Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
$
#
#
!
%
!!
&'()& * ! +,
&
-
VARSHA N
RASALKAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
"
#
+
-2-
#
$
#
%
!
%
&
#
!%'
( )
#
+
"+
*
*
+
+
,
"'"
,
"+
%
$+
*
!+
+
*
+
+
% $+
!+
#
"'"
#
*
.
#
+
+ $
*
#
/
-3-
*
*
%
*
#
*
#
#
*
123 455647 82769 ): ;16 <=>5742?4?;
;4;6 23 ;16
@63A7; =8 ;16 BA9C>6?; 4?9 =@96@ =8 4<DA2;;47 94;69
"+
+
=8 ;16
6332=?3 *A9C6
=
+
+
764@?69
992;2=?47
474)A@4C2 8=@ 31=@; .;16 ;@247
E
=A@;/ 2?
E16@62? ;16 4556774?;3 4@6 4<DA2;;69 =8
;16 =886?<63 5A?2314)76 A?96@
!+
23;@2<; 4?9
6<;2=?
6<;2=?
"'
%
$+
"
16 )@268 84<;3 =8 ;16 <436 =8 5@=36<A;2=? 23 ;14;
;16 96<64369
6CA> 23 E286 =8 ;16 4<<A369
=
;16
4<<A369
4?9 ! 4@6 54@6?;3 4?9 ;16 4<<A369
=
4?9
=
$ 4@6 )@=;16@3 =8 ;16 4<<A369
E286 =8 ;16 4<<A369
;16 4<<A369
4<<A369
=
=
=
=
16 4<<A369
;16 4<<A369
4?9 ;16 4<<A369
16 4<<A369
=
=
= % 23 1A3)4?9 =8
= ' 23 323;6@ =8 ;16
>4@@269 ;16 96<64369
-4-
6CA>
14?4>
;16 94AC1;6@ =8 ;16 <=>5742?4?;
4)=A;
412@4
:64@3 4C= 43 =? ;16 964;1 =8 ;16
96<64369
; ;16 ;2>6 =8 >4@@24C6
4>=A?; =8
3 + +++ - E2;1 1=A361=79 4@;2<763 E6@6 C2F6?
;= ;16 4<<A369
=
43 9=E@:
+ ;=743 =8 C=79 4?9 4?
8;6@ ;16 >4@@24C6 ;16
96<64369 769 >4@2;47 7286 E2;1 ;16 4<<A369
8=@ 86E >=?;13
16@648;6@
=
<=@92477:
477 ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
3;4@;69 14@4332?C 4?9 277-;@64;2?C ;16 96<64369 3;4;2?C ;14;
;16 9=E@: C2F6? 4; ;16 ;2>6 =8 >4@@24C6 E43 ?=; 3A882<26?;
4<<A369
E6@6
4)A32?C
74?CA4C6 4?9 4334A7;2?C 16@
4>=A?; =8
;16
96<64369
2?
FA7C4@
F6? 48;6@ C2F2?C 4?=;16@
3 $+ +++ - 43 9=E@: ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 929
?=; <14?C6 ;162@ )614F2=A@
16: 3;4@;69 C2F2?C >=@6
14@433>6?; ;= ;16 96<64369
96>4?92?C ;= C2F6 =?6
=;=@<:<76
16: >496 16@ ;= 3;4@F6 4?9 473= 4334A7;69
4?9 ;@269 ;= G277 16@
" +%
94@31
16? ;16 >4;;6@ 3;==9 ;1A3
+ + 2? ;16 1=A36 =8 ;16 4<<A369
4C4@
=7=?:
A7)4@C4
=
=?
32;A4;69 4;
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
)62?C >6>)6@ =8 A?74E8A7 4336>)7: E2;1 <=>>=? =)B6<;
-5-
A369 <@2>2?47 8=@<6 4?9 F2=76?<6 4?9 ;16@6): <=>>2;;69
@2=;2?C 4?9 DA4@@6769 E2;1 ;16 96<64369 4?9 3A)B6<;69 16@
;= <@A67;: 96>4?92?C ;= )@2?C 4? 4>=A?; =8 Rs.$+ +++ 8@=> 16@ 54@6?;30 1=A36 43 9=E@:
16 ;=@;A@6 =8 ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 E43 =8 3A<1 ?4;A@6 ;14; 2; E43 72G67: ;=
9@2F6 ;16 96<64369 ;= <=>>2; 3A2<296
;16 4<<A369
=
? ;16 3429 2?<296?;
47=?C E2;1 =;16@ 4<<A369 56@3=?3 4)A369
;16 96<64369 E2;1 827;1: 74?CA4C6 5@=F=G2?C 16@ ;= )@64G
5A)72< 564<6 4?9 ;16@6): 3A)B6<;69 16@ ;= 51:32<47 4?9
>6?;47 <@A67;: 4?9 @68A369 ;= 5@=F296 8==9 4?9 <7=;12?C ;=
16@ >4G2?C 16@ ;= 3;4@F6
16? 316 E43 3A886@2?C 8@=>
3;4@F4;2=? ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 E2;1 2?;6?;2=? ;= <4A36 ;16
964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369 =? ;16 34>6 94: <=>>2;;69 >A@96@
=8 ;16 96<64369 4?9 ;16@6): <=>>2;;69 ;16 =886?<6
4776C69 4C42?3; ;16>
!
? ;16 <=>5742?; =8
416@4
14?4> ;16
>=;16@ =8 ;16 96<64369 ;16 <=>5742?4?; 5=72<6 @6C23;6@69
<436
4C42?3;
;16
5A?2314)76 A?96@
4<<A369
6<;2=?
"'
56@3=?3
!+
8=@
4?9
;16
=886?<6
E 36<;2=?
"
-6-
4?9 ;==G A5 2?F63;2C4;2=?
2?F63;2C4;2=?
8;6@ <=>576;2=? =8 ;16
;16 <=>5742?4?; 5=72<6 82769 <14@C6 3166;
4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 8=@ ;16 =886?<63 5A?2314)76
A?96@
6<;2=?
"'
% $+
; ;16 2?2;247 3;4C6
4?9 !+
E 36<;2=?
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 E6@6
4@@63;69 4?9 ;16@648;6@ ;16: E6@6 @6764369 =? )427
764@?69
"
4C23;@4;6 ;==G <=C?2H4?<6 =8 ;16 =886?<63 4C42?3;
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 8=@ ;16 =886?<63 <14@C6 3166;69 4?9
@6C23;6@69 <@2>2?47 <436 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
;16 >64?;2>6 ;16 4<<A369
=
E43 @65=@;69 ;= )6 9649
4?9 16?<6 ;16 <436 4C42?3; 4<<A369
43 4)4;69
=
E43 923>23369
3 ;16 =886?<6 <14@C6 3166;69 4C42?3; ;16
4<<A369 56@3=? 23 6I<7A32F67: ;@24)76 ): ;16
=A@; ;16 764@?69
@
?
4C23;@4;6 4<;2?C A?96@
<=>>2;;69 ;16 <436 ;= ;16 ;@247
;16 164@2?C 4)=F6 ;16 4<<A369
=
=A@;
+% =8
3 3;4;69 2?
4?9 ! ;= ' E6@6 =?
)427 4?9 ;16: 45564@69 )68=@6 ;16 ;@247
<=A?367 4?9 C=; 6?74@C69 =? )427
6<;2=?
6332=?3
=A@; ;1@=AC1 ;16
-7-
8;6@
164@2?C
)=;1
;16
54@;263
4?9
<=?3296@2?C ;16 5@=36<A;2=? 5456@3 =? @6<=@9
=A@; 8@4>69 <14@C6 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369
=
=?
;16 ;@247
4?9 ! ;= '
8=@ ;16 =886?<63 5A?2314)76 A?96@
6<;2=?3
4?9 !+
;= E12<1 ;16 4<<A369
E 36<;2=?
"
%
"'
$+
56@3=?3 5764969 ?=; CA27;: 4?9 ;16@6): ;16: <742>69 ;= )6
;@269 =8 ;16 3429 =886?<63
$
? 3A55=@; =8 ;16 <436 =8 ;16 5@=36<A;2=?
E2;?63363 E6@6 6I4>2?69 43
5@=9A<69 9=<A>6?;3 4;
=)B6<; 4;
I3
;=
;=
$
$ 4?9 ;16: 14F6
$ 4?9 =?6 >4;6@247
8;6@ <7=32?C =8 ;16 6F296?<6 =8 ;16
5@=36<A;2=? E2;?63363 ;16 4<<A369
=
6I4>2?69 ): ;16 ;@247
6<;2=? ! ! =8
E16@62? ;16 4<<A369
=A@; A?96@
=
4?9 ! ;= ' E6@6
@
4?9 ! ;= ' 96?269 ;16
2?<@2>2?4;2?C >4;6@247 8=@;1<=>2?C 4C42?3; ;16> 2? ;16
5@=36<A;2=? 6F296?<6 143 84736
A@;16@ ;16 4<<A369
=
3;4;69 2? 123 3;4;6>6?; A?96@
6<;2=? ! ! =8
;14;
123 E286 ;16 96<64369 9269 =8 ;A)6@<A7=323
@
9236436
4?9 16 ;==G 16@ ;= ;16 1=352;47 4?9 356?; 3A882<26?;
-8-
4>=A?; 8=@ 16@ ;@64;>6?;
16 4<<A369
499A<6 9686?<6 6F296?<6
<<=@92?C7: ;16 4<<A369
C=; 12>3678 6I4>2?69 43
9=<A>6?;3 4;
I
;=
=
473= <1=36 ;=
=
4?9 16 5@=9A<69
2? 3A55=@; =8 ;16 9686?<6 5A;
8=@;1 ): ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
8;6@ 164@2?C ;16 4@CA>6?; =8 )=;1 ;16 54@;263
4?9 <=?3296@2?C ;16 =@47 4?9 9=<A>6?;4@: 6F296?<6
8=@;1<=>2?C =? @6<=@9
;16 ;@247
=A@; <=>2?C ;= ;16
<=?<7A32=? ;14; ;16 5@=36<A;2=? 143 842769 ;= 5@=F6 )6:=?9
@643=?4)76
9=A);
;16
=886?<63
<14@C69
4<<A369 56@3=?3 143 4<DA2;;69 ;16 4<<A369
' 8=@ ;16 =886?<63 5A?2314)76 A?96@
$+
!+
E
"
6<;2=?
4C42?3;
=
;16
4?9 ! ;=
"'
%
A?96@ ;16 2>5AC?69 BA9C>6?; =8
4<DA2;;47
%
;16 764@?69
62?C 4CC@26F69 ): ;16 2>5AC?69 BA9C>6?;
143 <=>6 A5 E2;1 ;16 5@636?;
455647 =? ;16 C@=A?9 ;14; ;16 2>5AC?69 BA9C>6?; 4?9
=@96@ =8 4<DA2;;47 =8 ;16 ;@247
=A@; 23 <=?;@4@: ;= 84<;3 =8
-9-
;16 <436 74E 4?9 >4;6@247 =? @6<=@9 4?9 34>6 23 724)76 ;=
)6 34;238269
16 ;@247
6F296?<6 =8
;16
9686?<6
=A@; 143 @67269 >=@6 =? ;16 9686?<6
4?9 9=<A>6?;4@: 6F296?<6 5@=9A<69 ):
4?9
4<<A369 56@3=?3
;16@6):
6@@=?6=A37:
4<DA2;;69
;16
16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;@269 ;= 5@=)4)27236
;162@ 9686?<6 ;14; ;16 F2<;2> 96<64369
9269 9A6 ;=
;A)6@<A7=323 )A; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 14F6 ?=; 63;4)723169
;16 34>6 )68=@6 ;16
=A@; ): 499A<2?C ;16 6F296?<6 =8 ;16
9=<;=@ E1= ;@64;69 ;16 F2<;2> 96<64369 8=@ ;A)6@<A7=323
16 E2;?63363
;=
! 4?9
+ 14F6 <764@7:
965=369 2? 3A55=@; =8 5@=36<A;2=? <436 4?9 ;162@ 6F296?<6
23 <=@@=)=@4;69 ): ;16 6F296?<6 =8 9=<;=@@65=@; 4;
I
$
4?9
16@6 23 <764@ >6?;2=? ;14; ;16 34>5763
<=?;42?69 =@C4? 51=351=@A3 2?36<;2<296
; 23 ?=; ;16
9686?<6
;16
96<64369
<=>>2;;69 3A2<296 ): <=?3A>2?C 2?36<;2<296
16@6 23
=8
;16
4<<A369
56@3=?3
;14;
3A882<26?; >4;6@247 =? @6<=@9 ;= 31=E ;16 5@636?<6 =8
2?36<;2<296 2? ;16 34>5763 =8 =@C4?3 =8 ;16 F2<;2> E12<1
E=A79 63;4)7231 ;16 <436 =8 5@=36<A;2=?
A; ;@247
=A@; 143
- 10 -
?=; 5@=56@7: 455@6<24;69 ;16 >4;6@247 =? @6<=@9 4?9
;16@6):
<=>>2;;69
6@@=@
2?
4<DA2;;2?C
;16
4<<A369
56@3=?3 574<2?C @6724?<6 A5=? 3=>6 >2?=@ <=?;@492<;2=?3
2? ;16 6F296?<6 =8 5@=36<A;2=? E2;?63363 #26E69 8@=> 4?:
4?C76 ;16 2>5AC?69 BA9C>6?; 4?9 =@96@ =8 4<DA2;;47 =8
;16 ;@247
=A@; 23 2776C47 4?9 <=?;@4@: ;= 84<;3 4?9 34>6 23
724)76 ;= )6 36; 43296
16@68=@6 ;16 764@?69
5@4:69 8=@ 477=E2?C ;16 455647
'
=
? 5A@3A4?<6 =8 36@F2<6 =8 ?=;2<6 ;= ;16 4<<A369
4?9 ! ;= ' )62?C ;16 @635=?96?;3 2? ;16 455647 14F6
45564@69 ;1@=AC1 ;16 <=A?367
16 ;@247
=A@; @6<=@93
14F6 )66? <47769 8=@
"
? ;16 )4323 =8 4@CA>6?;
;16 5=2?;3 =8 74E
A@C69 ): )=;1 ;16 54@;263 2? ;162@ 4@CA>6?;3 4?9 473=
<=?3296@2?C
;16
=@47
8=@;1<=>2?C =? @6<=@9
<=?3296@4;2=? =8 ;123
4?9
9=<A>6?;4@:
6F296?<6
;16 5=2?; ;14; 4@2363 8=@ ;16
=A@; 23 ;14;
- 11 -
16;16@ ;16 ;@247
=A@; 143 842769 ;=
<=?3296@ ;16 =@47 4?9 9=<A>6?; 6F296?<6
8=@;1<=>2?C
=?
@6<=@9
2?
5@=56@
56@356<;2F6 4?9 ;16@6): <=>>2;;69 4?:
6@@=@ 2? 4<DA2;;2?C ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 8=@
;16 =886?<63 <14@C69J
+
; 23 ?=; 2? 9235A;6 ;14; ;16 4<<A369
1A3)4?9 ;16 4<<A369
4<<A369
=
=
=
=
4?9 ! 4@6 54@6?;3-2?-74E ;16
4?9 $ 4@6 )@=;16@3-2?-74E 4?9 ;16 4<<A369
4?9 ' 4@6 323;6@3-2?-74E =8 ;16 96<64369
?=; 2? 9235A;6 ;14; ;16 4<<A369
; 23 473=
= % 23 1A3)4?9 =8 ;16
4<<A369
=
8;6@ ;16 @6C23;@4;2=? =8 ;16 <436
4<<A369
=
E43 @65=@;69 ;= )6 9649 4?9 16?<6 ;16 <436
4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369
=
;16
E43 47@649: 923>23369 43 4)4;69
4?9 ;16 <436 E43 5@=<66969 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369
=
4?9
! ;= ' =?7:
16 4@CA>6?; =8 ;16 764@?69
;16
4<<A369
56@3=?3
3A)B6<;69
;16
23 ;14;
96<64369
;=
14@433>6?; 4?9 277-;@64;>6?; 96>4?92?C ;= )@2?C 8A@;16@
4>=A?; =8
3 $+ +++ 43 9=E@: 4?9 ;16@6): <4A369 964;1
- 12 -
=8 ;16 96<64369
; 23 ?=; 2? 9235A;6 ;14; ;16 96<64369
9269 2? ;16 >4;@2>=?247 1=>6 )67=?C2?C ;= ;16 4<<A369
=
)6:=?9
=E6F6@ A?7633 ;16@6 23 6F296?<6 =8 ;16 5@=36<A;2=?
@643=?4)76
3A)B6<;69
;16
9=A);
96<64369
;14;
;=
;16
4<<A369
14@433>6?;
56@3=?3
4?9
<@A67;:
96>4?92?C 16@ ;= )@2?C 9=E@: 4?9 ;16@6): 4)A369 ;16
96<64369 2? 827;1: 74?CA4C6 4?9 <4A369 964;1 =8 ;16
96<64369 ?= <436 <4? )6 >496 =A; 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369
56@3=?3 8=@ ;16 =886?<63 <14@C69
? ;123 )4<GC@=A?9 2; 23
?6<6334@:
;16
;=
43<6@;42?
E16;16@
;@247
=A@;
<=>>2;;69 ;16 6@@=@ 2? 4<DA2;;2?C ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 =8
;16 =886?<63 <14@C69
16 =@47 4?9 9=<A>6?;4@: 6F296?<6
8=@;1<=>2?C =? @6<=@9 31477 )6 <=?3296@69 2? 5@=56@
56@356<;2F6
=A@; )62?C ;16 82@3; 4556774;6
=A@; ;123
=A@; 31477 @6-455@6<24;6 4?9 @6<=?3296@ ;16 6F296?<6
8=@;1<=>2?C =? @6<=@9 2? 5@=56@ 56@356<;2F6
3 >6?;2=?69 16@62? 4)=F6
;16 5@=36<A;2=?
E43 36; 2?;= >=;2=? 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 =? ;16
<=>5742?; =8
E1= 23 >=;16@ =8 ;16 96<64369
16 143
- 13 -
)66?
6I4>2?69
6I4>2?4;2=?
?
;16
6F296?<6
143 965=369 ;14; 4)=A;
=8
<1268
+ :64@3 4C=
6CA> >4@@269 ;16
16@ 94AC1;6@
;16 96<64369
4<<A369
43 56@ ;16 <A3;=>3 4?9 @2;63 5@6F4272?C 2?
=
;162@ <=>>A?2;:
;16 4>=A?; =8
? ;16 >4@@24C6
+ C@4>3 =8 C=79 4?9
3 + +++ - E6@6 C2F6? ;= ;16 4<<A369
4?9 $ C@4>3 =8 C=79 E43 C2F6? ;= ;16 96<64369
=
9=>63;2< 4@;2<763 E6@6 473= C2F6? 3A<1 43 <=; 47>6@4 4;
;16 ;2>6 =8 >4@@24C6 4?9 ;16 <=3; =8 ;16 >4@@24C6 E43
)=@?6 ): ;16>
!
; 23 473= ;16 6F296?<6 =8
;14; 48;6@ ;16
>4@@24C6 =?7: 8=@ ! >=?;13 ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 7==G69
48;6@ ;16 96<64369 E677
16@648;6@ ;16 96<64369 ;=79 16@
;14; 16@ >=;16@-2?-74E 4?9 1A3)4?9 A369 ;= 3A)B6<; 16@ ;=
<@A67;: 96>4?92?C ;= )@2?C
3 $+ +++ - 8@=> 54@6?;30
1=A36 4?9 ;16: 929 ?=; C2F6 8==9 ;= 16@
16 >=;16@-2?-
74E 4?9 16@ 3=?3 4?9 94AC1;6@3 A369 ;= 14@433 ;16
96<64369
=
6?<6 ;16: C4F6 Rs.$+ +++ - ;= ;16 4<<A369
)A; 48;6@ 56@2=9 =8 ! >=?;13 =8 ;16 >4@@24C6 ;16
- 14 -
96<64369 <4>6 ;= 16@ 54@6?;30 1=A36 4?9 ;=79
;14;
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 E6@6 ?=; C2F2?C 8==9 ;= 16@
6?<6
316 47=?C E2;1 16@ 1A3)4?9 4?9 )@=;16@-2?-74E E6?; ;= ;16
1=A36 =8 4<<A369 56@3=?3 4?9 49F2369 ;16> ;= 7==G 48;6@
;16 96<64369 E677
; ;14; ;2>6 ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?
4334A7;69 16@ 1A3)4?9 2?3296 ;16 1=A36 ): <7=32?C 9==@ =8
;16 1=A36 4?9 ;16 4<<A369
>=;=@<:<76
=
96>4?969 ;= C2F6
16? ;16 54@6?;3 =8 ;16 96<64369 842769 ;=
C2F6 >=;=@<:<76 ;= ;16 4<<A369
=
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
3A)B6<;69 ;16 96<64369 ;= 14@433>6?; ): ?=; 5@=F292?C
8==9 ;= 16@ 4?9 ;16: 929 ?=; 477=E ;16 96<64369 ;= <=>6
=A; =8 ;16 1=A36
=E6F6@ ;16 6F296?<6 =8
23 473= ;14; 16@
94AC1;6@ ;16 96<64369 ;=79 16@ ;14; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
E6@6 F6@: <@2>2?47 4?9 316 ;=79 ?=; ;= <=>6 ;= 16@ 1=A36
4?9 16?<6
4?9 16@ 1A3)4?9 929 ?=; C= ;= ;16 1=A36
=8 ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 4?9
<4>6 ;= G?=E ;1@=AC1
3=>6 =;16@ 56@3=? ;14; ;16 96<64369 C4F6 )2@;1 ;= ;1@66
86>476 <1279@6?
3 5=2?;69 =A; ): ;16 764@?69 <=A?367 4?9
- 15 -
): ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
6F296?<6 =8
;16 @676F4?; 5=@;2=? 2? ;16
2? 16@ <1268-6I4>2?4;2=? 2;3678 @6493 ;1A3
!
$%
%
&'
! (
$ )*+!
"#
,
& 2
-.
/
! 3 14 + 56
'
:6 9
!;
$
16 @676F4?; 5=@;2=? 2? ;16 6F296?<6 =8
2?
<1268-6I4>2?4;2=? 23 473= ;14;
1 %
*
" 2 > ?@
(A
$
*+
* B-A
$
<$
! B
*
D E=
$%
"5 :
$
$
/A
&'
&'
IJ
=
:C (A
$ A '!
" F0
&G
H
: 2
D
D
")*+!
3 3A)>2;;69 ): ;16 764@?69 <=A?367 8=@ ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;16 4)=F6 @686@@69 6F296?<6 =8
2?
16@ <1268-6I4>2?4;2=? E=A79 <764@7: 31=E ;14; ;16
- 16 -
?=; C= ;= ;16 1=A36 =8 4<<A369 56@3=?3 4; 4?: ;2>6 48;6@ !
>=?;13 =8 ;16 >4@@24C6 =8 ;16 96<64369 E2;1 ;16 4<<A369
=
16@68=@6 4?: 4776C4;2=? @6C4@92?C 277-;@64;>6?; ):
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;= ;16 96<64369 23 =?7: 164@34:
6F296?<6 =8
=@6=F6@
6F296?<6 =8
2? <@=33-6I4>2?4;2=? @6493 ;1A3
&
K
IJ
L &
$A
&' )*+! ( $ 7
%
$%2
( $7
P5
M
$
%
16 @676F4?; 5=@;2=? =8
*
$
N
$JO*+!
*
2*+!
* )+ I J
D
N )+
/
A*+!;
; 23 473= ;16 6F296?<6 =8
2? 16@ <@=33-
6I4>2?4;2=? E12<1 @6493 ;1A3
Q
( $7
- " RH ("C G
& 0
:$ )"
*+
$
!
-
JO
)+
B
: +0O
:$ )"
!
)+
:$ )"
?*
*+
D
- 17 -
$
$A
)+
$ =
:$ )"
"
'
( $7
*+
*+!;
A@;16@ 2; 23 F6@: >A<1 @676F4?; ;= ?=;6 ;14; 2?
;16 6F296?<6 2? <@=33-6I4>2?4;2=? ;16
143 96?269 ;16
3ACC63;2=? =8 ;16 764@?69 <=A?367 8=@ ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
;14; ;16 96<64369 E43 3A886@2?C 8@=> ;A)6@<A7=323 4?9
4<<A369
=
C4F6 ;@64;>6?; ;= ;16 96<64369 @6C4@92?C
3429 472>6?;
143 8A@;16@ 965=369 ;14; 316 E43 ?=;
;=79 4?:;12?C 4)=A; ;16 96<6436
=
=E6F6@ ;16 4<<A369
143 C=; 12>3678 6I4>2?69 43
@6C4@92?C 123
9686?36 5A; 8=@;1 2? ;16 <436 4?9 16 143 5@=9A<69 3=>6
9=<A>6?;3 @6C4@92?C ;16 ;@64;>6?; C2F6? ;= ;16 96<64369
8=@ 472>6?; 3A<1 43 ;A)6@<A7=323
"
3 3A)>2;;69 ): ;16 764@?69 <=A?367 8=@ ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 28 ;16 ;=;472;: =8 6F296?<6 =8
2?;= <=?3296@4;2=? 2; 23 <764@ ;14;
23 ;4G6?
23 ?=; 4E4@6 =8 4?:
84<; @6C4@92?C ;16 96<64369 E16? 316 E43 @63292?C E2;1
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 2? >4;@2>=?247 1=>6
6?<6 E2;1=A;
- 18 -
;16 3A55=@; =8 4?: <=@@=)=@4;2F6 6F296?<6 ;16 6F296?<6 =8
9=63 ?=; >6@2; <=?3296@4;2=? ;= 5@=F6 ;16 4776C69
2?<296?; 4?9 ;16@6): ;= 5@=F6 ;16 =886?<63 <14@C69 4C42?3;
;16 56@3=?3 2? ;16 <436
+
4?BA@
1>69 23 84;16@ =8 ;16 96<64369
23 6F296?<6 23 32>274@ ;= ;16 6F296?<6 =8
@6C4@92?C
;16 4776C69 277-;@64;>6?; ;= ;16 96<64369 ): ;16 4<<A369
56@3=?3
16 @676F4?; 5=@;2=? 2? ;16 6F296?<6 2? <1268-
6I4>2?4;2=? =8
@6493 ;1A3
"
)+
B
$4
IN $4
'
$: F
$= O
' QS " 5
!
LT, &
$
)+
U U :G
I F
( $7
& &'
D
&'
!
( $7
$ %
A;
& 0
!
;16@6
VS " 5
VS " 5
4)3=7A;67:
$ %
$JO
$%
:G
!
?=
$: F
%
% &'
$: F
$JO
2?9656?96?;
!;
6F296?<6
8=@;1<=>2?C 8@=> ;16 5@=36<A;2=? 2? 5@==8 =8 6F296?<6 =8
- 19 -
@6C4@92?C ;16 277-;@64;>6?; 4776C697: >6;69 =A; ):
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;= ;16 96<64369
16@6
4)3=7A;67:
?=
4?:
9=<A>6?;
8=@;1<=>2?C 8@=> ;16 5@=36<A;2=? ;= 5@=F6 ;14; ;16 64@726@
;= ;16 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369 ;16@6 E43 4?: <=>5742?;
C2F6? ): ;16 96<64369 =@ ): 16@ 54@6?;3 4C42?3; ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 @6C4@92?C ;16 4776C69 277-;@64;>6?; =8 ;16
96<64369 ): ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 96>4?92?C ;= C2F6 ;16
<431 4>=A?; 4?9 473=
6@=
=?94 >=;=@<:<76 43 9=E@:
? ;16 94;6 =8 4776C69 2?<296?; =8 964;1 =8 ;16
96<64369 E16? ;16
4?9
E6?; ;= ;16 1=A36 =8
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;16
929 ?=; 366 4?: 2?BA@263 =?
;16 )=9: =8 ;16 96<64369
A; ;16 6F296?<6 =8
2?
<1268-6I4>2?4;2=? 23 ;14; ;16@6 E6@6 <2C4@6;;6 )A@? 2?BA@263
=? )=;1 76C3 =8 ;16 96<64369
A; @6C4@92?C ;1=36 2?BA@263
;16@6 23 ?= 3A55=@;2?C >692<47 6F296?<6 8=@;1<=>2?C =?
@6<=@9 ;14; 3A<1 2?BA@263 E6@6 2?872<;69 ): <2C4@6;;6 64@726@
- 20 -
;= ;16 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369 4?9 3A<1 2?BA@263 E6@6 ;16
@643=? 8=@ ;16 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369
!
3 3A)>2;;69 ): ;16 764@?69 <=A?367 8=@ ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;16 8=77=E2?C 5=@;2=? 8=@;1<=>2?C 2? ;16
6F296?<6 =8
2? <@=33-6I4>2?4;2=? E=A79 31=E ;14; ;16
E43 ?=; 4E4@6 =8 4?: 84<; @6C4@92?C ;16 96<64369
E16? 316 E43 2? ;16 1=A36 =8 ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
@676F4?; 5=@;2=? 2? ;16 6F296?<6 =8
"
@6493 ;1A3
$ * JW (A '
*+ (
$&'*+!
JW
-
>N
)*+
X G
%
(
'
"
*+! Q
' "$ 4 :$
* ZU/
>@
-
$&'*+!
$
"
M
%&
0 "
L
>N
:$ )"[ \
$ 2
*+!
( $7
)+ ?U Y
,
"
/
(A
)+
! 3
$ 'A ! B ]
^
!;
- 21 -
=@6=F6@
;16
6F296?<6
=8
2?
<@=33-
6I4>2?4;2=? @6493 ;1A3
"
"
*+! "X
A
_
*
X
L`!S,!LSSa
#0
)&
"
A
*+!
"
&
)+
)+
&"* (
"$?0
2*+ 1
%
*+!
d N
X
" UZ B
$
$ J"
" "
c
$ J"
) 4_ $ J0 )+ b
!
(
$9
) 4_
) 4_
& 0
K
U*
$&'*+! "
#0
a
2 _
B
!"
>
W% &' )*+
I6
)+
2*+!
$ 0
) "#
/ " UZ
&"*
' !
123 6F296?<6 =8
E1= 23 84;16@ =8 ;16
96<64369 E=A79 31=E ;14; 16 ;@269 ;= 3A55@633 3=>6 84<;3
4)=A; 123 94AC1;6@ ;16 96<64369
<;A477: 28 ;16 4)=F6
@686@@69 3ACC63;2=? =8 ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 2? ;16 <@=336I4>2?4;2=? =8
23 <=?3296@69 2; E=A79 )6 <764@ ;14;
;16 96<64369 16@3678 233A69 76C47 ?=;2<6 ;= 16@ 54@6?;3
- 22 -
E16@62? 316 ;=79 ;14; 16@ 1A3)4?9 ;16 4<<A369
=
E43
2? C==9 ;6@>3 E2;1 16@ 4?9 316 929 ?=; E4?; 16@ 54@6?;3
;= 2?;6@86@6 E2;1 16@ >4;@2>=?: 7286
!
96<64369
D)47
1>69 23 6796@ )@=;16@ =8 ;16
6 143 965=369 2? 123 6F296?<6 2? <1268-
6I4>2?4;2=? ;14; 123 84;16@ C4F6
<431 4>=A?; =8
+ C@4>3 =8 C=79 4?9
+ +++ - ;= ;16 4<<A369
>4@@24C6 =8 ;16 96<64369 E2;1 ;16 4<<A369
=
=
2? ;16
)=A;
;= ! >=?;13 48;6@ ;16 >4@@24C6 ;16 96<64369 <4>6 ;= 123
1=A36 ;1@2<6
A; ;16@648;6@ ;16@6 E43 ?= <=?;4<; )6;E66?
12> 4?9 ;16 96<64369 4?9 16 929 ?=; G?=E E16;16@ ;16
96<64369 149 4?: <1279@6?
%
; 23 ;16 6F296?<6 =8
! ;14; =?6 94: 8@=>
A7)4@C4 123 @674;2F6 ;=79 =F6@ 51=?6 @6C4@92?C ;16 964;1
=8 123 323;6@
;16 96<64369
6?<6
16 47=?C E2;1 123
54@6?;3 4?9 =;16@ 56@3=?3 E6?; ;= ;16 1=A36 =8 ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 4?9 34E ;16 9649 )=9: =8 ;16 96<64369
2? ;16 1477 =8 ;16 1=A36 =8 ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
- 23 -
6F296?<6 =8
! 2? ;16 <1268-6I4>2?4;2=? E=A79 31=E ;14;
;16@6 4@6 ?= 4?: 356<282< 4776C4;2=?3 >496 4C42?3; 4<<A369
56@3=?3
;14;
;16:
3A)B6<;69
;16
96<64369
;=
4?:
? ;16 =;16@ 14?9 43 56@ ;16 6F296?<6 =8
!
14@433>6?;
'
16 929 ?=; G?=E 4)=A; ;16 96<64369 48;6@ ! >=?;13 =8 16@
>4@@24C6 E2;1 ;16 4<<A369
=8
=
16@68=@6 ;16 6F296?<6
! 9=63 ?=; >6@2; <=?3296@4;2=? ;= <=>6 ;= ;16
<=?<7A32=? ;14; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 <4A369 964;1 =8 ;16
96<64369 3A)B6<;2?C 16@ ;= >6?;47 4?9 51:32<47 <@A67;:
96>4?92?C 9=E@: 2? ;16 8=@> =8 <431 4>=A?; 4?9
>=;=@<:<76
"
96<64369
6796@ 323;6@
%
=A3A8
14? 23 >4;6@?47 A?<76 =8 ;16
6 143 965=369 2? 123 6F296?<6 ;14;
; 23 ;@A6 ;14;
23 123
% 2? 123 <1268-6I4>2?4;2=?
143 3;4;69 @6C4@92?C <431 4>=A?; 4?9 C=79 4776C697: C2F6?
;= ;16 4<<A369
96<64369
=
4; ;16 ;2>6 =8 123 >4@@24C6 E2;1 ;16
A; ;16@6 23 ?= >4;6@247 2? ;16 6F296?<6 =8
%
- 24 -
2? <@=33-6I4>2?4;2=? ;14; 16 E2;?63369 4?: 2?<296?; =8 ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 277-;@64;2?C ;16 96<64369 2? ;16 1=A36 =8
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
% 143 C6?6@477: ;=79 ;14;
E16? 16 47=?C E2;1 ;16 84;16@ =8 ;16 96<64369 E6?; ;=
1=A36 =8 ;16 4<<A369
=
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 A369 ;=
34: ;14; ;16: 929 ?=; @6<=C?2H6 ;16> 4?9 ;16: A369 ;=
4334A7; 4?9 4)A36 ;16 96<64369
!+
; 23 473= ;16 6F296?<6 =8
% 2? <1268-
6I4>2?4;2=? ;14; E16? 16 47=?C E2;1 ;16 54@6?;3 =8 ;16
96<64369 E6?; ;= ;16 1=A36 =8 ;16 4<<A369 ;16 4<<A369
56@3=?3 4334A7;69 ;16> E2;1 3;=?6 4?9 14?93 4?9 929 ?=;
36?9 ;16 96<64369 E2;1 ;16> ;= 16@ 54@6?;30 1=A36
143 473= ;=79 ;14; ;16: C4F6 <=>5742?; ;=
3;4;2=? @6C4@92?C ;16 3429 2?<296?;
?=
9=<A>6?;4@:
6F296?<6
4C4@ 5=72<6
A; ;16@6 23 4)3=7A;67:
8=@;1<=>2?C
8@=>
;16
5@=36<A;2=? ;= 31=E ;14; ;16@6 E43 4?: <436 @6C23;6@69
4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 =? ;16 <=>5742?; =8 ;16
54@6?;3 =8 ;16 96<64369 =@ =? ;16 <=>5742?; =8
;2>6 64@726@ ;= ;16 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369
% 4; 4?:
- 25 -
!
+
=14>>69 72:43 23 ?6516E =8
6F296?<6 2? <1268-6I4>2?4;2=? 23 @6C4@92?C 54:>6?; =8
Rs. + +++ - 4?9 $ C@4>3 =8 C=79 ;= ;16 4<<A369
;16
=
4?9
+ C@4>3 =8 C=79 ;= ;16 96<64369 4; ;16 ;2>6 =8 ;162@
>4@@24C6
=E6F6@ @6C4@92?C ;16 4776C69 277-;@64;>6?; ):
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;= ;16 96<64369
;16 6F296?<6 =8
+ 2? <1268-6I4>2?4;2=? 23 164@34: 6F296?<6
@676F4?; 5=@;2=? 2? ;16 6F296?<6 =8
+ 2? <1268-
6I4>2?4;2=? 23 ;14;
$
"$
' !
, &
( $7
$
$% &'
"$
^
X
'
!
:G
F
VS " 5
W8"* D " 4
$ %
$%
&'
!
&'
$: F
% &'
!;
123 6F296?<6 =8
6F296?<6
@6C4@92?C
4<<A369
56@3=?3
;=
"4
;16
;16
+ E=A79 31=E ;14; 123
4776C69
277-;@64;>6?;
96<64369
):
;16
164@34:
=?6
- 26 -
16@68=@6 ;16 6F296?<6 =8
+ 23 2? ?= E4: 16758A7 ;=
;16 <436 =8 5@=36<A;2=? ;= <=>6 ;= ;16 <=?<7A32=? ;14; ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 <4A369 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369 3A)B6<;2?C
16@ ;= 51:32<47 277-;@64;>6?;
!!
=@6=F6@
5=2?;69
=A;
):
;16
764@?69
<=A?367 8=@ ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 2? ;16 6F296?<6 2? <@=336I4>2?4;2=?
E=@G 32?<6
+ 143 965=369 ;14; 16 23 9=2?C E6792?C
+ :64@3 4?9 16 23 ?=; 9=2?C ;427=@2?C E=@G
143 473= 3;4;69 ;14; ;16 5=72<6 >6?;2=?2?C 2? 123 4776C69
3;4;6>6?; ;14; 16 23 ;16 ;427=@ 23 ?=; <=@@6<;
!
16 @676F4?; 5=@;2=? 2? ;16 4776C69 3;4;6>6?; =8
+ ;= ;16 5=72<6 23 DA2;6 <=?;@4@: ;= 123 6F296?<6 2?
<@=33-6I4>2?4;2=?
16@68=@6 ;16 @676F4?; 5=@;2=? 2? 123
3;4;6>6?; 23 C=; >4@G69 4;
2? <@=33-6I4>2?4;2=?
I
! ): ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
=@6=F6@ 2; 23 F6@: >A<1 @676F4?;
;= ?=;6 ;14; ;16 6F296?<6 2? <@=33-6I4>2?4;2=? =8
@6493 ;1A3
+
- 27 -
e 2
M
"
)"4 A 1
)+ & 2 !
M
!$
,T
$/
$ * "
" (A
$&' )*+ 1
!
)*+
!;
123 49>2332=? =8
$
(
+ 2? 123 6F296?<6 E=A79
31=E ;14; 16 E43 ?=; 4E4@6 =8 4?:;12?C 4)=A; ;16 4776C69
2?<296?; =8 ;16 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369
6F296?<6 =8
16@68=@6
;16
+ 473= 9=63 ?=; >6@2; <=?3296@4;2=? ;=
5@=F6 ;16 <436 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 )6:=?9
@643=?4)76 9=A);
!
@4)1A
=
1A74554 23 4776C69 ;= )6
4;;63;=@ ;= ;16 2?DA63; 54?<14?4> 4;
I
6 143
296?;28269 ;16 51=;=3 =8 ;16 96<64369 43 56@
I3 ! 4?9
A@;16@ 16 143 49>2;;69 123 32C?4;A@6 2? ;16 35=;
54?<14?4>4 4;
I $
54?<14?4>4 4;
I $ ;14; ;16 5=72<6 ;==G 123 32C?4;A@6 ;=
;16 3429 54?<14?4>4 2?
6 143 965=369 @6C4@92?C 362HA@6
=F6@?>6?;
=352;47
A; ;16@6 23 4)3=7A;67: ?= 6F296?<6 8@=>
A7)4@C4
;14; 4?:
54?<14?4>43 E6@6 9@4E? 4?9 4?: 5@=56@;: E43 362H69 2?
- 28 -
123 5@636?<6 ): ;16 5=72<6 @6C4@92?C ;16 4776C69 2?<296?;
=E6F6@
296?;28269 ;16 ?2C1;:
;16 96<64369
A; ;16
43 )67=?C2?C ;=
6F296?<6 =8
23 ?=; 2?
4<<=@94?<6 E2;1 ;16 5@=36<A;2=? <436 4?9 16?<6
16 23
;@64;69 1=3;276 ): ;16 5@=36<A;2=?
!%
=E6F6@ A?7633 ;16@6 23 2?9656?96?; 6F296?<6
;= 5@=F6 ;16 4776C69 2?<296?; 6F6? 28 ;16 6F296?<6 =8
23 <=?3296@69 43 ;@A6 2? 5@==8 =8 ;16 2?DA63; 54?<14?4 4;
I
35=; 54?<14?4>4 4;
I $ 4?9 362HA@6 54?<14?4 4;
I
123 6F296?<6 23 2? ?= E4: 16758A7 ;= ;16 <436 =8
5@=36<A;2=? ;= 5@=F6 ;14; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 3A)B6<;69
;16 96<64369 ;= 277-;@64;>6?; 4?9 ;16@6): <4A369 964;1 =8
;16 96<64369
!'
$
>;
4H24
6CA> 23 =?6 =8 ;16 4;;63;=@ ;=
;16 2?DA63; 54?<14?4>4 4;
96<64369
56@
;16
I
6F296?<6
16 23 <=A32? =8 ;16
=8
6I4>2?4;2=? ;16 5=72<6 ;==G 16@ 32C?4;A@6 ;=
$
2?
I
<12684; ;16
;2>6 =8 5=3; >=@;6> =8 ;16 9649 )=9: =8 ;16 96<64369
- 29 -
16 143 473= 296?;28269 ;16 51=;=3 4;
I3 ! 4?9
51=;=3 =8 ;16 9649 )=9: =8 ;16 96<64369
43 ;16
=E6F6@ 43
>6?;2=?69 16@62? 4)=F6 6F6? 28 ;16 9=<A>6?; 4;
I
<=?3296@69 43 5@=F69 E2;1 ;16 3A55=@; =8 ;16 6F296?<6 =8
$
;16 3429 9=<A>6?; 4?9 ;16 6F296?<6 =8
4?9
$ 9= ?=; 1675 ;16 5@=36<A;2=? ;= 5@=F6 ;16 4776C69
2?<296?; =8 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369
!"
=A3A8
14? 23 4? 2?9656?96?; E2;?633
E1= 143 965=369 ;14; 4; ;16 ;2>6 =8 >4@@24C6 =8 ;16
96<64369 4? 4>=A?; =8
3 + +++ 4?9
E6@6 4C@669 ;= )6 C2F6? ;= 4<<A369
8;6@
+ C@4>3 =8 C=79
=
2? ;16 >4@@24C6
;= ! >=?;13 =8 ;16 >4@@24C6 ;16 96<64369 E43
<=>2?C ;= ;16 1=A36 =8 16@ 54@6?;3
929 ?=; >66; ;16 96<64369
6F296?<6 =8
16 @676F4?; 5=@;2=? 2? ;16
2? <1268- 6I4>2?4;2=? 23 ;14;
$
%
$&'*+ $ =
$A
")
$: F
A; ;16@648;6@
)*+! ( $ 7
$%
!
Q
( $7
!
VS " 5
- 30 -
*+ (
"5
( 5f
$: F
+
A
$
/
: 0
! VS
b
$&'*!;
3 4@CA69 ): ;16 764@?69 <=A?367 8=@ ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 28 ;16 4)=F6 @686@@69 6F296?<6 =8
<1268-6I4>2?4;2=? 23 ;4G6? 2?;= <=?3296@4;2=?
2?
;16@6 23
4)3=7A;67: ?= >4;6@247 2? 123 6F296?<6 @6C4@92?C ;16
4776C69 277-;@64;>6?; ): ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;= ;16
96<64369
A@;16@ ;16
143 96?269 2? 123 6F296?<6 2?
<@=33 6I4>2?4;2=? ): ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;14; 16 C4F6
4?: 54@;2<A74@ 3;4;6>6?; ;= ;16 5=72<6
<=?;@492<;2=?
4?9 43 ;16@6 23
;16 3429 5=@;2=? 23 C=; >4@G69 4;
6?<6 ;16 6F296?<6 =8
I
E=A79 31=E ;14; 123 6F296?<6
23 ?=; 2? 4<<=@94?<6 E2;1 5@=36<A;2=? <436 4776C69 4C42?3;
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
"
??4??4
;= ;16 54?<14?4>4 4;
14? 23 4776C69 ;= )6 ;16 4;;63;=@
I
4?9 362HA@6 54?<14?4>4 4;
2?DA63; 54?<14?4> 4;
I $
23 6F296?<6 23 ;14; 48;6@
<=>2?C ;= G?=E =8 ;16 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369 16 E6?; ;=
- 31 -
;16 1=A36 =8 ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 =?
+
" +%
+ + 4; 4)=A;
++ 5 > 4?9 8=A?9 <2C4@6;;6 )A@? 2?BA@263 =? ;16 9649
)=9: =8 ;16 96<64369
16 35=; 54?<14?4>4 E43 9@4E? 4;
;14; ;2>6 4?9 ;16@648;6@
9=?6
=F;
;16 2?DA63; 54?<14?4>4 E43
16 5=72<6 362H69 ;16 ?2C1;: =8 ;16 96<64369 4;
=352;47 9A@2?C ;16 5=3; >=@;6> 6I4>2?4;2=?
=E6F6@ 43 >6?;2=?69 64@726@ E1276 923<A332?C
4)=A; ;16 6F296?<6 =8
;16 6F296?<6 =8
" 473= 9=63
?=; 1675 ;16 5@=36<A;2=? ;= 5@=F6 ;16 4776C69 2?<296?;
6F6? ;1=AC1 ;16 35=; 54?<14?4>4 4;
54?<14?4>4 4;
I
I $
362HA@6
4?9 2?DA63; 54?<14?4>4 4;
I
4@6 ;4G6? 2?;= <=?3296@4;2=? 43 5@=F69 ): ;16 6F296?<6 =8
"
=@6=F6@ ;16 6F296?<6 =8
" 23 ?=; 2? 4<<=@94?<6
E2;1 ;16 5@=36<A;2=? <436 4?9 16?<6
16 23 ;@64;69
54@;2477: 1=3;276 ): ;16 5@=36<A;2=? 4?9 16 23 3A)B6<;69 ;=
<@=33-6I4>2?4;2=? ): ;16 5@=36<A;2=?
E16@62? 16 143
296?;28269 ;16 51=;=3 4;
43 ;16 51=;=3 =8
I ! 4?9
;16 9649 )=9: =8 ;16 96<64369
I
- 32 -
!
@
4F2;@2 23 4776C69 ;= 14F6 <=?9A<;69
;16 5=3; >=@;6> 6I4>2?4;2=? =8 ;16 9649 )=9: =8 ;16
96<64369 4?9 316 233A69
6F296?<6
2?
<1268
@65=@; 43 56@
6I4>2?4;2=?
I
? ;16
965=369
@6C4@92?C ;16 2?BA@263 8=A?9 =? ;16 9649 )=9: =8 ;16
96<64369
16 2?BA@263 >6?;2=?69 2?
I
4@6 43 ;16
8=77=E2?C
?86<;69 )693=@63 =F6@ )=;1 C7A;<47
@6C2=?3 6I;6?92?C A5 ;= >69247 3296
=8 768; ;12C1 4?9 <478 >A3<763 764G2?C
=A; =886?32F6 923<14@C6
7<6@3 =F6@ ;16 9=@34> =8 768; 8==9
32;A4;69 4; 4 923;4?<6 =8
- $ <>
454@; ;E= 2? ?A>)6@ <2@<A74@ 4)=A;
$ <> 2? 9 924>6;6@ @42369 >4@C2?3
!
A7;2576 4)@432=?3 =F6@ ;16 @2C1;
1667 @2C1; G?66 @2C1; 8=@64@> 4?9
768; 8=@64@> @=A?9 2? 31456 )@=E?
<=7=A@ >643A@2?C
- $ <> 2?
924>6;6@ 64<1
77 ;16 4)=F6
>6?;2=?69 2?BA@263 4@6 4?;6>=@;6>
2? ?4;A@6
=E6F6@ 43 3A)>2;;69 ): ;16 764@?69 <=A?367
8=@ ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
;16
2? 16@ 6F296?<6 2?
<@=33-6I4>2?4;2=? 143 965=369 43 16@6A?96@
- 33 -
?U Y
$=O $ "#
"$?0
/ " UZ
$
: UZ0
Z
g628
"
"
$A
:G& UGF "
d ' "
R '
!(
$
$ I
A
(R
16$O
$
^
R ' A '
RU'
)*+! 1
$
; 23 473= ;16 6F296?<6 =8
' !
!;
2? 16@ <1268-
6I4>2?4;2=? ;14;
7TQL
L
)+
$204 +
N2
!
(
"
*+!;
$/ $ *
^
M
4+
)+ " =O
D
" =O
" =O
%
"
h
=2
&'
123 6F296?<6 =8 2?9656?96?; E2;?633 E=A79
<764@7: 31=E ;14; ;16@6 E6@6 ?= 2?BA@263 8=A?9 =? ;16 9649
)=9: =8 ;16 96<64369 E12<1 E6@6 4776C69 ;= 14F6 )66?
2?872<;69 9A6 ;= 4?: 4334A7; ): ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
A@;16@ 28 ;16 6F296?<6 =8
23 <=?3296@69 2; E=A79 )6
- 34 -
<764@ ;14; ;16 96<64369 >2C1; 14F6 9269 9A6 ;= 4<A;6
E64G?633 )6<4A36 =8 ;A)6@<A7=323 9236436
%
=@6=F6@ 4; ;123 3;4C6 2;3678 2; 23 @676F4?; ;=
@686@ ;= ;16 6F296?<6 =8 4<<A369
6I4>2?69 43
=
=
E1= 143 )66?
2? 3A55=@; =8 123 9686?<6
16 4<<A369
143 965=369 2? 123 6F296?<6 ;14; ;16 96<64369 E43
3A886@2?C 8@=> ;A)6@<A7=323 4?9 316 9269 =8 164@; 4;;4<G
9A6 ;= >6?;47 3;@633
A@;16@ ;16 54@6?;3 =8 ;16 96<64369
A369 ;= 14@433 14@433 12> 4?9 ;16 96<64369 96>4?92?C
;14; ;16: 31=A79 )6 5429 4>=A?; 64@?69 ): ;16 4<<A369
=
4?9 @6C4@92?C ;16 34>6
76C47 ?=;2<6 ;=
'
$
=
233A69
43 56@ I
A@;16@
E16? ;16 96<64369 E43 472F6
47=?C E2;1 ;16 4<<A369
I
;16 4<<A369
=
6I6<A;69 488294F2; 43 56@
16 8276 <=?323;2?C =8
9=<A>6?;3 @6C4@92?C ;16
;@64;>6?; C=; C2F6? ;= ;16 96<64369 ): ;16 4<<A369
23 5@=9A<69 43 56@
=
I
=
6?<6 ;16 6F296?<6 =8 4<<A369
<=A5769 E2;1 ;16 9=<A>6?;3 4; I3
! ;=
- 35 -
E=A79 <764@7: 31=E ;14; ;16@6 E43 ?= 14@433>6?; 4?9 277;@64;>6?; ): ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
? ;16 =;16@ 14?9 ;16
54@6?;3 =8 ;16 96<64369 E1= 4@6
4?9
A369 ;=
14@433 ;16 96<64369
"
3 923<A3369 16@62? 4)=F6 2; 23 <764@ 8@=> ;16
6F296?<6 =8
4?9
;14; ;16: 929 ?=; 366 ;162@
94AC1;6@ ;16 96<64369 8=@ 4)=A; " :64@3 48;6@ ! >=?;13
=8 ;16 >4@@24C6 =8 ;16 96<64369 E2;1 ;16 4<<A369
4?9
=
<764@7: 3;4;69 ;14; ;16: 929 ?=; G?=E
;14; ;16 96<64369 149 4?: <1279@6?
<764@7: 31=E ;14; ;16
;=
123 6F296?<6 E=A79
! E1= 4@6 54@6?;3 4?9
)@=;16@ =8 ;16 96<64369 149 ?=; 366? ;16 96<64369 8=@
4)=A; " :64@3 64@726@ ;= 16@ 964;1
16@68=@6 ;16 6F296?<6
=8 ;1=36 E2;?63363 6356<2477: ;16 6F296?<6 =8
4?9
@6C4@92?C ;16 277-;@64;>6?; 4?9 14@433>6?; ): ;16
4<<A369 ;= ;16 96<64369 4?9 473= ;16 <=>5742?; 4F6@>6?;3
E=A79 C= 31=E ;14;
E=A79 14F6 <=>6 A5 E2;1 84736
<=?;6?;2=?3 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
- 36 -
$+
166>4)42 23 ;16 ;16? E=>6? 5=72<6
3;4;2=? E1= ;==G
;= ;16 764@?69
92@6<;2=? =8 16@ 12C16@ =882<6@
;16?
=72<6
E4;<12?C
!% +
4C23;@4;6 43 56@ ;16
!
=>436G14@ 23 ;16
=?3;4)76 E1= E43 965A;69 =? ;16 9A;: =8
;16
)=9:
6 143
965=369
;14; =?
+ + 48;6@ ;16 5=3; >=@;6> 6I4>2?4;2=? =8 ;16
9649 )=9: 16 ;==G ;16 ?2C1;: =8 ;16 96<64369 C2F6? ;=
12> ): ;16 9=<;=@ 4?9 5@=9A<69 ;16 34>6 )68=@6 ;16
16 ?2C1;: 23 5@=9A<69 4;
$
47)66 23 ;16 ;16?
=8 ;16 <=>5742?4?;
5=72<6 3;4;2=?
3 56@ 16@ 6F296?<6
=?
4)=A; +$ ++
E16? 316 E43 2? ;16 5=72<6 3;4;2=? ;16
<=>5742?4?;
<4>6 ;= ;16 5=72<6 3;4;2=? 4?9 C4F6 =@47
<=>5742?; 43 56@
I
+ + 4;
6 @6C23;6@69 ;16 <436 =? ;16
3429 <=>5742?; 4?9 3A)>2;;69
2? ;16 6F296?<6 =8
" +%
43 56@
I
=E6F6@
4?9 473= 2? ;16 6F296?<6 =8
2; 23 <764@ ;14; ;16 32C?4;A@6 =@ ;1A>) 2>5@6332=? =8
?=; 8=@;1<=>2?C 2? ;16 <=>5742?; 4; I
- 37 -
$
2? 16@ 6F296?<6 2? <@=33 6I4>2?4;2=?
143 49>2;;69
;14;
2>5@6332=? =8
2?
;16@6
23 ?= 32C?4;A@6 =@
I
;1A>)
16 143 473= 965=369 2? 16@
6F296?<6 2? <@=33 6I4>2?4;2=? ;14; ;16 4<<A369
=
?=; 3;4;6 )68=@6 16@ ;14; ;16 9649 )=9: =8 ;16 96<64369
E43 2?
434F631E4@4
=352;47
;14; 2? ;16 <=>5742?; 4;
I
; 23 473= 965=369 ):
;16 <=>5742?4?;
?=; 3;4;69 ;14; E16? 316 E6?; ;= ;16 1=A36 =8 ;16 4<<A369
56@3=?3
;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 E6?; =A; =8 1=A36
143 965=369 ;14; 316 <4>6 ;= G?=E ;14; ;16
96<64369 149 ;A)6@<A7=323
$!
$
4H66@
1>69 23 ;16 ;16?
<=>5742?4?; 5=72<6 3;4;2=?
=8 ;16
23 6F296?<6 23 @6C4@92?C ;16
2?F63;2C4;2=? 9=?6 2? ;16 <436 4?9 8272?C =8 ;16 <14@C6
4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?
@6<62F69 ):
; 23 ;@A6 ;14;
$ 4?9 34>6 23 5@=9A<69 4;
@65=@; E43
I
$
82?47 =52?2=? =8 ;16 9=<;=@ @6C4@92?C 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369
23 5@=9A<69 43 56@
I
!
=@6=F6@ 43 5=2?;69 =A; ):
;16 764@?69 <=A?367 8=@ ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 ;16 @676F4?;
- 38 -
5=@;2=? 2? ;16 6F296?<6 2? <@=33-6I4>2?4;2=? =8
$
@6493 ;1A3
$
"*
78 ^2
*+ 1
78 ^2
!
&
$%
$
$%
%
( $7
A*
?@
)+
*+!
78 ^2
-
" RH
("C G
)+
78 ^2
Q
$JO*+!
$
( $7
78 ^2
$ =
$
*+!;
$
; 23 473= ;16 6F296?<6 =8
$ ;14; ;16
C4F6 3;4;6>6?; )68=@6 12> 43 56@
I
C4F6 3;4;6>6?; )68=@6 12> 43 56@
I
@676F4?; 5=@;2=? 2? ;16 6F296?<6 =8
$ 23 ;14;
i
"
J5
!h (
F4
'1
%2
=@6=F6@ ;16
$ 'A 1
(
% &'
:j&N iR^ A ' 1
(: I
4?9 ;16
$
!
-
! ( $7
$%
"
h
$ f $ :\
- 39 -
U
"
"
h $ f $ :\
$$
!h 78 ^2
U
123 6F296?<6 =8
"
h!;
$ E=A79 <764@7: 31=E ;14;
;16 96<64369 E=A79 14F6 9269 =8 ;A)6@<A7=323 9236436 9A6
;= E64G?633
16@68=@6 8@=> ;16 6F296?<6 =8 5@=36<A;2=?
E2;?63363 =? @6<=@9
;16 <436 =8 5@=36<A;2=? ;14; ;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 3A)B6<;69 ;16 96<64369 ;= 4?: 51:32<47
<@A67;: 4?9 ;16@6): <4A369 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369 23 ?=;
5@=F69
$
3 E6 923<A3369 16@62? 4)=F6
;16 <436 E43
@6C23;6@69 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=? =? ;16 <=>5742?; =8
;16 >=;16@ =8 ;16 96<64369
>4@G69 4;
I
=@6=F6@
16 <=>5742?; 23
16 3429 <=>5742?; 23 ?=; 32C?69 ):
;16 4776C4;2=?3 >496 2? ;16 <=>5742?;
@6C4@92?C ;16 4776C69 14@433>6?; ): ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?
;= ;16 96<64369 4@6 ?=; 5@=F69 ): ;16 5@=36<A;2=? E2;1
;16 3A55=@; =8 4?: 2?9656?96?; <=@@=)=@4;2F6 6F296?<6
- 40 -
$%
A@;16@ ;16 82?47 @65=@; =8 ;16 9=<;=@ @6C4@92?C
;16 =52?2=? =8 964;1 43 56@
I
! E=A79 31=E ;14; ;16
<4A36 =8 964;1 =8 ;16 96<64369 23
@63A7;
=8
2?86<;69
9682<26?<:
)69
3=@63
65;2<47>2< 31=<G 43 4
4?9
36F6@6
3 923<A3369 16@62? 4)=F6
?A;@2;2=?47
;16 6F296?<6 =?
@6<=@9 E=A79 31=E ;14; ;16 96<64369 E43 3A886@2?C 8@=>
;A)6@<A7=323
$'
;16
9=<;=@
>=@;6> =8 ;16 9649 )=9:
E1=
<=?9A<;69
5=3;
16 143 965=369 2? 16@
6F296?<6 ;14; ;16 )69 3=@63 >2C1; )6 ;16 @63A7; =8
5@=7=?C69 )69@2996? =8 ;16 96<64369
A@;16@ ;16 4<<A369
56@3=?3 2? 3A55=@; =8 ;162@ 9686?<6 14F6 5@=9A<69 =?6
B=2?; 96<74@4;2=? 6I6<A;69 ): ;16 96<64369 4?9 4<<A369
=
=? " +!
++ 2 6 4; A?9235A;69 5=2?; =8 ;2>6
? ;16
3429 9=<A>6?; 2; 23 >6?;2=?69 ;14; ;16 >4@@24C6 =8 ;16
96<64369 4?9 ;16 4<<A369
=
;==G 574<6 $ :64@3 4C= 43
=? ;16 94;6 =8 6I6<A;2=? =8 ;16 3429 B=2?; 96<74@4;2=? 4?9
;16: 149
<1279@6? 4?9 32?<6 ;16 >4@@24C6 )=;1 =8 ;16>
149 )66? 72F2?C ;=C6;16@ 4;
A7)4@C4 4?9 ;16 54@6?;3 =8
- 41 -
;16 96<74@4?;
=
;16 96<64369 E6@6 2?;6@86@2?C 2? ;16
564<68A7 7286 =8 )=;1 ;16 96<74@4?;3 4?9 ;@:2?C ;= 3654@4;6
;16 96<74@4?;
=
;16 96<64369 8@=> ;16 4<<A369
4?9 123 84>27: 4?9 473= ;1@64;6?2?C ;16 4<<A369
92@6 <=?36DA6?<63
=
=
E2;1
16 3429 9=<A>6?; E43 6I6<A;69 4;
A?9235A;69 5=2?; =8 ;2>6 4?9 2; E=A79 <764@7: 31=E ;14;
4<;A477:
4?9
E1= 4@6 54@6?;3 =8 ;16 96<64369
E6@6 2?;6@86@2?C E2;1 ;16 564<68A7 7286 =8 ;16 4<<A369
=
4?9 ;16 96<64369
$"
I
; 23 473= >6?;2=?69 2? ;16 B=2?; 96<74@4;2=? 4;
$ ;14; ;16 2?;6?;2=? =8 ;16 54@6?;3 =8 ;16 96<64369
4?9 16@ )@=;16@3 E43 ?=; 842@ ;=E4@93 ;16 4<<A369
4?9 ;16 96<64369
=
; 23 ;@A6 ;14; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 14F6
?=; 6I4>2?69 4?: 2?9656?96?; 56@3=?3 2 6 ;16 E2;?633 ;=
;16 3429 B=2?; 96<74@4;2=? ;= 5@=F6 ;16 <=?;6?;3 =8 ;16 B=2?;
96<74@4;2=? 4;
I $
=E6F6@ 8@=> ;16 923<A332=? >496
16@62? 4)=F6 ;16 6F296?<6 =8 ;16 54@6?;3 4?9 )@=;16@ =8
;16 96<64369 =? @6<=@9 E=A79 31=E ;14; ;16: 149 ?=; 366?
;16 96<64369 48;6@ ! >=?;13 8@=> ;16 94;6 =8 16@
- 42 -
>4@@24C6 4?9 ;16: 473= 929 ?=; 366 ;16 <1279@6? =8 ;16
96<64369 9A@2?C ;16 7286;2>6 =8 ;16 96<64369
6?<6 ;16
=@47 4?9 9=<A>6?;4@: 6F296?<6 =? @6<=@9 23 DA2;6 <=?;@4@:
;= ;16 4776C4;2=?3 >496 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3 2? ;16
<436
+
=@6=F6@
43 1679 ): ;16 ;@247
2>5AC?69 BA9C>6?;
=A@; 2? ;16
;16 9=<A>6?;3 =? @6<=@9
E12<1
<4>6 2?;= 6I23;6?<6 2? ;16 <=A@36 =8 56@8=@>4?<6 =8 9A;:
=8 ;16 <=?<6@?69
692<47 =882<6@ E=A79 31=E ;14; ;16
96<64369 ;==G ;@64;>6?; 2? ;16 <=?<6@?69 1=352;473 8=@ ;16
427>6?; =8 ;A)6@<A7=323
):
;16
4<<A369 56@3=?3 23 2?
<=?;6?;2=?
;16 4<<A369
I
5@=9A<69
3A55=@; =8 ;16 3429
A@;16@ ;16 <=?;6?;2=? =8 ;16
;14; ;16: C4F6
4?9
3 $+ +++ 48;6@ ;16 >4@@24C6 =? 96>4?9 =8
=
23 ?=; 3A55=@;69 ): 4?: 2?9656?96?;
<=@@=)=@4;2F6 6F296?<6
6F296?<6
16 9=<A>6?; 4;
16 6F296?<6 =8
23 164@34:
6 143 ?=; 3A55=@;69 ;16 <436 =8 5@=36<A;2=?
;14; ;16 4<<A369
=
96>4?969 >=;=@<:<76 8@=> ;16
54@6?;3 =8 ;16 96<64369 43 9=E@:
- 43 -
A@;16@
2>5@=F69
;162@
3;4;6>6?;3
2? ;16 6F296?<6
F6@32=?
C2F6?
2?F63;2C4;2=?
)68=@6
;16
2?
;162@
5=72<6
16 6F296?<6 =8
4776C69
9A@2?C
6 143 ?=;
=A@; ;14; 16 34E ;16 54:>6?; =8
3 $+ +++ - ;= ;16 4<<A369
=
): ;16
54@6?;3 =8 ;16 96<64369 4?9 ;14; ;16 4<<A369
96>4?969
;16
+ E1= 23 3=? =8
23 473= 164@34: 6F296?<6
965=369 )68=@6 ;16 ;@247
4?: 4>=A?; =8
8=@;1
14F6
162@ 6F296?<6 23 ?=; 3A55=@;69 ): 4?:
2?9656?96?; E2;?633
;16 323;6@ =8
5A;
4?9
4?9
=
;= C2F6 >=;=@<:<76
=@6=F6@ ;=;472;: =8 ;16 6F296?<6 8=@;1<=>2?C
=? @6<=@9 E=A79 31=E ;14;
;=
+ 149 ?6F6@ 366? ;16 4<<A369
8=@ 4 7=?C ;2>6 2 3 8=@ 4)=A; " ;=
964;1
!
=
% 4?9
4?9 ;16 96<64369
+ :64@3 5@2=@ ;= 16@
6?<6 4?: 6F296?<6 =8 ;1=36 E2;?63363 @6C4@92?C
;16 4776C69 14@433>6?; 23 ?=; )6726F4)76
!
;@247
6;2<A7=A3 <=?3296@4;2=? =8 ;16 @643=?2?C =8 ;16
=A@; 2? ;16 2>5AC?69 BA9C>6?; E=A79 <764@ 31=E
- 44 -
;14;
;16
;@247
=A@;
<=?3296@69
;16
=@47
4?9
9=<A>6?;4@: 6F296?<6 8=@;1<=>2?C =? @6<=@9 2? 5@=56@
56@356<;2F6 4?9 ;16@6): <=@@6<;7: <=>6 ;= ;16 <=?<7A32=?
;14; ;16 5@=36<A;2=? 143 842769 ;= 5@=F6 )6:=?9 @643=?4)76
9=A); ;16 =886?<63 <14@C69 4C42?3; ;16 4<<A369 56@3=?3
16@68=@6 ;16 764@?69
143 842769 ;= >4G6 =A;
4?: C@=A?9 ;= 2?;6@86@6 E2;1 ;16 2>5AC?69 BA9C>6?; =8
;16 ;@247
=A@; 2? ;16 455647 4?9 ;16@6): ;= 36; 43296 ;16
2>5AC?69
BA9C>6?;
=?36DA6?;7:
E6
4@6
=8
;16
<=?3296@69 F26E ;14; ;16 2>5AC?69 BA9C>6?; 9=63 ?=; <477
8=@ 4?: 2?;6@86@6?<6 4; ;16 14?93 =8 ;123
5@636?;
455647
6?<6
;16
455647
=A@; 2? ;16
724)76
;=
)6
923>23369
? ;16 @63A7; E6 5@=<669 ;= 5433 ;16 8=77=E2?C
16 455647 23 16@6):
=?36DA6?;7: ;16 BA9C>6?; 4?9 =@96@ =8
4<DA2;;47 94;69
"+
+
=8 ;16 764@?69
- 45 -
23;@2<; (
6332=?3 *A9C6
=
+
31477 3;4?9 <=?82@>69
6?9 )4<G ;16 ;@247
+
474)A@4C2 2?
=A@; @6<=@93 47=?C
E2;1 <=5: =8 ;123 BA9C>6?; ;= ;16 ;@247
=A@;
8=@;1E2;1
.,
&
!
+
.,
&
23;
=
=
%
+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review