Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010251022025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP(IO)/471/2025
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 2 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM,
DISPUR, GUWAHATI-781006
2: THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
KAMRUP (M)
HENGRABARI
GUWAHATI-781006
3: THE CIRCLE OFFICER
DISPUR REVENUE CIRCLE
BELTOLA CHARIALI
GUWAHATI-78102
VERSUS
GAUTAM BARUAH
S/O OF LATE ANIL KUMAR BARUAH, RESIDENT OF BOSABARI HOUSE,
K.K BARUAH ROAD, JORHAT-785001, AT B2, URVASHI APARTMENTS, UZAN
BAZAR, GUWAHATI-781001 AND AT SARUSAJAI GAON, MOUZA- BELTOLA,
GUWAHATI-781029, KAMRUP (M), ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. B K BHAGAWATI, MR B S DEKA
Advocate for the Respondent : MR S KHOUND, MS. S. SAIKIA,MS. N BORAH
Page No.# 2/9
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
21.02.2026
Heard Mr. B. K. Bhagawati, learned Counsel for the petitioners and Mr. S.
Khound, learned counsel for the respondent.
2.
Correctness or otherwise of the order, dated 18.07.2025, passed by the
learned District Judge, Kamrup (M) at Guwahati (Appellate Court, for short) in
Misc.(J) Case No. 83/2024, arising out of Title Appeal No.
30/2023, is
challenged in this petition, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, by the
three petitioners, i.e. (i) State of Assam (ii) The Deputy Commissioner
Kamrup(M), Guwahati and (iii) The Circle Officer, Dispur Revenue Circle.
3.
It is to be noted here that vide impugned order, dated 18.07.2025, the
learned District Judge, Kamrup (M) at Guwahatihad rejected the petition filed by
the petitioners under Order XXVI Rule 9 and 10 read with Section 107 and 151
CPC for appointment of a Commissioner to make local investigation of the
disputed property as regard the allegation against the District Administration
regarding wrongful demolition of boundary wall of the plaintiff/respondent.
4.
Mr. Bhagawati, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that the
respondent herein, as plaintiff, instituted a suit, being Title Suit
No.191/2015,
for
declaration,
damages/compensation,
permanent
injunction, mandatory injunction along with consequential reliefs and the
suit was decreed by the learned Civil Judge No. 2, Kamrup (M), Guwahati
(Trial Court, for short). Mr. Bhagawati further submits that in the said suit,
Page No.# 3/9
the defendants/petitioners could not file their written statement and
consequently, closed its evidence although they were allowed to crossexamine the witnesses of the respondent/plaintiff. Mr. Bhagawati also
submits that perusal of the Schedule-'C' of the suit land reveals that
Northern Boundary of the Schedule-'C' land, is the National Highway NH-37
and the respondent/plaintiff in Para-6 of the plaint averred
that on
28.10.2014, the officials of the District Administration demolished the
Northern Boundary Wall measuring about 123 feet.
4.1.Mr. Bhagawati also submits that thereafter, a Task Force comprising of
Commissioner GMC, Secretary GMDA, Project Director P.W.D. N.H. and
Superintendent of Police, was constituted by the then Principal Secretary to
the Chief Minister (Assam) and accordingly, to clear illegal structures and
other constructions including in the N.H-37 from Khanapara to Jalukbari
and upto LGBI Airport. He also submits that NH-37 was initially 4 Lane and
thereafter, it was upgraded to 6 Lane Highway and inspite of upgrading NH37 to 6 Lane Highway, the water logging problems continued to persist, for
want of proper drainage. The Task Force then carried out clearance work of
illegal structure andobstructions over the NH-37 and other roads and dug a
huge drain in the Northern Side of NH-37 from Khanapara to DeeporBill for
proper draining of rain water to avoid water logging in the National
Highway and for free flow of road traffic. Accordingly, the Task Force had
cleared the obstructions over the Northern Side of NH-37 and also dug the
huge drain over the National Highway land and there was no public outcry
as the same was done for public interest and within the land of National
Highway.
4.2.It is the further submission of Mr. Bhagawati that thereafter, the
Page No.# 4/9
respondent had instituted the aforesaid suit alleging damages caused to the
hisPatta land, only against three authorities i.e., the present appellants, and
therefore, the suit was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties, but the
Learned Trial Court failed to consider this vital aspect. He also submits that
the construction permission from National Highway Authority of India is
necessary, but the respondent/plaintiff did not file any document to show
that he took any permission from the said authority nor the plaintiff
impleaded the said authority as a party to the suit and even if any wall etc.
were pulled down, it was illegally constructed by the plaintiff over the land
of NH-37 and as per amended Rule 18(ii) of the Assam Land Revenue and
Regulation, the respondent/plaintiff is not entitled to get any compensation.
But despite that the learned Trial Court has decreed the suit. The
respondent/plaintiff in the Title Suit, had prayed for exercising the power
under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC to elucidate the matter in dispute including the
question of damages and compensation and the plaintiff duly prayed for
such local commission in Paragraph-16 of hisplaint. But the learned Trial
Court failed to consider such prayer.
4.3.Mr. Bhagawati also submits that against the said decree the petitioners
herein has preferred an appeal being Title Appeal No. 30/2023,and during
the pendency of the said appeal the petitioners had pray before the learned
appellate court to exercise the power of Order 26 Rule 9 CPC. But, vide
impugned order dated 18.07.2025, the learned appellate court had rejected
the petition and the order is being impugned in this revision petition.
According to him, the impugned order is illegal and arbitrary and it requires
interference of this Court. He submits that the respondent herein has not
Page No.# 5/9
impleaded some other necessary parties such as National Highway
Authority and that the wall is situated over the land of National Highway
Authority and to determine the same, appointment of Commission is very
much necessary and therefore, he contended to allow this petition.
4.4.Mr. Bhagawati has referred following decisions to bolster his
submission:(i) Shreepat vs. Rajendra Prasad &Ors., reported in
2006(6) Supreme 389;
(ii) Haryana Wakf Board vs. ShatiSarup&Ors, reported in
2008(8) SCC 671;
(iii) Rajaram Mali vs. SmtiSushmaShukla(Misc. Appeal
No. 1282 of 2025.
5.Per contra, Mr. Khound, learned counsel for the respondent has
vehemently opposed the petition. Mr. Khound, supporting the impugned
order of the learned appellate Court submits that the petitioners herein had
failed to file their written statement and though they were allowed to crossexamine the witnesses of the plaintiff,they could not setup their case by
filing written statement and also could not lead evidence in support of their
defence and during the trial they had failed to make any such plea before
the learned trial Court and now at the appellate stage they cannot be
allowed to fish out the evidence in the name of the Commission. Under
such circumstances, Mr. Khound has contended to dismiss this petition.
5.1. In support of his submission, Mr. Khound has referred following case
laws:(i) NityanandaChutia vs. SabirAzim Shah [Civil Revision
Petition (I/O) No. 54/2004];
Page No.# 6/9
(ii)
RajibBarooah vs. Purnimati Plantation
reported in (2018) 2 GLR 204;
(P)
Ltd.,
(iii) Pankaj Kumar Mahato vs. State of Assam and Ors.,
reported in 2018 (2) GLR 210;
(iv)
6.
Swastik Assam Real Estate (P) Ltd. &Anr. vs.
RatanRaha and Ors., reported in 2018 SCC OnLineGau
2350.
Having heard the submission of learned counsel for both the parties,
this Court has carefully gone through the petition and the documents
placed on record and also perused the impugned order, dated 18.07.2025,
and also gone through the decisions relied upon by learned counsel for
both the parties.
7.It appears that the learned appellate Court in the impugned order had
held that admittedly the appellants/ defendants have failed to adduce any
evidence in support of their claim that the wall stood on the national
highway or in the vicinity thereof which entitled them to demolish the same
without notice, therefore, there is nothing for the court to seek further
elucidation of the matter by resorting to Order 26 Rule 9 CPC when even
the basic evidence, whether oral or documentary, is missing. The learned
appellate Court had also observed that the defendant had failed to
discharge their onus to prove their case byadducing oral or documentary
evidence
and
in
such
a
situation,
the
court
cannot
assist
the
defendant/appellant in fishing out or unearthing evidence to support their
case. Thereafter, it went on to observe as held by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court that a Commissioner cannot be appointed to retrieve evidence when
the plaintiff himself has failed to adduce the basic evidence. Moreover, no
such application was made at the trial and it is at the belated stage of the
Page No.# 7/9
appeal when such recourse has been made and when the plaintiff has
already secured a decree in his favor and acceding to the prayer of the
appellantsat this stage would amount to permitting them to introduce
evidence in a indirect manner when they had failed to do so directly at the
time of the trial. Such back door entry of evidence cannot be permitted and
thereafter, it had rejected the petition.
8. The aforesaid finding of the learned appellate Court, when examined in
the light of the submissions, so advanced by counsel of both the parties
before this Court, and also in the light of the object of Order XXVI Rule 9
CPC, this Court finds no merit in the submission of Mr. Bhagawati, the
learned counsel for the petitioners.
9.The primary object of Order XXVI Rule 9 CPC is to elucidate disputed
matters through on-site examination, rather than to gather evidence for
any party.It empowers courts to appoint a Commissioner for local
investigations in civil suits.
9.1. There is no doubt that the appellate courts may allow an application
under Order XXVI Rule 9 CPC under strict conditions tied to Order XLI Rule
27 CPC. But, while the Appellate Court consider such a prayer, it has to
satisfy itself existence of following facts and circumstances in the case, and
should allow it in a routine manner:(i) In the event of elucidating a material issue by the Commission the
same will have a direct bearing on the outcome of the appeal.
(ii)
The material issue could not be made available despite due
diligence and reasonable effort during trial.
(iii) Refusal of appointment of such Commission will result in failure
Page No.# 8/9
of justice.
9.2.
In the case in hand, the petitioners had failed to file a written
statement, which leads to passing of a decree under Order VIII Rule 10
CPC. No evidence was lead during trial by the petitioners as no written
statement was filed. They had failed to setup their defence before the
learned Trial Court. That being so, there is no material issue, that could be
elucidated by appointing a Commission. They had not filed any application
before the learned Trial Court for appointment of such Commission. Nothing
is placed on record to demonstrate their due diligence; rather their conduct
demonstrated their lackadaisical attitude towards the case demolished.
Since no written statement was filed to raise a contention that the wall of
the respondent was situated over the land of National Highway Authority
not on the land of the respondent herein, so as to appoint a Commission to
elucidate the said issue, the contention of the petitioners cannot be
accepted. Under the given facts and circumstances, the petitioners cannot
be permitted to invoke the provisions of Order 26 Rule 9 of the Code of
Civil Procedure and call upon the Court to generate evidence for them.The
petition filed by the petitioners at best can be termed as "fishing
expeditions" or attempts to fill evidentiary gaps from trial lapses.
10.
Thus,having examined the impugned order passed by the learned
Court below and having heard learned Counsel for both the parties, this
Court does not find any perversity in the impugned order, requiring any
interference of this Court.
11. This Court has also carefully gone through the decisions referred by
Mr. Bhagawati, learned counsel for the petitioners and it appears that the
present case is factually distinguishable from those cases, as herein this
Page No.# 9/9
case, the petitioners had failed to file their written statement. Therefore,
the decisions so relied upon by Mr. Bhagawati, would not come into his
assistance. On the other hand this Court finds substance in the submission
of Mr. Khound, learned counsel for the respondent and the decisions
referred by him also advanced his argument and accordingly, the same is
accepted.
12.In the result, this Court finds no merit in this petition and accordingly,
the same stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review