Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 14TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA
CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION NO. 100124 OF 2025
(397(CR.PC)/438(BNSS))
BETWEEN:
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY LOKAYUKTA POLICE STATION HAVERI-581 110
TQ. AND DIST. HAVERI.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. ANIL KALE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
SMT SHAKUNTALA VEERAYYA HIREMATH
AGE 66 YEARS, OCC. RETIRED OFFICE SUPERINTENDENT
WOMAN AND CHILD DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
DISTRICT ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING HAVERI 581110
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
R/O. B-BLOCK 11TH CROSS,
BASAVESHWAR NAGAR, HAVERI 581110
TQ AND DIST HAVERI,
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. B.G. INDI, ADVOCATE FOR SRI. K.L. PATIL, ADVOCATE)
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION IS FILED U/S 438 R/W
SECTION 442 OF BNSS, PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE RECORDS IN
SPECIAL CASE (SVC) NO. 5/2018 ON THE FILE OF THE PRL. DISTRICT
AND SESSIONS AND SPECIAL JUDGE, HAVERI AND ALLOW THIS
REVISION PETITION AND SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 30.08.2023
PASSED BY THE PRL DIST AND SESSIONS AND SPECIAL JUDGE,
HAVERI ON APPLICATION FILED U/S 227 OF CR.P.C., IN SPECIAL
CASE (SVC) NO 05/2018 FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTION 13(1) (e) R/W 13(2) OF PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT,
IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY, ORDER
WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL ORDER
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA)
1.
Heard
the
Sri.Anil
Kale
and
Sri.B.G.Indi,
for
Sri.K.L.Patil, the parties.
2.
The order under challenge is the allowing of the
application filed by the accused under Section 227 and 239 of
the Criminal Procedure Code (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
Cr.P.C.’ for short) seeking discharge of the accused in the Special
Case (SVC) No.5 of 2018.
3.
Facts in the nutshell which are utmost necessary for
disposal of the present petition are under:
The revision petitioner Lokayuktha-Haveri, filed a charge
sheet against the petitioner herein for the offence under Section
13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption
of Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’).
4.
Learned trial Judge after taking cognizance of the
alleged offences, was proceeding with the case and at that
juncture, an application under Sections 227 and 239 of the
Cr.P.C. came to be filed.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
5.
According to the accused, the explanation offered by
him was not taken into consideration and an incorrect charge
sheet came to be filed. The assets noted therein formed the
basis for the prosecution to file the charge sheet under Section
13(1)(e) of the Act, which, according to the accused did not tally
with his known sources of income to the prosecution. After
appearing before the Court, the accused filed the application,
explaining the excess amount alleged by the prosecution and
furnished the necessary documents in support of his explanation.
6.
It is also contented on behalf of the accused that
10% of the assets which are possessed by the accused needs to
be excluded while computing the excess amount, in accordance
with the dictum of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Krishnanand
Agnihotri v. State of Madhya Pradesh1, wherein it was held that
if the excess assets are comparatively small and less than ten
percent of
the
total income, the
assets
cannot
be
held
disproportionate to known sources of income. Therefore, the
explanation offered by the accused is just and proper and sought
discharge of the accused from the pending criminal proceedings
under Section 13(1)(e) of the Act.
(1977) 1 SCC 816
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
7.
Learned trial Judge after entertaining the objections
of the prosecution, considered the material placed on record by
the prosecution and the accused in detail in the impugned order
and noted that the excess income calculated by the prosecution
in the form of charge sheet is properly explained by the accused.
Further, applying the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Krishnanand Agnihotri (supra), the learned trial Judge
held that the accused was entitled to discharge.
8.
Being aggrieved by the same, Lokayuktha-Haveri is
before this Court in this revision on the following grounds:
“The order under challenge is erroneous, illegal and
the discharge of the accused before framing of
charge is based on the materials/documents placed
by the accused is highly illegal, arbitrary and
against the settled propositions of law hence the
same requires to be set aside.
The order impugned is the mini trial on the
application of the accused for discharge therefore
the learned trial judge has erred in discharging the
accused without proceeding for trial, when there
are ample materials available on record against the
accused and there are sufficient grounds available
on record to show that the prima facie case is made
out against the accused hence the discharge of the
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
accused is erroneous and the same required to be
set aside.
It is submitted that the Special Judge has failed to
appreciate that at the stage of framing of charge
consideration of application for discharge, the court
is to consider whether there is any prima facie case
made out against the accused or not and at that
stage the court is required to evaluate the material
and documents relied on by the prosecution only
with a view to find out whether the facts emerging
therefrom, if taken at their face value, disclose the
existence of all ingredients constituting the offence
or not. But in the case on hand the learned trial
judge, based on the documents produced by the
accused without considering the objections of the
prosecution and without going for trial believed the
documents and statements of the accused which
were based on disputed questions of fact which
could have been decided only after trial. hence the
order impugned is required to be set aside.
Further it is submitted that the special Court has
erroneously believed the version of the accused
without
there
being
any
material
on
record
substantiating the fact that the permission was
obtained from the Government prior to purchase of
the properties and documents produced regarding
the income from the rent and agriculture income
are to be considered only at the time of trial the
Special
Court
placing
reliance
on
the
said
documents has blindly believed the version of the
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
respondent/accused and erroneously come to the
conclusion that the income of the respondent is
Rs.85,91,152/- during the check period and also
believed the total value of the movable and
immovable assets and expenditure of the accused,
therefore the said exercise undertaken by the
Special Court while discharging the accused is
erroneous hence the impugned order required to be
set aside.
It
is
most
prosecution
respectfully
submitted
has
submitted
already
that
the
relevant
materials along with the charge sheet which prima
facie establishes the value of the assets and
expenditure and the total income of the respondent
and the respondent has to prove her defense
during the
course
of
trial by leading cogent
evidence on record and the rent agreements do not
prima facie disclose the income and the declaration
made by the respondent is to be established since
the prosecution has also produced the relevant
materials to show the income and expenditure of
the respondent, therefore the order impugned
order required to be set aside.
Further the Special Judge while discharging the
accused has held that the prosecution sanction
accorded by the authority is without application of
mind. The said reasoning is also erroneous as the
validity of sanction is required to be considered
during the course of trial and any error in according
the said sanction would not absorb the guilt of the
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
accused. Therefore, the said reasoning and the
finding of the Learned Special Judge are bad in Law
and further the Prosecution sanction is accorded by
the competent authority with due application of
mind by considering the materials available against
the respondents therefore the order impugned
required to the set aside.
It is most respectfully submitted that the Hon’ble
Apex Court in case of State of Rajasthan V/s Ashok
Kumar
Kashyap
decided
in
Criminal
Appeal
No.407/2021 has held that while exercising its
judicial mind to the facts of the case in order to
determine weather a case for trial has been made
out by the prosecution, is not necessary for the
court to enter into the Pros and Cons of the matter
or into weighing and balancing of evidence and
probabilities which is really the function of the court
after the trial. And it was held that the court is
required to consider whether a Prima facia case has
been made out or not and whether the accused is
required to be further tried or not. At the stage of
framing of the charge and/or considering the
discharge
application,
permissible.
Therefore,
the
Mini
Trail
the
Special
is
not
Judge
has
looked into the defense of the accused while
considering the discharge application which is an
erroneous approach and the same is required to be
set aside.
It is most respectfully submitted that Hon’ble Apex
in a latest judgment decided in a Criminal Appeal
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
No.2504/2023 in the case of State of Gujarat V/s
Dilipshinh and Kishorisinh Rao Kishorisinh Rao has
held that while discharging the accused the defense
of the accused cannot be looked into, therefore
looking from a all angles the order impugned is an
erroneous and the same is required to be set
aside.”
9.
petitioner
Sri.Anil
Kale,
retreating
the
learned
grounds
counsel
for
the
revision
urged
in
the
petition,
vehemently contented that at the time of considering discharge,
what is to be taken note of is only the prosecution material on
record and not the defence material, that has been put forward
as per the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in State of
Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi2. Therefore, he submitted that
approach of the trial Court is erroneous and sought for allowing
the revision petition and a direction to continue the trial against
the respondent.
10.
Per contra, Sri.B.G.Indi, learned counsel representing
the accused on behalf of Sri.K.L.Patil, would contend that the
principles of law enunciated in Debendra Nath Padhi (supra)
cannot be disputed. However, in a matter of this nature, where
the allegation is that the accused has possessed disproportionate
(2005) 1 SCC 568
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
assets, the principles of law enunciated in Debendra Nath Padhi
(supra) would not be strictly applicable inasmuch as the offence
would get completed before the Court and not before the
Investigating Authority.
11.
Therefore, explanation if any offered by the accused,
if not considered by the Investigation Officer, can be placed
before the Court inasmuch as unwanted trial should not be
allowed to continue and accused need not undergo the ordeal of
the long drawn trial, when the explanation offered by the
accused is sufficient enough to hold that the charge is not prima
facie maintainable against the accused. Therefore, the order of
the trial Judge is just and proper and sought for dismissal of the
revision petition.
12.
Having heard the arguments of both sides, this Court
perused the material on record meticulously.
13.
On such perusal of the material on record, there
cannot be any dispute that, at the time of considering discharge,
only the prosecution papers are to be considered to determine
whether any offence has been made out or not. However, an
offence under Section 13(1)(e) of the Act stands on a different
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
footing, inasmuch as the explanation of the accused is also to be
taken note of before a charge sheet is filed.
14.
In the case on hand, according to the accused such
an explanation was offered, but the Investigation Officer did not
take that explanation into consideration, particularly regarding
domestic expenses etc., which has been dealt with in extenso by
the learned trial Judge in the impugned order.
15.
The nature of the offence under Section 13(1)(e) of
the Act would make it clear that the offence would be complete
when the accused fails to offer a reasonable, plausible or
possible explanation to the assets held, which are in excess to
the known sources of income and Courts are not precluded to
accept the same, if it is in the usual course of the life that the
expenses were incurred by the accused and income was earned
by the accused during the relevant period.
16.
In the case on hand, the Investigation Officer is of
the opinion that during the relevant period, the income and
expenditure did not tally and according to the known sources of
the prosecution, the accused held excess assets to the tune of
69% over the known source of income.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
17.
However, according to the accused, the very arrival
of the excess holding of assets to the tune of 69% is per se
incorrect and offered the explanation on each and every item,
which has been considered by the learned trial Judge while
passing the impugned order.
18.
Therefore, even though there cannot be any dispute
as to the principles of law enunciated in Debendra Nath Padhi
(supra), and Rajnish Kumar Biswakarma v. State of NCT of
Delhi & Anr., in Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No.5290 of 2024, it
is clear that in cases of alleged possession of disproportionate
assets under Section 13(1)(e) of the Act, the explanation offered
by the accused can and must be taken into consideration at the
stage of discharge. Where such explanation is reasonable and
substantiated, no offence can be said to be made out, and
framing of charge would not be justified.
19.
Having regard to the nature of offence, this Court is
of the opinion that there is no strict bar to considering the
explanation of the accused. If the explanation is accepted, no
offence can be made out and charge cannot be framed. Thus,
the approach of the trial Court is just and proper. It is pertinent
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:461
CRL.RP No. 100124 of 2025
HC-KAR
to note that an order of discharge cannot, at any given point of
time, be equated with an order of acquittal.
20.
Discharge constitutes a temporary closure of the
offences alleged against the accused. If the Investigation Agency
is in a position to collect any additional material which would
fortify the alleged offences, it is always at liberty to file
supplementary or additional charge sheet, as contemplated
under Section 173(8) of the Cr.P.C. or Section 193(9) of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, in accordance with law.
21.
With that liberty to the Investigation Agency, the
following order:
ORDER
The revision petition is dismissed.
Sd/RHR/-CT-CMU
LIST NO.: 2 SL NO.: 22
(V.SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review