Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 19TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100340 OF 2023 (A)
BETWEEN:
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CBI, ACB BRANCH BENGALURU
R/BY SPL. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. NEELENDRAD .GUNDE,ADVOCATE)
AND:
SRI. SUDDHARUD T. METRE
AGE. 48 YEARS,
OCC. THE THEN PRINCIPAL OF KENDRIYA VIDYALAY-1
RAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI,
R/O. APPORVA NAGAR, SILVER TOWN,
GOKUL ROAD, HUBBALLI,
PERMANENT R/O. MADAN HIPPARAG VILLAGE
AND POST TQ. ALAND DIST. KALABURAGI 585101.
…RESPONDENT
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
(BY SRI. SHIVAKUMAR S. BADAWADAGI, ADVOCATE)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED U/SEC. 378(4) OF CR.P.C.
PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE RECORDS AND ALLOW THIS CRIMINAL
APPEAL
BY
SETTING
ASIDE
THE
JUDGMENT
AND
ORDER
OF
ACQUITTAL DATED 13.04.2023 PASSED IN SPL. CBI. CC NO. 07/2018
BY III ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS AND SPL. JUDGE DHARWAD
AND CONVICT THE RESPONDENT AND ETC.,.
THIS
APPEAL,
COMING
ON
FOR
ADMISSION,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
THIS
DAY,
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA)
1.
Heard the learned counsel Sri.Neelendra D.Gunde,
appearing for appellant-Central Bureau of Investigation1 and
Sri.Shivakumar Badawadagi, appearing for respondent-accused.
2.
The CBI, ACB Branch, Bangalore, has preferred the
appeal challenging the judgment of acquittal of the respondent in
Special CBI C.C.No.7/2018 by
considered judgment dated
13.04.2023 passed by the III Additional District and Sessions
and Spl.Judge, Dharwad.
3.
Facts in the nutshell which are at most necessary for
disposal of the present appeal are as under:
A complaint was lodged by Sri.Basavaraj S. Pujar (PW-1)
before the CBI, ACB, Bangalore alleging that the respondent,
who was working as the Principal of Kendriya Vidyalay-I, Raj
Nagar,
Hubli,
being
a
public
servant,
demanded
illegal
gratification of ₹.50,000/- in the form of a mixer grinder and five
bottles of liquor procured from CSD Canteen, for securing
admission of the complainant’s son to IV Standard and it was
Hereinafter referred to as ‘the CBI’.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
alleged
that
the
respondent
thereby
committed
offences
punishable under Section 7 and Section 13(1)(d) read with
Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 19882.
4.
Based on the complaint, the head of the right party
formed a raid team comprising of himself, his sub-staff and two
independent government servants as panchas for the intended
ride and all of them proceeded towards the Kendriya Vidyalay-I,
Raj Nagar, Hubli.
5.
The complainant and the the shadow witness were
directed to proceed on a motorcycle and hand over the illegal
gratification upon demand by the accused and thereafter, they
give a pre-designated signal. These proceedings were reduced
into writing by way of an experimental mahazar. As per the
prosecution case, when the complainant wanted to hand over the
illegal gratification in kind to the accused, a raid was conducted
and five bottles of liquor and a mixer grinder was seized, which
were admittedly purchased by the complainant from the CSD
Canteen with receipts.
Hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
6.
A trap mahazar was laid and thereafter the accused
was arrested.
7.
After detailed investigation, a charge sheet came to
be filed for the offences under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with
13(2) of the Act. The presence of accused was secured, charges
were framed and the accused pleaded not guilty and therefore,
trial was held.
8.
In order to establish the guilt of the accused, the
prosecution examined 22 witnesses comprising of complainant,
shadow witness, co-pancha, other circumstantial witnesses, the
Investigation Officer and the chemical examiner. As many as, 71
documentary evidence were placed on record which are exhibited
and marked as Ex.P-1 to Ex.P-17. Four bottles of liquor and a
mixer grinder were marked as Material Objects Nos. 1 to 5.
9.
The statement of the accused under Section 313 of
the Criminal Procedure Code3 was recorded, wherein the accused
has denied all the incriminating circumstances. After hearing the
arguments, the learned trial Judge, by impugned judgment
Hereinafter referred to as ‘the Cr.P.C.’
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
acquitted the accused, inter alia, on the reasons recorded in
paragraph Nos.8 to 10 of the Judgment which reads as under:
“8.
The specific defence of the accused is that he has
nowhere demanded illegal gratification. But, only enquired
about purchasing liquor and Mixer from the Military
canteen, since complainant is a Army personnel and he will
get the same at discount price, he was about to pay for the
said items. But, at that time all of a sudden the police have
forcibly
caught
hold
him,
without
documents
and
application, it is not possible to get a seat for P.W. 1's son.
In the cross-examination of P.W-1 at page No.14 para-26
he has specifically admitted as follows:
"it is correct to suggest that the accused removed
the cash from his pocket, at that time I gave a signal
that his hands not to give it because I have already
lodged a complainant to the CBI police".
9. Even the Spl. Public Prosecutor has treated the
witness as hostile to this portion and cross-examined for
which the witness has stick on to the earlier version in the
chief examination. Further, the P.W-1 also admitted that
liquors are not allowed inside the School and he know that
liquor could not be carried inside the School. From the
above admission it is very much clear that accused never
demanded illegal gratification. P.W-1 in his further crossexamination at page No.11 para 23 also admitted as
follows:
"the price of Mixer Grinder and liquor was known to
the accused and the total amount was around only
Rs.3,500/-".
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
10.
Hence, from the above admission by the P.W-1
who is a Military person working as Hawaldar in Indian
Army, he will get the various items including liquor and
house hold articles for a discounted prices exclusively for
the persons working in the Military. Hence, accused
intended to purchase the above items from the complainant
for the Payment. Accordingly, when the said items were
handed over the accused had kept the said amount and
even removed the cash from his pocket to give the price of
the sajt articles to the complainant. But, at that time CBI
police have conducted the raid and seized articles and
prepared the mahazars. In view of the evidence of P.W-1
stated
in
the
chief-examination
as
discussed
above
evidence of all other witnesses is noway helpful to prove
the case of prosecution. The accused has clearly proved his
defence not only in the cross-examination and also in his
written 313 statement. It is very unfortunate that the price
of the materials is very nominal of Rs.3500/-, nobody
would demand such items as a bribe from anybody for
getting a seat in the School. The accused being a Principal
of reputed Institution which is Kendriya Vidyalay definitely
would never demanded for such items as bribe. The entire
incident has taken place at outside the compound of the
School and the prosecution has not proved anything which
has been taken place inside the School and in the chamber
of the School. It is very unfortunate that accused being a
Principal of such a reputed institution was caught by layng
the trap for such cheap items and such a case has been
filed. The prosecution has totally failed to prove the
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
ingredients of Sec. 7 and 13(1) R/w 13(2) of PC Act. If at
all accused intended to demand illegal gratification, he
would have demanded cash or valuable things. But, in this
case, the seized M.O-1 to M.O-4 are the consumable items
and M.O-5 is a Mixer Grinder and they are not valuable
items. On careful consideration of all those materials,
prosecution utterly failed to prove all the charges and
accused has proved his defence that no case has been
made out against him and he is liable to be acquitted.
Hence, I answered these points No.1 and 2 in negative.”
10.
Being aggrieved by the said Judgment, the CBI has
filed the present appeal on following grounds:
The impugned judgment and order of acquittal passed by
the lower court below is contrary to law, facts and evidence
on record, and as such the same is liable to be set aside.
The reasons assigned by the learned Special Judge while
passing the impugned judgment and order of acquittal are
erroneous and hence he has slipped into error and
proceeded to pass the impugned judgment and order of
acquittal, thereby resulting in substantial miscarriage of
justice to the case of the appellant.
It is submitted that interestingly the court below has
acquitted the respondent mainly on one single stress
admission of PW-1/ Complainant in the cross examination
except said admission nothing is discussed by the Court
below.
It is submitted that though PW-1 has been treated as partly
hostile. However, the court below relying upon the cross
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
examination of PW-1 at page 14 which read as under "It is
correct to suggest that the accused removed the cash from
his pocket, at that time I gave a signal that his hands not
to give it because I have already lodged a complainant to
the CBI Police", has acquitted the respondent. Except the
said admission which by itself is Incriminating in nature,
the court below has not considered other material available
against the respondent.
It is submitted that during the cross examination of the
other prosecution witness, nothing is elicited during the
cross examination so as to discard the case of prosecution.
Further, if it is the defense of the respondent accused that
he was going to receive the liquor and mixer by paying
cash then he ought to have stated so in his explanation
under 313 Cr.PC. and also after arrest and thereafter ought
have lead defense evidence so as to prove his case. In view
of not leading any defense evidence the court below ought
not have acquitted the respondent herein.
It is submitted that the evidence of PW-1 and PW-2 clearly
reveals
about
the
demand
and
acceptance
by
the
respondent herein. And their evidence also corroborates
with the contents of the complaint at Ex-P-1. This being the
evidence on record the court below ought not have passed
the impugned order.
The prosecution has examined PW-3/Prashanth Kumari who
speaks about the procedure for getting the students
admitted in Kendriya Vidyalaya and the evidence of this
witness clearly reveals that it was respondent herein who
was working as principal on the date of incident and as
such when the prosecution has examined PW-1 and 2 to
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
prove about demand and acceptance and pendency of work
by this witness, the court below ought not have acquitted
the respondent herein.
When demand, acceptance and pendency of work were
proved by prosecution beyond reasonable doubt, the court
below ought not have acquitted the respondent herein.
It is submitted that the court below has failed to appreciate
the presumption available in favour of the prosecution
under section 20 of P. C Act. section 20 reads as follows:
"Where, in any trial of an offence punishable
under section 7 or under section 11. it is proved
that a public servant accused of an offence has
accepted or obtained or attempted to obtain for
himself, or for any other person, any undue
advantage
from
any
person,
it
shall
be
presumed, unless the contrary is proved, that he
accept or obtained or attempted to obtain that
undue advantage, as motive or reward under
section 7 for performing or to cause performance
of a public duty improperly or dishonestly either
by himself or by another public servant or, as the
case may be, any undue advantage without
consideration or for a consideration which he
knows to be inadequate under section 11".
Said section clearly makes it clear that when the
prosecution proves that the accused has accepted or
obtained or attempted to obtain for himself or for any other
person it shall be presumed that the same is accepted as
bribe unless the contrary is proved. The Court below has
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
failed to raise said legal presumption in favor of the
prosecution and to shift the onus on the respondent shows to
prove is defense on his behalf by probabilities.
It is submitted that the SD cards at M.O-9 and 10 of
recorder and mobile of complainant is sufficient enough to
prove the entire case of prosecution about demand and
acceptance. Transcript of the same would clearly reveal
about pendency of work with respondent, the demand and
acceptance by respondent. This material evidence has not
at all been appreciated by the Special Court.
Further to identify the voice of respondent in M.O 9 and 10
the prosecution got examined PW-3, 4 and 5 who are is coemployees. And they have clearly identified the voice of the
respondent
herein.
When
such
being
the
oral
and
documentary evidence on record the court below is not
justified in passing the order of acquittal.
It is submitted that the prosecution got examined PW-10 to
12 for the purpose of securing the CDR report of the mobile
belonging to complainant PW-1 and also that of land line of
Kendriya Vidyalaya. In that view of the matter the court
ought not have acquitted the respondent.
It is submitted that the court below has failed to appreciate
properly the documentary and oral evidence on record and
has passed the impugned order.
It is submitted that even otherwise the evidence of PW-1
clearly proved that the respondent herein has misused his
position as Principal and demanding liquor and mixer or
cash of Rs.50,000/- and acceptance of the same by him. In
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
that view of the matter the court below ought have
convicted respondent herein.
It is most respectfully submitted that by examining the
witness
and
prosecution
producing
has
the
established
relevant
that
the
materials,
the
accused
has
demanded the illegal gratification and accepted the same.
The prosecution has proved the demand and acceptance
and the recovery of the illegal gratification is also proved as
phenolphthalein test was also positive. Such being the
case, hence, the acquittal of accused is erroneous.
It is submitted that, the co- pancha has supported the case
of the prosecution. Pw-2 is the shadow witness who had
accompanied the complainant has categorically stated that,
the accused has demanded and accepted the illegal
gratification. And nothing is elucidated in cross examination
of this witness from the defense. This being the fact,
prosecution has clearly proved the demand and acceptance
of the mixature & liquor bottles. Therefore the special judge
has erred in acquitting the accused.
It is submitted that, the prosecution has obtained the
sanction
order
and
sanctioning
authority
has
also
categorically deposed in the trial.
Thus viewed from any angle, the judgment and order of
acquittal passed by the court below is even otherwise
illegal, erroneous and unsustainable.
11.
appellant
Sri.Neelendra D. Gunde, learned counsel for the
reiterating
the
grounds
urged
in
the
appeal,
vehemently contended that a stray suggestion which was
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
admitted by PW-1 and a pillion rider (shadow witness) has been
blown out of proportion, ignoring the other material evidence on
record resulting
in miscarriage of justice and sought for
admitting the appeal for further consideration.
12.
counsel
Per
contra,
representing
Sri.Shivakumar
the
Badawadagi,
respondent-accused,
learned
supports
impugned judgment. He would further contend that the actual
trap itself has not taken place and therefore, question of
acceptance being absent, acquittal order is just and proper and
sought for dismissal of the appeal.
13.
Having heard the arguments of both sides, this Court
perused the material on record meticulously.
14.
On such perusal of the material on record, it is
evident that the suggestions put to PW-1 were categorically
admitted by him, which has been rightly taken note of by the
learned trial Judge in paragraphs 8 to 10 of the impugned
judgment.
15.
These suggestions would be sufficient enough to hold
that there is no proper evidence to place on record to prove
demand and acceptance, which are sine qua non for establishing
the offences under Sections 7 and 13 of the Act.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
16.
Further,
in
the
case
hand,
the
alleged
illegal
gratification was in kind. Admittedly, the accused did not receive
the ‘kind’ said to have been given by the complainant and even
before illegal gratifications could be handed over to the custody
of the accused, the raid has taken place and it has been seized.
17.
No
doubt,
the
shadow
witness
supported
the
prosecution case. However, when the complainant himself has
admitted in categorical terms the suggestion which was referred
in paragraph Nos. 8 to 10 of the impugned judgment, question of
any improvement to be made by the examination of PW-2 would
not arise and therefore, order of acquittal is just and proper.
18.
Further, whenever a duly constituted Court records
the order of acquittal, it reinforces the innocence of the accused
and if two views are permissible on the same set of facts, the
view favourable to the accused must be preferred.
19.
Keeping in mind, these celebrated legal principles in
the background and upon re-appreciation of the evidence on
record, this Court do not find any good grounds to interfere with
the impugned judgment or to admit the appeal for further
consideration.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:518
CRL.A No. 100340 of 2023
HC-KAR
20.
Hence, the following order:
ORDER
The appeal dismissed.
Sd/(V.SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
RHR/-CT-CMU
LIST NO.: 2 SL NO.: 25
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review