Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010707402022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
THURSDAY, THE 17th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 572 OF 2022
Between:
1. THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, Rep. by its Divisional
Manager, Divisional Office II,
SVC Office (CBO-4), Near Eenadu SBH
Complex, Patamatalanka, MG Road, Vijayawada, Krishna District.
...Petitioner
AND
1. SUTHI RAMADEVI, Wife of late Suthi Sivanandam alias Siva, Hindu, aged
about
years,
House
wife,
r/o.D.No.32-40/1-46,
Karmikanagar,
Machavaram, Vijayawada, Krishna District,
2. Suthi Bharani Lokesh, D/o.Sivanandam alias Siva, Hindu, Aged about 13
years, 7th class student, r/o.D.No.32-40/1-46, Karmikanagar, Machavaram,
Vijayawada, Krishna District.
3. Suthi Bhargavi, D/o.late Sivanandam alias Siva, Hindu, aged about 11
years, 6th class student, do.D.No.32-40/1-46, Karmikanagar, Machavaram,
Vijayawada, Krishna District. (Petitioners 2 and 3 are being minors rep. by
their mother and natural guardian 1st petitioner Suthi Ramadevi)
4. Suthi Narayanamma, W/o.Guruvulu,
Hindu, aged about 53 years, No
avocation, do.D.No.32-40/1-46, Karmikanagar,
Krishna District.
Machavaram, Vijayawada,
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
5. Suthi Guruvulu, S/o.late Ramulu, Hindu,
Aged about 59 years, No
avocation,
Machavaram, Vijayawada.
do.D.No.32-40/1-46, Karmikanagar,
Krishna District.
6. Nakka Srinu, S/o.Narasimha Rao, Hindu, Aged about 41 years, Driver of
Innova Car bearing No. AP 16 TB 9376, R/o.D.No.20-3/1-32 Road Street,
Ayodhyanagar, Vijayawada.
7. Vegi Haribabu, S/o.Rajarao, Hindu, Aged about 45 years, Owner of Innova
Car bearing No. AP 16 TB 9376, R/o.30-10-25, Ayyana Naidu Street, Durga
Agraharam, Vijayawada. Krishna District.
8. Ch Kranthi Kumar, son of not known, Hindu, Aged about 40 years. Driver
of Car bearing No. TS 09 EF 6999.
r/o.D.No.29-19-53, Dornakala Road,
Suryaraopet, Vijayawada.
9. Pramod Kumar, S/o.Not known, Hindu, Aged about 45 years, Owner of Car
bearing No. TS 09 EF 6999, R/o.Banjara Hills, Hyderabad.
10. The Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited, Rep. by its Branch
Manager, Branch Office, Vijayawada.
...Respondents
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtpleased allow
this appeal by setting aside the judgment and decree passed in
M.V.O.P.No.607 of 2015 on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal - cum Metropolitan sessions judge-cum-II Additional District Judge,Vijayawada,
dated 12th day of September, 2022 and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to grant stay of all further proceedings pursuant to the decree and
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
judgment dated the 12th day of September, 2022 passed in M.V.O.P.No.607
of 2015 on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal - cum -Metropolitan
sessions
judge-cum-II
Additional
District
Judge,Vijayawada,
including
execution proceedings, pending disposal of the main M.A.C.M.A., and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner: GUDI SRINIVASU
Counsel for the Respondents: AMANCHARLA SATISH BABU Counsel
for the Respondents:D.SUMANTH
The Court made the following
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
JUDGMENT:
The insurance company has preferred the present appeal challenging
the order and decree dated 12.09.2022 passed in M.V.O.P.No.607 of 2015 on
the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-II Additional District
Judge, Vijayawada,
wherein the Tribunal awarded compensation of
Rs.24,26,500/- (Rupees Twenty Four Lakhs Twenty Six Thousand and Five
Hundred only) to the petitioners/claimants, as against the claim of
Rs.20,00,000/-, on account of the death of the deceased, Suthi Sivanandam
@ Siva, in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 19.09.2015.
02.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
03.
The case of the claimants, in brief, is as follows:
a) On 19.09.2015, at about 9.30 a.m., P.W.3, being the rider of the
motorcycle, and the deceased, being the pillion rider, were proceeding on their
motorcycle from Singhnagar towards Agiripalli. When they reached near
Reddigari Poultry Farm at about 9.40 a.m., respondent No.1, who was driving
the Innova Car bearing No.AP 16 TB 9376, drove the said vehicle in a rash
and negligent manner and attempted to overtake the motor vehicles
proceeding ahead of him. In the course of such overtaking, he suddenly
turned the vehicle towards the right side and thereafter towards the left side.
In that process, the said vehicle hit the motorcycle ridden by P.W.3, as a result
of which the deceased fell onto the road. At that time, respondent No.4, who
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
was driving the Car bearing No.TS 09 EF 6999 from Agiripalli towards Nunna
in the opposite direction, also drove the said vehicle in a rash and negligent
manner and ran over the deceased, resulting in his death on the spot. Based
on the report lodged by P.W.3, a case was registered in Crime No.255 of 2015
under Section 304-A of the Indian Penal Code against respondent Nos.1 and
4, and a charge sheet was also filed.
b) The deceased was working as a painter at Care and Share
Charitable Trust, Buddavaram, Gannavaram Mandal, and was earning a
monthly salary of Rs.11,500/-, besides receiving Rs.2,000/- per month
towards travelling expenses. He was aged about 36 years and was hale and
healthy at the time of the accident. All the petitioners were dependent upon
the deceased and, due to his death, they lost their sole source of income,
besides his love, affection and care. The petitioners, therefore, filed the claim
petition seeking compensation of Rs.20,00,000/- with interest at the rate of
12% per annum from the date of the accident till the date of realization.
c) It was contended by the petitioners that the accident occurred solely
due to the rash and negligent driving of crime vehicle Nos.1 and 2 by
respondent Nos.1 and 4, respectively. Hence, the concerned respondents and
their insurers are jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation claimed.
Accordingly, the claim petition was filed.
04.
Before the Tribunal, respondent Nos.1, 2, 4 and 5 remained exparte.
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
05.
Respondent No.3 filed a counter denying all the material allegations
made in the petition and contending that the petitioners were put to strict proof
of the occurrence of the accident, the rash and negligent driving of crime
vehicle No.1 by respondent No.1, the death of the deceased in the accident,
and the age and earnings of the deceased at the time of the accident. It was
further contended that the petitioners were required to prove that respondent
No.1 possessed a valid driving licence at the time of the accident and that
there was no violation of the terms and conditions of the insurance policy. It
was also contended that the claim of the petitioners was excessive. It is
further stated that respondent No.3, the accident occurred due to the negligent
driving of the motorcycle by P.W.3 as well as the rash and negligent driving of
crime vehicle No.2 by respondent No.4, and there was no rash or negligent
driving on the part of respondent No.1. Hence, respondent No.3 prayed for
dismissal of the petition.
06.
Respondent No.6 filed a counter stating that the petitioners were put to
strict proof of the occurrence of the accident, the rash and negligent driving of
crime vehicle No.2 by respondent No.4, the death of the deceased in the
accident, and the age and earnings of the deceased at the time of the
accident. It was contended that the petitioners had to prove that respondent
No.4 possessed a valid driving licence at the time of the accident and that
there was no violation of the terms and conditions of the insurance policy. It
was also contended that the claim of the petitioners was excessive. It was
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
further contended that the accident occurred due to the negligent driving of the
motorcycle by P.W.3 as well as the rash and negligent driving of crime vehicle
No.1 by respondent No.1, and there was no rash or negligent driving on the
part of respondent No.4. It was further contended that the petition was bad for
non-joinder of the necessary parties, as the driver, owner and insurer of the
motorcycle ridden by P.W.3 had not been impleaded as parties. Hence,
respondent No.6 prayed for dismissal of the petition.
07.
Basing on the pleadings, the Tribunal framed the following issues for
trial:
“1. Whether the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent
driving of the Innova Car bearing No.AP 16 TB 9376 by the 1st
respondent an Black Car bearing No.TS 09 EF 6999 by the 4th
respondent on 19.09.2015 at about 9.30 A.M., in the morning at the
Reddigari Poultry Forum in Nunna on Vijayawada Nuzvid main road,
Vijayawada Rural?
2. Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation, and if so
the quantum and by whom payable?
3. To what relief?
08.
On behalf of the petitioners/claimants, P.W.s 1 to 3 were examined and
Exs.A1 to A10 were marked. On behalf of the respondents, R.W.1 and R.W.2
were examined and Exs.B1 to B3 were marked.
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
09.
After hearing both parties and after considering the oral and
documentary evidence on record, the Tribunal allowed the claim petition with
the following terms:
“In the result, this petition is allowed in favour of the petitioners 1 to 5
awarding compensation of Rs.24,26,500/- (Rupees Twenty Four
Lakhs Twenty Six Thousand and Five Hundred only) with costs and
interest thereon at 7.5% per annum from the date of petition till the
date of realization against respondent Nos.1 to 3 jointly and
severally. This petition against the respondent Nos.4 to 6 is
dismissed but without costs.
The respondents 1 to 3 are directed to deposit the compensation
amount with interest and costs within one month from the date of this
order. On such deposit, the petitioners 1 to 5 are entitled to their
share of compensation amount explained as under:
(1) Petitioner No.1 is entitled to an amount of Rs.6,26,500/(Rupees Six Lakhs twenty six thousand five hundred only)
together with interest on the entire compensation amount and
costs thereon. The petitioner No.1 is permitted to withdraw
her entire share of compensation including the interest and
costs.
(2) Petitioner Nos.2 and 3 each are entitled to an amount of
Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees Five lakhs only). The share of
petitioner Nos.2 and 3 they being minors, shall be kept in
Fixed Deposit in any Nationalized bank till they attain majority.
(3) Petitioner Nos.4 and 5 each are entitled to an amount of
Rs.4,00,000/- (Rupees Four Lakhs only). The petitioner Nos.4
and 5 are permitted to withdraw their entire share of
compensation.
The petitioners paid the Court fee on their original claim and they
need to pay the Deficit Court fee on the excess amount of the
compensation awarded by this Tribunal. Hence, the office is directed
to prepare the decree subject to payment of the Deficit Court fee by
the petitioners.”
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
10.
The present appeal has been preferred, inter alia, contending that the
Tribunal failed to appreciate that, as evidenced by the FIR, the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of both the Innova Car bearing
No.AP 16 TB 9376 and the Car bearing No.TS 09 EF 6999. It is further
contended that the Tribunal failed to properly appreciate the evidence of
P.W.3, who was the rider of the motorcycle and an eyewitness to the
occurrence, while the deceased was travelling as a pillion rider. The specific
contention of the appellant is that P.W.3 categorically admitted that the
accident occurred on account of the rash and negligent driving of both the
aforesaid vehicles, namely, the Innova Car bearing No.AP 16 TB 9376 driven
by respondent No.1 and the Car bearing No.TS 09 EF 6999 driven by
respondent No.4. The appellant would further contend that the Tribunal erred
in fastening the liability solely upon respondent Nos.1 to 3 and has raised
several other grounds in support of the appeal.
11.
Heard Mr.Gudi Srinivasu, learned Standing Counsel for the appellant
learned counsel for the claimants.
12.
Now the point for consideration is:
Whether the order of the Tribunal needs any interference?
POINT:
13.
With regard to Issue No.1, the 1stpetitioner, being the wife of the
deceased, examined herself as P.W.1 and deposed with regard to the manner
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
in which the accident occurred and marked Exs.A1 to A10. Apart from her
evidence, the petitioners examined P.W.3, who was the rider of the
motorcycle on which the deceased was travelling as a pillion rider at the time
of the accident and an eyewitness to the occurrence. He categorically
deposed that on 19.09.2015, at about 9.30 a.m., while he was proceeding on
his motorcycle from Singhnagar towards Agiripalli, with the deceased
travelling as a pillion rider, when they reached near Reddigari Poultry Farm at
about 9.40 a.m., respondent No.1, who was driving the Innova Car bearing
No.AP 16 TB 9376, came from behind their motorcycle in a rash and negligent
manner. While overtaking the vehicles proceeding infront of him, respondent
No.1 suddenly turned the vehicle towards the right side and thereafter towards
the left side, as a result of which the said vehicle hit the motorcycle, P.W.3
and the deceased fell on the road. At that time, respondent No.4, who was
driving the Car bearing No.TS 09 EF 6999 from the opposite direction, also
drove the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner and ran over the deceased,
resulting in his death on the spot. It is further the evidence of P.W.3 that he
lodged a report against respondent Nos.1 and 4, pursuant to which an FIR
was registered. He also deposed that he gave evidence before the Criminal
Court reiterating the contents of his report. However, during his crossexamination, P.W.3 stated that the Innova Car bearing No.AP 16 TB 9376
driven by respondent No.1 alone was responsible for the accident. It is also
evident from the record that, after investigation, the police filed a charge sheet
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
against respondent No.1. However, on a careful consideration of the evidence
of P.Ws.1 and 3, the pleadings and the documentary evidence on record, this
Court is of the view that the testimony of P.W.3 cannot be discarded.
Admittedly, P.W.3 was the rider of the motorcycle on which the deceased was
travelling as a pillion rider and was, therefore, an eyewitness to the
occurrence. He has categorically narrated the manner in which the accident
occurred. His version is also supported by Ex.A1/FIR, which was lodged by
him immediately after the occurrence. Therefore, the evidence of P.W.3,
coupled with Ex.A1/FIR, corroborates the case of the petitioners/claimants.
14.
The Tribunal, however, mainly relied upon the charge sheet filed by the
police against respondent No.1 and, accordingly, answered Issue No.1
holding that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of
respondent No.1, driver of the Innova Car bearing No.AP 16 TB 9376,
resulting in the death of the deceased, and that there was no negligence on
the part of respondent No.4, driver of the Car bearing No.TS 09 EF 6999. This
Court is of the view that the said finding is not supported by the evidence on
record. It is not in dispute that the first crime vehicle, i.e., the Innova Car
bearing No.AP 16 TB 9376, hit the motorcycle on which the deceased was
travelling as a pillion rider, due to which the deceased fell on the road.
Thereafter, the second crime vehicle, driven by respondent No.4, came from
the opposite direction and ran over the deceased. Though it is admitted that
respondent No.4 could not have controlled the vehicle, the fact remains that
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
the deceased was crushed by the vehicle driven by respondent No.4. In these
circumstances, this Court is of the considered view that the death of the
deceased occurred due to the negligence of both respondent Nos.1 and 4.
Accordingly, the finding of the Tribunal on Issue No.1 is modified by holding
that respondent No.1, being the driver of the Innova Car bearing No.AP 16 TB
9376, and respondent No.4, being the driver of the Car bearing No.TS 09 EF
6999, were negligent and that their negligence contributed to the accident and
the death of the deceased. Thus, there was composite negligence on the part
of the drivers of both the crime vehicles, which is apportioned at 60:40.
15.
Coming to the quantum of compensation, though the petitioners did not
produce any proof regarding the age of the deceased as on the date of the
accident, the Tribunal, relying upon Ex.A3/post-mortem report, determined the
age of the deceased as 38 years. Accordingly, the age of the deceased as on
the date of the accident was rightly taken as 38 years, and the said finding of
the Tribunal does not warrant any interference by this Court. With regard to
the income of the deceased, the petitioners contended that the deceased was
working as a Painter in Care and Share Charitable Trust and was earning a
monthly salary of Rs.11,500/-. In support of the said contention, the petitioners
examined P.W.2, who was working as an Accountant in Care and Share
Charitable Trust. P.W.2 deposed that the deceased was working as a Painter
in their organization and was being paid a monthly salary of Rs.11,500/-,
besides travelling expenses of Rs.2,000/- per month. The petitioners also
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
marked Ex.A8/Service Certificate of the deceased, which shows that the
deceased was drawing a monthly salary of Rs.11,500/-. Ex.A9 is the copy of
the bank passbook of the deceased, which shows that an amount of
Rs.11,500/- was being credited to his account every month towards salary
from his employer. However, insofar as the travelling expenses of Rs.2,000/per month are concerned, the petitioners have not produced any documentary
evidence in support of the same. Therefore, based on the evidence of P.W.2
coupled with Exs.A8 and A9, the Tribunal rightly assessed the monthly income
of the deceased at Rs.11,500/-. Since there were five dependents, the
Tribunal deducted 1/4th of his income towards personal and living expenses,
in accordance with the principles laid down in Sarla Verma v. Delhi
Transport Corporation 1 . Accordingly, the monthly contribution of the
deceased to his family was taken at Rs.8,625/- (Rs.11,500/- - 1/4th). As the
deceased was aged 38 years at the time of the accident, the Tribunal added
40% towards future prospects, in accordance with the principles laid down by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in National Insurance Company v. Pranay
Sethi2. Thus, the monthly income for the purpose of calculating the loss of
dependency was determined at Rs.12,075/- (Rs.8,625/- + Rs.3,450/-).
Applying the appropriate multiplier of '15' applicable to the age of the
deceased, the loss of dependency was calculated at Rs.21,73,500/(Rs.12,075/- × 12 × 15). In addition to the above, the Tribunal awarded
2009 ACJ 1298
2017 ACJ 2700
VS,J,
MACMA No.572 of 2022
Rs.16,500/- each towards loss of estate and funeral expenses and
Rs.44,000/- each to petitioner Nos.1 to 5 towards consortium. Thus, the
Tribunal awarded a total compensation of Rs.24,26,500/- to the petitioners,
which in the opinion of this Court the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is
just and reasonable and does not warrant any interference.
16.
With regard to the liability, as the accident occurred due to the
composite negligence of respondent Nos.1 and 4, the liability is apportioned at
60% on respondent No.1, driver of the Innova Car bearing No.AP 16 TB 9376,
and 40% on respondent No.4, driver of the Car bearing No.TS 09 EF 6999.
Accordingly, respondent Nos.1 to 3, being the driver, owner and insurer of the
Innova Car, are jointly and severally liable to pay 60% of the compensation,
while respondent Nos.4 to 6, being the driver, owner and insurer of the Car,
are jointly and severally liable to pay the remaining 40% of the compensation.
17.
Accordingly, the M.A.C.M.A. is partly allowed. The finding of the
Tribunal regarding liability is modified to the above extent. The apportionment
of compensation among the claimants and the rate of interest shall remain as
ordered by the Tribunal. There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V. SUJATHA
Date: 17.09.2026
KGR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review