Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010283762023
2026:GAU-AS:7347
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
1.
MAC APPEAL NO. 458 OF 2023
The Reliance General Insurance Company Limited,
having its registered Office at 19,
Reliance Centre, Walchand Hirachand Marg,
Ballard Estate, Mumbai- 400001
and Corporate Office at 570, Rectifier House,
Nagaum Cross, next to Royal Industries Estate,
Wadala (W), Mumbai-400031
and one of the Branch Offices at Prag Plaza,
5th Floor, Bhangagarh, Guwahati- 781005.
……..Appellant
-Versus1.Smti Rita Bora,
W/o- Late Sarat Bora,
R/o- House No. 20, Bye Lane No. 2,
Shreenagar, P.O. and P.S.- Dispur,
Guwahati- 781005, Assam
2.Bhagadutta Medhi,
S/o-Horeswar Medhi,
Village- Palasung, P.S.- Jagiroad
District- Morigaon, Assam
Pin- 782410.
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 1
3.Md. Jahirul Islam,
S/o-Abdul Wahab,
Village- Garaimari, P.S.- Laharighat,
District- Morigaon, Assam, Pin- 782127
……..Respondents
2.MAC APPEAL NO. 422 OF 2023
Smti Rita Bora,
W/o- Late Sarat Bora,
R/o- House No. 20, Bye Lane No. 2,
Sheenagar, P.O. and P.S.- Dispur,
Guwahati- 781005, Assam
-Versus1.Bhagadutta Medhi,
S/o- Horeswar Medhi,
R/o- Village Palasung, P.S.- Jagiroad
District- Morigaon, Assam
Pin- 782410.
2.Md. Jahirul Islam,
S/o- Abdul Wahab,
Village- Garaimari, P.S.- Laharighat,
District- Morigaon, Assam, Pin- 782127
3.Reliance General Insurance Company Limited,
Registered Office & Corporate Office6thFloor,
Oberoi Commerz, International Business Park
Oberoi Garden City, Off. Western Express Highway
Goregaon (E), Mumbai 400063
Regional Office
5thFloor, Prag Plaza
Bhangagarh, Guwahati 781005, Assam
……..Respondents
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 2
: BEFORE ::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
For the Appellant
: Mr. A. J. Saikia, Advocate
(in MAC Appeal No. 458/2023)
:Mr. A. Lal, Advocate
(inMAC Appeal No. 422/2023)
For the Respondents : Mr. A. J. Saikia, Advocate
(for respondent No.3 in MAC Appeal No. 422/2023)
: Mr. A. Lal, Advocate
(for respondent/claimant
in MAC Appeal No.458/2023)
Date of Hearing
: 22.01.2026
Date of Judgment
: 19.05.2026
JUDGMENT & ORDER
1.
Heard Mr. A. J. Saikia, the learned counsel for the appellant
in MAC Appeal No. 458/2023 and respondent No. 3 in MAC Appeal
No. 422/2023. Also heard Mr. A. Lal, the learned counsel for the
respondent/claimant in MAC Appeal No. 458/2023 and appellant in
MAC Appeal No. 422/2023.
2.
By this common judgment, this Court proposes to dispose
of MAC Appeal No. 458/2023 as well as MAC Appeal No. 422/2023
as both the appeal arose out of a common judgment and award
dated 14.09.2023 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.
1, Kamrup(M), Assam in MAC Case No. 381/2018.
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 3
3.
The Reliance General Insurance Company has filed the MAC
Appeal
No.
458/2023
challenging
the
quantum
of
the
compensation, which was granted to the claimant/respondent No.
1. The contention of the Insurance Company is that the
compensation awarded to the claimant is on the higher side. On the
other hand, the MAC Appeal No. 422/2023 has been filed by the
claimant/respondent praying for enhancement of the compensation
awarded to her on the ground that the compensation awarded to
her is on the lower side.
4.
The facts relevant for consideration of both the appeals, in
brief, are that the appellant in MAC Appeal No. 458/2023, namely,
Smt. Rita Bora has preferred a claim petition under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 seeking compensation on account of
death of her husband late Sarat Bora in a motor vehicular accident
on 09.08.2020. The vehicular accident in which the husband of the
claimant expired occurred, on 10.10.2017 at about 6:15 PM, near
Demow Chariali on National Highway No. 37, Nagaon.
5.
It is stated in the claim petition that on the date of accident,
the husband of the claimant was knocked by a motorcycle bearing
Registration No. AS-21-F-4610 which was driven in a rash and
negligent manner at the time when the accident occurred. On the
basis of the claim petition filed by the claimant, MAC Case No.
381/2018 was registered. The Insurance Company contested the
claim by filing written statement. However, the inquiry proceeded
ex-parte against the owner and the driver of the offending vehicle.
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 4
6.
On the basis of the pleading of both the parties, following
issues were framed by the Tribunal:
a. Whether the deceased Sarat Bora had died of injuries
sustained in road accident on 10.10.2017 that have been
caused due to rash and negligent driving by the driver of
the alleged offending vehicle bearing Registration No.
AS-21-F-4610?
b. Whether the claimants are entitled to get any
compensation and if yes, to what extent and by whom
amongst the opposite parties, the said compensation
amount is to be paid?
7.
In support of the claim, the claimants examined two
witnesses, namely, the claimant No.1 Smt. Rita Bora herself as PW1 and one Subhajit Dutta as PW-2. The Insurance Company did not
adduce any counter evidence. Ultimately, by the impugned
judgment and award, an amount of Rs.27,81,000/- was awarded to
the claimant with an interest at the rate of 6% per annum excluding
the interest on future prospect from the date of filing of the claim
petition till the date of realization.
8.
Mr. A. J. Saikia, the learned counsel for the Insurance
Company has contended that while assessing the annual income of
the deceased, the concerned Tribunal failed to take into
consideration that the deceased was shown to be an employee of a
NGO, namely, Prakriti Sishu Kalyan Samity. However, he submits
that though the Tribunal accepted the salary slip as well as
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 5
appointment letter exhibited by the claimant during the claim
proceeding, the Tribunal failed to take into consideration that the
claimant failed to produce any PAN, TAN or income tax return (ITR)
to show the earnings of the said NGO and its capacity to pay the
salary shown to have been paid to the claimant. He submits that
the Tribunal has erred in computing the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs. 20,000/- which is on a higher side. The learned
counsel for the Insurance Company has also submitted that the
tribunal has also erred in adding 30% income of the victim of the
deceased against loss of future prospect.
9.
He also submits that the Tribunal also erred in deducting
one third of the income of the deceased against his living and
personal expenses, whereas the deduction ought to have been at
the rate of 50% as the only dependent was the present claimant
and his daughter expired during the pendency of the inquiry. He
submits that otherwise also the daughter being a married daughter
was not a dependent of the deceased and therefore, deduction of
one third of income for personal and living expenses of the
deceased was not right. In support of his submissions, the learned
counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company has cited following
rulings of this Court:
i.
New India Assurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Babita Singh
@ Singha and Others (MAC App./197/2019 dated 07.03.2022)
ii.
United India Insurance Company Limited Vs. Rajumai Medhi
and Another (MAC App./698/2022, dated 14.09.2019)
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 6
10.
On the other hand, Mr. A. Lal, the learned counsel for the
claimant and appellant in MAC Appeal No. 422/2023 has submitted
that the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal had erred in awarding the
compensation to the claimant on a lower side. He submits that there
is categorical evidence as regards the monthly income of the
deceased as Rs. 25,000/- including Rs.5,000/- as allowances.
However, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal had erred in excluding
the allowances of Rs. 5,000/- received by the deceased while
computing his monthly salary.
11.
He submits that in this regard, the Supreme Court of India,
has clarified in the case of “Manorama Sinha and Another Vs.
Divisional Manager, Oriental Insurance Company Limited and
Another” reported in 2025 SCC Online 2241 that the allowances
received by the deceased had to be taken into consideration during
computation to be arrived at decision as regards the income of the
deceased. He also submits that the Tribunal has also erred in
granting only Rs. 44,000/- against the head of loss of spousal
consortium as the said amount is extremely low and does not justify
to be regarded as just compensation.
12.
He also submits that the Tribunal was correct in deducting
only one-third of the earning of the deceased towards his personal
expenses as the daughter of the deceased alive when the claim case
was filed by the present claimant. He submits that the claims and
legal liabilities crystallize at the time of accident itself and changes
posed thereto ought not to ordinarily affect the pending
proceedings and as such, subsequent death of the daughter of the
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 7
deceased during the pendency of the inquiry has no impact on the
pending proceedings. In support of his submission, the learned
counsel for the claimant has cited a ruling of Apex Court in the case
of “Kirti and Another Vs. Oriental Insurance Company Limited”
reported in (2021) 2 SCC 166.
13.
The learned counsel for the claimant has also submitted
that the claimant has adduced the evidence of the employer of her
deceased husband and who has categorically exhibited the salary
slip which indicates that the salary of the deceased was Rs. 25,000/. He submits that in a claim case, the claimant is not required to
prove the contentions in support of her claim beyond all reasonable
doubt, it is sufficient if she is able to prove her contentions on the
touchstone of preponderance of probability, which she has already
done.
14.
The learned counsel for the claimant submits that the
insurance company has failed to rebut the evidence adduced by the
claimant and has also failed to adduce any counter evidence and as
such the plea by the learned counsel for the insurance company
that the claimant has unable to prove the monthly income of her
deceased husband is not tenable and is liable to be rejected. He
also submits that the interest awarded on the compensation
awarded to the claimant is on the lower side and it should be
increased to 18% considering the rate of inflation of the other
essential
commodities.
He,
therefore,
submits
that
the
compensation awarded to the claimant may accordingly be
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 8
enhanced. In support of his submission the learned counsel for the
claimant, apart from the judgments which have already been
referred hereinbefore, has cited following rulings.
i.
Mohd. Ameeruddin and Another Vs. United India Insurance
Company Limited reported in (2011) 1 SCC 304
ii.
New
India
Assurance
Company
Limited
Vs.
Pratiksha
Hemchandra Kulkarni and Others reported in 2019 SCC Online
BOM 647.
iii.
Kamakhya Saha and Another Vs. Basanti Rani Das and Another
reported in 2015 SCC Online GAU 1026.
iv.
Rajwati alias Rajjo and Other Vs. United India Insurance
Company Limited and others reported in 2022 SCC Online SC
1699.
15.
I have considered the submissions made by the learned
counsel for both sides and have gone through the materials
available on record. I have also gone through the rulings cited by
the learned counsel for both sides in support of their respective
submissions.
16.
On perusal of the impugned judgment, it appears that the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, after considering the materials on
record, while deciding the issue No.1, had arrived at a conclusion
that the vehicular accident which occurred on 10.10.2017, in which
the husband of the claimant, namely, late Sarat Bora expired, was
caused on account of negligence of the driver of the offending
vehicle. This finding is not agitated by the insurance company. The
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 9
appeal of the insurance company is directed mainly towards the
quantum of compensation awarded to the claimant.
17.
It appears that in paragraph No.17 of the impugned
judgment, the Tribunal, after perusing the salary slips of the
deceased Sarat Bora, though, came to the finding that he was
getting an amount of Rs. 20,000/- per month as salary and Rs.
5,000/- for miscellaneous expenses, however, it computed the
monthly salary only at Rs. 20,000/- by excluding the amount of Rs.
5,000/- which he was getting as allowances. In this regard, the Apex
Court has observed in the case of ““Manorama Sinha and Another
Vs. Divisional Manager, Oriental Insurance Company Limited and
Another” (Supra) that the allowances ought to be included while
assessing the monthly income of a person of the deceased
irrespective of fact that whether the same is taxable or not. As such,
this Court is of the consider opinion that the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal had erred in excluding the allowances of Rs. 5,000/received by the deceased husband of the claimant when computing
his monthly income. As such, the monthly income of the deceased
is computed at Rs. 25,000/- instead of Rs.20,000/-.
18.
As regards the addition of 30% of the established monthly
income of the deceased towards the head “future prospect” is
concerned, it appears that in the case of “Sarla Verma and Others
Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Others” reported in (2009) 6 SCC
121, it was held that there should be an addition of 30% if the age
of the deceased was between 40-50 years. However, that is
applicable only when the deceased had a permanent job. In case
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 10
where the deceased was self-employed or on a fixed salary, an
addition of 25% where the age of the deceased was between 4050 years was suggested by the Apex Court in the case of “National
Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi and Others” reported in
(2017) 16 SCC 680. In the instant case, there is no material to
suggest that the deceased was doing a permanent job. Rather, the
evidence suggests that he was employed in a non-governmental
organization at a fixed salary of Rs. 20,000/- per month plus
allowances of Rs. 5,000/- per month. As such, in view of the
guidelines of the Apex Court in the case of “National Insurance
Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi and Others” (Supra) the addition
of 25% to the actual salary of the deceased is justified against the
loss of future prospect and as the Tribunal has already indicated,
no interest is awarded against such addition of future prospect.
19.
As regards fixed amount of Rs. 44,000/- awarded against
loss of spousal consortium to the claimant, same appears to be in
conformity with the guidelines issued by the Apex Court in the case
of “National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi and
Others” (Supra). Hence, it needs no interference.
20.
As regards deduction towards personal and living expenses
of the deceased, this Court is of considered opinion that Tribunal
was correct in deducting one-third of the income of the deceased
towards his personal and living expenses. As at the time of filing of
the claim petition, the daughter of the deceased was alive, and in
the evidence adduced by CW-1, it has been specifically mentioned
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 11
by her that the deceased used to contribute towards expenses of
his daughter also. Considering the fact that at the time of filing of
the claim case by the claimant, the deceased had two dependents,
including the claimant and her daughter, the subsequent death of
the daughters cannot be a reason for increasing the deduction
towards personal and living expenses of the deceased to 50%
instead of one-third. In this regard, the observations made by the
Apex Court in the case of “Kirti and Another Vs. Oriental Insurance
Company Limited” reported in (2021) 2 SCC 166, are relevant, which
are quoted herein below:
“9. We have thoughtfully considered the rival
submissions. It cannot be disputed that at the time of
death, there in fact were four dependants of the deceased
and not three. The subsequent death of the deceased's
dependant mother ought not to be a reason for reduction
of motor accident compensation. Claims and legal
liabilities crystallise at the time of the accident itself, and
changes post thereto ought not to ordinarily affect
pending proceedings. Just like how the appellant
claimants cannot rely upon subsequent increases in
minimum wages, the respondent insurer too cannot seek
benefit of the subsequent death of a dependant during
the pendency of legal proceedings. Similarly, any
concession in law made in this regard by either counsel
would not bind the parties, as it is legally settled that
advocates cannot throw away legal rights or enter into
arrangements contrary to law. “
21.
Further, though the interest paid for by the claimant
appellant at the rate of 18% appears to be on a much higher side,
however, the interest awarded by the Tribunal at the rate of 6%
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 12
also appears to be on a lower side. Hence, same is enhanced at the
rate of Rs 7.5% per annum.
22.
Thus, taking the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.
25,000/- and adding the 25% thereto as future prospect, the annual
income of the deceased at the time of accident comes at Rs.
3,75,000/-. After deduction of one-third from the same on account
of expenses towards living and personal expenses of the deceased,
the amount comes at Rs 2,50,000/-. Since the age of the deceased
was assessed at 47 years, hence, the multiplier of 13 is to be applied
to the aforesaid multiplicand and accordingly, the amount comes to
Rs 32,50,000/-.
23.
With the aforesaid amount, i.e., Rs 32,50,000/-, if the
compensation awarded against the head funeral expenses, loss of
estate and loss of spousal consortium is added at the rate of Rs
16,500/-, Rs 16,500 and Rs 44,000/- respectively, the total
compensation to be awarded to the claimant comes at Rs
33,27,000/-.
24.
Accordingly, the claimant is entitled to get a compensation
amount of Rs 33,27,000/- along with an interest at the rate of Rs.
7.5% thereon. Further, since in pursuing these appeals, a period of
three years has already lapsed, the claimant shall deposit only Rs
7,00,000/- out of the aforesaid amount as fixed deposit in her name
in a nationalized bank for a period of two years and remaining
amount shall be disbursed to her.
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 13
25.
The insurance company is directed to disburse the amount
which is payable to the claimant in terms of the above directions
minus the amount which has already been paid to her within a
period of six weeks from the date of this judgment.
26.
Both these appeals are accordingly disposed of.
27.
Let the records of the MAC Case No. 381/2018 be send back
to the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal No. 1, Kamrup (M),
Guwahati along with a copy of this judgment.
Amita
Sharma
Digitally signed
by Amita Sharma
Date: 2026.05.27
12:26:09 +05'30'
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
MACApp./458/2023
with MACApp./422/2023
Page 14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review