Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
T AX REVISION CASE NO: 233 OF 2009
Tax Revision Case under Section 22(1) Read with Rule 40 of APGST Rules
under Section APGST Act to revise the order dated 01.06.2009 passed in
T.A.No.428l2008 on the file of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, Andhra Pradesh,
Hyderabad.
Between:
ih" Strte of Andhra Pradesh, Rep.by the State Representative before STAT
D.No.5-4-404 to 408, Nampally, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad
...PETITIONER/RESPONDENT
AND
M/s.DR.Reddys Laboratories Limited, 7-1-27, Ameerpet, Hyderabad - 500 016
,..RESPONDENT'APPELLANT
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRl. T.CHAITANYA KIRAN
Counsel for the Respondent : SRI RAGHAV CHADA, REP.SRI KARTHIK
RAMANA PUTTAM REDDY
The Court made the following: ORDER
e
TN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TE:L {NGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM Ko ]HY .
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHAL,,I PATHI RAO TREVC.No.233 of 2OO9
Dfiq}r.2026
Between:
The State ofAndhra Pradesh
Petitioner
And
M/s Dr.Reddy's Laboratories Limited.
ORDER:
Respondent
(Per the Horr'ble Sr[ Justtce Suddata Chalapothr llc r
The present Tax Revision Case arises olr of the order,
dt.O1.06.2009, passed by the Sa-les Tax Apg,r llate Tribuna,l,
Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad (for short '1cir Led STATJ
IN
TA.No.428 of 2008,
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, the respo rdent/assessee,
was on the rolls of the Assistant Commissi rner(CT) (LTU),
Punjagutta Division, Hyderabad. The Deputy Co:.missioner (CT),
Punjagutta, had submitted refund claim c I the assessee
amounting to Rs.2,87,14,114 /- relating to sales tax relief on
closing stock held as on 01.O4.2005.
3.
The said order granting refund was revised by the Joint
Commissioner(CT), Audit-ll, Office of the Commissioner of
Commercial Taxes, A.P., uide proceedings in CCT's Ref.No.BVI(1)
Refunds/ 16l2OO5, dt.06.04.2008, and
held that
the
respondent/ assessee was not liable to the refund on the closing
stock as on O1.04.2005, and accordingly, rejected the refund
claim.
4.
Assailing the said order of the Joint Comlnissioner, the
respondent/assessee filed an appeetl before the learned STAT in
TA.No.428 of 2008. The learned STAT, a-fter appreciation of the
facts and evidence on record, allowed the appeal by setting aside
the orders of the Joint Comrnissioner, dt.O6.O4.2008 and directed
the Assessing Authorily to grant the refund to the
respondent/ assessee on the closing stock as on O1'04.2005,
challenging the said order, the petitioner/ Revenue has frled the
instant Tax Revision Case.
5.
Heard Sri T.Chaitanya Kiran, learned Asstste nt Government
Pieader for State Tax appea-r-ing for the petitioni r/Revenue, Sri
Raghav Chadha, learned counsel representing Sn L ztrthik Ramana
Puttam Reddy, learned counsel for the respondentT assessee
6.
The iearned Assistant Goven-.ment Pleadcr ;eprcsenting thc
petitioner/ State contended that the iealned STAT fai 3d to appreciate
the fact that there was no violation of principles of r r tural justice. It
was contended that although the Joint Commissionr,' , u,ho heard the
revision proceedings namely Sri Dr.K.Ravindra, on 15. ).3.2007, \A'as not
the officer, who has passed the irnpugned order, the sur:cessor Joint
Commissioner, Sri K.Raghavaiah, passed the impugrr rrl order revising
the order of the Deputy Commissioner, only after dul considering the
facts-and material available on record. Thus, it is c:: rtended that the
learned STAT grossly erred in reversing the well < rnsidered order,
dt.06.04.2OO8, passed b5; the Joint-Commissioner.
7.
The learned Assistant Government Pleader rr so contends that
the respondent/ assessee has not furnished the det uls ol the stock
showing that they are purchased prior to 31.03.200: and the learned
STAT has not appreciated the facts on proper persp( ( tive and erred in
reversing the u,ell considered findings of the Joint (l rmmissioner and
there is no violation of principles of natural justice as the incumbent
Joint Commissioner, after perusing the material on record, passed the
impugned order under appeal beforc the learncd STAT
8.
Per contra, Iearned counsel for the responden t/assessee
contended that the order of the Joint Commissioner was vitiated
on the ground of violation of principles of natura-l justice, as the
matter was heard by one Sri Dr.K.Ravindra, the then Joint
Commissioncr on 15.O7.2OO7, the Sltccessor-in-Office i.c.,
Dr.K.Ragavaiah, without affording any opportunity, passed the
impugned order revising arrd setting aside the orders passed by
the Deputy Commissioner(CT), Punlagutta, and the learned STAT
appreciated the said fact ancl held that there is viola.tion of
principles of natural justice.
9.
The other contention raised by the respondent/ assessee was
that uncler Section 13 of the VAT Act, input ta-x credit is a-llou'able
to a VAT dealer irr respect of tax paid on pu:chases of taxable
goods used in the course of business, in terms of Sche<lu1e
VI.(2)(a), which entitles a dcaler registered as a VAI dealer'on the
date of commencement of VAT Act, to claim input tax credit fcr the
r^)
''('\
sales tax paid under the APGST Act, 1957, on the s iock purchased
in the state, subject to the requirement that, tlr: goods should
havc been purchased during the period from Ol .O4.2OO4 to
31.O3.2005. In the case of the respondent/ assesr; r:, as the goods
were purchased during the said period, the respc -rdent/assessee
was eligibie for input tax credit. Further, it is co::ended that the
Deputy Commissioner (CT), Punjagutta, had rigt tly allowed the
refund claim by order, dt.O4.09.2006,
10. It tvas further contended by the (1,) tnsel for the
respondent/assessee that the learned STAT, aftc examining the
evidence and statutory provisions, categorically ,leld that there
was clear violation of principles of natural jr stice artd also
misinterpretation of Seclion 13 of the VAT A r t b1, the Joint
Commissioner u,hile refusing the input tax crec r for the goods,
purchased from 01.04.2004 to 31.03.2005, ancl thus, contends
that the learned STAT, on both counts, has ri11 rtly allowed the
appeal and directed the Assessing Authority to qrant input tax
credit to the respondent/assessee for the disprr ed stock period
and prayed to dismiss the instant tax revision cas,
.
We have given earnest consideration to the submissions made
by both the counsel appearing on either side and perused the
material on record.
12. The main contention of the learned Assistant Government Pleader
for the petitioner/ Revenue is that, even assuming that there rvas
violation of the principles of natural justice as the ofhcer who heard the
revision did not pass the revision order, the said ordcr ought to be
sustained as it rvas passed by the incumbent offrcer after considering
the facts and materials on record.
13. In the considered view of this Court, the said contention cannot
be accepted, in the facts and circumstances of the case, as the affected
party is the respondent/ assessee, who was denied the right of ar.tdience
b), the successor Joint Commissioner and inasmuch as the
respondent/ assessee challenged the said order before the learned STAT,
which, after hearing both parties, recorded a categcrical finding that
there was a violation of the principles of natural justice and, on that
ground also, the order of the Joint Con:rmissioner was held to be uoid
and non est in the eye of law.
14. Further, the learned STAT, upon proper appreciation of
Section 13 of the VAT Act, held that a dealer registered as a VAT
a)
dealer as on the date of comnrencement of the Gii' ' Act is entitled
to claim input ta-x credit for sales tax paid unde ^ the APGST Act
on the stock held as on O 1.04.2005, provided I rtch stock was
purchased during the period from 01.04.2004 to : .03.2005.
15. In the instant case, it is undisp.-;.t:d that the
respondent/ assessee had purchased the stock , uring the said
period from 01.04.2OO4 to 31.03.2OO5. Thus, tL e learned STAT
rightly held that the respondent/ assessee was r ligible to claim
input tax credit ald also consequential refund. rvidently, these
(
(
statutory provisions came into force w.e.f., O i .04. )005, which are
properly interpreted and applied by the learned S'[ \T.
16. As such, the findings recorded by the learr t cl STAT on both
counts namely violation of principles of nat'-l -a-l justice and
entitlement to input tax credit under Section 1li of the VAT Act,
are well reasoned, justified and based on prop(,l appreciation of
Iaw and facts, and needs no interference by this t) rurt
17. The substantial question of law is acco: Iingly answered
against the petitioner/Revenue and in
I
t
avour of
the
'o
B
respondent/ assessee, and the Tax Revision Case is devoid of any
merits and liable to be dismissed.
18. In the result, the Tax Revlsion Case is dismissed confirming
the order, dt.01.06.2009, passed by the learned STAT in
TA.No.428 of 20O8. No order as to c,rsts.
As a bequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions. if any, pending
shall stand closed.
D/- L. LAKSHMI BABU
DEPUTY REGISTRA
\
//TRUE COPY//
CTION OFFICER
To,
. The Registrar, Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, A
(With Records)
hr
Z. bne CC to Sri'T.Chartanya Kiran, Advocate (OPUC )
3. One CC to Sri Karthik Ramana, Advocate (OPUU)
4. Two CD CoPies
Ks/PSL
o
Pradesh, Hyderabad
HIGH COURT
DATED:0910112026
( oB. 1l't
o
o
t
ORDER
TR.E.V.C.No.233 of 2009
Dismissing the TREVC.
Without Costs.
)Ta
0I r,t1
*
Bt-- :'I
-'-
=='
*
zr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review