The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. Therefore, in view of the forgoing discussion, this Court is of the considered opinion that the award passed by the Tribunal warrants interference enhancing the compensation from Rs.6,06,000/- to Rs.8,83,100/-.Thus, this point is answered accordingly.
26. In the result, is dismissed. However, awarded compensation of ₹8,83,100/- (Rupees Eight Lakh Eighty Three Thousand One Hundred only), together with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition till the date of realization, withcosts, payable by Respondent Nos.1 and 2. The Respondent No.2/Insurance Company shall deposit the compensation amount, together with accrued interest and costs, before the Tribunal within a period of two (2) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. Upon such deposit, the claimant No.1/wifeshall be entitled to receive enhanced compensation in addition to the compensation awarded to her by the Tribunal under the same apportionment and she are permitted to withdraw the same with interest accrued thereon.The Tribunal shall proceed to pay the amount in the aforesaid terms, adjusting the amount, if any, already paid.The appellants/claimants are directed to pay the deficit Court Fee before the Tribunal forthwith. Interim orders granted earlier if any, stand vacated. Miscellaneous petitions pending if any, stand closed. Dr.JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA Krs THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA M.A.C.M.A.No.4319 of 2008 ( JUDGMENT ) Krs
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010588342008
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3396]
WEDNESDAY, THE 16th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 4319/2008
Between:
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, REP.BY ITS BRANCH
MANAGER PH ROAD CHITTOOR DISTRICT
...APPELLANT
AND
1. K MANJULA CHITTOOR DIST 5 OTHERS, W/O. LATE KANCHI
SUDARSHAN@ SUDHAKAR REDDY HOUSE WIFE D.NO.21-81
THIMMASAMUDRAM(V) T.CHAVATAPALLI POST,CHITTOOR TOWN
2. MINOR K SUMITHARA, D/O. LATE SUNDARSHAN@ SUDHAKAR
REDDY STUDENT AND NATURAL GUARDIAN K.MANJULA THE
1ST RESPONDENT HEREIN
3. MINOR K YAMINI, D/O. LATE SUNDARSHAN@ SUDHAKAR REDDY
AND NATURAL GUARDIAN K.MANJULA THE 1ST RESPONDENT
HEREIN
4. K RAMACHANDRA REDDY, S/O.K.MUNUSWAMY REDDY(61)
DEPENDANT
5. K JAYAMMMA, W/O.RAMACHANDRA REDDY DEPENDANT
6. J S SREENIVASA MURTHY, S/O.J.R SAI PRASAD ONWER OF
LORRY AP 03U 2637 D.NO.9-35 VANNIAR BLOCK CHITTOOR
TOWN AND DISTRICT
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Court
Counsel for the Appellant:
P RAMANJANEYULU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
SURESH KUMAR REDDY KALAVA
The Court made the following:
JUDGMENT:
1.
The present appeal arises out of the award dated 16.05.20081 passed
by the Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-District Judge at
Chittoor2,
in
M.V.O.P.No.7of
20063
in
awarding
compensation
of
Rs.6,06,000/- against the claim of Rs.8,50,000/-.
2.
The appellant is the insurer of the Lorry bearing No.AP 03U 26374.
The respondent Nos.1 and 2, who are wife, children and parents of one
Kanchi Sudarshan @ Sudhakar Reddy5 respectively, are the claimants
before the Tribunal. The respondent No.3 is the owner of the crime lorry.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter referred to as
they arrayed before the Tribunal.
4.
The case of the claimants, in the petition before the Tribunal is that:
On 14.04.2005 at about 07.00a.m., while the deceased was
proceeding in the crime lorry along with his jaggery load,
when he reached near Anjaneyaswamy Temple on Rayachoti
to Cuddapah Ghat Road, the driver of the crime lorry drove
the same in a rash and negligent manner and lost control
hereinafter called as „Impugned award‟
hereinafter called as „the Tribunal‟
hereinafter called as „Claim petition‟
hereinafter referred to as “crime lorry”
hereinafter called as „deceased‟
over the same, resulted the lorry turned turtle and deceased
died on the spot. The claimants being legal representative,
claiming
compensation
of
Rs.8,50,000/-
against
the
respondents.
5.
The respondent No.1/owner of the crime lorry filed written statement
and pleaded that the deceased travelling in the crime lorry as owner of the
goods and the incident was occurred due to brakes failure, thereby, prayed
to dismiss the petition against this respondent.
6.
The respondent No.2/insurer of the crime lorry filed written statement
denying the averments in the petition and pleaded that the compensation
claimed by the claimants is excessive, thereby, prayed to dismiss the
petition against this respondent.
7.
During enquiry before the Tribunal,on behalf of the claimants, P.Ws.1
to 3 were examined and got exhibited Exs.A.1 to A.4. On behalf of the
respondents, R.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and Exs.B.1 and B.2 were
marked.
8.
Upon appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence on record,
the Tribunal held that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent
driving of the crime lorry by its driver and that Ex.B.2 policy issued in respect
of the crime lorry is in force. Accordingly, a sum of ₹6,06,000/- was awarded
as compensation to the claimants, together with interest at the rate of 9%
per annum from the date of the claim petition till the date of realization,
against respondent Nos.1 and 2.
9.
Aggrieved by the said findings of fastening the liability against the
insurer, the insurance company has preferred the present appeal.
10.
Heard
Sri
N.Ramakrishna,
leaned
counsel
representing
Sri
P.Ramanjaneyulu, learned counsel for the appellant/insurance company and
Sri
Suresh
Kumar
Reddy
Kalava,
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents/claimants. Notice sent to the respondent No.6, who is owner of
the crime lorry, was not served. Since the liability is fixed against the
insurance company and owner jointly and severally, the notice to the
respondent No.6 is dispensed with.
11.
Learned counsel for the appellant/insurance company submits that by
the time of accident the deceased was travelling in the crime lorry as
unauthorized passenger in a commercial vehicle, which is violation of terms
and conditions of Ex.B.2 policy, thereby, the Tribunal erred in fastening the
liability on the insurance company.
12.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondents/claimants
vehemently contends that the deceased was travelling the crime vehicle as
owner of the goods, thereby, he cannot be termed as unauthorized
passenger and that there are no valid grounds warranting interference of
this Court.
13.
He further submits that the Tribunal erred in calculating the
compensation payable, by not adding future prospects and taking the age of
the mother while computing the compensation, resulting in a meagre award,
thereby, prays to award just compensation.
14.
Now, the points that arise for determination are;
“i).Whether there are any valid grounds to meddle with the
findings of the Tribunal in fastening the liability against the
insurance company? and
ii).Whether the claimants are entitled to enhancement of
compensation, and if so, to what amount?”
15.
POINT NO.I:
It is not in dispute that the deceased died in a motor vehicle accident
occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the crime vehicle by its driver.
It is also not in controversy that the Ex.B.2 policy issued in respect of the
crime vehicle is in force by the date of incident.
16.
It is the specific case of the claimants that the deceased engaged the
crime lorry to transport his jaggery load. Admittedly, the testimony of P.W.3
and R.W.1 and admissions made by R.W.2 categorically show that the
deceased was the owner of the goods and was travelling in the crime lorry
in that capacity only. Furthermore, as per Ex.A.1 F.I.R. also the deceased
was travelling in the crime vehicle as owner of the goods by the date of
incident.
17.
In that view, the Tribunal after thorough appreciation of the material on
record rightly fastened liability on the insurer, by virtue of valid existence of
Ex.B.2 insurance policy, since the deceased cannot be termed as
unauthorized passenger and he was travelling in the crime vehicle as owner
of the goods only.
18.
Having regard to the above, absolutely there are no valid grounds
urged by the insurer to meddle with the findings of the Tribunal regarding
liability of the insurer to pay compensation to the claimants, thereby, the
resent appeal has no merits and liable for dismissal. Thus, this point is
answered accordingly.
19.
POINT NO.II:
Coming to the quantum of compensation entitled by the claimants is
concerned, since it is a first appeal, matter is at large, this Court can
examine the impugned order to fix the just compensation. It is also a fact
that since the Motor Vehicles Act being a benevolent legislation, this Court
proceeds to appreciate the material on record to assess just compensation,
even in the absence of cross appeal in view of the settled legal position.
20.
According to the claimants, by the date of incident, the deceased was
aged about 35 years, which is not in dispute and he used to earn
Rs.10,000/- to Rs.15,000/- per month by doing Jaggery business apart from
doing agriculture. In the absence of any substantial proof to prove the actual
income of the deceased, the Tribunal rightly taken the notional income of
the deceased at Rs.36,000/- per annum.
21.
In terms of the Constitution Bench decision in National Insurance
Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi,6 where the deceased was selfemployed or on a fixed salary and was below the age of 40 years, an
addition of 40% of the established income is warranted towards future
prospects. Applying the above, and the deceased being aged about 25years
(2017) 16 SCC 680
at the time of the accident, which is not in dispute, 40% is added towards
future prospects, and the income is determined at Rs.50,400/- (Rs.36,000/+ Rs.14,400/-). As per Pranay Sethi (referred supra), following Sarla
Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation,7where there are dependants four
to six, the deduction towards personal and living expenses is 1/4th. In the
present case, there are five dependants, deduction is accordingly taken at
1/4th of the income, bringing the quantum to Rs.37,800/-.
22.
The multiplier method, being logically sound and legally well
established for quantifying loss of income arising from death, is applied in
terms of Sandeep Khanuja v. Atul Dande &Anr.8, wherein the Hon'ble
Supreme Court held that the choice of multiplier is determined by the age of
the deceased, and that future prospects are factored into the multiplicand
before the multiplier is applied. The appropriate multiplier applicable to the
age of the deceased, 35 years, in terms of Sarla Verma (referred supra), is
16. The loss of dependency is, accordingly, determined at Rs.6,04,800/(Rs.37,800/- × 16).
23.
On the point of the conventional heads, as per the judgment in
Pranay Sethi (supra), Magma National Insurance Company Limited v.
(2009) 6 SCC 121
(2017) 3 SCC 351
Nanu Ram @ Chuhru Ram and Ors.9, Smt. Anjali and Others v.
Lokendra Rathod and Others10, United India Insurance Co. Ltd v.
Satinder Kaur @ Satwinder Kaur and ors.11and Rojalini Nayak and
others v. Ajit Sahoo and others12, this Court can award the enhanced
amounts under the conventional heads of loss of estate, loss of consortium
and funeral expenses. The claimants are also entitled for an amount of
Rs.2,42,000/- towards loss of spousal, parental and filial consortium,
towards funeral expenses Rs.18,150/- and towards loss of estate
Rs.18,150/-, respectively as was awarded in Rojalini Nayak case(referred
to supra).
24.
A brief exposition of the calculation made to arrive at the
compensation is set out infra:
Heads
Award of the Calculation/Enhanced by
Tribunal
this Court
The annual income Rs.36,000/per annum
of the deceased.
(2018) 18 SCC 130
(2022) SCC OnLine SC 1683
(2022) SCC OnLine SC 1683
2024 INSC 584
Rs.36,000/- per annum
40% to be added
as future prospects
--
(Rs.30,000/-+Rs.14,400/-)
Rs.50,400/-
1/4th to be deducted
as
personal
expenses
of
deceased.
(Rs.50,400/- - Rs.12,600/-)
Compensation
Rs.5,76,000/arrived
at
on
application
of
multiplier „16‟ under
the head of loss of
dependency.
(Rs.37,800/- x 16)
Loss of spousal,
parental and filial
consortium
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.2,42,000/(Rs.48,400/- X 5)
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.18,150/-
Funeral expenses
--
Rs.18,150/-
Total
compensation
awarded
Rs.6,06,000/-
Rs.8,83,100/-
Rs.37,800/-
Rs.6,04,800/-
(wife, two children
and parents)
Loss of estate
25.
Therefore, in view of the forgoing discussion, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the award passed by the Tribunal warrants
interference
enhancing
the
compensation
from
Rs.6,06,000/-
to
Rs.8,83,100/-.Thus, this point is answered accordingly.
26.
In
the
result,
M.A.C.M.A.
is
dismissed.
However,
awarded
compensation of ₹8,83,100/- (Rupees Eight Lakh Eighty Three Thousand
One Hundred only), together with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum
from the date of the claim petition till the date of realization, withcosts,
payable by Respondent Nos.1 and 2. The Respondent No.2/Insurance
Company shall deposit the compensation amount, together with accrued
interest and costs, before the Tribunal within a period of two (2) months from
the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. Upon such deposit, the
claimant No.1/wifeshall be entitled to receive enhanced compensation in
addition to the compensation awarded to her by the Tribunal under the same
apportionment and she are permitted to withdraw the same with interest
accrued thereon.The Tribunal shall proceed to pay the amount in the
aforesaid
terms,
adjusting
the
amount,
if
any,
already
paid.The
appellants/claimants are directed to pay the deficit Court Fee before the
Tribunal forthwith.
Interim orders granted earlier if any, stand vacated.
Miscellaneous petitions pending if any, stand closed.
________________________________________
Dr.JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
Date: 16.09.2026
Krs
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
M.A.C.M.A.No.4319 of 2008
( JUDGMENT )
DATE: 16.09.2026
Krs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review