the learned Single Judge in W.P.No.3235 L of 202\ _whereby the
learned Single Judge directed the appellants to release the seized
stock of rice (54.15 quintals), vehicle (TS 19 T 8902) and cell
phones, on the ground that the seized rice was not found to be
Public Distribution System (PDS) rice.
2.
Heard Sri N.S.Arjun Kumar, learned Government Pleader'for
Civil Suppties appearing for the appellants, Sri K.Venu Madhav,
learned counsel for respondent Nos.l and 2 and Sri Majesh Raju,
learned Gov,lrnment pleader for Home appearirig for respondent
No.3 and perused the record.
Factual Mat.rix in brieft
3.
on 09.o9.2o2s, acting upon credible information, the
Enforcemenc officials of the civil Supplies Department conducted
an inspecticn of the premises of M/s Sri vasavi Modern Rice Mill,
situated at Dahegaon, belonging to respondent No.l. During the
course of the inspection, a vehicle bearing registration No. TS 19 r
8902 was found unloading rice packed in plastic bags. on
verification, a quantity of 54.15 quintals of rice, suspected to be
PDS rice mrlant for illegal diversion and recl,cling, rvas seized along
with the said vehicle and certain mobile phonr:s.
4-
consequent thereto, proceedings under Section 6-4 of the
Essential tlommodities Act, 19s5 (for short '195s Act,) were
initiated b,:fore the collector (civil supplies), Kumuram Bheem
Asifabad, Ibr confiscation of the seized rice, vehicle, and other
material. iSimultaneously, FIR No. 111 of 2025 came to be
registered against the respondents alleging tampering with seized
evidence.
5.
A sample of the seized rice was forwarded for analysis and
was examined on 1t.o9.2o25 by the Technical Assistant of the
Telangana State civil supplies corporation Limited (TGSCSCL),
\
\
\
\
e,,
which reported trre presence of Fortified Rice
extent of o.9o/o, stated to be within the range
6.
Kernels (FRK) to the
applicable to pDS rice.
Subsequently, on a representation submitted by respondent
No.l, a second test was conducted on 14.10.2025, wherein
report indicated 0.00% FRK, suggesting that the rice
PDS origin. The appellants contend that the said
the
was not of
second analysis
suffered from procedural irregularities and was influenced
by
extraneous considerations.
7'
The learned single Judge, placing primary reriance on the
second test report dated 14.ro.2025, allowed the writ petition
by respondent No.1 and directed release of the seized rice,
and other rnaterial, which order is the subject matter
filed
vehicle,
of challenge
in the present proceedings.
8'
The learned Government pleader for the appellant has
Qp-njended hereunder:
i' That the impugned order passed by the learned Single
Judge is vitiated flor violation of the principles of natural
-.
justice, inas.much a.s the same was passed at the
threshold
without affording sufficient opportunity to the appellants
to file a counter-aflidavit and without proper consideration
of the material placed on record, including the
sworn/confessional statements of respondent Nos.2 and 3
,/
//
/
recorcled on 17.o9.2025, wherein they categorically
admitted. the illegal purchase, transportation and
atterr.pted recycling of PDS rice.
ii. That the learned single Judge committed a patent error of
fact in observing that even the first technical report dated
11.O9.2025 disclosed *no FRK grains". That on the
contrary, the said report specifically recorded the presence
of FRK to the extent of O.9oh, which is a determinative
indicator of PDS rice.
iii. That the subsequent report dated 14.10.2025 is selfcontradictory and. unreliable, particularly in view of the
unauthorized presence of potitical functionaries during
sarnpling and the subsequent arrest of the concerned
Ter:hnical Assistant by the Anti-Corruption Burcau (ACB)
on charges of bribery, thereby casting scrious doubt on its
cr,:dibility.
iv. Ttrat the impugned order amounts to an impermissible
interference with the statutory powers and jurisdiction of
ttre Collector under Section 6-A of the 1955 Act. That the
Collector is the competent authority to adjudicate
ccnfiscation proceedings upon consideration of the entire
evidence, including the seizure panchanama, the
contradictory technical reports and the sworn statements
\
L
\
of the accused persons, and such adjudication was still
pending.
v. That the direction for release of the seized rice, vehicle and
other material objects seriously prejudices the ongoing
criminal investigation in FIR No.l11 of 2o2s registered at
Dahegaon Police Station, as the seized articles constitute
case property. Such release also defeats the statutory
mandate contained in Para 22 of G.O.Ms.No.2l dated
30.09.2024, which requires strict action against diversion
and recycling of PDS rice.
vi. That the writ petition itself was not maintainable, being
premature, since the proceedings under Section 6-4 of the
1955 Act were admittedly pending and no Iinal order had
been passed by the Collector. Without exhausting the
" statutory remedy, invocation of the extraordinary
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the constitution was
unwarranted.
Contentions of the respondents
9.
The learned counsel for respondent Nos.l and 2 has
contended hereunder:
i. That the seizure in question was actuated by mala ftdes
and personal vendetta, arising out of earlier complaints
lodged by respondent No. I against the enforcement
ofrlcyi.
ii. That the second technical report dated 14.IO.2025,
conducted pursuant to the directions o.f the Sub-Collector,
conclusively established that the seized rice was not PDS
rice, as no FRK were found either in the gunny bags or in
the plastic bags"
iii. That the continued detention of the rice stock, vehicle and
mol>ile phones, without atly final adjudication, has
resrrlted in grave hardship and is violative of the
lundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 14, 19 and
2l of the Const.itution of India.
iv. Th;rt the first technical report dated L1.O9.2O25 \/as
inc,onclusive and confined only to Fair Average Quality
(F1\Q) parameters, and was never intended to dctermine
rvtrether the rice was PDS rice. In contrast, the second
report was comprehensive, conclusive and conducted in a
fair and transparent manner, clearly negating the
allegation of PDS rice.
v. That the pendency of the criminal case is an independent
p:oceeding and cannot, by itself, justify the continued
s,:izure or wit.hholding of the property, especiq.lly when the
Civil Supplies Department has failed to establish any
violation under the 1955 Act or the relevant control
C)rders.
\
I
\
10. We have taken note of the respective contentions urged and
the material on record.
Consideration by this Court
11. It is pertinent to note that the jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution of India, though wide, is discretionary and is
ordinarily not to be exercised when the statute provides for an
efficacious alternative remedy. In the present case, proceedings
under Section 6-A of the 1955 Act were admittedly initiated and
were pending consideration before the Collector (Civil Supplies),
who is the competent statutory authority vested with the power to
adjudicate confiscation upon appreciation of evidence.
t2.
The material placed on record discloses serious and disputed
questions of fact relating to the nature of the seized rice, the
circumstances of seizure, the credibility of the technical reports,
and the evidentiary value of the sworn statements of the accused
persons. Such issues cannot be summarily adjudicated in writ
jurisdiction. The learned Single Judge by ordering release of the
seized property at the threshold, has bypassed the statutory
process and interfered with the jurisdiction of the authority
competent under the Act.
13. A perusal of the record shows that the lirst quality analysis
report dated L1.O9.2O25 recorded the presence of FRK [o the
extent of O.9o/o, falling within the prescribed range for PDS rice,
whereas the subsequent report dated 14.10.2025 recorded 0.o0%
FRK and cr>ncluded that the rice was not pDS rice. These
contradicton, hndings ra.ise serious issues concerning the integrity
of the sampling process, possible tampering of the seized stock and
the reliability of the later report, which, in the backdrop of
allegations of unauthorized interference during the second
sampling arrd subsequent developments relating to the Technical
Assistant, r'rquire detailed examination. Such an enquiry squarely
falls within the jurisdiction of the collector (civil supplies) under
section 6-1, of the 1955 Act and is not suitable for summarv
determination in writ proceedings.
L4. [t is to be notcd that the record contains sworn statements
recorded on 17.o9.2025 before the competent authority, wherein
respondenl. Nos.l and 2 are stated to have admitted the illegal
purchase, transportation and attempted recycling of pDS rice,
which con:;titute material evidence forming part of the proceedings
under section 6-A of the 1955 Act. However, the impugned order
does not reflect any consideration of these statements or their
bearing on the pima facie case, and at a stage when statutory
adjudicati,ro w?S yet to be completed, the writ court ought not to
have disregarded such vital material, particularly when its
evidentiary value required examination by the competent authority.
15. Further, it is not in dispute that the seizure also forms the
subject matter of FIR No. 1 1 r of 2o2s registered at Dahegaon police
\
\
\
\
Station arrd LhaL Lhe seized rice, vehicle and other articles
constitute case property therein. An unconditional d.irection for
release of such property, prior to completion of the criminal
investigation or adjudication under Section 6-A of the 1955 Act,
carries a risk of prejudicing both the prosecution and the
confiscation proceedings, and Courts have consistently held that
writ jurisdiction ought not to be exercised in a manner that renders
statutory proceedings nugatory or frustrates an ongoing criminal
investigation, an effect which the impugned order may bring about.
16. At this juncture, it is necessary to note that the allegations
pertain to diversion and recycling of PDS rice, which strikes at the
very foundation of the PDS meant to ensure food security for
economically weaker sections, and the policy framework under
G.O.Ms.No.21 dated 3O.O9.2024 mandates strict action against
such practices. Though the hardship pleaded by the writ
petitioners cannot be overlooked, the balance of convenience lies in
directing the statutory authority to expeditiously conclude the
adjudication in accordance with law, as the larger public interest in
preserving the integrity of the PDS system outweighs the private
interest in immediate release of-the'seized propert5r, particularly
when the proceedings are at a threshold stage.
l0
Conclusion
17. For the foregoing reasons, this court is of the considered
view that the learned single Judge was not justified in directing
release of the seized property at this stage, thereby bypassing the
statutory acljudication contemplated under Section 6-A of the
Essential c,rmmodities Act, Igss. In this regard, the impugned
order cannot be sustained and is liable to be set aside.
18. In the result, the writ Appear is allowed and the order dated
28.10.2025 passed in !\/.P.No.3235 | of 2o2s is set aside, relegating
respondent Nos.l and 2 to pursue their remedies before the
collector (oivil Supplies), Kumuram Bheem Asifabad District,'in
the pendirrg proceedings under Section 6-A of the Essential
Commoditir:s Act, 1951i; respondent Nos. 1 and 2 are directed to
cooperate :-ully with ttre expeditious disposal of the proceedings.
This cooperation shall inclucle, but not be limited to: i) appearing
before the District collector (civil Supplies), Kumuram Bheem
Asifabad [)istrict or t]re designated authority on os.02.2o26 and
other all scheduled hearings without seeking unnecessary
adjournme:nts; ii) submitting all required documents, evidence and
represente.tions in a timely manner and iii) refraining from any
dilatory tetctics that may hinder the progress of the proceedings.
The collector is directed to proceed with the matter after giving
due
opportqnity of hearing to all concerned parties and pass
reasoned order in accordance with law within a period of
I
\
t,
\
a
three (3)
il
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgrnent. It is
(
clarified that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the
merits of the matter and this order shall not prejudice nor
influence the ongoing criminal investigation in FIR No. I 11 of 2025
registered at Dahegaon Police Station. The seized property shall
continue to remain subject to such orders as may be passed by the
Collector (Civil Suppties) and the competent criminal Court. No
order as to costs.
As a sequel, the miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall
stand closed.
SD/-M.RAMANA KRISHNA
JOINT REGISTRAR
,/TRUE COPY/'
To,
@
SECTION OFFICER
Dahegaon
1. Sri Sandeep Sura, S/o.MadhuEI, S,i Va.savi B,gg
,Yit! Proprietor,
District.
Kumuram Bheem Asifabad
"nOirtancidl.
2.
Sri Gulbam Rakesh, S/o.Gulbam Vaikuntam, R/o'H'No'4-38/1, Tekulapally
-' Vittage,
kanhepally Mandal, Manctrerial District
3. The Station House fficer, Dahegaon Police Station, Kumuram Bheem
Asifabad District.
4. Two CCs to GP for Civil supplies, High court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderabad.[OUTI
Viltrg"
l
5. One CC to SRI K. VENUMADHAV, Advocate IOPUC]
6. Two CCs to-GP for HoME;"Fligh court forthe state of Telangana at
Hyderabad.[OUI
7. Two CD CoPies
DAN
I
HIGH COURT
i
i
;
DATED i?.910112026
I
I
t
I
t
I
t
lHE ST.4:,::
JUDGME:NT
a
:_)
WA.No.107 of 2026
*
ALLOWING THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOTJT COSTS
I
0 6
,..
'' jr'
:
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review