Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 34881
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGAT{A AT HYOEFABAD
THURSDAY, THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDOIN
WRIT APPEAL NO: 5 OF 2026
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Against Order Dated 171OG12025 in
WP No 3878 of 2023 on the file of the High Court.
Between:
1 . The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Higher Education
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Commissioner of Collegiate Education Education, State of Telangana,
Nampally, Hyderabad.
3. The Regional Joint Director of Collegiate Education,Warangal, Warangal
District.
4. The Principal, Government Degree College, Chandur, Nalgonda Districl
...APPELLANTS
ANO
A. Dhana Murthy, S/o A.Ashaiah, Aged about 55 years, Occ. Contract Lecturer in
Political Science, Govemment Degree College, Chandur, Nalgonda District.
...RESPONDENTS
lA NO: 2 OF Z)26
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the orders passed in WP No 3878 of 2023 dated 17-06-2025 by the
Learned Single Judge, during the pendency of the appeal.
Counsel for the Appellant : SRI SANTHAPUR SATYANARAYANA RAO,
.
GP FOR SERVICES I
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI K.LAXMAIAH, rep.,
.
SRt V.BRAHI'iA|AH CHOWDARY
The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
IIT TIIE HIGH COTIRT rlOR THE STATE OF TEIAT{C}AT{A
AT IIYDERABAT)
TIIE HONELE THE CHIEF JIISIICE SRI APARESiH KT'MAR SINGH
AT{D
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHITIDDIN
WRIT APPEAL No.S of 2O26
DATE: OA.OL.2O26
BETtrIEEN:
The State of Telangana,
rep. by its Principal Secretary
and 3 others
.Appellants
AND
A.Dhana Murthy.
....Respondent
JUDGMENT
Heard Sri Santhapur Satyanarayana Rao, learned Government
Pleader for Services-l appearing for the appellants and
Sri l(.Laxmaiah, learned counsel representing Sri V.Brahmaiah
Chowdary, learned counsel for the respondent and perused the
record.
2.
The present writ appeal is filed under Clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, is directed against the final order dated 17.06.2025 passed
by the learned Single Judge in W.P.No.3878 of 2023, whereby the
writ petition {iled by the respondent herein was disposed of with a
direction to the second appellant to reconsider the respondent's
request for re-engagement as a Contract Lecturer in Political Science,
-)
)..
against anrr existing va-cancy either
in the fourth appellant,s colrege
or In any nearby institution at Suryapet.
strictl,v in accordarrc. ,*ith
law.
3'
The factuar matrix of the case is that
the respondent was
appointed as a contract Lecturer in politiceil
pursuant tc a due selection process.
periodically renewed tilr 31-03.2017.
Science in 2ool
and his engagement was
The appe,ants did not renern,
his contract for trre academic year 2o]T-rg,
attendance between 2L.ro.2or6 and
2o.o2.2ol1 and his non_
availability in April 2oLZ, allegedry causing
respondent, however, asserts that
citing irregurar
academic disruption. The
his absence was due to serious
illness supported by medical certificates,
reported for duty on 25.04 .2or7, he was
and that though he
not permitted to resume
duties.
4'
Aggrieved by the non-renewar, the
respondent submitted
representations seeking re-engagement. pursuant
issued by this Court in W.p. No. 1g1S
of 2019, his representation
dated o3.o3.2o18 was considered and rejected
of collegiate Education (2na appellant) by
Judge directed the appeflants to
r
filed w.p. No. 3g7g of
ro.o2.2o23, the learned singre
consider his case for re_engagement
against any existing vacancy in
(
by the commissioner
order dated rg.o4.2org.
challenging the said rejection, the respondent
2023, wherein, by interim order dated
to directions
or around suryapet, withou-t
reference to the earlier rejection, keeping in view his long senrice and
absence of adverse record.
5.
In compliance, the 2"d appellant passed a speaking order dated
14.06.2023 reiterating the grounds of alleged absence and nonavailability of vacancies, and again rejected the respondent's request.
The learned Single Judge, finding the order to be mechanical and
passed without due consideration of the respondent's long and
unblemished service, disposed of the writ petition by issuing the
directions now under challenge in the present appeal.
6.
The learned Government Pleader raised the following
contentions:
l.
That the impugned order is contrary to the Government
Memos dated 08.12.2O16 and 17.O1.2O18, which categorically
stipulate that proposals for re-engagement of disengaged
contract lecturers, particutarly after a considerable lapse of
time and post-bifurcation (re-organisation of the State of A.P.)
are not to be entertained.
11.
That the direction issued by the learned Single Judge travels
beyond the scope of the relief sought in the writ petition, which
was confined to re-engagement of the respondent only in the
4th appellant's college.
That the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate that the
respondent was irregular in attending duties during the
relevant period and that, in any event; no contract lecturer
vacancies were available for re-engagement.
\
\
:i4::
iv'
That the engagement of contract recturers
procedure prescribed under
is governed by the
G.o.Ms.N o.r42, dated 0g.10.2000,
and the impugned direction overlooks
the said procedure.
the mandatory nature of
v' That the direction to consider the
respondent
vacancies of oGuest Facult5/ is
against
legally impermissible, as the
posts of contract Lecturer and
Guest Facurt5r are distinct,
governed by different norms,
7'
and are not interchangeable.
Per contra, the learned counsel
supported the order of the learned
appearing for the respondent
Singre Judge and contended that
the order of the rearned single Judge
r'vhich did not warrant any
8'
was a werl reasoned order
interference by this court.
we have taken note of the respective
co,tentions urged and
the material on record.
Analysis and finding
9'
It is pertinent to note that the rearned
on the premise that the respondent,s
16 years of service created a
right, or at least a legitimate expectation,
approach is legally untenable. The
Lecturer is' by its very nature,
of re-engagement. This
engagement of a contract
temporary, contractuar, and co-
terminus with the academic session,
or continuity. The Honble supreme
(
single Judge proceeded
conferring no right to renewal
court in secre t ry, state of
..(..
Kclntattalka a. tlmodeulr, has held that contractual or temporary
service d.oes not ripen into an enforceable right. Reliance on length of
service to override the explicit terms of engagement is therefore
contrary to settled law.
1(). It is to be noted that the Doctrine of Legitimate Expectation
cannot be invoked to compel a pubtic authority to act contrary to its
policy or governing norms. The Government Memos dated
O8.L2.2O16 and 17.01.2018 expressly prohibit re-engagement of
disengaged contract lecturers after a prolonged gap, particularly in
the post-bifurcation context. These policy decisions, taken in
administrative interest, bind the appellants and were not accorded
due weight by the learned Single Judge.
11. Judicial review under Article 226 is confined to examining the
legality of the decision-making process and not the merits of the
decision itself. The reasons for non-renewal and unauthorized
absence and its adverse impact on academic functioning fall squarely
within the realm of administrative and academic discretion. By
characterizing the speaking order dated 14.06.2023 as "mechanical,"
the learned Single Judge effectively re-appreciated facts and
substituted his own assessment for that of the competent authority,
which is impermissible, as held in Tata cellular a. (Inion of Indtoz.
l1zooo;4 scc I
lrss+1 6 scc 6s1
::6::
t2- The direction to consider the respondent for vacancies in
institutions "nearby Suryapct' was beyond the scope of juclicial
re'iew and the relief sought. Engageme.t of contract Lecturers
governed by G-o.Ms.No. t42 dated 09.10.2000, which
is
mandates a
prescribed selection process through a Three-Man Committee
rvhich
cannot be bypassed.
13. It is to be noted that the reliance placcd by the learned Single
Judge on vacancies of "Guest FacultJ/ is legally unsustainable.
posts of Contract Lecturer and Guest Faculgr are distinct
The
cacires
go'zerned by separate norms relating to recruitment, qualilicatiops,
remuneration, and tenure. Directing consideration of the respondent
for a cadre governed by different rules, for which the respo*dent
neither applied nor was considered, is legally impermissible and is
prejudicial to other eligible candidates.
14. It will not be out of context to note that the respondent,s
engagement ended in March 2orr, and his first representation
made in March 2018, and thc writ petition was filed only in
was
2023.
The unexplained and inordinate delay was not considered by the
learned single Judge, though it constitutes an independent ground
to decline discretionary relief under Article 226 of the Constitution.
The claims arising out of contractual engagements cannot be
agitated after such prolonged lapse, as it unsettles settled
administrative arrangem6ts.
Coacluslon
we
For the foregoing reasons'
15.
hold that the learned Single
error in granting relief
Judge committed an
contrary
governing
to the settled principles
laches attributable
overlooking the delay and
16.
and the said writ petition
stands dismissed'
pending if any'
miscellaneous petitions'
,/TRUE COPY'/
T*o cc. to GP FOR SERVICES
touTl
2. One CC to SRI V'BRAHMAIAH
3. Two CD CoPies'
ryMK
No order as to costs'
stand
SD,.K.SHYLESHI
JOTNT REGIS
I
To'1.
passed by the
of 2O23 is hereby set aside'
closed.
P
to the respondent'
is allowed'
Accordingly, the Writ Appeal
As a sequel,
\
judicial review, and in
17'O6'2025
In this regard' the order dated
W'P' No' 3878
Iearned Single Judge in
t7.
to the resPondent'
BSK
SECTION OFFTCER
l' High court f th State of Telangana
CHOWDARY' Advocate lOPUCl
HIGH COURT
DATED:0810112026
.i\
o
L)
JUDGMENT
WA.No.S ot 2026
ALLOWING THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT COSTS
\) (
2A
\
)k
10 tE8 itliil
*
I
HI SHIE
r('
PATC!
*:
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review