The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. So after hearing both the sides and also after going through the record of the Learned Tribunal below no infirmity is found in the said judgment. Hence in my considered view this appeal deserves no consideration and accordingly it stands rejected.
11. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby dismissed on contest being devoid of merit. The judgment and order dated 14.03.2020 delivered by Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala is hereby upheld and accordingly it is affirmed. The appellant insurance company i.e. the OP No.2 of the main case is hereby asked to comply the judgment within a period of 6(six) weeks from the date of passing of the judgment. It is on record that the appellant insurance company by this time has deposited Rs.16,16,500/- (sixteen lakh sixteen thousand and five hundred) vide cheque No.004681 dated 29.12.2023 to the Registry of the High Court. So the appellant insurance company be further asked to deposit the balance amount within the aforesaid stipulated period to the Registry of the High Court. The payment be disbursed by the Registry in pursuance of the judgment and award of the Tribunal dated 14.03.2023 passed in TS (MAC) 118 of 2020. With this observation and direction the case is disposed of. Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this judgment and also supply a copy of this judgment free of cost to the Learned counsel for the appellant insurance company and also for respondent claimant-petitioners for information. The pending application, if any, stands disposed of. Moumita 13:44:00 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP No.90 of 2023
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited,
A company registered under
the Companies Act, 1956,
Represented by the Assistant
Manager cum Officer in Legal Hub/Authorized Signatory,
Agartala, Division Office, H.G.B. Road,
(Near Sarkar Nursing Home),
Agartala, West Tripura
----Appellant (s)
Versus
1. Smt. Rumpa Bhattacharjee (Chakraborty),
Wife of Late Rinku Chakraborty
2. Sri Rajdip Chakraborty,
Son of Late Rinku Chakraborty
3. Sri Nityananda Chakraborty,
Father of Late Rinku Chakraborty
4. Smt. Smriti Chakraborty,
Mother of Late Rinku Chakraborty,
-All are residents of village:Suryamani Nagar, East
Durgapur, PS:Amtali, District: West Tripura
---- Claimant/Respondents (s)
5. Sri Suman Debnath,
Son of Late Bimal Debnath,
Resident of village: West Laximibil,
P.S. Bishalgarh, District: Sepahijala, Tripura,
(Owner of Motor Bike bearing No.TR-01-T9752
---- Respondents (s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. B. Debnath, Adv.
Ms. A. Banik, Adv.
Ms. Tulu Debnath, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
31.05.2024
20.06.2024
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred by the appellant challenging
the judgment and award dated 14.03.2023 passed by
Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court
No.1, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with Case
No.T.S.(MAC)118 of 2020. By the said judgment and award
Learned Tribunal has awarded a sum of Rs.32,33,000/- with
interest @ 7% per annum with effect from 07.09.2022 till
the date of actual payment or realization and liability was
fasten upon the insurance company.
02.
At the time of hearing Learned counsel Mr. B.
Majumder appearing for the appellant submitted that the
Learned Tribunal below assessed the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs.15,000/- per month without any basis which
needs to be modified because the claimant-petitioner side
could not adduce any documentary evidence in respect of
the monthly income of the deceased. Learned counsel for
the appellant further submitted that the Learned Tribunal
below also treated the father of the deceased as a
dependant which needs to be modified in view of the fact
that the father in a case under Motor Accident Act cannot be
treated as dependant. It was further submitted that the
Learned Tribunal below at the time of determination of
compensation also determined the interest in respect of
future loss of income which is also not legally permissible in
the eye of law because for future income there was no
scope to fix any interest. But the Learned Tribunal ignoring
the different principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
court has determined the rate of interest for future loss of
income for which the interference of the court is required.
03.
On the other hand, Mr. S.B. Debnath along with
Ms. Tulu Debnath appeared on behalf of the respondents
No.1-4 submitted that the accident took place in the year
2020 and during that period the daily income of a Mason
cum Steel Bar Cutter was not less than Rs.700-1000/- per
day in our state. So the Learned Tribunal below considering
the facts and circumstances of the case and considering the
number of working days in a month determined the monthly
income of the deceased @Rs.15,000/- per month which was
very rational and reasonable as per the prevailing market
rate of the state in the year 2020. So there was no infirmity
and ambiguity in the judgment of the Tribunal. Learned
counsel further submitted that in the given case the father
of the petitioner was totally depending upon the income of
his deceased son because there is no evidence on record
that
the
father
used
to
earn
money
individually
or
separately for which the Learned Tribunal below considered
the father as a dependent but in a normal practice in a case
under Motor Vehicles Act the Tribunal is always considers
the mother as the dependent but if the father also appears
to be dependent upon the income of the son there is no
legal bar to award any compensation to the dependent
father. Here in this case there is also no contrary evidence
on record from the side of the insurance company. So in
summing up Learned Counsel for the respondent-claimants
submitted that since there was no infirmity in the judgment
of the Learned Tribunal, so Learned counsel urged for
dismissal of this appeal upholding the judgment of the
Learned Tribunal below with costs.
04.
Now for the sake of convenience, I would like to
discuss herein below the subject matter of the claim petition
filed before the Tribunal. The claimant-petitioners submitted
one claim petition to the Learned Tribunal under Section
166 of MV Act alleging inter alia that on 15.03.2020 while
the victim Rinku Chakraborty was returning back to his
house from Babul Chowmuhani Bazar by walking keeping
the left side of the road, that time a motor bike bearing
registration No.TR-01-T-9752 came with high speed rashly,
carelessly and negligently dashed against the victim from
his back side and thus the accident took place in between
1930 hours to 2000 hours. As a result of which the victim
Rinku Chakraborty fell down on the road and sustained
grievous bleeding injuries on his person and he became
senseless. After the accident he was shifted to the TMC &
Dr.B.R. Ambedkar Memorial Teaching Hospital, Hapania
wherein
he
got
admitted
as
an
indoor
patient,
but
considering his serious condition, he was referred to the
AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala for better treatment. But
ultimately victim succumbed to his injuries. PM examination
was done over his body and in the claim petition the
petitioners have asserted that the accident took place due
to rash and negligent driving of the motor bike bearing
registration No.TR-01-T-9752. It was further submitted that
on this issue a police case was registered vide P.S. Case
No.50 of 2020 under Sections 279/304(A) of IPC and
Section 184 of M.V. Act, 1988. The claimant-petitioner
further submitted that the deceased was a Steel bar cutter
(Rod Mistry) having monthly income of Rs.15,000/- and was
32 years old at the time of death. Hence the claimantpetitioners filed the claim petition seeking compensation.
05.
The OP No.1 contested the case by filing written
objection denying the assertion of the claimant-petitioner
and submitted that on 15.03.2020 when the motor bike
bearing registration No.TR-01-T-9752 reached at Babul
Chowmuhani at that time a man while crossing the road
suddenly came in front of the motor bike. As a result, the
man sustained injuries on his person. But there was no
negligence on the part of the owner of the motor bike and
as such the owner of the motor bike is not liable to pay any
compensation to the claimant-petitioners. It was further
submitted that the motor bike was duly insured with the
Oriental Insurance Company Limited covering the period
with effect from 18.12.2019 to 17.12.2020 having a valid
driving licence of the rider of the motor bike. So, if any
compensation is awarded that should be paid by the insurer
of the said motor bike.
06.
The OP No.2, the Oriental Insurance Company
Limited also appeared and contested the case by filing
written statement denying the assertions of the claimantpetitioners and finally submitted that the claim petition is
subjected to strict proof by the claimant-petitioners. Upon
the pleadings of the parties following issues were framed:
(1) Did deceased Rinku Chakraborty die in a road traffic
accident occurred on 15.03.2020 at about 1930 to 2000
hours at Babul Chowmuhani on N.H. Road under Amtali
P.S. out of use of vehicle bearing registration No.TR-01-T9752 (Achiever Motor Cycle) due to rash and negligent
riding by the rider of aforesaid motor cycle?
(2) Are the petitioners entitled to get compensation as
prayed for and if so, to what amount and who is liable to
pay the same?
(3) To what other reliefs the parties are entitled?
07.
To substantiate the issues both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record:
Witnesses of the Claimant-Appellants:
PW-1: Rumpa Bhattacharjee
PW-2: Sri Nilanka Chakraborty
Exhibits of the Claimant-Appellants:
(i) Exbt 1 and Exbt 2: FIR alongwith ejahar
(ii) Exbt 3: Post Mortem Report
(iii) Exbt 4: Chargesheet
(iv) Exbt 5: Survival Certificate
Witnesses of OP Witness:
OPW-1: Sri Suman Debnath
Exhibits of the OPWs:
1) Exbt. A: Driving Licence
2) Exbt. B: Policy Certificate
3) Exbt C: Registration Certificate
4) Exbt D: Pollution Certificate
08.
Finally on conclusion of trial the Learned Tribunal
below allowed the claim petition by delivering the judgment.
The operative portion of the judgment dated 14.03.2023 is
mentioned below:
“It is, therefore, held that the claimant petitioners are
entitled to get compensation of Rs.32,33,000/- (Rupees
Thirty-two Lakh Thirty-three Thousand only) with
interest @ 7% per annum with effect from 07.09.2020 i.e.
the date of filing of the claim petition till the date of
actual payment. The opposite party No.2, Oriental
Insurance Company Ltd., will pay the amount of
compensation with interest within 30 days from today in
terms of Section 168(3) of M.V. Act, 1988.
Out of the awarded amount of compensation
inclusive of interest, the claimant petitioner no.1 will get
40% and the claimant petitioners no.2, 3 and 4 will get
20% each. Out of the respective share of the claimant
petitioners no.1, 2, 3 and 4, 50% each of their respective
share shall be kept in fixed deposit scheme in their
respective name in any Nationalized Bank of their locality
for a period of five years each and the remaining 50% of
their respective share shall be paid to them through their
respective bank account. The claimant petitioners no.1,
2, 3 and 4 shall however be at liberty to withdraw
monthly interest from their respective fixed deposit
account to meet their day to day expenses. No loan or
withdrawal shall be permitted from/against any of the
fixed deposit certificates without prior permission of this
Tribunal.
Supply copy of this award free of cost to the
parties.
The claim petition stands disposed of on contest.
Enter the result in the relevant Register as well as
in the CIS.”
09.
I have gone through the judgment of the
Learned Court below. Learned court below determined the
monthly income of the deceased @Rs.15,000/- per month
i.e. Rs.500/- per day considering the market situation in the
State of Tripura in the year 2020 and relying upon the
judgment of the Apex Court in National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Others reported
in (2017) 16 SCC 680. With that amount added 40% as
future income and thus assessed his monthly income to
Rs.21,000/- and calculated the loss of dependency as
Rs.21,000/-x12x16=Rs.40,32,000/-.
Thereafter
deducted
¼th amount as personal expenditure of the deceased and
thus calculated Rs.30,24,000/- as the loss of income.
Thereafter, Learned Tribunal below relying upon the said
judgment Pranay Sethi (supra) and also relying upon the
judgment
of
Hon’ble
Insurance
Company
Supreme
Court
in
United
India
Ltd.
Satinder
Kaur
alias
vs.
Satwinder Kaur & Ors in Civil Appeal No.2706 of 2020
arising out of SLP(Civil) No.12520 of 2015 came to the
observation that the loss of consortium is to be paid not
only to the spouse of the deceased but also to the children
in case of death of a parents or to the parents in case of
death of any child. According to the Learned Tribunal in the
said judgment the Hon’ble Supreme Court awarded separate
amount for loss of consortium @Rs.40,000/- for each of the
claimants following the principle of law laid down by Hon’ble
Supreme
Court.
Thereafter
Learned
Tribunal
below
determined loss of estate at Rs.15,000/- and 10% of that
Rs.15,000/- i.e. Rs.1500/- and for funeral expenses also
Learned Tribunal below determined Rs.15,000/-+10% of
the same amount i.e. Rs.16,500/- and thereafter also
calculated the loss of consortium for four persons at
Rs.1,60,000/- (one lakh sixty thousand). Along with that
10%
of
Rs.1,60,000/-
i.e.
more
16,000/-,
in
total
Rs.1,76,000/- as loss of consortium. Thus the Learned
Tribunal below calculated the total amount of compensation
at
Rs.32,33,000/-
Rs.16,500/-
+
(Rs.30,24,000/-
Rs.1,76,000/-)
and
+
Rs.16,500/finally
+
calculated
Rs.32,33,000/- as compensation along with 7% interest
from the date of filing the claim petition till realization.
10.
So after hearing both the sides and also after
going through the record of the Learned Tribunal below no
infirmity is found in the said judgment. Hence in my
considered view this appeal deserves no consideration and
accordingly it stands rejected.
11.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
hereby dismissed on contest being devoid of merit. The
judgment and order dated 14.03.2020 delivered by Learned
Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura,
Agartala is hereby upheld and accordingly it is affirmed. The
appellant insurance company i.e. the OP No.2 of the main
case is hereby asked to comply the judgment within a
period of 6(six) weeks from the date of passing of the
judgment. It is on record that the appellant insurance
company by this time has deposited Rs.16,16,500/- (sixteen
lakh sixteen thousand and five hundred) vide cheque
No.004681 dated 29.12.2023 to the Registry of the High
Court. So the appellant insurance company be further asked
to
deposit
the
balance
amount
within
the
aforesaid
stipulated period to the Registry of the High Court. The
payment be disbursed by the Registry in pursuance of the
judgment and award of the Tribunal dated 14.03.2023
passed in TS (MAC) 118 of 2020.
With this observation and direction the case is
disposed of.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this
judgment and also supply a copy of this judgment free of
cost to the Learned counsel for the appellant insurance
company and also for respondent claimant-petitioners for
information.
The pending application, if any, stands disposed
of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.06.21
13:44:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review