The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. [t is also specific contention ofthe appellants herein that the appellana have revoked the license of the writ petitioner on the ground that it has violated the provisions of the Forest , Act and ttre afrrementioned rules etc. By fol{owing ttre said ., procdure only, the appellan6 revoked the lioense of the writ .. , ,,, ] petitioner and the same w{ls confirmed by tlre.. appellate authority. Despite the said specifio contentiorU ttellea.r,ea Single Judge did not consider the said aspect in the impugired :i order. Therefore, the irapugned order is not in odmideration <if the aforesaid aspects and provisions of law including the statements of tlre proprietor of the writ petitioner Saw mill and owner of the said vehicle.
9. [n the light of the aforesaiddiscussion, this writ appeal is allowed and accordingly the impqgned order dated 16.08.2021 in W.P.Nq.ll3l of 2O20 is set aside and the lnafferi is remanded back to the learned Single Judge for disposal of the same in accordance with law by considerirg *re aforesaid aspects including pleadings of ttre parties ard also the documents Flled by bofrr the parties. Liberty is granted to the writ petitioner to request the learned Single Judge to dispose of the said writ petition as expeditiously as possible. The learned Single Judge shall decidp the aforesaid writ' petition corrsidering the material available, withbut being influeqoed by j r any of the 6bservations made in the present judgment, ',..' ', . As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications" if, any, shall stand closed. SD/.ii. RAMANA KRISHNA JOINT ., \ ,/TRUE COPYII G To, 'I?:",:ff f iil-J:',9ffiX|"T,p,:"?fl,L"'g#"".,nfu f ',,I???gffi r,, 2' The Section officer, WP(Non-Service) --'seetion, IHigh vvvr'v"' rru Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderibad.'- 3' The Section offioer, Posting Section, High Court for the State of Telangana o T:eo3:'#gir?r-3lJ?:fir. statistics section, Hish court ror the state or
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34s41
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE TT/VENTIETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHilIAN
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
WRIT APPEAL NO: 507 OF 2021
,/
Writ Appeat undei clause 15 of the Letters Patent lgaindte Oder dated
ffil0&f20?1 in W.P.No. 1 131 Of 2O2O on the frle of the High Co[]t.
Between:
'
1. The State of Telangana, represented by its Principal Secretary to
Govemment, Environment Forests, Science and technology Dept., Tehngana
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Pd. Chief Conservator of Forests And Head of the Foest Force (HoFF),
Telangana Aranya Bhavan, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
3. Tfrc Conservator of Forests, Adilabad Circle, Adilabad.
4. The Forest Divisional fficer, Kaghaznagar Division, Kaghaznagar, Komaram
Bheem Asifabad district (erstwhib Adilabad district).
5. The Forest Divisional Officer/ District Forest Officer,. Asifabad division,
Asifabad, Komaram Bheem Asifabad dislrict (erstwhile Adilabad district).
...APPELLANTS
AND
Mamidala Ramakrishna, S/ late M. Malleshwar, Owner of M/s Sree Venkateshwara
Saw Mill and Timber Depot, Khaghaznagar at H.No.1-3-10, Ambedkar Road,
Khaghaznagar, Komaram Bheem Asifabad district (erstwttile Adihbad district).
...RESPONOENTS
lA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the order made in W.P. No.1131 l2O2O, dated.16.8.2l21, pending
disposal of the Writ Appeal.
lA NO: 2 OF 2021
Between:
Mamida.la Ramakrishna, S/ late M. Malleshwar, owner of M/s sree venkateshwara
Saw,Mill and Timber Dgpot Klagh.aznagar at H.No.1-3-10, Ambedkar Road,
Knaghaz'ragar, Komaram Bheem Asifabad district (erstrrtrile Adilabad district).
... PETITIONER/RESPONDENTS
ANQ
1. The State of Telangana, reprcsented by ib princbal Secretarv to
Qover.nn-re.ntr.EnvironmEnt Foresis, Science a6O technotogioepi., fetinlaria
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Prl. chief consenrator of Forests And Head of the Forest Foroe (HoFF),
Telangana Aranya Bhavan, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
3. Th,: Conservator of Forests, Adilabad Circle, Adilabad.
4. Thr: Forest Divisional.Officer, Kaghaznagai Division, Kaghaznagai, Komaram
Bh,eem,Asifabad district (erstuhilSAdilab:d district).' "
5. Thr: Forest Divisional officer/ District Forest officer, Asifabad division,
Asifabad, Komaram Bheem Asifabad district (erstu,hile Aditabad aisiri"ti. - ... RESPONDENTS'APPELLANTS
Pelition under section Is1 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the Higfr court may be pleased to
vacate tht: interim orders passed in w.A No so7 of 2oz1 dated 30logt2o21.
Counsel lbr the Appellants : GP FOR FORESTS
Counsel for the Respondent: SRI G.RAMAN GOUD
The Court made the following: JUDGilENT
IIIGIICOURT FORTIIE STATE OF TELAI\IGANA
ATHYDERABAD
TIIE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN
ANI)
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
WRITAPP EAL No.507 of 2021
Date:20.01.2026
Between:
The State of Telangana" Rep. by its
Principal Secretary to Govemment,
Environmen! Forests, Science & Technology
Department, Telangana Secretariat,
Hyderabad- 50o022 and fourothers.
Appellants
And
Mamidala Ramakrishna, S/o. Late M- Malleshwar,
Owner of IVUs. Sree Venkteshwara Saw Mill and
Timber Depot, Khagaztngar,
Komaram Bheem Asifabad District
Respondent
JI]DGMENT: (Per Hon'bte Sri Justice KLal<shman)
Heard learned Govemment Pleader for Forest and
Sri G. Raman Goud, learned counsel for the respondent'
Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the order dated
16.08.2021in Writ Petition No'tl3l of 2020, the appellants
preferr€d the intra court present appeal, under Clause I 5 of the
Le:tters Patent.
3.
The respondent/writ petitioner filed the aforesaid writ
petition challenging the order dated 16.01.2019, which was
confirmed by the appellate authority vide order O2.A\.ZOZ0.
Vide said order dated 16.01.2019, the Authorized
Officer/Forest Divisional Officer, Khagaznagar, Appellant
Nc,.4 cancelled the license of the respondent. The said
proceedings were confirmed by
the appellate
authority/appellant No.3 on 02.01.2020. Challenging the said
orclers, the writ petitioner f,rled the aforesaid writ petition.
4.
The learned Government Pleader for Forests would
contend that the appellants have filed counter in the writ
petition narrating all the facts including the provisions of the
Act, rules and relevant provisions of the Statute etc: They
have also filed copies of the statements of the proprietor of the
Saw mill and driver of the vehicle. They have also filed
additional statemenb and copy of POR.
5.
[t is not the case of the appellants ttrat they have visited
writ petitioner Saw mill and they have found any irregularity
in the records maintained by them including the stock. It is the
specific case of the appellants herein that a case has been
registered vide P.O.R. No.l9l0l77 dated 27.09.2018 by the
staff of Forest Check Post, Asifabad of Asifabad Forest
Division against the respondent herein Sri Mamidala
Ramakrishna, who is the owner of IWs. Sree Venkateshwara
Saw Mill and Timber Depot, Khagaznagar of Klrugaznagar
Range of Kaghaznagar Division for the offence under Sections
2O and 29 of APF Act, 1967 md 44 (ixii) of A.P. Forest Act,
1967 alleging that on the instructions of the respondent the
driver of Tata Van bearing No. TS 01 W 5212 was illegally
transporting forest produce i.e., teak round logs 15/1.590 cmt
valuing Rs.1,,36,775/- and teak rough sizes lIlO.820 cm
valuing Rs.78,924/-. Accordingly, the aforesaid vehicle along
w:ith forest produce i.e., teak logs were seized on the same day.
The statement of the respondent i.e., owner of:the aforesaid
vehicle discloses that his driver has taken away the vehicle
without his notice and he is not aware of transportation of
itlegal material in the said vehicle. on the other hand, the
statement of the driver discloses that onry on the instructions
of the respondent herein, he has proceeded to Jainoor vil{age
shivar, wherein he met one unknown person and then went
inside the forest, wherein three unknown persons loaded the
illegal teak timber into the vehicle. Thus, it is the specific case
of the appellants that being owner of the said vehicle, it is the
responsibility of the respordent to take all the precautions to
ensure that the vehich is not used without his knowledge.
Further, the respondent has failed to produce any evidence to
prove his innocence. Hence, the appellants contend that
having foltowed the procedure laid down under law and they
have also issued show cause notice and called for the
explanation from the writ petitioner. Thereby, they have
afforded an opportunity to the writ petitioner in accordance
with law. Thereafter, the appellant No.4/competent authority
passed impugned orders revoking the license issuodto the writ
petitioner. [t is a reasoned order.
6.
Thus, the appellants herein filed counler in the aforesaid
writ petition narrating the aforesaid facts and also filed and
also filed copies of the documents in support of the same.
They have also specifically rclied upon Rule ll(l) of the
Telangana Wood Based Industries (Regulation) Rules, 2016 in
G.O.Ms.No.55, dated 26.09.2016, relevant provisions of the
Telangana Forest Act, 1967, Rules made thereunder, the
Telangana Forest Produce Transit Rules, 1970 and also the
principle laid down by the Apex Court in several judgments, to
contend that they have followed the procedure laid down under
law while passing the impugned revocation order of the
appellant No.4 confirmed by appellant No.3. Without
considering the said aspects, the learned Single Judge, vide
impugned order, set aside the proceedings holding that the writ
petitioner is the owner of the seized vehicle and as well as
ovuner of the Saw mill. The counter affrdavit is silent with
regard to any inspection being made to veri$ whether any
contraband is present in the Saw rnill with the Saw mill
re<nrds, or any kind of irregularity or seizure of contraband
frcrm the Saw mill of the writ petitioner. Hence, the appellants
miserably failed to establish involvement of the writ petitioner
Saw mill in the alleged offence.
7.
It is the specific contention ofthe appellants herein that
Mr. Mamidala Ramakrishna, who is the proprietor of writ
pelitioner Saw mill i.e., Sree Venkateshwara Saw Mi.ll and
Timber Depo! is also the owner of Tata Van bearing No. TS 0l
W 5212. Thus, the appellants have established the nexus
between the writ petitioner Saw mill and the vehicle.
8.
[t is also specific contention ofthe appellants herein that
the appellana have revoked the license of the writ petitioner
on the ground that it has violated the provisions of the Forest
, Act and ttre afrrementioned rules etc. By fol{owing ttre said .,
procdure only, the appellan6 revoked the lioense of the writ
.. ,
,,, ]
petitioner and the same w{ls confirmed by tlre.. appellate
authority. Despite the said specifio contentiorU ttellea.r,ea
Single Judge did not consider the said aspect in the impugired
:i
order. Therefore, the irapugned order is not in odmideration
<if the aforesaid aspects and provisions of law including the
statements of tlre proprietor of the writ petitioner Saw mill and
owner of the said vehicle.
9.
[n the light of the aforesaiddiscussion, this writ appeal is
allowed and accordingly the impqgned order dated 16.08.2021
in W.P.Nq.ll3l of 2O20 is set aside and the lnafferi is
remanded back to the learned Single Judge for disposal of the
same in accordance with law by considerirg *re aforesaid
aspects including pleadings of ttre parties ard also the
documents Flled by bofrr the parties. Liberty is granted to the
writ petitioner to request the learned Single Judge to dispose of
the said writ petition as expeditiously as possible. The learned
Single Judge shall decidp the aforesaid writ' petition
corrsidering the material available, withbut being influeqoed by
j
r
any of the 6bservations made in the present judgment,
',..'
',
.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications" if, any,
shall stand closed.
SD/.ii. RAMANA KRISHNA
JOINT .,
REGISTRAR
\
,/TRUE COPYII
G
SECTION OFFICER
To,
'I?:",:ff f iil-J:',9ffiX|"T,p,:"?fl,L"'g#"".,nfu f ',,I???gffi r,,
2' The Section officer, WP(Non-Service)
--'seetion, IHigh
vvvr'v"'
rru
Court for the State of
Telangana at Hyderibad.'-
3' The Section offioer, Posting Section, High Court for the State of Telangana
o
T:eo3:'#gir?r-3lJ?:fir.
statistics section, Hish court ror the state or
5. Ihq Section Offioeq ER Section, High Court for the Stat6 of Telangana
Hyderabad
at
at
6. Two ccs !o GIJOR FOREST, High court
vvsrr for
r'' state of rerangana at
'v' the
Hyderrabad.tou[
7. one cc to sRr GUNDRATT,RAMAN GouD, Advocate.
topucl
8. Two,CD Copies.
BSK
BS
6i'l-
,t{tcfl COURT
TED:20lO1tZOZ6
.',?\
.J
a UT
6!
tt
J,UDGMENT
WA.No;Ot ot 2021
ALLOWING,TI{E WRIT
COSTS
(
.iy
D
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review