Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/19
GAHC040000182026
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/1/2026
The State of AP and 4 Ors
represented by the Commissioner/ Secretary (PWD), Govt of Arunachal Pradesh,
Itanagar.
2: The Chief Engineer (WZ)
Age:
Occupation :
PWD
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3: The Superintending Engineer
Age:
Occupation :
PWD
Capital Circle
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
4: The Executive Engineer
Age:
Occupation :
Doimukh Division
PWD
Papum Pare District
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh.
5: The Assistant Engineer
Age:
Occupation :
Balijan Sub Division
PWD
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 2/19
VERSUS
M/s Bhimji Velji Sorathia Construction Pvt Ltd and Anr
Plot No.112-113, Arbuda Nagar, Opposite PITMANS, Tagor Road, Gujarat
represented by its Director, Shri Ramesh Bhimji Hadiya, resident of Plot No.112,
Arbuda Nagar Adipur, Kutch, Gujarat 370205
2:Tai Tajik
Age: 0
Occupation :
General Manager(Contract) Son of Late Tai Taa
PO and PS Sangram
Kurung Kumey District
Arunachal Pradesh authorized signatory of M/s Bhimji Velji Sorathia Construction
Pvt Ltd
Advocate for the Petitioner
: GA (AP), GA (AP)
Advocate for the Respondent : Gamken Bam,
Linked Case : WA/2/2026
The State of AP and 4 Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the Commissioner/ Secretary (PWD)
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
2: The Chief Engineer (WZ)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:PWD
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3: The Superintending Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:PWD
Capital Circle
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
Page No.# 3/19
4: The Executive Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Doimukh Division
PWD
Papum Pare District
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh.
5: The Assistant Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Balijan Sub Division
PWD
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
M/s Bhimji Velji Sorathia Construction Pvt Ltd and Anr
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Plot No.112-113
Arbuda Nagar
Opposite PITMANS
Tagor Road
Gujarat represented by its Director
Shri Ramesh Bhimji Hadiya
resident of Plot No.112
Arbuda Nagar Adipur
Kutch
Gujarat 370205
2:Tai Tajik
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:General Manager(Contract) Son of Late Tai Taa
PO and PS Sangram
Kurung Kumey District
Arunachal Pradesh authorized signatory of M/s Bhimji Velji Sorathia Construction Pvt
Ltd.
-----------Advocate for : GA (AP)
Advocate for : Gamken Bam appearing for M/s Bhimji Velji Sorathia Construction Pvt
Ltd and Anr: Advocate , appearing for 2, respectively.
Page No.# 4/19
BEFORE
HO'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE MITALI THAKURIA
Advocates for the Appellants
Advocates for the respondents
: Shri Mr. Subu Tapin, G.A., A.P.
: Shri A. Dasgupta, Sr. Advocate &
Shri S. Dutta, Advocate.
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 02.06.2026.
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 05.06.2026.
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment?
: NA
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
Judgment & Order
(S.K. Medhi, J.)
The present intra-court appeals have been preferred by the State of Arunachal
Pradesh against a common judgement and order dated 18.12.2025 passed by a
learned Single Judge of this Court in WP(C)/219/2025 and WP(C)/346/2025 whereby,
both the writ petitions filed by the same petitioner were allowed.
2.
As per the facts projected and deciphered from the materials in the writ
proceedings, the issue is with regard to a work of construction of 6 nos. of bridges.
There is, however a chequered history in the litigation. Initially, a work of construction
and widening of the National Highway from Itanagar to Jote Road was allowed to the
writ petitioner for which, an agreement was entered into on 10.11.2021. The work
was completed on 31.03.2024. However, after about 4 months from the completion,
the local MLA had issued a D.O. letter dated 24.07.2024 requesting for construction of
6 nos. of bridges over the said road. It was also requested that the work could be
Page No.# 5/19
done by the writ petitioner. Upon receipt of the said letter, the Public Works
Department (P.W.D) issued an intra-office letter on 31.07.2024 communicating the
proposal of the MLA and further communications were exchanged. The matter went
up to the level of the Chief Minister, who vide an endorsement dated 17.09.2024 had
given the approval. On 23.09.2024, on the subject of allotment of additional work of 6
nos. of bridges to the petitioner, the petitioner was directed to carry out sub-soil
investigation. It is the case of the petitioner that such communications would clearly
convey the intention to allot the work of construction of the 6 nos. of bridges to the
petitioner. Subsequently, the Assistant Engineer, P.W.D. had written to the petitioner a
letter dated 20.11.2024 directing them to dismantle the existing bridges which were in
dilapidated
condition.
The
Chief
Engineer,
P.W.D.,
however
had
issued
a
communication dated 21.01.2025 to the Executive Engineer bringing into notice the
unauthorised
construction.
Further
communication
was
issued
to
stop
any
unauthorised construction. The same was followed by a communication dated
29.03.2025 by the Executive Engineer to the petitioner whereby the petitioner
informed that while there would be no restriction for construction of the two bridges
at Dokoso Nallah and Gara Nallah which the petitioner was already constructing, the
remaining 4 nos. of bridges would be constructed by calling for tenders. It is the
aforesaid actions which are the subject matter of challenge in the two writ petitions.
To be specific, the petitioner had instituted WP(C)/346/2025 impugning two
communications dated 21.01.2025 and 21.02.2025 and thereafter WP(C)/219/2025
was filed challenging the communications dated 29.03.2025 and 24.04.2025.
3.
The learned Single Judge after hearing the parties was of the view that when
the approval of the Chief Minister was obtained for carrying out the works, the
impugned letter could not have been issued at the level of the Chief Engineer. It has
also been held that the same has to be done by a conscious decision of the competent
authority. Both the writ petitions were accordingly allowed vide the impugned
judgement and order dated 18.12.2015 which is the subject matter of challenge in the
Page No.# 6/19
present appeals.
4.
We have heard Shri Subu Tapin, learned Sr. Govt. Advocate, A.P. for the
appellants-State. We have also heard Shri A. Dasgupta, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Shri S. Dutta, learned counsel for the writ petitioner.
5.
Shri Tapin, learned Sr. Govt. Advocate, A.P. has submitted that the learned Single
Judge, while allowing the two aforesaid writ petitions had overlooked the aspect and
principles which govern the law relating to distribution of State largesse. He has
submitted that the earlier work was only for the construction and widening of the road
from Itanagar to Jote and the same was completed on 31.03.2024. He has highlighted
that after about four months from the said completion, the DO letter was issued by
the local MLA on 24.07.2024 to construct the 6 nos. of bridges over the said road and
to see if the same could be done by the writ petitioner. He has submitted that though
there were certain communications, those are only with the respect of completing the
formalities, including the aspect of soil testing, preparing the Detail Project Report,
(DPR), floating of tenders and thereafter allot the work to the suitable bidder in
accordance with law. He has submitted that the estimate involved in the present work
would be around ₹ 80 crores whereas, the earlier work for the road was about ₹ 60
crores and therefore, by no stretch of imagination, the work of construction of the 6
nos. of bridges can be treated to be an extension of the earlier work. He has
submitted that the office notes would clearly show that though the authorities, at the
initial stage had envisaged the same to be a consolidated project, due to certain
factors including finance, the construction and widening of the roads were decided to
be done first. He has submitted that so far as the preliminary work of dismantling the
existing bridges is concerned, the petitioner was engaged which, however would not
give any right to the petitioner to claim the work for construction of the new bridges
without calling for any tenders. He has submitted that under the General Financial
Rules of 2017, the principles governing allotment of works have been clearly laid
down. He has specifically referred to Rule 132 and 136 which are extracted
Page No.# 7/19
hereinbelow:
“Rule 132. Powers to sanction works. The powers delegated to various subordinate
authorities to accord administrative approval, sanction expenditure and reappropriate funds for works are regulated by the Delegation of Financial Powers
Rules, and other orders contained in the respective departmental regulations.
Rule 136. (1) No works shall be commenced or inability incurred in connection with
it until:
i) administrative approval has been obtained from the appropriate authority in
each case.
ii) sanction to incur expenditure has been obtained from the competent
authority.
iii) a properly detailed design has been sanctioned; while designing the projects
etc., principles of Life Cycle cost may also be considered.
iv) estimates containing the detailed specifications and quantities of various
items have been prepared on the basis of the Schedule of Rates maintained by
CPWD or other Public Works Organisations and sanctioned.
(v) funds to cover the charge during the year have been provided by competent
authority.
(vi) tenders invited and processed in accordance with rules.
(vii) a Work Order issued.
Rule 136 (2) On grounds of urgency or otherwise, if it becomes necessary to carry
out a work or incur a liability under circumstances when the provisions set out
under sub rule 1 of rule 136 cannot be complied with, the concerned executive
officer may do so on his own judgement and responsibility. Simultaneously, he
should initiate action to obtain approval from the competent authority and also to
intimate the concerned Accounts Officer.
Rule 136 (3) Any department of a project considered necessary while a work is in
progress, which is not contingent on the execution of work as first sanctioned,
shall have to be covered by a supplementary estimate.”
Page No.# 8/19
6.
He has submitted that the aforesaid General Financial Rules took into
consideration the guidelines laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Nagar Nigam, Meerut Vs. Al Faheem Meat Exports (P) Ltd. & Ors. , reported in
(2006) 13 SCC 382 and the aforesaid principles are extracted hereinbelow:
“13. This Court time and again has emphasised the need to maintain transparency
in grant of public contracts. Ordinarily, maintenance of transparency as also
compliance with Article 14 of the Constitution would inter alia be ensured by
holding public auction upon issuance of advertisement in the well-known
newspapers. That has not been done in this case. Although the Nagar Nigam had
advertised the contract, the High Court has directed that it should be given for 10
years to a particular party (Respondent 1). This was clearly illegal.
14. It is well settled that ordinarily the State or its instrumentalities should not give
contracts by private negotiation but by open public auction/tender after wide
publicity. In this case the contract has not only been given by way of private
negotiation, but the negotiation has been carried out by the High Court itself,
which is impermissible.
15. We have no doubt that in rare and exceptional cases, having regard to the
nature of the trade or largesse or for some other good reason, a contract may
have to be granted by private negotiation, but normally that should not be done as
it shakes the public confidence.
16. The law is well settled that contracts by the State, its corporations,
instrumentalities and agencies must be normally granted through public
auction/public tender by inviting tenders from eligible persons and the notification
of the public auction or inviting tenders should be advertised in well-known dailies
having wide circulation in the locality with all relevant details such as date, time
and place of auction, subject-matter of auction, technical specifications, estimated
cost, earnest money deposit, etc. The award of government contracts through
public auction/public tender is to ensure transparency in the public procurement,
to maximise economy and efficiency in government procurement, to promote
Page No.# 9/19
healthy competition among the tenderers, to provide for fair and equitable
treatment of all tenderers, and to eliminate irregularities, interference and corrupt
practices by the authorities concerned. This is required by Article 14 of the
Constitution. However, in rare and exceptional cases, for instance during natural
calamities and emergencies declared by the Government; where the procurement
is possible from a single source only; where the supplier or contractor has
exclusive rights in respect of the goods or services and no reasonable alternative
or substitute exists; where the auction was held on several dates but there were
no bidders or the bids offered were too low, etc., this normal rule may be departed
from and such contracts may be awarded through “private negotiations”. (See Ram
and Shyam Co. v. State of Haryana [(1985) 3 SCC 267: AIR 1985 SC 1147])
17. In Sachidanand Pandey v. State of W.B. [(1987) 2 SCC 295 : AIR 1987 SC
1109] , AIR at p. 1133, O. Chinnappa Reddy, J. after considering almost all the
decisions of the Court on the subject summarised the legal propositions in the
following terms:
‘40. On a consideration of the relevant cases cited at the Bar the following
propositions may be taken as well established: State-owned or public-owned
property is not to be dealt with at the absolute discretion of the
executive. Certain precepts and principles have to be observed. Public interest is
the paramount consideration. One of the methods of securing the public interest,
when it is considered necessary to dispose of a property, is to sell the property by
public auction or by inviting tenders. Though that is the ordinary rule, it is not an
invariable rule. There may be situations where there are compelling reasons
necessitating departure from the rule but then the reasons for the departure must
be rational and should not be suggestive of discrimination. Appearance of public
justice is as important as doing justice. Nothing should be done which gives
an appearance of bias, jobbery or nepotism.’
‘14. The public property owned by the State or by any instrumentality of
the State should be generally sold by public auction or by inviting
tenders. This Court has been insisting upon that rule, not only to get the
Page No.# 10/19
highest price for the property but also to ensure fairness in the activities
of the State and public authorities. They should undoubtedly act fairly. Their
actions should be legitimate. Their dealings should be aboveboard. Their
transactions should be without aversion or affection. Nothing should be suggestive
of discrimination. Nothing should be done by them which gives an impression of
bias, favouritism or nepotism. Ordinarily these factors would be absent if the
matter is brought to public auction or sale by tenders. That is why the court
repeatedly stated and reiterated that the State-owned properties are required to
be disposed of publicly. But that is not the only rule. As O. Chinnappa Reddy, J.
observed, ‘that though that is the ordinary rule, it is not an invariable rule’. There
may be situations necessitating departure from the rule, but then such instances
must be justified by compulsions and not by compromise. It must be justified by
compelling reasons and not by just convenience.’
18. The law is, thus, clear that ordinarily all contracts by the Government or by an
instrumentality of the State should be granted only by public auction or by inviting
tenders, after advertising the same in well-known newspapers having wide
circulation, so that all eligible persons will have an opportunity to bid in the bid
(sic auction), and there is total transparency. In our opinion this is an essential
requirement in a democracy, where the people are supreme, and all official acts
must be actuated by the public interest, and should inspire public confidence.”
7.
He has submitted that the requirement of law is to ensure transparency and
fairness in matters pertaining to distribution of state largesse and the present work for
construction of the 6 nos. of bridges is a major work which would involve huge
expenditure to the tune of more than ₹ 80 crores. He has submitted that the State had
filed detailed affidavit-in-opposition in which, all the aforesaid facts were brought on
record. However, unfortunately, the learned Single Judge did not even discuss or
address the stand of the State. He has submitted that the authority to decide is the
Cabinet Sub-Committee which cannot be replaced by the Chief Minister.
8.
The learned State Counsel has submitted that 11.03.2025 is a very crucial date
Page No.# 11/19
in which, the Finance Department, while giving the concurrence, has clearly laid down
that the works have to be done by means of tender which is mandatory. However, on
the said date, the Administrative Department had given the approval, and under
Clause 12, it has been stated that the work would be treated to be an extended
tender. The learned State Counsel has submitted that such approval by the
administrative department i.e., P.W.D. has mentioned that the same was done in
concurrence with the Finance Department’s approval dated 11.03.2025. He has
submitted that P.W.D. had clearly overlooked the remarks of the Finance Department
in paragraph 12 which reads as follows:
“12.
The
execution
of
works/schemes/projects
and
procurement
of
items/materials, furniture etc. should be done strictly as per the provisions of GFR,
DFPR , CPWD Manual etc. All the financial Rules and Regulations, the guidelines
and directives issued by Govt. of India, Ministry of Finance, GoI/ Administrative
Ministry of GoI,-CVC and Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh in this regard from time to
time should be followed in letter and spirit without fall. The process of
tendering and competitive bidding should mandatorily be followed and
complied with as envisaged in the GFR, DFPR, Financial Rules and Regulations and
the conditions guidelines, Circulars and directives issued/prescribed by Govt. of
India, CVC and Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh in this regard .”
9.
The learned State Counsel has submitted that when the aforesaid matter had
come to light on 21.03.2025, a corrigendum was issued whereby the administrative
approval
11.03.2025 which
was signed
on 18.03.2025
was
cancelled
and
subsequently, a sanction order was issued whereby there was a requirement of
tendering and competitive bidding. The same was followed by the communication
dated
29.03.2025
whereby
the
Administrative
Department,
by
taking
into
consideration that so far as two bridges are concerned, namely, Dokoso Nallah and
Gara Nallah, as the petitioner was already executing and sufficient progress was
made, the same would be continued to be done by the petitioner whereas, the
Page No.# 12/19
remaining four bridges would be done by tender process. He has submitted that no
wrong or fault can be attributed to the aforesaid decision and this aspect, was not
appreciated by the Hon’ble Single Judge. He submits that in view of the above, the
writ appeal is liable to be allowed and the impugned judgment dated 18.12.2025 is
liable to be interfered with and impugned communication dated 29.03.2025 be upheld.
10.
Per contra, Shri Dasgupta, learned Senior Counsel for the opposite party/ writ
petitioner has submitted that when the highest authority of the State, namely, the
Chief Minister had given the approval, that would mean the decision to allot the work
of construction of the 6 nos. of bridges to the writ petitioner had attained finality. He
has submitted that in the instant case, the Cabinet Sub-Committee which consisted of
3 persons where the Chief Minister was also holding the P.W.D. portfolio, the approval
of the Chief Minister has to be construed to be a decision of the Cabinet SubCommittee. He has submitted that the Administrative Department had clearly given
the approval on 11.03.2025 that the work has to be treated as an extended tender
and such approval was given after the concurrence of the Chief Minister who is the
highest executive. By drawing the attention of this Court to the CPWD Manual, the
learned Senior Counsel has submitted that under Clause 1.5, there is the aspect of
works of inescapable nature. He has submitted that the present work of construction
of the 6 nos. of bridges would fall under the aforesaid clause, as admittedly, the
bridges were in dilapidated condition requiring immediate replacement. He has
submitted that under the peculiar facts and circumstances, the Administrative
Department had taken a conscious decision to treat the aspect as extended tender.
The learned Senior Counsel has also drawn the attention of this Court to the Rules of
Executive Business and Rule 21 has been pressed into service. He has submitted that
for any change in the decision, Clause 17 of the Schedule is required to be followed.
He has submitted that proposal to vary or reverse a decision previously taken by the
Cabinet has to be done in accordance with the said Rules. He has also submitted that
the Chief Engineer, vide the communication data 25.03.2025 has accorded technical
Page No.# 13/19
sanction.
11.
The learned Senior Counsel has relied upon the decision of MRF Limited Vs.
Manohar Parikar & Ors., reported in (2010) 11 SCC 374 and has submitted that
under Article 298 of the Constitution of India, the aspect of Executive Powers have
been explained. He has submitted that Article 298 of the Constitution of India deals
with the Executive Powers. Reference has also been made to Article 154 of the
Constitution of India which is to be exercised by the Governor and Article 163 wherein,
the aspect of taking the aid and advice of the Council of Minister has been stated. He
has also referred to Article 166 in which, there are three parts with regard to the
conduct of business of the Government. He has submitted that to facilitate the
functioning of the Government and for exercising executive powers, Article 166 has
been framed. In this regard, the learned Senior Counsel has relied upon the case of
Samsher Singh Vs. State of Punjab , reported in AIR 1974 SC 219 which deals with
the powers of the Governor. He has also drawn the attention of this Court to the Rules
of Executive Business of the State and relied upon the definition of Council in Rule
2(f). He has submitted that Cabinet has been defined under Rule 2(b).
12.
The learned Senior Counsel has submitted that the original project was of an
amount of ₹ 153.97 crores. However, the bridge component had to be delinked as it
was not possible to go ahead in one go and therefore, the project was reduced to ₹
89.52 crores. He has submitted that on 19.09.2024, the competent authority had
given the approval and therefore, the impugned decision is unsustainable in law which
has been rightly interfered with by the learned Single Judge.
13.
The learned State Counsel in his rejoinder has submitted that the proposal was
placed before the Cabinet Sub-Committee and there was no approval as such that the
work has to be done by the petitioner. He has submitted that the approval by the
Administrative Department (P.W.D.) was given erroneously and by overlooking the
condition imposed by the Finance Department which are in the concurrence order
Page No.# 14/19
dated 11.03.2025. He has submitted that the corrigendum dated 21.03.2025 is only a
step for correcting an error which is apparent. He has submitted that an error cannot
give any indefeasible right to any individual, more so when such error is apparently in
violation of the settled principles of law.
14.
The rival submissions have been duly considered and the materials on records
have been carefully examined.
15.
From the pleadings exchanged and the arguments advanced, it clearly appears
that the State’s version which is on appeal is that there was an approval by the
Administrative Department for getting the works of 6 nos. bridges done by the writ
petitioner by considering the same as an extended tender and the said approval was
apparently given by ignoring/overlooking the concurrence of the Finance Depart dated
11.03.2025. On the other hand, the emphasis of the learned Senior Counsel for the
opposite party/ writ petitioner is that all necessary procedures were followed,
including the exercise of power through delegation and the approval by the highest
authority, namely, the Chief Minister. While considering the rival submissions, this
court cannot overlook the aspect that the work in question is a major one involving an
amount of more than ₹80 crores. It appears that due to certain communications, the
petitioner had presumed that the work of construction of the 6 nos. of bridges would
be allotted to it and accordingly started the execution of construction of 2 nos. of
bridges at Dokoso Nallah and Gara Nallah. We have also noted that some idea in the
direction can also be gathered from the communication dated 20.11.2024 issued by
the Assistant Engineer, P.W.D. whereby, the writ petitioner was directed to dismantle
the existing bridges.
16.
While the writ petitioner has emphasised the aspect of works being of
inescapable nature, we are of the view that the present work would not come within
the definition of work of “inescapable nature” which is, otherwise required to be
objectively assessed by a Certificate from the competent authority as laid down in
Page No.# 15/19
Clause 1.5 of the C.P.W.D. Manual. At this juncture, it would be necessary to refer to
the aforesaid clause which will clarify the entire issue:
“1.5. Works of Inescapable Nature
(1) Emergent works
Various
works
of
inescapable
nature
can
be
classified
as
under:
These are emergency works which arise all of sudden and are of inescapable
nature requiring immediate action that cannot brook any delay like:
(i) Natural calamities like Earthquakes, Blizzards, Hurricanes/ Lightening,
Tornados Tsunami waves, Floods.
(ii) Other causes like Explosions/Arson, Fire, War, Sudden collapse of
building/bridge Terrorist attack, Mass strike affecting civic services such as
water sewer and power supply, Spread of epidemic, works required for
maintaining law and order.
(iii) Restoration of essential services in case of accidents/ break down etc.
(iv) Ceremonial functions at the time of death of President/Ex President, Vice
President Ex Vice President and Prime Minister/Ex Prime Minister.
(v) Restoration of services in Parliament, President/ Vice President House/
Prime Minister House, Prime Minister's Office, Hyderabad House, National
Security Council Secretariat and other Buildings of National importance and
prestige.
(vi) Works ordered by OSD/PS to PM, OSD to Dy. PM and Vice President
Secretariat to be executed by CPWD within a specific time. frame
(vii) Works on a specific reference from the Secretariat to the President of
India.
(viii) Critical Hospital services works on the requisition from Medical Supdt. or
equivalent.
(ix) Works on the specific reference from Chief of Protocol, Min. of External
Affairs
or
on
his
behalf
for
Hyderabad
House,
New
Delhi.
Page No.# 16/19
(X) Any other work, apart from the above, declared as Emergent by the CE or
the next authority if there is no CE.
(xi) To ensure-, transparency and uniformity while declaring the works
emergent, the Competent Authority i.e. CE/ADG/SDG should record a certificate
that:
(a) The work has arisen all of sudden.
(b) The work is of inescapable nature requiring immediate action that
cannot brook any delay.
The Competent Authority while declaring any work as emergent may also
decide the mode of calling quotations i.e. whether spot or through e-tender
portal duly supported with reasons.
(xii) Details of works awarded on the basis of spot quotation should be
compiled by each circle/zone (SE/CE) on quarterly basis and submitted to
ADG/SDG.
The Engineer in Charge as per his competence shall proceed to carry out the
necessary work and shall immediately intimate PAO concerned that such liability
is being incurred with approximate amount of liability. The competent officer
should initiate action for the AA & E/S and accord of T/S (if applicable) to
regularize the liability.
Such emergent works can be executed without call of tenders by issuing work
order or on hand receipt after collecting spot quotations as per delegation of
powers given in "Financial Powers Delegated to CPWD Officers", Spot
quotations shall be collected by officers not below the level of AE/AEE.
(Normal works which require compressed schedule for completion/early start
should not be considered as Emergent works)
(2) Urgent Works:
(i) The urgent works need not to be treated at par with the works to be taken up
Page No.# 17/19
under emergency situations. These are works which require early start/completion
within compressed schedule and are to be taken up on topmost priority at the
instructions of competent authority or on specific request of the user department.
Under these situations availability of funds needs to be ensured before taking up
execution of such works Engineer-in-Charge shall be responsible for assessing the
urgency of the work. Normally, unless situation warrants otherwise, work orders
shall be placed after open call o quotations with publicity through web for works
upto Rs 5 lacs. Quotations for works with estimated cost more than Rs. 5 lacs shall
be invited through e-tendering platform. In case of exigencies, with recorded
reasons, the urgent work may be executed by collecting spot quotations as per
delegation in "Financial Powers Delegated to CPWD Officers". In case of Deposit
works, urgent works can be taken up on written request o1 the client.
(ii) Details of urgent works should be compiled by each circle/ zone (SE/ CE) on
quarterly basis and submitted to ADG/ SDG for review.”
17.
As noted above, only in very exceptional circumstances, works can be done on
the basis of spot quotation and the CPWD Manual itself makes it clear that to ensure
transparency and uniformity, the aspect has to be certified by a competent authority,
including the finding that the work is of inescapable nature requiring immediate action
that cannot brook any delay. Even then, there is a requirement to come to a
conclusion whether quotations can be called on the spot or through e-Tender Portal
which is to be supported by reasons.
18.
We are of the view that such riders have been attached only to ensure that
there is fairness and transparency. In the instant case, admittedly, there is no such
Certificate.
19.
We also find force in the contention advanced by the learned State Counsel that
for urgency clause, there has to be a collapse of a bridge. He has submitted the
preconditions which are laid down in Clause 1.5 of the CPWD Manual are missing. We
also find force in his contention that Clause 21 of the Rules of Executive Business will
Page No.# 18/19
not have any application.
20.
While the learned Single Judge has agreed with the proposition advanced by the
petitioner and had interfered with the impugned action, we are of the opinion that
main issue which is connected with the present case is whether the principle of law
relating to distribution of State largesse has been followed or not and this issue has
not been addressed or answered.
21.
While it is not in dispute that the petitioner had successfully executed the work
of construction and widening of the road from Itanagar to Jote, the present work of
construction of 6 nos. of bridges, though may be connected to the original work of the
road, cannot be said to be a part of the initial tender process and therefore, could not
have been given the status of an “extended tender”. Emphasis, all along by a catena
of judicial pronouncements is that transparency and fairness would have to be
maintained in all matters connected to distribution of State largesse. In fact, the
aspect of transparency and fairness are the hallmark of a robust democratic process
where equality before the law has to be maintained. We are of the opinion that when
the work is of such magnitude of more than ₹80 crores, allotting the said works to the
petitioner without a tender system would be against the very principles of the law
relating to distribution of State largesse. We have also noted that under peculiar facts
and circumstances, vide the impugned order, 2 out of the 6 nos. of bridges have been
kept outside the purview of the tendering process as the petitioner has, in the
meantime, executed and almost completed the same. We are of the view that the
administrative approval given by the P.W.D. by overlooking the conditions imposed by
the Finance Department requiring calling for tenders is not sustainable in law.
22.
At this stage, the learned Senior Counsel for writ petitioner has submitted that
even for the remaining 4 nos. of other works, sufficient progress has been done by the
writ petitioner. While this Court would not give a stamp of approval towards any such
works done, by balancing the equities, it is directed that if at all, any work has been
Page No.# 19/19
done by the writ petitioner, it would be entitled for the payment. We make it clear that
the construction of the remaining 4 nos. of bridges is to be done by floating of tenders
and strictly in accordance with law.
23.
Both the writ appeals accordingly stand allowed in the manner indicated above.
Consequently, the judgment and order dated 18.12.2025 passed in WP(C)/219/2025
and WP(C)/346/2025 is interfered with and set aside. The writ petitions stand
dismissed.
24.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review