Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3488l
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE
OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE EIGHTEENTH DAY
OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND NIUCTIY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUS,TICE
SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
THE HoNouRo".a r^lnlro.TrcE
G.M. MoHruDDrN
WRIT APP EAL NOs :1237 1444 & 1475
0F 2025
W.A. N o.1237 oF 2025
Writ Appeal under clause 15 oJ_the
Letters patent Against to set aside order passed
in wP'2334 oF 2021 aatea-os.lt.ioiq
dated 07.08.2025on the file of the
(Prayer is amended as oer court
W.A.No.1237 ot 2O2Sl
". --""""-
Hlgh Court. "irtfrlro
in Review rA No.2 ot zozs
order dt.o6-01-2026 vide r.A.No.3 0f 25 in
Between:
' I!:'"t:?E, [R'fi H,*1,f frifJ;5"
:A
Pri ncipa I sec reta
ry, H ome Depa rtm en t,
' H.,?#3:T,fr:::iB:o:''ce (Head or Porice Force), state or reransana,
t
[l!"Atgfnal Director General of Police, Raitways, State of retansana,
' Iler?:??lntendent of Police, Railwav Police District, secunderabad. state
...APPELLANTS
AND
1,
33:3?H"1#91ffi '9,33Bru?lT,f flff
:S:l'.'^I:f, :ii,i:i^[X,g?,[,
2. Karri Srinivasa Rao. S/r
,.ro"d,iii""oi"ifi i;?:Hitiff l#hl*iipfill'#?l,e&p"iiRairway
'[:ffi1"",tfr:':fff i[],f8i$;78,iHffE??:g#;:,*,:[ff Jff B#i.i
4. Vemunuri Laxmanachar
Ha;a;;s-d6i;iffi fil*?L?."J3,,il4:1lre:?$ jivears,occRairway
' [E:lTsl3,':#,jf;,:.,.i flE [:*fl3f ffigi3:,,j
.3;..
vears, occ Rai,way
.I
I
6. Padman;rbuni NarasimhaRao,, .S/o-V€nkateshwarRao, aged about 55
occ. Ra*wav Head constabre r.lo +ss, i.F.-s.r.rirpii^j,livotiJuJo."" vears.
7. Kundavaram NageshwarRao,lyo]lte O^banna, Aged about SB years,
Raitway t-tead co-nstabta ruo rizl,
np.sill.liibLoro
8 Kemsararn Sa.llpaq, S/o yellaiah, Ased about 48
constabre r,ro:3l, ii.p"s.Manchiryat
,Aditabad otrtlSir.'
' J""l'ilifi3ii,'J8lx;1 B:.=.'JiliSLA%*
'"''''
Occ.
occ. Railway Head
about 55 vears, occ Rairwav Head
'0fl :'io'll-i,*HEllb??r.i".u8n*",1"#*Ag:gabout54years,occRairway
"i:?:f:ii;:rl.fl,:'fi stfJ:-?BB'^?fl%T;f8,titB:sh::#:r;f i,i,Lfl lisr
12. Rudravaram Satvanarayana, S/o
KrishnamRaju, Aged about 52 Vears. Occ.
.
Raitway Hr:ad constabt6 No.24b, R:i;.d:ru;hiil'd;l
uyaeraoao.
"AX?fslill:!13x3,5,isffi :,,.,HlFS?flJ*rfg"lfiil"r#T3i3f
...RESPONDENTS
IA NO: 40F 202!;
Petition under Section 151 cpc praying
that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit fireo in support of the petition, the
suspend the order dated 05.11.2024 passed
confirmed in Review r.A.No.2 0f 2025 dated
orders.
High court may be preased
in w.p.No.2334 0f 2021 as
07.08.2025 pass such order or
IA NO: 1 0F 2025
Petition uncrer section.l5'r cpc praying that
in the circumstances stated in
-tt"'nigh
fited in support of tne pLtit'ioni
Court may be pleased
lF_:ffi9qyil
suspend the order in Review petition tA No.
O2iro2s, dt.. 07.08.2025 in Wp. No.
2334t2021.
Counsel.forthe Appeflant : SRI S.RAHUL REDDY,
SpL.Gp
.
attached tc, the office of the Addl.Advocate
General
Counsel for the Rr:spondents: SRt KOWTURU
PAVAN KUMAR
W.A.No.1 444 oF 2A25
writ Appeal under r:rause 15 0f the Lefters patent
Wp.No. 33241 ot 2C.24 on the fite
"f
against the order dt.11-12-2024.
th;-iigh'i;;;.',
lr
Between:
1. The State of Telangana, Rep.by its Principal Secretary, Home Department,
Secretariat, BRKR Bhavan, Hyderabad.
2. The Director General of Police, (Head of Police Force), State of Telangana,
Lakd ikapool, Hyderabad.
3. The lnspector General of Police, Railways, State of Telangana, Hyderabad
4. The Superintendent of Police, Railway Police District, Secunderabad State
Telangana
...APPELLANTS
AND
1. J. Krishna Rao, S/o Raghava Rao, Aged about 48 years, Occ . Railway Head
Constable No. 477, ROP Bhongir, RPS Nalgonda.
2. B.G Prasad rao, S/o Late Ramulu Aged about 59 years, Occ. Railway Head
Constable No.265 RPS, Kachiguda.
3. T.Sai Babu, S/o Late Nageswara Rao, Aged about 56 years, Occ. Railway
Head Constable No. 316 RPS Hyderabad.
4. J. John, S/o J. Samuel, Aged about 54 years, Occ . Railway Head Constable
No. 169 RPS, Nizamabad.
5. Ivl. David Raju, S/o Late Das, Aged about 54 years, Occ . Railway Head
Constable No. 583, RPS, Secunderabad.
6. Koteswara Rao, S/o S.R.K Sastry, Aged about 55 years, Occ. Railway Head
Constable No. 522, RPS Hyderabad
7. G. Sai Kumar, S/o G. Satyanarayana, Aged about 54 years, Occ . Railway
Head Constable No. 15, RPS, Hyderabad.
8. M. Ravi Kumar, M. Ravi Kumar, S/o Venkat Rao, Aged about 54 years, Occ
.
Railway Head Constable No. 199, RPS, Nizamabad.
9. S. Pandari, S/o Balaiah, Aged about 51 years, Occ . Railway Head Constable
No' 123' RPS' secunderabad
...RES'.NDENTS
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circurnstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the order orders in WP. No. 33421 of 2024 dt. 11 .12.2024.
Counsel for the Appellant : SRI S.RAHUL REDDY, SPL.GP
.
aftached to the office of the Addl.Advocate General
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI KOWTURU PAVAN KUMAR
a
N
writ Appeal unrler crause 15 of the Letters patbnt Against
the order Dated
11112t2024 in W.p. No. 33742 of 2O24 on the file
ofifrl Hign Court.
Between:
1. The State of Telanoana, Rep.by its principal Secretary,
Home Department,
Secretaria:, BRKR Bhavin, Hi,O-draiiao. "'
2' The Director Generar and rnspector Generar of porice, state of rerangana,
Lakdikapool, Hyderabad.
3. The Additional Director General of porice,
- --' Rairways
''- "'-, office of DGp office state
ofTelangara, Hyderabad.
+. rng superintendent of porice, Rairway porice District, secunderabad.
state
Telangana
.APPELLANTS
D
1. P. Muneshrvar Rao, S/o Late Rama Swamy, Aged about 52 years,
Ra itway Head Constabte t to. s+b,' n pS
l53iun?".i"0"0.
2. S. Srinivas,lu. S/o Late Guravaiah, Aged about 54 years, Occ.
Constable No. 197 RpS, HyOeiabj
Occ.
Railway Head
'i;YEts"."SBBiJft i'1,?'aBE:?i"X;f :rd,t'F8iifl*',.#ars,occRai,wav
o
331,!fir:oi:1i9j f3 [i]::al,*o about 4e years, occ. Rairway Head
5. S. A. Rahman, S/o Late lmamsahed, Aged about 52 years, Occ. Railway
Head const,rbte No. 268, Rps,-$;u;AHb;;"'-
6' The superintendent of porice, Rairway porice District, secunderabad. State,
Telangana.
..RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 cpc praying that in the
in the affidavit firerr in support of the petition, the High
suspend the order orders in Wp. No. 33142 ol 2024
circumstances stated
court may be preased to
dt. 1111212024.
Counsel for the Appellant : SRI S.RAHUL REDOY, SPL.GP
attached to the office of the Addl .Advocate General
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI KOWTURU PAVAN
The Court made thr: fottowing: COMMON JUDGMENT
KUMAR
IN THE HTGH COURT FOR TT{E STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APAR.ESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THB HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT
PPEAL Nos. I
7,1444and 14
of 2025
DATED : 18.03.2026
w
o.1237 of 2025
Between:
The State of Telangana. rep., by its principal Secretary,
Horne Department, Secretariat, I{yderabad and 3 others.
Appellants
AND
Gangarapu Thirupathi and 12 others
w.A. No.1444
.. Respondents
202s
Between:
The State of T'elangana, rep., by its principal Secretary,
Home Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 3 others.
Appellants
AND
J. Krishna Rao and 8 others.
Respondents
W.A.No.l 75 of 2025
Between:
The State of Telangana, rep., by its principal Secretary.
Home Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 3 others
... Appellants
AND
\
f
P. Muneshwar Rao and 4 others.
I
Respondents
COMMON JUDGMENT:
Mr. ti. Rahul Reddy, learned Special Government Pleader attached to
the office ,rf the learned Additional Advocate General appears for the
appellants.
Mr. Ilowturu Pavan Kumar, learned counsel for the respondents/writ
petitioners.
2.
By c,rnsent of the learned counsel for the parties, these matters are
being taken up for disposal.
3.
w.A.No.l237 of 2025 is filed being aggrieved by the order dared
05.1 I .2024;rassed in w.P.No .2334 of 2021 as confirmed in Review I.A.No.2
of 2025 datt:d 07.08.2025. W.A.Nos.1444 and 1475 of 2025 are filed being
aggrieved bJ,the order dated 11.12.2024 passed in w.P.Nos.33742 and 33421
of2024.
4.
The 'writ petitioners have admittedly got absorbed in Government
Railway Police by virtue of the directions passed in Original Application
Nos.4311 and 4367 of 2007 by the erstwhile Andhra Pradesh Administrative
Tribunal, HJ,derabad, (for short, "the Tribunal"), which got affirmed by the
Hon'ble Supreme court in Special Leave Petition No.l1948 of 2018. The
Hon'ble Supreme court, however, made it clear that the impugned order not
to be treate<l as precedent in any other case. Thereafter, the present writ
petitioners sought a direction up on the appellants to consider their cases for
I
I
promotion to the post of l{ead Constables with effect from the date on which
they are eligible and are on par with Police Constables (Civil) and further to
consider their cases for promotion to the post of Sub-Inspectors of Police.
5.
The learned writ Court considered the background facts that the writ
petitioners were initially appointed as Police Constable (Civil) and were
deputed in Railway Police during the year 1990-91 and later on got absorbed
by virtue of the judgment rendered by the Tribunal in the Government
Railway Police establishment. However, it was only reasonable for the
petitioners to expect that they would be considered as regularly appointed in
the appellant organization and considered as feeder category for promotion to
the post of Sub-[nspectors. The appellants took a plea that they cannot fill up
the post of Sub-lnspector of Police with persons from other departments on
deputation, when the feeder category i.e., Head Constables in the very same
department are available. In this background, the learned writ Court directed
the appellants to amend their Rules and consider the case of the petitioners for
promotion to the post of Sub-Inspectors from the date on which the post of
Sub-Inspectors are vacant. Their cases for promotion would be considered in
accordance with the seniority after granting notional promotion as Head
Constables from the year 2005 when the vacancies of Head Constables were
I
available. This has aggrieved the department to prefer the present appeals.
\
6.
Learned Special Government Pleader subrnits that there are no separate
Rules for Government Railway Police establishment. Moreover, the direction
I
of the learned writ Court to grant notional promotion as [{ead Constable frorn
the year 20(t5 when the vacancies of Head Constable were available is also
not proper since promotional exercise would depend upon not only the
vacancy available in the higher cadre, but other eligibility criteria and
consideratiotr of the cases of those who are in the zone of consideration by
properly constituted committee. [t is not a case where anyone junior in their
cadre has been promoted as Head Constable from the year 2005 in the
Government Railway Police establishment. It is submitted that the writ
petitioners are pressing contempt petition. The impugned directions rnay be
set aside.
7.
Learned counsel for the writ petitioners submits that once the
petitioners have been absorbed in the Government Railway Police
Establishment from Police Constable (Civil) cadre, they have a legitimate
expectation ,rf being promoted to the higher post in the said establishment
Therefore, tlte learned writ Court was right in directing the appellants to
amend their .R.ules. Learned counsel for the writ petitioners, however, has not
been able to support the direction for grant of notional promotion as Head
Constable frrlrn the year 2005 when the vacancies of l{ead Constables in the
Government Railway Police establishment.
\
8.
Upon hearing the learned counsel for the parties, we are of the
considered view that in the background of the relevant facts and
circumstances taken note from the pleadings on record, once the petitioners
I
I
.$,
have got absorbed permanently as constables in Government Railway Police
establishment, the department cannot take a plea that their channels of
promotion would be governed by general rules. The petitioners cannot be
reverted upon their absorption to Civil Police and as such their caset fo1
promotion would only be considered in the establishment where they are
permanently absorbed. The Government Railway Police establishment
contains hierarchy of posts up to Inspector of Police which till now were
filled up only by deputation. In this background, we are of the view that the
appellants are required to frame Rules for consideration of cases of persons
who are absorbed in the Government Railway Police establishment like the
petitioners. However, the direction of the learned writ Court to grant the
notional promotion as Head Constables fiom the year 2005 only on the
ground that vacancies were available in that cadre does not appear to be
supported by sound reasoning. The cases of promotion to the post of Head
Constables would entail a promotional exercise. Mere existence of vacancies
does not confer right for notional promotion from a retrospective date as such,
that part of the impugned order is set aside-
g.
Accordingly, these writ appeals are allowed in part with the direction
upon the respondent Department to frame Rules within a period of six months
for considering the cases of incumbents like the petitioners in Railway Police
establishment. The appellants would thereafter consider the cases of
individual persons for promotion depending upon the eligibility criteria and
I
I
_L
\
other condir.ions laid down under the Rules. If the petitioners have already
been promoted as Head Constables from the due date, their cases for further
prornotion ntay be considered as per the Rules to be framed
Miscr:llaneous applications, if any pending, shalI stand closed
/TRUE coPY//
I
I
'l
i
J
To,
SD/.K. SHYLESHI
JOINT REGISTRAR
(q
SECTIt,ft OFFICER /
)
1. The Prinr:ipal Secretary, Home Department, Secretariat, Telangana State,
BRKR Bhavan, Hyderabad.
2. The Director General, of Police (Head of Police Force), State State of
Telangana, Lakdikapool, Hyderabad,
3. The Additional Director General of Police, Railways, State of Telangana,
Hyderabad.
4. The Supr:rintendent of Police, Railway Police District, Secunderabad. State
Telangana.
5. The lnsperctor General of Police, Railways, State of Telangana, Hyderabad
6 Two CCs to THE ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL, High Court for the
State of Telangana at Hyderabad. IOUTI
7. One CC tr SRI KOWTURU PAVAN KUIvIAR, Advocate. [OPUC]
8. Two CD Copies.
BSK
BS
/,
HIGH COIJRT
DATED:181031202G
C
ir:. .-
ni{**
v.,I
'.,)
COMMON JUDGMENT
2 ii illR 2026
* D
WA.No.1 2:37, 1444 & 14tS ot 2025
PARTLY ALLOWING THE WRIT APPEALS
WITHOUT COSTS
JKs
zelzlze
.i " ,.r
./
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review