Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present : The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
&
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandip Kumar De
FMAT 441 of 2026
With
CAN 1 of 2026
The Secretary, Panskura Vidyasagar Social Welfare Society and Anr.
Vs.
The District Magistrate and Collector, Purba Medinipur and Ors.
For the appellants
:
Mr. Siddhartha Banerjee,
Mr. Abhisek Baran Das,
Mr. Arka Chandra Roy,
Mr. Aurin Chakrabarty, Advs.
For the respondent nos.
6, 7 & 8
:
Mr. T. K. Sinha,
Mr. Sk. Rejaul Alam, Advs.
Heard on
:
October 15, 2026.
Judgment on
:
October 15, 2026.
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya , J.:
1. Affidavit of service filed today be kept on record.
2.
The present appeal arises out of a suit filed by the
plaintiffs/appellants for recovery of money alleged to have been
defalcated by the defendants/private respondents, as well as for
declaration that the plaintiffs alone have authority to submit annual
returns and function on behalf of the concerned Society, and for
declaration that the defendant nos. 6, 7 and 8/ private respondents
have no semblance of right or authority to represent the Society or
the Executive Committee thereof in any manner whatsoever before
any person or authority, along with other consequential reliefs.
3.
By the impugned order, the prayer of ad-interim injunction made
by the plaintiffs/appellants, to the effect that the private respondents
be restrained from operating the bank accounts of the Society as
well as from giving themselves out as office bearers thereof, was
refused.
4.
The learned Trial Judge, despite having observed that a prima
facie case has been made out, granted status quo directing both
the plaintiffs and the defendant nos. 6, 7 and 8 to maintain status
quo in respect of transactions in connection with the bank accounts
of the Society in respect of the suit.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the impugned
order was beyond the prayer made by the appellants as well as
would have the effect of paralysing the functioning of the Society
altogether, which is running an educational institution.
6.
Learned counsel takes the court through several documents
annexed to the injunction application before us as well as before the
Trial Court, from which it transpires that by a meeting dated
February 23, 2026, the President, that is, the father of the appellant
no. 2, Ms. Payel Sahoo, namely Shri Amiya Kumar Sahoo, presided
over the meeting where the private respondents were removed
respectively
from
the
posts
of
Secretary,
Treasurer
and
membership of the Society.
7.
Subsequent thereto, on the self-same date, the private
respondents, by forging the signature of Amiya Kumar Sahoo,
President, wrote a communication to the Joint Registrar, Office of
Firms, Societies and Non-trading Corporations, indicating that they
were the designated signatories of the Society, seeking to cancel a
copy of the minutes of a previous Annual General Meeting on the
ground that it was erroneous, and also to file annual returns afresh.
8.
By placing reliance on the said letter, annexed at page 276 of
the present injunction application, learned counsel submits that,
even on a visual comparison of the signature therein with the
signatures of the President as depicted in the earlier meetings of
February 2026, it would be revealed that the letter contained a
forged signature of the President.
9.
Taking advantage of such forgery, it is alleged that the private
respondents have appointed themselves in a subsequent meeting,
held on May 10, 2026, as various portfolio holders of the Society in
question and have started operating its bank accounts. Not
stopping there, it is argued that the private respondents have been
collecting money and have formed social media groups including
the newly inducted students, insisting upon all payments to be
made by the students to the private respondents.
10.
Learned counsel further points out that such activities are being
undertaken despite the private respondents having been already
removed from their offices on the allegation of serious monetary
defalcations.
11.
In view of arguable questions having been raised, the appeal is
admitted and is taken up for hearing.
12.
Learned counsel for the private respondents, upon being invited
by the court to address the issues raised, contends that it is the
private respondents who are the valid functionaries and portfolio
holders of the concerned Society. It is submitted that from a plain
reading of the averments made in the plaint, it would be found that
the name of the Secretary of the concerned Society, namely,
Panskura Vidyasagar Social Welfare Society, has not been
mentioned in the cause title of the plaint. In the body of the plaint, it
is submitted that the plaintiff no. 2 has claimed merely in the
capacity of being the daughter of the President of the Society. Thus,
it is argued that the suit is hit by Section 19 of the West Bengal
Societies Registration Act, 1961, which mandates that every
Society may sue or be sued in the name of the President, the
Secretary or any office bearer authorized by the governing body in
this behalf.
13.
Learned counsel next argues that the term of the erstwhile
President Amiya Kumar Sahoo expired with the financial year 20242025.
14. Thereafter, the earlier Executive Committee become defunct.
15. Subsequently, upon the private respondents being elected in the
respective portfolios in the month of May, 2026, it is them who are
entitled to operate the bank accounts of the Society and to run the
Society.
16.
Learned counsel submits that the letter dated February 23,
2026 allegedly given to the Joint Registrar is a manufactured
document produced by the appellants.
17.
Since the relief in the suit as well as the present appeal have
been primarily sought against the private respondents, we dispense
with service of notice on the other respondents.
18.
Upon a thorough perusal of the annexures to the plaint and the
injunction application and the contentions made therein, we find
sufficient substance in the contention of the appellants. Insofar as
the alleged violation of Section 19 of the 1961 Act is concerned, we
find from the cause title of the plaint that it is the Secretary of the
concerned Society which is the plaintiff no. 1 and the plaintiff no. 2
is Ms. Payel Sahoo, the Secretary herself, in her individual capacity.
19. However, in the very first paragraph of the plaint, it has been
stated that the plaintiff no. 1 is the Secretary of the Society whereas
in the affidavit filed in support of the plaint, the said plaintiff no. 2
has categorically averred that she is the plaintiff no. 1 in the suit as
well.
20.
That apart, from the averments made in paragraph no. 17 of the
plaint, it is found that the plaintiff no. 2, who is the plaintiff no. 1 (in
the capacity of Secretary of the Society) as well, was appointed as
such Secretary in the month of February, 2026. Necessary
documents, being the minutes of the said meetings dated February
16, 2026 and February 23, 2026, have also been annexed to the
injunction
application,
thereby
prima
facie
supporting
the
contentions made in the said paragraph of the plaint.
21.
It is well-settled that merely upon expiry of the tenure of the
erstwhile Executive Committee of a Society, the Committee does
not automatically become defunct unless a new body is elected by
a valid process of election, since otherwise, the Society would run
in a vacuum and, consequentially, its functioning will come to a
stand-still. Even as per the case of the respondents as canvassed
before us, the private respondents came into the picture only in the
month of May, 2026. Taking the averments in the plaint
chronologically, we find that prior to such election, on February 23,
2026, the private respondents had already been removed,
respectively from the posts of the Secretary, Treasurer and ordinary
membership of the same.
22.
Thus, as on May 10, 2026, they did not have any locus standi to
convene a further meeting.
23.
Also, in the resolution of May 10, 2026 on the strength of which
the private respondents seek to derive power, the respondent no. 6,
namely Sk. Mohammad Ali has described himself to be the
President, which is contrary to the position as on that date, since
Amiya Kumar Sahoo was still the existing President.
24.
From the rules and regulations of the Society, which are also
annexed in the present pleadings, we find that it is the President,
who shall preside over all meeting of the Executive Committee.
25.
Moreover, Regulation 13 provides that the banking accounts of
the Society shall be operated by the President, Secretary and
Treasurer, any of them jointly.
26.
In view of the above observations, based on the materials
placed before the Trial Court and before us, it transpires that a
strong
prima
facie
case
has
been
made
out
by
the
plaintiffs/appellants for getting an injunction as prayed for at the adinterim stage.
27.
We cannot also fail to take note of the fact that the learned Trial
Judge, despite having considered the respective cases of the
parties and having observed that the plaintiffs have prima facie
established a case to go for trial and that delay might defeat the
purpose for which ad-interim injunction was required, arrived at a
contradictory conclusion by granting a blanket order of status quo
restraining both the plaintiffs as well as the defendant nos. 6, 7 and
8 in respect of any transaction with respect of the bank accounts of
the concerned Society. Not only is the operating portion of the
impugned order contradictory to the findings arrived at therein, but
the same is also beyond the prayers made by the plaintiffs.
28.
It trite law that at the ad-interim stage, it is the averments made
in the plaint and injunction application and the documents relied on
therein which are to be taken as sacrosanct for the purpose of
considering grant of ad-interim injunction. In consonance with the
findings of the learned Trial Judge himself, we also find that a
strong prima facie case has been made out and that delay may
defeat the purpose of the injunction.
29.
Accordingly, FMAT 441 of 2026 is allowed, thereby setting aside
the impugned order dated September 24, 2026 passed by the
learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), First Court at Tamluk, District
– Purba Medinipur in Title Suit no. 266 of 2026 and granting adinterim injunction restraining the defendants/ respondent nos. 6, 7
and 8 from giving themselves out to be office bearers of the
Panskura Vidyasagar Social Welfare Society and/or from operating
the bank accounts of the said Society till disposal of the temporary
injunction application by the learned Trial Judge. The said private
respondents shall file their written objection to the injunction
application by November 13, 2026. In the event the said objection is
filed by the aforesaid date, the learned Trial Judge shall dispose of
the temporary injunction application as expeditiously as possible,
positively by December 15, 2026.
30.
We make it clear that the merits of the respective contentions of
the parties have not been conclusively decided by us and the above
findings are only tentative in nature, binding only at the stage of adinterim injunction, and the learned Trial Judge will be at liberty to
independently decide the injunction application and the suit on their
own merits, without being unduly influenced in any manner by any
of the observations made hereinabove or in the impugned order.
31. Consequentially, CAN 1 of 2026 is also disposed of.
32.
There will be no order as to costs.
33.
Urgent photostat certified copies of this judgment, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all requisite
formalities.
34.
All concerned are to act on the server copy of this judgment
without insisting unnecessarily upon prior production of a certified
copy thereof.
I agree.
(Sandip Kumar De, J.)
AD-11
Ct No.16
(SSS)
(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review