Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010922032017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3558]
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE CHEEKATI MANAVENDRANATH ROY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
WRIT APPEAL NO: 77/2018
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent against the order
passed dated 21-08-2017
2017 in W.P. No. 14209/ 2011.
Between:
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP BY ITS PRL. SECRETARY,
REVENUE DEPARTM
DEPARTMENT,
ENT, SECRETARIAT, HYDERABAD.
2. THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
VISAKHAPATNAM.
VISAKHAPATNAM
DISTRICT,
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. BUDUMOORI SIMHACHALAM, OCC AGRICULTURAL COOLIE,
MALLAIAHPALEM
VILLAGE,
MADHURAWADA,
CHINGADILI
MANDAL, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
2. KOLLI
RAMA
MURTHY,
OCC
AGRICULTURAL
COOLIE
MALLAIAHPALEM
VILLAGE,
MADHURAWADA,
CHINGADILI
MANDAL, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
3. DODDI
GANGA
RAJU,
OCC
AGRICULTURAL
COOLIE
MALLAIAHPALEM
VILLAGE,
MADHURAWADA,
CHINGADILI
MANDAL, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
4. KOLLI RAMULU, OCC AGRICULTURAL COOLIE MALLAIAHPALEM
VILLAGE,
MADHURAWADA,
CHINGADILI
MANDAL,
VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
5. KUDITI
APPA
RAO,
OCC
AGRICULTURAL
COOLIE
MALLAIAHPALEM
VILLAGE,
MADHURAWADA,
CHINGADILI
MANDAL, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
6. ALLADI
LAXMAN
RAO,
OCC
AGRICULTURAL
COOLIE
MALLAIAHPALEM
VILLAGE,
MADHURAWADA,
CHINGADILI
MANDAL, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
7. SMT ALLADI RATHALU, OCC AGRICULTURAL COOLIE
MALLAIAHPALEM
VILLAGE,
MADHURAWADA,
CHINGADILI
MANDAL, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
8. PUKKARLA
MASAIN,
OCC
AGRICULTURAL
COOLIE
MALLAIAHPALEM
VILLAGE,
MADHURAWADA,
CHINGADILI
MANDAL, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
9. THE GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP BY ITS PRL.
SECRETARY,
MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION AND URBAN
DEVELOPMENT DEPT., SECRETARIAT, HYDERABAD.
10. THE VISAKHAPTANAM URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,
VISAKHAPATNAM, REP BY ITS VICE CHAIRMAN.
...RESPONDENT(S):
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
IA NO: 2 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the order dated 21.8.2017 in W.P.No.14209/2011, pending disposal
of the Writ Appeal
IA NO: 3 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
modify the order dt.23.01.2018 I.A.No.2/2018 W.A.No.77/2018 bi suspending
the order of the learned single Judge dated 21.8.2017 in
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
W.P.No.14209/2011,7pending disposal of the Writ Appeal to protect the
interests of the Government, pending disposal of the Writ Appeal and pass
IA NO: 4 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
receive the following additional Material papers for the effective determination
of the list between the parties:
1) Judgment and decree made in
0.S.No.3/2002 on the file of the Prl. Senior Civil Judge, Visakhapatnam ( in
regard to Sy.No.353/4 . which is claimed by the lst Petitioner). 2) Judgment
and decree made in O.S.No.4/2002 on the file of the Prl. Senior Civil Judge.
Visakhapatnam ( in regard to Sy.No.353/4 , which is claimed by the 2nd
Petitioner). 3) Cancellation File with regard to Sy.No.35011 which is claimed
by the 3rd 4) Affidavit filed by Boddapati Sriramacliandra Rao and others in
W.P.No.30847/2014 in regard to Sy.No.127/6 for which the 46 Petitioner is
claiming right. 5) Cancellation file with regard to Sy.No.127/ 17 claimed by 5th
Petitioner. 6) E.C. issued by Joint Sub-Registrar, Visakhapatnam in regard to
sale transactions in Sy.No.127/1 for which the 6`11 Petitioner is makino,
claim. 7) Cancellation File in regard to Sy.No.129/2 for which the 7th
Petitioner is making claim. 8) Copy of the order 10.8.1990 made in
W.P.No.2/1989 filed by 8th Petitioner in regard to Sy.No.332/P.
9)
Cancellation Files with regard to other Survey Number ie., Sy.Nos. 127/1. 10)
Acknowledgment issued by the Government Pleaders' Office in regard to
receipt of original files. 11) Proof of Service on the assignees. 12) Letter
written by the Tahsildar under RTI Act on 03.08.2016. And pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
may kindly consider the above facts which could not be mentioned
comprehensively during the previous submissions. Hence, kindly consider the
facts comprehensively submitted in the additional affidavit and vacate the
interim order dated 23.01.2018 in I.A.No.2 of 2018 in W.A.NO.77 of 2018 and
pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
grant Leave to the Respondent No. 10 to file the Counter Affidavit in
W.A.No.77 of 2018 and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
May be pleased to receive the Additional Affidavit on record in WA No.77 of
2018 and pass
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. GP FOR ASSIGNMENT (AP)
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. N ASHWANI KUMAR
2. Chinkapalli Srinivas
3. SOMISETTY GANESH BABU SC For VUDA and MUDA
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
The Court made the following:
JUDGMENT: (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice Cheekati Manavendranath Roy)
This intra Court appeal under Clause 15 of Letters Patent Act, is filed by
the State, challenging the order dated 21.08.2017 of the learned Single Judge
passed in writ petition No.14209 of 2011, whereby, the learned Single Judge
has allowed the writ petition and directed the respondents therein to pay the
compensation for the lands acquired, which are assigned to the writ
petitioners.
2.
Heard Ms. S.Pranathi, learned Special Government Pleader appearing
for the appellants-State and Mr. N.Ashwani Kumar, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents.
3.
The parties will be referred as they are arrayed in the writ petition, for
the sake of convenience, in this writ appeal.
4.
Facts of the appeal germane to adjudicate the lis involved in this writ
appeal may briefly be stated as follows:
In total there are eight writ petitioners, who have filed the writ petition
before the learned Single Judge. According to them, all of them were
assignees and as they are landless poor, the State Government has assigned
the lands in question to them long back in the year 1970 and delivered
possession of the said lands to them and granted D-pattas to all of them in
respect of the lands that were assigned to them. Therefore, they have been in
possession of the said lands assigned to them respectively since the year
1970. While so, the State Government has abruptly made an effort to
dispossess them from the lands that were assigned to them, in the year 2006
on the ground that the lands that were assigned to them were resumed to the
State on the pretext that they have violated the terms of the grant in not
bringing the land under cultivation. Therefore, they have invoked the writ
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of Constitution of India and they
sought the relief that is claimed in the writ petition.
5.
The then District Collector of Visakhapatnam District, filed a detailed
counter opposing the prayer of the writ petitioners. At the outset, it is
significant to note that the material fact that lands were assigned to the writ
petitioners was categorically and unequivocally admitted in the counter that
was filed by the District Collector. However, it is pleaded that the ground
verification report submitted by the Tahsildar revealed that the petitioners, who
are the assignees of the lands, are not in possession of the lands as on the
date of physical verification of the lands by the Tahsildar and that they did not
bring the lands into cultivation and thereby violated the conditions of the
assignment and as such, the lands were resumed to the Government, after
giving show cause notice to the assignees. It is further pleaded by the District
Collector that after the lands were resumed to the State Government that the
ownership of the said lands was transferred to the Visakhapatnam Urban
Development Authority (hereinafter referred to as ‘VUDA’).
6.
The Special Grade Deputy Collector and Estate Officer of VUDA also
filed counter stating that the subject lands were subsequently transferred by
the State Government to the VUDA and that the lands are now in their
possession.
7.
The Joint Director of Municipal Administration and Urban Development
Department also filed counter, asserting the same fact that the lands were
subsequently transferred by the State Government to the VUDA.
8.
It is also pleaded by the respondents in their counters that the
proceedings issued to the other owners of the lands acquired by the State
Government, allotting the land to them in an extent of 750 sq. yards as
compensation for the lands acquired, are not applicable to the writ petitioners.
Therefore, the respondents have denied that the writ petitioners are entitled to
any compensation for the lands which are acquired after resumption of the
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
said lands to the State Government or alternatively any plots as claimed by
them.
9.
The learned Single Judge, after hearing both the parties and
considering their submissions and after considering the pleadings in the writ
petition and also the counters filed by the respondents, has recorded a
categorical finding that the respondents have unequivocally admitted that the
subject lands were assigned to the writ petitioner Nos.1 to 8 and the details of
the assignment are also clearly furnished in a tabular form in the impugned
order of the learned Single Judge, as admitted by the District Collector in the
counter filed by him. Therefore, the learned Single Judge held that when the
material placed on record and the pleadings in the counter prove that the
subject lands were assigned to the writ petitioners in the year 1970, the
resumption of the lands subsequently in the year 2001 on the ground that the
lands are not brought under cultivation is not correct as the respondents did
not produce any evidence to substantiate the fact that the lands are not
brought into cultivation. Learned Single Judge also held that the respondents
did not produce any document to prove or show that the D-pattas issued in
favour of the writ petitioners in respect of the lands assigned are in fact
cancelled before resuming the lands. Learned Single Judge also held that the
record, showing that the lands were resumed by the State Government, is
also not produced before the Court to prove that the lands are resumed on the
ground that the assignees have violated the conditions of the grant. Therefore,
the learned Single Judge, taking into consideration the law laid down by the
erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh in the case of Vajja Shantamma and
others v. State of Andhra Pradesh and others1 and also the law laid down
by the larger Bench of the then High Court of Andhra Pradesh in the case of
Land Acquisition Officer-cum-R.D.O., Chevella Division, Hyderabad and
others v. Mekala Pandu and others(LB) 2 , held that when the State has
2012 (03) ALD 322
2004 (2) ALD 451
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
acquired the lands assigned to the assignees that the assignees are also
entitled to payment of compensation equivalent to the full market value of the
land and other benefits on par with the full owners of the land even in cases
where assigned lands are taken possession by the State in accordance with
the terms of grant or patta, though resumption is for public purpose. Having
held so, the learned Single Judge has allowed the writ petition and directed
the respondents in the writ petition to pay compensation equivalent to full
market value of the lands assigned to the petitioners on par with the full
owners of the lands under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency
in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, within a period
four months from date of receipt of copy of the order.
10.
After perusing the impugned order of the learned Single Judge, we
absolutely do not find any legal flaw or infirmity in the impugned order.
11.
Admittedly, the State did not produce the record showing the
cancellation of the D-pattas that are issued to the writ petitioners in respect of
the subject lands and they also did not produce the resumption proceedings
before the learned Single Judge in the writ petition, to substantiate their pleas
taken in the counters filed in the writ petition. However, the learned Special
Government Pleader has now filed I.A.No.4 of 2018 seeking permission to
produce additional documents in proof of resumption of the subject lands by
the State Government. We have gone through the said documents produced
now as additional documents in this writ appeal. They are only the show
cause notice said to have been issued to the assignees to resume the lands
on the ground that they did not bring the lands into cultivation. But, nothing is
produced before this Court in this appeal to show that the D-pattas that were
assigned to the writ petitioners in respect of the lands that are assigned are in
fact cancelled as a first step on the ground that the writ petitioners did not
bring the land into cultivation. In fact, when the State intends to resume the
lands of the assignees on the ground of violation of the conditions of the grant,
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
first they have to conduct an enquiry by issuing a show cause notice to them
as to why the D-pattas that were issued to them should not be cancelled on
the ground of not bringing the lands into cultivation. After conducting an
enquiry, then they have to first cancel the D-pattas and then they have to take
steps to resume the lands to the State Government and then take steps to
evict the assignees from the lands and take possession of the lands from the
assignees. In this case either before the learned Single Judge or before this
Court in this appeal, nothing is placed to prove that any enquiry was
conducted on the ground that the lands were not brought under cultivation by
the assignees and the terms of the grant are violated and that thereafter the
D-pattas issued to them were cancelled. Therefore, when the D-pattas that
were issued to the writ petitioners are not cancelled, even if any proceedings
are initiated to resume the lands, they are not valid under law as the
procedure prescribed under law is not followed for resuming the lands. As
noticed supra, the learned Single Judge has already recorded a finding in his
order that nothing is placed before the learned Single Judge to show that the
D-pattas are cancelled by the State Government.
12.
Though, now at the belated stage, the learned Special Government
Pleader has produced additional documents to show that the D-pattas were
cancelled and the lands were resumed, a perusal of the same show that there
is no separate order passed, cancelling the D-pattas. It shows that under the
same order both the D-pattas were cancelled and also the lands were
resumed. In fact, there should be two orders. First, cancelling the D-pattas
that were issued to the assignees and then passing an order of resumption.
Therefore, the order that is now placed is also not valid according to law.
Further, except producing a postal acknowledgement showing that the said
order was served on petitioner No.3, no evidence is produced to show that the
said order was communicated or personally served on the other petitioners.
Though, it is contended by the learned Special Government Pleader that the
order was communicated and served on all the writ petitioners, there is
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
absolutely no evidence on record even as per the additional material, which is
now produced, to prove that the said order was personally communicated or
served on the other writ petitioners. Therefore, when the order was not
communicated and served on the other writ petitioners, the said order cannot
be accepted as a valid order passed, cancelling the D-pattas and resuming
the lands.
13.
It is significant to note that the State Government has miserably failed to
produce the said record pertaining to cancellation of D-pattas and resumption
of the lands. To a pointed question, as to why the record and orders pertaining
to grant of D-pattas, cancellation of D-pattas on the ground of violating the
terms of grant and resuming the lands are not produced before the Court,
learned Special Government Pleader, on instruction, would submit that the
said record is now not available, as it is missing. The said explanation is
absolutely not acceptable. When, it is specifically contended and that too
vehemently in this appeal by the learned Special Government Pleader that the
D-pattas are cancelled and lands were resumed, they are expected to
produce the said record showing the cancellation of D-pattas and resumption
of the lands before the Court. Particularly, when the said fact is emphatically
denied by the writ petitioners, the said record is essential for the Court to
examine the truth of the matter relating to the cancellation of the D-pattas and
resumption of the lands to the State Government and also to examine whether
they are legally valid or not. Non-production of the said record relating to the
cancellation of D-pattas and the resumption of the lands is certainly fatal to the
case of the respondents and in fact adverse inference is to be drawn for nonproduction of the same and deliberately withholding the said record which a
vital piece of evidence required to adjudicate the lis in this appeal. By simply
contending that the said record is now not available and the same is
misplaced, the State Government cannot shun its responsibility to produce the
vital piece of evidence showing the material fact of cancellation of D-pattas in
fact and resumption of the lands to the State Government. The inference is
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
that if the said record is produced, real truth will be unfolded and it would
establish that the D-pattas were not in fact cancelled on the ground of violation
of terms and conditions of the grant and that the lands were not in fact
resumed, as per the procedure, according to law, on the ground of violation of
terms and conditions of grant.
14.
Further, another important fact that is to be noticed here is that when it
is specifically contended that the writ petitioners, who are the assignees, have
violated the terms and conditions by not bringing the lands into cultivation and
that the D-pattas are cancelled on that ground and that the lands were also
resumed on that ground, the burden is on the State Government to establish
the said material fact that the writ petitioners have not brought the lands under
cultivation and thereby violated the terms and conditions of grant. They did not
produce any evidence to show that the writ petitioners did not cultivate the
lands and bring the lands into cultivation, except filing a report of the
Tahsildar, relating to his ground verification that too which was made in the
year 2001. When the lands were assigned long back in the year 1970 and
when it is contended that they did not bring the lands under cultivation till the
year 2001, after a period of 21 years from the date of assignment, definitely
relevant evidence would be available with the State Government to show that
the lands were left as barren lands without cultivating the same and it was not
brought under cultivation. No evidence worth the name is produced to that
effect. The Court has specifically questioned as to why the cultivation
adangals relating to the assigned lands are not produced to show that the
lands were not brought under cultivation. The learned Special Government
Pleader again simply submits that the said cultivation accounts i.e., adangals
are also not available with the State Government. It is really beyond our
apprehension as to how the public record, maintained by the public servants
in discharge of their official duties is found missing or not available in the office
of the Revenue Department. Cultivation accounts which are the adangals will
be maintained by the concerned public servants, wherein, they will record as
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
to whether the lands were cultivated during the relevant fasli year or not and
what is the crop that was raised and if it is not cultivated whether it was left as
barren lands or not. The said cultivation account and adangals would bear
ample proof of the fact whether the lands were under cultivation or not. The
State Government is the custodian of the said record as they would maintain
the said record. It is a best piece of evidence to decide the said material fact
whether the lands are brought under cultivation or not. The said best piece of
evidence again is not produced before the Court and it was again suppressed
simply saying that the same is not available at present in the office. It is not at
all an acceptable explanation. We have no hesitation to hold that the said
cultivation accounts, which are the public record, are deliberately suppressed.
So, again adverse inference is to be drawn for non-production of the said
material record. The inference that could be drawn in the facts and
circumstances of the case is that if the said record is produced, the truth will
be unfolded and the fact that the lands are under cultivation and that the writ
petitioners, who are assignees, have brought the lands under cultivation would
be established and as such, the said record is suppressed. Therefore, at any
rate as the burden is on the State Government to prove the fact that the lands
were not brought under cultivation and terms of the grant are violated and as
they miserably failed to discharge their burden, it cannot be held with certainty
that the writ petitioners have violated the terms and conditions of the
assignment and thereby rendered themselves liable for cancellation of the Dpattas and for resumption of the lands.
15.
Therefore, the fact that the records showing the cancellation of D-pattas
is not produced, the fact that the records showing the lands were resumed to
the Government is not produced and most importantly, the fact that the
cultivation adangals showing that the lands were not brought under cultivation
are not produced are all adverse factors that proves that the contention of the
respondents that the writ petitioners have violated the terms of the assignment
is not correct.
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
16.
Therefore, in view of the above discussion as it is not proved that the D-
pattas are validly cancelled and the lands were validly resumed and that the
writ petitioners have violated the terms of the assignment, as the said lands
were illegally resumed and taken possession and transferred to another
department, as rightly held by the learned Single Judge relying on the law laid
down in Mekala Pandu’s case, the writ petitioners are undoubtedly entitled to
compensation on par with the full owners as per the market value of the lands.
17.
Learned Special Government Pleader would contend that even though
D-pattas were granted to writ petitioner Nos.1 to 7, no D-patta was granted to
petition No.8 and no land was assigned to him and as such, petitioner No.8 is
not entitled to any compensation. The said contention has no merit at all. It is
pertinent to note that in the counter that was filed by the District Collector, he
has clearly admitted in para No.3 of his counter that the lands were assigned
to all the writ petitioners and he has given the details of the assignments in the
counter itself, wherein, the name of petitioner No.8 is also mentioned along
with the extent of the land and details of the lands. However, in the last
column it is shown as AWD i.e., Assessed Waste Dry lands. Therefore, when
the said fact is clearly admitted in the counter of the District Collector, it cannot
be said under any stretch of reasoning that no D-patta was granted to
petitioner No.8 and no land was assigned to him. Therefore, the said
contention is rejected.
18.
It is also relevant to note that even as per the additional documents that
are now produced, the show cause notice relating to resumption proceedings
or cancellation of D-pattas is not produced relating to petitioner Nos.1, 2 and
4. Therefore, there is absolutely no evidence on record whatsoever to prove
that the D-pattas of petitioner Nos.1, 2 and 4 are cancelled and their lands are
resumed. Thus, the case of the respondents suffers from several legal
infirmities. Therefore, the contention of the State, as pleaded, cannot be
accepted in the said facts and circumstances of the case.
CMR,J & GTK,J
W.A.No.77 of 2018
19.
Therefore, the impugned order of the learned Single Judge is perfectly
sustainable under law and it warrants no interference in this writ appeal. The
writ appeal is devoid of any merit and it fails.
20.
Resultantly, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. As per the interim order dated
23.01.2018, passed by this Court, the respondents are directed to pay the
compensation as per the market value for the lands which are assigned to the
writ petitioners or alternatively to allot 750 sq. yards of developed land, per
acre, to them, within a period of four months from date of this order. There
shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________________________
JUSTICE CHEEKATI MANAVENDRANATH ROY
_____________________________
JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
Date: 24.04.2026
MDP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review