Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:610-DB
Serial No.09
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.104/2024
Reserved on : 03.06.2024
Pronounced on: 08.07.2024
The Shillong Municipal Employees Association, represented by its
General Secretary, Shillong, Meghalaya.
.... Petitioner
Vs.
1. The State of Meghalaya, represented by its Commissioner &
Secretary, Urban Affairs Department, Shillong.
2. The Chief Executive Officer, Shillong Municipal Board, Shillong.
..... Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Vaidyanathan, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance
For the Petitioner
: Mr. A.S. Siddiqui, Sr.Adv with
Mr. R.D. Hynniewta, Adv
For the Respondents
: Ms. S. Ain, GA with
Mr. E.R. Chyne, GA
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv for R/2
ORDER
(Made by Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
The present writ petition has been filed for the following
prayer.
“In the premises aforesaid it is most respectfully prayed that
your Lordship would be graciously pleased to issue Rule, call
for the record and after hearing the parties be pleased
(i) to direct the Respondent No.2 to comply with its order
passed on 19.01.2021 and provide the payment of gratuity to
2024:MLHC:610-DB
the Shillong Municipal Employees under section 4(5) of the
Payment of Gratuity Act 1972 and
(ii) to direct immediate payment of Gratuity to the retired
employees of the Shillong Municipal Board and to the next of
kin of the deceased employees.
(iii) to quash the Shillong Municipal Board (Gratuity) Rules,
1980.
(iv) to direct the Respondent No.2 to make reimbursement of
medical bills to the Municipal employees.
And to pass any order/orders as your Lordship deem fit and
proper.
And for which act of kindness your humble petitioners shall
every pray.”
2.
As the Shillong Municipal Board (Gratuity) Rules, 1980
is challenged, the writ petition is listed before Division Bench. The case
of the petitioner is that the petitioner’s Union is registered with the
Registrar of Society, Shillong and is affiliated to the Indian National
Trade Union Congress bearing registration No.63/1986. According to
the petitioner, the workers through all Assam Civic Bodies Workers’
Federation raised an industrial dispute when it was in the composite
State of Assam and the dispute was referred to the Industrial Tribunal at
Guwahati for adjudication and the same was taken up for hearing as
Reference No.21 of 1969. The following issues were referred for
adjudication:
“(i) Whether the pay scale of the Municipal Employees should
be brought at par with the Government employees?
2024:MLHC:610-DB
(ii) Whether the Municipal employees are entitled to Gratuity
at the rate of one month’s pay on the basis of last pay drawn for
each complete year of services with immediate effect?
(iii) Whether the Rule governing the services of the
Government employees should be made applicable to the
Municipal employees?
(iv) Whether medical facilities and other facilities as available
to the State Government employees should be granted to the
civic employees?”
3. During the pendency of the dispute before the Tribunal,
there was a settlement arrived at between the parties with regard to all
the issues that were referred to for adjudication including gratuity, the
Tribunal had rendered an award on 23.08.1971 which was published in
the Assam Gazette on 01.09.1971. While passing an award, the Tribunal
has recorded the settlement in the award and for the sake of
convenience, the gratuity payable to the employee is based on one
month’s pay on the basis of last drawn pay should be granted for each
completed year of service and the relevant clause is extracted below:
“2. Gratuity at the rate of one month’s pay on the basis of last
pay drawn should be granted for each completed year of
service with immediate effect.”
4. According to the petitioner, once a Tribunal has passed an
award which was published in the Gazette on 01.09.1971, it has come
into effect in terms of Section 17 and Section 17A of the Industrial
2024:MLHC:610-DB
Disputes Act, 1947. Section 17 and Section 17A of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 are extracted below:
“17. Publication of reports and awards.–(1) Every report of
a Board or Court together with any minute of dissent recorded
therewith, every arbitration award and every award of a Labour
Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal shall, within a period of
thirty days from the date of its receipt by the appropriate
Government, be published in such manner as the appropriate
Government thinks fit.
(2) Subject to the provisions of section 17A, the award
published under sub-section (1) shall be final and shall not be
called in question by any Court in any manner whatsoever.
“17A. Commencement of the award.–(1) An award
(including an arbitration award) shall become enforceable on
the expiry of thirty days from the date of its publication under
section 17:
Provided that–
(a) if the appropriate Government is of opinion, in any case
where the award has been given by a Labour Court or Tribunal
in relation to an industrial dispute to which it is a party; or
(b) if the Central Government is of opinion, in any case where
the award has been given by a National Tribunal, that it will be
inexpedient on public grounds affecting national economy or
social justice to give effect to the whole or any part of the
award, the appropriate Government, or as the case may be, the
Central Government may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, declare that the award shall not become enforceable
on the expiry of the said period of thirty days.
(2) Where any declaration has been made in relation to an
award under the proviso to sub-section (1), the appropriate
Government or the Central Government may, within ninety
days from the date of publication of the award under section
17, make an order rejecting or modifying the award, and shall,
on the first available opportunity, lay the award together with a
copy of the order before the Legislature of the State, if the
2024:MLHC:610-DB
order has been made by a State Government, or before
Parliament, if the order has been made by the Central
Government.
(3) Where any award as rejected or modified by an order made
under sub-section (2) is laid before the Legislature of a State or
before Parliament, such award shall become enforceable on the
expiry of fifteen days from the date on which it is so laid; and
where no order under sub-section (2) is made in pursuance of a
declaration under the proviso to sub-section (1), the award
shall become enforceable on the expiry of the period of ninety
days referred to in sub-section (2).
(4) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (1) and sub-section
(3) regarding the enforceability of an award, the award shall
come into operation with effect from such date as may be
specified therein, but where no date is so specified, it shall
come into operation on the date when the award becomes
enforceable under sub-section (1) or sub-section (3), as the
case may be.”
5. According to the petitioner, the award of the Tribunal is
binding on the parties and it should be extended to all the employees
who were present at the time of raising the dispute, the past members
and future recruits. After the separation of the State of Meghalaya from
the composite State of Assam, it has been stated that except the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, there is no Centre enactment to regulate
the payment of gratuity to the industrial workers. The Gratuity Act was
amended from time to time in view to meet the escalation of price
index. It is stated that the payment of Gratuity Act is applicable to the
employees of the Municipality. It has been stated that once the Act is
applicable to the Municipality and that those employees who were
2024:MLHC:610-DB
completed five years of continuous service would be entitled to gratuity
on attainment of his superannuation, retirement or resignation, on his
death or disablement due to accident or disease for every completed
year of service or part thereof in excess of six months, the gratuity will
be calculated at the rate of 15 days wages based on the last drawn wage
of the employee concerned. It is contended that in terms of Section 4(5)
of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, the employees are entitled to
receive better term of gratuity as per the award or agreement or contract
with the employer. Section 4(5) of the Payment of Gratuity, 1972 is
extracted below:
“4(5) Nothing in this section shall affect the right of an
employee to receive better terms of gratuity under any award or
agreement or contract with the employer.”
6. It is further contended that instead of paying gratuity at the
rate of one month’s pay on the basis of last pay drawn for every
completed year of service, the respondent No.2 arbitrarily paying
gratuity at the rate of 30 days’ pay to some of the employees and to
other at the rate of 15 days’ pay for each completed years thereby
creating artificial division. There are about 171 employees who retired
between 1990 to 2019 were paid their gratuity as per the Tribunal award
of 1971 and 118 employees who retired from 1992 to 2012 were paid
their gratuity as per the provision of the Shillong Municipal Board
2024:MLHC:610-DB
(Gratuity) Rules, 1980, which is at par with the Gratuity Act which
stipulates every 15 days wages for every completed year of service. It
also contended that contracting out is impermissible in terms of Section
14 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and the said Section is
extracted below:
14. Act to override other enactments, etc.–The provisions
of this Act or any rule made thereunder shall have effect
notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in
any enactment other than this Act or in any instrument or
contract having effect by virtue of any enactment other than
this Act.”
7. Learned counsel argued that Section 50 of the Meghalaya
Municipal Act (Assam Act), 1956 provides that the Municipal Board at
a meeting may, with the sanction of the State Government, make Rules
for Gratuity or Pension to be granted and paid out of its fund. The
Shillong Municipal Board with the approval of the Government of
Meghalaya, the Municipal Administration Department made Rules
which is called the Shillong Municipal Board (Gratuity) Rules, 1980
which is said to have come into effect from 18.02.1980. In terms of
Rule 3(4) of the Rules of 1980, the amount of gratuity will be one fourth
of the emoluments of an officer for every completed six months period
of qualifying service subject to a maximum of 16½ times of his
emoluments and in the case of death of an employee while in service,
2024:MLHC:610-DB
the gratuity will be subject to a maximum of twelve times of the
emoluments of the officer at the time of his death. In no case, the
amount shall exceed Rs.30,000/-. However, on 19.06.2018, the
Government of Meghalaya has amended the Rules with the approval of
the Governor of Meghalaya and enhanced the maximum amount of Rs.7
lakhs and the provisions of the Municipal Gratuity Rules is in conflict
with Section 4(5) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 which provides
that nothing in this Section shall affect the right of an employee to
receive better terms of gratuity on any award or agreement or contract
with the employer.
8. As stated supra, in terms of Section 14 of the Gratuity Act of
1972, notwithstanding anything contained in any instrument or contract
having effect by virtue of any enactment other than the Gratuity Act of
1972, gratuity can be deprived. According to the petitioner, the Rules
are inconsistent with Section 4(5) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972,
hence it is not enforceable. Unfortunately, the employer without
implementing the award in letter and spirit is adopting different
yardstick with regard to the payment of gratuity and that in terms of the
award, the employee should be treated on par with the employees of the
State Government of Assam, and the Municipal employees cannot be
2024:MLHC:610-DB
denied the benefits of the rights conferred under the award by the
successor of the State of Assam namely, the Shillong Municipality.
According to the petitioner, the non-payment of gratuity in terms of the
award is violative of Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India
and hence, the relief sought for by the petitioner needs to be granted.
9. The respondent No.2 has contended that the petitioner has
come forward with the similar relief in the earlier round of litigation and
on 18.12.2020 in WP (C) No.318 of 2017 and WP (C) No.371 of 2014,
this Court has categorically upheld the Shillong Municipal Board
(Gratuity) Rules, 1980, read with the notification dated 04.08.2016 and
that pursuant to the order of the Court, the gratuity is paid to the
employees of the Shillong Municipal Board in accordance with the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The Division Bench of this Court has
disposed of the writ petitions on 08.12.2020 and the relevant paragraph
is extracted below:
“In such circumstances as stated above, we dispose of both the
writ petitions with a direction to the Chief Executive Officer,
Shillong Municipal Board, to take a decision in the matter with
regard to payment of gratuity to those employees of Shillong
Municipal Board, being represented by its Employees’
Association in Writ Petition (C) No. 318 of 2017 as well as the
writ petitioners in Writ Petition (C) No. 371 of 2014, invoking
the provisions of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, in the light of
section 14 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, read with the
observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Nagar Ayukt
2024:MLHC:610-DB
Nagar Nigam, Kanpur (supra). Such a decision shall be taken
by the Chief Executive Officer, Shillong Municipal Board, as
expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of six
weeks, but not later than eight weeks from date of
communication of a photostat certified copy of this order.”
10. After the order of this Court dated 08.12.2020, a decision
was taken to extend the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 to all the
employees retrospectively w.e.f. 30.06.2012.
11. Heard the parties.
12. The employees are demanding the payment of gratuity in
terms of the award dated 23.08.1971 published in the Gazette and it
should be 30 days wages for every completed year of service. The
employees further stated that the notification dated 22.12.1980 issued
pursuant to Section 50(3) of the Meghalaya Municipal Act (Assam Act
1956 as adopted by Meghalaya), it needs to be interfered with and that
the maximum gratuity payable, more so, in the light of Rule 4 of the
Meghalaya Municipal Act, would make it very clear that it would be
one-fourth of the emoluments of an officer for each completed six
monthly period of qualifying service subject to a maximum of 16½
times of his emoluments. After the order of this Court, a decision dated
19.01.2021 has been taken extending the Payment of Gratuity Act to the
employees. A glance of the pleadings is very clear that the employees
who were in service on the date of the award were extended the benefits
2024:MLHC:610-DB
of the award of the Industrial Tribunal and the number of employees
was 1671. The employees who were retired from 1992 to 2012 were
given the benefits of gratuity as per the Shillong Municipal Board
(Gratuity) Rules, 1980. Pursuant to the order dated 19.01.2021, as per
the order of this Court, the Shillong Municipal Board has extended the
gratuity to all the employees who have retired since 30.06.2012 and by
the notification dated 22.12.1980, the provision of the Rules pertaining
to gratuity has come into effect. For the sake of convenience, Section
18(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is extracted below:
“18(3) A settlement arrived at in the course of conciliation
proceedings under this Act or an arbitration award in a case
where a notification has been issued under sub-section (3A) of
section 10A or an award of a Labour Court, Tribunal or
National Tribunal which has become enforceable shall be
binding on–
(a) all parties to the industrial dispute;
(b) all other parties summoned to appear in the
proceedings as parties to the dispute, unless the
Board, arbitrator, Labour Court, Tribunal or National
Tribunal, as the case may be, records the opinion that they
were so summoned without proper cause;
(c) where a party referred to in clause (a) or clause (b) is
an employer, his heirs, successors or assigns in respect of
the establishment to which the dispute relates;
(d) where a party referred to in clause (a) or clause (b) is
composed of workmen, all persons who were employed in
the establishment or part of the establishment, as the case
may be, to which the dispute relates on the date of the
dispute and all persons who subsequently become
employed in that establishment or part.”
2024:MLHC:610-DB
13. In terms of the award, the employer will have to extend the
benefits of gratuity to the employees, who were in service at the time
raising a dispute and continue to give the same till the award is modified
by means of a subsequent award or a settlement. In case of alteration by
means of amendment to the Act or introduction of new enactment, the
employer is entitled to follow the new procedure prescribed in the latest
enactments or Rules.
14. A reading of the pleadings would make it very clear that
those employees who were in service at the time of raising a dispute
based on the settlement which incorporated by the Tribunal in its award
mentioned supra were given the benefit of 30 days’ pay on the basis of
last pay drawn for each completed year of service with immediate
effect. Consequently coming into force of the Municipal Rules, the
employees who were retired from 1992 till 2012 were given the benefit
of gratuity as per the Rules. After the orders of this Court dated
08.12.2020 passed in WP (C) No. 371 of 2014 and WP (C) No. 318 of
2017 which is extracted supra, more so, which has been accepted by the
Municipal Board, the employees have been extended the benefit of
gratuity in terms of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
2024:MLHC:610-DB
15. The Rules have already been challenged which has attained
finality. The benefits to the employees having been deprived by this
Court, challenging the very same Rules is not permissible, by the very
same petitioner against the same management is hit by res judicata. The
employer has extended the benefit of the Payment of Gratuity Act and
that the employees would be governed only by the said enactment. The
award passed in the year 1971 was superseded by means of a Rule and
that Rule has become final due to unsuccessful challenge by the
employees. Question of reopening it again by means of another writ
petition is not permissible. Even assuming that the employees are
entitled to get the relief of better gratuity under Section 4(5) of the
Payment of Gratuity Act, the writ petition is not an alternate remedy,
more so, in the light of the judgment of the Supreme Court reported in
the case of Allahabad Bank v. All India Allahabad Bank Retired
Employees Association reported in (2010) 2 SCC 44. Paragraphs 44 and
45 of the judgment are extracted below:
“44. Sub-section (7) of Section 7 provides for an appeal against
the order of the Controlling Authority. The Act nowhere
confers any jurisdiction upon the Controlling Authority to deal
with any issue under sub-section (5) of Section 4 as to whether
the terms of gratuity payable under any award or agreement or
contract is more beneficial to employees than the one provided
for payment of gratuity under the Act. This Court’s order could
not have conferred any such jurisdiction upon the Controlling
2024:MLHC:610-DB
Authority to decide any matter under sub-section (5) of Section
4, since Parliament in its wisdom had chosen to confer such
jurisdiction only upon the appropriate Government and that too
for the purposes of considering to grant exemption from the
operation of the provisions of the Act.
45. Even on merits the conclusions drawn by the Controlling
Authority that the Pension Scheme (Old) offered by the Bank
is more beneficial since the amount of money the pensioners
got under the pension scheme is more than the amount that
could have been received in the form of gratuity under the
provisions of the Act is unsustainable. The Controlling
Authority failed to appreciate that sub-section (5) of Section 4
of the Act protects the right of an employee to receive better
terms of gratuity under any award or agreement or contract
with the employer than the benefits conferred under the Act.
The comparison, if any, could be only between the terms of
gratuity under any award or agreement or contract and payment
of gratuity payable to an employee under Section 4 of the Act.
There can be no comparison between a pension scheme which
does not provide for payment of any gratuity and right of an
employee to receive payment of gratuity under the provisions
of the Act.”
16. The decision of the Supreme Court has already been
followed by the Madras High Court, in which one of us is a party both
in the Division Bench holding that even the authority under the Payment
of Gratuity Act cannot decide the issue. The only remedy to get the
relief under Section 4(5) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is before
the Labour Court. This Court is not giving liberty to the employees to
approach the Labour Court, more so, the challenge to the Rules have
already been in the negative and a finding has been rendered against the
employees. The employees should have challenged the order of the
2024:MLHC:610-DB
Division Bench dated 08.12.2020 before the Supreme Court but they
cannot re-agitate the same issue as stated supra. The reference to
Section 14 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 may not be applicable
to the facts of this case. In case the award and the Rules are pari
materia then depriving employees the gratuity of 30 days’ for each
completed year may be illegal. The award has been modified due to the
introduction of the Shillong Municipal Board (Gratuity) Rules, 1980.
Hence, on all counts, the writ petition needs to be dismissed. That apart,
in the affidavit it has been stated by the petitioner that the petitioner
association is registered with the Registrar of Societies. A register trade
union alone is empowered to file a writ petition provided there is no
disputed question of fact.
17. In this case, the writ petition has been filed by an
association, which is not registered under the trade unions Act claiming
service benefits and on that score also the writ petition has got to be
dismissed. An unregistered trade union can challenge the award of the
Tribunal or the Labour Court or the Authorities, but cannot maintain a
writ petition. Five men Committee is also on the same footing.
18. Even assuming that the registration of the petitioner union
is under the Trade Unions Act, 1926, still the writ petition is not
2024:MLHC:610-DB
maintainable on the ground as it is hit by res judicata apart from
disputed question of fact. Claiming the benefits under Sections 4(5) of
the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 cannot be entertained by this Court,
and each and every individual will have to get their grievance redressed.
As stated supra, we are not granting any relief in this writ petition and
also not permitting the employees to approach the authority or the
Labour Court as the case may be, and there should be finality to the
litigation. Regarding the reimbursement of medical amount if any
payable to the employees, liberty is given to the members of the
petitioner to work out in accordance with law.
19. In view of the above, the writ petition is dismissed.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(S. Vaidyanathan)
Chief Justice
PRE-DELIVERY JUDGMENT IN
WP (C) No.104 of 2024
LAMPHRANG KHARCHANDY
Date: 2024.07.08 18:12:14 IST
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review