Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 4TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.100010 OF 2016
BETWEEN:
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA POLICE,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
BENCH AT DHARWAD, DHARWAD.
(LOKAYUKTA POLICE DHARWAD)
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI.ANIL KALE, Spl.PP)
AND:
SRI.LAXMAN S/O. IRAPPA PATTAR,
AGE: 42 YEARS,
OCC. VILLAGE ACCOUNTANT,
KAMALAPUR/MALAPUR VILLAGE, TQ. DHARWAD.
…RESPONDENT
Digitally signed
by
VIJAYALAKSHMI VIJAYALAKSHMI
M KANKUPPI
M KANKUPPI
Date: 2026.02.10
10:40:28 +0530
(BY SRI.MOHANKUMAR M., ADVOCATE FOR
SRI.SHANKAR HEGDE, ADVOCATE)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 378(1) & (3)
OF CR.P.C., PRAYING TO GRANT LEAVE TO APPEAL AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF ACQUITTAL PASSED BY THE III ADDL.
DISTRICT & SESSIONS & SPECIAL JUDGE FOR THE LOKAYUKTA AND
CBI CASES, AT DHARWAD DATED 29/7/2015 IN SPL.KLA C.C.
NO.6/2014, TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF ACQUITTAL
PASSED BY THE III ADDL. DISTRICT & SESSIONS & SPECIAL JUDGE
FOR LOKAYUKTA AND CBI CASES AT DHARWAD DATED 29/6/2015 IN
SPL.KLA C.C. NO.6/2014 AND TO CONVICT THE SENTENCE THE
RESPONDENT / ACCUSED PERSON FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE
UNDER SECTIONS 7, 13(1), (d) R/W. SECTION 13(2) OF PREVENTION
OF CORRUPTION ACT, 1988 AND ETC.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
ORAL JUDGMENT
1.
The impugned judgment dated 29.06.2015 passed
by the learned III Additional District and Sessions and Special
Judge for Lokayuktha and CBI cases at Dharwad, in Special
KLA C.C.No.6/2014, acquitting the accused of the offence
punishable under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2)
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, is assailed in this
appeal preferred by the State/Lokayukta Police.
2.
Heard
Sri.
Anil
Kale
learned
Special
Public
Prosecutor appearing for the appellant/Lokayukta and the
learned counsel Sri. Mohankumar M. appearing for Sri.
Shankar Hegde for the respondent/accused.
Perused the
evidence and material on record.
3.
Briefly stated, it is the case of prosecution that the
first informant’s father late Somashekar Hatarki, resident of
Dharwad had 3 brothers.
After the death of Somashekar,
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
there was a suit for partition filed between the complainant’s
mother against his 3 uncles for partitioning the landed
property bearing R.S. No.12 measuring 6 acres 34 guntas
situated at Malapur village. They were allotted 1/4th share
each in the landed property. On 19.03.2013, complainant's
mother Smt. Nirmala (PW.3) filed an application for entering
her name to the extent of 1/4th share in the aforesaid
property, as per the decree. The accused, who was working as
a Village Accountant, Malapur Village, Dharwad Taluk, did not
carry out the work, in spite of several requests made by
complainant's mother. On the other hand, he demanded bribe
of ₹5,000/-. Initially, a sum of ₹2,500/- was paid to him by
complainant's mother. She entrusted the work of getting the
entries
in
revenue
complainant/PW1.
records
When
the
to
her
complainant
son
i.e.
the
enquired
the
accused regarding the entry, he demanded the balance
amount of bribe. Hence, not willing to pay the bribe, he lodged
a
complaint
with
the
Lokayukta
Police,
Dharwad.
The
Lokayukta Police after preparing the Entrustment mahazar,
proceeded to the office of the accused along with the
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
complainant and panchas.
taking the bribe.
Accused was apprehended while
Trap Mahazar–Ex.P7 was drawn in the
presence of panchas.
4.
It is stated that, PW.2, working as FDC in Social
Welfare Office, was secured to act as a shadow witness. The
complainant and shadow witness along with the panchas and
other police officials went to the office of accused i.e. Chavadi
situated in the premises of the Tahsildar’s Office, Dharwad.
The complainant was instructed to give the bribe amount to
the accused only when it was demanded. The complainant and
the shadow witness went to the office of the accused. The
accused demanded and accepted a sum of ₹2,000/- towards
bribe from the complainant and at that point of time he was
apprehended by the Lokayukta officials. The tainted currencies
were recovered from the left side shirt pocket of the accused.
The statement of the accused was obtained from him, marked
as Ex.P.5. On completing the formalities and investigation,
charge sheet was filed against the accused.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
5.
Charges
were
framed
for
the
aforementioned
offences for which, the accused pleaded not guilty and claimed
to be tried.
6.
The prosecution in all examined 10 witnesses and
got marked 29 documents and M.Os.1 to 14. The defence of
the accused was total denial.
7.
In the course of trial, the complainant, who was
examined as PW.1 and his mother, who was examined as
PW.4, have completely turned hostile. Further, the prosecution
also treated PW.2, PW.3 and PW.8 as hostile and they were
cross-examined by the learned Special Public Prosecutor.
8.
The learned Sessions Judge framed the following
points for determination:
“Point No.1: Whether the prosecution proves beyond all
reasonable doubts that, on 14.5.2013 at about 5.55 PM
in his office (chavadi) situated in the premises of
Tahasildar office, Dharwad, the accused being a public
servant i.e. Village Accountant has demanded and
accepted a bribe of Rs.2000/- from complainant for
making division in survey No.12 measuring 6 acres 34
guntas of Malapur village and thereby he has
committed an offence punishable under Section 7 of
the Prevention of Corruption Act 1988 as alleged?
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
Point No.2: Whether the prosecution beyond all
reasonable doubts that, on 14.5.2013 at about 5.55 PM
in his office (chavadi) situated in the premises of
Tahasildar office, Dharwad, the accused being a public
servant i.e. Village Accountant has demanded and
accepted a bribe of Rs.2000/- from complainant as a
bribe other than the legal remuneration to effct a
division in survey No.12 measuring 6 acres 34 guntas
of Malapur village and thereby he has committed an
offence of criminal misconduct which is an offence
punishable under Section 13(1)(d) r/w. Sec. 13(2) of
Prevention of Corruption Act 1988 as alleged?
Point No.3: Whether the prosecution has made out
sufficient grounds to initiate proceedings against
P.Ws.1 to 4 and 8 as claimed U/s.340 Cr.P.C.?
Point No.4: What order?”
9.
Vide impugned judgment, the learned Sessions
Judge came to the conclusion that the prosecution has failed
to establish the guilt of the accused and accordingly acquitted
him.
10.
Village
According to prosecution, the accused working as a
Accountant
demanded
bribe
of
₹5,000/-
from
complainant's mother-PW.4 for entering her name to an
extent of 1/4th share in the revenue records. It is alleged,
initially, a bribe of ₹2,500/- was received by the accused and
in spite of several requests made by PW.4, he did not get the
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
work done and demanded the balance amount. Hence, a
complaint was lodged by her son-PW.1 with the Lokayukta
Police, who prepared the pre-trap Panchanama, after securing
the shadow witness and panch witnesses and proceeded to the
office of the accused, wherein while demanding and accepting
bribe, the accused was apprehended and the tainted currency
of ₹2,000/- was recovered from his possession.
11.
So far as initial payment of ₹2,500/- to the
accused is concerned, there is absolutely no evidence placed
on record. PW.1 being the complainant and PW.4, his mother,
have turned hostile to the prosecution case. PW.1 has deposed
that his uncle had requested him to appear before revenue
authority and therefore he met the accused and as per the
request of his uncle, he gave a sum of ₹2,000/- to the
accused to enter the names in the concerned records as per
partition. He has deposed that accused did not ask him for any
bribe and he has not even lodged any complaint against the
accused on his own.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
12.
In the cross-examination, he has denied the
suggestion put to him by the Special Public Prosecutor that the
accused demanded a bribe of ₹8,000/-, which is nobody's
case. He has pleaded his ignorance about the initial payment
of ₹2,500/- by his mother. Though, he stated that the accused
had demanded balance bribe of ₹2,500/-, at another breath,
he has stated that the accused has not demanded ₹2,500/- for
entering their names in the concerned records through phone.
He has also denied the fact of receiving the voice recorder
from the Lokayukta Police given to him with an instruction to
record the voice of the accused at the time of demanding the
bribe.
13.
Insofar as the complaint at Ex.P.1, PW.1 has
admitted his signature, however, he has stated that he does
not know the contents of Ex.P.1 and denied the suggestion
that, as per his say, the police got typed the complaint.
14.
The evidence of the complainant, examined as
PW.1, does not throw any light on the prosecution case to
prove that the accused has either demanded or accepted
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
bribe, to do an official favour. PW.4,
complainant's mother
has also denied the prosecution case in toto insofar as the
accused demanding any bribe to enter the names in the
concerned records. She has categorically stated that she has
not paid any bribe to the revenue official i.e. the Village
Accountant to enter their names in the concerned records. In
the cross-examination conducted by the Special PP, she has
denied the suggestion that the accused demanded a bribe of
₹5,000/- and she made initial payment of ₹2,500/- and then
the accused insisting her son to pay balance amount of
₹2,500/-. She has also denied that the accused received a
bribe of ₹2,000/- from her son.
15.
The learned Special Public Prosecutor appearing for
the appellant would vehemently contend that even though
PW.1 and PW.4 have not supported the case of prosecution,
the evidence of PW.2-shadow witness, PW.3-pancha and the
Investigation Officer-PW.10 as well as the evidence of PW.6
and PW.7 are sufficient to establish the charges levelled
against the accused. He contended that from their evidence,
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
the prosecution has proved the entrustment mahazar-Ex.P.4,
Trap mahazar-Ex.P.7 and identification of the voice sample.
He would further contend that the accused has given the
explanation as per Ex.P.5 and the learned Sessions Judge
without
properly
appreciating
the
said
evidence,
has
erroneously acquitted the accused.
16.
PW.2 is a shadow witness who accompanied the
complainant to the office of the accused. He has deposed
about accompanying the complainant to the Tahasildar’s
office. He has stated that the complainant contacted a person
sitting in the corner and thereafter both of them came outside
the chavadi and discussed and once again went inside the
chavadi. The complainant gave money to him i.e. the accused
present before the court, who counted the money and kept in
his left side pocket of his shirt. Thereafter, the complainant
came outside and gave signal and immediately the Lokayukta
staff came and caught hold of the hands of the accused. He
has further stated about the preparation of the sodium
carbonate solution and preparation of trap mahazar. He has
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
stated that the Sheristedar Vernekar has identified the voice
of accused in the duplicate CD.
17.
A careful perusal of the entire evidence of PW.2
goes to show that after he visited the Tahsildar's office, he did
not go inside the Chavadi. On the other hand, only the
complainant and accused went inside the Chavadi. He has not
stated that he too went inside the Chavadi. He has not stated
about what transpired or what was the discussion between the
accused and the complainant. He has stated that it was the
Lokayukta Police who removed the amount from the pocket of
the accused whereas the case of the prosecution is that it is
PW.2 who removed the tainted amount from the shirt pocket
of the accused. His evidence does not inspire the confidence of
the Court to hold that the accused demanded and accepted
the bribe from PW.1.
18.
The case of the defence is that accused collected
an amount of ₹2,000/- to deposit the same in the bank
towards the charges for effecting 4 shares. PW.1 has stated in
his evidence regarding the payment towards effecting the
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
partition in the land. The evidence of PW.2 is not helpful to the
prosecution to prove the charges of demand and acceptance
of bribe by accused.
The learned Sessions Judge having
carefully examined the evidence of PW.2 has come to the
conclusion that his evidence would indicate the fact of he
going with the complainant to Chavadi and his evidence is not
helpful to prove the demand and acceptance of bribe by the
accused. At the cost of repetition, his evidence would clearly
indicate that he stood outside the Chavadi and at that time
the complainant alone entered the office of the accused and
then came out. Hence, findings recorded by the trial Court to
discard the evidence of PW.2 is based on reasoning and does
not suffer from any infirmities or illegality.
19.
The prosecution has examined PW.3-panch witness
to the entrustment and trap mahazar.
His evidence is not
helpful to the prosecution in proving the demand and
acceptance of the bribe by the accused, which is sine qua non
to establish the charges. He has stated that he came to know
that the complainant met the accused and in turn the accused
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
demanded the amount from him and said fact was recorded in
the voice recorder produced by the complainant. He stated
that he got converted the voice recorder into CD. He has
further
stated
that
IO
gave
a
digital
camera
to
the
complainant. He stated that on enquiry with the complainant,
he told the IO that he paid the amount to the Village
Accountant i.e. the accused and then the Lokayukta Police
caught hold the hands of the accused.
20.
PW.3
has
admitted
in
the
cross-examination
conducted by the defence about accused giving statement as
per Ex.P.5 stating that a sum of ₹2,000/- was received as fees
and accordingly the accused issuing challan. A perusal of the
evidence of PW.7, would also show that challan was filled at
Ex.P.15(c) and (d), though he stated that there was no
necessity for depositing another ₹2,000/-. In the crossexamination conducted by the defence, he admitted that if in
case an amount of ₹2,000/- is deposited through challan, the
procedure will be correct and admitted the suggestion that as
challan is only for ₹1,000/-, an additional amount of ₹1,000/-
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
was yet to be paid and in case of depositing of excess amount,
it may not amount to an irregularity.
21.
PW8 has stated that the accused was working as
Village Accountant, Kamalapur-Malapur village and they used
to conduct their work in the Chavadi situated in front of
Tahasildar office and he was present in the Chavadi on
14.05.2013. He has only stated that he came to know about
the trap. His evidence is also not helpful to the prosecution to
establish the charges levelled against the accused.
22.
It is relevant to mention that the prosecution has
also placed reliance on Ex.P3, the Voice recorder. Ex.P6, the
Button camera script, MOs.4, 5, 11 and 12, the CDs of voice
recording collected during entrustment mahazar as well as
trap mahazar. Admittedly, none of the documents were duly
certified by the competent authority as contemplated under
Section 65(B) of the Evidence Act. The learned Sessions Judge
has observed that the prosecution has not made clear as to
who converted these scripts and whether the said person was
specially skilled person in that regard. As rightly observed, in
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
order to prove such evidence in the form of electronic
evidence, the prosecution has to establish the genuineness of
the CD and in that regard, a certificate under Section 65(B)
has to be obtained, as these electronic evidence are much
prone to tampering, imitating etc.
23.
As regards the point raised by the learned Sessions
Judge to initiate proceedings against P.W.1 to P.W.4 and
P.W.8 under Section 340 of Cr.P.C., as per the request of
prosecution,
the
following
reasons
are
assigned
in
judgment:
“38. Point No.3: Now, the question comes regarding
taking of action against the complainant, P.Ws.2 to 4 and
8 as requested by the Spl., Public Prosecutor through his
application u/s.340 of Cr.P.C. Under this application the
learned Spl., Public Prosecutor contends that, though
these witnesses have stated before the I.O. regarding the
incident but they have turned hostile to the prosecution.
Hence, he prayed for taking legal action against those
witnesses. In this connection, I have carefully perused the
alleged statements given by these witnesses before the
I.O. and evidence given by them before the court. So also
I have perused the pre-trap mahazar Ex.P.4 and trapmahazar Ex.P.7. As already noticed by me above, the
complainant is not the author of the complaint and it has
been typed and computerized by some other person. It is
not the case of the prosecution that, the complainant
knows the computer typing and it is the print out taken
the
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
out by him. It is true that, these witnesses have been
treated as hostile and the learned Spl., Public Prosecutor
was permitted to cross-examine these witnesses. Just
merely because of the reason that, the witnesses have
not given evidence as per the wish and will of the
prosecution, no action against them can be taken unless
and until it is shown that, those witnesses have
deliberately stated falsehood before the court. The
prosecution got marked the relevant portions of the
statement of P.Ws.1, 2 and 4 these markings themselves
are not sufficient to come to the conclusion that, the said
witnesses are giving a false evidence before the court.
Admittedly the above referred statements of witnesses
are before the Lokayukta Police and they do not bear the
signatures of above referred witnesses. Those statements
have been recorded by I.O. himself. If in case, the
documents were containing the signatures of these
witnesses the things could be different. No oath is
administered to those witnesses at the time of giving their
statements before the police. Admittedly the I.O. is an
interested person in prosecution and his evidence alone
neither is wholly reliable nor it is wholly unreliable.
Besides this, no where in his evidence the I.O. has stated
that, he has read over the statements of the witnesses to
them and after confirmation of the said witnesses he has
recorded such statements. Mechanically the I.O. has
stated in his evidence that, those witnesses have stated
before him as per statements. But, the said witnesses
have denied on oath before the court that they have not
at all stated as per the said exhibits before I.O. It is
pertinent to note that, all these witnesses have not turned
hostile to the full extent. It is interesting to note that, all
the above referred witnesses have supported the case of
the prosecution to the maj0or extent. Filing of complaint
by the complainant, preparation of pre-trap mahazar in
the presence of panchas, the proceedings taken place like
seizure of samples at MOs. taking of positive photos by
I.O. etc., have been stated by all the witnesses. These
witnesses have turned hostile only in respect of the fact of
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
giving and taking of bribe by the complainant to the
accused. Under these circumstances, it cannot be said
that, these witnesses are deliberately giving false
evidence before the court. If really the witnesses were
intended to give false evidence definitely they could have
given go-bye to the entire statements given before the
I.O. and they could have turned hostile to the full extent.
That has not been done by the witnesses in this case.
Therefore, the evidence of above referred witnesses
appears to be natural without tainted with any
malafideness. Therefore, the evidence given by these
witnesses cannot be termed as a false evidence that too
giving of false evidence deliberately by these witnesses
Though the prosecution has cross-examined these
witnesses at length nothing material worth is elicited from
their mouths so as to connect the accused with the crime
or regarding giving of false evidence by them.
39. In a similar situation in an unreported decision in
Bhupal Pundalikappa Totagi Vs. State of Karnataka by
Lokayukta Police, Belgaum in Crl., Petn.No.8495/2010
Dated: 16.9.2013 Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad bench has held as under.
5. In the above circumstances the question
would
be
whether
the
inconsistent
statements made in the court of the
evidence of the complainant vis-a-vis the
statements made in the complaint in the
first instance can be construed as tendering
false evidence and the answer is in the
negative. For the allegation in the complaint
would necessarily have to be tested by
tendering evidence in support of the
complainant. It is only then the complaint
takes
the
evidenciary
value.
If
the
complainant in the course of his evidence in
support of the complaint seeks to make
inconsistent statements, it cannot be
construed as false evidence for it is always
possible that, there can be inconsistencies in
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
the allegations made in the 1st instance and
the evidence tendered in the course of the
trial. If all such inconsistencies are taken as
false evidence, it would result in every
witness making inconsistent statements
being tried for furnishing false evidence.
Therefore,
the
degree
of
any
such
inconsistency will not make any difference
in applying the principle that if a witness
tenders inconsistent evidence with the
statement made elsewhere, it cannot be
construed as false evidence. On the other
hand, if the complainant had tendered
evidence in another case, which had been
found established and was left undisturbed
and if the same witness speak in relation to
the same facts and makes any contradictory
statement, it would then be straightaway
construed as tendering false evidence as
there is a statement recorded on oath which
is available and it can easily be saved that,
false evidence was tendered. This is not the
case in present case on hand. As the very
complaint was subject matter of trial and if
there were inconsistent statements, it could
only defeat the case of the prosecution and
it cannot be construed as false evidence
being tendered.
Consequently, the petition is allowed
and the direction to lodge a complaint
against the petitioner stands quashed.
Therefore, following the principles laid down by the
Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka, in the decisions referred
above, I hold that, prosecution has failed to make out a
case of perjury against these witnesses as contemplated
u/s.340 of Cr.P.C. and under chapter XI Indian Penal
Code. Hence with this observation, I answer Point No.3 in
the Negative.”
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1593
CRL.A No. 100010 of 2016
HC-KAR
24.
Having re-appreciated the evidence and material
on record and the impugned judgment passed by the trial
Court, this Court is of the considered view that the reasons
assigned are in accordance with law. This being an appeal
preferred against the judgment of acquittal, no compelling
reasons are made out to reverse the said judgment. Hence,
the following:
ORDER
The appeal is dismissed.
SD/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
Kmv upto para 17
RKM
CT:PA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review