Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page - 1 of 12
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No. 35/2020
The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
Represented by the Divisio-nal Manager, Agartala Division
Office, H.B. Road, (Near Sarkar Nursing Home), Agartala,
West Tripura.
…………… Appellant.
Versus
1.
Smt. Kanakprava Das
W/O. Late Surjya Kanta Das, of village South Rajnagar,
P.O.- Rajnagar, P.S. -P.R. Bari, District - South Tripura.
2.
Sri. Litan Das
S/O. Late Surjya Kanta Das, of village South Rajnagar, P.O.
- Rajnagar, P.S.- P.R. Bari, District - South Tripura.
3.
Sri. Suman Das,
S/O. Late Surjya Kanta Das, of village South Rajnagar, P.O.Rajnagar, P.S.- P.R. Bari, District - South Tripura.
4.
Smt. Shiuli Das,
W/O. Sri Bikas Majumder, D/O -Late Surjya Kanta Das, of
village Arjya Samaj, P.S. - Belonia, District- South Tripura.
5.
Smt. Dipali Das,
W/O. Sri Mohan Chandra Das, of village Ghosh Khamar,
South Krishnapur, P.O. - Radhanagar, P.S. P.R. - Bari,
District - South Tripura. (Owner of the Vehicle)
6.
Sri. Basudeb Das,
S/O. Lt. Dhananjoy Das, of village South Rajnagar, P.O.Rajnagar, P.S. P.R. -Bari, District - South Tripura. (Driver of
the vehicle)
…………… Respondent.
MAC App. No. 39/2021
1.
Sri Litan Das
S/O. Late Surjya Kanta Das,
2.
Sri Suman Das
S/O. Lt. Surjya Kanta Das
3.
Smt. Shiuli Das(Majumder)
D/O. Lt. Surjya Kanta Das All R/O. Vill. South Rajnagar, P.O.
- Rajnagar, P.S - P.R Bari, District - South Tripura.
…………… Appellant.
Versus
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 2 of 12
1.
Smt. Dipali Das
W/O Sri Moran Chandra Das R/O Vill - Gosh Khamar, South
Krishnapur PO - Radhanagar, PS - P.R Bari District - South
Tripura (Owner of vehicle TR-03-2555, Commander Jeep)
2.
Sri Basudeb Das,
S/O. Lt. Dhananjoy Das R/O vill. South Rajnagar, PORajnagar PS - P.R Bari, District - South Tripura (Driver of
vehicle no. TR-03-2555, Commander Jeep)
3.
The Branch Manager
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Udaipur Branch, P.O and P.S R.K Pur, District - Gomati Tripura (Insurer of TR-03-2555,
Commander Jeep)
…………… Respondent.
BEFORE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
In MAC App. No.35/2020.
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Biswanath Majumder, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. R. G. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Ms. Simita Chakraborty, Advocate.
In MAC App. No.39/2021.
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. R. G. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Ms. Simita Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Biswanath Majumder, Advocate.
Date of hearing
: 15th December, 2021.
Date of Judgment & Order :
Whether fit for reporting
2nd February, 2022.
: NO.
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Both the appeals under Section 173(1) of the Motor
Vehicles Act have been filed against the same judgment and award
dated 16.06.2020 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, South
Tripura, Belonia in case No. TS(MAC) 22 of 2018. Therefore, these
appeals have been heard together and they will be disposed of by this
common judgment.
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 3 of 12
By the impugned award dated 16.06.2020, MACT, Belonia
[2]
awarded compensation of a sum of Rs.16,25,603/- along with 6%
annual interest thereon from the date of filing the claim petition
till
disbursement on account of the death of Surjya Kanta Das in a road
traffic
accident.
Allegedly,
the
deceased
sustained
injury
on
17.02.2017 in a road traffic accident while he was going to Rajnagar
Market at Belonia from Barpathari on his by-cycle. He succumbed to
his injuries on 19.02.2017 in AMRI Hospital, Dhakuria in Kolkata.
Insurance company has challenged the award by filing this appeal on
02.12.2020. The original claimants have also filed separate appeal
against the award subsequently on 18.09.2021 for enhancement of
compensation awarded by the Tribunal. As stated both the appeals
have been heard together and taken up for disposal by this common
judgment.
[3]
Heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned Advocate representing the
Insurance Company. Heard Mr. R. G. Chakraborty as well as Ms.
Simita Chakraborty, learned advocates appearing for the original
claimants.
[4]
Factual backgrounds of the case are as under:
The Officer-in-Charge of P.R.Bari police station, Belonia
registered P.R. Bari P.S Case No.0010 of 2017 under Sections 279 and
338 IPC against the driver of TR-03-2555 (Commander Jeep) on the
basis of written FIR lodged by Sri Suman Das, son of deceased Surjya
Kanta Das who alleged in his FIR that the offending vehicle hit the byMAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 4 of 12
cycle of his father when his father was going to Rajnagar market from
Barpathari on his by-cycle in the afternoon of 17.02.2017. His father
was first taken to Rajnagar hospital from where he was referred to
AGMC-GBP hospital at Agartala. Thereafter, his father was taken to
Kolkata on the following day where he was initially admitted in Kolkata
Medical College and Hospital. The informant alleged that the accident
occurred as a result of rash and negligent driving of the offending
vehicle. He sought for police action against the driver of the offending
vehicle.
[5]
After registration of the case, investigation was taken up
by police. The vehicle was seized and mechanical inspection of the
vehicle was conducted by Sri Subrata Debbarma, Inspector of Motor
Vehicles who opined that there was no mechanical disorder in the said
vehicle on the alleged date of occurrence. In the course of the
investigation, Surjya Kanta Das succumbed to his injuries in Kolkata
on 19.02.2017. His post mortem examination was conducted at Alipur
Police morgue on 20.02.2017. In the post mortem examination report,
autopsy surgeon opined that death was due to effects of injuries as
noted in the report which were ante-mortem in nature. Having
completed investigation of the case the Investigating Officer submitted
charge sheet No.65 of 2017 dated 31.12.2007 against Basudeb Das,
driver of the offending vehicle bearing registration No.TR-03-2555 for
commission of offence punishable under Sections 279, 304 Part-II IPC
and Section 187 of Motor vehicles Act.
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 5 of 12
[6]
Smt. Kanak Prabha Das, wife of the deceased, her sons,
Litan Das, Suman Das and
daughter Sheuli Das filed an application
under Section 166 M.V. Act in the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal at
Belonia in South Tripura District claiming compensation of a sum of
Rs.17,22,429/- under various pecuniary and non-pecuniary heads. The
owner of the vehicle, his driver Basudeb Das and the insurance
Company were impleaded as respondent No.1, 2, and 3 respectively in
the said claim petition.
[7]
Owner and driver of the offending vehicle in their joint
written statement pleaded that their vehicle was duly insured with
respondent No.3. The driver was also having a valid driving license
and the vehicle was duly registered. It had also tax clearance
certificate and all other valid documents. They claimed that liability, if
any; arising out of the accident would be shouldered by the insurer of
the vehicle.
[8]
The Insurance Company (respondent No.3) by filing its
written objection against the claim of the original claimants pleaded
that the claim of compensation was exorbitant and moreover the
insurance company would not be liable to pay any compensation until
it was proved that the driver had a valid driving license, the insurance
policy was in force and there was no breach of any condition of the
insurance policy.
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 6 of 12
[9]
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties Tribunal
framed three issues. Issue No.1 was whether the accident occurred
due to rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle. Issue No.2
was whether the claimants were entitled to compensation due to the
death of Surjya Kanta Das in road traffic accident and Issue No.3 was
what would be a fair amount of compensation.
[10]
In the course of hearing, the claimants adduced evidence
of one witness and relied on nine exhibits (Exbt.1 to Exbt.9). No oral
evidence was adduced on behalf of the respondents. Respondent No.1
however, relied on the documents (Exbt.A to Exbt.C) of the offending
vehicle.
[11]
On
appreciation
of
evidence
Tribunal
held
that
the
deceased was a Government pensioner and at the time of his death he
was 61 years of age and his pension payment order revealed that his
monthly basic pension was Rs.12,705/-. Tribunal assessed that along
with admissible DA, the deceased used to draw a monthly sum of
Rs.24,381 as pension. On that basis, Tribunal worked out his annual
income at Rs.2,92,572/-. From this amount Tribunal deducted 1/3rd of
the amount towards personal and living expenses of the deceased
since number of dependent family members of the deceased was three
including his wife and two sons. Daughter was not included as she was
married at that time. After such deduction loss of annual income was
worked out to be Rs.2,92,572 – Rs.97,524 = Rs.1,95,048/-. Since the
deceased was 61 years old at the time of his death Tribunal applied
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 7 of 12
multiplier 7 as per the schedule provided in the case of Sarla
Verma(Smt.) and others Vrs. Delhi Transport Corporation and
Another: reported in (2009) 6 SCC 121. After multiplication by 7 the
amount came to be Rs.1,95,048 x 7 =Rs.13,65,336/-. With this
amount Tribunal added Rs.40,000/- as loss of consortium to the wife
of the deceased, Rs.15,000/- for funeral expenses and Rs.15,000/- for
loss of estate. This apart, Tribunal also awarded Rs.97,457/- as
medical expenses, Rs.18,600/- for preservation of the dead body of
the deceased for a day in Kolkata. Rs.3,000/- was awarded for
attendant charges and Rs.71,210/- was awarded for
travelling
expenses. Total amount of compensation awarded by the Tribunal was
as under:
SL.
No.
Heads
1.
Loss of income
Rs.13,65,336/-
2.
Loss of spousal
consortium to wife
Rs.
40,000/-
3.
Loss of estate
Rs.
15,000/-
4.
Funeral expenses
Rs.
15,000/-
5.
Actual medical expenses
Rs.
97,457/-
6.
For preservation of the
dead body in Kolkata
Rs.
18,600/-
7.
Attendant charges
Rs.
3,000/-
8.
Travelling Expenses
Rs.
71,210/-
Amount
Total:
Rs.16,25,603/-
6% annual interest on the said amount was granted from
the date of filing of the claim petition till disbursement of the award.
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 8 of 12
[12]
Insurance company has challenged the said award of the
Tribunal mainly on the following grounds:
(i)
Tribunal
awarded
an
exorbitant
amount
of
compensation against the settled principles.
(ii)
Tribunal did not appreciate the fact that there was no
proof of rash and negligent driving and in absence of proof
of rash and negligent driving, the claimants were not
entitled to compensation.
(iii) Tribunal wrongly calculated the amount of monthly
pension of the deceased at Rs.24,381/- because deceased
was drawing a basic monthly pension of Rs.12,705/- only.
Under the premises aforesaid, the Insurance Company
urged for setting aside the judgment and award passed by the
Tribunal.
[13]
In their appeal the original claimants emphasized on the
following grounds:
(i)
Tribunal did not appreciate the fact that the original
appellants in their claim petition claimed compensation on
the basis of their actual entitlement. Therefore, the
Tribunal
should
not
have
reduced
the
amount
of
compensation claimed by them. The Tribunal did not add
any amount towards future prospect of the deceased
while working out the amount of compensation which was
grossly erroneous.
(ii)
The
amount
of
compensation
Tribunal was unfair and unjust.
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
granted
by
the
Page - 9 of 12
Under the premises aforesaid, the claimants sought for
enhancement of compensation.
[14]
Appearing for the appellants, Mr. B. Majumder, learned
counsel has argued that amount of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal is more than the claimants lawfully deserve. Moreover, the
Tribunal awarded compensation under various heads against the
settled principles. Counsel therefore, urges for reducing the amount of
compensation granted to the claimants.
[15]
Counsel appearing for the claimants on the other hand
contends that Tribunal worked out the amount of compensation most
arbitrarily and unfairly without taking into account the claim of the
petitioners and their actual entitlement. Counsel therefore, urges the
Court to award a fair amount of compensation to them by
enhancement of the award.
[16]
With
regard
to
the
claim
of
the
respondents
for
compensation towards future prospect of the deceased, it is found
that the claim is devoid of merit because the Hon’ble Apex court in
the case of National Insurance Company Limited Vrs. Pranay
Sethi and others; reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680 in paragraph
59.3 has held that while determining the income, an addition of 15%
of actual salary would be made towards future prospect in case the
deceased was a salaried person and between the age of
50 to 60
years. Admittedly, the deceased was a 61 years’ old pensioner at the
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 10 of 12
time of his death. Therefore, no addition can be made towards future
prospect in the present case.
Claim of the insurance company that no negligence and
[17]
rash driving has been proved in this case is not entertainable
because in a petition for compensation arising out of road traffic
accidents, the claimants are not required to proof such negligence
beyond reasonable shadow of doubt as required in a criminal case.
The standard of proof required in such case is the preponderance of
probability.
Deceased was admittedly travelling on his by-cycle at
day time when he was hit by the offending vehicle. Police conducted a
detailed investigation of the case. Sufficient number of witnesses
including eye witnesses were examined during such investigation and
the by-cycle of the deceased as well as the offending vehicle were
also seized. The offending vehicle was also examined by an expert
who opined that such accident did not occur for any mechanical fault
of the vehicle. After investigation police charge sheeted the accused
driver of the offending vehicle for negligent driving punishable under
Sections 279 and 338 IPC and culpable homicide not amounting to
murder punishable under Section 304 Part-II IPC. Claimants also
adduced oral evidence supporting the charge of rash and negligent
driving.
The
materials
available
on
record
are
sufficient
for
entertaining the claim for compensation arising out of road traffic
accident.
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 11 of 12
[18]
It was contended by the counsel of the insurance
company that Tribunal awarded an exorbitant compensation without
adopting the settled mode for assessing such compensation. It is
settled that compensation is not expected to be a bonanza, it should
be just and fair and not a source of profit. At the same time such
compensation should not also be a pittance. In the case in hand,
deceased was a Government pensioner. Tribunal had taken into
account his basic pension and admissible DA plus other allowances at
the time of his death for calculation of compensation towards loss of
income. Tribunal thus adopted a correct method to work out the
annual income of the deceased which was multiplied by 7 as per
schedule approved by the Apex Court in the Case of Sarla
Verma(Smt.)(supra).
Tribunal
also
made
deductions
towards
personal and living expenses taking into consideration the number of
dependant family member of the deceased as per procedure laid
down in the case of Sarla Verma(Smt.)(supra). Therefore, the
assessment made by the Tribunal for loss of income, loss of
consortium, loss of estate, funeral expenses etc. cannot be faulted
with. Insofar as
the assessment made by the Tribunal for medical
expenses, travelling expenses, attendant charges and charges for
preservation of the dead body is concerned, the submission of the
counsel of the Insurance Company that such compensation awarded
by the Tribunal is not based on sufficient proof is accepted. As a
result, compensation payable to the claimants is reassessed as under:
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
Page - 12 of 12
Sl.
No.
1.
Loss of income
Rs.13,65,336/-
2.
Loss of consortium
Rs.
40,000/-
3.
Loss of estate
Rs.
15,000/-
4.
Funeral expenses
Rs.
15,000/-
Amount
Heads
Total:
[19]
Rs.14,35,336/-
Claimants will be entitled to 6% annual interest on the
said amount from the date of filing of the claim petition till the date of
disbursement. Amount already paid, if any, shall be deducted from
the amount of compensation. Insurance company is directed to
deposit the said amount of compensation along with the interest
accrued thereon within a period of six weeks from today with the
Registry of this Court.
It is reported that Smt. Kanak Prabha Das,
wife of the deceased has died on 4.5.2020 and she is survived by her
two sons namely Suman Das and Litan Das and a daughter namely,
Shiuli Das (Majumder) who are claimants in this case. Therefore, the
whole amount of compensation on deposit shall be equally distributed
among them by transferring the same to their individual bank
accounts on verification of their identity
[20]
In terms of the above, the appeals stand disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Dipankar
MAC App. No.35/2020 & MAC App. No.39/2021.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review