Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRt JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
ANT)
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
TAX REVISION CASE NO: 37 OF 2009
(Tax Revision Case Under Section 22 (1) of A.P.G.S.T Act read with
Rule 10 of APGST Rules U/S.APGST Act to revise the Order made in
T.A. No. 556 of 2008 Dated 05-09-2008 on the file of the Sales Tax
Appellate Tribunal Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad )
Between:
The State of Andhra Pradesh, rep. by the State Representative before STAT, D.No.
5-4-404 to 408, Nampally, Andhra Pradesh ., Hyderabad.
...PETITIONER
AND
M/s. A.P. State Agro lndustries Development Corporation Limited, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPECIAL GOVT.
PLEADER FOR STATE TAX
Counsel for the Respondent: SRI SURIBABU SAMUDRALA
The Court made the following ORDER:
IN TI{E HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TI{E HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
TAX REVISION CASE No.37 of 2OO9
DATE OF ORDER," 1.0 t.2026
Between
:
The State r>f Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by tht: State Representative before STAI
D.No.5-4-404 to 408,
Nampally,,\ndhra Pradesh, Hyderabad.
...Petitioner
Ef\rf,
M/s. A.P. Si:ate Agro Industries Development,
Corporatiorr Limited,
Hyderabad.
Respondent
ORDER: @er the Hon'ble Sri lustice P.iam Koshy)
Hearcl Mr. Swaroop Oorilla, learned Special Government
Pleader for State Tax appearing on behalf of the petitioner; and
Mr. Suribabu Samudrala, learned counsel for the respondent.
2.
The irrstant Tax Revision Case under Section 22(t) read with
Rule 10 of the APGST Rules under the APGST Act has been
preferred by the petitioner - State clrallenging the order passed by
the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad (for
short, the'STAT'), in T.A.No.556 of 2008, decided on 05.09.2008.
3.
The respondent M/s. A.P. State Agro Industries Development
Corporation Limited is engaged in the business of dealing with
tractors, trailers and agricultural implennents. During the
assessment year 20Ot-O2, under the APGST Act, the assessing
authority initially allowed exemption on hire charges received by
the respondent for the bulldozers working on an hourly basis
considering these transactions as service charges rather than
transfer of right to use goods. However, the Deputy Commissioner
(CT), Abids, revised this order and levied tax at Bolo under Section
5(E) of the APGST Act, treating the bulldozer hire charges as
turnover liable to tax. The Deputy Commissioner further held that
the transaction involved transfer of right to use goods in the form
of bulldozers hired to farmers on hourly basis.
4.
Aggrieved by the Deputy Commissioner's order, the
respondent filed an appeal before the srAT. The srAT allowed the
appeal in favor of the respondent, setting aside the order of the
Deputy Commissioner. The STAT opined that there was no transfer
of right to use the goods as there was no effective control of the
chattel vested with the transferee (farmers). The STAT concluded
that the essential ingredients of transfer of right to use goods
under Ser:tion 5(E) of the APGST Act were not satisfied in the
present ctrse thereby granting exemption to the respondent from
tax liabilit'/ on bulldozer hire charges.
5.
Aggrieved by the STAT's order, the instant Tax Revision Case
has been preferred by the State.
6.
Learned Special Government Pleader for state Tax contended
that the :irAT erred in law by holding that the bulldozer hire
charges collected by the respondent corporation did not constitute
turnover under section 5(E) of the APGST Act. The learned Special
Government Pleader for State Tax further contended that all
essential ingredients of lease transactions are present in the
agreement:s between the respondent and the farmers, viz.,
i.
A deiinite period of use (calculated on hourly basis),
ii
Consideration (hire charges paid by farmers); and
iii. Effective control over the bulldozers transferred to the
farmers for the stipulated period.
7.
Learned special Government Pleader for State Tax argues
that Section 5(E) was substantially amended by the Act 22 of 1995
w.e.f. 01.04.1995 and by the Act 27 of 1996 w.e.f. 01.08.1996
rendering the earlier circular dated 25.11.1985 inapplicable to the
present transactions. He further relies on the three-fold test laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of BSNL vs.
Union of Indial, which requires:
(i)
Goods available for delivery;
(ii)
Consensus ad idem as to the identity of goods; and
(iii)
The transferee having legal right to use the goods.
According to the learned Special Government pleader for
State Tax, all the aforesaid conditions are satisfied in the instant
case.
B.
Learned special Government Pleader for state Tax further
submits that the terms and conditions of the agreements clearly
' (zooo) 42 APSTJ 8s
establish that effective control over the bulldozers was transferred
to the fe rmers during the period of hire. According to the
agreemeni: terms, if the execution of work is halted for any reason
attributable to the applicant (farmer), the amounts remain payable
and the corporation is not responsible for resutts of the work,
therefore, the applicant has no right to seek refund on account of
lack of results and most significantly the security of the machinery
during use is the responsibility of the applicant. These conditions
demonstrate that the farmers acquired complete control over the
bulldozers for the agreed period and purposes and the fact that the
tenure of use is short (hourly basis) and that ownership is not
transferrec does not vitiate the transaction from being a transfer of
rigffi to us: goods. He thus contends that it is immaterial whether
the bulldozers are used for purposes other than those mentioned in
the agreement or even works executed strictly within the
framework of the agreements constitute taxable turnover under
Section 5(E:) of the APGST Act.
9.
Lastlv, the learned Special Government Pleader for State Tax
relied on :;everal judicial precedents to {Pnort his contentions.
rb
Firstly, he relied upon a full Bench judgment of the STAT in M/s.
vananberg rr Park vs. state of A.p. (T.A.Nos. g5B, 959,
96012007) wherein it was upheld that tax levied on rentals
received towards lease of equipment to IT companies, recognizing
such transactions as falling within the definition of section 5(E) of
the APGST Act. Secondly, he relied upon a decision rendered by the
Gauhati High court in M/s. HLs Asio Limited vs. state of
Assam2 wherein it was held that transfer of equipment, tools and
machinery to be operated by technically qualified personnel of
another company falls under lease transactions. Thirdly, he relied
upon another decision of the Gauhati High court in the case of
state of Tripura vs. Tripura Bus syndicate3, wherein it was
held that when 'vehicles are taken under control by election
authorities and plied according to their directions, there is transfer
of right to use constituting a sale. Lastly, he relied upon a decision
of orissa High court in the case of Krushna chandra Behera vs.
state of orissaa, wherein it was held that where effective control
of a vehicle rests with the hirer, there is transfer of right to use
constituting a sale
'8 vsr 31a
' lzzstc'ns
o
ag stc gzs
PageT of 16
10. Lea-ned counsel for the respondent, however, opposing the
instant Tax Revision Case contended that the transaction in
question rloes not involve a transfer of the right to use goods but
rather corstitutes a works contract for the development of land
using bulllozers and related apparatus. The learned counsel for the
responderrt further argues that under the terms and conditions of
the agreement with the applicant farmers, the respondent retains
complete control and possession of the machinery at all times. The
machinery is operated by the respondent's personnel and the
applicant l=armers have no legal right to use, control or possess the
equipmenl: independently. The farmers merely provide access to
their land for the development work to be carried out by the
respondent's men and machinery.
11. Learned counsel for the respondent relied on the Supreme
Court's decision in the case of BSNL (supra), which laid down five
essential attributes that must be present for a transaction to
constitute a transfer of the right to use goods. The learned counsel
for the rr:spondent submits that none of these attributes are
present in the instant case, viz.,
i. There is no delivery of goods to the farmers;
ii.
No consensus ad idem as to the identity of specific goods
being transferred;
iii. No legal right vested in the farmers to use the machinery;
iv. No exclusion of the appellant's rights during the period of
work; and
v. No possibility of the appellant transferring the same rights to
others since the appellant retains complete control
throughout.
t2. Additionally, the learned counsel for the respondent points
out to the earlier precedents including the decision of the Deputy
commissioner for assessment years 1986-87 and 1987-BB which
held that under similar terms and conditions there was no transfer
of right to use machinery in favour of contractors. The learned
counsel for the respondent argues that the application form clearly
describes it as an "Application for development of land by bulldozer
and related apparatus" emphasizing that it is a service contract for
land development work, rather than a lease or transfer of
equipment. The various rules appended to the application further
demonstrate that the respondent maintains responsibility for the
machineq,, its operation, and execution of the work while the
farmers' c,bligations are limited to payment and providing access to
the land
13. Hav ng heard the contentions put forth on either side and on
perusal of records, the question of law that arises for consideration
in the insl:ant case is "whether the transaction involving bulldozer
hire charges collected by the respondent corporation constitutes a
transfer of right to use goods under Section 5(E) of the ApGST
Act?"
14. It would be trite at this juncture to refer to a recent judgment
of the Horr'ble supreme court in the case of K.p. Mozika vs. oil
and Natural Gas corporation Ltd. and Anothers, wherein the
Hon'ble supreme court held at paragraph Nos.40 and 42 as under:
"40. On a conjoint reading of the aforesaid terms of the
conl'ract, it is apparent that the contractor has an option of
replacing the cranes in case one of the cranes was not
worlcing properly. Only the contractor is liable to take care
of i.he legal consequences of using the cranes. The
contractor must maintain the cranes, and it is for the
contractor to pay for consumables like fuel, oil, etc. Even
the cranes must be moved and operated by the crew
t 2o2q SCC Orline SC 28
members appointed by the contractor. Moreover, in case of
any mishap or accident in connection with the cranes or
connection with the use of the cranes or as a consequence
thereof, the entire liability will be of the contractor and not
of the ONGC. Thus, in short, the contract is for providing
the senrice of cranes to ONGC. The reason is that the
transferee (ONGC) is not required to face legal
consequences for using the cranes supplied by the
contractor. Therefore, the tests laid down in clauses (c) and
(d) of paragraph 97 of the decision of Dr. AR Laxmanan, J
are not fulfilled.
42. Essentially, the transfer of the right to use will involve
not only possession, which may be granted at some stage
(after execution of the contract), but also the control of the
goods by the user. When the substantial control remains
with the contractor and is not handed over to the user,
there is no transfer of the right to use the vehicles, cranes,
tankers, etc. Whenever there is no such control on the
goods vested in the person to whom the supply is made,
the transaction will be of rendering seruice within the
meaning of Section 65(105) (zzzzj) of the Finance Act after
the said provision came into force."
15. It would be also relevant at this juncture to refer to the
relevant general conditions and rules & regulations of the contract
entered between the respondent and the farmers', which reads as
under:
"Qeneral Conditions
c) The applicant has no right to seek compensation from
the Corporation if he feels that the work is not being
executed as per the memo.
e) While executing the work, if any trees, boundaries,
su..vey stones, closing of water sources or trespass of the
vil;age roads, the applicant himself should obtain
pe"mission from the required authorities and only after
obtaining such permission, the Corporation commences the
work. The applicant has to give an undertaking to
corporation stating that for executing the above works, if
an.t loss is incurred the corporation do not have any
res'ponsibility.
Rules & Reoulations
4) On satisfying the above conditions and on receipt of the
advance, though the date of commencement of work is not
spercified by the Corporation, the Corporation woutd take att
steos for executing the work. The Corporation is not
responsible for the delay in executing the works, The
Corporation has got full authority to withdraw the men and
machinery after executing the work and before concluding
the work. In such circumstances, the appticant has got a
right to receive the balance amount from the Corporation.
The, applicant has no authority to seek compensation.
5) tf the execution of the works by machine is hatted for
any reason on account of the applicant, the amounts
payable to the Corporation are to be paid by the applicant
according to the price list.
t
I
Page L2 of 16
6) The corporation is not responsible for results in the
execution of works. The appricant do not have any
right to
seek refund of the amount paid to the Corporation
on
account of lack of results.
7) The corporation machinery and the personner are reft
free for the reasons attributed to the appricant. such cosfs
would be revied on the appticant. For carcurating the rent
for such stoppage of work, eight hours would be
constituted as work for one day.
8) Though the corporation personner wourd be present at
the place of execution of the work, the security of the
machinery being used is only on the applicant.,,
16. The Bench is of the opinion that upon scrutiny of the terms
and conditions governing the agreement between the respondent
corporation and the farmers, it becomes evident that the
ingredients required to constitute a transfer of right
essentiar
to use goods
are conspicuously absent in the present case. The Hon,ble
Supreme
court in the case of BsNL (supra) raid down five essentiar
attributes that must be cumulatively present for a transaction
qualify as transfer of right to use goods. In the instant
to
case, none
of these essential attributes are satisfied. The bulldozers remained
under the complete control and possession of the respondent
corporation at all times with the corporation's own personnel
,/
I
I
I
operating the machinery. The applicant (farmers') neither acquire
I
i
I
j
!
physical possession of the equipment nor obtain any legal right to
indepenc ently use, control or operate the bulldozers. What is
I
i
l
contractod for is not the use of machinery, but rather the execution
of specific land development work by the respondent using its
machinery and manpower. Therefore, this transaction is essentially
a works contract for land development rather than a lease or
tra nsfe r r>f equipment.
17. Further, what is to be considered is that, the State before
concludirg whether the contract between the company and the
farmers in the transaction of bulldozer constitutes a transfer of
right to use goods under Section 5(E) of APGST Act, the following
grounds need to be taken into consideration: the contracts
executed by the respondent are for rendering of service and they
are perfcrmance contracts; the intention of respondent and their
clients is to render and receive the service; the clients are neither
interested in acquiring any interest in the bulldozer nor do they
actually arcquire any interest in the bulldozer; the possession and
control ol the bulldozer are always with the respondent and the
bulldozer operators are the employees of the respondent; there
was no delivery of bulldozer at any point of time to clients; there is
absolutely no transfer of right to use the bulldozer; even during the
period covered by the contract the road taxes, tolls and other
imposts are paid by the respondent and licenses are in the name of
the respondent; even during the period covered by the contract the
insurance is paid by the respondent; even during the period
covered by contract the road-risk is borne by the respondent;
during the contract period the fuel and maintenance expenses are
borne by the respondent; and lastly the respondent is paid on
hourly basis for the period bulldozer work.
18. The amendments to the statute and the judicial precedents
cited by the state deal with the situations where there is actual
transfer of possession, control and legal right to use the goods to
the transferee, which is fundamentaily different from the present
case where the respondent retains complete dominion over the
machinery throughout the transaction. The fact that security
responsibility is placed on the applicant (farmers') or that amounts
remain payable even if work is halted for reasons attributable to
the applicant does not alter the basic character of the transaction
as a works contract. These contractual stipulations merely protect
the respr>ndent's commercial interests and ensure payment for the
work undertaken, but do not evidence any transfer of right to use
the bullcozers. The previous assessment orders for earlier years
treating r;imilar transactions as service charges rather than transfer
of right t:o use goods further support the respondent's contentlon
and establish a consistent administrative interpretation of such
transactions.
19. In light of the foregoing discussion and analysis, the Bench is
of the considered opinion that there is no merit in the Tax Revision
Case filerl by the State. The STAT has correctly appreciated the
facts and law in concluding that the bulldozer hire charges collected
by the respondent corporation do not constitute taxable turnover
under Sec:tion 5(E) of the APGST Act, The transaction in question is
a compos te works contract for land development services and does
not invoh,e any transfer of right to use goods as contemplated
u nder the statutory provisions.
20. For all the aforesaid reasons, we are of the considered
opinion that the instant Tax Revision Case being devoid of merit
deserves to be and is accordingly dismissed. The order dated
II
;
I
i
05.09.2008, in T.A.No.556 of 2008, passed by
the srAT is hereby
upheld. The question of law framed above stands
answered in
favour of the respondent and against the State
hording that
transactions involving bulldozer hire charges collected
respondent does not constitute a transfer of right
by the
to use goods
under Section 5(E) of the ApGST Act.
21. As a sequer, misceilaneous petitions pending if any, shail
stand closed. Howeveri there shall be no order
as to costs.
SD/. N. SRIHARI
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad
2. One CC to SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, Special Govt. Pleader for state Tax'
[igh Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad'
3. One CC to SRl. S. SURIBABU , Advocate (OPUC)
4. Two CD CoPies
Kul/PSL
w
HIGH COURT
DATED:091O112026
( o'r{ 1'
I
t\
D
c
(J
i: 5 iFB
ii
i\, rr)
*
ORDER
TREVC.No.37 of 2009
DISMISSING T IIr l'RI1VC
WIl'IIOTJT- COSl'S
C"red
Ss,-
170?0
*
z
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review