Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
"$
%
&
#
&
#
#
"
#
'
%%
(
)
)
*
+)
%%
,,
$
%%
,,!
$
%%
$
%%
,
%%
Digitally signed
by SACHIN
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
$
%%
, ,
%%
!
+
)
!
$
$
" #!
" %
$
"
-2-
!# &
" '
$
' "
# '
'
" !
'& $
(
&
&
# %
)*
(%
"
(
$
(
"
"
(# (+
!
!
(
$
"
& $
$
,, +
)
!
$
"
#
" '
'
# '
"
"
+
" #!
" %
-3-
'
" !
'& $
(
&
&
#
)*
# %
(%
"
(
$
!
!
(
+
(
#
"
"
(+
$
"
& $
$
,,!+
)
!
" #!
" %
$
#
" '
$
' "
# '
'
" !
'& $
(
&
&
#
)* (%
# %
"
-4-
(
$
!
!
(
+
(
#
"
"
(+
$
"
& $
$
+
)
(
!
" #!
" %
$
#
%
(
"
,
#
" '
$
' "
# '
"
!
'
" !
'& $
!#
" '
$
' "
# '
"
!
'
" !
'& $
&
&
#
&
# %
-5-
#
)* (%
"
(
$
!
!
( ))#
"
"
(+
$
& $
$
,+
)
%
&
" !
!
" #!
" %
'& $
$
(
#
" '
$
' "
# '
'
&
'& $
&
"
" !
"
" '
$
# '
'
&
'& $
#
' "
&
"
" !
-
&
(
&
%
"
-6-
#
)* (%
"
(
$
!
!
)
(
)#
"
"
(+
$
"
& $
$
+
)
%
'& $
&
" !
!
" #!
" %
-
$
# &
" '
$
' "
# '
'
&
'& $
&
"
" !
&
&
#
)* (%
"
(
$
!
!
%
+ ((
(
"
"
-7-
$
"
& $
$
(
#
(+
, ,+
)
(
!
" #!
" %
$
#
" '
$
#
'& $
'
-
"
" !
( (
&
&
#
%
)* (%
"
(
$
!
!
(
(
(
(#
"
"
(+
$
& $
$
"
-8-
!+
)
'& $
(
!
" #!
" %
$
&
#
" '
$
' "
# '
'
" !
'& $
&
&
#
%
)* (%
"
(
$
!
!
(
./
(
#
"
"
(+
$
(
#
& $
$
(+
$
"
!
'
"
&
'
$
$
$
2/3
"
$
&
"
-9-
#
'
$
(* )#
$%
#
+#
267 8.973 :;2997/<./< =;7 :4667:=/755 48 =;7 >?3<@7/= 2/3
2A263 32=73
(
#
(
+
B25573 ./
(+ 2/3 (
#
() #
(
(
45 ( ))#
(+ (
#
(+
(())#
#
2/3
2/3
32=73
)
( 2/3
)#
(+ CD =;7
2/3 =;7
(#
* 267 8.973 :;2997/<./< =;7 :4667:=/755 48 =;7
>?3<@7/= 2/3 2A263
(
(+ 2/3
* #
(+#
+ ((
45 (
(+
&.>2DB?62
678767/:7
4?6=0%
(
33.=.4/29
:E?.5.=.4/
?=;46.=D
(
#
B25573 ./
(+ (
.5=6.:= 2/3
(#
755.4/5 $?3<7
7;2C.9.=2=.4/ 2/3
;7/:7846=;
(+ 2/3
757==97@7/=
67876673
=4
F=;7
;7 675B4/37/=5 ;767./ ;7/:7846=; 67876673 =4
25 F=;7 :92.@2/=50% A767 =;7 4A/765 48 92/3 C726./<
D
4 ( ++#
@725?6./<
( 2:67
<?/=25
@725?6./<
2:675
* <?/=25
D
<?/=25
4( *
@725?6./<
+ <?/=25
D
4(
#
D
4( (
@725?6./< (
D
4(
#(
- 10 -
@725?6./<
2:675 (
<?/=25
D
4(
D
*#
<?/=25
4 ((
D
@725?6./<
@725?6./<
/<2975;A26 &.992<7
;7
4 ( +)#* @725?6./<
2:675
2846752.3
92/35
A767
?92A23
64>7:= ./ =76@5 48 2 /4=.8.:2=.4/ ?/376
.<;= =4
2.6
(*
<?/=25
B64B4573
2<7A23. 29?G
2:E?.5.=.4/ 846 =;7 B?6B457 48
=;7
<?/=25
4@B7/52=.4/ 2/3
:E?.5.=.4/
7;2C.9.=2=.4/ 2/3
32=73
(
2/3
66.<2=.4/
7:=.4/ (( (% 48
62/5B267/:D ./
757==97@7/=
(
88.:76 B25573 2/ 2A263 4/
.8=
;7
(
:=
2/3
2/3
(
:E?.5.=.4/
(+ 37=76@././< =;7
@26G7= H29?7 48 =;7 B64B76=D 2= 2 5?@ 48
5(
B76 2:67 846 36D 92/3 2/3
B76 2:67 846
.66.<2=73 92/3
5(
#
#
;7 :92.@2/=5 2<<6.7H73 CD =;7 E?2/=?@ 48
:4@B7/52=.4/ 37@2/373 ;.<;76 :4@B7/52=.4/ A;.:; A767
67876673 =4 =;7
4?6= ?/376
7:=.4/ (
(% 48 =;7
2/3
* (% 48 =;7
.<;=
:E?.5.=.4/
:= ( +* 6723 A.=;
7:=.4/
=4
4@B7/52=.4/
2/3
62/5B267/:D
./
2/3
7;2C.9.=2=.4/ 2/3
757==97@7/=
:=
(
2.6
:E?.5.=.4/
2/3 54?<;= 678767/:7 A;.:; A25 /?@C7673 25
- 11 -
45 (
(
(#
)#
(+
(+ (
*
(
#
#
(+
(
#
(+
(+ (
(#
(+ 2/3 (
( ))#
#
(+
(+
;7 7H.37/:7 48 =;7 :92.@2/=5 A767 67:46373 25
! ( ./ =;7.6 675B7:=.H7 :2575 2/3 =;7D @26G73
(
./ =;7.6 675B7:=.H7 :92.@5
I5
( =4
;7 678767/:7
I5
( =4
;7 C7/78.:.26D @26G73
4?6= 28=76 :4/5.376./< =;7
4629 2/3 34:?@7/=26D 7H.37/:7 B25573 2/ 2A263 32=73
(
+
(
(
2/3
(
:4@B7/52=.4/ =4 2 5?@ 48 Rs.
5)
)* *
)
#
5*
2/3
+
5 ( () +
)
+ ((
(
7/;2/:./<
=;7
=4=29
+* +
#
+
( #
5(
+)
5((
(
294/< A.=; C7/78.=5
7./< 2<<6.7H73 CD =;7 52.3 >?3<@7/= 2/3 2A263 =;757
2BB7295 267 8.973
;7
9726/73
33.=.4/29
3H4:2=7
"7/7629
67B6757/=./< =;7 C7/78.:.26D 5?C@.==73 =;2= =;7 678767/:7
4?6= ;23 C9./39D 7/;2/:73 =;7 :4@B7/52=.4/ CD 679D./<
?B4/ =;7 >?3<@7/= 2/3 2A263 32=73 ((
4(
#
(+
)
B25573 ./
;7 :4/=7/35 =;2= =;7 678767/:7
4?6=
- 12 -
4?<;= =4 ;2H7 :4/5.37673 A;7=;76 =;7 92/3 =;2= A25 =;7
5?C>7:= @2==76 48
4(
#
(+ A25 5.@.926 =4 =;7
92/3 48 =;7 :92.@2/=5 ./ =;757 2BB7295
/ 5?BB46= 48 =;.5 :4/=7/=.4/ 5;7 67876673 =4
=;7 >?3<@7/= 48 =;7
B7I
4?6= ./ =;7 :257 48 =;7
I7:?=.H7
/<./776
H5
//2624 ,
/H7762BB2 2/3
2/4=;76 ./
.H.9
+(#
2/3 :4//7:=73
BB729
2BB7295 2/3 :4/=7/373 =;2= =;7 678767/:7
4?6= A25
C4?/3 =4 H76.8D 72:; 2/3 7H76D :257 =4 25:76=2./ =;7
B7:?9.26.=.75 48 =;2= 92/3 2/3 =;76728=76 37=76@./7 =;7
:4@B7/52=.4/
;7 =;7678467 :4/=7/35 =;2= =;7 .@B?</73
>?3<@7/= 2/3 2A263 B25573 CD =;7 678767/:7
4?6= .5
A.=;4?= 3?7 2BB9.:2=.4/ 48 @./3 2/3 ;7/:7 =;7 52@7 267
9.2C97 =4 C7 57= 25.37
)
=;7
9726/73
:4?/579
=;7
:92.@2/=5 :4/=7/373 =;2= =;7 C7/78.:.26D ;23 52=.58.73 =;7
2A263 ./
45 ( ) #
( ) #
4(
2/3 ( ))#
A;.:; A25 ./ 675B7:= 48
D
#( ((+#( 2/3 (
#( 48
/<2975;A26 H.992<7
;7678467 ;7 :4/=7/35 =;2= =;7
- 13 -
C7/78.:.26D :2//4= /4A :;2997/<7 =;7 >?3<@7/= 2/3 2A263
B25573
./
:4/=7/35
=;7
2846752.3
=;2=
=;7
92/3
92/3
2:E?.5.=.4/
2:E?.5.=.4/
:2575
488.:76
A;.97
37=76@././< =;7 @26G7= H29?7 48 =;7 2:E?.673 92/3 48 =;7
:92.@2/=5 ./ =;757 2BB7295 ;793 =;2= =;7 H29?7 48 =;7 92/3
54 2:E?.673 A25 2 5?@ 48 Rs.(
(
# B76 2:67
.G7A.57
=;7 92/3 2:E?.5.=.4/ 488.:76 ;23 37=76@./73 =;7 @26G7=
H29?7
( ))#
2:67
=;7
92/3
2/3 ( ) #
2:E?.673
./
2= 2 5?@ 48 Rs.(
4( ) #
(
# B76
7 =;7678467 :4/=7/35 =;2= ./ 675B7:= 48 =;7 92/35 ./
/<2975;A26 &.992<7 A;.:; A767 2:E?.673 846 =;7 B?6B457
48 =;7
?92A23
.8= 66.<2=.4/
64>7:= =;7 92/3 2:E?.5.=.4/
488.:76 A25 48 =;7 4B./.4/ =;2= 2 ?/.846@ @26G7= H29?7
:4?93 C7 2BB9.73
7 =;7678467 :4/=7/35 =;2= 7H7/ 25 B76
=;7 92/3 2:E?.5.=.4/ 488.:76
299 =;7 92/35 =;2= A767
2:E?.673 ./ /<2975A;26 H.992<7 A767 5.@.9269D 5.=?2=7 2/3
=;7678467 ;7 ;23 37=76@./73 =;7 52@7 @26G7= H29?7 ./
675B7:= 48 299 =;7 92/35 =;2= A767 2:E?.673
7 =;?5
:4/=7/35 =;2= =;7 C7/78.:.26D ;2H./< 52=.58.73 =;7 :92.@5
- 14 -
@237 ./
45 ( ) #
( ) #
2/3 ( ))#
:2//4= /4A :;2997/<7 =;7 :4@B7/52=.4/ 37=76@./73 CD =;7
678767/:7
4?6=
;7 9726/73
5?C@.==73
=;2=
./
( ))#
2/3 ( ) #
33.=.4/29
675B7:=
3H4:2=7 "7/7629 82.69D
45 ( ) #
=;7 :4@B7/52=.4/ .5 296723D
B2.3 2/3 =;7 C7/78.:.26D ;25 52=.58.73 =;7 2A263
;4A7H76
:4/=7/373
=;2=
C78467
2BB9D./<
=;7
;7
B6.:7
37=76@./73 CD =;7 678767/:7
4?6= ./
( ))#
.= .5 ./:?@C7/= ?B4/ =;.5
2/3 ( ) #
45 ( ) #
4?6= =4 944G ./=4 =;7 E?75=.4/ A;7=;76 299 =;7 92/35
./H49H73
./
45 ( ) #
( ))#
2/3
( ) #
267 5.@.9269D 5.=?2=7 25 =;7 92/35 ./ E?75=.4/
;7 :4/=7/35 =;2= A;7/ =;767 .5 /4 7H.37/:7 =4 =;2=
7887:= =;.5
4?6= :2//4= 2BB9D =;7 52@7 2/3 ?B;493 =;7
2A2635 B25573 CD =;7 678767/:7
+
9726/73
4?6=
!7 ;2H7 :4/5.37673 =;7 5?C@.55.4/5 48 =;7
33.=.4/29
3H4:2=7 "7/7629 846 =;7 C7/78.:.26D
2/3 =;7 9726/73 :4?/579 846 =;7 675B4/37/=5
- 15 -
(
= .5 /4= ./ 3.5B?=7 =;2= 92/35 ./
H.992<7 A767 2:E?.673 846 =;7 B?6B457 48
66.<2=.4/ 64>7:=
/<2975;A26
?92A23
./46
;7 92/35 ./ E?75=.4/ A767 299 /4=.8.73 ./
=76@5 48 2 /4=.8.:2=.4/ 32=73
.G7A.57 =;7 92/35 ./
D
(
4 ((+#( (
2/3
(
#( 2/3 (
#( 48
/<2975A;26 H.992<7 A767 2954 2:E?.673 ./ =76@5 48 =;7
/4=.8.:2=.4/ 32=73
/<2975;A26
(
H.992<7
=;7
/ 675B7:= 48 299 =;7 92/35 ./
92/3
2:E?.5.=.4/
488.:76
;23
37=76@./73 =;7 @26G7= H29?7 48 =;7 92/3 2:E?.673 2= 2
5?@ 48 Rs.(
:4/=7@B92=.4/
(
#
B76 2:67
=;7
;7678467
C7/78.:.26D
7H7/ ./ =;7
=;7
92/35
./
/<2975;A26 H.992<7 A767 5.@.9269D 5.=?2=73 2/3 =;7678467 2
?/.846@ B6.:7 A25 8.I73 25 =;7 @26G7= H29?7
4?6=
;23
7/;2/:73
45 ( ) #
D
( ))#
45 ((+#( (
#( (
=;7
;7 678767/:7
:4@B7/52=.4/
2/3 ( ) #
./
./ 675B7:= 48
#( 48 /<2975;A26 &.992<7
52.3 2A263 .5 /4A 52=.58.73 CD =;7 C7/78.:.26D
;7
;7678467
=;767 .5 /4 76646 ./ =;7 46376 B25573 CD =;7 678767/:7
4?6=
7/;2/:./<
=;7
:4@B7/52=.4/
=4
5?@
- 16 -
5 (
#
B76 <?/=2 25 =;7 C7/78.:.26D ;25 296723D
52=.58.73 =;7 2A263 ./
45 ( ) #
( ))#
2/3
( ) #
((
/ =;2= H.7A 48 =;7 @2==76 .= :2//4= /4A 9.7 ./
=;7 @4?=; 48 =;7 C7/78.:.26D =;2= =;7 >?3<@7/= 2/3 2A263
B25573 CD =;7 678767/:7
C25.5
4?6= .5 7I:755.H7 46 A.=;4?= 2/D
7/:7 299 =;757 2BB7295 267
(
/D
2@4?/=
./
=62/5876673 =4 =;7 678767/:7
37B45.=
.5
4637673
=4
4?6= 846 /7:75526D 463765
-+
(
#*
#
-+
( "
# .5=
4'(
4'
#
#
'
"*
C7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review