Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
GOVT. APPEAL (DB) No.1 of 2025
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-23 Year-2021 Thana- SHASTRINAGAR District- Patna
======================================================
The State of Bihar through the District Magistrate, Patna
... ... Appellant
Versus
1.
Ritu Raj Son of Manoranjan Kumar Village- Adarsh Colony, Road No. 2,
Khemni Chak, Ps- Ram Krishna nagar, Dist- patna
2.
Jai Shankar @ Chhotu @ Pushkar son of Late Ram Prakash Dhari villageshankar Sita Sadan, House No. A/1, Bank Mens Colony, Chitragupt Nagar,
Kankarbagh, ps- Chitragupt Nagar, Dist- patna
3.
Saurabh Kumar son of Late Prashant Kumar village- 82.k Mahadeo market
Mini LIC Colony, Chitragupta Nagar, Kankarbagh Ps- Patrakarnagar, DistPatna
4.
Aryan Jaisawal son of Sri Krishna Jaiswal village- Ghanshulpur, PsSalimpur, Dist- patna
... ... Respondents
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Appellant
For the Respondents
:
:
Mr. Ajay Mishra, APP
Mr. Madhukar Anand, Advocate
Mr. Shubham Kumar Singh, Advocate
Mr. Amritanshu Udbhava, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR SINGH
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH KUMAR VERMA
ORAL JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR SINGH)
Date : 24-09-2026
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. The present memo of appeal has been preferred
against the judgment and order of acquittal dated 06.08.2024
passed in Sessions Trial Case No. 519 of 2021, arising out of
Shashtri Nagar P.S. Case No.21 of 2021 passed by the learned
Additional District & Sessions Judge-IX, Patna, whereby the
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
2/14
concerned Trial Court has acquitted all the respondents for the
offences punishable under Sections 302 & 120(B) of the Indian
Penal Code and Section 27 of the Arms Act.
3. Vide order dated 16.10.2025, trial court records were
called for, which were received on 25.11.2025.
4. The prosecution case, in brief, as per the fardbeyan of
the informant, is that when the informant was at his village, the
wife of his younger brother, namely, Nitu Singh informed that
when her husband, namely, Rupesh Singh (deceased) was
returning from duty from the air port to his house at Punaichak,
five to six persons at about 07:15 p.m, surrounded his vehicle and
fired indiscriminately due to which he got injured. Thereafter, with
the help of local and police personnel, the injured was taken to
Paras Hospital where the doctor declared him dead.
5. On the basis of the fardbeyan of the informant, Shastri
Nagar P.S. Case No.519 of 2021 was instituted under Sections 302
& 120(B) of the I.P.C. and Section 27 of the Arms Act and
investigation was taken up by the police. The police, after
investigation, submitted charge-sheet against the respondents and,
accordingly, cognizance was taken. Thereafter, the case was
committed to the Court of Sessions. Charges were framed against
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
3/14
the accused persons to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed
to be tried.
6. During the trial, the prosecution examined altogether
18 witnesses, i.e., PW-1 (Ritesh Ranjan Singh), PW-2 (Manish
Chandra), PW-3 (Manoj Kumar Rai), PW-4 (Ragini Devi), PW-5
(Nitu Singh), PW-6 (Dhirendra Yadav), PW-7 (Hare Ram Singh),
PW-8 (Md. Chand Parvej), PW-9 (Dr. Sidhyarth Ramanuj), PW-10
(Lokesh Shankar), PW-11 (Nandeshwar Singh), PW-12 (Das
Ashok Kumar), PW-13 (Vinay Prakash), PW-14 (Dilip Kumar),
PW-15 (Sanjeet Kumar), PW-16 (Dr. Achay Kumar Bagre), PW-17
(Harendra Prasad), PW-18 (Ram Shankar Singh-I.O.). The
prosecution has also produced certain documents which were
marked as Exhibits, i.e., Ext.1- Explanation, Ext.2-Signature of
Chand Parvej, Ramesh Prasad Singh, Ram Shankar Singh and
Manoj Kumar Rai on seizure list, Ext.3-Signature of Chand Parvej
on Report, Ext.4-Post Mortem Report, Ext.5-Signature of
Nandeshwar Singh on fardbeyan, Ext.6 & 6/1-Map and signature
on Vinay Prakash, Ext.7-Entire F.S.L Report No.389/21 dated
24.03.2021, Ext.8 & 8/1-Signature of Sanjeet Kumar and Reena
Kumari on Seizure List, Ext.9-Medical Legal Report dated
12.01.2021, Ext.10-Intimation Form dated 12.01.2021, Ext.11Inquest Report of Deceased, Ext.12-Supplementary Inquiry
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
4/14
Report, Ext.13-Signature of Ram Shankar Singh on fardbeyan,
Ext.14-Carbon copy of Inquest Report, Ext.15-Carbon copy of
Chalan of Dead Body of the deceased, Ext.16-Xerox copy of
Search and Seizure List dated 02.02.2021, Ext.17-Original Copy
of search and seizure list dated 12.01.2021, Ext.18-Photograph of
Search and seizure list dated 12.01.2021, Ext.19-Report of
Director F.S.L. Patna dated 25.03.2022 No.1672/21, Ext.20-F.S.L.
Report of Director F.S.L. Patna dated 24.08.2021 No.766/2021,
Ext.21-Letter
No.2431,
F.S.L.
Report
No.389/21
dated
30/09/2021, Ext.22-Letter No.3048, F.S.L Report No.389/21, dated
22.12.2021, Ext.23-Search and Seizure List dated 03.02.2021,
Ext.23/1-Seizure List of 12.01.2021, Ext.24-Certificate of Mobile
C.D.R Call dated 18.06.2021, Ext.25-Format of Forensix
Examination of Crime Scene of F.S.L Patna, Ext.26-Production
cum Seizure list of Shastri Nagar P.S. Case No.23/21. The
prosecution has further produced material documents which were
marked as Exhibits, i.e., Ext.I-Entire Album of C.C.T.V Footage,
Ext.II-HPUSB 2.0 pen drive 32 GB kept in Envelop, Ext.IIIHPUSB 3-1 pen drive 32 GB kept in Envelop, Ext.IV-CD 47 GB
kept in Envelop, Ext.V-Toshiba Hard Disc of Black Colour,
Ext.VI-USB Cable of Black Colour. After closure of prosecution
evidence, the statements of the accused persons were recorded
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
5/14
under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and after conclusion of trial, the learned
trial court has acquitted the accused persons.
7. Upon consideration of the prosecution case as a whole
and careful scrutiny of the evidence adduced during trial, the
learned Trial Court recorded the following findings while
acquitting the accused:
"(i) CCTV footage from Om Saudh Apartment did not
capture the actual occurrence. It neither showed the
firing nor clearly established the identity of the persons
involved and the vehicle numbers.
(ii) CCTV footage was not duly proved as the persons
who issued the Section 65-B certificates were not
examined. It further noted that no hash values were
obtained.
(iii) Learned Trial Court noticed apparent interpolation
in the fardbeyan, particularly regarding the vehicle
number and the word “police.” The officer who recorded
the fardbeyan was also not examined by the prosecution.
(iv) The prosecution failed to establish any definite
motive for the murder. The alleged road-rage incident,
business dispute and political angle were not proved by
the prosecution.
(v) The alleged confessional statements were made in
police custody, and no statements under Section 164
Cr.P.C. were recorded.
(vi) The prosecution failed to establish, beyond
reasonable doubt, the involvement of the accused in the
commission of the alleged offence."
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
6/14
8. Learned counsel for appellant, submits that the
learned Trial Court has failed to properly appreciate and analyze
the material available on record. It is submitted that, although there
is no eyewitness to the occurrence and the prosecution case rests
entirely on circumstantial evidence, the learned Trial Court has
failed to properly appreciate the circumstances brought on record
and to consider the complete chain of circumstantial evidence
connecting the accused persons with the occurrence. It is further
submitted that the learned Trial Court, without properly
appreciating the evidence on record, acquitted the accused persons,
and therefore, impugned judgment is not sustainable in law.
9. Learned counsel for respondents on the other hand,
submits that the prosecution has failed to establish the complete
chain of circumstances so as to connect the accused persons with
the commission of the alleged offence. It is submitted that the
material inconsistencies in the prosecution evidence create a
reasonable doubt regarding the involvement of the accused persons
in the present case and, therefore, the judgment of acquittal does
not warrant interference.
10. After hearing the arguments advanced by learned
counsel appearing for the parties and in the factual backdrop of the
present case, it is apparent that there is no eyewitness to the
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
7/14
alleged occurrence and the prosecution case rests entirely on
circumstantial evidence. The limited question that, therefore, arises
for consideration is whether the circumstances relied upon by the
prosecution, when considered as a whole, form a complete and
unbroken chain pointing towards the guilt of the accused persons
so as to warrant interference with the order of acquittal passed by
the learned Trial Court.
11. At the outset, it would be appropriate to take note of
the settled principles governing an appeal against acquittal. In such
an appeal, the appellate Court is required to examine whether the
findings recorded by the learned Trial Court are perverse or
otherwise unsustainable in law. Once the appellate Court finds that
the view taken by the learned Trial Court is a reasonable view on
the evidence available on record, the scope for interference
remains limited, particularly in view of the fact that the
presumption of innocence of the accused stands further
strengthened by an order of acquittal. In this regard, it would be
apposite to take note of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Ghurey Lal v. State of Uttar Pradesh, reported in (2008) 10
SCC 450, wherein, in paragraph 75, it was observed as under:
“The trial court has the advantage of watching the
demeanour of the witnesses who have given evidence,
therefore, the appellate court should be slow to interfere
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
8/14
with the decisions of the trial court. An acquittal by the
trial court should not be interfered with unless it is totally
perverse or wholly unsustainable.”
12. In the case of Muralidhar @ Gidda &Anr. v. State
of Karnataka, reported in (2014) 5 SCC 730 the Hon'ble Supreme
Court reiterated the said view in para no. 12 and observed as
under:
“12. ...in dealing with appeals against acquittal, the
appellate court must bear in mind the following:
(i) There is presumption of innocence in favour of an
Accused person and such presumption is strengthened by
the order of acquittal passed in his favour by the trial
court;
(ii) The Accused person is entitled to the benefit of
reasonable doubt when it deals with the merit of the
appeal against acquittal;
(iii) Though, the powers of the appellate court in
considering the appeals against acquittal are as
extensive as its powers in appeals against convictions but
the appellate court is generally loath in disturbing the
finding of fact recorded by the trial court. It is so because
the trial court had an advantage of seeing the demeanour
of the witnesses. If the trial court takes a reasonable view
of the facts of the case, interference by the appellate
court with the judgment of acquittal is not justified.
Unless, the conclusions reached by the trial court are
palpably wrong or based on erroneous view of the law or
if such conclusions are allowed to stand, they are likely
to result in grave injustice, the reluctance on the part of
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
9/14
the appellate court in interfering with such conclusions is
fully justified; and
(iv) Merely because the appellate court on reappreciation
and re-evaluation of the evidence is inclined to take a
different view, interference with the judgment of acquittal
is not justified if the view taken by the trial court is a
possible view. The evenly balanced views of the evidence
must not result in the interference by the appellate court
in the judgment of the trial court.”
13. In a case based on circumstantial evidence, the Court
is required to arrive at its conclusion by drawing appropriate
inferences
from
the
material
available
on
record.
The
circumstances relied upon by the prosecution must be firmly
established and considered cumulatively to determine whether
they form a complete and unbroken chain. The chain so formed
must be consistent with the guilt of the accused and inconsistent
with any reasonable hypothesis of his innocence. At this juncture,
it is important to take note of the settled principles with respect to
circumstantial evidence laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra,
reported in (1984) 4 SCC 116, which is as under:
"153. A close analysis of this decision would show that
the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case
against an accused can be said to be fully established:
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
10/14
(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt
is to be drawn should be fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the
circumstances concerned “must or should” and not
“may be” established. There is not only a grammatical
but a legal distinction between “may be proved” and
“must be or should be proved” as was held by this Court
in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra
[(1973) 2 SCC 793 : 1973 SCC (Cri) 1033 : 1973 Crl LJ
1783] where the observations were made: [SCC para 19,
p. 807: SCC (Cri) p. 1047]
“Certainly, it is a primary principle that the accused
must be and not merely may be guilty before a court can
convict and the mental distance between 'may be' and
'must be' is long and divides vague conjectures from sure
conclusions.”
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only with
the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say,
they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis
except that the accused is guilty,
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature
and tendency,
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except
the one to be proved, and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not
to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused and must
show that in all human probability the act must have
been done by the accused.”
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
11/14
14. Similarly, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Hanumant v. State of M.P., reported in (1952) 2 SCC 71, has
observed the following:
“12. It is well to remember that in cases where the
evidence is of a circumstantial nature, the circumstances
from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should
in the first instance be fully established, and all the facts
so established should be consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the accused. Again, the
circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and
tendency and they should be such as to exclude every
hypothesis but the one proposed to be proved. In other
words, there must be a chain of evidence so far complete
as not to leave any reasonable ground for a conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused and it must
be such as to show that within all human probability the
act must have been done by the accused....”
15. Upon perusal of the material available on record, it
is apparent that the prosecution has failed to establish any clear or
cogent motive on the part of the accused persons. The absence of
motive assumes significance where the prosecution case rests
primarily on circumstantial evidence, as motive constitutes an
important circumstance in assessing the chain of evidence. In this
regard, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Indrajit Das v. State of
Tripura, reported in (2023) 18 SCC 506, has observed the
following:
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
12/14
"16. In a case of circumstantial evidence, motive has an
important role to play. Motive may also have a role to
play even in a case of direct evidence but it carries much
greater importance in a case of circumstantial evidence
than a case of direct evidence. It is an important link in
the chain of circumstances."
16. Another aspect which casts doubt on the prosecution
case relates to the alleged recovery and forensic examination of the
weapons. The seizure list described Rituraj’s (one of the accused
persons) weapon as a “Made in USA” pistol, whereas the FSL
report described it as a country-made pistol. Likewise, the weapon
allegedly recovered from Saurabh (one of the accused persons)
was described in the seizure list as a “Made in Jai” revolver, while
the FSL report described it as “Made in Japan”. Further, although
the pistol and cartridges were directed to be sealed in two separate
boxes, the FSL received them in a single box, raising a doubt
regarding the integrity of the seized articles.
17. Another circumstance relates to the alleged recovery
of the “extra” bullet. The doctor reported on 10.03.2021 that a
bullet had fallen from the shirt of the deceased, although the dead
body had already been taken away from the hospital on
12.01.2021. It was also noticed that six bullets were handed over,
whereas only five were forwarded to the FSL. These
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
13/14
circumstances, coupled with the fact that certain bullets recovered
from the body did not match the alleged weapons, cast further
doubt on the prosecution case.
18. A further aspect requiring consideration in the
present case relates to the CCTV footage relied upon by the
prosecution. PW-3, PW-8 and PW-18 stated that the motorcycle
whose number was allegedly seen at various places in the CCTV
footage was not visible in the footage recorded by the CCTV
camera installed at Om Saudh Apartment. Further, the prosecution
did not examine the custodians of the CCTV footage. No hash
value of the CCTV footage was taken or placed on record so as to
establish the integrity and authenticity of the electronic evidence.
Thus, the CCTV evidence failed to establish the identity of the
assailants or connect the accused persons with the alleged
occurrence.
19.
In
light
of
the
aforesaid
discussion,
the
circumstances relied upon by the prosecution, when considered in
their entirety, do not form a complete and unbroken chain of
events pointing towards the guilt of the accused persons. The
absence of material evidence connecting the accused persons with
the alleged occurrence, leave gaps in the chain which cannot be
overlooked. The prosecution has, therefore, failed to establish its
Patna High Court G. APP. (DB) No.1 of 2025 dt.24-09-2026
14/14
case beyond reasonable doubt. The findings recorded by the
learned Trial Court, therefore, do not warrant interference.
Accordingly, the issue framed for consideration is answered in the
negative.
20. Accordingly, the present appeal is dismissed at the
admission stage itself.
21. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(Sudhir Singh, J.)
(Rajesh Kumar Verma, J.)
Gaurav Kumar/AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
N.A.F.R.
N.A.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review