Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010389752018
2026:CGHC:46081
NAFR
Digitally signed
AMIT
by AMIT KUMAR
KUMAR DUBEY
Date: 2026.10.31
DUBEY 12:33:37 +0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
THE DATE
THE DATE
WHEN THE
WHEN THE
CASE IS
JUDGMENT IS
RESERVED PRONOUNCED
16.10.2026
THE DATE WHEN THE JUDGMENT IS
UPLOADED ON THE WEBSITE
Operative
Full
-----
30.10.2026
30.10.2026
MAC No. 81 of 2019
The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Through Divisional Manager,
Madina Building, Kachari Chowak, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
(Insurer Of Offending Vehicle Truck Bearing Registration No. C. G. 04
G-1317)
... Appellant / respondent No. 3.
versus
1 - Sumit Sahu S/o Shri Ishwar Sahu Aged About 8 Years Respondent
No. 1 under the gurdianship Of Father Ishwar Sahu R/o Village Babai,
Police Station Sahaspur, Lohara, District Kawardha Chhattisgarh,
Present Address:Bada Ashok Nagar, Gudhiyari, District Raipur Chhattigarh
(Claimant
No.1)
2 - Palturam Gond S/o Late Ratsingh Gond Aged About 50 Years R/o
Village Mazgaon, Police Station Mawai And District Mandla (M. P.),
Present Address:-Transport Nagar, Ravabhata Parking Number-1
Police Station Urla, Raipur Chhattisgarh (The Above Address Is Driver
Of Offending Vehicle Truck Bearing Registration No. C. G. 04 G-1317)
(Non-applicant No.1)
3 - Smt. Usha Jain D/o Dinesh Jain Age Major, R/o Om Complex
Fafadih, District Raipur Chhattisgarh ( Owner Of Offending Vehicle
Truck Bearing Registration No. C. G. 04 G-1317 )
{Non Appellant No. 2}
... Respondents
{Cause title, as taken from CIS}
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Appellant
: Mr. Hanuman Prasad Agrawal, Advocate.
For Respondent No. 1 : Ms. Prachi Singh, Advocate on behalf of Mr.
Raghvendra Pradhan, Advocate.
For Respondent No. 3 : Mr. Satish surya, Advocate on behalf of Mr.
Yogesh Chandra Pandey, Advocate.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(Hon’ble Mr. Justice Santosh Sharma)
C A V Judgment
1.
The appellant/Insurance Company has preferred this appeal
under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short “MV Act,
1988”) challenging the award passed by First Additional Presiding
Officer, Raipur of First Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Raipur (for brevity ‘the Claims Tribunal’) in Motor Accident Claim Case
No. 402/2015 whereby the liability of payment of compensation has
been fastened upon the appellant/Insurance Company to indemnify
the award of ₹ 10,32,447/- along with interest @ 9 percent per annum
from the date of filing of claim petition, till its realization.
2.
Respondent
objection/cross
No.
/claimant
has
also
preferred
cross
appeal seeking enhancement of compensation
awarded by the Claims Tribunal.
3.
The case of the appellant, as pleaded in the claim petition, is
that on 25th March,2018, Ishwar Sahu was riding his motorcycle from
Raipur to his village, Babai, in Kawardha district, with his son, Sumit
Sahu, seated on the motorcycle as a pillion rider. When they reached
near Dharsiwa Police Station, Siltara, the driver of a truck bearing
registration No. CG-04-G-1317 (hereinafter referred to as the
“offending vehicle”), drove the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner
and dashed against their motorcycle. As a result of the accident, Sumit
Sahu (respondent No.1) sustained multiple injuries, including the
complete crushing of his leg below the knee. Ishwar Sahu (father of
respondent No.1) also sustained injuries in the said accident. In
connection with the accident, a report was lodged at Police Station
Dharsiwa against respondent No. 1, the driver of the offending vehicle,
for offences punishable under Sections 279, 337 and 338 of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860.
4.
Upon completion of the investigation, a charge-sheet was filed
against respondent No. 1 before the competent criminal court. It is
further evident from the claim application that the respondent No.1
/claimant remained hospitalized at Narayana Hospital, Pandri, Raipur,
from 25.03.2015 to 15.06.2015, incurring medical expenses of
approximately Rs. 7,00,000/-. As a result of the injuries sustained in
the accident, the right leg of the claimant was amputated below the
knee, rendering him permanently disabled and severely impairing his
ability to walk.
5.
At the time of the accident, the claimant was only eight years old
and was studying in Class III. In addition to his studies, he used to
assist his father in agricultural work. The permanent disability suffered
by the claimant at such a tender age has adversely affected his
prospects of leading a normal life and pursuing future educational and
vocational opportunities. The injury has also caused immense physical
and mental suffering and has deprived him of the opportunity to enjoy
the ordinary pleasures of childhood. The consequences of such
disability extend beyond the claimant himself and have caused
considerable hardship to his family.
circumstances,
the
respondent
In view of the aforesaid
No.1/claimant
has
claimed
compensation of Rs. 28,50,000/- under various heads.
6.
The respondents No. 2 & 3, who are driver & owner of the
offending vehicle, while denying the averments made in the claim
application, has pleaded that on 25th March, 2015, the respondent
No. 2 , after getting his Truck bearing registration No. CG-04-G-1317
repaired at Bihar Motor Garage, was driving slowly and cautiously on
the left side of the road, when Ishwar Sahu lost control of his
motorcycle and collided with the truck, causing the accident. It was
further pleaded that, at the time of the accident, Respondent No. 2
was holding a valid and effective driving licence authorising him to
drive the offending truck and that the said vehicle was duly insured
with the appellant-Insurance Company. Accordingly, it was contended
that, in the event of any liability arising for payment of compensation,
the same would be required to be discharged by the Insurance
Company.
7.
The appellant-Insurance Company (non-applicant No. 3 before
learned Claims Tribunal) also contested the claim petition, contending
that the offending vehicle did not possess a valid and effective permit
and fitness certificate at the time of the accident. Accordingly, it sought
to be exonerated from its liability to pay compensation to the claimant.
8.
The Tribunal, on a close scrutiny of evidence led, material
placed and submissions made by the parties, held that the accident
had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of Truck bearing
registration No. CG-04G 1317 by its driver- Palturam Gond
(respondent No.2), owned by Smt. Usha Jain (respondent No. 3) and
insured with the appellant-Insurance Company, dashed the Motorcycle
bearing registration No. CG 04KD-7401 driven by Ishwar Sahu (father
of respondent No.1/claimant). In the said accident, respondent
No.1/claimant sustained multiple injuries resulting into permanent
disability of the whole body to the extent of 30% whereas treating
doctor has issued a certificate of 45% permanent disability in respect
of the left leg of the injured, which is evident from disability certificate
(Ex.P-4) ;
appellant /Oriental Insurance Company Limited, who is
insurer of offending vehicle Truck, was held liable for payment of
compensation to the claimant, as it could not establish the violation of
policy conditions and awarded a sum of Rs. 10,32,447 alognwith
interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing of claim application,
till its actual payment in favour of the claimant.
9.
Being aggrieved & dissatisfied with the award passed by the
Claims Tribunal, appellant / Oriental Insurance Company preferred
instant miscellaneous appeal on various grounds that the learned
Claims Tribunal has committed an error of law in failing to appreciate
that the offending truck was not having a valid Permit and Fitness
Certificate on the date of the accident. The learned Tribunal has
completely
overlooked
this
material
statutory
violation
while
determining liability, thereby rendering the impugned award legally
unsustainable. Owner himself admitted in his written statement that
the vehicle was not having a valid Fitness Certificate on the date of
accident. The learned Tribunal has ignored this material oral and
documentary
evidence
while
deciding
the
liability
of
the
Appellant/Insurance Company. It is further stated that, in view of
Sections 39, 56 and 66 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, a transport
vehicle cannot be lawfully operated in a public place without a valid
Fitness Certificate and Permit. In the absence of a valid Fitness
Certificate, the vehicle shall be deemed not to be validly registered for
the purposes of the Act. Such statutory violations constitute a
fundamental breach of the terms and conditions of the insurance
policy, particularly when the owner permits the vehicle to ply on public
roads without complying with the mandatory legal requirements,
thereby endangering the lives of passengers and the general public.
Hence, the Appellant/Insurance Company cannot be fastened with
liability to indemnify the insured. It is next contended that learned
ClaimsTribunal
has
erred
in
awarding
compensation
of
Rs. 10,32,447/- and fastening the liability to pay the same upon the
Appellant/Insurance Company, whereas the liability, if any, ought to
have been fastened upon the owner of the offending vehicle.
10.
Learned Counsel for Respondent No. 1/Claimant, while filing a
cross-appeal/cross-objection, stated that following the accident,
Respondent No. 1/Claimant was admitted to Narayana Hospital in
Raipur, where he remained hospitalized from 25.03.2015 to
15.06.2015. During this period, the expenditure incurred on his
medical treatment amounted to Rs. 7,00,000. He sustained severe
injuries to his right leg, resulting in a disability that renders him unable
to walk or move about properly. The Claims Tribunal incorrectly
assessed the permanent disability at 30%, whereas, according to the
doctor, it is 45%. It was further submitted that the accident has
severely impacted the future of Respondent No. 1/Claimant and will
serve as an impediment to his development. It is next contended that
respondent No. 1, through his natural guardian, i.e., his father, had
filed a claim application seeking compensation of Rs. 28,50,000/-.
However, the learned Claims Tribunal has awarded compensation of
Rs. 10,32,447/-, which, according to the claimant, who is 8 years child
at the time of accident, is inadequate having regard to the nature and
severity of the injuries sustained by him and the consequent adverse
impact on his future prospects and quality of life. It is, therefore,
submitted that the compensation awarded by the learned Claims
Tribunal warrants appropriate enhancement.
To buttress his
submissions, learned counsel for respondent No. 1 places reliance
upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the matter of Hitesh
Nagjibhai Patel vs. Babbahi Nagjibhai Rabari & another 1 and drew
attention of this Court that potential earning capacity of an eight-year-
Civil Appeal No. 10278 of 2025, decided on 8th August, 2025.
old child cannot be ignored and that, at the very least, he would earn
monthly income at the rate of unskilled worker.
11.
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellant/Insurance
Company would submit that the offending vehicle, Truck bearing
Registration No. CG-04G 1317, being a goods-carrying commercial
vehicle, did not possess a valid and effective permit and Fitness
Certificate on the date of the accident and the driver of the offending
vehicle was not having valid and effective driving licence to the said
vehicle. He submits that Insurance Policy (Ex.D-28) issued by the
Insurance Company in favour of the owner of the vehicle i.e. Smt.
Usha Jain was not the comprehensive policy but it is the ‘act only
policy, which has duly been proved by examining witness Ritesh
Kumar Rahangdale (DW-2) – Administrative Officer of the Insurance
Company and, therefore, the finding recorded by the Claims Tribunal
fastening the liability of payment of compensation upon the
appellant/Insurance Company deserves to be set aside. He further
submits that the act only policy issued by the appellant/Insurance
Company in favour of the original owner was not covered the risk of
pillion rider sitting in the vehicle.
He places reliance upon the
judgment of Full Bench of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in
the matter of Pareed Pillai vs. Oriental Insurance Company
Limited2 in support of his submission.
In the instant case, the
offending vehicle was not having a valid and effective Permit and
Fitness Certificate on the date of the accident, constituting a
MACA No. 2030 of 2015 and other connected cases, decided on 09.10.2018.
fundamental breach of the terms and conditions of the insurance
policy.
12.
Per contra, learned counsels appearing for the respondents
No. 2 & 3 respectively submitted that the appellant/insurance
company failed to prove the fact that respondent No. 3, owner of the
offending vehicle, was not holding a valid permit /fitness certificate on
the date of accident by proving and exhibiting the permit, and
therefore, the Tribunal has not committed any error in holding the
appellant/insurance company liable for payment of compensation.
13.
I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and
perused the record of the Claims Tribunal, including the impugned
award, the evidence adduced by the parties and the grounds raised in
the appeal as well as the cross-appeal/cross-objection.
14.
The first question that arises for consideration is whether the
learned Claims Tribunal has committed any illegality in fastening the
liability to pay compensation upon the appellant/Insurance Company.
15.
The question as to whether the absence of, or expiry of, a
valid fitness certificate or permit in respect of the offending vehicle
constitutes a fundamental breach of the insurance policy, thereby
entitling the insurer to avoid its liability, came up for consideration
before the Full Bench of the Kerala High Court in Augustine V.M. v.
Ayyappankutty and Others3, wherein the Court observed as follows:“11.………………...However,
if
such
a
vehicle is used only for the permitted
M.A.C.A. Nos. 2526 of 2009 & 2507 of 2010, decided on 4th March, 2015.
purpose, and the accident occurs when the
permit or fitness certificate ceased to exist, it
amounts to a technical violation only, which
will not entitle the insurer to disown the
liability to third parties. For avoiding the
liability relying on Section 149(2)(a)(i)(c), the
insurer should plead and prove that the
offending vehicle was used for a purpose
not authorised by the permit. ……………….
We are of the definite view that Thara v.
Syamala4 does not lay down the correct
law……”
16.
The same view has been reiterated and followed by this Court in
the matter of Saleem Chandrakar Vs. Mohd. Saleem5.
17.
In the instant case, the principal defence raised by the
appellant/Insurance Company is that the offending vehicle did not
possess a valid and effective permit and fitness certificate on the date
of the accident. However, the material available on record indicates
that respondent No. 2 was not using the offending vehicle for the
purpose of public transportation at the relevant time but was returning
the vehicle after getting it repaired at a motor garage.
18.
It is not in dispute that offending vehicle did not possess a valid
and effective Permit and Fitness Certificate on the date of the
accident. The requirement of a fitness certificate must be examined in
2009 (2) KHC 706
M.A. (C) No. 1251 of 2017, decided on 26.09.2017
the context of the condition of the vehicle and the purpose for which it
was being operated. Where a vehicle is taken for repairs and is being
returned after completion of such repairs, the question of its fitness for
use on a public road must be considered in the light of the applicable
statutory provisions and the evidence on record. Similarly, the
requirement of a permit under Section 66 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988, must be examined with reference to the nature and purpose of
the journey undertaken by the vehicle at the relevant time.
19.
In the present case, the circumstances indicate that the
offending vehicle was being driven after repairs and was not being
operated for the purpose of carrying goods in the ordinary course of
commercial transportation. However, merely because the offending
vehicle was being driven back after repairs from a motor garage,
rather than being used for public transportation, it cannot be exempted
from the statutory requirements of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The
vehicle was still required to possess a valid and effective Permit and
Fitness Certificate, as mandated under Sections 66 and 56 of the Act.
Section 66 imposes a statutory obligation upon the owner to ensure
that the transport vehicle is operated in accordance with the requisite
permit, while Section 56 provides that a transport vehicle shall not be
deemed to be validly registered for the purposes of Section 39 unless
it carries a valid Certificate of Fitness. Therefore, the absence of such
mandatory statutory documents constitutes a violation of the
provisions of the Act.
20.
In the matter of Pareed Pillai vs. Oriental Insurance Company
Limited(supra) full Bench of the Kerala High Court held as under:15. …………………..., fitness of a vehicle, to be used as a
transport vehicle, is of paramount importance. The
necessity to have 'Fitness Certificate' is prescribed under
Section 56 of the Act. Sub- section (1) of Section 56
clearly stipulates that, a transport vehicle [subject to the
provisions of Section 59 (power to fix the age limit of
motor vehicle) and Section 60 (registration of the vehicles
belonging to the Central Government)] shall not be
deemed to be validly registered for the purpose of Section
39, unless it carries a 'Certificate of Fitness' as
prescribed………...”
21.
In the matter of Chandresh Kumar Agrawal Vs. Yogendra
Kumar Shrivastava6, learned Single Bench of the Allahabad High
Court has held as under :“15. I have considered the arguments advanced
on behalf of the parties on this point and find force
in the contention of the learned counsel for the
Insurance Company. The owner of the truck came
to the Tribunal with clear allegations that the
vehicle was being repaired at Gorakhpur on the
date in question and all documents including
permit, certificate of fitness, etc. had been
surrendered in the office of the R.T.O. at
Gorakhpur. It is, therefore, clear that the truck in
question was being driven by the driver on the road
in an unauthorized manner and against the terms
and conditions of the policy and caused accident.
Section 76 of the new Act (Section 42 of the old
Act) clearly provides that no owner of a transport
vehicle shall use or permit the use of the vehicle in
any public place except in accordance with the
conditions of a permit granted or countersigned by
a Regional or State Transport Authority. It means
plying of a transport vehicle on the road without
valid permit and certificate of fitness is prohibited
under the law. It was clearly held by the Apex Court
2005 AIHC 2329
that a person without permit to ply a vehicle cannot
be placed at a better pedestal vis-a-vis one who
has a permit, but has violated any condition
thereof. Plying of a vehicle without a permit is an
infraction. Therefore, In terms of Section 149(2)
defence is available to the insurer on that aspect. It
was also held that the question of policy being
operative had no relevance for the issue regarding
liability of insurer. Therefore, in view of the clear law
laid down by the Apex Court recently in such
matters, I am clearly of the opinion that the learned
Tribunal committed no error of law in fastening
liability to pay compensation on the owner of the
vehicle. I find no good ground to interfere with the
finding recorded by the Tribunal on this point and it
is held that owner of the truck in question is liable
to satisfy the claimant.”
22.
In view of the foregoing discussion, it is established that the
offending vehicle was being driven without a valid Permit and Fitness
Certificate, in violation of the statutory requirements and the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy. The fact that the vehicle was
returning from a garage after repairs does not exempt the owner from
complying with these requirements merely because it was not being
used for commercial or transport purposes at that time. It was the
responsibility of the owner to ensure that all valid documents were in
place before allowing the vehicle to ply on a public road. Therefore,
the absence of the requisite Permit and Fitness Certificate amounts to
a violation of the statutory provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
and the relevant policy conditions.
23.
The next question for consideration is whether the claimant is
entitled to enhancement of compensation, as sought in the crossappeal/cross-objection. Learned counsel appearing for the claimant
has submitted that, at the time of the accident, the claimant was only
eight years of age and sustained grievous injuries, resulting in the
amputation of his right leg below the knee. It has further been
submitted that the claimant remained hospitalized at Narayana
Hospital, Raipur, from 25.03.2015 to 15.06.2015 and incurred medical
expenses of approximately ₹7,00,000/-. According to learned counsel,
the learned Claims Tribunal erred in assessing the permanent
disability at 30%, despite the disability certificate (Ex. P-4) indicating
disability to the extent of 45%, and consequently awarded inadequate
compensation.
24.
There can be no dispute that the claimant sustained serious
injuries in the accident, but there is no material on record to establish
that the claimant’s right leg was amputated below the knee, although
the learned Claims Tribunal assessed 30% permanent disability in
relation to the whole body. The consequences of such an injury are
particularly grave when suffered by a child of tender age, as the
disability may affect not only his physical mobility but also his
education,
future
employment
prospects,
independence
and
enjoyment of life. The assessment of compensation in such
circumstances must be guided by the settled principles of just and
reasonable compensation, having due regard to the nature and extent
of the injuries, the permanent disability suffered, the medical expenses
incurred and the non-pecuniary losses arising from the injury.
25.
It is also well settled that the percentage of physical disability
assessed by a medical practitioner cannot, in every case, be treated
as equivalent to the percentage of functional disability. The effect of
the disability upon the claimant's future earning capacity and ability to
lead a normal life must be assessed in the light of the nature of the
injury, the claimant's age and the evidence available on record.
Accordingly, the assessment of compensation must be based on the
evidence as a whole in respect of earning capacity and not merely on
the percentage of permanent physical disability recorded in the
disability certificate.
26.
The Supreme Court in case of Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and
Another7 has held : the extent of disability of a limb (or part of body)
expressed in terms of a percentage of the total functions of that limb,
obviously cannot be assumed to be the extent of disability of the
whole body. Where the claimant suffers a permanent disability as a
result of injuries, the assessment of compensation under the head of
loss of future earning would depend upon the effect and impact of
such permanent disability on his earning capacity.
The Tribunal
should not mechanically apply the percentage of permanent disability
as the percentage of economic loss or loss of earning capacity. What
requires to be assessed by the Tribunal is the effect of the permanent
disability on the earning capacity of the injured; and after assessing
the loss of earning capacity in terms of a percentage of the income, it
has to be quantified in terms of money, to arrive at the future loss of
earnings.
27.
On the issue of determining the monthly income of the minor
respondent No. 1/claimant, this Court is inclined to interfere with the
2011 (1) SCC 343
award passed by the Claims Tribunal. In the present case, it is evident
that the Claims Tribunal has failed to take into consideration the
monthly income of the claimant while assessing the quantum of
compensation. It is a well-settled principle of law that a minor child
who sustains permanent disability in a motor vehicle accident cannot
be equated with a non-earning individual merely on the ground that
the child was not engaged in any gainful employment at the time of
the accident. Such an approach would fail to adequately account for
the loss of future earning capacity occasioned by the permanent
disability. Accordingly, while assessing compensation under the head
of loss of income, the notional income of the minor claimant ought to
be determined by adopting, at the very least, the minimum wages
prescribed for unskilled workman under the applicable notification
issued by the competent authority of the State concerned for the
relevant period.. The said observation was rendered by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the matter of Kajal v. Jagdish Chand and Ors.8
and Baby Sakshi Greola v. Manzoor Ahmad Simon and Anr.9
28.
Adverting to the facts at hand, the respondent No. 1-claimant
was an 8- year-old child at the time of the accident. In view of the
above exposition of law, this Court must advert to the prevailing
minimum wages, which for the un-skilled one, as in the year of
accident, i.e., 2018, in State of Chhattisgarh minimum wages for unskilled one is 7,930/- per month, therefore, in the interest of justice,
(2020) 4 SCC 413
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3692
this Court deem it appropriate to determine the income of the minor
claimant/respondent No. 1 as Rs.7,930/- per month.
29.
Coming to the assessment of disability suffered by the minor
claimant, he sustained severe injuries to his right leg, resulting in a
disability that renders him unable to walk or move about properly.
Upon examination of the disability certificate and other medical
documents, as also considering the nature, extent and impact of the
injuries sustained by the claimant, the Claims Tribunal in para 22 of
the impugned award, quantified the permanent disability of whole
body of the claimant to the extent of 30%. This Court is also adopted
the above percentage of disability, in terms of impact of earning
capacity of minor claimant in view of the judgment of the Supreme
Court in that matter of
Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and Another
(supra).
30.
Taking into account the direct correlation between the injuries
sustained and the consequent loss of permanent disability suffered by
the appellant of his entire body, this Court in agreement with the
finding of the Claims Tribunal that the permanent disability stands
rightly fixed at 30%.
31.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the compensation now
payable to the claimant-respondent No. 1 would be recalculated as
under:-
Sl. Heads
No.
Calculation
(in rupees)
01.
Rs.
7,930/-
per
month
i.e.
Rs.
Income of the claimant
95,160/- per annum
02.
40% of (i) above to be added towards Rs.95,160/future prospects.
+Rs.
38,064/-=
Rs.1,33,224/-
2A
Percentage of disability {30 % of Rs.39,967/Rs.1,33,224/-), as assessed by the
Claims Tribunal.
03.
Multiplier of 18 to be applied, as per Rs.39,967 x 18 =
judgment of the Supreme Court in the Rs. 7,19,406/matter
of
National
Insurance
Company vs. Pranay Sethi, reported
in (2017) 16 SCC 680
04.
Medical expenses in respect of pain & Rs.3,00,000/-,
suffering, physical and mental agone,
inconvenience
and
deprivation
comforts due to temporary disability
05.
For Attendants
awarded
by
as
the
of
Claims Tribunal
Rs.90,400/-,
as
awarded
the
by
Claims Tribunal.
For Medical expenses
Rs.5,37,047/-,
as
awarded
the
by
Claims Tribunal.
For transportation
Rs.
30,000/-,
as
awarded
by
the
Claims Tribunal.
04.
For future treatment
Rs.50,000/-,
as
awarded
the
by
Claims Tribunal.
05.
For nutritious food
Rs.25,000/-,
as
awarded
the
by
Claims Tribunal.
Total compensation
32.
Rs.17,51,853/-
In view of foregoing, cross-appeal /cross objection filed by the
respondent No. 1-claimant is allowed in part. The compensation of
Rs.
10,32,447/-awarded
by
the
Tribunal
is
enhanced
to
Rs.17,51,853/-. The claimant is entitled for a further sum of Rs.
7,19,406/-
[Rs.17,51,853/- - Rs. 10,32,447]. Remaining terms &
condition of the award of Claims Tribunal shall remain intact.
33.
The Appellant/ Oriental Insurance Company Limited is granted
two months’ time to deposit enhanced amount of compensation of Rs.
7,19,406/- along with aforesaid interest before the concerned Claims
Tribunal. No order as to costs.
34.
In view of forgoing, the appeal filed by the appellant-Insurance
Company is allowed in part. Part of award by which the insurance
company has been held liable for payment of compensation is set
aside and instead, the claimant is entitled for compensation against
the respondent No. 3 i.e. owner of the offending vehicle.
The
appellant/Insurance Company is directed to first pay the award
amount to the claimant and then to recover it from the respondent
No. 3 (owner of offending vehicle) in accordance with law.
35.
Whereas cross-appeal/ cross-objection filed by the respondent
No. 1-claimant is also allowed in part to the extent that the above
enhanced amount shall be deposited in a Nationalized Bank
till
attaining the age of majority of the claimant.
Sd/(Santosh Sharma)
Judge
Dubey
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review