Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 11TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.100144 OF 2016
BETWEEN
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
LOKAYUKTHA POLICE,
POLICE INSPECTOR,
KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA,
POLICE WING, BELAGAVI.
REPRESENTED BY
SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ANIL KALE, ADVOCATE)
AND
BALAKRISHNA S/O. NARAYAN BIRJE
AGE: 58 YEARS,
OCC: FDA IN APMC BELAGAVI,
R/O. 244/6, TAHASILDAR GALLI, BELAGAVI.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI M.H. PATIL, ADVOCATE)
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
Date: 2026.02.12
16:54:58 +0530
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED U/SEC. 378(1) AND (3) OF
CR.P.C., SEEKING TO GRANT LEAVE TO APPEAL AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF ACQUITTAL PASSED BY THE IVTH ADDL.
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS & SPECIAL JUDGE, AT BELGAVI, DATED
31/7/2015 IN SPL. C. NO. 43/2012 AND TO SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF ACQUITTAL PASSED BY THE IVTH ADDL.
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS & SPECIAL JUDGE, AT BELGAVI, DATED
31/07/2015 IN SPL. C. NO. 43/2012 AND TO CONVICT AND SENTENCE
THE
RESPONDENT/ACCUSED
PERSON
FOR
THE
OFFENCES
PUNISHABLE U/SEC. 7, 13(1), (d) R/W SEC. 13(2) OF PREVENTION OF
CORRUPTION ACT, 1988.
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR
JUDGMENT
ON
28.01.2026
AND
COMING
ON
FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN
AS UNDER:
-2CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA)
Appeal by the State challenging the Judgment of acquittal
recorded in Special Case No.43/2012 dated 31.07.2015 by the IV
Addl. District and Sessions Judge and Special Judge (PCA),
Belagavi.
2.
Facts of the case in brief which are utmost necessary for
disposal of the present appeal are as under:
A complaint came to be lodged with Lokayuktha police
contending that complainant is having a vegetable vending shop
in Anantshayana Galli, Belagavi, for last 10 years. Father of the
complainant is having a plot bearing No.18 in the APMC yard and
complainant wanted to construct a shop in the said plot. In that
regard,
an
application
was
filed
on
24.12.2007
seeking
permission for construction.
However due to financial constraint complainant could not
construct the shop immediately.
As such, on 11.11.2010 he
contacted the office of the APMC for obtaining necessary
permission.
3.
It is further contented that accused-respondent who was
working as a First Division Assistant in the APMC Office, did not
-3CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
respond properly on and from 16.09.2011.
Whenever the
complainant contacted the accused, he used to reply that he
would visit his shop and then decide about according permission.
4.
As such, at about 8.30 p.m. on 16.09.2011 the accused
visited the shop of the complainant. At that juncture, friend of
the
complainant
by
name
Abhijith
was
also
present.
Complainant requested the accused to accord permission.
5.
To get the permission sanctioned as per the application,
accused
said
to
have
demanded
Rs.35,000/-
as
illegal
gratification. The conversation was recorded by Abhijith on his
mobile telephone and the same was intimated to the Lokayukta
police.
6.
After receipt of the complaint, for the intended raid,
Lokayukta police secured two independent Government servants
as panchas and 35 currency notes of Rs.1,000/- denomination
and recorded the serial numbers of the said currency notes on a
separate paper. Phenolphthalein powder was smeared on those
currency notes and demonstrated the chemical reaction of
phenolphthalein powder with the sodium carbonate solution. An
experimental mahazar was drafted.
-4CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
7.
Complainant and shadow witness were told to go to the
office of the accused and on demand, to hand over the tainted
currency notes. The shadow witness was told to observe the
activities that could take place at the time of handing over the
tainted currency notes.
8.
Photographs of the experimental chemical reaction were
taken.
Thereafter, trap was conducted, trap mahazar was
drawn.
The accused was arrested and thereafter produced
before the Special Judge.
9.
On completion of the investigation, charge sheet came to
be filed.
10.
The presence of the accused was secured and charge was
framed. Accused did not plead guilty. Therefore, trial was held.
11.
In order to prove the case of the prosecution, ten
witnesses were examined and 43 material documents were
placed on record which were exhibited and marked as Exs.P-1 to
P-43.
Twelve material objects were placed on record as per
MOs-1 to 12.
-5CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
12.
Learned Special Judge, on conclusion of recording of
evidence of the prosecution witnesses, recorded the statement of
the accused as is contemplated under Section 313 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure.
Then, heard the arguments of the parties
and by the impugned judgment, acquitted the accused.
13.
The validity of the said judgment is called in question in
this appeal on following grounds:
•
“The
evidence
of
PW-9
Abhijit
Somnath
Bathkhande... has in the examination wherein he has
categorically stated about the demand made by
accused regarding payment of Rs.35000/- as illegal
gratification and it is further stated in the evidence of
PW-9 that Accused first demanded Rs.50000/- and on
request of complainant to reduce the same accused
had reduced to Rs.35000/-. And has recorded the
conversation of demand made by the accused in his
mobile bearing No.9242288683.
•
That the Court below has failed to appreciate
the evidence of PW1Dr:C.Somshekhar who is Director
of Agriculture Karnataka State Agricultural Produce
Marketing Department deposed that he has given
sanction Order as Per EXP-1, after verifying the
documents
sent
by
ADGP
Karnataka
Lokayukta
Bangalore on 12-2-2012. PW-2 who deposed about
visitng the spot as shown by PW4. And prepared Map
ExP-3.
-6CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
•
The court below ought to have seen that PW-4
shadow witness Chinmaya Prabhu Malgowda Patil.,
has stated about the filing of complaint before
Lokayukta Police.ExP-3.P.S.Crime No.20/2011, by the
complaint. Which was read before him, PW-4 has
further stated about the entrustment of 35 currency
notes of Rs. 1000-/ denominations, after applying the
phenolphthalein powder same were handed over to
the complainant, conducting of chemical test, under
Ex.P2. and also admits about the conversation in
phone recorded which was played in his presence and
the conversation therein disclosed the demand made
by the accused.
•
That with regard to trap that PW4 shadow
witness states that he along with PW8, went to
complainant's shop as told by accused on the phone,
accused arrived at the shop of the complainant,
demanded for bribe amount, as Complaint handed
over bribe amount, accused told within 8 days
sanction for construction will be given. As told earlier
complainant gave a pre-arranged signal to the
investigating officer who came along with his staff
and also another panch to the spot. Accordingly
tainted amount was recovered. same was seized with
Rs.35000/- and sealed. And identifies the bate
amount Rs.35,000/- which accused received -M.O.11.
and the money recovered was the same which were
entrusted to CW-1 under Ex. P-7.
-7CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
•
PW5 another punch witness Mr:Anant Suresh
Shinde.,
corroborated
with
PW4.
Regarding
entrustment of money under ExP-7, ExP17
•
CW1 compliant has expired during trail, his
father PW6 Shantaram Haribhahu Pawar., has stated
about allotment of Plot No.18 to him by APMC.
Depose about Order of High Court of Karnataka for
granting permission for construction.
•
That the Court below has failed to appreciate
the evidence of PW7, who is Secretary in APMC
Belgavi, who deposed about identifying the Photos
and Voice of the accused contained in CD.MO-12.
PW-8
supports
prosecution
who
deposed
about
identifying the Photos and Voice of the accused
contained in CD.MO-12. And stated that accused was
used to place in-charge of CW6 whenever he goes on
leave for more than 10 days or for training as per
order of the Secretary.
•
The accused did not dispute about the recovery
of money as per Exp11. gave written explanation as
under Exp 18. Which is denied by PW-4 and PW9.
•
The documents at Exhibit P-17 entrustment
panchaname,
Ex
P-29
i.e.,
trap
mahazar,
photographs ExP19-28 and the FSL report at Exhibit
P-42 would clearly prove the fact of demand and
acceptance.
-8CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
•
The official favour for demanding bribe is clearly
explained by the PW-9 as the accused told to pay the
bribe when he visits his shop, The said evidence
would prove the official favour sought to done.
•
The written explanation of accused ExP-11
would show that the amount recovered is an illegal
gratification received by the accused.
•
The
evidence
of
PW-4,
clearly
states
the
sequence of events in respect of demand, acceptance
and recovery of bribe from accused. The said
evidence is in consonance with the evidence of PW-5
which proves the guilt of accused punishable under
Section 13 of Prevention of Corruption Act.
•
That the Court below has erred in not taking
into consideration of the evidence of PW10 Sri:
Raghvendra B Havaldar, who is the Investigation
Office,
who
has
stated
the
Complainant
CW1
appeared before him on 19/9/2011 and told him
about the demand made by the accused and field
written complaint No.20/2011, EXP-34, heard the
phone recorded conversation recorded by PW-9, MO1, was entrusted to CW1 Recovery of MO-11 from the
accused after the trap under Mahazer ExP29.
•
The court below erred in not appreciating
presumption under Section 20 of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1998 and in the absence of accused
-9CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
rebutting the same court below was not justified in
passed the judgment and order of acquittal.”
14.
Sri Anil Kale, learned counsel for the Lokayukta would
contend that the reasoning recorded by the learned Special
Judge that accused was not the person who was required to
process the application of the complainant is incorrect as there
was an order of sanction granted to prosecute the accused by
the competent authority.
15.
He would further contend that the finding recorded by the
learned Special Judge that there was no work pending with the
accused as on the date of trap is incorrect, having regard to the
material evidence placed on record and therefore sought for
allowing the appeal.
16.
He would further contend that, admittedly father of the
complainant, namely, Shantaram Haribahu Pawar examined as
PW-6 held a shop in the APMC Yard, Belagavi, and his son i.e.,
the complainant was looking after the business of onion and
potato in the said shop.
He was the one who wanted to
construct the shop. Therefore, an application was given seeking
permission for construction.
But they could not construct the
- 10 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
shop immediately and therefore, again they approached the
accused in the year 2011.
17.
He
further
argued
that
on
16.09.2011,
when
the
complainant approached the accused, he told that he would visit
the shop.
18.
Sri Kale would further contend that on 16.09.2011 at about
08.30 p.m. accused visited the shop of the complainant wherein,
the complainant along with his friend were present and at that
juncture accused has demanded Rs.35,000/-. The complainant
was not willing to part away the said amount.
Therefore, all
ingredients required to attract offence for the offence punishable
under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988, have been established which has not been
properly appreciated by the learned Special Judge and therefore,
sought for allowing the appeal.
19.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent/ accused Sri
M.H.Patil, supports the impugned judgment by contending that in
the case on hand, the prosecution utterly failed to establish
necessary ingredients viz., demand, acceptance and the work of
the complainant that was pending with the accused. Therefore,
- 11 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
the impugned judgment needs to be sustained and sought for
dismissal of the appeal.
20.
In the light of the above rival contentions, following points
would arise for consideration:
(i)
Whether
the
prosecution
successfully
established all the ingredients to attract the offence
punishable under Section 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section
13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988?
(ii)
Whether the impugned judgment is suffering
from legal infirmity or perversity and thus calls for
interference?
(iii)
If the answer to point No.(i) is affirmative, what
is the sentence?
(iv)
21.
What Order?
REGARDING POINT Nos.(i) AND (ii): In the case on
hand, complainant died before the evidence could commence.
Therefore he is not examined as a witness.
22.
The shadow witness is examined as PW-4.
He deposed
before the Court in line with the pre-trap mahazar.
He has
deposed about complainant handing over Rs.35,000/- which was
sought to be given as illegal gratification comprising of 35
currency notes of Rs.1,000/- each and phenolphthalein powder
- 12 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
being smeared on it and the chemical reaction of phenolphthalein
powder with sodium carbonate solution.
23.
He would further depose that since the accused has
assured the complainant that he would come and collect the
illegal gratification in his shop, the entire raid team proceeded to
the Anantashayana Galli where the shop of the complainant was
situated.
24.
It is his further testimony that at about 07.40 p.m. on
19.09.2011 a person went inside the shop and sat on a chair.
Complainant and his friend Abhijith were conversing with the
said person.
It is his case that the accused demanded money
and assured the complainant that he would get the permission
within eight days.
25.
The complainant handed over the tainted currency to the
hands of the accused. Accused counted the same with his two
hands and kept it in his T-shirt pocket.
Complainant gave the
pre-designated signal and immediately head of the raid party
and his sub-staff along with co-pancha came to the spot and
recovered the tainted currency from the accused.
They
- 13 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
conducted the colour test in separate bowls which turned into
pink colour. Thereafter, arrested the accused.
26.
In his cross-examination, P.W.4 admitted that he worked
as a physical education teacher in Honaga Marathi School for
about 13 years. He has answered that there were no customers
in the shop when the accused was trapped.
He has further
answered that there was one more person in the shop.
But,
when himself and the complainant went inside the shop, that
person went away from the shop. He has further answered that
accused took the money in the right hand and kept in his pocket.
He has further answered that the writing of trap mahazar
commenced at 08.55 p.m. and was completed at 10.20 p.m.
27.
He has stated that he was standing outside the shop.
Remaining members of the raid party were standing at about 30
to 40 feet away from the shop.
28.
The sanctioning authority is examined as per P.W.1.
He
has stated that as per the request of the Investigation Officer, he
has issued the sanction order vide Ex.P-1.
- 14 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
29.
In his cross-examination, he admits that as per the order
of the High Court, construction of the shop should have taken
place within one year from the date of the Order.
But,
complainant had not constructed the shop as per the order of the
High Court.
He admits that as per the office order dated
21.07.2010, it is the accused who was required to handle the file
of the complainant.
30.
PW-2 is the Engineer from P.W.D., who prepared the spot
sketch as required by the Investigation Agency.
31.
PW-3 is the official of APMC, Belagavi.
He has deposed
that the application of the complainant was being handled by an
official by name Malagali. Whenever he was on leave, as an incharge officer, accused was required to handle the file.
32.
He admits that in Ex.P-5, it is mentioned that the accused
had already completed his portion of the work in respect of the
complainant’s application and had forwarded the same to
Secretary, APMC.
33.
In his cross-examination, he admits that he cannot
specifically say or reveal the date on which the accused has
- 15 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
worked as in-charge Officer.
He also admits that in Ex.P-5 at
page No.81, the office note does not contain the date on which
said note has been prepared.
He also admits that the final
decision to process the application is with the Secretary of the
APMC and not the accused.
34.
P.W.5 is the co-pancha who has supported the case of the
prosecution deposing in line with the experimental mahazar and
after
the
pre-designated
signal,
visiting
the
shop
of
the
complainant and tallying the serial numbers of the tainted
currency notes recovered from the T-shirt pocket of the accused
and subscribing his signature to the trap mahazar.
35.
PW-6 is the father of the complainant. He deposed that he
had possessed a plot in APMC yard and they wanted to construct
a shop in the said plot. In that regard, they had earlier applied
for
permission
but
construction
could
not
be
completed.
Therefore, again on 16.09.2011, an application was filed seeking
permission to construct the shop. It is his case that his business
was looked after by his son/complainant-Kiran.
In his cross-
examination, he admits that he does not know personally as to
how he has interacted with the accused.
- 16 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
36.
Remaining evidence on record is in the form of scientific
officer and that of the Investigation Officer.
37.
On cumulative consideration of the aforesaid evidence on
record, prosecution case is weakened to an extent that the
complainant was no more when the trial was commenced.
Therefore, demand and acceptance of illegal gratification is
sought to be established by the prosecution by examining the
shadow witness who has supported the case of the prosecution,
coupled with the contents of the trap mahazar and complaint
averments including the conversation recorded in the mobile
telephone of the friend of the complainant by name Abhijith.
38.
In the case on hand, colour test stood positive.
But the
material evidence placed on record would go to show that the
Officer by name Malagali was the person who was required to
handle the application of the complainant.
The material on
record also depicts that, earlier permission obtained by the
complainant was not utilized by completing the construction
within an year.
- 17 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
39.
As such, the complainant had sought for permission afresh
to construct the shop in the plot owned by his father in the APMC
Yard. The material on record, especially, the document marked
at Ex.P.5 would go to show that being the in-charge officer of
Malagali, accused has completed his work and has put up the
Note as required and placed the file before the Secretary, APMC
for further necessary action.
40.
The witness categorically admitted that the Secretary of
APMC is the proper person to pass suitable Orders on the
application of the complainant.
It is not the case of the
prosecution that for and on behalf of the Secretary, APMC, that
the
accused
had
demanded
illegal
gratification
from
the
complainant.
41.
Thus, on cumulative consideration of the material on
record, the prosecution though established its case that there is
handling of the tainted currency in the shop of the complainant
by the accused which has been noticed by the shadow witness
who was standing outside the shop, since the work of the
complainant was not pending with the accused as on the date of
- 18 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
handling of the tainted currency, learned Trial Judge recorded an
Order of acquittal.
42.
It is settled principles of law and requires no emphasis that
whenever a duly constituted Court records an Order of acquittal,
it reinforces the innocence of the accused as the accused is
presumed to be innocent.
43.
Likewise, it is yet another celebrated principles of criminal
jurisprudence that if two views are permissible on the same set
of facts, the view which favours the accused must be preferred.
44.
It is equally settled principles of law that prosecution has to
travel a long distance between ‘may be proved’ and ‘actual
proof’.
45.
Applying the above principles to the facts of the case, on
re-appreciation of the material on record, this Court does not
find compelling reasons to upset the finding of acquittal recorded
by the learned Special Judge, more so, having regard to the fact
that the work of the complainant was not pending with the
- 19 CRL.A No.100144 of 2016
accused,
so
as
to
demand
illegal
gratification
from
the
complainant.
46.
Accordingly, point Nos.(i) and (ii) are answered in the
negative.
47.
REGARDING POINT No.(iii):
Since the finding of this
Court on point No.(i) is in the negative, this point would not arise
for consideration.
48.
REGARDING POINT No.(iv):
In view of the finding of
this Court on point Nos.(i) to (iii) as above, the following:
ORDER
(i)
Appeal dismissed.
(ii)
Bail bond stands discharged.
Sd/(V.SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
kcm
CT-CMU
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review