Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 23-24
17.06.2026
Court No.9
Swd
IN THE High COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
FMA 323 of 2024
CAN 1 of 2024
The Oriental Insurance CO. LTD.
VS
Rekha Sau @ Sahoo & Ors.
With
COT 42 of 2024
Rekha Sau @ Sahoo & Ors.
Vs.
The Oriental Insurance CO. LTD.
Mr. Ananda Gopal Mukherjee.
… for the Appellant.
Mr. Pingal Bhattacharyya,
Mr. Rajdeep Sinha..
… for the Respondent.
1. Learned advocates for the parties are present. The
matter is taken up for hearing.
2. Heard learned advocates for the parties.
3. The appellant before this Court was an opposite
party in a case under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 and is aggrieved by the
judgment and award dated 17th July, 2023
passed by learned Additional District Judge, 2nd
Court, Purba Medinipur, in M.A.C. Case No. 115 of
2017. The claimants respondent Nos. 1 to 5 being
also aggrieved by the judgment and award passed
by the learned Trial Court have come up with the
cross objection.
4. The case of the claimants before the learned Trial
Court may be summed up thus:
On 20.01.2017 at about 8.30 A.M. the victim
Bhagwan Sau @ Sahoo and Sukanta Paria were
returning home by a motor cycle bearing no. WB34G/4334 from Aman filling station (HP) Oil
Pump, Asti Mouza, after taking Oil when they
came out from the said oil pump, suddenly the
offending vehicle bearing no.-WB-33C/6445(Bus)
which was coming from Belda side towards
Khakurda
side
with
extreme
high
speed
endangering to human life and safety with Zig-Zag
manner without blowing any horn dashed the said
motor cycle along with the victim Bhagwan Sau @
Sahoo and Sukanta Paria with great force.
As a result the said motor cycle was damaged the
victim Bhagwan Sau @ Sahoo and Sukanta Paria
were seriously injured all over the body specially
on head. Then and there they were taken to Belda
Hospital, where the attending doctor examined
them and declared dead.
The accident was caused due to rash and
negligent driving on the part of the driver of the
offending
vehicle
bearing
no.-WB-33C/6445
(Bus).The victim was Green Betel Stockist by his
profession. The victim was the only earning
member of his family and due to the death of the
victim, his family members are very much shocked
and they are suffering with great economic crisis.
5. Pursuant to filing of this case notice was issued
upon the opposite party (vehicle owner) and
opposite party Insurance Company. Opposite party
(vehicle owner) did not contest the case. However,
the opposite party insurance Company contested
the case by filing written statement. Issues were
framed and evidence was adduced. The learned
Trial Judge upon considering the evidence and
upon hearing the learned advocates was pleased to
dispose of the claim case by observing and
directing as follows:
ORDERED
“That the instant M.A.C. Case being no. 115/17
(Reg. No.117/17) be and the same is allowed on
contest against OP No.2/the Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd. (insurer) and ex parte against the OP No.1/Sri
Bishnupada Chanda (owner). All five petitioners are
entitled to get equal amount with interest @ 7% per
annum from the date of filing of this case till
realization against the opposite party No. 2, the
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. within three months
(preferably) from the date of receipt of copy of order
failing which the petitioners will recover the same
through process of law.
The O.P. No. 2, the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. shall
issue five account payee cheques in favour of the
applicants namely, 1. Rekha Sau @ Sahoo, 2.
Anupama Sau @ Sahoo, 3. Nirupama Sau @ Sahoo,
4. Milan Sau @ Sahoo & 5. Sandhya Sau @ Sahoo
in equal amount.
Let a copy of this order be issued in favour of
claimants and O.P. No.2, Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd. at free of costs”.
6. The appellant Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
being aggrieved with regard to the quantum of
compensation awarded has come up with the
instant appeal. The claimants respondent Nos. 1-5
have also filed cross objection challenging the
quantum of compensation awarded. The grounds
of challenge of the appellant Oriental Insurance
Company Ltd. is that the learned Trial Court ought
not to have based the findings on the basis of
income of Rs. 1,00,000/- but the learned Judge
ought to have proceeded on the basis of some
notional income. The other ground of appeal is
that the deduction of personal expenses ought not
to be 1/5th but 1/4th. The ground of challenged
by the claimants respondent Nos. 1-5 is that the
claimants respondent Nos. 1-5 had yearly income
of Rs.4,15,668/-but the learned Judge erred in
proceeding on the basis of Rs. 1,00,000/-.
7. During the pendency of this appeal the matter was
remitted to the learned Trial Court for examining
the Income Tax Authority. Pursuant to the matter
being remitted before the learned Trial Court the
Income Tax Authority was examined on 14th
August, 2025 being P.W. 3 of MACC 115 of 2017.
8. Upon
hearing
the
learned
advocates
and
considering the facts of the case this Court is of
the view that as the claimants respondent Nos. 1-5
have examined the Income Tax Authority in terms
of the direction of this Court and as per the
evidence of the Income Tax Authority the gross
total income of the incumbent was Rs.14,15,668/and the Income Tax deducted was Rs.2253/- it
would be proper to proceed on the basis of the said
total income.
9. Learned advocate for the appellant Insurance
Company has relied upon the following judicial
decisions:
i)
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Charlie
and another reported in (2005) 10 SCC 720.
10. In the case of New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs.
Charlie and another the Hon’be Supreme Court
was pleased to observe as follows:
“11. The manner of arriving at the damages is
to ascertain the net income of the deceased
available for the support of himself and his
dependants and to deduct therefrom such part
of his income as the deceased was accustomed
to spend upon himself, as regards both self-
maintenance and pleasure, and to ascertain
what part of his net income the deceased was
accustomed to spend for the benefit of the
dependants. Then that should be capitalized by
multiplying it by a figure representing the
proper number of a year’s purchase.”
11.
Learned advocate appearing for the claimants
respondent Nos. 1-5 have relied upon the following
judicial decisions:
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
National Insurance Co. Ltd. Versus Indira
Srivastava and Others reported in (2008) 2
SCC 763.
Sunil Sharma and Others Versus Bachitar
Singh and Others reported in (2011) 11 SCC
425.
The new India Assurance Co. Ltd. Versus
Renuka Laha & Ors. reported in 2013 SCC
OnLine Cal 12771.
Manasvi
Jain
Vs.
Delhi
Transport
Corporation Limited and Ors. reported in
(2014) 13 SCC 22.
12. Upon considering the judicial decisions it is clear
that while computing compensation that income of
the victim will be taken into consideration which
remained
after
deducting
the
statutory
taxes,
namely, the Income Tax and the Professional Tax.
13. It is held that in the case of National Insurance Co.
Ltd. Versus Indira Srivastava and Others that
income connotes the follows:
“9.
The
term
“income”
has
different
connotations for different purposes. A court of
law, having regard to the change in societal
conditions must consider the question not only
having
regard
to
pay-packet
the
employee
carries home at the end of the month but also
other perks which are beneficial to the members
of the entire family. Loss caused to the family
on a death of a near and dear one can hardly be
compensated on monetary terms.
14. The Hon’ble Court further observed that:
“10. Section 168 of the Act uses the word “just
compensation” which, in our opinion, should be
assigned
a
broad
meaning.
We
cannot,
in
determining the issue involved in the matter,
lose sight of the fact that the private sector
companies in place of introducing a pension
scheme take recourse to payment of contributory
provident fund, gratuity and other perks to
attract the people who are efficient and hardworking. Different offers made to an officer by
the employer, same may be either for the benefit
of the employee himself or for the benefit of the
entire
family.
If
some
facilities
are
being
provided whereby the entire family stands to
benefit, the same, in our opinion, must be held
to be relevant for the purpose of computation of
total income on the basis whereof the amount of
compensation payable for the death of the kith
and kin of the applicants is required to be
determined. For the aforementioned purpose, we
may notice the elements of pay, paid to the
deceased:
“Basic
:63,400.00
Conveyance Allowance
:12,000.00
Rent CO Lease
:49,200.00
Bonus (35% of basic)
:21,840.00
Total
1,45,440.00
In addition to above, his other entitlements were
Contribution to PF-10% basic
Rs.6240 (p.a.)
LTA reimbursement
Rs.7000 (p.a.)
Medical reimbursement
Rs.6000 (p.a.)
Superannuation 15% of basic
Rs.9360 (p.a.)
Gratuity contribution -5.34% of basic Rs.6240 (p.a.)
Rs.55000 (p.a.)
Medical policy-self and family @
Education scholarship @ Rs.500
Payable to his two children directly Rs.12000
(p.a.)
15. Thus, it is clear that apart from the statutory taxes
the investments made by the victim the allowances
which are receivable and the perquisites cannot be
deducted
for
the
purpose
of
arriving
at
the
compensation.
16. In the instant case as the gross total income of the
victim as per the deposition of the Income Tax
Authority is Rs.4,15,668/-, the compensation should
be arrived at upon deduction of the Income Tax Act
from the gross total income. Although certain
deductions are permissible under the Income Tax
from the gross total income but the said deductions
are only for the purpose of assessment of the Income
Tax and the same does not have any relation with
the procedure of computing the compensation in a
motor accident claim case. Hence, although the total
taxable income of the victim is Rs.2,72,530/-which is
arrived at after making different deductions under
the Income Tax Act but the compensation should be
computed after deduction the Income Tax from
Rs.4,15,668/- which is gross total income. In the
event the total annual income is Rs.4,15,668/- 1/4th
should be deducted on account of personal expenses
and the yearly income comes to Rs.3,11,751/-. The
Income Tax which should be deducted as per the
deposition of the Income Tax Authority Rs.2,253/-.
Thus the net income comes to Rs.3,09,500/-.
However, for the purpose of convenience the net
annual income. As the victim was 42 years of age
multiplier of 14 should be applied and the total
dependency loss comes to Rs.43,33,000/-. The
future prospect of 25% being added comes to
Rs.54,16,250/-. Further the claimants are entitled to
Rs.70,000/- on account of loss of estate, funeral
expenses and loss of consortium which is Rs.
70,000/- hence, the total compensation comes to
Rs.54,86,250/-. However this Court is of the view
that Rs.55,00,000/- is just and reasonable.
17. In the facts and circumstances, this appeal FMA 323
of 2024 along with COT No. 42 of 2024 and CAN 1 of
2024 stands disposed.
18. The claimants respondent Nos. 1 to 5 are entitled to
compensation
of
Rs.55,00,000/-
from
appellant
Oriental Insurance company Ltd. of Rs. 55,00,000/along with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of
filing of the claim case till today. The appellant
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. shall deposit Rs.
55,00,000/- along with interest
before the learned
Registrar General, High Court, Calcutta within eight
weeks from the date of communication of this order.
However, in the event the compensation awarded by
the learned Trial Court is already deposited the
balance amount be deposited within eight weeks. The
claimants’ respondent Nos. 1 to 5 is permitted to
withdraw
the
compensation
amount
upon
compliance of necessary formalities.
19. Urgent certified photocopy of this order, if applied
for, be supplied as expeditiously as possible.
(BISWAROOP CHOWDHURY, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review