Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC. APP.No.30 of 2023
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited,
represented by the Divisional Manager,
Agartala, Division Office,
H.G.B. Road (Near Sarkar Nursing Home),
Agartala, West Tripura
---- Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Smt. Sandhya Debnath,
wife of late Jitendra Debnath
2. Master Diptanu Debnath,
son of late Jitendra Debnath
3. Miss Diya Debnath,
daughter of late Jitendra Debnath
4. Sri Bimal Debnath,
son of late Jitendra Debnath,
all are residents of Village-Chandraichara,
P.S. Ambassa, District- Dhalai Tripura,
Agartala, P.S. East Agartala, District- West Tripura
The petitioner Nos.2 & 3 being minors are represented
by their natural guardian and next friend mother,
the petitioner No.1.
----Claimant-Respondent(s)
Sri Manik Lal Saha,
son of Subal Chandra Saha,
resident of Village-jangalia,
P.O. Bishalgarh, P.S. Bishalgarh,
District- Sepahijala, Tripura
(Owner of the Truck bearing No.NL-01-N-0176)
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Samar Das, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
20.02.2024
Date of Judgment
& Order
:
23.02.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Mr. Biswanath Majumder, Learned counsel appearing
for the appellant-Oriental Insurance Company Limited as well as Mr.
Samar Das, Learned counsel appearing for the claimant-respondents.
None appeared for the other respondent when the matter is called out.
2.
This is an appeal by the Insurer namely Oriental Insurance
Company Limited challenging the judgment and award dated 06.12.2022
passed by the Learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.1, West
Tripura, Agartala in connection with Case No.T.S.(MAC)169 of 2020.
3.
The genesis of the case of the respondent-claimants before
the Learned tribunal was that on 16.10.2020 at about 6:30 am in the
morning when the victim Jitendra Debnath along with one co-worker
namely Amit Paul were proceeding towards Jaharnagar towards Ambassa
by riding the motor cycle bearing registration No.TR-02-F-5664 with
normal speed and when they reached near the house of one Bikram Das
that time one twelve wheeler Truck bearing registration No.NL-01-N0176 was coming from the opposite direction being driven by the driver
very rashly and negligently and at a very high speed lost control over the
vehicle and dashed against the said motor cycle coming to the wrong
side of the road resulting which the victim Jitendra Debnath sustained
fracture injuries on his person and fell down on the road with severe
bleeding injuries and died at the spot. After the accident, the driver of
the offending Truck was trying to flee away from the place of occurrence
with the Truck by driving the same and as a result, the driver of the said
Truck again lost control over the vehicle and dashed another female
person namely Riya Namasura who also died at the spot.
Thereafter,
postmortem examination was done over the dead bodies by doctor of
Kulai Hospital, Ambassa on the same day. Further, according to the
claimant-petitioners, the accident took place due to rash and negligent
driving with high speed by the driver of the Truck bearing registration
No.NL-01-N-0176.
4.
Regarding the accident an FIR was registered with Ambassa
Police Station vide Ambassa P.S. Case No.45 of 2020 under Sections
279/338/304(A) of IPC and the respondent-claimants ultimately filed the
claim petition before the Learned tribunal. Before the tribunal, the OP
owner filed written statement denying the assertions of the respondentclaimant petitioners and also took the plea that the accident occurred on
that day due to rash and negligent driving of the rider of the motor bike
bearing registration No.TR-02-F-5664 and further took the plea that on
the alleged day his vehicle was duly insured with the Oriental Insurance
Company and if any compensation is awarded that should be paid by the
Insurer of the said vehicle. The noticee i.e. the Oriental Insurance
Company Limited also filed written statement denying the entire
assertions. They also took the plea that the accident occurred due to
rash and negligent driving of the motor cycle by the deceased. As such,
the petitioners are not entitled to get any compensation and also took
the plea that the owner of the Truck is to produce the original Insurance
policy of the vehicle along with the driving license of the driver with other
relevant documents and prayed for dismissal of the claim petition. On the
pleadings of the parties, three issues were framed and both the parties
adduced evidence and finally by the judgment/award as aforesaid
Learned tribunal below awarded compensation allowing the prayer of the
claimant-petitioners. For the sake of convenience, the operative portion
of the order of Learned tribunal below runs as follows :
“It is, therefore, held that the petitioners are entitled to
get compensation of Rs.32,33,000/- (Rupees Thirty two
Lakh Thirty three Thousand only) with interest @ 9%
per annum from 24.11.2020 i.e. from the date of filing
of the claim petition till the date of actual payment. The
Noticee No.2 Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. is directed to
make the payment of compensation with interest within
30 days from today.
Out of the awarded amount of compensation inclusive
of interest, the petitioner no.1 will get 40% and other
petitioners no.2,3 and 4 will get 20% each. Out of the
respective share of the petitioners no.1 and 4, 50%
each of their share shall be kept in a fixed deposit
scheme in their respective names in any Nationalized
Bank for a period of five years each and rest 50% of
their respective share will be paid to them through their
respective Bank Account. However, the petitioners No.1
and 4 shall be entitled to receive monthly interest
therefrom for their day to day expenses. The entire
share of minor petitioners no.2 and 3 will be kept in fixe
deposit scheme in their respective names in the same
bank and branch of the petitioners no.1 and 4 till they
become major i.e. 21 years of age. The petitioner no.1
being the natural guardian and next friend mother of
the minor petitioners no.2 and 3 is also entitled to
receive monthly interest from their fixed deposit
account and to utilize the same for their proper
upbringing. No loan or withdrawal shall be permitted
from any of the fixed deposit accounts without prior
permission of this Tribunal.”
Challenging the judgment/award as aforestated, the present
appellant has preferred this appeal before the High Court.
5.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned counsel for the
appellants submitted that the judgment/award of the Learned tribunal
suffers from various infirmities as because the owner of the offending
motor cycle was not made as party by the respondent-claimant
petitioners in the original claim petition. No enquiry was made by the
tribunal under Section 169 of the M.V. Act.
6.
Learned counsel for
the
appellant
further
drawn
the
attention of the Court that by the impugned judgment/award the father
of the deceased was treated as the dependent but as per law he was not
dependent and there was no such evidence on record that the father of
the deceased was dependent on the income of the deceased. As such,
Learned tribunal below committed serious infirmities in the process of
assessment of compensation.
7.
Further, according to Learned counsel for the appellant, the
respondent-claimant petitioners before the tribunal failed to produce and
proof any income certificate of the deceased, no certificate showing the
actual age of the deceased was produced before the Learned tribunal by
the respondent-claimant petitioners and the Learned tribunal also failed
to frame the proper issues. So, according to the Learned counsel, the
award of the Learned tribunal was suffers from various infirmities and
furthermore, in deciding the compensation Learned tribunal awarded
interest @ 9% p.a. which was too excessive and high beyond the
principles of law laid down by this High Court. Even, the driving license of
the driver of the motor bike was not produced before the Learned
tribunal by the respondent-claimant petitioners. So, Learned counsel for
the appellant at the time of hearing of argument submitted that as the
Learned tribunal below did not consider the above aspects in delivering
the judgment/award, so, the appeal be allowed by setting aside the
judgment of the Learned tribunal.
8.
On the contrary, Learned counsel for the respondent-
claimant petitioners strongly countered the submission made by Learned
counsel for the appellant and submitted that the Insurance Company has
no locus standi to file this appeal under Section 149(2) of M.V. Act being
a noticee and furthermore, the driver of the offending Truck was not a
necessary party for determination of the compensation because as per
the policy it was the joint liability of the owner of the offending Truck as
well as the Insurer to pay compensation to the actual claimants. Learned
counsel for the respondent-claimant petitioners further submitted that
after considering the oral and documentary evidence on record, Learned
tribunal below rightly determined the amount of compensation. So,
Learned counsel for the respondent-claimant petitioners finally urged for
dismissal of the appeal upholding the judgment of the Learned tribunal
below. In support of his contention, Learned counsel for the respondentclaimant petitioners referred few citations.
9.
I have heard submission of Learned counsels at length and
also gone through the record of the Learned tribunal below and also the
citations as referred by the Learned counsel for the respondent-claimant
petitioners. The Learned tribunal below at the time of determination of
compensation determined the compensation to Rs.32,33,000/-(Rupees
Thirty Two Lakh Thirty Three Thousand only) and awarded interest @ 9%
p.a. from 24.11.2020 i.e. from the date of filing the claim petition by the
respondent-claimant petitioners till the date of actual payment.
10.
In The IFFCO TOKIO General Insurance Company
Limited versus Smti. Uma Adhikari (Barua) [judgment dated
27.01.2017 in MAC.APP.No.26 of 2016] this High Court at the time of
determination of the appeal in para-6 observed as under :
“6. Mr. Das, learned counsel has relied a decision of this
court in New India Assurance Company Limited versus
Bishaka Rudra Paul and Another reported in (2014) 1
TLR 497, where this court has clearly held that :
“The insurer as the noticee has no locus
standi to challenge the award passed by the
tribunal on questioning its legality inasmuch
as the notice does not have that status to
carry out an appeal under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act beyond the grounds those
would flow from Section 149(2) of the Motor
Vehicles Act. Apart that, if on the premises as
provided under Section 170(b) of the Motor
Vehicles Act, the insurer is not provided with
leave by the tribunal for resorting to all the
defences as available to the owner of the
vehicle or the driver, the insurer even as the
party cannot resort to all such defences
available to the owner/driver.”
11.
In Maheshwari and Others versus Ramachandran and
Others reported in (2023) ACJ 1210 [CA No.9187 of 2022; decided
on 13.12.2022] the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in para-12
observed as under :
“12. The notional income of the deceased is thus fixed
at Rs.15,000/- per month.”
12.
Further,
in
Josphine
James
versus
United
India
Insurance Co.Ltd. & Anr. reported in 2013 STPL(Web)663 SC the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in paras-13 & 19 observed as under :
“13. It is an undisputed fact that the son of the
appellant died in a motor vehicle accident on 12.6.1998,
who was the sole earning member of the family. The
respondent driver and insurer were initially impleaded
as parties but notice could not be served to the driver
despite repeated efforts. The driver was therefore later
on deleted from the array of parties on the basis of the
decisions of various High Courts including Delhi High
Court wherein it was held that non-impleadment of
driver of the offending vehicle is not fatal to the
proceedings in view of the fact that the liability of the
owner and the insurer of the offending vehicle is joint
and several. The insured was placed ex-parte since he
remained absent despite the service of notice upon him
in the proceeding whereas the Insurance Company filed
written statement wherein it has admitted that on the
date of accident the offending truck stood duly insured
with it and the insured was respondent No. 2 in the
proceedings before the Tribunal.
19. Further, the award of interest at the rate of 6% per
annum on the compensation as has been awarded both
by the Tribunal and the High Court is also bad in law for
the reason that in the case of Municipal Council of Delhi
Vs. Association of Victims of Uphaar Tragedy :
(2011) 4 SCC 481 this Court has awarded interest at the
rate of 9% per annum on the compensation awarded in
favour of the appellant. There is no justification for
them in not applying the ratio of the abovementioned
case to the fact situation of the present case. We
therefore, grant interest at the rate of 9% per annum
on the compensation amount awarded by the Tribunal
as the Insurance Company has been contesting the case
without any justifiable reason. Further, the Insurance
Company has deprived the appellant of the benefit of
her legitimate claim of getting the compensation and
she was made to approach the court for determination
of the claim even after passing of the award by the
Tribunal since the same was contested by the Insurance
Company by filing appeal by urging wholly untenable
grounds which are not maintainable in law. Accordingly,
we allow the appeal by setting aside the impugned
judgment and award of the High Court and restore the
compensation awarded by the Tribunal of Rs.
13,07,000/- both under the heads of pecuniary and
non-pecuniary damages and the said amount carries
9% interest per annum from the date of filing of the
application till the date of payment of the amount. We
direct the Insurance Company to deposit 50% of the
awarded amount with proportionate interest in any of
the nationalized Banks of the choice of the appellant for
a period of 3 years. During the said period, if she wants
to withdraw a portion or entire deposited amount for
her personal or any other expenses, then she is at
liberty to file application before the Tribunal which may
be considered by it and pass appropriate order in this
regard. If the amount of compensation has not yet been
paid by the Insurance Company to the appellant, the
same shall be paid within six weeks by obtaining
demand draft in favour of the appellant.”
13.
In New India Assurance Company Ltd. versus Bishaka
Rudra Paul and Anr. reported in (2014) 1 TLR 497 this Court further
observed as under :
6. Mr. S.K. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents at the outset has vociferously raised the
appellant’s objection as to whether the New India
Assurance Company Ltd. has got any locus-standi to
prefer an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act on challenging the quantum or resorting to
any other grounds beyond what has been provided
under Section 149(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act or
without taking leave of the tribunal for taking all
defences under Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
Mr. S.K. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents has submitted that the New India
Assurance Company Ltd. was not a party in the
proceeding being T.S. (MAC) 52 of 2011. The New India
Assurance Company Ltd. was a noticee and the same
would be apparent from the judgment and award dated
06.05.2013. He has further contended that even if the
noticee does file the reply to the show cause, he cannot
be considered as the party. Noticee is a non party
observant, thus the noticee does not have any locusstandi to file an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act.
7. Mr. S.K. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents, relying on United India Insurance
Company Ltd. vs. Shila Datta and Others, reported in
2011 ACJ 2729, has contended that when the insurance
company is a noticee, not a party respondent it can
oppose the claim on the grounds mentioned in Section
149(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act. For purpose of
appreciation, the paragraphs 7,8,9 & 10 of Shila Datta
(supra) are reproduced hereunder:
“7. The scheme of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988, as contained in Chapters XI (Insurance
of Motor Vehicles against Third Party risks)
and XII (Claims Tribunals) proceeds on the
basis that an insurer need not be impleaded
as a party to the claim proceedings and it
should only be issued a statutory notice under
Section149(2) of the Act so that it can be
made liable to pay the compensation awarded
by the tribunal and also resist the claim on
any one of the grounds mentioned in Clauses
(a) and (b) of Sub-section (2) of Section 149.
Sub-sections (1), (2) and (7) of Section 149
clearly refer to the insurer being merely a
noticee and not a party. Similarly, Sections
158(6), 166(4), 168(1) and 170 clearly
provide for and contemplate insurer being
merely a noticee for the purposes mentioned
in the Act and not being a party respondent
Section 170 specifically refers to impleading
of insurer as a party to the claim proceedings.
8. When an insurer is impleaded as a party Respondent
to
the
claim
petition,
as
contrasted from merely being a noticee under
Section 149(2) of the Act, its rights are
significantly different. If the insurer is only a
noticee, it can only raise such of those
grounds as are permissible in law under
Section 149(2). But if he is a partyrespondent, it can raise, not only those
grounds which are available under Section
149(2), but also all other grounds that are
available to a person against whom a claim is
made. It therefore follows that if a claimant
impleads the insurer as a party-respondent,
for
whatever
reason,
then
as
such
Respondent, the insurer will be entitled to
urge all contentions and grounds which may
be available to it.
9. The Act does not require the claimants to
implead the insurer as a party Respondent.
But if the claimants choose to implead the
insurer as a party, not being a noticee under
Section 149(2), the insurer can urge all
grounds and not necessarily the limited
grounds mentioned in Section 149(2) of the
Act. If the insurer is already a Respondent
(having
been
impleaded
as
a
party
Respondent), it need not seek the permission'
of the Tribunal under Section 170 of the Act to
raise grounds other than those mentioned in
Section 149(2) of the Act. The entire scheme
and structure of Chapters XI and XII is that
the claimant files a claim petition only against
the owner and driver and the tribunal issues
notice to the insurer under Section 149(2) so
that it can be made liable to pay the amount
awarded against the insurer and if necessary,
deny liability under the policy of insurance, on
any of the grounds mentioned in Section
149(2). If an insurer is only a noticee and not
a party Respondent, having regard to the
decision in Nicolletta Rohtagi, it can defend
the claim only on the grounds mentioned in
Section 149(2) and not any of the other
grounds relating to merits available to the
insured-respondent. This is the position even
where the claim proceedings are initiated suo
moto under Sections 149(7) and 158(6) of the
Act, without any formal application by the
claimants, as the insurer is only a noticee
under Section 149(2) of the Act.
10. Section 170 of the Act does not
contemplate an insurer making an application
for impleadment. Nor does it contemplate the
insurer, if he is already impleaded as a party
Respondent by the claimants, making any
application seeking permission to contest the
matter on merits. Section 170 proceeds on the
assumption that a claim petition is filed by the
claimants, or is registered suo moto by the
tribunal, with only the owner and driver of the
vehicle as the Respondents. It also proceeds
on the basis that in such a proceeding, a
statutory notice would have been issued by
the tribunal to the insurer so that the insurer
may know about its future liability in the
claim petition and also resist the claim, on
any of the grounds mentioned in Section
149(2). Section 170 of the Act also assumes
that the tribunal will hold an inquiry into the
claim, where only the claimants and the
owner and driver will be the parties. Section
170 provides that if during the course of such
inquiry, the tribunal finds and satisfies itself
that there is any collusion between the
claimant and the owner/driver or where the
owner/driver has failed to contest the claim,
the tribunal may suo moto, for reasons to be
recorded in writing, direct that the insurer
who may be liable in respect of the claim, who
was till then only a notice, shall be treated as
a party to the proceedings. The insurer so
impleaded,
without
prejudice
to
the
provisions of Section 149(2), will have the
right to contest the claim on all or any of the
grounds
that
are
available
to
the
driver/owner.”
14. A conjoint reading of the principles as laid down in
Shila Datta (supra) and Rekha Jain v. National
Insurance Company Ltd. : 2013 STPL (Web) 612 SC it
would eminently transpire that the insurer as the
noticee has no locus-standi to challenge the award
passed by the tribunal on questioning its legality
inasmuch as the noticee does not have that status to
carry out an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act beyond the grounds those would flow from
Section 149(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act. Apart that, if
on the premises as provided under Section 170(b) of
the Motor Vehicles Act, the insurer is not provided with
leave by the tribunal for resorting to all the defences as
available to the owner of the vehicle or the driver, the
insurer even as the party cannot resort to all such
defences as available to the owner/driver. Indubitably
in this case, the appellant is simply a noticee. Thus, in
view of Shila Datta (supra) the appellant does not have
any locus-standi to carry out this appeal on questioning
the quantum either directly or by implications and
accordingly, this appeal fails and is dismissed. However,
there shall be no order as to costs.”
14.
Here in the case at hand, it appears that the Learned
tribunal below at the time of determination of compensation considered
all the relevant points as well as documentary evidence on record
adduced by the parties and ultimately determined the amount of
compensation/award. In view of the principles of law down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court and the High Court and also scrutinizing the grounds
of objection this Court is constrained to hold that in this case the
appellant being a noticee does not have a legal right to raise the
objection as has been raised in the appeal and accordingly, this appeal
being
bereft
of
merit
and
accordingly
stands
judgment/award dated 06.12.2022 passed by the
dismissed.
The
Learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal No.1, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with
Case No.T.S.(MAC)169 of 2020 is hereby upheld and accordingly it is
affirmed.
The sum as awarded by the tribunal if not paid by the
appellant Insurance Company shall be paid within a period of 2(two)
months from today.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Send down the LCRs.
Pending application/s, if any, also stands dismissed.
Copy be supplied to Learned counsels for information and
compliance.
JUDGE
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.02.26 14:53:59 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review