Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010628012022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
TUESDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 571/2022
Between:
1. THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, REP. BY IT'S DEPUTY
MANGER, T.P HUB, GUTTIKONDA ZOOM PLAZA, NEAR VINAYAK
THEATRE, RING ROAD, VIJAYAWADA-10
...APPELLANT
AND
1. EDIGA RAMALINGANNA GOUD, A
2. EDIGA LAKSHMI DEVI, W/O EDIGA RAMALINGANNA GOUD, AGE
ABOUT 40 YEARS, OCC COOLI, R/O. TARIGOPULA VILLAGE,
JUPADU BUNGLOW MANDAL, KURNOOL DISTRICT.
3. K MAHABOOB BASHA, S/O K.MURTHUJA, OWNER OF TRUCK
BEARING NO.AP21-W-3105, NEAR RANGAMAHAL THEATRE,
ATMAKUR,KURNOOL DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtbegs to
present this Memorandum of Civil Miscellaneous Appeal to this Hon'ble Court,
against the Judgment and decree dated 27-07-2022 passed in M.V.O.P
No.468 of 2014 on the file Before The Chairman Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal -Cum-VI Additional District Judge, Kurnool
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
pleased to stay all further proceedings in pursuant to the Judgment and
Decree order dated 27-07-2022 passed in M.V.O.P No.468 of 2014 on the file
Before The Chairman Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal —Cum-VI Additional
District Judge, Kurnool pending disposal of appeal and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to vacate the Stay Orders dt.02.01.2023 in IA.No.1 of 2022 in
MACMA.No.571 of 2022 on the file of this Hon'ble Court and pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. V RAGHU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. N CHANDRA SEKHAR REDDY
The Court made the following:
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
JUDGMENT:
The insurance company has preferred the present appeal challenging
the order and decree dated 27.07.2022 passed in M.V.O.P.No.468 of 2017 on
the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-VI Additional District,
Kurnool, wherein the Tribunal awarded compensation of Rs.5,54,000/(Rupees Five Lakhs Fifty Four thousand only) to the petitioners/claimants, as
against the claim of Rs.6,00,000/-, on account of the death of the deceased,
Yellagoud Ramalinga Goud, in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on
10.06.2012.
02.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
03.
The case of the claimants, in brief, is as follows:
On 10.06.2012, after loading goods at Bethamcherla in Andhra
Pradesh, the deceased, who was working as a driver of the truck bearing
No.AP 21-W-3105, proceeded towards Vasai via the Mumbai–Agra Highway
along with the cleaner, namely Nagendra Babu, K. Narasaiah, for the purpose
of unloading the said goods at Vasai. On the same day, at about 1:20 a.m.,
when the said truck reached near Mintu Dhaba within the limits of Kandali
Village, the deceased, while driving the said vehicle at a high speed in a rash
and negligent manner, dashed against a vehicle proceeding ahead of it. As a
result, the truck turned turtle on the roadside. Consequently, the deceased,
Yellagoud Ramalinga Goud @ Yella Goud Mitta, along with the cleaner, got
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
trapped in the cabin of the truck and sustained grievous bleeding injuries. The
deceased succumbed to the injuries sustained in the accident. Based on the
report given by Dinesh Dhondu Kadam, Station House Officer, Padgha Police
Station, Thane Rural, a case was registered against the driver of the truck for
the offences punishable under Sections 304-A, 279, 337, 338, and 427 of the
Indian Penal Code.
04.
The claimants contended before the Tribunal that, at the time of the
accident, the deceased, who was the driver of the truck, possessed a valid
and effective driving licence to drive the said vehicle. He was hale and healthy
and aged about 25 years. He was working as a heavy transport vehicle driver
and earning a monthly income of Rs.12,000/-, apart from batta of Rs.200/- per
day. He was contributing his entire income towards the maintenance of the
petitioners. It is further contended that, due to the sudden demise of the
deceased, the petitioners were put to great mental shock and agony, as they
lost their sole breadwinner, and are now leading a miserable life. Hence, they
claimed compensation of Rs.6,00,000/-.
05.
The 2nd respondent/Insurance Company filed its counter denying all the
allegations made by the petitioners and contended that the amounts claimed
under various heads are imaginary, exaggerated, and made only to suit the
claim, and that the compensation sought is highly excessive. It is further
contended that the liability of the 2nd respondent is subject to proof that the
deceased was employed under the 1st respondent and was working as a
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
driver of the truck bearing No. AP21-W-3105 at the time of the accident. The
2nd respondent also alleged that the 1st respondent has colluded with the
petitioners and is not properly contesting the claim. In its additional counter,
the 2nd respondent contended that the petition is unjust and not maintainable
either in law or on facts, and that the accident occurred due to the negligence
of the deceased himself, as evidenced by the police records under Section
184 of the Motor Vehicles Act. It is further contended that the owner of the
vehicle did not pay any additional premium to cover the risk of the deceased
driver and that no such premium was collected under the policy; therefore, the
2nd respondent is not liable to pay any compensation to the petitioners.
Accordingly, it prayed for dismissal of the petition with costs.
06.
Basing on the pleadings, the Tribunal framed the following issues for
trial:
“1. Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving
of driver of truck bearing No.AP21-W-3105
2. Whether deceased Yella Goud Ramalingam Goud @ Yella Goud
Mitta died in the accident?
3. Whether petitioners are entitled to compensation? If so what
amount and against whom?
4. To what relief?
07.
On behalf of the petitioners/claimants, P.W.1 was examined and Exs.A1
to A4 were marked. On behalf of the respondents, R.W.1 was examined and
Ex.B1 was marked.
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
08.
After hearing both parties and after considering the oral and
documentary evidence on record, the Tribunal partly allowed the claim petition
with the following terms:
“In the result, this petition is partly allowed awarding
compensation of Rs.5,54,000/- (Rupees five lakh fifty four thousand
only) to the petitioners with costs and interest thereon at the rate of
7.5% p.a. from the date of petition till 01.03.2016 (which is the date of
dismissal of this petition earlier). Petitioners also entitled for interest
at the rate of 7.5% p.a. from 27.12.2021 (which is the date of
petitioners concluded their evidence) to till the date of decree and
thereafter at 6% p.a. till payment. Respondents 1 and 2 are directed
to deposit compensation amount with interest and costs within one
month from the date of this order.
First and second petitioners are entitled to Rs.2,77,000/- each
(Rupees two lakhs seventy seven thousand only) along with total
costs and interest.
On such deposit first and second petitioners are permitted to
withdraw Rs.1,77,000/- each (Rupees one lakh seventy seven
thousand only) initially along with total costs and interest
proportionately and balance amount of Rs.1,00,000/- each (Rupees
one lakh only) shall be deposited in any Nationalized bank as fixed
deposit for a period of two years. Petitioners 1 and 2 are permitted to
withdraw amounts deposited after expiry of respective periods. Rest
of the petitioners claim is dismissed. Advocate fee is fixed at
Rs.3,000/-.”
09.
Aggrieved by the said award, the appellant/Insurance Company
preferred the present appeal contending that the Tribunal ought to have
considered that the claimants failed to prove the income of the deceased. It is
further contended that, since the deceased himself was driving the vehicle and
the accident occurred due to his own negligence, the claimants are not
entitled to any compensation. The appellant also contended that the claim
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
petition filed under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act is not
maintainable in cases where the income of the deceased exceeds Rs.40,000/per annum. It is further contended that the Tribunal erred in awarding future
prospects and granting amounts towards funeral expenses and transportation
charges, which are not in accordance with the Second Schedule of the Motor
Vehicles Act. Lastly, it is contended that the Insurance Company is not liable
to pay compensation as there was a violation of the terms and conditions of
the policy.
10.
Heard Mr.V.Raghu, learned Standing Counsel for the appellant
Mr.N.Chandra Shekar Reddy,.learned counsel for the claimants.
11.
Now the point for consideration is:
Whether the order of the Tribunal needs any interference?
POINT:
12.
On a perusal of the record, it is evident that the claim petition was filed
under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act claiming compensation of
Rs.6,00,000/-. The 1st claimant, father of the deceased, was examined as
P.W.1 and deposed that the deceased was working as a driver under the 1st
respondent and was driving the truck bearing No. AP21-W-3105 at the time of
the accident. On 10.06.2012, in the early hours, while proceeding towards
Vasai with a load, the deceased lost control of the vehicle near Mintu Dhaba,
Kandali Village, dashed against a vehicle moving ahead, and the truck turned
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
turtle, resulting in his death. A criminal case was registered in Crime No.195 of
2012 by Padgha Police Station. Though the 2nd respondent/Insurance
Company contended that the deceased himself was negligent and that no
additional premium was paid to cover the risk of the driver, R.W.1, in his
cross-examination, admitted that Ex.B1 policy is a package policy covering the
driver and that the premium was duly paid. The policy was in force as on the
date of the accident. In view of the same, the finding of the Tribunal fixing
liability on respondents 1 and 2 jointly and severally does not suffer from any
illegality or irregularity and warrants no interference.
13.
Coming to the quantum of compensation, P.W.1 deposed that the
deceased was aged 25 years at the time of the accident. Though
Ex.A2/inquest report and the postmortem report mention the age as 35 years,
the driving licence/Ex.A4 shows the date of birth of the deceased as
09.05.1987. Accordingly, as on the date of the accident i.e., 10.06.2012, the
age of the deceased is rightly taken as 25 years, and the same finding of the
Tribunal warrants no interference. With regard to income, though the
claimants asserted that the deceased was earning Rs.12,000/- per month
along with batta of Rs.200/- per day, in view of the claim being made under
Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, the annual income is to be restricted
to Rs.40,000/-. After deducting 50% towards personal expenses, as the
deceased was unmarried, the contribution to the family would be Rs.20,000/per annum. Applying the multiplier ‗18‘ applicable to the age group of 25
years, as per settled principles, the loss of earnings comes to Rs.3,60,000/-
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
(Rs.20,000 × 18). It is further observed that the Tribunal added 40% towards
future prospects to the established income of the deceased, placing reliance
on the judgment of the Hon‘ble Apex Court in National Insurance Company
v. Pranay Sethi1. However, as rightly contended by the learned counsel for
the appellant, such addition towards future prospects is impermissible in a
claim made under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act.
14.
Admittedly, the claim petition has been filed under Section 163-A of the
Motor Vehicles Act. For better appreciation, the said provision is extracted
hereunder:
―163A. Special provisions as to payment of compensation on structured
formula basis.—
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in any other law for the
time being in force or instrument having the force of law, the owner of the
motor vehicle of the authorised insurer shall be liable to pay in the case of
death or permanent disablement due to accident arising out of the use of
motor vehicle, compensation, as indicated in the Second Schedule, to the
legal heirs or the victim, as the case may be. Explanation.—For the
purposes of this sub-section, ―permanent disability‖ shall have the same
meaning and extent as in the Workmen‘s Compensation Act, 1923 (8 of
1923).
(2) In any claim for compensation under sub-section (1), the claimant shall
not be required to plead or establish that the death or permanent
disablement in respect of which the claim has been made was due to any
wrongful act or neglect or default of the owner of the vehicle or vehicles
concerned or of any other person.
2017 ACJ 2700
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
(3) The Central Government may, keeping in view the cost of living by
notification in the Official Gazette, from time to time amend the Second
Schedule‖
15.
Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 introduces a special
provision for the payment of compensation on a structured formula basis,
creating a no-fault liability regime. Under this provision, the owner of the motor
vehicle or the authorised insurer becomes liable to pay compensation to the
victim or to the legal heirs of a deceased in cases of death. In a petition filed
under this provision, the claimant is not required to establish negligence,
wrongful act, or default on the part of the owner or any other person and
compensation shall be determined strictly in accordance with the II Schedule
prescribed under the Act.This provision is intended to provide speedy and
predetermined compensation to victims of motor accidents or their
dependents.
16.
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 provides the substantive
mechanism for filing an application for compensation arising out of a motor
accident before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal. Under this provision, a
claim petition may be instituted by the person who has sustained injury, by the
owner of the damaged property, by the legal representatives of the deceased
in case of death, or by any person duly authorised by them. A claim under
Section 166 is upon the principle of fault liability, and therefore the claimant is
required to establish that the accident occurred due to the rash or negligent
act of the driver or owner of the offending vehicle. The Tribunal, upon
appreciation of the pleadings and evidence adduced by the parties,
determines the quantum of compensation which appears to be just and
reasonable, having regard to the nature of injuries, loss of dependency,
medical expenses, and other attendant circumstances.
17.
The Second Schedule to the Motor Vehicles Act contains a table
prescribing the compensation to be awarded with reference to the age and
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
income of the deceased. It specifies the amount of compensation to be
awarded with reference to the annual income range of Rs.3,000/- to
Rs.40,000/-. It does not specify the quantum of compensation in case the
annual income of the deceased is more than Rs.40,000/-, however, it provides
the multiplier to be applied with reference to the age of the deceased. The
table starts with a multiplier of 15, goes up to 18 and then steadily comes
down to 5. It also provides the standard deduction as one-third on account of
personal living expenses of the deceased. As such, where an application is
under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, it is possible to calculate the
compensation on the structured formula basis, even where the compensation
is not specified with reference to the annual income of the deceased or is
more than Rs.40,000/- by applying the formula: Two-thirds of the annual
income multiplied by the multiplier applicable to the age of the deceased.
Several principles of tortious liability are excluded when the claim is under
Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act. It has to be noted that where the
annual income of the deceased exceeds Rs.40,000/-, a claim under Section
163A of the Motor Vehicles Act is not maintainable as the said provision is
restricted to a specified income group; in such cases, the appropriate remedy
lies under Section 166 of the Act.
18.
The Hon‘ble Supreme Court of India, in Deepal Girishbhai Soni and
ors., Vs. United India Insurance Company Limited2, while dealing with
Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 held as under:
―Chapter XI was, thus, enacted for grant of immediate relief to a section of
people whose annual income is not more than Rs. 40,000/- having regard
to the fact that in terms of Section 163-A of the Act read with the Second
Schedule appended thereto; compensation is to be paid on a structured
formula not only having regard to the age of the victim and his income but
also the other factors relevant therefor. An award made thereunder,
therefore, shall be in full and final settlement of the claim as would appear
from the different columns contained in the Second Schedule appended to
the Act. The same is not interim in nature. The note appended to column 1
2004 (5) SCC 385
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
which deals with fatal accidents makes the position furthermore clear
stating that from the total amount of compensation one-third thereof is to
be reduced in consideration of the expenses which the victim would have
incurred towards maintaining himself had he been alive. This together with
the other heads of compensation as contained in column Nos. 2 to 6
thereof leaves no manner of doubt that the Parliament intended to lay a
comprehensive scheme for the purpose of grant of adequate
compensation to a section of victims who would require the amount of
compensation without fighting any protracted litigation for proving that the
accident occurred owing to negligence on the part of the driver of the motor
vehicle or any other fault arising out of use of a motor vehicle.‖
Thus, Chapter XI of the Act was enacted to provide immediate relief to
a limited class of victims whose annual income does not exceed Rs.40,000/as compensation under Section 163-A and it is determined on a structured
formula basis, as discussed above and is intended to be a full and final
settlement without the need to prove negligence. Therefore, persons having
an income above Rs.40,000/- are not entitled to file a petition under Section
163-A. In the present case, though the claimants themselves have
contended that the deceased used to earn Rs.400/- to Rs.500/- per day, in
which case the annual income exceeds Rs.40,000/-, the Tribunal considered
the same despite the claim being filed under Section 163-A, which is
contrary to the very scheme and intent of the provision.
20.
In view of the above and considering the provisions of Section 163-A
of the Motor Vehicles Act and the settled legal position, this Court is of the
opinion that the claimants are not entitled for addition of 40% towards future
prospects. Accordingly, the loss of earnings is fixed at Rs.3,60,000/-.
21.
Further, the Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs.15,000/- towards loss of
estate, Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses, and Rs.20,000/- towards
transportation charges, which do not warrant any interference. However, on a
perusal of the award, it can be observed that the Tribunal failed to grant any
compensation under the head of parental consortium to the claimants, who
VS,J
MACMA No.571 of 2022
are the parents of the deceased. Therefore, this Court deems it appropriate to
award a sum of Rs.40,000/- each to the claimants under the head of parental
consortium.
22.
Thus, to sum up, the amounts awarded by the Tribunal and the
amounts granted in the present appeal, in the light of the computations made
above, are as follows:
23.
Head
Amount granted
by the Tribunal
Amount now awarded by
this Court
Loss of earnings
Rs.5,04,000/-
Rs.3,60,000/-
Loss of estate
Funeral expenses
Transportation charges
Loss of consortium
Total
Rs.15,000/Rs.15,000/Rs.20,000/-Rs.5,54,000/-
Rs.15,000/Rs.15,000/Rs.20,000/Rs.80,000/Rs.4,90,000/-
In the result, the M.A.C.M.A. is partly allowed, reducing the total
compensation amount awarded by the Tribunal from Rs.5,54,000/- to
Rs.4,90,000/-, with the interest as ordered by the Tribunal. The compensation
shall be apportioned among the claimants in the same manner and ratio as
ordered by the Tribunal. No costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V. SUJATHA
Date: 31.03.2026
KGR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review